Normalized to: Busch, J.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2007.01844 [pdf] - 2127600
KiDS-1000 Methodology: Modelling and inference for joint weak
gravitational lensing and spectroscopic galaxy clustering analysis
Joachimi, B.;
Lin, C. -A.;
Asgari, M.;
Tröster, T.;
Heymans, C.;
Hildebrandt, H.;
Köhlinger, F.;
Sánchez, A. G.;
Wright, A. H.;
Bilicki, M.;
Blake, C.;
Busch, J. L. van den;
Crocce, M.;
Dvornik, A.;
Erben, T.;
Getman, F.;
Giblin, B.;
Hoekstra, H.;
Kannawadi, A.;
Kuijken, K.;
Napolitano, N. R.;
Schneider, P.;
Scoccimarro, R.;
Sellentin, E.;
Shan, H. Y.;
von Wietersheim-Kramsta, M.;
Zuntz, J.
Submitted: 2020-07-03
We present the methodology for a joint cosmological analysis of weak
gravitational lensing from the fourth data release of the ESO Kilo-Degree
Survey (KiDS-1000) and galaxy clustering from the partially overlapping BOSS
and 2dFLenS surveys. Cross-correlations between galaxy positions and
ellipticities are incorporated into the analysis, developing a hybrid model of
non-linear scales that blends perturbative and non-perturbative approaches, and
assessing signal contributions by astrophysical effects. All weak lensing
signals are measured consistently via Fourier-space statistics that are
insensitive to the survey mask and display low levels of mode mixing. The
calibration of photometric redshift distributions and multiplicative
gravitational shear bias is updated, and a more complete tally of residual
calibration uncertainties is propagated into the likelihood. A dedicated suite
of more than 20000 mocks is used to assess the performance of covariance models
and to quantify the impact of survey geometry and spatial variations of survey
depth on signals and their errors. The sampling distributions for the
likelihood and the $\chi^2$ goodness-of-fit statistic are validated, with
proposed changes to calculating the effective number of degrees of freedom.
Standard weak lensing point estimates on $S_8=\sigma_8\,(\Omega_{\rm
m}/0.3)^{1/2}$ derived from its marginal posterior are easily misinterpreted to
be biased low, and an alternative estimator and associated credible interval
are proposed. Known systematic effects pertaining to weak lensing modelling and
inference are shown to bias $S_8$ by no more than 0.1 standard deviations, with
the caveat that no conclusive validation data exist for models of intrinsic
galaxy alignments. Compared to the previous KiDS analyses, $S_8$ constraints
are expected to improve by 20% for weak lensing alone and by 29% for the joint
analysis. [abridged]
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:2007.01846 [pdf] - 2127602
Testing KiDS cross-correlation redshifts with simulations
Submitted: 2020-07-03
Measuring cosmic shear in wide-field imaging surveys requires accurate
knowledge of the redshift distribution of all sources. The clustering-redshift
technique exploits the angular cross-correlation of a target galaxy sample with
unknown redshifts and a reference sample with known redshifts, and is an
attractive alternative to colour-based methods of redshift calibration. We test
the performance of such clustering redshift measurements using mock catalogues
that resemble the Kilo-Degree Survey (KiDS). These mocks are created from the
MICE simulation and closely mimic the properties of the KiDS source sample and
the overlapping spectroscopic reference samples. We quantify the performance of
the clustering redshifts by comparing the cross-correlation results with the
true redshift distributions in each of the five KiDS photometric redshift bins.
Such a comparison to an informative model is necessary due to the
incompleteness of the reference samples at high redshifts. Clustering mean
redshifts are unbiased at $|\Delta z|<0.006$ under these conditions. The
redshift evolution of the galaxy bias can be reliably mitigated at this level
of precision using auto-correlation measurements and self-consistency
relations, and will not become a dominant source of systematic error until the
arrival of Stage-IV cosmic shear surveys. Using redshift distributions from a
direct colour-based estimate instead of the true redshift distributions as a
model for comparison with the clustering redshifts increases the biases in the
mean to up to $|\Delta z|\sim0.04$. This indicates that the interpretation of
clustering redshifts in real-world applications will require more sophisticated
(parameterised) models of the redshift distribution in the future. If such
better models are available, the clustering-redshift technique promises to be a
highly complementary alternative to other methods of redshift calibration.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:2007.01845 [pdf] - 2127601
KiDS-1000 catalogue: weak gravitational lensing shear measurements
Giblin, Benjamin;
Heymans, Catherine;
Asgari, Marika;
Hildebrandt, Hendrik;
Hoekstra, Henk;
Joachimi, Benjamin;
Kannawadi, Arun;
Kuijken, Konrad;
Lin, Chieh-An;
Miller, Lance;
Tröster, Tilman;
Busch, Jan Luca van den;
Wright, Angus H.;
Bilicki, Maciej;
Blake, Chris;
de Jong, Jelte;
Dvornik, Andrej;
Erben, Thomas;
Getman, Fedor;
Napolitano, Nicola R.;
Schneider, Peter;
Shan, HuanYuan
Submitted: 2020-07-03
We present weak lensing shear catalogues from the fourth data release of the
Kilo-Degree Survey, KiDS-1000, spanning 1006 square degrees of deep and
high-resolution imaging. Our `gold-sample' of galaxies, with well calibrated
photometric redshift distributions, consists of 21 million galaxies with an
effective number density of $\sim 6.2$ galaxies per square arcminute. We
quantify the accuracy of the spatial, temporal and flux-dependent point-spread
function (PSF) model, verifying that the model meets our requirements to induce
less than a $0.1\sigma$ change in the inferred cosmic shear constraints on the
clustering cosmological parameter $S_8 = \sigma_8\sqrt{\Omega_{\rm m}/0.3}$.
Through a series of two-point null-tests we validate the shear estimates,
finding no evidence for significant non-lensing B-mode distortions in the data.
PSF residuals are detected in the highest-redshift bins, originating from
object selection and/or weight bias. The amplitude is however shown to be
sufficiently low and within our stringent requirements. With a shear-ratio
null-test we verify the expected redshift scaling of the galaxy-galaxy lensing
signal around luminous red galaxies. We conclude that the joint KiDS-1000 shear
and photometric redshift calibration is sufficiently robust for combined-probe
gravitational lensing and spectroscopic clustering analyses.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:2005.14351 [pdf] - 2104092
Testing gravity using galaxy-galaxy lensing and clustering amplitudes in
KiDS-1000, BOSS and 2dFLenS
Blake, Chris;
Amon, Alexandra;
Asgari, Marika;
Bilicki, Maciej;
Dvornik, Andrej;
Erben, Thomas;
Giblin, Benjamin;
Glazebrook, Karl;
Heymans, Catherine;
Hildebrandt, Hendrik;
Joachimi, Benjamin;
Joudaki, Shahab;
Kannawadi, Arun;
Kuijken, Konrad;
Lidman, Chris;
Parkinson, David;
Shan, HuanYuan;
Tröster, Tilman;
Busch, Jan Luca van den;
Wolf, Christian;
Wright, Angus H.
Submitted: 2020-05-28
The physics of gravity on cosmological scales affects both the rate of
assembly of large-scale structure, and the gravitational lensing of background
light through this cosmic web. By comparing the amplitude of these different
observational signatures, we can construct tests that can distinguish General
Relativity from its potential modifications. We use the latest weak
gravitational lensing dataset from the Kilo-Degree Survey, KiDS-1000, in
conjunction with overlapping galaxy spectroscopic redshift surveys BOSS and
2dFLenS, to perform the most precise existing amplitude-ratio test. We measure
the associated E_G statistic with 15-20% errors, in five dz = 0.1 tomographic
redshift bins in the range 0.2 < z < 0.7, on projected scales up to 100 Mpc/h.
The scale-independence and redshift-dependence of these measurements are
consistent with the theoretical expectation of General Relativity in a Universe
with matter density Omega_m = 0.27 +/- 0.04. We demonstrate that our results
are robust against different analysis choices, including schemes for correcting
the effects of source photometric redshift errors, and compare the performance
of angular and projected galaxy-galaxy lensing statistics.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:2005.04207 [pdf] - 2091839
KiDS+VIKING-450: Improved cosmological parameter constraints from
redshift calibration with self-organising maps
Submitted: 2020-05-08
We present updated cosmological constraints for the KiDS+VIKING-450 cosmic
shear dataset (KV450), estimated using redshift distributions and photometric
samples defined using self organising maps (SOMs). Our fiducial analysis finds
marginal posterior constraints of $S_8\equiv\sigma_8\sqrt{\Omega_{\rm
m}/0.3}=0.716^{+0.043}_{-0.038}$; smaller than, but fully consistent with,
previous work using this dataset ($|\Delta S_8| = 0.023$). We analyse
additional samples and redshift distributions constructed in three ways:
excluding certain spectroscopic surveys during redshift calibration, excluding
lower-confidence spectroscopic redshifts in redshift calibration, and
considering only photometric sources which are jointly calibrated by at least
three spectroscopic surveys. In all cases, the method utilised here proves
robust: we find a maximal deviation from our fiducial analysis of $|\Delta S_8|
\leq 0.009$ for all samples defined and analysed using our SOM. Our largest
shift in $S_8$ is found when calibrating redshift distributions without the
DEEP2 spectroscopic subset, where we find $S_8=0.707_{-0.042}^{+0.046}$. This
difference with respect to the fiducial is both significantly smaller than, and
in the opposite direction to, the equivalent shift from previous work. No
sample analysed in this work results in a meaningful positive shift in $S_8$
with respect to our fiducial constraints. These results suggest that our
improved cosmological parameter estimates are insensitive to pathological
misrepresentation of photometric sources by the spectroscopy used for direct
redshift calibration, and therefore that this systematic effect cannot be
responsible for the observed difference between $S_8$ estimates made with KV450
and Planck CMB probes.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1906.09262 [pdf] - 2124507
KiDS+VIKING-450 and DES-Y1 combined: Cosmology with cosmic shear
Joudaki, S.;
Hildebrandt, H.;
Traykova, D.;
Chisari, N. E.;
Heymans, C.;
Kannawadi, A.;
Kuijken, K.;
Wright, A. H.;
Asgari, M.;
Erben, T.;
Hoekstra, H.;
Joachimi, B.;
Miller, L.;
Tröster, T.;
Busch, J. L. van den
Submitted: 2019-06-21, last modified: 2020-04-22
We present a combined tomographic weak gravitational lensing analysis of the
Kilo Degree Survey (KV450) and the Dark Energy Survey (DES-Y1). We homogenize
the analysis of these two public cosmic shear datasets by adopting consistent
priors and modeling of nonlinear scales, and determine new redshift
distributions for DES-Y1 based on deep public spectroscopic surveys. Adopting
these revised redshifts results in a $0.8\sigma$ reduction in the DES-inferred
value for $S_8$, which decreases to a $0.5\sigma$ reduction when including a
systematic redshift calibration error model from mock DES data based on the
MICE2 simulation. The combined KV450 + DES-Y1 constraint on $S_8 =
0.762^{+0.025}_{-0.024}$ is in tension with the Planck 2018 constraint from the
cosmic microwave background at the level of $2.5\sigma$. This result highlights
the importance of developing methods to provide accurate redshift calibration
for current and future weak lensing surveys.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1909.09632 [pdf] - 2124533
Photometric Redshift Calibration with Self Organising Maps
Submitted: 2019-09-20, last modified: 2020-03-19
Accurate photometric redshift calibration is central to the robustness of all
cosmology constraints from cosmic shear surveys. Analyses of the KiDS
re-weighted training samples from all overlapping spectroscopic surveys to
provide a direct redshift calibration. Using self-organising maps (SOMs) we
demonstrate that this spectroscopic compilation is sufficiently complete for
KiDS, representing $99\%$ of the effective 2D cosmic shear sample. We use the
SOM to define a $100\%$ represented `gold' cosmic shear sample, per tomographic
bin. Using mock simulations of KiDS and the spectroscopic training set, we
estimate the uncertainty on the SOM redshift calibration, and find that
photometric noise, sample variance, and spectroscopic selection effects
(including redshift and magnitude incompleteness) induce a combined maximal
scatter on the bias of the redshift distribution reconstruction ($\Delta
\langle z \rangle=\langle z \rangle_{\rm est}-\langle z \rangle_{\rm true}$) of
$\sigma_{\Delta \langle z \rangle} \leq 0.006$ in all tomographic bins. We show
that the SOM calibration is unbiased in the cases of noiseless photometry and
perfectly representative spectroscopic datasets, as expected from theory. The
inclusion of both photometric noise and spectroscopic selection effects in our
mock data introduces a maximal bias of $\Delta \langle z \rangle
=0.013\pm0.006$, or $\Delta \langle z \rangle \leq 0.025$ at $97.5\%$
confidence, once quality flags have been applied to the SOM. The method
presented here represents a significant improvement over the previously adopted
direct redshift calibration implementation for KiDS, owing to its diagnostic
and quality assurance capabilities. The implementation of this method in future
cosmic shear studies will allow better diagnosis, examination, and mitigation
of systematic biases in photometric redshift calibration.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1910.05336 [pdf] - 2054043
KiDS+VIKING-450 and DES-Y1 combined: Mitigating baryon feedback
uncertainty with COSEBIs
Asgari, Marika;
Tröster, Tilman;
Heymans, Catherine;
Hildebrandt, Hendrik;
Busch, Jan Luca van den;
Wright, Angus H.;
Choi, Ami;
Erben, Thomas;
Joachimi, Benjamin;
Joudaki, Shahab;
Kannawadi, Arun;
Kuijken, Konrad;
Lin, Chieh-An;
Schneider, Peter;
Zuntz, Joe
Submitted: 2019-10-11, last modified: 2020-01-21
We present cosmological constraints from a joint cosmic shear analysis of the
Kilo-Degree Survey (KV450) and the Dark Energy Survey (DES-Y1), conducted using
Complete Orthogonal Sets of E/B-Integrals (COSEBIs). With COSEBIs we isolate
any B-modes which have a non-cosmic shear origin and demonstrate the robustness
of our cosmological E-mode analysis as no significant B-modes are detected. We
highlight how COSEBIs are fairly insensitive to the amplitude of the non-linear
matter power spectrum at high $k$-scales, mitigating the uncertain impact of
baryon feedback in our analysis. COSEBIs, therefore, allow us to utilise
additional small-scale information, improving the DES-Y1 joint constraints on
$S_8=\sigma_8(\Omega_{\rm m}/0.3)^{0.5}$ and $\Omega_{\rm m}$ by $20\%$.
Adopting a flat $\Lambda$CDM model we find $S_8=0.755^{+0.019}_{-0.021}$, which
is in $3.2\sigma$ tension with the Planck Legacy analysis of the cosmic
microwave background.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1910.11327 [pdf] - 2050240
The effects of varying depth in cosmic shear surveys
Heydenreich, Sven;
Schneider, Peter;
Hildebrandt, Hendrik;
Asgari, Marika;
Heymans, Catherine;
Joachimi, Benjamin;
Kuijken, Konrad;
Lin, Chieh-An;
Tröster, Tilman;
Busch, Jan Luca van den
Submitted: 2019-10-24, last modified: 2019-12-16
We present a semi-analytic model for the shear two-point correlation function
of a cosmic shear survey with non-uniform depth. Ground-based surveys are
subject to depth variations that primarily arise through varying atmospheric
conditions. For a survey like the Kilo-Degree Survey (KiDS), we find that the
measured depth variation increases the amplitude of the observed shear
correlation function at the level of a few percent out to degree-scales,
relative to the assumed uniform-depth case. The impact on the inferred
cosmological parameters is shown to be insignificant for a KiDS-like survey.
For next-generation cosmic shear experiments, however, we conclude that
variable depth should be accounted for.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1812.06076 [pdf] - 2030437
KiDS+VIKING-450: Cosmic shear tomography with optical+infrared data
Hildebrandt, H.;
Köhlinger, F.;
Busch, J. L. van den;
Joachimi, B.;
Heymans, C.;
Kannawadi, A.;
Wright, A. H.;
Asgari, M.;
Blake, C.;
Hoekstra, H.;
Joudaki, S.;
Kuijken, K.;
Miller, L.;
Morrison, C. B.;
Tröster, T.;
Amon, A.;
Archidiacono, M.;
Brieden, S.;
Choi, A.;
de Jong, J. T. A.;
Erben, T.;
Giblin, B.;
Mead, A.;
Peacock, J. A.;
Radovich, M.;
Schneider, P.;
Sifón, C.;
Tewes, M.
Submitted: 2018-12-14, last modified: 2019-11-18
We present a tomographic cosmic shear analysis of the Kilo-Degree Survey
(KiDS) combined with the VISTA Kilo-Degree Infrared Galaxy Survey (VIKING).
This is the first time that a full optical to near-infrared data set has been
used for a wide-field cosmological weak lensing experiment. This unprecedented
data, spanning $450~$deg$^2$, allows us to improve significantly the estimation
of photometric redshifts, such that we are able to include robustly
higher-redshift sources for the lensing measurement, and - most importantly -
solidify our knowledge of the redshift distributions of the sources. Based on a
flat $\Lambda$CDM model we find $S_8\equiv\sigma_8\sqrt{\Omega_{\rm
m}/0.3}=0.737_{-0.036}^{+0.040}$ in a blind analysis from cosmic shear alone.
The tension between KiDS cosmic shear and the Planck-Legacy CMB measurements
remains in this systematically more robust analysis, with $S_8$ differing by
$2.3\sigma$. This result is insensitive to changes in the priors on nuisance
parameters for intrinsic alignment, baryon feedback, and neutrino mass. KiDS
shear measurements are calibrated with a new, more realistic set of image
simulations and no significant B-modes are detected in the survey, indicating
that systematic errors are under control. When calibrating our redshift
distributions by assuming the 30-band COSMOS-2015 photometric redshifts are
correct (following the Dark Energy Survey and the Hyper Suprime-Cam Survey), we
find the tension with Planck is alleviated. The robust determination of source
redshift distributions remains one of the most challenging aspects for future
cosmic shear surveys.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1910.14006 [pdf] - 2101313
Strong Lensing Model of SPT-CLJ0356-5337, a Major Merger Candidate at
Redshift 1.0359
Mahler, Guillaume;
Sharon, Keren;
Gladders, Michael D.;
Bleem, Lindsey;
Bayliss, Matthew B.;
Calzadilla, Michael S.;
Floyd, Benjamin;
Khullar, Gourav;
McDonald, Michael;
Gonzàlez, Juan D. Remolina;
Schrabback, Tim;
Stark, Antony A.;
Busch, Jan Luca van den
Submitted: 2019-10-30
We present an analysis of the mass distribution inferred from strong lensing
by SPT-CL J0356-5337, a cluster of galaxies at redshift z = 1.0359 revealed in
the follow-up of the SPT-SZ clusters. The cluster has an Einstein radius of
Erad=14 for a source at z = 3 and a mass within 500 kpc of M_500kpc =
4.0+-0.8x10^14Msol. Our spectroscopic identification of three multiply-imaged
systems (z = 2.363, z = 2.364, and z = 3.048), combined with HST F606W-band
imaging allows us to build a strong lensing model for this cluster with an rms
of <0.3'' between the predicted and measured positions of the multiple images.
Our modeling reveals a two-component mass distribution in the cluster. One mass
component is dominated by the brightest cluster galaxy and the other component,
separated by ~170 kpc, contains a group of eight red elliptical galaxies
confined in a ~9'' (~70 kpc) diameter circle. We estimate the mass ratio
between the two components to be between 1:1.25 and 1:1.58. In addition,
spectroscopic data reveal that these two near-equal mass cores have only a
small velocity difference of 300 km/s between the two components. This small
radial velocity difference suggests that most of the relative velocity takes
place in the plane of the sky, and implies that SPT-CL J0356-5337 is a major
merger with a small impact parameter seen face-on. We also assess the relative
contributions of galaxy-scale halos to the overall mass of the core of the
cluster and find that within 800 kpc from the brightest cluster galaxy about
27% of the total mass can be attributed to visible and dark matter associated
with galaxies, whereas only 73% of the total mass in the core comes from
cluster-scale dark matter halos.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1906.08174 [pdf] - 1916986
Optical follow-up study of 32 high-redshift galaxy cluster candidates
from Planck with the William Herschel Telescope
Submitted: 2019-06-19
The Planck satellite has detected cluster candidates via the Sunyaev
Zel'dovich (SZ) effect, but the optical follow-up required to confirm these
candidates is still incomplete, especially at high redshifts and for SZ
detections at low significance. In this work we present our analysis of optical
observations obtained for 32 Planck cluster candidates using ACAM on the 4.2-m
William Herschel Telescope. These cluster candidates were preselected using
SDSS, WISE, and Pan-STARRS images to likely represent distant clusters at
redshifts $z \gtrsim 0.7$. We obtain photometric redshift and richness
estimates for all of the cluster candidates from a red-sequence analysis of
$r$-, $i$-, and $z$-band imaging data. In addition, long-slit observations
allow us to measure the redshifts of a subset of the clusters
spectroscopically. The optical richness is often lower than expected from the
inferred SZ mass when compared to scaling relations previously calibrated at
low redshifts. This likely indicates the impact of Eddington bias and
projection effects or noise-induced detections, especially at low
SZ-significance. Thus, optical follow-up not only provides redshift
measurements, but also an important independent verification method. We find
that 18 (7) of the candidates at redshifts $z > 0.5$ ($z > 0.8$) are at least
half as rich as expected from scaling relations, thereby clearly confirming
these candidates as massive clusters. While the complex selection function of
our sample due to our preselection hampers its use for cosmological studies, we
do provide a validation of massive high-redshift clusters particularly suitable
for further astrophysical investigations.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1606.05338 [pdf] - 1530851
KiDS-450: Cosmological parameter constraints from tomographic weak
gravitational lensing
Hildebrandt, H.;
Viola, M.;
Heymans, C.;
Joudaki, S.;
Kuijken, K.;
Blake, C.;
Erben, T.;
Joachimi, B.;
Klaes, D.;
Miller, L.;
Morrison, C. B.;
Nakajima, R.;
Kleijn, G. Verdoes;
Amon, A.;
Choi, A.;
Covone, G.;
de Jong, J. T. A.;
Dvornik, A.;
Conti, I. Fenech;
Grado, A.;
Harnois-Déraps, J.;
Herbonnet, R.;
Hoekstra, H.;
Köhlinger, F.;
McFarland, J.;
Mead, A.;
Merten, J.;
Napolitano, N.;
Peacock, J. A.;
Radovich, M.;
Schneider, P.;
Simon, P.;
Valentijn, E. A.;
Busch, J. L. van den;
van Uitert, E.;
Van Waerbeke, L.
Submitted: 2016-06-16, last modified: 2016-10-28
We present cosmological parameter constraints from a tomographic weak
gravitational lensing analysis of ~450deg$^2$ of imaging data from the Kilo
Degree Survey (KiDS). For a flat $\Lambda$CDM cosmology with a prior on $H_0$
that encompasses the most recent direct measurements, we find
$S_8\equiv\sigma_8\sqrt{\Omega_{\rm m}/0.3}=0.745\pm0.039$. This result is in
good agreement with other low redshift probes of large scale structure,
including recent cosmic shear results, along with pre-Planck cosmic microwave
background constraints. A $2.3$-$\sigma$ tension in $S_8$ and `substantial
discordance' in the full parameter space is found with respect to the Planck
2015 results. We use shear measurements for nearly 15 million galaxies,
determined with a new improved `self-calibrating' version of $lens$fit
validated using an extensive suite of image simulations. Four-band $ugri$
photometric redshifts are calibrated directly with deep spectroscopic surveys.
The redshift calibration is confirmed using two independent techniques based on
angular cross-correlations and the properties of the photometric redshift
probability distributions. Our covariance matrix is determined using an
analytical approach, verified numerically with large mock galaxy catalogues. We
account for uncertainties in the modelling of intrinsic galaxy alignments and
the impact of baryon feedback on the shape of the non-linear matter power
spectrum, in addition to the small residual uncertainties in the shear and
redshift calibration. The cosmology analysis was performed blind. Our
high-level data products, including shear correlation functions, covariance
matrices, redshift distributions, and Monte Carlo Markov Chains are available
at http://kids.strw.leidenuniv.nl.