Normalized to: Burkhart, B.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2006.16317 [pdf] - 2124993
First results from SMAUG: The need for preventative stellar feedback and
improved baryon cycling in semi-analytic models of galaxy formation
Pandya, Viraj;
Somerville, Rachel S.;
Anglés-Alcázar, Daniel;
Hayward, Christopher C.;
Bryan, Greg L.;
Fielding, Drummond B.;
Forbes, John C.;
Burkhart, Blakesley;
Genel, Shy;
Hernquist, Lars;
Kim, Chang-Goo;
Tonnesen, Stephanie;
Starkenburg, Tjitske
Submitted: 2020-06-29
Semi-analytic models (SAMs) are a promising means of tracking the physical
processes associated with galaxy formation, but many of their approximations
have not been rigorously tested. As part of the SMAUG (Simulating Multiscale
Astrophysics to Understand Galaxies) project, we compare predictions from the
FIRE-2 hydrodynamical "zoom-in" simulations to those from the Santa Cruz SAM
run on the same halo merger trees, with an emphasis on the global mass flow
cycle. Our study includes 13 halos spanning low-mass dwarfs (M_vir~10^10 M_sun
at z=0), intermediate-mass dwarfs (M_vir~10^11 M_sun) and Milky Way-mass
galaxies (M_vir~10^12 M_sun). The SAM and FIRE-2 predictions agree relatively
well with each other in terms of stellar and interstellar mass, but differ
dramatically on circumgalactic mass (the SAM is lower than FIRE-2 by ~3 orders
of magnitude for dwarfs). Strikingly, the SAM predicts higher gas accretion
rates for dwarfs compared to FIRE-2 by factors of ~10-100, and this is
compensated for with higher mass outflow rates in the SAM. We argue that the
most severe model discrepancies are caused by the lack of preventative stellar
feedback and the assumptions for halo gas cooling and recycling in the SAM. As
a first step towards resolving these model tensions, we present a simple yet
promising new preventative stellar feedback model in which the energy carried
by supernova-driven winds is allowed to heat some fraction of gas outside of
halos to at least the virial temperature such that accretion is suppressed.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:2006.14626 [pdf] - 2122719
Winds in Star Clusters Drive Kolmogorov Turbulence
Submitted: 2020-06-25
Intermediate and massive stars drive fast and powerful isotropic winds that
interact with the winds of nearby stars in star clusters and the surrounding
interstellar medium (ISM). Wind-ISM collisions generate astrospheres around
these stars that contain hot $T\sim 10^7$ K gas that adiabatically expands. As
individual bubbles expand and collide they become unstable, potentially driving
turbulence in star clusters. In this paper we use hydrodynamic simulations to
model a densely populated young star cluster within a homogeneous cloud to
study stellar wind collisions with the surrounding ISM. We model a
mass-segregated cluster of 20 B-type young main sequence stars with masses
ranging from 3--17 $M_{\odot}$. We evolve the winds for $\sim$11 kyrs and show
that wind-ISM collisions and over-lapping wind-blown bubbles around B-stars
mixes the hot gas and ISM material generating Kolmogorov-like turbulence on
small scales early in its evolution. We discuss how turbulence driven by
stellar winds may impact the subsequent generation of star formation in the
cluster
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:2006.10775 [pdf] - 2124938
The relative orientation between the magnetic field and gradients of
surface brightness within thin velocity slices of 12CO and 13CO emission from
the Taurus molecular cloud
Submitted: 2020-06-18, last modified: 2020-06-22
We examine the role of the interstellar magnetic field to modulate the
orientation of turbulent flows within the Taurus molecular cloud using spatial
gradients of thin velocity slices of 12CO and 13CO antenna temperatures. Our
analysis accounts for the random errors of the gradients that arise from the
thermal noise of the spectra. The orientations of the vectors normal to the
antenna temperature gradient vectors are compared to the magnetic field
orientations that are calculated from Planck 353~GHz polarization data. These
relative orientations are parameterized with the projected Rayleigh statistic
and mean resultant vector. For 12CO, 28 percent and 39 percent of the cloud
area exhibit strongly parallel or strongly perpendicular relative orientations
respectively. For the lower opacity 13CO emission, strongly parallel and
strongly perpendicular orientations are found in 7 percent and 43 percent of
the cloud area respectively. For both isotopologues, strongly parallel or
perpendicular alignments are restricted to localized regions with low levels of
turbulence. If the relative orientations serve as an observational proxy to the
Alfvenic Mach number then our results imply local variations of the Alfvenic
Mach number throughout the cloud.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:2001.06023 [pdf] - 2089077
The driving scale -- density decorrelation scale relation in a turbulent
medium
Submitted: 2020-01-16, last modified: 2020-04-22
Density fluctuations produced by supersonic turbulence are of great
importance to astrophysical chemical models. A property of these density
fluctuations is that the two point correlation function decreases with
increasing scale separation. The relation between the density decorrelation
length scale ($L_{\rm dec}$) and the turbulence driving scale ($L_{\rm drive}$)
determines how turbulence affects the density and chemical structures in the
interstellar medium (ISM), and is a key component for using observations of
atomic and molecular tracers to constrain turbulence properties. We run a set
of numerical simulations of supersonic magnetohydrodynamic turbulence, with
different sonic Mach numbers ($\mathcal{M}_s=4.5, 7$) , and driven on varying
scales (1/2.5, 1/5, 1/7) the box length. We derive the $L_{\rm dec}-L_{\rm
drive}$ relation as a function of Mach number, driving scale, and the
orientation of the line-of-sight (LOS) in respect to the magnetic-field. We
find that the mean ratio $L_{\rm dec}/L_{\rm drive} = 0.19 \pm 0.10$, when
averaged over snapshots, Mach numbers, driving lengths, and the three LOSs. For
LOS parallel to the magnetic field the density structures are statistically
smaller and the $L_{\rm dec}-L_{\rm drive}$ relation is tighter, with $L_{\rm
dec}/L_{\rm drive} = 0.112 \pm 0.024$. We discuss our results in the context of
using observations of chemical tracers to constrain the dominant turbulence
driving scale in the ISM.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:2004.09567 [pdf] - 2097421
Turbulence and Energetic Particles in Radiative Shock Waves in the
Cygnus Loop I: Shock Properties
Submitted: 2020-04-20
We have obtained a contiguous set of long-slit spectra of a shock wave in the
Cygnus Loop to investigate its structure, which is far from the morphology
predicted by 1D models. Proper motions from Hubble Space Telescope images
combined with the known distance to the Cygnus Loop provide an accurate shock
speed. Earlier analyses of shock spectra estimated the shock speed, postshock
density, temperature, and elemental abundances. In this paper we determine
several more shock parameters: a more accurate shock speed, ram pressure,
density, compression ratio, dust destruction efficiency, magnetic field
strength, and vorticity in the cooling region. From the derived shock
properties we estimate the emissivities of synchrotron emission in the radio
and pion decay emission in the gamma rays. Both are consistent with the
observations if we assume simple adiabatic compression of ambient cosmic rays
as in the van der Laan mechanism. We also find that, although the morphology is
far from that predicted by 1D models and the line ratios vary dramatically from
point to point, the average spectrum is matched reasonably well by 1D shock
models with the shock speed derived from the measured proper motion. A
subsequent paper will analyze the development of turbulence in the cooling zone
behind the shock.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1911.09029 [pdf] - 2001509
An In-depth Investigation of Faraday Depth Spectrum Using Synthetic
Observations of Turbulent MHD Simulations
Submitted: 2019-11-20
In this paper we present a detailed analysis of the Faraday depth (FD)
spectrum and its clean components obtained through the application of the
commonly used technique of Faraday rotation measure synthesis to analyze
spectro-polarimetric data. In order to directly compare the Faraday depth
spectrum with physical properties of a magneto-ionic medium, we generated
synthetic broad-bandwidth spectro-polarimetric observations from
magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) simulations of a transonic, isothermal, compressible
turbulent medium. We find that correlated magnetic field structures give rise
to a combination of spiky, localized peaks at certain FD values, and broad
structures in the FD spectrum. Although the majority of these spiky FD
structures appear narrow, giving an impression of a Faraday thin medium, we
show that they arise from strong synchrotron emissivity at that FD. Strong
emissivity at a FD can arise because of both strong spatially-local polarized
synchrotron emissivity at a FD or accumulation of weaker emissions along the
distance through a medium that have Faraday depths within half the width of the
rotation measure spread function. Such a complex Faraday depth spectrum is a
natural consequence of MHD turbulence when the lines of sight pass through a
few turbulent cells. This therefore complicates the convention of attributing
narrow FD peaks to presence of a Faraday rotating medium along the line of
sight. Our work shows that it is difficult to extract the FD along a line of
sight from the Faraday depth spectrum using standard methods for a turbulent
medium in which synchrotron emission and Faraday rotation occur simultaneously.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1902.10153 [pdf] - 2025406
Massive Star Formation via the Collapse of Subvirial and Virialized
Turbulent Massive Cores
Submitted: 2019-02-26, last modified: 2019-11-05
Similar to their low-mass counterparts, massive stars likely form via the
collapse of pre-stellar molecular cores. Recent observations suggest that most
massive cores are subvirial (i.e., not supported by turbulence) and therefore
are likely unstable to gravitational collapse. Here we perform radiation
hydrodynamic simulations to follow the collapse of turbulent massive
pre-stellar cores with subvirial and virialized initial conditions to explore
how their dynamic state affects the formation of massive stars and core
fragmentation into companion stars. We find that subvirial cores undergo rapid
monolithic collapse resulting in higher accretion rates at early times as
compared to the collapse of virialized cores that have the same physical
properties. In contrast, we find that virialized cores undergo a slower,
gradual collapse and significant turbulent fragmentation at early times
resulting in numerous companion stars. In the absence of strong magnetic fields
and protostellar outflows we find that the faster growth rate of massive stars
that are born out of subvirial cores leads to an increase in the radiative
heating of the core thereby further suppressing fragmentation at early times
when turbulent fragmentation occurs for virialized cores. Regardless of initial
condition, we find that the massive accretion disks that form around massive
stars dominant the accretion flow onto the star at late times and eventually
become gravitationally unstable and fragment to form companion stars at late
times.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1909.12305 [pdf] - 1996140
Chemical Abundances in a Turbulent Medium -- H$_2$, OH$^+$, H$_2$O$^+$,
ArH$^+$
Submitted: 2019-09-26, last modified: 2019-10-09
Supersonic turbulence results in strong density fluctuations in the
interstellar medium (ISM), which have a profound effect on the chemical
structure. Particularly useful probes of the diffuse ISM are the ArH$^+$,
OH$^+$, H$_2$O$^+$ molecular ions, which are highly sensitive to fluctuations
in the density and the H$_2$ abundance. We use isothermal magnetohydrodynamic
(MHD) simulations of various sonic Mach numbers, $\mathcal{M}_s$, and density
decorrelation scales, $y_{\rm dec}$, to model the turbulent density field. We
post-process the simulations with chemical models and obtain the probability
density functions (PDFs) for the H$_2$, ArH$^+$, OH$^+$ and H$_2$O$^+$
abundances. We find that the PDF dispersions increases with increasing
$\mathcal{M}_s$ and $y_{\rm dec}$, as the magnitude of the density fluctuations
increases, and as they become more coherent. Turbulence also affects the median
abundances: when $\mathcal{M}_s$ and $y_{\rm dec}$ are high, low-density
regions with low H$_2$ abundance become prevalent, resulting in an enhancement
of ArH$^+$ compared to OH$^+$ and H$_2$O$^+$. We compare our models with
Herschel observations. The large scatter in the observed abundances, as well as
the high observed ArH$^+$/OH$^+$ and ArH$^+$/H$_2$O$^+$ ratios are naturally
reproduced by our supersonic $(\mathcal{M}_s=4.5)$, large decorrelation scale
$(y_{\rm dec}=0.8)$ model, supporting a scenario of a large-scale turbulence
driving. The abundances also depend on the UV intensity, CR ionization rate,
and the cloud column density, and the observed scatter may be influenced by
fluctuations in these parameters.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1908.00544 [pdf] - 1994114
A Markov model for non-lognormal density distributions in compressive
isothermal turbulence
Submitted: 2019-08-01, last modified: 2019-10-06
Compressive isothermal turbulence is known to have a near lognormal density
probability distribution function (PDF) with a width that scales with the sonic
Mach number and nature of the turbulent driving (solenoidal vs compressive).
However, the physical processes that mold the extreme high and low density
structures in a turbulent medium can be different, with the densest structures
being composed of strong shocks that evolve on shorter timescales than the low
density fluid. The density PDF in a turbulent medium exhibits deviations from
lognormal due to shocks, that increases with the sonic Mach number, which is
often ignored in analytic models for turbulence and star formation. We develop
a simple model for turbulence by treating it as a continuous Markov process,
which explains both the density PDF and the transient timescales of structures
as a function of density, using a framework developed in n Scannapieco &
Safarzadeh (2018). Our analytic model depends on only a single parameter, the
effective compressive sonic Mach number, and successfully describes the
non-lognormal behavior seen in both 1D and 3D simulations of supersonic and
subsonic compressive isothermal turbulence. The model quantifies the
non-lognormal distribution of density structures in turbulent environments, and
has application to star forming molecular clouds and star formation
efficiencies.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1905.00918 [pdf] - 1958126
Do Androids Dream of Magnetic Fields? Using Neural Networks to Interpret
the Turbulent Interstellar Medium
Submitted: 2019-05-02, last modified: 2019-08-21
The interstellar medium (ISM) of galaxies is composed of a turbulent
magnetized plasma. In order to quantitatively measure relevant turbulent
parameters of the ISM, a wide variety of statistical techniques and metrics
have been developed that are often tested using numerical simulations and
analytic formalism. These metrics are typically based on the Fourier power
spectrum, which does not capture the Fourier phase information that carries the
morphological characteristics of images. In this work we use density slices of
magnetohydrodyanmic turbulence simulations to demonstrate that a modern tool,
convolutional neural networks, can capture significant information encoded in
the Fourier phases. We train the neural network to distinguish between two
simulations with different levels of magnetization. We find that, even given a
tiny slice of simulation data, a relatively simple network can distinguish
sub-Alfv\'enic (strong magnetic field) and super-Alfv\'enic (weak magnetic
field) turbulence >98% of the time, even when all spectral amplitude
information is stripped from the images. In order to better understand how the
neural network is picking out differences betweem the two classes of
simulations we apply a neural network analysis method called "saliency maps".
The saliency map analysis shows that sharp ridge-like features are a
distinguishing morphological characteristic in such simulations. Our analysis
provides a way forward for deeper understanding of the relationship between
magnetohydrodyanmic turbulence and gas morphology and motivates further
applications of neural networks for studies of turbulence. We make publicly
available all data and software needed to reproduce our results.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1908.07495 [pdf] - 1945993
PICO: Probe of Inflation and Cosmic Origins
Hanany, S.;
Alvarez, M.;
Artis, E.;
Ashton, P.;
Aumont, J.;
Aurlien, R.;
Banerji, R.;
Barreiro, R. B.;
Bartlett, J. G.;
Basak, S.;
Battaglia, N.;
Bock, J.;
Boddy, K. K.;
Bonato, M.;
Borrill, J.;
Bouchet, F.;
Boulanger, F.;
Burkhart, B.;
Chluba, J.;
Chuss, D.;
Clark, S.;
Cooperrider, J.;
Crill, B. P.;
De Zotti, G.;
Delabrouille, J.;
Di Valentino, E.;
Didier, J.;
Dore, O.;
Eriksen, H. K.;
Errard, J.;
Essinger-Hileman, T.;
Feeney, S.;
Filippini, J.;
Fissel, L.;
Flauger, R.;
Fuskeland, U.;
Gluscevic, V.;
Gorski, K. M.;
Green, D.;
Hensley, B.;
Herranz, D.;
Hill, J. C.;
Hivon, E.;
Hlozek, R.;
Hubmayr, J.;
Johnson, B. R.;
Jones, W.;
Jones, T.;
Knox, L.;
Kogut, A.;
Lopez-Caniego, M.;
Lawrence, C.;
Lazarian, A.;
Li, Z.;
Madhavacheril, M.;
Melin, J. B.;
Meyers, J.;
Murray, C.;
Negrello, M.;
Novak, G.;
O'Brient, R.;
Paine, C.;
Pearson, T.;
Pogosian, L.;
Pryke, C.;
Puglisi, G.;
Remazeilles, M.;
Rocha, G.;
Schmittfull, M.;
Scott, D.;
Shirron, P.;
Stephens, I.;
Sutin, B.;
Tomasi, M.;
Trangsrud, A.;
van Engelen, A.;
Vansyngel, F.;
Wehus, I. K.;
Wen, Q.;
Xu, S.;
Young, K.;
Zonca, A.
Submitted: 2019-08-20
The Probe of Inflation and Cosmic Origins (PICO) is a proposed probe-scale
space mission consisting of an imaging polarimeter operating in frequency bands
between 20 and 800 GHz. We describe the science achievable by PICO, which has
sensitivity equivalent to more than 3300 Planck missions, the technical
implementation, the schedule and cost.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1907.04460 [pdf] - 1914294
Astro2020: Training the Future Generation of Computational Researchers
Besla, Gurtina;
Huppenkothen, Daniela;
Lloyd-Ronning, Nicole;
Schneider, Evan;
Behroozi, Peter;
Burkhart, Blakesley;
Chan, C. K.;
Jacobson, Seth A.;
Morrison, Sarah;
Nam, Hai Ah;
Naoz, Smadar;
Peter, Annika;
Ramirez-Ruiz, Enrico
Submitted: 2019-07-09
The current disparity in computational knowledge is a critical hindrance to
the diversity and success of the field. Recommendations are outlined for
policies and funding models to enable the growth and retention of a new
generation of computational researchers that reflect the demographics of the
undergraduate population in Astronomy and Physics.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1703.03035 [pdf] - 1899309
Velocity centroid gradients for absorbing media
Submitted: 2017-03-08, last modified: 2019-06-11
We explore how the velocity gradient technique (VGT) can be applied to
absorbing media in the case of$^{13}$CO 2-1 emission. The VGT is a new way to
trace magnetic fields in the plane of the sky using only spectroscopic
observations. We apply the VGT to magnetohydrodynamic turbulence simulations
that have been post-processed to include $^{13}$CO 2-1 emission and we
calculate the velocity centroid gradients. We find that the velocity centroid
gradients trace the projected magnetic field in media with different $^{13}$CO
abundances, densities and optical depths. Our study opens up the possibility of
using velocity centroid gradients to trace magnetic fields in molecular clouds
using 13CO emission.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1906.04788 [pdf] - 1905884
CMB foreground measurements through broad-band radio
spectro-polarimetry: prospects of the SKA-MPG telescope
Submitted: 2019-06-11
Precise measurement of the foreground synchrotron emission, which
contaminates the faint polarized cosmic microwave background radiation (CMB),
is a major challenge for the next-generation of CMB experiments. To address
this, dedicated foreground measurement experiments are being undertaken at
radio frequencies between 2 and 40 GHz. Foreground polarized synchrotron
emission measurements are particularly challenging, primarily due to the
complicated frequency dependence in the presence of Faraday rotation, and are
best recovered through broad fractional-bandwidth polarization measurements at
frequencies $\lesssim 5$ GHz. A unique opportunity for measuring the foreground
polarized synchrotron emission will be provided by the 15-m SKA-MPG telescope
operating in the frequency range 1.7 to 3.5~GHz (S-Band). Here, we present the
scope of a Southern sky survey in S-Band at 1 degree angular resolution and
explore its added advantage for application of powerful techniques, such as,
Stokes $Q$, $U$ fitting and RM-synthesis. A full Southern-sky polarization
survey with this telescope, when combined with other on-going efforts at
slightly higher frequencies, will provide an excellent frequency coverage for
modeling and extrapolating the foreground polarized synchrotron emission to CMB
frequencies ($\gtrsim80$~GHz) with rms brightness temperature better than 10~nK
per 1 degree$^2$. We find that this survey will be crucial for understanding
the effects of Faraday depolarization, especially in low Galactic latitude
regions. This will allow better foreground cleaning and thus will contribute
significantly in further improving component separation analyses and increase
usable sky area for cosmological analysis of the \textit{Planck} data, and the
\textit{LiteBIRD} mission in the future.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1805.11104 [pdf] - 1920777
The Self-gravitating Gas Fraction and The Critical Density for Star
Formation
Submitted: 2018-05-28, last modified: 2019-05-29
We analytically calculate the star formation efficiency and dense
self-gravitating gas fraction in the presence of magneto-gravo-turbulence using
the model of Burkhart (2018), which employs a piecewise lognormal and powerlaw
density Probability Distribution Function (PDF). We show that the PDF
transition density from lognormal to powerlaw forms is a mathematically
motivated critical density for star formation and can be physically related to
the density where the Jeans length is comparable to the sonic length, i.e. the
post-shock critical density for collapse. When the PDF transition density is
taken as the critical density, the instantaneous star formation efficiency
($\epsilon_{\rm inst}$) and depletion time ($\tau_{\rm depl}$) can be
calculated from the dense self-gravitating gas fraction represented as the
fraction of gas in the PDF powerlaw tail. We minimize the number of free
parameters in the analytic expressions for $\epsilon_{\rm inst}$ and $\tau_{\rm
depl}$ by using the PDF transition density instead of a parameterized critical
density for collapse and thus provide a more direct pathway for comparison with
observations. We test the analytic predictions for the transition density and
self-gravitating gas fraction against AREPO moving mesh gravoturbulent
simulations and find good agreement. We predict that, when gravity dominates
the density distribution in the star-forming gas, the star formation efficiency
should be weakly anti-correlated with the sonic Mach number while the depletion
time should increase with increasing sonic Mach number. The star formation
efficiency and depletion time depend primarily on the dense self-gravitating
gas fraction, which in turn depends on the interplay of gravity, turbulence and
stellar feedback. Our model prediction is in agreement with recent
observations, such as the M51 PdBI Arcsecond Whirlpool Survey (PAWS).
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1904.08941 [pdf] - 1899392
The Supersonic Project: Shining Light on SIGOs - a New Formation Channel
for Globular Clusters
Submitted: 2019-04-18, last modified: 2019-05-24
Supersonically induced gas objects (SIGOs) with little to no dark matter
component are predicted to exist in patches of the Universe with non-negligible
relative velocity between baryons and the dark matter at the time of
recombination. Using {\sc arepo} hydrodynamic simulations we find that the gas
densities inside these objects are high enough to allow stars to form. An
estimate of the luminosity of the first star clusters formed within these SIGOs
suggests that they may be observed at high redshift using future HST and JWST
observations. Furthermore, our simulations indicate that SIGOs lie in a
distinct place in the luminosity-radius parameter space, which can be used
observationally to distinguish SIGOs from dark-matter hosting gas systems.
Finally, as a proof-of-concept, we model star formation before reionization and
evolve these systems to current times. We find that SIGOs occupy a similar part
of the magnitude-radius parameter space as globular clusters. These results
suggest that SIGOs may be linked with present-day metal-poor local globular
clusters. Since the relative velocity between the baryons and dark matter is
coherent over a few Mpc scales, we predict that if this is the dominant
mechanism for the formation of globular clusters, their abundance should vary
significantly over these scales.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1904.10484 [pdf] - 1898029
TurbuStat: Turbulence Statistics in Python
Submitted: 2019-04-23, last modified: 2019-04-25
We present TurbuStat (v1.0): a Python package for computing turbulence
statistics in spectral-line data cubes. TurbuStat includes implementations of
fourteen methods for recovering turbulent properties from observational data.
Additional features of the software include: distance metrics for comparing two
data sets; a segmented linear model for fitting lines with a break-point; a
two-dimensional elliptical power-law model; multi-core fast-fourier-transform
support; a suite for producing simulated observations of fractional Brownian
Motion fields, including two-dimensional images and optically-thin HI data
cubes; and functions for creating realistic world coordinate system information
for synthetic observations. This paper summarizes the TurbuStat package and
provides representative examples using several different methods. TurbuStat is
an open-source package and we welcome community feedback and contributions.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1903.06796 [pdf] - 1850859
Astro2020 Science White Paper: The Next Decade of Astroinformatics and
Astrostatistics
Siemiginowska, A.;
Eadie, G.;
Czekala, I.;
Feigelson, E.;
Ford, E. B.;
Kashyap, V.;
Kuhn, M.;
Loredo, T.;
Ntampaka, M.;
Stevens, A.;
Avelino, A.;
Borne, K.;
Budavari, T.;
Burkhart, B.;
Cisewski-Kehe, J.;
Civano, F.;
Chilingarian, I.;
van Dyk, D. A.;
Fabbiano, G.;
Finkbeiner, D. P.;
Foreman-Mackey, D.;
Freeman, P.;
Fruscione, A.;
Goodman, A. A.;
Graham, M.;
Guenther, H. M.;
Hakkila, J.;
Hernquist, L.;
Huppenkothen, D.;
James, D. J.;
Law, C.;
Lazio, J.;
Lee, T.;
López-Morales, M.;
Mahabal, A. A.;
Mandel, K.;
Meng, X. L.;
Moustakas, J.;
Muna, D.;
Peek, J. E. G.;
Richards, G.;
Portillo, S. K. N.;
Scargle, J.;
de Souza, R. S.;
Speagle, J. S.;
Stassun, K. G.;
Stenning, D. C.;
Taylor, S. R.;
Tremblay, G. R.;
Trimble, V.;
Yanamandra-Fisher, P. A.;
Young, C. A.
Submitted: 2019-03-15
Over the past century, major advances in astronomy and astrophysics have been
largely driven by improvements in instrumentation and data collection. With the
amassing of high quality data from new telescopes, and especially with the
advent of deep and large astronomical surveys, it is becoming clear that future
advances will also rely heavily on how those data are analyzed and interpreted.
New methodologies derived from advances in statistics, computer science, and
machine learning are beginning to be employed in sophisticated investigations
that are not only bringing forth new discoveries, but are placing them on a
solid footing. Progress in wide-field sky surveys, interferometric imaging,
precision cosmology, exoplanet detection and characterization, and many
subfields of stellar, Galactic and extragalactic astronomy, has resulted in
complex data analysis challenges that must be solved to perform scientific
inference. Research in astrostatistics and astroinformatics will be necessary
to develop the state-of-the-art methodology needed in astronomy. Overcoming
these challenges requires dedicated, interdisciplinary research. We recommend:
(1) increasing funding for interdisciplinary projects in astrostatistics and
astroinformatics; (2) dedicating space and time at conferences for
interdisciplinary research and promotion; (3) developing sustainable funding
for long-term astrostatisics appointments; and (4) funding infrastructure
development for data archives and archive support, state-of-the-art algorithms,
and efficient computing.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:1902.10541 [pdf] - 1842579
PICO: Probe of Inflation and Cosmic Origins
Hanany, Shaul;
Alvarez, Marcelo;
Artis, Emmanuel;
Ashton, Peter;
Aumont, Jonathan;
Aurlien, Ragnhild;
Banerji, Ranajoy;
Barreiro, R. Belen;
Bartlett, James G.;
Basak, Soumen;
Battaglia, Nick;
Bock, Jamie;
Boddy, Kimberly K.;
Bonato, Matteo;
Borrill, Julian;
Bouchet, François;
Boulanger, François;
Burkhart, Blakesley;
Chluba, Jens;
Chuss, David;
Clark, Susan E.;
Cooperrider, Joelle;
Crill, Brendan P.;
De Zotti, Gianfranco;
Delabrouille, Jacques;
Di Valentino, Eleonora;
Didier, Joy;
Doré, Olivier;
Eriksen, Hans K.;
Errard, Josquin;
Essinger-Hileman, Tom;
Feeney, Stephen;
Filippini, Jeffrey;
Fissel, Laura;
Flauger, Raphael;
Fuskeland, Unni;
Gluscevic, Vera;
Gorski, Krzysztof M.;
Green, Dan;
Hensley, Brandon;
Herranz, Diego;
Hill, J. Colin;
Hivon, Eric;
Hložek, Renée;
Hubmayr, Johannes;
Johnson, Bradley R.;
Jones, William;
Jones, Terry;
Knox, Lloyd;
Kogut, Al;
López-Caniego, Marcos;
Lawrence, Charles;
Lazarian, Alex;
Li, Zack;
Madhavacheril, Mathew;
Melin, Jean-Baptiste;
Meyers, Joel;
Murray, Calum;
Negrello, Mattia;
Novak, Giles;
O'Brient, Roger;
Paine, Christopher;
Pearson, Tim;
Pogosian, Levon;
Pryke, Clem;
Puglisi, Giuseppe;
Remazeilles, Mathieu;
Rocha, Graca;
Schmittfull, Marcel;
Scott, Douglas;
Shirron, Peter;
Stephens, Ian;
Sutin, Brian;
Tomasi, Maurizio;
Trangsrud, Amy;
van Engelen, Alexander;
Vansyngel, Flavien;
Wehus, Ingunn K.;
Wen, Qi;
Xu, Siyao;
Young, Karl;
Zonca, Andrea
Submitted: 2019-02-26, last modified: 2019-03-05
The Probe of Inflation and Cosmic Origins (PICO) is an imaging polarimeter
that will scan the sky for 5 years in 21 frequency bands spread between 21 and
799 GHz. It will produce full-sky surveys of intensity and polarization with a
final combined-map noise level of 0.87 $\mu$K arcmin for the required
specifications, equivalent to 3300 Planck missions, and with our current
best-estimate would have a noise level of 0.61 $\mu$K arcmin (6400 Planck
missions). PICO will either determine the energy scale of inflation by
detecting the tensor to scalar ratio at a level $r=5\times 10^{-4}~(5\sigma)$,
or will rule out with more than $5\sigma$ all inflation models for which the
characteristic scale in the potential is the Planck scale. With LSST's data it
could rule out all models of slow-roll inflation. PICO will detect the sum of
neutrino masses at $>4\sigma$, constrain the effective number of light particle
species with $\Delta N_{\rm eff}<0.06~(2\sigma)$, and elucidate processes
affecting the evolution of cosmic structures by measuring the optical depth to
reionization with errors limited by cosmic variance and by constraining the
evolution of the amplitude of linear fluctuations $\sigma_{8}(z)$ with
sub-percent accuracy. Cross-correlating PICO's map of the thermal
Sunyaev-Zeldovich effect with LSST's gold sample of galaxies will precisely
trace the evolution of thermal pressure with $z$. PICO's maps of the Milky Way
will be used to determine the make up of galactic dust and the role of magnetic
fields in star formation efficiency. With 21 full sky legacy maps in intensity
and polarization, which cannot be obtained in any other way, the mission will
enrich many areas of astrophysics. PICO is the only single-platform instrument
with the combination of sensitivity, angular resolution, frequency bands, and
control of systematic effects that can deliver this compelling, timely, and
broad science.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:1711.09907 [pdf] - 1759253
Developing the 3-Point Correlation Function For the Turbulent
Interstellar Medium
Submitted: 2017-11-27, last modified: 2018-10-01
We present the first application of the angle-dependent 3-Point Correlation
Function (3PCF) to the density fields magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) turbulence
simulations intended to model interstellar (ISM) turbulence. Previous work has
demonstrated that the angle-averaged bispectrum, the 3PCF's Fourier-space
analog, is sensitive to the sonic and Alfv\'enic Mach numbers of turbulence.
Here we show that introducing angular information via multipole moments with
respect to the triangle opening angle offers considerable additional
discriminatory power on these parameters. We exploit a fast, order $N_{\rm g}
\log N_{\rm g}$ ($N_{\rm g}$ the number of grid cells used for a Fourier
Transform) 3PCF algorithm to study a suite of MHD turbulence simulations with
10 different combinations of sonic and Alfv\'enic Mach numbers over a range
from sub to super-sonic and sub to super-Alfv\'{e}nic. The 3PCF algorithm's
speed for the first time enables full quantification of the time-variation of
our signal: we study 9 timeslices for each condition, demonstrating that the
3PCF is sufficiently time-stable to be used as an ISM diagnostic. In future,
applying this framework to 3-D dust maps will enable better treatment of dust
as a cosmological foreground as well as reveal conditions in the ISM that shape
star formation.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:1804.02732 [pdf] - 1762926
Statistical tracing of magnetic fields: comparing and improving the
techniques
Yuen, Ka Ho;
Chen, Junda;
Hu, Yue;
Ho, Ka Wai;
Lazarian, A.;
Lazarian, Victor;
Yang, Bo;
Burkhart, Blakesley;
Correia, Caio;
Cho, Jungyeon;
Canto, Bruno;
De Medeiros, J. R.
Submitted: 2018-04-08, last modified: 2018-08-14
Magnetohydrodynamic(MHD) turbulence displays velocity anisotropies which
reflect the direction of the magnetic field. This anisotropy has led to the
development of a number of statistical techniques for studying magnetic fields
in the interstellar medium. In this paper, we review and compare three
techniques that use radio position-position-velocity data for determining
magnetic field strength and morphology : the correlation function anisotropy
(CFA), Principal Component Analysis of Anisotropies (PCAA), and the more recent
Velocity Gradient Technique (VGT). We compare these three techniques and
suggest improvements to the CFA and PCAA techniques to increase their accuracy
and versatility. In particular, we suggest and successfully implement a much
faster way of calculating non-periodic correlation functions for the CFA. We
discuss possible improvements to the current implementation of the PCAA. We
show the advantages of the VGT in terms of magnetic field tracing and stress
the complementary nature with the other two techniques.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:1801.05428 [pdf] - 1736286
The Star Formation Rate in the Gravoturbulent Interstellar Medium
Submitted: 2018-01-16, last modified: 2018-06-15
Stars form in supersonic turbulent molecular clouds that are
self-gravitating. We present an analytic determination of the star formation
rate (SFR) in a gravoturbulent medium based on the density probability
distribution function of molecular clouds having a piecewise lognormal and
power law form. This is in contrast to previous analytic SFR models that are
governed primarily by interstellar turbulence which sets purely lognormal
density PDFs. In the gravoturbulent SFR model described herein, low density gas
resides in the lognormal portion of the PDF. Gas becomes gravitationally
unstable past a critical density ($\rho_{crit}$), and the PDF begins to forms a
power law. As the collapse of the cloud proceeds, the transitional density
($\rho_t$) between the lognormal and power law portions of the PDF moves
towards lower-density while the slope of the power law ($\alpha$) becomes
increasingly shallow. The star formation rate per free-fall time is calculated
via an integral over the lognormal from $\rho_{crit}$ to $\rho_t$ and an
integral over the power law from $\rho_t$ to the maximum density. As $\alpha$
becomes shallower the SFR accelerates beyond the expected values calculated
from a lognormal density PDF. We show that the star formation efficiency per
free fall time in observations of local molecular cloud increases with
shallower PDF power law slopes, in agreement with our model. Our model can
explain why star formation is spatially and temporally variable within a cloud
and why the depletion times observed in local and extragalactic giant molecular
clouds vary. Both star-bursting and quiescent star-forming systems can be
explained without the need to invoke extreme variations of turbulence in the
local interstellar environment.
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:1805.11105 [pdf] - 1729004
Star formation from dense shocked regions in supersonic isothermal
magneto-turbulence
Submitted: 2018-05-28
Supersonic isothermal turbulence establishes a network of transient dense
shocks that sweep up material and have a density profile described by balance
between ram pressure of the background fluid versus the magnetic and gas
pressure gradient behind the shock. These rare, densest regions of a turbulent
environment can become Jeans unstable and collapse to form pre-stellar cores.
Using numerical simulations of magneto-gravo-turbulence, we describe the
structural properties of dense shocks, which are the seeds of gravitational
collapse, as a function of magnetic field strength. In the regime of a weak
magnetic field, the collapse is isotropic. Strong magnetic field strengths lead
to significant anisotropy in the shocked distribution and collapse occurs
preferentially parallel to the field lines. Our work provides insight into
analyzing the magnetic field topology and density structures of young
protostellar collapse, which the theory presented here predicts are associated
with large-scale strong shocks that persist for at least a free-fall time.
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:1803.11522 [pdf] - 1686812
The CARMA-NRO Orion Survey
Kong, Shuo;
Arce, Héctor G.;
Feddersen, Jesse R.;
Carpenter, John M.;
Nakamura, Fumitaka;
Shimajiri, Yoshito;
Isella, Andrea;
Ossenkopf-Okada, Volker;
Sargent, Anneila I.;
Sánchez-Monge, Álvaro;
Suri, Sümeyye T.;
Kauffmann, Jens;
Pillai, Thushara;
Pineda, Jaime E.;
Koda, Jin;
Bally, John;
Lis, Dariusz C.;
Padoan, Paolo;
Klessen, Ralf;
Mairs, Steve;
Goodman, Alyssa;
Goldsmith, Paul;
McGehee, Peregrine;
Schilke, Peter;
Teuben, Peter J.;
Maureira, María José;
Hara, Chihomi;
Ginsburg, Adam;
Burkhart, Blakesley;
Smith, Rowan J.;
Schmiedeke, Anika;
Pineda, Jorge L.;
Ishii, Shun;
Sasaki, Kazushige;
Kawabe, Ryohei;
Urasawa, Yumiko;
Oyamada, Shuri;
Tanabe, Yoshihiro
Submitted: 2018-03-30
We present the first results from a new, high resolution, $^{12}$CO(1-0),
$^{13}$CO(1-0), and C$^{18}$O(1-0) molecular line survey of the Orion A cloud,
hereafter referred to as the CARMA-NRO Orion Survey. CARMA observations have
been combined with single-dish data from the Nobeyama 45m telescope to provide
extended images at about 0.01 pc resolution, with a dynamic range of
approximately 1200 in spatial scale. Here we describe the practical details of
the data combination in uv space, including flux scale matching, the conversion
of single dish data to visibilities, and joint deconvolution of single dish and
interferometric data. A $\Delta$-variance analysis indicates that no artifacts
are caused by combining data from the two instruments. Initial analysis of the
data cubes, including moment maps, average spectra, channel maps,
position-velocity diagrams, excitation temperature, column density, and line
ratio maps provides evidence of complex and interesting structures such as
filaments, bipolar outflows, shells, bubbles, and photo-eroded pillars. The
implications for star formation processes are profound and follow-up scientific
studies by the CARMA-NRO Orion team are now underway. We plan to make all the
data products described here generally accessible; some are already available
at https://dataverse.harvard.edu/dataverse/CARMA-NRO-Orion
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:1706.00106 [pdf] - 1670440
A Unified Model for Galactic Discs: Star Formation, Turbulence Driving,
and Mass Transport
Submitted: 2017-05-31, last modified: 2018-03-29
We introduce a new model for the structure and evolution of the gas in
galactic discs. In the model the gas is in vertical pressure and energy
balance. Star formation feedback injects energy and momentum, and
non-axisymmetric torques prevent the gas from becoming more than marginally
gravitationally unstable. From these assumptions we derive the relationship
between galaxies' bulk properties (gas surface density, stellar content, and
rotation curve) and their star formation rates, gas velocity dispersions, and
rates of radial inflow. We show that the turbulence in discs can be powered
primarily by star formation feedback, radial transport, or a combination of the
two. In contrast to models that omit either radial transport or star formation
feedback, the predictions of this model yield excellent agreement with a wide
range of observations, including the star formation law measured in both
spatially resolved and unresolved data, the correlation between galaxies' star
formation rates and velocity dispersions, and observed rates of radial inflow.
The agreement holds across a wide range of galaxy mass and type, from local
dwarfs to extreme starbursts to high-redshifts discs. We apply the model to
galaxies on the star-forming main sequence, and show that it predicts a
transition from mostly gravity-driven turbulence at high redshift to star
formation-driven turbulence at low redshift. This transition, and the changes
in mass transport rates that it produces, naturally explain why galaxy bulges
tend to form at high redshift and discs at lower redshift, and why galaxies
tend to quench inside-out.
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:1802.10092 [pdf] - 1666849
The Multi-phase Turbulence Density Power Spectra in the Perseus
Molecular Cloud
Submitted: 2018-02-27
We derive two-dimensional spatial power spectra of four distinct interstellar
medium tracers, HI, $^{12}$CO($J$=1--0), $^{13}$CO($J$=1--0), and dust, in the
Perseus molecular cloud, covering linear scales ranging from $\sim$0.1 pc to
$\sim$90 pc. Among the four tracers, we find the steepest slopes of
$-3.23\pm0.05$ and $-3.22\pm0.05$ for the uncorrected and opacity-corrected HI
column density images. This result suggests that the HI in and around Perseus
traces a non-gravitating, transonic medium on average, with a negligible effect
from opacity. On the other hand, we measure the shallowest slope of
$-2.72\pm0.12$ for the 2MASS dust extinction data and interpret this as the
signature of a self-gravitating, supersonic medium. Possible variations in the
dust-to-gas ratio likely do not change our conclusion. Finally, we derive
slopes of $-3.08\pm0.08$ and $-2.88\pm0.07$ for the ${}^{12}$CO(1--0) and
${}^{13}$CO(1--0) integrated intensity images. Based on theoretical predictions
for an optically thick medium, we interpret these slopes of roughly $-3$ as
implying that both CO lines are susceptible to the opacity effect. While simple
tests for the impact of CO formation and depletion indicate that the measured
slopes of ${}^{12}$CO(1--0) and ${}^{13}$CO(1--0) are not likely affected by
these chemical effects, our results generally suggest that chemically more
complex and/or fully optically thick media may not be a reliable observational
tracer for characterizing turbulence.
[29]
oai:arXiv.org:1802.05403 [pdf] - 1652486
Advanced Diagnostics for the Study of Linearly Polarized Emission. II:
Application to Diffuse Interstellar Radio Synchrotron Emission
Herron, C. A.;
Burkhart, Blakesley;
Gaensler, B. M.;
Lewis, G. F.;
McClure-Griffiths, N. M.;
Bernardi, G.;
Carretti, E.;
Haverkorn, M.;
Kesteven, M.;
Poppi, S.;
Staveley-Smith, L.
Submitted: 2018-02-14
Diagnostics of polarized emission provide us with valuable information on the
Galactic magnetic field and the state of turbulence in the interstellar medium,
which cannot be obtained from synchrotron intensity alone. In Paper I (Herron
et al. 2017b), we derived polarization diagnostics that are rotationally and
translationally invariant in the $Q$-$U$ plane, similar to the polarization
gradient. In this paper, we apply these diagnostics to simulations of ideal
magnetohydrodynamic turbulence that have a range of sonic and Alfv\'enic Mach
numbers. We generate synthetic images of Stokes $Q$ and $U$ for these
simulations, for the cases where the turbulence is illuminated from behind by
uniform polarized emission, and where the polarized emission originates from
within the turbulent volume. From these simulated images we calculate the
polarization diagnostics derived in Paper I, for different lines of sight
relative to the mean magnetic field, and for a range of frequencies. For all of
our simulations, we find that the polarization gradient is very similar to the
generalized polarization gradient, and that both trace spatial variations in
the magnetoionic medium for the case where emission originates within the
turbulent volume, provided that the medium is not supersonic. We propose a
method for distinguishing the cases of emission coming from behind or within a
turbulent, Faraday rotating medium, and a method to partly map the rotation
measure of the observed region. We also speculate on statistics of these
diagnostics that may allow us to constrain the physical properties of an
observed turbulent region.
[30]
oai:arXiv.org:1707.09356 [pdf] - 1757221
The Anatomy of the Column Density Probability Distribution Function
(N-PDF)
Submitted: 2017-07-28
The column density probability distribution function (N-PDF) of GMCs has been
used as a diagnostic of star formation. Simulations and analytic predictions
have suggested the N-PDF is composed of a low density lognormal component and a
high density power-law component, tracing turbulence and gravitational
collapse, respectively. In this paper, we study how various properties of the
true 2D column density distribution create the shape, or "anatomy" of the PDF.
We test our ideas and analytic approaches using both a real, observed, PDF
based on Herschel observations of dust emission as well as a simulation that
uses the ENZO code. Using a dendrogram analysis, we examine the three main
components of the N-PDF: the lognormal component, the power-law component, and
the transition point between these two components. We find that the power-law
component of an N-PDF is the summation of N-PDFs of power-law substructures
identified by the dendrogram algorithm. We also find that the analytic solution
to the transition point between lognormal and power-law components proposed by
Burkhart, Stalpes & Collins (2017) is applicable when tested on observations
and simulations, within the uncertainties. We reconfirm and extend the results
of Lombardi, Alves & Lada (2015), which stated that the lognormal component of
the N-PDF is difficult to constrain due to the artificial choice of the map
area. Based on the resulting anatomy of the N-PDF, we suggest avoiding
analyzing the column density structures of a star forming region based solely
on fits to the lognormal component of an N-PDF. We also suggest applying the
N-PDF analysis in combination with the dendrogram algorithm, to obtain a more
complete picture of the global and local environments and their effects on the
density structures.
[31]
oai:arXiv.org:1706.07038 [pdf] - 1585002
The Detectability of Radio Auroral Emission from Proxima B
Submitted: 2017-06-21, last modified: 2017-06-29
Magnetically active stars possess stellar winds whose interaction with
planetary magnetic fields produces radio auroral emission. We examine the
detectability of radio auroral emission from Proxima b, the closest known
exosolar planet orbiting our nearest neighboring star, Proxima Centauri. Using
the Radiometric Bode's Law, we estimate the radio flux produced by the
interaction of Proxima Centauri's stellar wind and Proxima b's magnetosphere
for different planetary magnetic field strengths. For plausible planetary
masses, Proxima b produces 6-83 mJy of auroral radio flux at frequencies of
0.3-0.8 MHz for planetary magnetic field strengths of 1-3 B$_{\oplus}$.
According to recent MHD models that vary the orbital parameters of the system,
this emission is expected to be highly variable. This variability is due to
large fluctuations in the size of Proxima b's magnetosphere as it crosses the
equatorial streamer regions of the dense stellar wind and high dynamic
pressure. Using the MHD model of Garraffo et al. 2016 for the variation of the
magnetosphere radius during the orbit, we estimate that the observed radio flux
can vary nearly by an order of magnitude over the 11.2 day period of Proxima b.
The detailed amplitude variation depends on the stellar wind, orbital, and
planetary magnetic field parameters. We discuss observing strategies for
proposed future space-based observatories to reach frequencies below the
ionospheric cut off ($\sim 10$ MHz) as would be required to detect the signal
we investigate.
[32]
oai:arXiv.org:1706.03806 [pdf] - 1584582
Unveiling the Role of the Magnetic Field at the Smallest Scales of Star
Formation
Hull, Charles L. H.;
Mocz, Philip;
Burkhart, Blakesley;
Goodman, Alyssa A.;
Girart, Josep M.;
Cortés, Paulo C.;
Hernquist, Lars;
Springel, Volker;
Li, Zhi-Yun;
Lai, Shih-Ping
Submitted: 2017-06-12
We report ALMA observations of polarized dust emission from the protostellar
source Ser-emb 8 at a linear resolution of 140 au. Assuming models of
dust-grain alignment hold, the observed polarization pattern gives a projected
view of the magnetic field structure in this source. Contrary to expectations
based on models of strongly magnetized star formation, the magnetic field in
Ser-emb 8 does not exhibit an hourglass morphology. Combining the new ALMA data
with previous observational studies, we can connect magnetic field structure
from protostellar core (~80,000 au) to disk (~100 au) scales. We compare our
observations with four magnetohydrodynamic gravo-turbulence simulations made
with the AREPO code that have initial conditions ranging from super-Alfv\'enic
(weakly magnetized) to sub-Alfv\'enic (strongly magnetized). These simulations
achieve the spatial dynamic range necessary to resolve the collapse of
protostars from the parsec scale of star-forming clouds down to the ~100 au
scale probed by ALMA. Only in the very strongly magnetized simulation do we see
both the preservation of the field direction from cloud to disk scales and an
hourglass-shaped field at < 1000 au scales. We conduct an analysis of the
relative orientation of the magnetic field and the density structure in both
the Ser-emb 8 ALMA observations and the synthetic observations of the four
AREPO simulations. We conclude that the Ser-emb 8 data are most similar to the
weakly magnetized simulations, which exhibit random alignment, in contrast to
the strongly magnetized simulation, where the magnetic field plays a role in
shaping the density structure in the source. In the weak-field case, it is
turbulence -- not the magnetic field -- that shapes the material that forms the
protostar, highlighting the dominant role that turbulence can play across many
orders of magnitude in spatial scale.
[33]
oai:arXiv.org:1703.08549 [pdf] - 1582119
The HI-to-H2 Transition in a Turbulent Medium
Submitted: 2017-03-24, last modified: 2017-06-07
We study the effect of density fluctuations induced by turbulence on the
HI/H$_2$ structure in photodissociation regions (PDRs) both analytically and
numerically. We perform magnetohydrodynamic numerical simulations for both
subsonic and supersonic turbulent gas, and chemical HI/H$_2$ balance
calculations. We derive atomic-to-molecular density profiles and the HI column
density probability density function (PDF) assuming chemical equilibrium. We
find that while the HI/H$_2$ density profiles are strongly perturbed in
turbulent gas, the mean HI column density is well approximated by the
uniform-density analytic formula of Sternberg et al. (2014). The PDF width
depends on (a) the radiation intensity to mean density ratio, (b) the sonic
Mach number and (c) the turbulence decorrelation scale, or driving scale. We
derive an analytic model for the HI PDF and demonstrate how our model, combined
with 21 cm observations, can be used to constrain the Mach number and driving
scale of turbulent gas. As an example, we apply our model to observations of HI
in the Perseus molecular cloud. We show that a narrow observed HI PDF may imply
small scale decorrelation, pointing to the potential importance of
subcloud-scale turbulence driving.
[34]
oai:arXiv.org:1702.06133 [pdf] - 1554042
Moving mesh simulations of star forming cores in
magneto-gravo-turbulence
Submitted: 2017-02-20
Star formation in our Galaxy occurs in molecular clouds that are
self-gravitating, highly turbulent, and magnetized. We study the conditions
under which cloud cores inherit large-scale magnetic field morphologies and how
the field is governed by cloud turbulence. We present four moving-mesh
simulations of supersonic, turbulent, isothermal, self-gravitating gas with a
range of magnetic mean-field strengths characterized by the Alfv\'enic Mach
number $\mathcal{M}_{{\rm A}, 0}$, resolving pre-stellar core formation from
parsec to a few AU scales. In our simulations with the turbulent kinetic energy
density dominating over magnetic pressure ($\mathcal{M}_{{\rm A}, 0}>1$), we
find that the collapse is approximately isotropic with $B\propto\rho^{2/3}$,
core properties are similar regardless of initial mean-field strength, and the
field direction on $100$ AU scales is uncorrelated with the mean field.
However, in the case of a dominant large-scale magnetic field
($\mathcal{M}_{{\rm A}, 0}=0.35$), the collapse is anisotropic with
$B\propto\rho^{1/2}$. This transition at $\mathcal{M}_{{\rm A}, 0}\sim1$ is not
expected to be sharp, but clearly signifies two different paths for magnetic
field evolution in star formation. Based on observations of different star
forming regions, we conclude that star formation in the interstellar medium may
occur in both regimes. Magnetic field correlation with the mean-field extends
to smaller scales as $\mathcal{M}_{{\rm A}, 0}$ decreases, making future ALMA
observations useful for constraining $\mathcal{M}_{{\rm A}, 0}$ of the
interstellar medium.
[35]
oai:arXiv.org:1608.03293 [pdf] - 1531243
The Effect Of AGN Heating On The Low-Redshift Ly{\alpha} Forest
Submitted: 2016-08-10, last modified: 2017-02-07
We investigate the effects of AGN heating and the ultraviolet background on
the low-redshift Lyman-$\alpha$ forest column density distribution (CDD) using
the Illustris simulation. We show that Illustris reproduces observations at $z
=0.1$ in the column density range $10^{12.5} - 10^{13.5}$cm$^{-2}$, relevant
for the "photon underproduction crisis." We attribute this to the inclusion of
AGN feedback, which changes the gas distribution so as to mimic the effect of
extra photons, as well as the use of the Faucher-Gigu\`ere ultraviolet
background, which is more ionizing at $z=0.1$ than the Haardt & Madau
background previously considered. We show that the difference between
simulations run with smoothed particle hydrodynamics and simulations using a
moving mesh is small in this column density range but can be more significant
at larger column densities. We further consider the effect of supernova
feedback, Voigt profile fitting and finite resolution, all of which we show to
have little influence on the CDD. Finally, we identify a discrepancy between
our simulations and observations at column densities $10^{14} -
10^{16}$cm$^{-2}$, where Illustris produces too few absorbers, which suggests
the AGN feedback model should be further refined. Since the "photon
underproduction crisis" primarily affects lower column density systems, we
conclude that AGN feedback and standard ionizing background models can resolve
the crisis.
[36]
oai:arXiv.org:1608.05284 [pdf] - 1542706
The interaction of relativistic spacecrafts with the interstellar medium
Submitted: 2016-08-18, last modified: 2016-12-27
The Breakthrough Starshot initiative aims to launch a gram-scale spacecraft
to a speed of $v\sim 0.2$c, capable of reaching the nearest star system,
$\alpha$ Centauri, in about 20 years. However, a critical challenge for the
initiative is the damage to the spacecraft by interstellar gas and dust during
the journey. In this paper, we quantify the interaction of a relativistic
spacecraft with gas and dust in the interstellar medium. For gas bombardment,
we find that damage by track formation due to heavy elements is an important
effect. We find that gas bombardment can potentially damage the surface of the
spacecraft to a depth of $\sim 0.1$ mm for quartz material after traversing a
gas column of $N_{\rm H}\sim 2\times 10^{18}\rm cm^{-2}$ along the path to
$\alpha$ Centauri, whereas the effect is much weaker for graphite material. The
effect of dust bombardment erodes the spacecraft surface and produces numerous
craters due to explosive evaporation of surface atoms. For a spacecraft speed
$v=0.2c$, we find that dust bombardment can erode a surface layer of $\sim 0.5$
mm thickness after the spacecraft has swept a column density of $N_{\rm H}\sim
3\times 10^{17}\rm cm^{-2}$, assuming the standard gas-to-dust ratio of the
interstellar medium. Dust bombardment also damages the spacecraft surface by
modifying the material structure through melting. We calculate the equilibrium
surface temperature due to collisional heating by gas atoms as well as the
temperature profile as a function of depth into the spacecraft. Our
quantitative results suggest methods for damage control, and we highlight
possibilities for shielding strategies and protection of the spacecraft.
[37]
oai:arXiv.org:1612.05672 [pdf] - 1533544
Probes of turbulent driving mechanisms in molecular clouds from
fluctuations in synchrotron intensity
Submitted: 2016-12-16
Previous studies have shown that star formation depends on the driving of
molecular cloud turbulence, and differences in the driving can produce an order
of magnitude difference in the star formation rate. The turbulent driving is
characterised by the parameter $\zeta$, with $\zeta=0$ for compressive,
curl-free driving (e.g. accretion or supernova explosions), and $\zeta=1$ for
solenoidal, divergence-free driving (e.g. Galactic shear). Here we develop a
new method to measure $\zeta$ from observations of synchrotron emission from
molecular clouds. We calculate statistics of mock synchrotron intensity images
produced from magnetohydrodynamic simulations of molecular clouds, in which the
driving was controlled to produce different values of $\zeta$. We find that the
mean and standard deviation of the log-normalised synchrotron intensity are
sensitive to $\zeta$, for values of $\zeta$ between $0$ (curl-free driving) and
$0.5$ (naturally-mixed driving). We quantify the dependence of zeta on the
direction of the magnetic field relative to the line of sight. We provide
best-fit formulae for $\zeta$ in terms of the log-normalised mean and standard
deviation of synchrotron intensity, with which $\zeta$ can be determined for
molecular clouds that have similar Alfv\'enic Mach number to our simulations.
These formulae are independent of the sonic Mach number. Signal-to-noise ratios
larger than $5$, and angular resolutions smaller than $5\%$ of the cloud
diameter, are required to apply these formulae. Although there are no firm
detections of synchrotron emission from molecular clouds, by combining Green
Bank Telescope and Very Large Array observations it should be possible to
detect synchrotron emission from molecular clouds, thereby constraining the
value of $\zeta$.
[38]
oai:arXiv.org:1609.04817 [pdf] - 1490882
The HI Probability Distribution Function and the Atomic-to-Molecular
Transition in Molecular Clouds
Submitted: 2016-09-15
We characterize the column density probability distributions functions (PDFs)
of the atomic hydrogen gas, HI, associated with seven Galactic molecular clouds
(MCs). We use 21 cm observations from the Leiden/Argentine/Bonn Galactic HI
Survey to derive column density maps and PDFs. We find that the peaks of the HI
PDFs occur at column densities ranging from ~1-2$\times 10^{21}$ cm$^2$
(equivalently, ~0.5-1 mag). The PDFs are uniformly narrow, with a mean
dispersion of $\sigma_{HI}\approx 10^{20}$ cm$^2$ (~0.1 mag). We also
investigate the HI-to-H$_2$ transition towards the cloud complexes and estimate
HI surface densities ranging from 7-16 $M_\odot$ pc$^{-2}$ at the transition.
We propose that the HI PDF is a fitting tool for identifying the HI-to-H$_2$
transition column in Galactic MCs.
[39]
oai:arXiv.org:1609.04409 [pdf] - 1531597
The Razor's Edge of Collapse: The Transition Point from Lognormal to
Powerlaw in Molecular Cloud PDFs
Submitted: 2016-09-14
We derive an analytic expression for the transitional column density value
($s_t$) between the lognormal and power-law form of the probability
distribution function (PDF) in star-forming molecular clouds. Our expression
for $s_t$ depends on the mean column density, the variance of the lognormal
portion of the PDF, and the slope of the power-law portion of the PDF. We show
that $s_t$ can be related to physical quantities such as the sonic Mach number
of the flow and the power-law index for a self-gravitating isothermal sphere.
This implies that the transition point between the lognormal and power-law
density/column density PDF represents the critical density where turbulent and
thermal pressure balance, the so-called "post-shock density." We test our
analytic prediction for the transition column density using dust PDF
observations reported in the literature as well as numerical MHD simulations of
self-gravitating supersonic turbulence with the Enzo code. We find excellent
agreement between the analytic $s_t$ and the measured values from the numerical
simulations and observations (to within 1.5 A$_V$). We discuss the utility of
our expression for determining the properties of the PDF from unresolved low
density material in dust observations, for estimating the post-shock density,
and for determining the HI-H$_2$ transition in clouds.
[40]
oai:arXiv.org:1604.01767 [pdf] - 1422288
Predicted Sizes of Pressure-Supported HI Clouds in the Outskirts of the
Virgo Cluster
Submitted: 2016-04-06, last modified: 2016-05-13
Using data from the ALFALFA Arecibo HI survey of galaxies and the Virgo
cluster X-ray pressure profiles from XMM-Newton, we investigate the possibility
that starless dark HI clumps, also known as "dark galaxies", are supported by
external pressure in the surrounding intercluster medium. We find that the
starless HI clump masses, velocity dispersions and positions allow these clumps
to be in pressure equilibrium with the X-ray gas near the virial radius of the
Virgo cluster. We predict the sizes of these clumps to range from 1-10 kpc, in
agreement with the range of sizes found for spatially resolved HI starless
clumps outside of Virgo. Based on the predicted HI surface density of the Virgo
sources, as well as a sample of other similar resolved ALFALFA HI dark clumps
with follow up optical/radio observations, we predict that most of the HI dark
clumps are on the cusp of forming stars. These HI sources therefore mark the
transition between starless HI clouds and dwarf galaxies with stars.
[41]
oai:arXiv.org:1603.02751 [pdf] - 1400499
Radio Synchrotron Fluctuation Statistics as a Probe of Magnetized
Interstellar Turbulence
Submitted: 2016-03-08
We investigate how observations of synchrotron intensity fluctuations can be
used to probe the sonic and Alfv\'enic Mach numbers of interstellar turbulence,
based on mock observations performed on simulations of magnetohydrodynamic
turbulence. We find that the structure function slope, and a diagnostic of
anisotropy that we call the integrated quadrupole ratio modulus, both depend on
the Alfv\'enic Mach number. However, these statistics also depend on the
orientation of the mean magnetic field in the synchrotron emitting region
relative to our line of sight, and this creates a degeneracy that cannot be
broken by observations of synchrotron intensity alone. We conclude that the
polarization of synchrotron emission could be analyzed to break this
degeneracy, and suggest that this will be possible with the Square Kilometre
Array.
[42]
oai:arXiv.org:1512.03439 [pdf] - 1378733
Is Turbulence in the Interstellar Medium Driven by Feedback or Gravity?
An Observational Test
Submitted: 2015-12-10, last modified: 2016-02-22
Galaxies' interstellar media (ISM) are observed to be
supersonically-turbulent, but the ultimate power source that drives turbulent
motion remains uncertain. The two dominant models are that the turbulence is
driven by star formation feedback and/or that it is produced by gravitational
instability in the gas. Here we show that, while both models predict that the
galaxies' ISM velocity dispersions will be positively correlated with their
star formation rates, the forms of the correlation predicted by these two
models are subtly but measurably different. A feedback-driven origin for the
turbulence predicts a velocity dispersion that rises more sharply with star
formation rate, and that does not depend on the gas fraction (i.e. $\dot{M}_*
\propto \sigma^2$), while a gravity-driven model yields a shallower rise and a
strong dependence on gas fraction (i.e. $\dot{M}_* \propto f_g^2 \sigma$). We
compare the models to a collection of data on local and high-redshift galaxies
culled from the literature, and show that the correlation expected for
gravity-driven turbulence is a better match to the observations than a
feedback-driven model. This suggests that gravity is the ultimate source of ISM
turbulence, at least in the rapidly-star-forming, high velocity dispersion
galaxies for which our test is most effective. We conclude by discussing the
limitations of the present data set, and the prospects for future measurements
to enable a more definitive test of the two models.
[43]
oai:arXiv.org:1511.03660 [pdf] - 1457131
The Phase Coherence of Interstellar Density Fluctuations
Submitted: 2015-11-11
Studies of MHD turbulence often investigate the Fourier power spectrum to
provide information on the nature of the turbulence cascade. However, the
Fourier power spectrum only contains the Fourier amplitudes and rejects all
information regarding the Fourier phases. Here we investigate the utility of
two statistical diagnostics for recovering information on Fourier phases in ISM
density data: the averaged amplitudes of the bispectrum and the phase coherence
index (PCI), a new phase technique for the ISM. We create 3D density and 2D
column density maps using a set of simulations of isothermal ideal MHD
turbulence with a wide range of sonic and Alfv\'enic Mach numbers. We find that
the bispectrum averaged along different angles with respect to either the $k_1$
or $k_2$ axis is primarily sensitive to the sonic Mach number while averaging
the bispectral amplitudes over different annuli is sensitive to both the sonic
and Alfv\'enic Mach numbers. The PCI of density suggests that the most
correlated phases occur in supersonic sub-Alfv\'enic turbulence and also near
the numerical dissipation regime. This suggests that non-linear interactions
with correlated phases are strongest in shock dominated regions, in agreement
with findings from the solar wind. Additionally, our results are particularly
encouraging as they suggests the phase information contained in the bispectrum
and PCI can be used to find parameters of turbulence in column density maps.
[44]
oai:arXiv.org:1511.03712 [pdf] - 1362621
Principal Component Analysis studies of turbulence in optically thick
gas
Submitted: 2015-11-11
In this work we investigate the Principal Component Analysis (PCA)
sensitivity to the velocity power spectrum in high opacity regimes of the
interstellar medium (ISM). For our analysis we use synthetic
Position-Position-Velocity (PPV) cubes of fractional Brownian motion (fBm) and
magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) simulations, post processed to include radiative
transfer effects from CO. We find that PCA analysis is very different from the
tools based on the traditional power spectrum of PPV data cubes. Our major
finding is that PCA is also sensitive to the phase information of PPV cubes and
this allows PCA to detect the changes of the underlying velocity and density
spectra at high opacities, where the spectral analysis of the maps provides the
universal -3 spectrum in accordance with the predictions of Lazarian \&
Pogosyan (2004) theory. This makes PCA potentially a valuable tool for studies
of turbulence at high opacities provided that the proper gauging of the PCA
index is made. The later, however, we found to be not easy, as the PCA results
change in an irregular way for data with high sonic Mach numbers. This is in
contrast to synthetic Brownian noise data used for velocity and density fields
that show monotonic PCA behavior. We attribute this difference to the PCA's
sensitivity to Fourier phase information.
[45]
oai:arXiv.org:1509.02889 [pdf] - 1288524
The Lognormal Probability Distribution Function of the Perseus Molecular
Cloud: A Comparison of HI and Dust
Submitted: 2015-09-09
The shape of the probability distribution function (PDF) of molecular clouds
is an important ingredient for modern theories of star formation and
turbulence. Recently, several studies have pointed out observational
difficulties with constraining the low column density (i.e. Av <1) PDF using
dust tracers. In order to constrain the shape and properties of the low column
density probability distribution function, we investigate the PDF of multiphase
atomic gas in the Perseus molecular cloud using opacity-corrected GALFA-HI data
and compare the PDF shape and properties to the total gas PDF and the N(H2)
PDF. We find that the shape of the PDF in the atomic medium of Perseus is well
described by a lognormal distribution, and not by a power-law or bimodal
distribution. The peak of the atomic gas PDF in and around Perseus lies at the
HI-H2 transition column density for this cloud, past which the N(H2) PDF takes
on a powerlaw form. We find that the PDF of the atomic gas is narrow and at
column densities larger than the HI-H2 transition the HI rapidly depletes,
suggesting that the HI PDF may be used to find the HI-H2 transition column
density. We also calculate the sonic Mach number of the atomic gas by using HI
absorption line data, which yields a median value of Ms=4.0 for the CNM, while
the HI emission PDF, which traces both the WNM and CNM, has a width more
consistent with transonic turbulence.
[46]
oai:arXiv.org:1506.03448 [pdf] - 1273150
The Turbulence Velocity Power Spectrum of Neutral Hydrogen in the Small
Magellanic Cloud
Submitted: 2015-06-10
We present the results of the Velocity Coordinate Spectrum (VCS) technique to
calculate the velocity power spectrum of turbulence in the Small Magellanic
Cloud (SMC) in 21cm emission. We have obtained a velocity spectral index of
-3.85 and an injection scale of 2.3 kpc. The spectral index is steeper than the
Kolmogorov index which is expected for shock-dominated turbulence which is in
agreement with past works on the SMC gas dynamics. The injection scale of 2.3
kpc suggests that tidal interactions with the Large Magellanic Cloud are the
dominate driver of turbulence in this dwarf galaxy. This implies turbulence
maybe driven by multiple mechanisms in galaxies in addition to supernova
injection and that galaxy-galaxy interactions may play an important role.
[47]
oai:arXiv.org:1208.4103 [pdf] - 1150783
The GALFA-HI Compact Cloud Catalog
Saul, Destry R.;
Peek, J. E. G.;
Grcevich, J.;
Putman, M. E.;
Douglas, K. A.;
Korpela, E. J.;
Stanimirovic, S.;
Heiles, C.;
Gibson, S. J.;
Lee, M.;
Begum, A.;
Brown, A. R. H.;
Burkhart, B.;
Hamden, E. T.;
Pingel, N. M.;
Tonnesen, S.
Submitted: 2012-08-20, last modified: 2015-05-21
We present a catalog of 1964 isolated, compact neutral hydrogen clouds from
the Galactic Arecibo L-Band Feed Array Survey Data Release One (GALFA-HI DR1).
The clouds were identified by a custom machine-vision algorithm utilizing
Difference of Gaussian kernels to search for clouds smaller than 20'. The
clouds have velocities typically between |VLSR| = 20-400 km/s, linewidths of
2.5-35 km/s, and column densities ranging from 1 - 35 x 10^18 cm^-2. The
distances to the clouds in this catalog may cover several orders of magnitude,
so the masses may range from less than a Solar mass for clouds within the
Galactic disc, to greater than 10^4 Solar Masses for HVCs at the tip of the
Magellanic Stream. To search for trends, we separate the catalog into five
populations based on position, velocity, and linewidth: high velocity clouds
(HVCs); galaxy candidates; cold low velocity clouds (LVCs); warm, low
positive-velocity clouds in the third Galactic Quadrant; and the remaining warm
LVCs. The observed HVCs are found to be associated with previously-identified
HVC complexes. We do not observe a large population of isolated clouds at high
velocities as some models predict. We see evidence for distinct histories at
low velocities in detecting populations of clouds corotating with the Galactic
disc and a set of clouds that is not corotating.
[48]
oai:arXiv.org:1505.03855 [pdf] - 1258911
Observational Diagnostics of Self-Gravitating MHD Turbulence in Giant
Molecular Clouds
Submitted: 2015-05-14
We study the observable signatures of self-gravitating MHD turbulence by
applying the probability density functions (PDFs) and the spatial density power
spectrum to synthetic column density maps. We find that there exists three
characterizable stages of the evolution of the collapsing cloud which we term
"early," "intermediate," and "advanced." At early times, i.e. $t<0.15t_{ff}$,
the column density has a power spectral slope similar to nongravitating
supersonic turbulence and a lognormal distribution. At an intermediate stage,
i.e. $0.15t_{ff}< t \leq 0.35t_{ff}$, there exists signatures of the prestellar
cores in the shallower PDF and power spectrum power law slopes. The column
density PDF power law tails at these times have line of sight averaged slopes
ranging from -2.5 to -1.5 with shallower values belonging to simulations with
lower magnetic field strength. The density power spectrum slope becomes shallow
and can be characterized by $P(k)=A_1k^{\beta_2}e^{-k/k_c}$, where $A_1$
describes the amplitude, $k^{\beta_2}$ describes the classical power law
behavior and the scale $k_c$ characterizes the turn over from turbulence
dominated to self-gravity dominated. At advanced stages of collapse, i.e.
$\approx t>0.35t_{ff}$, the power spectral slope is positive valued, and a
dramatic increase is observed in the PDF moments and the Tsallis incremental
PDF parameters, which gives rise to deviations between PDF-sonic Mach number
relations. Finally, we show that the imprint of gravity on the density power
spectrum can be replicated in non-gravitating turbulence by introducing a
delta-function with amplitude equivalent to the maximum valued point in a given
self-gravitating map. We find that the turbulence power spectrum restored
through spatial filtering of the high density material.
[49]
oai:arXiv.org:1412.3452 [pdf] - 1095544
Alfvenic Turbulence Beyond the Ambipolar Diffusion Scale
Submitted: 2014-12-10
We investigate the nature of the Alfv\'enic turbulence cascade in two fluid
MHD simulations in order to determine if turbulence is damped once the ion and
neutral species become decoupled at a critical scale called the ambipolar
diffusion scale (L$_{AD}$). Using mode decomposition to separate the three
classical MHD modes, we study the second order structure functions of the
Alfv\'en mode velocity field of both neutrals and ions in the reference frame
of the local magnetic field. On scales greater than L$_{AD}$ we confirm that
two fluid turbulence strongly resembles single fluid MHD turbulence. Our
simulations show that the behavior of two fluid turbulence becomes more complex
on scales less than L$_{AD}$. We find that Alfvenic turbulence can exist past
L$_{AD}$ when the turbulence is globally super-Alfv\'enic, with the ions and
neutrals forming separate cascades once decoupling has taken place. When
turbulence is globally sub-Alfvenic and hence strongly anisotropic with a large
separation between the parallel and perpendicular decoupling scales, turbulence
is damped at L$_{AD}$. We also find that the power spectrum of the kinetic
energy in the damped regime is consistent with a $k^{-4}$ scaling (in agreement
with the predictions of Lazarian, Vishniac & Cho 2004).
[50]
oai:arXiv.org:1408.4858 [pdf] - 1216439
Measuring the Alfvenic Nature of the Interstellar Medium: Velocity
Anisotropy Revisited
Submitted: 2014-08-20
The dynamics of the interstellar medium (ISM) are strongly affected by
turbulence, which shows increased anisotropy in the presence of a magnetic
field. We expand upon the Esquivel & Lazarian method to estimate the Alfven
Mach number using the structure function anisotropy in velocity centroid data
from position-position-velocity maps. We utilize 3D magnetohydrodynamic (MHD)
simulations of fully developed turbulence, with a large range of sonic and
Alfvenic Mach numbers, to produce synthetic observations of velocity centroids
with observational characteristics such as thermal broadening, cloud
boundaries, noise, and radiative transfer effects of carbon monoxide. In
addition, we investigate how the resulting anisotropy-Alfven Mach number
dependency found in Esquivel & Lazarian (2011) might change when taking the
second moment of the position-position-velocity cube or when using different
expressions to calculate the velocity centroids. We find that the degree of
anisotropy is related primarily to the magnetic field strength (i.e. Alfven
Mach number) and the line-of-sight orientation, with a secondary effect on
sonic Mach number. If the line-of-sight is parallel to up to ~45 deg off of the
mean field direction, the velocity centroid anisotropy is not prominent enough
to distinguish different Alfvenic regimes. The observed anisotropy is not
strongly affected by including radiative transfer, although future studies
should include additional tests for opacity effects. These results open up the
possibility of studying the magnetic nature of the ISM using statistical
methods in addition to existing observational techniques.
[51]
oai:arXiv.org:1404.6077 [pdf] - 815866
Galactic interstellar turbulence in the southern sky seen through
spatial gradients of the polarization vector
Iacobelli, M.;
Burkhart, B.;
Haverkorn, M.;
Lazarian, A.;
Carretti, E.;
Staveley-Smith, L.;
Gaensler, B. M.;
Bernardi, G.;
Kesteven, M. J.;
Poppi, S.
Submitted: 2014-04-24
Radio synchrotron polarization maps of the Galaxy can be used to infer the
properties of interstellar turbulence in the diffuse warm ionized medium (WIM).
In this paper, we investigate the spatial gradient of linearly polarized
synchrotron emission ($|\nabla\textbf{P}|/|\textbf{P}|$) as a tracer of
turbulence, the relationship of the gradient to the sonic Mach number of the
WIM, and changes in morphology of the gradient as a function of Galactic
position in the southern sky. We use data from the S-band Polarization All Sky
Survey (S-PASS) to image the spatial gradient of the linearly polarized
synchrotron emission ($|\nabla \textbf{P}|/|\textbf{P}|$) of the entire
southern sky at $2.3$~GHz. The spatial gradient of linear polarization reveals
rapid changes of the density and magnetic fluctuations in the WIM due to
magnetic turbulence as a function of Galactic position; we make comparisons of
these data to ideal MHD numerical simulations. In order to constrain the sonic
Mach number ($M_{s}$), we apply a high order moments analysis to the
observations and to the simulated diffuse, isothermal ISM with ideal
magneto-hydrodynamic turbulence. We find that polarization gradient maps reveal
elongated structures, which we associate with turbulence in the ISM. Our
analysis corroborates the view of a turbulent WIM in a transonic regime
$M_{s}\lesssim 2$. Filamentary structures with typical widths down to the
angular resolution are seen and the observed morphologies match closely with
numerical simulations and in some cases H$\alpha$ contours. The $|\nabla
\textbf{P}|/|\textbf{P}|$ intensity is found to be approximately log-normal
distributed. No systematic variations of the sonic Mach number are observed as
a function of Galactic coordinates, which is consistent with turbulence in the
WIM inferred by the analysis of H$\alpha$ data.
[52]
oai:arXiv.org:1402.6702 [pdf] - 841565
Opacity Broadening of $^{13}$CO Linewidths and its Effect on the
Variance-Sonic Mach Number Relation
Submitted: 2014-02-26, last modified: 2014-03-03
We study how the estimation of the sonic Mach number ($M_s$) from $^{13}$CO
linewidths relates to the actual 3D sonic Mach number. For this purpose we
analyze MHD simulations which include post-processing to take radiative
transfer effects into account. As expected, we find very good agreement between
the linewidth estimated sonic Mach number and the actual sonic Mach number of
the simulations for optically thin tracers. However, we find that opacity
broadening causes $M_s$ to be overestimated by a factor of ~ 1.16 - 1.3 when
calculated from optically thick $^{13}$CO lines. We also find that there is a
dependency on the magnetic field: super-Alfv\'enic turbulence shows increased
line broadening as compared with sub-Alfv\'enic turbulence for all values of
optical depth for supersonic turbulence. Our results have implications for the
observationally derived sonic Mach number--density standard deviation
($\sigma_{\rho/<\rho>}$) relationship, $\sigma^2_{\rho/<\rho>}=b^2M_s^2$, and
the related column density standard deviation ($\sigma_{N/<N>}$) sonic Mach
number relationship. In particular, we find that the parameter b, as an
indicator of solenoidal vs. compressive driving, will be underestimated as a
result of opacity broadening. We compare the $\sigma_{N/<N>}-M_s$ relation
derived from synthetic dust extinction maps and $^{13}$CO linewidths with
recent observational studies and find that solenoidally driven MHD turbulence
simulations have values of $\sigma_{N/<N>}$ which are lower than real molecular
clouds. This may be due to the influence of self-gravity which should be
included in simulations of molecular cloud dynamics.
[53]
oai:arXiv.org:1310.7244 [pdf] - 1180272
Characterizing the Turbulent Properties of the Starless Molecular Cloud
MBM16
Pingel, Nickolas M.;
Stanimirovic, Snezana;
Peek, J. E. G.;
Lee, Min-Young;
Lazarian, Alex;
Burkhart, Blakesley;
Begum, Ayesha;
Douglas, Kevin A.;
Heiles, Carl;
Gibson, Steven J.;
Grcevich, Jana;
Korpela, Eric J.;
Lawrence, Allen;
Murray, Claire;
Putman, Mary E.;
Saul, Destry
Submitted: 2013-10-27
We investigate turbulent properties of the non-star-forming, translucent
molecular cloud, MBM16 by applying the statistical technique of a
two-dimensional spatial power spectrum (SPS) on the neutral hydrogen (HI)
observations obtained by the Galactic Arecibo L-Band Feed Array HI (GALFA-HI)
survey. The SPS, calculated over the range of spatial scales from 0.1 to 17 pc,
is well represented with a single power-law function, with a slope ranging from
-3.3 to -3.7 and being consistent over the velocity range of MBM16 for a fixed
velocity channel thickness. However, the slope varies significantly with the
velocity slice thickness, suggesting that both velocity and density contribute
to HI intensity fluctuations. By using this variation we estimate the slope of
3D density fluctuations in MBM16 to be -3.7\pm0.2. This is significantly
steeper than what has been found for HI in the Milky Way plane, the Small
Magellanic Cloud, or the Magellanic Bridge, suggesting that interstellar
turbulence in MBM16 is driven on scales >17 pc and that the lack of stellar
feedback could be responsible for the steep power spectrum.
[54]
oai:arXiv.org:1307.3527 [pdf] - 1172696
Observational Diagnostics for Two-Fluid Turbulence in Molecular Clouds
As Suggested by Simulations
Submitted: 2013-07-12, last modified: 2013-07-18
We present high resolution simulations of two-fluid (ion-neutral) MHD
turbulence with resolutions as large as 512^3. The simulations are supersonic
and mildly sub-Alfvenic, in keeping with the conditions present in molecular
clouds. Such turbulence is thought to influence star formation processes in
molecular clouds because typical cores form on length scales that are
comparable to the dissipation scales of this turbulence in the ions. The
simulations are motivated by the fact that recent studies of isophotologue
lines in molecular clouds have found significant differences in the
linewidth-size relationship for neutral and ion species. The goals of this
paper are to explain those observations using simulations and analytic theory,
present a new set of density-based diagnostics by drawing on similar
diagnostics that have been obtained by studying single-fluid turbulence, and
show that our two-fluid simulations play a vital role in reconciling
alternative models of star formation. The velocity-dependent diagnostics
display a complementarity with the density-dependent diagnostics. We find that
the linewidth-size relationships show a prominent difference between ions and
neutrals when the line of sight is orthogonal to the mean field. This is
because the MHD waves in the ions differ from hydrodynamic waves in the
neutrals. We also find that the density probability distribution functions
(PDFs) show prominent differences between the ions and neutrals when the line
of sight is parallel to the mean field. This is because the velocity
fluctuations in the ions tend to produce column density fluctuations along
field lines. When the magnetic field makes an angle to the line of sight, both
observable differences should be visible. These diagnostics should be easy for
observers to test. This analysis assumes optically thin lines and a mean
magnetic field that is uniform in direction within a cloud.
[55]
oai:arXiv.org:1305.3619 [pdf] - 1166670
The Turbulence Power Spectrum in Optically Thick Interstellar Clouds
Submitted: 2013-05-15
The Fourier power spectrum is one of the most widely used statistical tools
to analyze the nature of magnetohydrodynamic turbulence in the interstellar
medium. Lazarian & Pogosyan (2004) predicted that the spectral slope should
saturate to -3 for an optically thick medium and many observations exist in
support of their prediction. However, there have not been any numerical studies
to-date testing these results. We analyze the spatial power spectrum of MHD
simulations with a wide range of sonic and Alfv\'enic Mach numbers, which
include radiative transfer effects of the $^{13}$CO transition. We confirm
numerically the predictions of Lazarian & Pogosyan (2004) that the spectral
slope of line intensity maps of an optically thick medium saturates to -3.
Furthermore, for very optically thin supersonic CO gas, where the density or CO
abundance values are too low to excite emission in all but the densest shock
compressed gas, we find that the spectral slope is shallower than expected from
the column density. Finally, we find that mixed optically thin/thick CO gas,
which has average optical depths on order of unity, shows mixed behavior: for
super-Alfv\'enic turbulence, the integrated intensity power spectral slopes
generally follow the same trend with sonic Mach number as the true column
density power spectrum slopes. However, for sub-Alfv\'enic turbulence the
spectral slopes are steeper with values near -3 which are similar to the very
optically thick regime.
[56]
oai:arXiv.org:1206.4703 [pdf] - 1124270
Hierarchical Structure of Magnetohydrodynamic Turbulence In
Position-Position-Velocity Space
Submitted: 2012-06-20, last modified: 2013-04-10
Magnetohydrodynamic turbulence is able to create hierarchical structures in
the interstellar medium that are correlated on a wide range of scales via the
energy cascade. We use hierarchical tree diagrams known as dendrograms to
characterize structures in synthetic Position-Position-Velocity (PPV) emission
cubes of optically thin isothermal magnetohydrodynamic turbulence. We show that
the structures and degree of hierarchy observed in PPV space are related to the
physics of the gas, i.e. self-gravity and the global sonic and Alfvenic Mach
number. Simulations with higher Alfvenic Mach number, self-gravity and
supersonic flows display enhanced hierarchical structure. We observed a strong
sonic and Alfvenic dependency when we apply the the statistical moments (i.e.
mean, variance, skewness, kurtosis) to the dendrogram distribution. Larger
magnetic field and sonic Mach number correspond to larger values of the
moments. Application of the dendrogram to 3D density cubes, also known as
Position-Position-Position cubes (PPP), reveals that the dominant emission
contours in PPP and PPV are related for supersonic gas but not for subsonic. We
also explore the effects of smoothing, thermal broadening and velocity
resolution on the dendrograms in order to make our study more applicable to
observational data. These results all point to hierarchical tree diagrams as
being a promising additional tool for studying ISM turbulence and star forming
regions in the direction of obtaining information on the degree of
self-gravity, the Mach numbers and the complicated relationship between PPV and
PPP.
[57]
oai:arXiv.org:1304.3131 [pdf] - 1165888
The Effects of Radiative Transfer on the PDFs of Molecular MHD
Turbulence
Submitted: 2013-04-10
We study the effects of radiative transfer on the Probability Distribution
Functions (PDFs) of simulations of magnetohydrodynamic turbulence in the widely
studied $^{13}$CO 2-1 transition. We find that the integrated intensity maps
generally follow a log-normal distribution, with the cases that have $\tau
\approx 1$ best matching the PDF of the column density. We fit a 2D
variance-sonic Mach number relationship to our logarithmic PDFs of the form
$\sigma_{ln(\Sigma/\Sigma_0)}^2=A\times ln(1+b^2{\cal M}_s^2)$ and find that,
for parameter $b=1/3$, parameter $A$ depends on the radiative transfer
environment. We also explore the variance, skewness, and kurtosis of the linear
PDFs finding that higher moments reflect both higher sonic Mach number and
lower optical depth. Finally, we apply the Tsallis incremental PDF function and
find that the fit parameters depend on both Mach numbers, but also are
sensitive to the radiative transfer parameter space, with the $\tau \approx 1$
case best fitting the incremental PDF of the true column density. We conclude
that, for PDFs of low optical depth cases, part of the gas is always
sub-thermally excited so that the spread of the line intensities exceeds the
spread of the underlying column densities and hence the PDFs do not reflect the
true column density. Similarly, PDFs of optically thick cases are dominated by
the velocity dispersion and therefore do not represent the true column density
PDF. Thus, in the case of molecules like carbon monoxide, the dynamic range of
intensities, structures observed and consequently, the observable PDFs, are
less determined by turbulence and more-often determined by radiative transfer
effects.
[58]
oai:arXiv.org:1205.3792 [pdf] - 1123463
The Column Density Variance-Sonic Mach Number Relationship
Submitted: 2012-05-16, last modified: 2012-06-22
Although there are a wealth of column density tracers for both the molecular
and diffuse interstellar medium, there are very few observational studies
investigating the relationship between the density variance ($\sigma^2$) and
the sonic Mach number (${\cal M}_s$). This is in part due to the fact that the
$\sigma^2$-${\cal M}_s$ relationship is derived, via MHD simulations, for the
3D density variance only, which is not a direct observable. We investigate the
utility of a 2D column density $\sigma_{\Sigma/\Sigma_0}^2$-${\cal M}_s$
relationship using solenoidally driven isothermal MHD simulations and find that
the best fit follows closely the form of the 3D density
$\sigma_{\rho/\rho_0}^2$-${\cal M}_s$ trend but includes a scaling parameter
$A$ such that: $\sigma_{ln(\Sigma/\Sigma_0)}^2=A\times ln(1+b^2{\cal M}_s^2)$,
where $A=0.11$ and $b=1/3$. This relation is consistent with the observational
data reported for the Taurus and IC 5146 molecular clouds with $b=0.5$ and
$A=0.16$ and $b=0.5$ and $A=0.12$, respectively. These results open up the
possibility of using the 2D column density values of $\sigma^2$ for
investigations of the relation between the sonic Mach number and the PDF
variance in addition to existing PDF sonic Mach number relations.
[59]
oai:arXiv.org:1111.3544 [pdf] - 1091661
Properties of Interstellar Turbulence from Gradients of Linear Radio
Polarization Maps
Submitted: 2011-11-15
Faraday rotation of linearly polarized radio signals provides a very
sensitive probe of fluctuations in the interstellar magnetic field and ionized
gas density resulting from magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) turbulence. We used a set
of statistical tools to analyze images of the spatial gradient of linearly
polarized radio emission ($|\nabla \textbf{P}|$) from the ISM for both
observational data from a test image of the Southern Galactic Plane Survey
(SGPS) and isothermal simulations of MHD turbulence. We compared the
observational data with results of synthetic observations obtained with the
simulations of 3D turbulence. Visually, in both data sets, a complex network of
filamentary structures is seen. Our analysis shows that the filaments in the
gradient can be produced by shocks as well as random fluctuations
characterizing the non-differentiable field of MHD turbulence. The latter
dominates for subsonic turbulence, while the former dominates for supersonic
turbulence. In order to quantitatively characterize these differences we use
the topology tool known as a genus curve as well as the moments of the image
distribution. We find that higher values for the moments correspond to cases of
$|\nabla \textbf{P}|$ with larger Mach numbers, but the strength of the
dependency is connected to the telescope angular resolution. In regards to the
topology, the supersonic filaments observed in $|\nabla \textbf{P}|$ have a
positive genus shift, which indicates a "swisscheese" like topology, while the
subsonic cases show a negative genus, indicating a "clump" like topology. In
the case of the genus, the dependency on the telescope resolution is not as
strong. The SGPS test region data has a distribution and morphology that
matches subsonic to transsonic type turbulence, which independently confirms
what is now expected for the WIM.
[60]
oai:arXiv.org:1110.2896 [pdf] - 425295
Low-Mach-number turbulence in interstellar gas revealed by radio
polarization gradients
Gaensler, Bryan M.;
Haverkorn, Marijke;
Burkhart, Blakesley;
Newton-McGee, Katherine J.;
Ekers, Ronald D.;
Lazarian, Alex;
McClure-Griffiths, Naomi M.;
Robishaw, Timothy;
Dickey, John M.;
Green, Anne J.
Submitted: 2011-10-13
The interstellar medium of the Milky Way is multi-phase, magnetized and
turbulent. Turbulence in the interstellar medium produces a global cascade of
random gas motions, spanning scales ranging from 100 parsecs to 1000
kilometres. Fundamental parameters of interstellar turbulence such as the sonic
Mach number (the speed of sound) have been difficult to determine because
observations have lacked the sensitivity and resolution to directly image the
small-scale structure associated with turbulent motion. Observations of linear
polarization and Faraday rotation in radio emission from the Milky Way have
identified unusual polarized structures that often have no counterparts in the
total radiation intensity or at other wavelengths, and whose physical
significance has been unclear. Here we report that the gradient of the Stokes
vector (Q,U), where Q and U are parameters describing the polarization state of
radiation, provides an image of magnetized turbulence in diffuse ionized gas,
manifested as a complex filamentary web of discontinuities in gas density and
magnetic field. Through comparison with simulations, we demonstrate that
turbulence in the warm ionized medium has a relatively low sonic Mach number,
M_s <~ 2. The development of statistical tools for the analysis of polarization
gradients will allow accurate determinations of the Mach number, Reynolds
number and magnetic field strength in interstellar turbulence over a wide range
of conditions.
[61]
oai:arXiv.org:1105.0929 [pdf] - 353903
Statistical Tools of Interstellar Turbulence: Bridging the Gap Between
Numerics and Observations
Submitted: 2011-05-04
MHD Turbulence is a critical component of the current paradigms of star
formation, particle transport, magnetic reconnection and evolution of the ISM.
Progress on this difficult subject is made via numerical simulations and
observational studies. However, due to limitations of resolution, scale
discrepancies, and complexity of the observations, the best approach for
connecting numerics to observations is not always obvious. Here we advocate for
a approach that invokes statistical techniques to understand the underlying
physics of turbulent astrophysical systems. The wealth of numerical and
observational data calls for new statistical tools to be developed in order to
study turbulence in the interstellar medium. We briefly review some of the
recently developed statistics that focus on characterizing gas compressibility
and magnetization and their uses to interstellar studies.
[62]
oai:arXiv.org:1103.3299 [pdf] - 1052787
Interstellar Sonic and Alfv\'enic Mach Numbers and the Tsallis
Distribution
Submitted: 2011-03-16
In an effort to characterize the Mach numbers of ISM magnetohydrodynamic
(MHD) turbulence, we study the probability distribution functions (PDFs) of
patial increments of density, velocity, and magnetic field for fourteen ideal
isothermal MHD simulations at resolution 512^3. In particular, we fit the PDFs
using the Tsallis function and study the dependency of fit parameters on the
compressibility and magnetization of the gas. We find that the Tsallis function
fits PDFs of MHD turbulence well, with fit parameters showing sensitivities to
the sonic and Alfven Mach numbers. For 3D density, column density, and
position-position-velocity (PPV) data we find that the amplitude and width of
the PDFs shows a dependency on the sonic Mach number. We also find the width of
the PDF is sensitive to global Alfvenic Mach number especially in cases where
the sonic number is high. These dependencies are also found for mock
observational cases, where cloud-like boundary conditions, smoothing, and noise
are introduced. The ability of Tsallis statistics to characterize sonic and
Alfvenic Mach numbers of simulated ISM turbulence point to it being a useful
tool in the analysis of the observed ISM, especially when used simultaneously
with other statistical techniques.
[63]
oai:arXiv.org:1103.0771 [pdf] - 1052487
Statistical Tools of ISM turbulence
Submitted: 2011-03-03
MHD Turbulence is a critical component of the current paradigms of star
formation, particle transport, magnetic reconnection and evolution of the ISM,
to name just a few. Progress on this difficult subject is made via numerical
simulations and observational studies, however in order to connect these two,
statistical methods are required. This calls for new statistical tools to be
developed in order to study turbulence in the interstellar medium. Here we
briefly review some of the recently developed statistics that focus on
characterizing gas compressibility and magnetization and their uses to
interstellar studies.
[64]
oai:arXiv.org:0911.3652 [pdf] - 902475
Characterizing Magnetohydrodynamic Turbulence in the Small Magellanic
Cloud
Submitted: 2009-11-18
We investigate the nature and spatial variations of turbulence in the Small
Magellanic Cloud (SMC) by applying several statistical methods on the neutral
hydrogen (HI) column density image of the SMC and a database of isothermal
numerical simulations. By using the 3rd and 4th statistical moments we derive
the spatial distribution of the sonic Mach number (M_s) across the SMC. We find
that about 90% of the HI in the SMC is subsonic or transonic. However, edges of
the SMC `bar' have M_s=4 and may be tracing shearing or turbulent flows. Using
numerical simulations we also investigate how the slope of the spatial power
spectrum depends on both sonic and Alfven Mach numbers. This allows us to gauge
the Alfven Mach number of the SMC and conclude that its gas pressure dominates
over the magnetic pressure. The super-Alfvenic nature of the HI gas in the SMC
is also highlighted by the bispectrum, a three-point correlation function which
characterizes the level of non-Gaussianity in wave modes. We find that the
bispectrum of the SMC HI column density displays similar large-scale
correlations as numerical simulations, however it has localized enhancements of
correlations. In addition, we find a break in correlations at a scale of 160
pc. This may be caused by numerous expanding shells of a similar size.
[65]
oai:arXiv.org:0811.0822 [pdf] - 315284
Density Studies of MHD Interstellar Turbulence: Statistical Moments,
Correlations and Bispectrum
Submitted: 2008-11-05
We present a number of statistical tools for obtaining studying turbulence in
molecular clouds and diffuse interstellar medium. For our tests we used of
three-dimensional 512 cube compressible MHD isothermal simulations performed
for different sonic and Alfvenic Mach numbers. We introduce the bispectrum, a
new tool for statistical studies of the interstellar medium which, unlike an
ordinary power spectrum of turbulence, preserves the phase information of the
stochastic field. We show that the bispectra of the 3D stochastic density field
and of column densities, available from observations, are similar. We use the
bispectrum technique to define the role of non-linear wave-wave interactions in
the turbulent energy cascade. We also obtained the bispectrum function for
density and column densities with varying magnetic field strength. Larger
values of sonic Mach number result in increased correlations for modes with
different wavenumbers. This effect becomes more evident with increasing
magnetic field intensity. In addition to the bispectrum, we calculated the 3rd
and 4th statistical moments of density and column density, namely, skewness and
kurtosis, respectively. We found a strong dependence of skewness and kurtosis
with the sonic Mach number. In particular, as this number increases, so does
the asymmetry of the density distribution. We also studied the correlations of
2D column density with dispersion of velocities and magnetic field, as well as
the correlations of 3D density with magentic and kinetic energy and Alfven Mach
number for comparison. Our results show that column density is linearly
correlated with magnetic field for high sonic Mach number. This trend is
independent of the turbulent kinetic energy and can be used to characterize
inhomogeneities of physical properties in low density clumps in the ISM.