Normalized to: Buldgen, G.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2004.13666 [pdf] - 2109091
Investigating surface correction relations for RGB stars
Jørgensen, Andreas Christ Sølvsten;
Montalbán, Josefina;
Miglio, Andrea;
Rendle, Ben M.;
Davies, Guy R.;
Buldgen, Gaël;
Scuflaire, Richard;
Noels, Arlette;
Gaulme, Patrick;
García, Rafael A.
Submitted: 2020-04-28, last modified: 2020-06-06
State-of-the-art stellar structure and evolution codes fail to adequately
describe turbulent convection. For stars with convective envelopes, such as red
giants, this leads to an incomplete depiction of the surface layers. As a
result, the predicted stellar oscillation frequencies are haunted by systematic
errors, the so-called surface effect. Different empirically and theoretically
motivated correction relations have been proposed to deal with this issue. In
this paper, we compare the performance of these surface correction relations
for red giant branch stars. For this purpose, we apply the different surface
correction relations in asteroseismic analyses of eclipsing binaries and open
clusters. In accordance with previous studies of main-sequence stars, we find
that the use of different surface correction relations biases the derived
global stellar properties, including stellar age, mass, and distance estimates.
We furthermore demonstrate that the different relations lead to the same
systematic errors for two different open clusters. Our results overall
discourage from the use of surface correction relations that rely on reference
stars to calibrate free parameters. Due to the demonstrated systematic biasing
of the results, the use of appropriate surface correction relations is
imperative to any asteroseismic analysis of red giants. Accurate mass, age, and
distance estimates for red giants are fundamental when addressing questions
that deal with the chemo-dynamical evolution of the Milky Way galaxy. In this
way, our results also have implications for fields, such as galactic
archaeology, that draw on findings from stellar physics.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:2006.01783 [pdf] - 2105878
Chronologically dating the early assembly of the Milky Way
Montalbán, Josefina;
Mackereth, John Ted;
Miglio, Andrea;
Vincenzo, Fiorenzo;
Chiappini, Cristina;
Buldgen, Gaël;
Mosser, Benoît;
Noels, Arlette;
Scuflaire, Richard;
Vrard, Mathieu;
Willett, Emma;
Davies, Guy R.;
Hall, Oliver;
Nielsen, Martin Bo;
Khan, Saniya;
Rendle, Ben M.;
van Rossem, Walter E.;
Ferguson, Jason W.;
Chaplin, William J.
Submitted: 2020-06-02
The Milky Way, like other disc galaxies, underwent violent mergers and
accretion of smaller satellite galaxies in its early history. Thanks to
$\mathit Gaia$-DR2 and spectroscopic surveys, the stellar remnants of such
mergers have been identified. The chronological dating of such events is
crucial to uncover the formation and evolution of the Galaxy at high redshift,
but it has so far been challenging owing to difficulties in obtaining precise
ages for these oldest stars. Here we combine asteroseismology -- the study of
stellar oscillations -- with kinematics and chemical abundances, to estimate
precise stellar ages ($\sim$ 11%) for a sample of stars observed by the
$\mathit{Kepler}$ space mission. Crucially, this sample includes not only some
of the oldest stars that were formed inside the Galaxy, but also stars formed
externally and subsequently accreted onto the Milky Way. Leveraging this
unprecedented temporal resolution in age, we provide overwhelming evidence in
favour of models in which the Galaxy had already formed a significant
population of its stars (which now reside mainly in its thick disc) before the
in-fall of the satellite galaxy $\mathit{Gaia}$-$\mathit{Enceladus}$ 10
billions years ago.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:2001.11525 [pdf] - 2042426
Asteroseismology of evolved stars to constrain the internal transport of
angular momentum II. Test of a revised prescription for transport by the
Tayler instability
Submitted: 2020-01-30
Context: Asteroseismic measurements reveal that an unknown efficient angular
momentum (AM) transport mechanism is needed for subgiant and red giant stars. A
revised prescription for AM transport by the magnetic Tayler instability has
been recently proposed as a possible candidate for such a missing mechanism.
Results: The revised prescription for the transport by the Tayler instability
leads to low core rotation rates after the main sequence that are in better
global agreement with asteroseismic measurements than those predicted by models
with purely hydrodynamic processes or with the original Tayler-Spruit dynamo. A
detailed comparison with asteroseismic data shows that the rotational
properties of at most two of the six subgiants can be correctly reproduced by
models accounting for this revised magnetic transport process. This result is
obtained independently of the value adopted for the calibration parameter in
this prescription. We also find that this transport by the Tayler instability
faces difficulties in simultaneously reproducing asteroseismic measurements
available for subgiant and red giant stars. The low values of the calibration
parameter needed to correctly reproduce the rotational properties of two of the
six subgiants lead to core rotation rates during the red giant phase that are
too high. Inversely, the higher values of this parameter needed to reproduce
the core rotation rates of red giants lead to a very low degree of radial
differential rotation before the red giant phase, which is in contradiction
with the internal rotation of subgiant stars.
Conclusions: In its present form, the revised prescription for the transport
by the Tayler instability does not provide a complete solution to the missing
AM transport revealed by asteroseismology of evolved stars.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1911.04504 [pdf] - 2065316
Towards a precision calculation of the effective number of neutrinos
$N_{\rm eff}$ in the Standard Model I: The QED equation of state
Submitted: 2019-11-11, last modified: 2020-01-22
We revisit several aspects of Standard Model physics at finite temperature
that drive the theoretical value of the cosmological parameter $N_{\rm eff}$,
the effective number of neutrinos in the early universe, away from 3. Our chief
focus is finite-temperature corrections to the equation of state of the QED
plasma in the vicinity of neutrino decoupling at $T \sim 1$ MeV, where $T$ is
the photon temperature. Working in the instantaneous decoupling approximation,
we recover at ${\cal O}(e^2)$, where $e$ is the elementary electric charge, the
well-established correction of $\delta N_{\rm eff}^{(2)} \simeq 0.010$ across a
range of plausible neutrino decoupling temperatures, in contrast to an
erroneous claim in the recent literature which found twice as large an effect.
At ${\cal O}(e^3)$ we find a new and significant correction of $\delta N_{\rm
eff}^{(3)} \simeq -0.001$ that has so far not been accounted for in any
precision calculation of $N_{\rm eff}$, significant because this correction is
potentially larger than the change in $N_{\rm eff}$ induced between including
and excluding neutrino oscillations in the transport modelling. In addition to
the QED equation of state, we make a first pass at quantifying
finite-temperature QED corrections to the weak interaction rates that directly
affect the neutrino decoupling process, and find that the ${\cal O}(e^2)$
thermal electron mass correction induces a change of $\delta N_{\rm
eff}^{m_{\rm th}} \lesssim 10^{-4}$. A complete assessment of the various
effects considered in this work on the final value of $N_{\rm eff}$ will
necessitate an account of neutrino energy transport beyond the instantaneous
decoupling approximation. However, relative to $N_{\rm eff} = 3.044$ obtained
in the most recent such calculation, we expect the new effects found in this
work to lower the number to $N_{\rm eff} = 3.043$.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1912.01986 [pdf] - 2009591
From the Sun to solar-like stars: how does the solar modelling problem
affect our studies of solar-like oscillators?
Submitted: 2019-12-04
Since the first observations of solar oscillations in 1962, helioseismology
has probably been one of the most successful fields of astrophysics. Besides
the improvement of observational data, solar seismologists developed
sophisticated techniques to infer the internal structure of the Sun. Back in
1990s these comparisons showed a very high agreement between solar models and
the Sun. However, the downward revision of the CNO surface abundances in the
Sun in 2005, confirmed in 2009, induced a drastic reduction of this agreement
leading to the so-called solar modelling problem. More than ten years later, in
the era of the space-based photometry missions which have established
asteroseismology of solar-like stars as a standard approach to obtain their
masses, radii and ages, the solar modelling problem still awaits a solution. We
will briefly present the results of new helioseismic inversions, discuss the
current uncertainties of solar models and possible solutions to the solar
modelling problem. We will also discuss how the solar problem can have
significant implications for asteroseismology as a whole by discussing the
modelling of the exoplanet-host star Kepler-444, thus impacting the fields
requiring a precise and accurate knowledge of stellar masses, radii and ages,
such as Galactic archaeology and exoplanetology.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1912.02003 [pdf] - 2009592
Global Helioseismology
Submitted: 2019-12-04
Helioseismology is one of the most successful fields of astrophysics. The
observation and characterization of solar oscillation has allowed solar
seismologists to study the internal structure and dynamics of the Sun with
unprecedented thoroughness. Ground-based networks and dedicated space missions
have delivered data of exquisite quality, enabling the development of
sophisticated inference techniques. The achievements of the fields count,
amongst other, the determination of solar photospheric helium abundance,
unacessible to spectroscopic constraints, the precise positioning of the base
of the convective zone and the demonstration of the importance of microscopic
diffusion in stellar radiative regions. Helioseismology played also a key role
in validating the framework used to compute solar and stellar models and played
an important role in the so-called solar neutrino problem. In the current era
of astrophysics, with the increasing importance of asteroseismology to
precisely characterize stars, the Sun still plays a crucial calibration role,
acting as a benchmark for stellar models. With the revision of the solar
abundances and the current discussions related to radiative opacity
computations, the role of the Sun as a laboratory of fundamental physics is
undisputable. In this brief review, I will discuss some of the inference
techniques developed in the field of helioseismology, dedicated to the
exploitation of the solar global oscillation modes.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1911.06343 [pdf] - 2000310
Rotation rate of the solar core as a key constraint to magnetic angular
momentum transport in stellar interiors
Submitted: 2019-11-14
Context: The internal rotation of the Sun constitutes a fundamental
constraint when modelling angular momentum transport in stellar interiors. In
addition to the more external regions of the solar radiative zone probed by
pressure modes, measurements of rotational splittings of gravity modes would
offer an invaluable constraint on the rotation of the solar core. Aims: We
study the constraints that a measurement of the core rotation rate of the Sun
could bring on magnetic angular momentum transport in stellar radiative zones.
Results: We first show that models computed with angular momentum transport by
magnetic instabilities and a recent prescription for the braking of the stellar
surface by magnetized winds can reproduce the observations of surface
velocities of stars in open clusters. These solar models predict both a flat
rotation profile in the external part of the solar radiative zone probed by
pressure modes and an increase in the rotation rate in the solar core, where
the stabilizing effect of chemical gradients plays a key role. A rapid rotation
of the core of the Sun, as suggested by reported detections of gravity modes,
is thus found to be compatible with angular momentum transport by magnetic
instabilities. Moreover, we show that the efficiency of magnetic angular
momentum transport in regions of strong chemical gradients can be calibrated by
the solar core rotation rate independently from the unknown rotational history
of the Sun. In particular, we find that a recent revised prescription for the
transport of angular momentum by the Tayler instability can be easily
distinguished from the original Tayler-Spruit dynamo, with a faster rotating
solar core supporting the original prescription.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1910.04564 [pdf] - 1977497
Comprehensive stellar seismic analysis: A preliminary application of
Whosglad to 16 Cygni system
Submitted: 2019-10-10
We present a first application of Whosglad method to the components A and B
of the 16 Cygni system. The method was developed to provide a comprehensive
analysis of stellar oscillation spectra. It defines new seismic indicators
which are as uncorrelated and precise as possible and hold detailed information
about stellar interiors. Such indicators, as illustrated in the present paper,
may be used to generate stellar models via forward seismic modeling. Finally,
seismic constraints retrieved by the method provide realistic stellar
parameters.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1908.05129 [pdf] - 1942186
HAYDN -- High-precision AsteroseismologY of DeNse stellar fields (ESA
Voyage 2050 White Paper)
Miglio, Andrea;
Girardi, Leo;
Grundahl, Frank;
Mosser, Benoit;
Bastian, Nate;
Bragaglia, Angela;
Brogaard, Karsten;
Buldgen, Gael;
Chantereau, William;
Chaplin, Bill;
Chiappini, Cristina;
Dupret, Marc-Antoine;
Eggenberger, Patrick;
Gieles, Mark;
Izzard, Rob;
Kawata, Daisuke;
Karoff, Christoffer;
Lagarde, Nadege;
Mackereth, Ted;
Magrin, Demetrio;
Meynet, Georges;
Michel, Eric;
Montalban, Josefina;
Nascimbeni, Valerio;
Noels, Arlette;
Piotto, Giampaolo;
Ragazzoni, Roberto;
Soszynski, Igor;
Tolstoy, Eline;
Toonen, Silvia;
Triaud, Amaury;
Vincenzo, Fiorenzo
Submitted: 2019-08-14
In the last decade, the Kepler and CoRoT space-photometry missions have
demonstrated the potential of asteroseismology as a novel, versatile and
powerful tool to perform exquisite tests of stellar physics, and to enable
precise and accurate characterisations of stellar properties, with impact on
both exoplanetary and Galactic astrophysics. Based on our improved
understanding of the strengths and limitations of such a tool, we argue for a
new small/medium space mission dedicated to gathering high-precision,
high-cadence, long photometric series in dense stellar fields. Such a mission
will lead to breakthroughs in stellar astrophysics, especially in the metal
poor regime, will elucidate the evolution and formation of open and globular
clusters, and aid our understanding of the assembly history and chemodynamics
of the Milky Way's bulge and few nearby dwarf galaxies.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1907.10315 [pdf] - 1975344
Revisiting Kepler-444 Part I. Seismic modelling and inversions of
stellar structure
Buldgen, G.;
Farnir, M.;
Pezzotti, C.;
Eggenberger, P.;
Salmon, S. J. A. J.;
Montalban, J.;
Ferguson, J. W.;
Khan, S.;
Bourrier, V.;
Rendle, B. M.;
Meynet, G.;
Miglio, A.;
Noels, A.
Submitted: 2019-07-24
Context. The CoRoT and Kepler missions have paved the way for synergies
between exoplanetology and asteroseismology. The use of seismic data helps
providing stringent constraints on the stellar properties which directly impact
the results of planetary studies. Amongst the most interesting planetary
systems discovered by Kepler, Kepler-444 is unique by the quality of its
seismic and classical stellar constraints. Its magnitude, age and the presence
of 5 small-sized planets orbiting this target makes it an exceptional testbed
for exoplanetology. Aims. We aim at providing a detailed characterization of
Kepler-444, focusing on the dependency of the results on variations of key
ingredients of the theoretical stellar models. This thorough study will serve
as a basis for future investigations of the planetary evolution of the system
orbiting Kepler-444. Methods. We use local and global minimization techniques
to study the internal structure of the exoplanet-host star Kepler-444. We
combine seismic observations from the Kepler mission, Gaia DR2 data and revised
spectroscopic parameters to precisely constrain its internal structure and
evolution. Results. We provide updated robust and precise determinations of the
fundamental parameters of Kepler-444 and demonstrate that this low-mass star
bore a convective core during a significant portion of its life on the
main-sequence. Using seismic data, we are able to estimate the lifetime of the
convective core to approximately 8 Gyr out of the 11 Gyr of the evolution of
Kepler-444. The revised stellar parameters found by our thorough study are M =
0.754 +- 0.03M_Sun , R = 0.753 +- 0.01R_Sun , Age = 11 +- 1 Gy.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1906.08213 [pdf] - 1903252
Progress in global helioseismology: a new light on the solar modelling
problem and its implications for solar-like stars
Submitted: 2019-06-19
Since the first observations of solar oscillations, helioseismology has been
one of the most successful fields of astrophysics. Data of high quality were
obtained through the implementation of networks of ground-based observatories
such as the GONG project or the BiSON network, coupled with space-based
telescopes such as SOHO and SDO missions. Besides the improvement of
observational data, solar seismologists developed sophisticated techniques to
infer the internal structure of the Sun. These methods, then already
extensively used in the field of Geophysics, are called inversion techniques.
They allowed to determine the position of the solar convective envelope, its
helium abundance and the internal radial profiles of thermodynamic quantities.
Back in 1990s these comparisons showed a very high agreement between solar
models and the Sun. However, the downward revision of the CNO surface
abundances in the Sun induced a drastic reduction of this agreement leading to
the solar modelling problem. More than ten years later, in the era of the
space-based photometry missions which have established asteroseismology of
solar-like stars as a standard approach to obtain their masses, radii and ages,
the solar modelling problem still awaits a solution. We will present the
results of new helioseismic inversions, discuss the current uncertainties of
solar models as well as some possible solutions to the solar problem. We will
show how helioseismology can help us grasp what is amiss in our models. We will
also show that, far from being an argument about details of solar models, the
solar problem has significant implications for seismology of solar-like stars,
on the main sequence and beyond, impacting asteroseismology as a whole as well
as the fields requiring precise and accurate knowledge of stellar masses, radii
and ages, such as Galactic archaeology and exoplanetology.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1902.10399 [pdf] - 1839729
Current problems in stellar evolution
Submitted: 2019-02-27
The theory of stellar evolution plays a central role in astrophysics as
stellar models are used to infer properties for Galactic and Extragalactic
stellar populations as well as exoplanetary systems. However, despite decades
of experience, stellar models still face major issues linked to transport
processes of chemicals and angular momentum. This review will focus on some of
the processes responsible for the most sizable uncertainties in stellar models
such as for example convection, rotation and mass loss. The presentation will
discuss their implementation, their impact on theoretical predictions and how
various observational constraints can help us gain insight on the physics
inside stars and face the current challenges of the theory of stellar
evolution.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1902.10390 [pdf] - 1839728
Combining multiple structural inversions to constrain the Solar
modelling problem
Submitted: 2019-02-27
The Sun is the most studied of stars and a laboratory of fundamental physics.
However, the understanding of our star is stained by the solar modelling
problem which can stem from various causes. We combine inversions of sound
speed, an entropy proxy and the Ledoux discriminant with the position of the
base of the convective zone and the photospheric helium abundance to test
combinations of ingredients such as equation of state, abundance and opacity
tables. We study the potential of the inversions to constrain ad-hoc opacity
modifications and additional mixing in the Sun. We show that they provide
constraints on these modifications to the ingredients and that the solar
problem likely occurs from various sources and using phase shifts with our
approach is the next step to take.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1901.02663 [pdf] - 1816327
AIMS - A new tool for stellar parameter determinations using
asteroseismic constraints
Rendle, B. M.;
Buldgen, G.;
Miglio, A.;
Reese, D.;
Noels, A.;
Davies, G. R.;
Campante, T. L.;
Chaplin, W. J.;
Lund, M. N.;
Kuszlewicz, J. S.;
Scott, L. J. A.;
Scuflaire, R.;
Ball, W. H.;
Smetana, J.;
Nsamba, B.
Submitted: 2019-01-09
A key aspect in the determination of stellar properties is the comparison of
observational constraints with predictions from stellar models. Asteroseismic
Inference on a Massive Scale (AIMS) is an open source code that uses Bayesian
statistics and a Markov Chain Monte Carlo approach to find a representative set
of models that reproduce a given set of classical and asteroseismic
constraints. These models are obtained by interpolation on a pre-calculated
grid, thereby increasing computational efficiency. We test the accuracy of the
different operational modes within AIMS for grids of stellar models computed
with the Li\`ege stellar evolution code (main sequence and red giants) and
compare the results to those from another asteroseismic analysis pipeline,
PARAM. Moreover, using artificial inputs generated from models within the grid
(assuming the models to be correct), we focus on the impact on the precision of
the code when considering different combinations of observational constraints
(individual mode frequencies, period spacings, parallaxes, photospheric
constraints,...). Our tests show the absolute limitations of precision on
parameter inferences using synthetic data with AIMS, and the consistency of the
code with expected parameter uncertainty distributions. Interpolation testing
highlights the significance of the underlying physics to the analysis
performance of AIMS and provides caution as to the upper limits in parameter
step size. All tests demonstrate the flexibility and capability of AIMS as an
analysis tool and its potential to perform accurate ensemble analysis with
current and future asteroseismic data yields.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1812.04995 [pdf] - 1815123
Asteroseismology of evolved stars to constrain the internal transport of
angular momentum. I. Efficiency of transport during the subgiant phase
Eggenberger, P.;
Deheuvels, S.;
Miglio, A.;
Ekström, S.;
Georgy, C.;
Meynet, G.;
Lagarde, N.;
Salmon, S.;
Buldgen, G.;
Montalbán, J.;
Spada, F.;
Ballot, J.
Submitted: 2018-12-12
Context: The observations of solar-like oscillations in evolved stars have
brought important constraints on their internal rotation rates. To correctly
reproduce these data, an efficient transport mechanism is needed in addition to
meridional circulation and shear instability. Aims: We study the efficiency of
the transport of angular momentum during the subgiant phase. Results: The
precise asteroseismic measurements of both core and surface rotation rates
available for the six Kepler targets enable a precise determination of the
efficiency of the transport of angular momentum needed for each of these
subgiants. These results are found to be insensitive to all the uncertainties
related to the modelling of rotational effects before the post-main sequence
phase. An interesting exception in this context is the case of young subgiants
(typical values of log(g) close to 4), because their rotational properties are
sensitive to the degree of radial differential rotation on the main sequence.
These young subgiants constitute therefore perfect targets to constrain the
transport of angular momentum on the main sequence from asteroseismic
observations of evolved stars. As for red giants, we find that the efficiency
of the additional transport process increases with the mass of the star during
the subgiant phase. However, the efficiency of this undetermined mechanism
decreases with evolution during the subgiant phase, contrary to what is found
for red giants. Consequently, a transport process with an efficiency that
increases with the degree of radial differential rotation cannot account for
the core rotation rates of subgiants, while it correctly reproduces the
rotation rates of red giant stars. This suggests that the physical nature of
the additional mechanism needed for the internal transport of angular momentum
may be different in subgiant and red giant stars.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1812.04984 [pdf] - 1826864
Comprehensive stellar seismic analysis : New method exploiting the
glitches information in solar-like pulsators
Submitted: 2018-12-12
Aims: We develop a method that provides a comprehensive analysis of the
oscillation spectra of solar-like pulsators. We define new seismic indicators
that should be as uncorrelated and as precise as possible and should hold
detailed information about stellar interiors. This is essential to improve the
quality of the results obtained from asteroseismology as it will provide better
stellar models which in turn can be used to refine inferences made in
exoplanetology and galactic archaeology. Methods: The presented method -
WhoSGlAd - relies on Gram-Schmidt's orthogonalisation process. A Euclidean
vector subspace of functions is defined and the oscillation frequencies are
projected over an orthonormal basis in a specific order. This allows the
obtention of independent coefficients that we combine to define independent
seismic indicators. Results: The developed method has been shown to be stable
and to converge efficiently for solar-like pulsators. Thus, detailed and
precise inferences can be obtained on the mass, the age, the chemical
composition and the undershooting in the interior of the studied stars.
However, attention has to be paid when studying the helium glitch as there
seems to be a degeneracy between the influence of the helium abundance and that
of the heavy elements on the glitch amplitude. As an example, we analyse the
16CygA (HD 186408) oscillation spectrum to provide an illustration of the
capabilities of the method.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1809.08958 [pdf] - 1811122
Combining multiple structural inversions to constrain the Solar
modelling problem
Buldgen, G.;
Salmon, S. J. A. J.;
Noels, A.;
Scuflaire, R.;
Montalban, J.;
Baturin, V. A.;
Eggenberger, P.;
Gryaznov, V. K.;
Iosilevskiy, I. L.;
Meynet, G.;
Chaplin, W. J.;
Miglio, A.;
Oreshina, A. V.;
Richard, O.;
Starostin, A. N.
Submitted: 2018-09-24
The Sun is the most studied of all stars. It is a reference for all other
observed stars and a laboratory of fundamental physics helping us understand
processes occuring in conditions irreproducible on Earth. However, our
understanding of the Sun is currently stained by the solar modelling problem
which can stem from various causes, such as the opacities, the equation of
state and the mixing of chemical elements. We combine inversions of sound
speed, an entropy proxy and the Ledoux discriminant with constraints such as
the position of the base of the convective zone and the photospheric helium
abundance. We test various combinations of standard ingredients for solar
modelling such as abundance tables, equation of state, formalism for convection
and diffusion and opacity tables and study the diagnostic potential of the
inversions to constrain ad-hoc modifications of the opacity profile and
additional mixing below the convective envelope. Combining inversions provides
stringent constraints on the modifications on the models, far beyond what is
achievable only from sound speed inversions. We constrain the form and
amplitude of the opacity increase required and show that a 15% increase at log
T=6.35 provides a significant improvement but that a more global increase of
the opacity, within the uncertainties of current tables, coupled with an
additional mixing at the bottom of the convective zone gives the best agreement
for low metallicity models. We show that high metallicity models do not satisfy
all the inversion results. We conclude that the solar problem likely occurs
from various small sources, as ingredients such as the equation of state or the
formalism of convection can induce small but significant changes and that using
phase shift analyses combined with our approach is the next step for a better
understanding of the inaccuracies of solar models just below the convective
envelope.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1808.08391 [pdf] - 1743894
Mean density inversions for red giants and red clump stars
Buldgen, Gaël;
Rendle, B.;
Sonoi, T.;
Davies, G. R.;
Miglio, A.;
Salmon, S. J. A. J.;
Reese, D. R.;
Bossini, D.;
Eggenberger, P.;
Noels, A.;
Scuflaire, R.
Submitted: 2018-08-25
Since the CoRoT and Kepler missions, the availability of high quality seismic
spectra for red giants has made them the standard clocks and rulers for
Galactic Archeology. With the expected excellent data from the TESS and PLATO
missions, red giants will again play a key role in Galactic studies and stellar
physics, thanks to the precise masses and radii determined by asteroseismology.
The determination of these quantities is often based on so-called scaling laws,
which have been used extensively for main-sequence stars. We show how the SOLA
inversion technique can provide robust determinations of the mean density of
red giants within 1 per cent of the real value, using only radial oscillations.
Combined with radii determinations from Gaia of around 2 per cent precision,
this approach provides robust, less model-dependent masses with an error lower
than 10 per cent. It will improve age determinations, helping to accurately
dissect the Galactic structure and history. We present results on artificial
data of standard models, models including an extended atmosphere from averaged
3D simulations and non-adiabatic frequency calculations to test surface
effects, and on eclipsing binaries. We show that the inversions provide very
robust mean density estimates, using at best seismic information. However, we
also show that a distinction between red-giant branch and red-clump stars is
required to determine a reliable estimate of the mean density. The stability of
the inversion enables an implementation in automated pipelines, making it
suitable for large samples of stars.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1711.05031 [pdf] - 1630250
Constraining convective regions with asteroseismic linear structural
inversions
Submitted: 2017-11-14
Context. Convective regions in stellar models are always associated with
uncertainties, for example due to extra-mixing or the possible inaccurate
position of the transition from convective to radiative transport of energy.
These have a strong impact on stellar models and their fundamental parameters.
The most promising method to reduce these uncertainties is to use
asteroseismology to derive diagnostics probing the structural characteristics
of these regions. Aims. We wish to use custom-made integrated quantities to
improve the capabilities of seismology to probe convective regions in stellar
interiors. We hope to increase the number of indicators obtained with
structural seismic inversions to provide additional constraints on stellar
models and the fundamental parameters determined from theoretical modeling.
Methods. First, we present new kernels associated with a proxy of the entropy
in stellar interiors. We then show how these kernels can be used to build
custom-made integrated quantities probing convective regions inside stellar
models. We present two indicators suited to probe convective cores and
envelopes, respectively, and test them on artificial data. Results. We show
that it is possible to probe both convective cores and envelopes using
appropriate indicators obtained with structural inversion techniques. These
indicators provide direct constraints on a proxy of the entropy of the stellar
plasma, sensitive to the characteristics of convective regions. These
constraints can then be used to improve the modeling of solar-like stars by
providing an additional degree of selection of models obtained from classical
forward modeling approaches. We also show that in order to obtain very accurate
indicators, we need l = 3 modes for the envelope but that the core-conditions
indicator is more flexible in terms of the seismic data required for its use.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1709.00298 [pdf] - 1587802
Determining the metallicity of the solar envelope using seismic
inversion techniques
Submitted: 2017-09-01
The solar metallicity issue is a long-lasting problem of astrophysics,
impacting multi- ple fields and still subject to debate and uncertainties.
While spectroscopy has mostly been used to determine the solar heavy elements
abundance, helioseismologists at- tempted providing a seismic determination of
the metallicity in the solar convective enveloppe. However, the puzzle remains
since two independent groups prodived two radically different values for this
crucial astrophysical parameter. We aim at provid- ing an independent seismic
measurement of the solar metallicity in the convective enveloppe. Our main goal
is to help provide new information to break the current stalemate amongst
seismic determinations of the solar heavy element abundance. We start by
presenting the kernels, the inversion technique and the target function of the
inversion we have developed. We then test our approach in multiple
hare-and-hounds exercises to assess its reliability and accuracy. We then apply
our technique to solar data using calibrated solar models and determine an
interval of seismic measurements for the solar metallicity. We show that our
inversion can indeed be used to estimate the solar metallicity thanks to our
hare-and-hounds exercises. However, we also show that further dependencies in
the physical ingredients of solar models lead to a low accuracy. Nevertheless,
using various physical ingredients for our solar models, we determine
metallicity values between 0.008 and 0.014.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:1709.00287 [pdf] - 1587799
Inversions of the Ledoux discriminant: a closer look at the tachocline
Buldgen, Gaël;
Salmon, S. J. A. J.;
Godart, M.;
Noels, A.;
Scuflaire, R.;
Dupret, M. A.;
Reese, D. R.;
Colgan, J.;
Fontes, C. J.;
Eggenberger, P.;
Hakel, P.;
Kilcrease, D. P.;
Richard, O.
Submitted: 2017-09-01
Modelling the base of the solar convective envelope is a tedious problem.
Since the first rotation inversions, solar modellers are confronted with the
fact that a region of very limited extent has an enormous physical impact on
the Sun. Indeed, it is the transition region from differential to solid body
rotation, the tachocline, which furthermore is influenced by turbulence and is
also supposed to be the seat of the solar magnetic dynamo. Moreover, solar
models show significant disagreement with the sound speed profile in this
region. In this paper, we show how helioseismology can provide further
constraints on this region by carrying out an inversion of the Ledoux
discriminant. We compare these inversions for Standard Solar Models built using
various opacity tables and chemical abundances and discuss the origins of the
discrepancies between Solar Models and the Sun.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:1707.05138 [pdf] - 1586000
Seismic inversion of the solar entropy: A case for improving the
Standard Solar Model
Buldgen, G.;
Salmon, S. J. A. J.;
Noels, A.;
Scuflaire, R.;
Reese, D. R.;
Dupret, M-A.;
Colgan, J.;
Fontes, C. J.;
Eggenberger, P.;
Hakel, P.;
Kilcrease, D. P.;
Turck-Chièze, S.
Submitted: 2017-07-17
The Sun is the most constrained and well-studied of all stars. As a
consequence, the physical ingredients entering solar models are used as a
reference to study all other stars observed in the Universe. However, our
understanding of the solar structure is still imperfect, as illustrated by the
current debate on the heavy element abundances in the Sun. We wish to provide
additional information on the solar structure by carrying out structural
inversions of a new physical quantity, a proxy of the entropy of the solar
plasma which properties are very sensitive to the temperature gradient below
the convective zone. We use new structural kernels to carry out direct
inversions of an entropy proxy of the solar plasma and compare the solar
structure to various standard solar models built using various opacity tables
and chemical abundances. We also link our results to classical tests commonly
found in the literature. Our analysis allows us to probe more efficiently the
uncertain regions of the solar models, just below the convective zone, paving
the way for new in-depth analyses of the Sun taking into account additional
physical uncertainties of solar models beyond the specific question of chemical
abundances.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:1702.07204 [pdf] - 1581603
Asteroseismic inversions in the Kepler era: application to the Kepler
Legacy sample
Submitted: 2017-02-23, last modified: 2017-02-24
In the past few years, the CoRoT and Kepler missions have carried out what is
now called the space photometry revolution. This revolution is still ongoing
thanks to K2 and will be continued by the Tess and Plato2.0 missions. However,
the photometry revolution must also be followed by progress in stellar
modelling, in order to lead to more precise and accurate determinations of
fundamental stellar parameters such as masses, radii and ages. In this context,
the long-lasting problems related to mixing processes in stellar interior is
the main obstacle to further improvements of stellar modelling. In this
contribution, we will apply structural asteroseismic inversion techniques to
targets from the Kepler Legacy sample and analyse how these can help us
constrain the fundamental parameters and mixing processes in these stars. Our
approach is based on previous studies using the SOLA inversion technique to
determine integrated quantities such as the mean density, the acoustic radius,
and core conditions indicators, and has already been successfully applied to
the 16Cyg binary system. We will show how this technique can be applied to the
Kepler Legacy sample and how new indicators can help us to further constrain
the chemical composition profiles of stars as well as provide stringent
constraints on stellar ages.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:1702.07208 [pdf] - 1537488
Linear approximation of seismic inversions: new kernels and structural
effects
Submitted: 2017-02-23
Thanks to the space-based photometry missions CoRoT and Kepler, we now
benefit from a wealth of seismic data for stars other than the sun. In the
future, K2, Tess and Plato will provide further observations. The quality of
this data may allow kernel-based linear structural inversion techniques to be
used for stars other than the sun. To understand the limitations of this
approach, we analyse the validity of the linear assumption used in these
inversion techniques. We inspect various structural pairs and see how they are
affected by structural changes. We show that uncertainties in radius strongly
affect structural pairs of nondimensional variables, and that various other
effects might come into play. Amongst these, the importance of micro-physics
give the most striking example of how uncertainties in stellar models impact
the verification of the linear relations. We also point out that including
seismic constraints in the forward modelling fit helps with satisfying the
linear relations.
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:1610.01460 [pdf] - 1531887
Analysis of the linear approximation of seismic inversions for various
structural pairs
Submitted: 2016-10-05
Thanks to space-based photometry missions CoRoT and Kepler, we benefit from a
wealth of seismic data for stars other than the sun. In the future, K2, Tess,
and Plato will complement this data and provide observations in addition to
those already at hand. The availability of this data leads to questions on how
it is feasible to extend linear structural inversion techniques to stars other
than the sun. Linked to this problem is the question of the validity of the
linear assumption. In this study, we analyse its limitations with respect to
changes of structural variables.We wish to provide a more extended theoretical
background to structural linear inversions by doing a study of the validity of
the linear assumption for various structural variables. First, we recall the
origins of the linear assumption for structural stellar inversions and explain
its importance for asteroseismic studies. We recall the impact of unknown
structural quantities such as the mass and the radius of the star on structural
inversion results. We explain how kernels for new structural variables can be
derived using two methods, one suited to asteroseismic targets, the other to
helioseismic targets. For this second method, we present a new structural pair,
namely the (A, Y) structural kernels. The kernels are tested in various
numerical experiments that enable us to evaluate the weaknesses of different
pairs and the domains of validity of their respective linear regime. The
numerical tests we carry out allow us to disentangle the impact of various
uncertainties in stellar models on the verification of the linear integral
relations. We show the importance of metallicity, the equation of state,
extra-mixing, and inaccuracies in the microphysics. We discuss the limitations
of the method of conjugated functions due to the lack of extremely precise
determinations of masses or radii in the asteroseismology.
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:1608.05546 [pdf] - 1528151
In-depth study of 16CygB using inversion techniques
Submitted: 2016-08-19
The 16Cyg binary system hosts the solar-like Kepler targets with the most
stringent observational constraints. Moreover, this system is particularly
interesting since both stars are very similar in mass but the A component is
orbited by a red dwarf, whereas the B component is orbited by a Jovian planet
and thus could have formed a more complex planetary system. In our previous
study, we showed that seismic inversions of integrated quantities could be used
to constrain microscopic diffusion in the A component. In this study, we
analyse the B component in the light of a more regularised inversion. We wish
to analyse independently the B component of the 16Cyg binary system using the
inversion of an indicator dedicated to analyse core conditions, denoted tu.
Using this independent determination, we wish to analyse any differences
between both stars due to the potential influence of planetary formation on
stellar structure and/or their respective evolution. First, we recall the
observational constraints for 16CygB and the method we used to generate
reference stellar models. The inversion results were then used to analyse the
differences between the A and B components. The tu indicator for 16CygB shows a
disagreement with models including microscopic diffusion and sharing the
chemical composition previously derived for 16CygA. Small changes in chemical
composition are insufficient to solve the problem but that extra mixing can
account for the differences seen between both stars. We use a parametric
approach to analyse the impact of extra mixing in the form of turbulent
diffusion on the behaviour of the tu values. We conclude on the necessity of
further investigations using models with a physically motivated implementation
of extra mixing including additional constraints to further improve the
accuracy with which the fundamental parameters of this system are determined.
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:1604.08404 [pdf] - 1433045
SpaceInn hare-and-hounds exercise: Estimation of stellar properties
using space-based asteroseismic data
Reese, D. R.;
Chaplin, W. J.;
Davies, G. R.;
Miglio, A.;
Antia, H. M.;
Ball, W. H.;
Basu, S.;
Buldgen, G.;
Christensen-Dalsgaard, J.;
Coelho, H. R.;
Hekker, S.;
Houdek, G.;
Lebreton, Y.;
Mazumdar, A.;
Metcalfe, T. S.;
Aguirre, V. Silva;
Stello, D.;
Verma, K.
Submitted: 2016-04-28
Context: Detailed oscillation spectra comprising individual frequencies for
numerous solar-type stars and red giants are or will become available. These
data can lead to a precise characterisation of stars.
Aims: Our goal is to test and compare different methods for obtaining stellar
properties from oscillation frequencies and spectroscopic constraints, in order
to evaluate their accuracy and the reliability of the error bars.
Methods: In the context of the SpaceInn network, we carried out a
hare-and-hounds exercise in which one group produced "observed" oscillation
spectra for 10 artificial solar-type stars, and various groups characterised
these stars using either forward modelling or acoustic glitch signatures.
Results: Results based on the forward modelling approach were accurate to 1.5
% (radius), 3.9 % (mass), 23 % (age), 1.5 % (surface gravity), and 1.8 % (mean
density). For the two 1 Msun stellar targets, the accuracy on the age is better
than 10 % thereby satisfying PLATO 2.0 requirements. The average accuracies for
the acoustic radii of the base of the convection zone, the He II ionisation,
and the Gamma_1 peak were 17 %, 2.4 %, and 1.9 %, respectively. Glitch fitting
analysis seemed to be affected by aliasing problems for some of the targets.
Conclusions: Forward modelling is the most accurate approach, but needs to be
complemented by model-independent results from, e.g., glitch analysis.
Furthermore, global optimisation algorithms provide more robust error bars.
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:1507.06466 [pdf] - 1300241
Using seismic inversions to obtain an internal mixing processes
indicator for main-sequence solar-like stars
Submitted: 2015-07-23
Determining accurate and precise stellar ages is a major problem in
astrophysics. These determinations are either obtained through empirical
relations or model-dependent approaches. Currently, seismic modelling is one of
the best ways of providing accurate ages. However, current methods are affected
by simplifying assumptions concerning mixing processes. In this context,
providing new structural indicators which are less model-dependent and more
sensitive to such processes is crucial. We build a new indicator for core
conditions on the main sequence, which should be more sensitive to structural
differences and applicable to older stars than the indicator t presented in a
previous paper. We also wish to analyse the importance of the number and type
of modes for the inversion, as well as the impact of various constraints and
levels of accuracy in the forward modelling process that is used to obtain
reference models for the inversion. First, we present a method to obtain new
structural kernels and use them to build an indicator of central conditions in
stars and test it for various effects including atomic diffusion, various
initial helium abundances and metallicities, following the seismic inversion
method presented in our previous paper. We then study its accuracy for 7
different pulsation spectra including those of 16CygA and 16CygB and analyse
its dependence on the reference model by using different constraints and levels
of accuracy for its selection We observe that the inversion of the new
indicator using the SOLA method provides a good diagnostic for additional
mixing processes in central regions of stars. Its sensitivity allows us to test
for diffusive processes and chemical composition mismatch. We also observe that
octupole modes can improve the accuracy of the results, as well as modes of low
radial order.
[29]
oai:arXiv.org:1507.06465 [pdf] - 1338933
Constraints on the structure of 16 Cyg A and 16 Cyg B using inversion
techniques
Submitted: 2015-07-23
Constraining mixing processes and chemical composition is a central problem
in stellar physics as their impact on stellar age determinations leads to
biases in our studies of stellar evolution, galactic history and exoplanetary
systems. In two previous papers, we showed how seismic inversion techniques
could offer strong constraints on such processes by pointing out weaknesses in
theoretical models. We now apply our technique to the solar analogues 16CygA
and 16CygB, being amongst the best targets in the Kepler field to test the
diagnostic potential of seismic inversions. The combination of various seismic
indicators helps to provide more constrained and accurate fundamendal
parameters for these stars. We use the latest seismic, spectroscopic and
interferometric observational constraints in the litterature for this system to
determine reference models independently for both stars. We carry out seismic
inversions of the acoustic radius, the mean density and a core conditions
indicator. We note that a degeneracy exists for the reference models. Namely,
changing the diffusion coefficient or the chemical composition within the
observational values leads to 5% changes in mass, 3% changes in radius and up
to 8% changes in age. We use acoustic radius and mean density inversions to
improve our reference models then carry out inversions for a core conditions
indicator. Thanks to its sensitivity to microscopic diffusion and chemical
composition mismatches, we are able to reduce the mass dispersion to 2%, namely
[0.96, 1.0] M_sun, the radius dispersion to 1%, namely [1.188, 1.200] R_sun and
the age dispersion to 3%, namely [7.0, 7.4] Gy, for 16CygA. For 16CygB, we can
check the consistency of the models but not reduce independently the age
dispersion. Nonetheless, assuming consistency with the age of 16CygA helps to
further constrain its mass and radius.
[30]
oai:arXiv.org:1411.2416 [pdf] - 926652
Stellar acoustic radii, mean densities and ages from seismic inversion
techniques
Submitted: 2014-11-10
Context. Determining stellar characteristics such as the radius, the mass or
the age is crucial when studying stellar evolution, exoplanetary systems or
characterising stellar populations in the Galaxy. Asteroseismology is the
golden path to accurately obtain these characteristics. In this context, a key
question is how to make these methods less model-dependant. Aims. Building on
the work of Reese et al. (2012), we wish to extend the SOLA inversion technique
to new stellar global characteristics in addition to the mean density. The goal
is to provide a general framework in which to estimate these characteristics as
accurately as possible in low mass main sequence stars. Methods. First, we
describe our framework and discuss the reliability of the inversion technique
and the possible sources of error.We then apply this methodology to the
acoustic radius, an age indicator based on the sound speed derivative and the
mean density and compare it to estimates based on the average large and small
frequency separations. These inversions are carried out for several test cases
which include: various metallicities, different mixing-lengths, non-adiabatic
effects and turbulent pressure. Results. We observe that the SOLA method yields
accurate results in all test cases whereas results based on the large and small
frequency separations are less accurate and more sensitive to surface effects
and structural differences in the models. If we include the surface corrections
of Kjeldsen et al. (2008), we obtain results of comparable accuracy for the
mean density. Overall, the mean density and acoustic radius inversions are more
robust than the inversions for the age indicator. Moreover, the current
approach is limited to relatively young stars with radiative cores. Increasing
the number of observed frequencies improves the reliability and accuracy of the
method.