Normalized to: Boughn, S.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1303.7162 [pdf] - 1165598
Fritz Hasenohrl and E = mc^2
Submitted: 2013-03-28
In 1904, the year before Einstein's seminal papers on special relativity,
Austrian physicist Fritz Hasenohrl examined the properties of blackbody
radiation in a moving cavity. He calculated the work necessary to keep the
cavity moving at a constant velocity as it fills with radiation and concluded
that the radiation energy has associated with it an apparent mass such that E =
3/8 mc^2. Also in 1904, Hasenohrl achieved the same result by computing the
force necessary to accelerate a cavity already filled with radiation. In early
1905, he corrected the latter result to E = 3/4 mc^2. In this paper,
Hasenohrl's papers are examined from a modern, relativistic point of view in an
attempt to understand where he went wrong. The primary mistake in his first
paper was, ironically, that he didn't account for the loss of mass of the
blackbody end caps as they radiate energy into the cavity. However, even taking
this into account one concludes that blackbody radiation has a mass equivalent
of m = 4/3 E/c^2 or m = 5/3 E/c^2 depending on whether one equates the momentum
or kinetic energy of radiation to the momentum or kinetic energy of an
equivalent mass. In his second and third papers that deal with an accelerated
cavity, Hasenohrl concluded that the mass associated with blackbody radiation
is m = 4/3 E/c^2, a result which, within the restricted context of Hasenohrl's
gedanken experiment, is actually consistent with special relativity. Both of
these problems are non-trivial and the surprising results, indeed, turn out to
be relevant to the "4/3 problem" in classical models of the electron. An
important lesson of these analyses is that E = mc^2, while extremely useful, is
not a "law of physics" in the sense that it ought not be applied
indiscriminately to any extended system and, in particular, to the subsystems
from which they are comprised.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1108.2250 [pdf] - 402461
Hasenohrl and the Equivalence of Mass and Energy
Submitted: 2011-08-10, last modified: 2011-08-24
In 1904 Austrian physicist Fritz Hasenohrl (1874-1915) examined blackbody
radiation in a reflecting cavity. By calculating the work necessary to keep the
cavity moving at a constant velocity against the radiation pressure he
concluded that to a moving observer the energy of the radiation would appear to
increase by an amount E=(3/8)mc^2, which in early 1905 he corrected to
E=(3/4)mc^2. Because relativistic corrections come in at order v^2/c^2 and
Hasenohrl's gedankenexperiment evidently required calculations only to order
v/c, it is initially puzzling why he did not achieve the answer universally
accepted today. Moreover, that $m$ should be equal to (4/3)E/c^2 has led
commentators to believe that this problem is identical to the famous "4/3
problem" of the self-energy of the electron and they have invariably attributed
Hasenohrl's mistake to neglect of the cavity stresses. We examine Hasenohrl's
papers from a modern, relativistic point of view in an attempt to understand
where exactly he went wrong. The problem turns out to be a rich and challenging
one with strong resonances to matters that remain controversial. We give an
acceptable relativistic solution to the conundrum and show that virtually
everything ever written about Hasenohrl's thought experiment, including a 1923
paper by Enrico Fermi, is misleading if not incorrect.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:0809.4218 [pdf] - 16689
Nonquantum Gravity
Submitted: 2008-09-24, last modified: 2009-04-08
One of the great challenges for 21st century physics is to quantize gravity
and generate a theory that will unify gravity with the other three fundamental
forces of nature. This paper takes the (heretical) point of view that gravity
may be an inherently classical, i.e., nonquantum, phenomenon and investigates
the experimental consequences of such a model. At present there is no
experimental evidence of the quantum nature of gravity and the liklihood of
definitive tests in the future is not at all certain. If gravity is, indeed, a
nonquantum phenomenon, then it is suggested that evidence will most likely
appear at mesoscopic scales.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:0801.4380 [pdf] - 9480
Combined analysis of the integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect and cosmological
implications
Submitted: 2008-01-29, last modified: 2008-05-06
We present a global measurement of the integrated Sachs-Wolfe (ISW) effect
obtained by cross-correlating all relevant large scale galaxy data sets with
the cosmic microwave background radiation map provided by the Wilkinson
Microwave Anisotropy Probe. With these measurements, the overall ISW signal is
detected at the ~ 4.5 sigma level. We also examine the cosmological
implications of these measurements, particularly the dark energy equation of
state w, its sound speed, and the overall curvature of the Universe. The flat
LCDM model is a good fit to the data and, assuming this model, we find that the
ISW data constrain Omega_m = 0.20 +0.19 -0.11 at the 95% confidence level. When
we combine our ISW results with the latest baryon oscillation and supernovae
measurements, we find that the result is still consistent with a flat LCDM
model with w = -1 out to redshifts z > 1.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:0708.4220 [pdf] - 4410
RMS Radio Source Contributions to the Microwave Sky
Submitted: 2007-08-30
Cross-correlations of the WMAP full sky K, Ka, Q, V, and W band maps with the
1.4 GHz NVSS source count map and the HEAO I A2 2-10 keV full sky X-ray flux
map are used to constrain rms fluctuations due to unresolved microwave sources
in the WMAP frequency range. In the Q band (40.7 GHz), a lower limit, taking
account of only those fluctuations correlated with the 1.4 GHz radio source
counts and X-ray flux, corresponds to an rms Rayleigh-Jeans temperature of ~ 2
microKelvin for a solid angle of one square degree. The correlated fluctuations
at the other bands are consistent with a beta = -2.1 +- 0.4 frequency spectrum.
Using the rms fluctuations of the X-ray flux and radio source counts, and the
cross-correlation of these two quantities as a guide, the above lower limit
leads to a plausible estimate of ~ 5 microKelvin for Q-band rms fluctuations in
one square degree. This value is similar to that implied by the excess, small
angular scale fluctuations observed in the Q band by WMAP, and is consistent
with estimates made by extrapolating low-frquency source counts.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0611655 [pdf] - 316614
Evidence for Inverted Spectrum 20 GHz Emission in the Galactic Plane
Submitted: 2006-11-20, last modified: 2007-06-01
A comparison of a 19 GHz full-sky map with the WMAP satellite K band (23 GHz)
map indicates that the bulk of the 20 GHz emission within 7 degrees of the
Galactic plane has an inverted (rising) spectrum with an average spectral index
alpha = 0.21 +/- 0.05. While such a spectrum is inconsistent with steep
spectrum synchrotron (alpha ~ -0.7) and flat spectrum free-free (alpha ~ -0.1)
emission, it is consistent with various models of electric dipole emission from
thermally excited spinning dust grains as well as models of magnetic dipole
emission from ferromagnetic dust grains. Several regions in the plane, e.g.,
near the Cygnus arm, have spectra with even larger alpha. While low signal to
noise of the 19 GHz data precludes a detailed map of spectral index, especially
off the Galactic plane, it appears that the bulk of the emission in the plane
is correlated with the morphology of dust. Regions with higher 23 GHz flux tend
to have harder spectra. Off the plane, at Galactic latitudes between 7 and 20
degree the spectrum steepens to alpha = -0.16 +/- 0.15.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:gr-qc/0601043 [pdf] - 112072
Can Gravitons Be Detected?
Submitted: 2006-01-11, last modified: 2006-12-02
Freeman Dyson has questioned whether any conceivable experiment in the real
universe can detect a single graviton. If not, is it meaningful to talk about
gravitons as physical entities? We attempt to answer Dyson's question and find
it is possible concoct an idealized thought experiment capable of detecting one
graviton; however, when anything remotely resembling realistic physics is taken
into account, detection becomes impossible, indicating that Dyson's conjecture
is very likely true. We also point out several mistakes in the literature
dealing with graviton detection and production.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:gr-qc/0605052 [pdf] - 112190
Aspects of Graviton Detection: Graviton Emission and Absorption by
Atomic Hydrogen
Submitted: 2006-05-09, last modified: 2006-09-27
Graviton absorption cross sections and emission rates for hydrogen are
calculated by both semi-classical and field theoretic methods. We point out
several mistakes in the literature concerning spontaneous emission of gravitons
and related phenomena, some of which are due to a subtle issue concerning gauge
invariance of the linearized interaction Hamiltonian.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0408242 [pdf] - 66733
Investigating the origins of the CMB-XRB cross correlation
Submitted: 2004-08-12
Recently, we presented evidence for a cross-correlation of the WMAP satellite
map of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) and the HEAO1 satellite map of the
hard X-ray background (XRB) with a dimensionless amplitude of 0.14 +- 0.05
normalized to the product of the rms fluctuations of the CMB and XRB (Boughn &
Crittenden, 2004). Such a correlation is expected in a universe dominated by a
cosmological constant via the integrated Sachs-Wolfe (ISW) effect and the level
of the correlation observed is consistent with that predicted by the currently
favored Lambda cold dark matter model of the universe. Since this offers
independent confirmation of the cosmological model, it is important to verify
the origin of the correlation. Here we explore in detail some possible
foreground sources of the correlation. The present evidence all supports an ISW
origin.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0404348 [pdf] - 64256
The large-scale bias of the hard X-ray background
Submitted: 2004-04-18, last modified: 2004-06-09
Recent deep X-ray surveys combined with spectroscopic identification of the
sources have allowed the determination of the rest-frame 2-8 keV luminosity as
a function of redshift. In addition, an analysis of the HEAO1 A2 2-10 keV
full-sky map of the X-ray background (XRB) reveals clustering on the scale of
several degrees. Combining these two results in the context of the currently
favored Lambda-CDM cosmological model implies an average X-ray bias factor,
b_x, of b_x^2 = 1.12 +- 0.33, i.e., b_x = 1.06 +- 0.16. These error estimates
include only statistical error; the systematic error sources, while comparable,
appear to be sub-dominant. This result is in contrast to the large biases of
some previous estimates and is more in line with current estimates of the
optical bias of L* galaxies.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0404470 [pdf] - 64378
A Detection of the Integrated Sachs-Wolfe Effect
Submitted: 2004-04-23
We have detected statistically significant correlations between the cosmic
microwave background and two tracers of large-scale structure, the HEAO1 A2
full sky hard X-ray map and the NVSS 1.4 GHz, nearly full sky radio galaxy
survey. The level of correlations in these maps is consistent with that
predicted for the integrated Sachs-Wolfe (ISW) effect in the context of a
Lambda CDM cosmological model and, therefore, provides independent evidence for
a cosmological constant. A maximum likelihood fit to the amplitude of the ISW
effect relative to the predicted value is 1.13 +- 0.35 (statistical error
only).
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0305001 [pdf] - 56474
A correlation of the cosmic microwave sky with large scale structure
Submitted: 2003-04-30
We cross correlate the large-scale cosmic microwave background (CMB) sky
measured by WMAP with two probes of large-scale structure at z ~ 1. The hard
X-ray background, measured by the HEAO-1 satellite, is positively correlated
with the WMAP data at the 2.5-3.0 sigma level. The number counts of radio
galaxies in the NVSS survey are also correlated at a slightly weaker level
(2.-2.5 sigma). These correlations appear to arise from both hemispheres on the
sky and are resilient to changes in the levels of masking of the Galaxy and
point sources, suggesting that foregrounds are not responsible for the signal.
The implication is that some of the observed CMB fluctuations arise at low
redshifts. The level of the correlations is consistent with that expected for
the cosmological constant (Omega_Lambda = 0.72) concordance model resulting
from the integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect. Thus, we may be observing dark energy's
effect on the growth of structure.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0208153 [pdf] - 50969
The Large-Scale Structure of the X-ray Background and its Cosmological
Implications
Submitted: 2002-08-07
A careful analysis of the HEAO1 A2 2-10 keV full-sky map of the X-ray
background (XRB) reveals clustering on the scale of several degrees. After
removing the contribution due to beam smearing, the intrinsic clustering of the
background is found to be consistent with an auto-correlation function of the
form (3.6 +- 0.9) x 10^{-4} theta^{-1} where theta is measured in degrees. If
current AGN models of the hard XRB are reasonable and the cosmological
constant-cold dark matter cosmology is correct, this clustering implies an
X-ray bias factor of b_X ~ 2. Combined with the absence of a correlation
between the XRB and the cosmic microwave background, this clustering can be
used to limit the presence of an integrated Sachs-Wolfe (ISW) effect and
thereby to constrain the value of the cosmological constant, Omega_Lambda <
0.60 (95 % C.L.). This constraint is inconsistent with much of the parameter
space currently favored by other observations. Finally, we marginally detect
the dipole moment of the diffuse XRB and find it to be consistent with the
dipole due to our motion with respect to the mean rest frame of the XRB. The
limit on the amplitude of any intrinsic dipole is delta I / I < 5 x 10^{-3} at
the 95 % C.L. When compared to the local bulk velocity, this limit implies a
constraint on the matter density of the universe of Omega_m^{0.6}/b_X(0) >
0.24.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0111281 [pdf] - 46047
Cross-Correlation of the Cosmic Microwave Background with Radio Sources:
Constraints on an Accelerating Universe
Submitted: 2001-11-14
We present a new limit on the cosmological constant based on the absence of
correlations between the cosmic microwave background (CMB) and the distribution
of distant radio sources. In the cosmological constant-cold dark matter models
currently favored, such correlations should have been produced via the
integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect, assuming that radio sources trace the local
(z=1) matter density. We find no evidence of correlations between the COBE 53Hz
microwave map and the NVSS 1.4 GHz radio survey. The implied 95% CL limit on
the cosmological constant is Lambda < 0.74, in marginal agreement with the
values suggested by recent measurements of the CMB anisotropy and type-IA
supernovae observations, 0.6 < Lambda < 0.7. If the cosmological model does lie
in this range, then the integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect should be detectable with
upcoming CMB maps and radio surveys.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9905216 [pdf] - 106542
On Radio and X-ray Emission Mechanisms in Nearby, X-ray Bright Galactic
Nuclei
Submitted: 1999-05-17
It has been suggested that advection-dominated accretion flows (ADAFs) are
responsible for the X-ray activity in nearby galactic nuclei. These X-ray
bright galactic nuclei (XBGN) are a heterogeneous group which includes LINERs,
low to moderate luminosity Seyferts, and narrow-line X-ray galaxies with 2-10
keV X-ray luminosities in the range ~10**39 to ~10**43 erg/s. In the absence of
a radio jet, the core 15 GHz radio luminosity of an ADAF is relatively low and
roughly proportional to the mass of the central black hole. The predicted radio
luminosity depends primarily on the black hole mass and for XBGN typically
falls in the range 10**35-10**39 erg/s. We designate these as ``radio quiet''
XBGN. However, some level of jet activity seems to be present in most sources
and the radio emission can be considerably larger than that from the ADAF core.
We discuss connections between radio-bright XBGN and radio-loud, powerful
active galactic nuclei (AGN) and suggest that the radio activities are directly
correlated with black hole spins in both cases. Even in the presence of a radio
jet, high resolution, high frequency radio imaging of nearby XBGN could
identify compact, inverted spectrum ADAF radio sources. The unique radio/X-ray
luminosity relation is confirmed in a few cases where black hole masses are
known and could be used as a tool to estimate unknown black hole masses. For
radio-dim (L_<10**39 erg/s), X-ray bright (L_x>10**43 erg/s) sources, which are
primarily Seyferts, the X-ray emission mechanism is not accounted for by pure
ADAFs and radio activities are likely to be similar to those of the radio-quiet
AGN.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9807329 [pdf] - 102323
Galactic emission at 19 GHz
Submitted: 1998-07-30, last modified: 1998-10-13
We cross-correlate a 19 GHz full sky Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) survey
with other maps to quantify the foreground contribution. Correlations are
detected with the Diffuse Infrared Background Experiment (DIRBE) 240, 140 and
100 micron maps at high latitudes (|b|>30degrees), and marginal correlations
are detected with the Haslam 408 MHz and the Reich & Reich 1420 MHz synchrotron
maps. The former agree well with extrapolations from higher frequencies probed
by the COBE DMR and Saskatoon experiments and are consistent with both
free-free and rotating dust grain emission.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9807308 [pdf] - 102302
Evidence for Hot, Diffuse Gas in the Local Supercluster
Submitted: 1998-07-29
Using the HEAO1 A2 full sky, 2-10 keV X-ray map evidence is found for the
presence of diffuse X-ray emission in the plane of the local supercluster.
Fitting this diffuse component with a simple ``pillbox'' model implies a volume
X-ray emissivity of 3.0 +- 0.3 x 10**39 (20 Mpc/R) erg/s/Mpc**3 where R is the
radius of the supercluster and the error is photon counting noise only. If one
considers fluctuations in the X-ray background as an additional component of
noise then the significance of the detection is reduced to 2 to 3 sigma. This
is consistent with fits of the model to data sets obtained by rotating the
original data. The distribution of these rotated fits indicates that the
detection is signficant at the 99% confidence level. If the source of the X-ray
emission is Bremsstrahlung from a uniformly distributed plasma with temperature
T_e then the implied electron number density is N_e = 2.5 x 10**-6
(R/20Mpc)**-1/2 (kT_e /10 keV)**-1/4 cm**-3. This value is about an order of
magnitude larger than the average baryon number density implied by
nucleosynthesis and is consistent with a collapse factor of 10. A search for
similar structure in the COBE 53 GHz microwave background map yielded a
marginal 1 sigma detection of -17 microKelvin which is consistent with the
Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (SZ) effect expected from 10 keV gas.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9710147 [pdf] - 98906
Hard X-rays from Emission Line Galaxies and the X-ray Background: A Test
for Advection Dominated Accretion with Radio Sources
Submitted: 1997-10-14
Recent studies of the cosmic X-ray background (XRB) have suggested the
possible existence of a population of relatively faint sources with hard X-ray
spectra; however, the emission mechanism remains unclear. If the hard X-ray
emission is from the radiatively inefficient, advection dominated accretion
flows (ADAFs) around massive black holes in galactic nuclei, X-ray luminosity
and radio luminosity satisfy the approximate relation $L_R\sim 7\times
10^{35}(\nu/15GHz)^{7/5}(M/10^7M_{\odot}) (L_x/10^{40} erg s^{-1})^{1/10} erg
s^{-1}$ where $L_R=\nu L_\nu$ is the radio luminosity at frequency $\nu$, $M$
is the mass of the accreting black hole, and $10^{40} \simle L_x\simle 10^{42}
erg s^{-1}$ is the 2-10 keV X-ray luminosity. These sources are characterized
by inverted radio spectra $I_\nu \propto \nu^{2/5}$. For example, an ADAF X-ray
source with luminosity $L_x\sim 10^{41} erg s^{-1}$ has a nuclear radio
luminosity of $\sim 4\times 10^{36}(M/3\times 10^7M_{\odot}) erg s^{-1}$ at
$\sim 20$ GHz and if at a distance of $\sim 10 (M/3\times 10^7M_{\odot})^{1/2}
Mpc$ would be detected as a $\sim 1mJy$ point radio source. High frequency
($\sim 20 GHz$), high angular resolution radio observations provide an
important test of the ADAF emission mechanism. Since $L_R$ depends strongly on
black hole mass and only weakly on X-ray luminosity, the successful measurement
of nuclear radio emission could provide an estimate of black hole mass. Because
the X-ray spectra produced by ADAFs are relatively hard, sources of this
emission are natural candidates for contributing to the hard, $>2$ keV,
background.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9709077 [pdf] - 98530
Cross-correlation of the 2-10 keV XRB with radio sources: constraining
the large-scale structure of the x-ray background
Submitted: 1997-09-09
We present cross-correlation analyses of the HEAO 2-10 keV diffuse X-ray map
with both the combined GB6/Parkes-MIT-NRAO (GB6-PMN) 5 GHz and the FIRST 1.4
GHz radio surveys. The cross-correlation functions (CCFs) of both radio surveys
with the unresolved X-ray background were detected at the 5 sigma level. While
the large angular resolution (3 degrees) of the X-ray map makes it difficult to
separate the contributions of clustering from those of Poisson fluctuations,
the amplitude of the CCF provides important constraints on the X-ray emissivity
of the radio sources as well as on the clustering properties of radio and X-ray
sources. These constraints are subject to a number of modeling parameters, e.g.
the X-ray luminosity evolution, clustering evolution, the radio luminosity
function, cosmological model, etc. For reasonable choices of paramters the
X-ray/FIRST CCF is consistent with a correlation scale length of 6/h Mpc. This
is somewhat smaller than the scale length inferred from the autocorrelation
function of the FIRST survey and implies that X-ray sources are less strongly
clustered than strong radio sources, a result which is consistent with previous
constraints on X-ray clustering. The X-ray/GB6-PMN CCF is several times larger
and is likely to be dominated by Poisson fluctuations. This implies that 2
percent of the diffuse X-ray background arises from the GB6-PMN sources.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9704043 [pdf] - 97005
Correlations Between the Cosmic X-ray and Microwave Backgrounds:
Constraints on a Cosmological Constant
Submitted: 1997-04-03
In universes with significant curvature or cosmological constant, cosmic
microwave background (CMB) anisotropies are created very recently via the
Rees-Sciama or integrated Sachs-Wolfe effects. This causes the CMB anisotropies
to become partially correlated with the local matter density (z < 4). We
examine the prospects of using the hard (2-10 keV) X-ray background as a probe
of the local density and the measured correlation between the HEAO1 A2 X-ray
survey and the 4-year COBE-DMR map to obtain a constraint on the cosmological
constant. The 95% confidence level upper limit on the cosmological constant is
\Omega_\Lambda \leq 0.5, assuming that the observed fluctuations in the X-ray
map result entirely from large scale structure. (This would also imply that the
X-rays trace matter with a bias factor of b_x = 5.6 \Omega_m^{0.53}.) This
bound is weakened considerably if a large portion of the X-ray fluctuations
arise from Poisson noise from unresolved sources. For example, if one assumes
that the X-ray bias is b_x = 2., then the 95% confidence level upper limit is
weaker, \Omega_\Lambda \leq 0.7. More stringent limits should be attainable
with data from the next generation of CMB and X-ray background maps.