Normalized to: Booth, C.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1811.12907 [pdf] - 1973647
GWTC-1: A Gravitational-Wave Transient Catalog of Compact Binary Mergers
Observed by LIGO and Virgo during the First and Second Observing Runs
The LIGO Scientific Collaboration;
the Virgo Collaboration;
Abbott, B. P.;
Abbott, R.;
Abbott, T. D.;
Abraham, S.;
Acernese, F.;
Ackley, K.;
Adams, C.;
Adhikari, R. X.;
Adya, V. B.;
Affeldt, C.;
Agathos, M.;
Agatsuma, K.;
Aggarwal, N.;
Aguiar, O. D.;
Aiello, L.;
Ain, A.;
Ajith, P.;
Allen, G.;
Allocca, A.;
Aloy, M. A.;
Altin, P. A.;
Amato, A.;
Ananyeva, A.;
Anderson, S. B.;
Anderson, W. G.;
Angelova, S. V.;
Antier, S.;
Appert, S.;
Arai, K.;
Araya, M. C.;
Areeda, J. S.;
Arène, M.;
Arnaud, N.;
Arun, K. G.;
Ascenzi, S.;
Ashton, G.;
Aston, S. M.;
Astone, P.;
Aubin, F.;
Aufmuth, P.;
AultONeal, K.;
Austin, C.;
Avendano, V.;
Avila-Alvarez, A.;
Babak, S.;
Bacon, P.;
Badaracco, F.;
Bader, M. K. M.;
Bae, S.;
Baker, P. T.;
Baldaccini, F.;
Ballardin, G.;
Ballmer, S. W.;
Banagiri, S.;
Barayoga, J. C.;
Barclay, S. E.;
Barish, B. C.;
Barker, D.;
Barkett, K.;
Barnum, S.;
Barone, F.;
Barr, B.;
Barsotti, L.;
Barsuglia, M.;
Barta, D.;
Bartlett, J.;
Bartos, I.;
Bassiri, R.;
Basti, A.;
Bawaj, M.;
Bayley, J. C.;
Bazzan, M.;
Bécsy, B.;
Bejger, M.;
Belahcene, I.;
Bell, A. S.;
Beniwal, D.;
Berger, B. K.;
Bergmann, G.;
Bernuzzi, S.;
Bero, J. J.;
Berry, C. P. L.;
Bersanetti, D.;
Bertolini, A.;
Betzwieser, J.;
Bhandare, R.;
Bidler, J.;
Bilenko, I. A.;
Bilgili, S. A.;
Billingsley, G.;
Birch, J.;
Birney, R.;
Birnholtz, O.;
Biscans, S.;
Biscoveanu, S.;
Bisht, A.;
Bitossi, M.;
Bizouard, M. A.;
Blackburn, J. K.;
Blackman, J.;
Blair, C. D.;
Blair, D. G.;
Blair, R. M.;
Bloemen, S.;
Bode, N.;
Boer, M.;
Boetzel, Y.;
Bogaert, G.;
Bondu, F.;
Bonilla, E.;
Bonnand, R.;
Booker, P.;
Boom, B. A.;
Booth, C. D.;
Bork, R.;
Boschi, V.;
Bose, S.;
Bossie, K.;
Bossilkov, V.;
Bosveld, J.;
Bouffanais, Y.;
Bozzi, A.;
Bradaschia, C.;
Brady, P. R.;
Bramley, A.;
Branchesi, M.;
Brau, J. E.;
Briant, T.;
Briggs, J. H.;
Brighenti, F.;
Brillet, A.;
Brinkmann, M.;
Brisson, V.;
Brockill, P.;
Brooks, A. F.;
Brown, D. D.;
Brunett, S.;
Buikema, A.;
Bulik, T.;
Bulten, H. J.;
Buonanno, A.;
Buskulic, D.;
Rosell, M. J. Bustamante;
Buy, C.;
Byer, R. L.;
Cabero, M.;
Cadonati, L.;
Cagnoli, G.;
Cahillane, C.;
Bustillo, J. Calderón;
Callister, T. A.;
Calloni, E.;
Camp, J. B.;
Campbell, W. A.;
Canepa, M.;
Cannon, K. C.;
Cao, H.;
Cao, J.;
Capocasa, E.;
Carbognani, F.;
Caride, S.;
Carney, M. F.;
Carullo, G.;
Diaz, J. Casanueva;
Casentini, C.;
Caudill, S.;
Cavaglià, M.;
Cavalier, F.;
Cavalieri, R.;
Cella, G.;
Cerdá-Durán, P.;
Cerretani, G.;
Cesarini, E.;
Chaibi, O.;
Chakravarti, K.;
Chamberlin, S. J.;
Chan, M.;
Chao, S.;
Charlton, P.;
Chase, E. A.;
Chassande-Mottin, E.;
Chatterjee, D.;
Chaturvedi, M.;
Chatziioannou, K.;
Cheeseboro, B. D.;
Chen, H. Y.;
Chen, X.;
Chen, Y.;
Cheng, H. -P.;
Cheong, C. K.;
Chia, H. Y.;
Chincarini, A.;
Chiummo, A.;
Cho, G.;
Cho, H. S.;
Cho, M.;
Christensen, N.;
Chu, Q.;
Chua, S.;
Chung, K. W.;
Chung, S.;
Ciani, G.;
Ciobanu, A. A.;
Ciolfi, R.;
Cipriano, F.;
Cirone, A.;
Clara, F.;
Clark, J. A.;
Clearwater, P.;
Cleva, F.;
Cocchieri, C.;
Coccia, E.;
Cohadon, P. -F.;
Cohen, D.;
Colgan, R.;
Colleoni, M.;
Collette, C. G.;
Collins, C.;
Cominsky, L. R.;
Constancio, M.;
Conti, L.;
Cooper, S. J.;
Corban, P.;
Corbitt, T. R.;
Cordero-Carrión, I.;
Corley, K. R.;
Cornish, N.;
Corsi, A.;
Cortese, S.;
Costa, C. A.;
Cotesta, R.;
Coughlin, M. W.;
Coughlin, S. B.;
Coulon, J. -P.;
Countryman, S. T.;
Couvares, P.;
Covas, P. B.;
Cowan, E. E.;
Coward, D. M.;
Cowart, M. J.;
Coyne, D. C.;
Coyne, R.;
Creighton, J. D. E.;
Creighton, T. D.;
Cripe, J.;
Croquette, M.;
Crowder, S. G.;
Cullen, T. J.;
Cumming, A.;
Cunningham, L.;
Cuoco, E.;
Canton, T. Dal;
Dálya, G.;
Danilishin, S. L.;
D'Antonio, S.;
Danzmann, K.;
Dasgupta, A.;
Costa, C. F. Da Silva;
Datrier, L. E. H.;
Dattilo, V.;
Dave, I.;
Davier, M.;
Davis, D.;
Daw, E. J.;
DeBra, D.;
Deenadayalan, M.;
Degallaix, J.;
De Laurentis, M.;
Deléglise, S.;
Del Pozzo, W.;
DeMarchi, L. M.;
Demos, N.;
Dent, T.;
De Pietri, R.;
Derby, J.;
De Rosa, R.;
De Rossi, C.;
DeSalvo, R.;
de Varona, O.;
Dhurandhar, S.;
Díaz, M. C.;
Dietrich, T.;
Di Fiore, L.;
Di Giovanni, M.;
Di Girolamo, T.;
Di Lieto, A.;
Ding, B.;
Di Pace, S.;
Di Palma, I.;
Di Renzo, F.;
Dmitriev, A.;
Doctor, Z.;
Donovan, F.;
Dooley, K. L.;
Doravari, S.;
Dorrington, I.;
Downes, T. P.;
Drago, M.;
Driggers, J. C.;
Du, Z.;
Ducoin, J. -G.;
Dupej, P.;
Dwyer, S. E.;
Easter, P. J.;
Edo, T. B.;
Edwards, M. C.;
Effler, A.;
Ehrens, P.;
Eichholz, J.;
Eikenberry, S. S.;
Eisenmann, M.;
Eisenstein, R. A.;
Essick, R. C.;
Estelles, H.;
Estevez, D.;
Etienne, Z. B.;
Etzel, T.;
Evans, M.;
Evans, T. M.;
Fafone, V.;
Fair, H.;
Fairhurst, S.;
Fan, X.;
Farinon, S.;
Farr, B.;
Farr, W. M.;
Fauchon-Jones, E. J.;
Favata, M.;
Fays, M.;
Fazio, M.;
Fee, C.;
Feicht, J.;
Fejer, M. M.;
Feng, F.;
Fernandez-Galiana, A.;
Ferrante, I.;
Ferreira, E. C.;
Ferreira, T. A.;
Ferrini, F.;
Fidecaro, F.;
Fiori, I.;
Fiorucci, D.;
Fishbach, M.;
Fisher, R. P.;
Fishner, J. M.;
Fitz-Axen, M.;
Flaminio, R.;
Fletcher, M.;
Flynn, E.;
Fong, H.;
Font, J. A.;
Forsyth, P. W. F.;
Fournier, J. -D.;
Frasca, S.;
Frasconi, F.;
Frei, Z.;
Freise, A.;
Frey, R.;
Frey, V.;
Fritschel, P.;
Frolov, V. V.;
Fulda, P.;
Fyffe, M.;
Gabbard, H. A.;
Gadre, B. U.;
Gaebel, S. M.;
Gair, J. R.;
Gammaitoni, L.;
Ganija, M. R.;
Gaonkar, S. G.;
Garcia, A.;
García-Quirós, C.;
Garufi, F.;
Gateley, B.;
Gaudio, S.;
Gaur, G.;
Gayathri, V.;
Gemme, G.;
Genin, E.;
Gennai, A.;
George, D.;
George, J.;
Gergely, L.;
Germain, V.;
Ghonge, S.;
Ghosh, Abhirup;
Ghosh, Archisman;
Ghosh, S.;
Giacomazzo, B.;
Giaime, J. A.;
Giardina, K. D.;
Giazotto, A.;
Gill, K.;
Giordano, G.;
Glover, L.;
Godwin, P.;
Goetz, E.;
Goetz, R.;
Goncharov, B.;
González, G.;
Castro, J. M. Gonzalez;
Gopakumar, A.;
Gorodetsky, M. L.;
Gossan, S. E.;
Gosselin, M.;
Gouaty, R.;
Grado, A.;
Graef, C.;
Granata, M.;
Grant, A.;
Gras, S.;
Grassia, P.;
Gray, C.;
Gray, R.;
Greco, G.;
Green, A. C.;
Green, R.;
Gretarsson, E. M.;
Groot, P.;
Grote, H.;
Grunewald, S.;
Gruning, P.;
Guidi, G. M.;
Gulati, H. K.;
Guo, Y.;
Gupta, A.;
Gupta, M. K.;
Gustafson, E. K.;
Gustafson, R.;
Haegel, L.;
Halim, O.;
Hall, B. R.;
Hall, E. D.;
Hamilton, E. Z.;
Hammond, G.;
Haney, M.;
Hanke, M. M.;
Hanks, J.;
Hanna, C.;
Hannam, M. D.;
Hannuksela, O. A.;
Hanson, J.;
Hardwick, T.;
Haris, K.;
Harms, J.;
Harry, G. M.;
Harry, I. W.;
Haster, C. -J.;
Haughian, K.;
Hayes, F. J.;
Healy, J.;
Heidmann, A.;
Heintze, M. C.;
Heitmann, H.;
Hello, P.;
Hemming, G.;
Hendry, M.;
Heng, I. S.;
Hennig, J.;
Heptonstall, A. W.;
Vivanco, Francisco Hernandez;
Heurs, M.;
Hild, S.;
Hinderer, T.;
Hoak, D.;
Hochheim, S.;
Hofman, D.;
Holgado, A. M.;
Holland, N. A.;
Holt, K.;
Holz, D. E.;
Hopkins, P.;
Horst, C.;
Hough, J.;
Howell, E. J.;
Hoy, C. G.;
Hreibi, A.;
Huang, Y.;
Huerta, E. A.;
Huet, D.;
Hughey, B.;
Hulko, M.;
Husa, S.;
Huttner, S. H.;
Huynh-Dinh, T.;
Idzkowski, B.;
Iess, A.;
Ingram, C.;
Inta, R.;
Intini, G.;
Irwin, B.;
Isa, H. N.;
Isac, J. -M.;
Isi, M.;
Iyer, B. R.;
Izumi, K.;
Jacqmin, T.;
Jadhav, S. J.;
Jani, K.;
Janthalur, N. N.;
Jaranowski, P.;
Jenkins, A. C.;
Jiang, J.;
Johnson, D. S.;
Johnson-McDaniel, N. K.;
Jones, A. W.;
Jones, D. I.;
Jones, R.;
Jonker, R. J. G.;
Ju, L.;
Junker, J.;
Kalaghatgi, C. V.;
Kalogera, V.;
Kamai, B.;
Kandhasamy, S.;
Kang, G.;
Kanner, J. B.;
Kapadia, S. J.;
Karki, S.;
Karvinen, K. S.;
Kashyap, R.;
Kasprzack, M.;
Katsanevas, S.;
Katsavounidis, E.;
Katzman, W.;
Kaufer, S.;
Kawabe, K.;
Keerthana, N. V.;
Kéfélian, F.;
Keitel, D.;
Kennedy, R.;
Key, J. S.;
Khalili, F. Y.;
Khan, H.;
Khan, I.;
Khan, S.;
Khan, Z.;
Khazanov, E. A.;
Khursheed, M.;
Kijbunchoo, N.;
Kim, Chunglee;
Kim, J. C.;
Kim, K.;
Kim, W.;
Kim, W. S.;
Kim, Y. -M.;
Kimball, C.;
King, E. J.;
King, P. J.;
Kinley-Hanlon, M.;
Kirchhoff, R.;
Kissel, J. S.;
Kleybolte, L.;
Klika, J. H.;
Klimenko, S.;
Knowles, T. D.;
Koch, P.;
Koehlenbeck, S. M.;
Koekoek, G.;
Koley, S.;
Kondrashov, V.;
Kontos, A.;
Koper, N.;
Korobko, M.;
Korth, W. Z.;
Kowalska, I.;
Kozak, D. B.;
Kringel, V.;
Krishnendu, N.;
Królak, A.;
Kuehn, G.;
Kumar, A.;
Kumar, P.;
Kumar, R.;
Kumar, S.;
Kuo, L.;
Kutynia, A.;
Kwang, S.;
Lackey, B. D.;
Lai, K. H.;
Lam, T. L.;
Landry, M.;
Lane, B. B.;
Lang, R. N.;
Lange, J.;
Lantz, B.;
Lanza, R. K.;
Lartaux-Vollard, A.;
Lasky, P. D.;
Laxen, M.;
Lazzarini, A.;
Lazzaro, C.;
Leaci, P.;
Leavey, S.;
Lecoeuche, Y. K.;
Lee, C. H.;
Lee, H. K.;
Lee, H. M.;
Lee, H. W.;
Lee, J.;
Lee, K.;
Lehmann, J.;
Lenon, A.;
Leroy, N.;
Letendre, N.;
Levin, Y.;
Li, J.;
Li, K. J. L.;
Li, T. G. F.;
Li, X.;
Lin, F.;
Linde, F.;
Linker, S. D.;
Littenberg, T. B.;
Liu, J.;
Liu, X.;
Lo, R. K. L.;
Lockerbie, N. A.;
London, L. T.;
Longo, A.;
Lorenzini, M.;
Loriette, V.;
Lormand, M.;
Losurdo, G.;
Lough, J. D.;
Lousto, C. O.;
Lovelace, G.;
Lower, M. E.;
Lück, H.;
Lumaca, D.;
Lundgren, A. P.;
Lynch, R.;
Ma, Y.;
Macas, R.;
Macfoy, S.;
MacInnis, M.;
Macleod, D. M.;
Macquet, A.;
Magaña-Sandoval, F.;
Zertuche, L. Magaña;
Magee, R. M.;
Majorana, E.;
Maksimovic, I.;
Malik, A.;
Man, N.;
Mandic, V.;
Mangano, V.;
Mansell, G. L.;
Manske, M.;
Mantovani, M.;
Marchesoni, F.;
Marion, F.;
Márka, S.;
Márka, Z.;
Markakis, C.;
Markosyan, A. S.;
Markowitz, A.;
Maros, E.;
Marquina, A.;
Marsat, S.;
Martelli, F.;
Martin, I. W.;
Martin, R. M.;
Martynov, D. V.;
Mason, K.;
Massera, E.;
Masserot, A.;
Massinger, T. J.;
Masso-Reid, M.;
Mastrogiovanni, S.;
Matas, A.;
Matichard, F.;
Matone, L.;
Mavalvala, N.;
Mazumder, N.;
McCann, J. J.;
McCarthy, R.;
McClelland, D. E.;
McCormick, S.;
McCuller, L.;
McGuire, S. C.;
McIver, J.;
McManus, D. J.;
McRae, T.;
McWilliams, S. T.;
Meacher, D.;
Meadors, G. D.;
Mehmet, M.;
Mehta, A. K.;
Meidam, J.;
Melatos, A.;
Mendell, G.;
Mercer, R. A.;
Mereni, L.;
Merilh, E. L.;
Merzougui, M.;
Meshkov, S.;
Messenger, C.;
Messick, C.;
Metzdorff, R.;
Meyers, P. M.;
Miao, H.;
Michel, C.;
Middleton, H.;
Mikhailov, E. E.;
Milano, L.;
Miller, A. L.;
Miller, A.;
Millhouse, M.;
Mills, J. C.;
Milovich-Goff, M. C.;
Minazzoli, O.;
Minenkov, Y.;
Mishkin, A.;
Mishra, C.;
Mistry, T.;
Mitra, S.;
Mitrofanov, V. P.;
Mitselmakher, G.;
Mittleman, R.;
Mo, G.;
Moffa, D.;
Mogushi, K.;
Mohapatra, S. R. P.;
Montani, M.;
Moore, C. J.;
Moraru, D.;
Moreno, G.;
Morisaki, S.;
Mours, B.;
Mow-Lowry, C. M.;
Mukherjee, Arunava;
Mukherjee, D.;
Mukherjee, S.;
Mukund, N.;
Mullavey, A.;
Munch, J.;
Muñiz, E. A.;
Muratore, M.;
Murray, P. G.;
Nagar, A.;
Nardecchia, I.;
Naticchioni, L.;
Nayak, R. K.;
Neilson, J.;
Nelemans, G.;
Nelson, T. J. N.;
Nery, M.;
Neunzert, A.;
Ng, K. Y.;
Ng, S.;
Nguyen, P.;
Nichols, D.;
Nielsen, A. B.;
Nissanke, S.;
Nitz, A.;
Nocera, F.;
North, C.;
Nuttall, L. K.;
Obergaulinger, M.;
Oberling, J.;
O'Brien, B. D.;
O'Dea, G. D.;
Ogin, G. H.;
Oh, J. J.;
Oh, S. H.;
Ohme, F.;
Ohta, H.;
Okada, M. A.;
Oliver, M.;
Oppermann, P.;
Oram, Richard J.;
O'Reilly, B.;
Ormiston, R. G.;
Ortega, L. F.;
O'Shaughnessy, R.;
Ossokine, S.;
Ottaway, D. J.;
Overmier, H.;
Owen, B. J.;
Pace, A. E.;
Pagano, G.;
Page, M. A.;
Pai, A.;
Pai, S. A.;
Palamos, J. R.;
Palashov, O.;
Palomba, C.;
Pal-Singh, A.;
Pan, Huang-Wei;
Pang, B.;
Pang, P. T. H.;
Pankow, C.;
Pannarale, F.;
Pant, B. C.;
Paoletti, F.;
Paoli, A.;
Papa, M. A.;
Parida, A.;
Parker, W.;
Pascucci, D.;
Pasqualetti, A.;
Passaquieti, R.;
Passuello, D.;
Patil, M.;
Patricelli, B.;
Pearlstone, B. L.;
Pedersen, C.;
Pedraza, M.;
Pedurand, R.;
Pele, A.;
Penn, S.;
Perego, A.;
Perez, C. J.;
Perreca, A.;
Pfeiffer, H. P.;
Phelps, M.;
Phukon, K. S.;
Piccinni, O. J.;
Pichot, M.;
Piergiovanni, F.;
Pillant, G.;
Pinard, L.;
Pirello, M.;
Pitkin, M.;
Poggiani, R.;
Pong, D. Y. T.;
Ponrathnam, S.;
Popolizio, P.;
Porter, E. K.;
Powell, J.;
Prajapati, A. K.;
Prasad, J.;
Prasai, K.;
Prasanna, R.;
Pratten, G.;
Prestegard, T.;
Privitera, S.;
Prodi, G. A.;
Prokhorov, L. G.;
Puncken, O.;
Punturo, M.;
Puppo, P.;
Pürrer, M.;
Qi, H.;
Quetschke, V.;
Quinonez, P. J.;
Quintero, E. A.;
Quitzow-James, R.;
Raab, F. J.;
Radkins, H.;
Radulescu, N.;
Raffai, P.;
Raja, S.;
Rajan, C.;
Rajbhandari, B.;
Rakhmanov, M.;
Ramirez, K. E.;
Ramos-Buades, A.;
Rana, Javed;
Rao, K.;
Rapagnani, P.;
Raymond, V.;
Razzano, M.;
Read, J.;
Regimbau, T.;
Rei, L.;
Reid, S.;
Reitze, D. H.;
Ren, W.;
Ricci, F.;
Richardson, C. J.;
Richardson, J. W.;
Ricker, P. M.;
Riemenschneider, G. M.;
Riles, K.;
Rizzo, M.;
Robertson, N. A.;
Robie, R.;
Robinet, F.;
Rocchi, A.;
Rolland, L.;
Rollins, J. G.;
Roma, V. J.;
Romanelli, M.;
Romano, R.;
Romel, C. L.;
Romie, J. H.;
Rose, K.;
Rosińska, D.;
Rosofsky, S. G.;
Ross, M. P.;
Rowan, S.;
Rüdiger, A.;
Ruggi, P.;
Rutins, G.;
Ryan, K.;
Sachdev, S.;
Sadecki, T.;
Sakellariadou, M.;
Salafia, O.;
Salconi, L.;
Saleem, M.;
Salemi, F.;
Samajdar, A.;
Sammut, L.;
Sanchez, E. J.;
Sanchez, L. E.;
Sanchis-Gual, N.;
Sandberg, V.;
Sanders, J. R.;
Santiago, K. A.;
Sarin, N.;
Sassolas, B.;
Sathyaprakash, B. S.;
Saulson, P. R.;
Sauter, O.;
Savage, R. L.;
Schale, P.;
Scheel, M.;
Scheuer, J.;
Schmidt, P.;
Schnabel, R.;
Schofield, R. M. S.;
Schönbeck, A.;
Schreiber, E.;
Schulte, B. W.;
Schutz, B. F.;
Schwalbe, S. G.;
Scott, J.;
Scott, S. M.;
Seidel, E.;
Sellers, D.;
Sengupta, A. S.;
Sennett, N.;
Sentenac, D.;
Sequino, V.;
Sergeev, A.;
Setyawati, Y.;
Shaddock, D. A.;
Shaffer, T.;
Shahriar, M. S.;
Shaner, M. B.;
Shao, L.;
Sharma, P.;
Shawhan, P.;
Shen, H.;
Shink, R.;
Shoemaker, D. H.;
Shoemaker, D. M.;
ShyamSundar, S.;
Siellez, K.;
Sieniawska, M.;
Sigg, D.;
Silva, A. D.;
Singer, L. P.;
Singh, N.;
Singhal, A.;
Sintes, A. M.;
Sitmukhambetov, S.;
Skliris, V.;
Slagmolen, B. J. J.;
Slaven-Blair, T. J.;
Smith, J. R.;
Smith, R. J. E.;
Somala, S.;
Son, E. J.;
Sorazu, B.;
Sorrentino, F.;
Souradeep, T.;
Sowell, E.;
Spencer, A. P.;
Srivastava, A. K.;
Srivastava, V.;
Staats, K.;
Stachie, C.;
Standke, M.;
Steer, D. A.;
Steinke, M.;
Steinlechner, J.;
Steinlechner, S.;
Steinmeyer, D.;
Stevenson, S. P.;
Stocks, D.;
Stone, R.;
Stops, D. J.;
Strain, K. A.;
Stratta, G.;
Strigin, S. E.;
Strunk, A.;
Sturani, R.;
Stuver, A. L.;
Sudhir, V.;
Summerscales, T. Z.;
Sun, L.;
Sunil, S.;
Suresh, J.;
Sutton, P. J.;
Swinkels, B. L.;
Szczepańczyk, M. J.;
Tacca, M.;
Tait, S. C.;
Talbot, C.;
Talukder, D.;
Tanner, D. B.;
Tápai, M.;
Taracchini, A.;
Tasson, J. D.;
Taylor, R.;
Thies, F.;
Thomas, M.;
Thomas, P.;
Thondapu, S. R.;
Thorne, K. A.;
Thrane, E.;
Tiwari, Shubhanshu;
Tiwari, Srishti;
Tiwari, V.;
Toland, K.;
Tonelli, M.;
Tornasi, Z.;
Torres-Forné, A.;
Torrie, C. I.;
Töyrä, D.;
Travasso, F.;
Traylor, G.;
Tringali, M. C.;
Trovato, A.;
Trozzo, L.;
Trudeau, R.;
Tsang, K. W.;
Tse, M.;
Tso, R.;
Tsukada, L.;
Tsuna, D.;
Tuyenbayev, D.;
Ueno, K.;
Ugolini, D.;
Unnikrishnan, C. S.;
Urban, A. L.;
Usman, S. A.;
Vahlbruch, H.;
Vajente, G.;
Valdes, G.;
van Bakel, N.;
van Beuzekom, M.;
Brand, J. F. J. van den;
Broeck, C. Van Den;
Vander-Hyde, D. C.;
van Heijningen, J. V.;
van der Schaaf, L.;
van Veggel, A. A.;
Vardaro, M.;
Varma, V.;
Vass, S.;
Vasúth, M.;
Vecchio, A.;
Vedovato, G.;
Veitch, J.;
Veitch, P. J.;
Venkateswara, K.;
Venugopalan, G.;
Verkindt, D.;
Vetrano, F.;
Viceré, A.;
Viets, A. D.;
Vine, D. J.;
Vinet, J. -Y.;
Vitale, S.;
Vo, T.;
Vocca, H.;
Vorvick, C.;
Vyatchanin, S. P.;
Wade, A. R.;
Wade, L. E.;
Wade, M.;
Walet, R.;
Walker, M.;
Wallace, L.;
Walsh, S.;
Wang, G.;
Wang, H.;
Wang, J. Z.;
Wang, W. H.;
Wang, Y. F.;
Ward, R. L.;
Warden, Z. A.;
Warner, J.;
Was, M.;
Watchi, J.;
Weaver, B.;
Wei, L. -W.;
Weinert, M.;
Weinstein, A. J.;
Weiss, R.;
Wellmann, F.;
Wen, L.;
Wessel, E. K.;
Weßels, P.;
Westhouse, J. W.;
Wette, K.;
Whelan, J. T.;
White, L. V.;
Whiting, B. F.;
Whittle, C.;
Wilken, D. M.;
Williams, D.;
Williamson, A. R.;
Willis, J. L.;
Willke, B.;
Wimmer, M. H.;
Winkler, W.;
Wipf, C. C.;
Wittel, H.;
Woan, G.;
Woehler, J.;
Wofford, J. K.;
Worden, J.;
Wright, J. L.;
Wu, D. S.;
Wysocki, D. M.;
Xiao, L.;
Yamamoto, H.;
Yancey, C. C.;
Yang, L.;
Yap, M. J.;
Yazback, M.;
Yeeles, D. W.;
Yu, Hang;
Yu, Haocun;
Yuen, S. H. R.;
Yvert, M.;
Zadrożny, A. K.;
Zanolin, M.;
Zappa, F.;
Zelenova, T.;
Zendri, J. -P.;
Zevin, M.;
Zhang, J.;
Zhang, L.;
Zhang, T.;
Zhao, C.;
Zhou, M.;
Zhou, Z.;
Zhu, X. J.;
Zimmerman, A. B.;
Zlochower, Y.;
Zucker, M. E.;
Zweizig, J.
Submitted: 2018-11-30, last modified: 2019-10-04
We present the results from three gravitational-wave searches for coalescing
compact binaries with component masses above 1$\mathrm{M}_\odot$ during the
first and second observing runs of the Advanced gravitational-wave detector
network. During the first observing run (O1), from September $12^\mathrm{th}$,
2015 to January $19^\mathrm{th}$, 2016, gravitational waves from three binary
black hole mergers were detected. The second observing run (O2), which ran from
November $30^\mathrm{th}$, 2016 to August $25^\mathrm{th}$, 2017, saw the first
detection of gravitational waves from a binary neutron star inspiral, in
addition to the observation of gravitational waves from a total of seven binary
black hole mergers, four of which we report here for the first time: GW170729,
GW170809, GW170818 and GW170823. For all significant gravitational-wave events,
we provide estimates of the source properties. The detected binary black holes
have total masses between $18.6_{-0.7}^{+3.2}\mathrm{M}_\odot$, and
$84.4_{-11.1}^{+15.8} \mathrm{M}_\odot$, and range in distance between
$320_{-110}^{+120}$ Mpc and $2840_{-1360}^{+1400}$ Mpc. No neutron star - black
hole mergers were detected. In addition to highly significant
gravitational-wave events, we also provide a list of marginal event candidates
with an estimated false alarm rate less than 1 per 30 days. From these results
over the first two observing runs, which include approximately one
gravitational-wave detection per 15 days of data searched, we infer merger
rates at the 90% confidence intervals of $110\, -\, 3840$
$\mathrm{Gpc}^{-3}\,\mathrm{y}^{-1}$ for binary neutron stars and $9.7\, -\,
101$ $\mathrm{Gpc}^{-3}\,\mathrm{y}^{-1}$ for binary black holes assuming fixed
population distributions, and determine a neutron star - black hole merger rate
90% upper limit of $610$ $\mathrm{Gpc}^{-3}\,\mathrm{y}^{-1}$.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1805.11579 [pdf] - 1820124
Properties of the binary neutron star merger GW170817
The LIGO Scientific Collaboration;
the Virgo Collaboration;
Abbott, B. P.;
Abbott, R.;
Abbott, T. D.;
Acernese, F.;
Ackley, K.;
Adams, C.;
Adams, T.;
Addesso, P.;
Adhikari, R. X.;
Adya, V. B.;
Affeldt, C.;
Agarwal, B.;
Agathos, M.;
Agatsuma, K.;
Aggarwal, N.;
Aguiar, O. D.;
Aiello, L.;
Ain, A.;
Ajith, P.;
Allen, B.;
Allen, G.;
Allocca, A.;
Aloy, M. A.;
Altin, P. A.;
Amato, A.;
Ananyeva, A.;
Anderson, S. B.;
Anderson, W. G.;
Angelova, S. V.;
Antier, S.;
Appert, S.;
Arai, K.;
Araya, M. C.;
Areeda, J. S.;
Ar`ene, M.;
Arnaud, N.;
Arun, K. G.;
Ascenzi, S.;
Ashton, G.;
Ast, M.;
Aston, S. M.;
Astone, P.;
Atallah, D. V.;
Aubin, F.;
Aufmuth, P.;
Aulbert, C.;
AultONeal, K.;
Austin, C.;
Avila-Alvarez, A.;
Babak, S.;
Bacon, P.;
Badaracco, F.;
Bader, M. K. M.;
Bae, S.;
Baker, P. T.;
Baldaccini, F.;
Ballardin, G.;
Ballmer, S. W.;
Banagiri, S.;
Barayoga, J. C.;
Barclay, S. E.;
Barish, B. C.;
Barker, D.;
Barkett, K.;
Barnum, S.;
Barone, F.;
Barr, B.;
Barsotti, L.;
Barsuglia, M.;
Barta, D.;
Bartlett, J.;
Bartos, I.;
Bassiri, R.;
Basti, A.;
Batch, J. C.;
Bawaj, M.;
Bayley, J. C.;
Bazzan, M.;
B'ecsy, B.;
Beer, C.;
Bejger, M.;
Belahcene, I.;
Bell, A. S.;
Beniwal, D.;
Bensch, M.;
Berger, B. K.;
Bergmann, G.;
Bernuzzi, S.;
Bero, J. J.;
Berry, C. P. L.;
Bersanetti, D.;
Bertolini, A.;
Betzwieser, J.;
Bhandare, R.;
Bilenko, I. A.;
Bilgili, S. A.;
Billingsley, G.;
Billman, C. R.;
Birch, J.;
Birney, R.;
Birnholtz, O.;
Biscans, S.;
Biscoveanu, S.;
Bisht, A.;
Bitossi, M.;
Bizouard, M. A.;
Blackburn, J. K.;
Blackman, J.;
Blair, C. D.;
Blair, D. G.;
Blair, R. M.;
Bloemen, S.;
Bock, O.;
Bode, N.;
Boer, M.;
Boetzel, Y.;
Bogaert, G.;
Bohe, A.;
Bondu, F.;
Bonilla, E.;
Bonnand, R.;
Booker, P.;
Boom, B. A.;
Booth, C. D.;
Bork, R.;
Boschi, V.;
Bose, S.;
Bossie, K.;
Bossilkov, V.;
Bosveld, J.;
Bouffanais, Y.;
Bozzi, A.;
Bradaschia, C.;
Brady, P. R.;
Bramley, A.;
Branchesi, M.;
Brau, J. E.;
Briant, T.;
Brighenti, F.;
Brillet, A.;
Brinkmann, M.;
Brisson, V.;
Brockill, P.;
Brooks, A. F.;
Brown, D. D.;
Brunett, S.;
Buchanan, C. C.;
Buikema, A.;
Bulik, T.;
Bulten, H. J.;
Buonanno, A.;
Buskulic, D.;
Buy, C.;
Byer, R. L.;
Cabero, M.;
Cadonati, L.;
Cagnoli, G.;
Cahillane, C.;
Bustillo, J. Calder'on;
Callister, T. A.;
Calloni, E.;
Camp, J. B.;
Canepa, M.;
Canizares, P.;
Cannon, K. C.;
Cao, H.;
Cao, J.;
Capano, C. D.;
Capocasa, E.;
Carbognani, F.;
Caride, S.;
Carney, M. F.;
Carullo, G.;
Diaz, J. Casanueva;
Casentini, C.;
Caudill, S.;
Cavagli`a, M.;
Cavalier, F.;
Cavalieri, R.;
Cella, G.;
Cepeda, C. B.;
Cerd'a-Dur'an, P.;
Cerretani, G.;
Cesarini, E.;
Chaibi, O.;
Chamberlin, S. J.;
Chan, M.;
Chao, S.;
Charlton, P.;
Chase, E.;
Chassande-Mottin, E.;
Chatterjee, D.;
Chatziioannou, K.;
Cheeseboro, B. D.;
Chen, H. Y.;
Chen, X.;
Chen, Y.;
Cheng, H. -P.;
Chia, H. Y.;
Chincarini, A.;
Chiummo, A.;
Chmiel, T.;
Cho, H. S.;
Cho, M.;
Chow, J. H.;
Christensen, N.;
Chu, Q.;
Chua, A. J. K.;
Chua, S.;
Chung, K. W.;
Chung, S.;
Ciani, G.;
Ciobanu, A. A.;
Ciolfi, R.;
Cipriano, F.;
Cirelli, C. E.;
Cirone, A.;
Clara, F.;
Clark, J. A.;
Clearwater, P.;
Cleva, F.;
Cocchieri, C.;
Coccia, E.;
Cohadon, P. -F.;
Cohen, D.;
Colla, A.;
Collette, C. G.;
Collins, C.;
Cominsky, L. R.;
Constancio, M.;
Conti, L.;
Cooper, S. J.;
Corban, P.;
Corbitt, T. R.;
Cordero-Carri'on, I.;
Corley, K. R.;
Cornish, N.;
Corsi, A.;
Cortese, S.;
Costa, C. A.;
Cotesta, R.;
Coughlin, M. W.;
Coughlin, S. B.;
Coulon, J. -P.;
Countryman, S. T.;
Couvares, P.;
Covas, P. B.;
Cowan, E. E.;
Coward, D. M.;
Cowart, M. J.;
Coyne, D. C.;
Coyne, R.;
Creighton, J. D. E.;
Creighton, T. D.;
Cripe, J.;
Crowder, S. G.;
Cullen, T. J.;
Cumming, A.;
Cunningham, L.;
Cuoco, E.;
Canton, T. Dal;
D'alya, G.;
Danilishin, S. L.;
D'Antonio, S.;
Danzmann, K.;
Dasgupta, A.;
Costa, C. F. Da Silva;
Dattilo, V.;
Dave, I.;
Davier, M.;
Davis, D.;
Daw, E. J.;
Day, B.;
DeBra, D.;
Deenadayalan, M.;
Degallaix, J.;
De Laurentis, M.;
Del'eglise, S.;
Del Pozzo, W.;
Demos, N.;
Denker, T.;
Dent, T.;
De Pietri, R.;
Derby, J.;
Dergachev, V.;
De Rosa, R.;
De Rossi, C.;
DeSalvo, R.;
de Varona, O.;
Dhurandhar, S.;
D'iaz, M. C.;
Dietrich, T.;
Di Fiore, L.;
Di Giovanni, M.;
Di Girolamo, T.;
Di Lieto, A.;
Ding, B.;
Di Pace, S.;
Di Palma, I.;
Di Renzo, F.;
Dmitriev, A.;
Doctor, Z.;
Dolique, V.;
Donovan, F.;
Dooley, K. L.;
Doravari, S.;
Dorrington, I.;
'Alvarez, M. Dovale;
Downes, T. P.;
Drago, M.;
Dreissigacker, C.;
Driggers, J. C.;
Du, Z.;
Dudi, R.;
Dupej, P.;
Dwyer, S. E.;
Easter, P. J.;
Edo, T. B.;
Edwards, M. C.;
Effler, A.;
Eggenstein, H. -B.;
Ehrens, P.;
Eichholz, J.;
Eikenberry, S. S.;
Eisenmann, M.;
Eisenstein, R. A.;
Essick, R. C.;
Estelles, H.;
Estevez, D.;
Etienne, Z. B.;
Etzel, T.;
Evans, M.;
Evans, T. M.;
Fafone, V.;
Fair, H.;
Fairhurst, S.;
Fan, X.;
Farinon, S.;
Farr, B.;
Farr, W. M.;
Fauchon-Jones, E. J.;
Favata, M.;
Fays, M.;
Fee, C.;
Fehrmann, H.;
Feicht, J.;
Fejer, M. M.;
Feng, F.;
Fernandez-Galiana, A.;
Ferrante, I.;
Ferreira, E. C.;
Ferrini, F.;
Fidecaro, F.;
Fiori, I.;
Fiorucci, D.;
Fishbach, M.;
Fisher, R. P.;
Fishner, J. M.;
Fitz-Axen, M.;
Flaminio, R.;
Fletcher, M.;
Fong, H.;
Font, J. A.;
Forsyth, P. W. F.;
Forsyth, S. S.;
Fournier, J. -D.;
Frasca, S.;
Frasconi, F.;
Frei, Z.;
Freise, A.;
Frey, R.;
Frey, V.;
Fritschel, P.;
Frolov, V. V.;
Fulda, P.;
Fyffe, M.;
Gabbard, H. A.;
Gadre, B. U.;
Gaebel, S. M.;
Gair, J. R.;
Gammaitoni, L.;
Ganija, M. R.;
Gaonkar, S. G.;
Garcia, A.;
Garc'ia-Quir'os, C.;
Garufi, F.;
Gateley, B.;
Gaudio, S.;
Gaur, G.;
Gayathri, V.;
Gemme, G.;
Genin, E.;
Gennai, A.;
George, D.;
George, J.;
Gergely, L.;
Germain, V.;
Ghonge, S.;
Ghosh, Abhirup;
Ghosh, Archisman;
Ghosh, S.;
Giacomazzo, B.;
Giaime, J. A.;
Giardina, K. D.;
Giazotto, A.;
Gill, K.;
Giordano, G.;
Glover, L.;
Goetz, E.;
Goetz, R.;
Goncharov, B.;
Gonz'alez, G.;
Castro, J. M. Gonzalez;
Gopakumar, A.;
Gorodetsky, M. L.;
Gossan, S. E.;
Gosselin, M.;
Gouaty, R.;
Grado, A.;
Graef, C.;
Granata, M.;
Grant, A.;
Gras, S.;
Gray, C.;
Greco, G.;
Green, A. C.;
Green, R.;
Gretarsson, E. M.;
Groot, P.;
Grote, H.;
Grunewald, S.;
Gruning, P.;
Guidi, G. M.;
Gulati, H. K.;
Guo, X.;
Gupta, A.;
Gupta, M. K.;
Gushwa, K. E.;
Gustafson, E. K.;
Gustafson, R.;
Halim, O.;
Hall, B. R.;
Hall, E. D.;
Hamilton, E. Z.;
Hamilton, H. F.;
Hammond, G.;
Haney, M.;
Hanke, M. M.;
Hanks, J.;
Hanna, C.;
Hannam, M. D.;
Hannuksela, O. A.;
Hanson, J.;
Hardwick, T.;
Harms, J.;
Harry, G. M.;
Harry, I. W.;
Hart, M. J.;
Haster, C. -J.;
Haughian, K.;
Healy, J.;
Heidmann, A.;
Heintze, M. C.;
Heitmann, H.;
Hello, P.;
Hemming, G.;
Hendry, M.;
Heng, I. S.;
Hennig, J.;
Heptonstall, A. W.;
Hernandez, F. J.;
Heurs, M.;
Hild, S.;
Hinderer, T.;
Hoak, D.;
Hochheim, S.;
Hofman, D.;
Holland, N. A.;
Holt, K.;
Holz, D. E.;
Hopkins, P.;
Horst, C.;
Hough, J.;
Houston, E. A.;
Howell, E. J.;
Hreibi, A.;
Huerta, E. A.;
Huet, D.;
Hughey, B.;
Hulko, M.;
Husa, S.;
Huttner, S. H.;
Huynh-Dinh, T.;
Iess, A.;
Indik, N.;
Ingram, C.;
Inta, R.;
Intini, G.;
Isa, H. N.;
Isac, J. -M.;
Isi, M.;
Iyer, B. R.;
Izumi, K.;
Jacqmin, T.;
Jani, K.;
Jaranowski, P.;
Johnson, D. S.;
Johnson, W. W.;
Jones, D. I.;
Jones, R.;
Jonker, R. J. G.;
Ju, L.;
Junker, J.;
Kalaghatgi, C. V.;
Kalogera, V.;
Kamai, B.;
Kandhasamy, S.;
Kang, G.;
Kanner, J. B.;
Kapadia, S. J.;
Karki, S.;
Karvinen, K. S.;
Kasprzack, M.;
Kastaun, W.;
Katolik, M.;
Katsanevas, S.;
Katsavounidis, E.;
Katzman, W.;
Kaufer, S.;
Kawabe, K.;
Keerthana, N. V.;
K'ef'elian, F.;
Keitel, D.;
Kemball, A. J.;
Kennedy, R.;
Key, J. S.;
Khalili, F. Y.;
Khamesra, B.;
Khan, H.;
Khan, I.;
Khan, S.;
Khan, Z.;
Khazanov, E. A.;
Kijbunchoo, N.;
Kim, Chunglee;
Kim, J. C.;
Kim, K.;
Kim, W.;
Kim, W. S.;
Kim, Y. -M.;
King, E. J.;
King, P. J.;
Kinley-Hanlon, M.;
Kirchhoff, R.;
Kissel, J. S.;
Kleybolte, L.;
Klimenko, S.;
Knowles, T. D.;
Koch, P.;
Koehlenbeck, S. M.;
Koley, S.;
Kondrashov, V.;
Kontos, A.;
Korobko, M.;
Korth, W. Z.;
Kowalska, I.;
Kozak, D. B.;
Kr"amer, C.;
Kringel, V.;
Krishnan, B.;
Kr'olak, A.;
Kuehn, G.;
Kumar, P.;
Kumar, R.;
Kumar, S.;
Kuo, L.;
Kutynia, A.;
Kwang, S.;
Lackey, B. D.;
Lai, K. H.;
Landry, M.;
Landry, P.;
Lang, R. N.;
Lange, J.;
Lantz, B.;
Lanza, R. K.;
Lartaux-Vollard, A.;
Lasky, P. D.;
Laxen, M.;
Lazzarini, A.;
Lazzaro, C.;
Leaci, P.;
Leavey, S.;
Lee, C. H.;
Lee, H. K.;
Lee, H. M.;
Lee, H. W.;
Lee, K.;
Lehmann, J.;
Lenon, A.;
Leonardi, M.;
Leroy, N.;
Letendre, N.;
Levin, Y.;
Li, J.;
Li, T. G. F.;
Li, X.;
Linker, S. D.;
Littenberg, T. B.;
Liu, J.;
Liu, X.;
Lo, R. K. L.;
Lockerbie, N. A.;
London, L. T.;
Longo, A.;
Lorenzini, M.;
Loriette, V.;
Lormand, M.;
Losurdo, G.;
Lough, J. D.;
Lousto, C. O.;
Lovelace, G.;
L"uck, H.;
Lumaca, D.;
Lundgren, A. P.;
Lynch, R.;
Ma, Y.;
Macas, R.;
Macfoy, S.;
Machenschalk, B.;
MacInnis, M.;
Macleod, D. M.;
Hernandez, I. Magaña;
Magaña-Sandoval, F.;
Zertuche, L. Magaña;
Magee, R. M.;
Majorana, E.;
Maksimovic, I.;
Man, N.;
Mandic, V.;
Mangano, V.;
Mansell, G. L.;
Manske, M.;
Mantovani, M.;
Marchesoni, F.;
Marion, F.;
M'arka, S.;
M'arka, Z.;
Markakis, C.;
Markosyan, A. S.;
Markowitz, A.;
Maros, E.;
Marquina, A.;
Marsat, S.;
Martelli, F.;
Martellini, L.;
Martin, I. W.;
Martin, R. M.;
Martynov, D. V.;
Mason, K.;
Massera, E.;
Masserot, A.;
Massinger, T. J.;
Masso-Reid, M.;
Mastrogiovanni, S.;
Matas, A.;
Matichard, F.;
Matone, L.;
Mavalvala, N.;
Mazumder, N.;
McCann, J. J.;
McCarthy, R.;
McClelland, D. E.;
McCormick, S.;
McCuller, L.;
McGuire, S. C.;
McIver, J.;
McManus, D. J.;
McRae, T.;
McWilliams, S. T.;
Meacher, D.;
Meadors, G. D.;
Mehmet, M.;
Meidam, J.;
Mejuto-Villa, E.;
Melatos, A.;
Mendell, G.;
Mendoza-Gandara, D.;
Mercer, R. A.;
Mereni, L.;
Merilh, E. L.;
Merzougui, M.;
Meshkov, S.;
Messenger, C.;
Messick, C.;
Metzdorff, R.;
Meyers, P. M.;
Miao, H.;
Michel, C.;
Middleton, H.;
Mikhailov, E. E.;
Milano, L.;
Miller, A. L.;
Miller, A.;
Miller, B. B.;
Miller, J.;
Millhouse, M.;
Mills, J.;
Milovich-Goff, M. C.;
Minazzoli, O.;
Minenkov, Y.;
Ming, J.;
Mishra, C.;
Mitra, S.;
Mitrofanov, V. P.;
Mitselmakher, G.;
Mittleman, R.;
Moffa, D.;
Mogushi, K.;
Mohan, M.;
Mohapatra, S. R. P.;
Montani, M.;
Moore, C. J.;
Moraru, D.;
Moreno, G.;
Morisaki, S.;
Mours, B.;
Mow-Lowry, C. M.;
Mueller, G.;
Muir, A. W.;
Mukherjee, Arunava;
Mukherjee, D.;
Mukherjee, S.;
Mukund, N.;
Mullavey, A.;
Munch, J.;
Muñiz, E. A.;
Muratore, M.;
Murray, P. G.;
Nagar, A.;
Napier, K.;
Nardecchia, I.;
Naticchioni, L.;
Nayak, R. K.;
Neilson, J.;
Nelemans, G.;
Nelson, T. J. N.;
Nery, M.;
Neunzert, A.;
Nevin, L.;
Newport, J. M.;
Ng, K. Y.;
Ng, S.;
Nguyen, P.;
Nguyen, T. T.;
Nichols, D.;
Nielsen, A. B.;
Nissanke, S.;
Nitz, A.;
Nocera, F.;
Nolting, D.;
North, C.;
Nuttall, L. K.;
Obergaulinger, M.;
Oberling, J.;
O'Brien, B. D.;
O'Dea, G. D.;
Ogin, G. H.;
Oh, J. J.;
Oh, S. H.;
Ohme, F.;
Ohta, H.;
Okada, M. A.;
Oliver, M.;
Oppermann, P.;
Oram, Richard J.;
O'Reilly, B.;
Ormiston, R.;
Ortega, L. F.;
O'Shaughnessy, R.;
Ossokine, S.;
Ottaway, D. J.;
Overmier, H.;
Owen, B. J.;
Pace, A. E.;
Pagano, G.;
Page, J.;
Page, M. A.;
Pai, A.;
Pai, S. A.;
Palamos, J. R.;
Palashov, O.;
Palomba, C.;
Pal-Singh, A.;
Pan, Howard;
Pan, Huang-Wei;
Pang, B.;
Pang, P. T. H.;
Pankow, C.;
Pannarale, F.;
Pant, B. C.;
Paoletti, F.;
Paoli, A.;
Papa, M. A.;
Parida, A.;
Parker, W.;
Pascucci, D.;
Pasqualetti, A.;
Passaquieti, R.;
Passuello, D.;
Patil, M.;
Patricelli, B.;
Pearlstone, B. L.;
Pedersen, C.;
Pedraza, M.;
Pedurand, R.;
Pekowsky, L.;
Pele, A.;
Penn, S.;
Perez, C. J.;
Perreca, A.;
Perri, L. M.;
Pfeiffer, H. P.;
Phelps, M.;
Phukon, K. S.;
Piccinni, O. J.;
Pichot, M.;
Piergiovanni, F.;
Pierro, V.;
Pillant, G.;
Pinard, L.;
Pinto, I. M.;
Pirello, M.;
Pitkin, M.;
Poggiani, R.;
Popolizio, P.;
Porter, E. K.;
Possenti, L.;
Post, A.;
Powell, J.;
Prasad, J.;
Pratt, J. W. W.;
Pratten, G.;
Predoi, V.;
Prestegard, T.;
Principe, M.;
Privitera, S.;
Prodi, G. A.;
Prokhorov, L. G.;
Puncken, O.;
Punturo, M.;
Puppo, P.;
P"urrer, M.;
Qi, H.;
Quetschke, V.;
Quintero, E. A.;
Quitzow-James, R.;
Raab, F. J.;
Rabeling, D. S.;
Radkins, H.;
Raffai, P.;
Raja, S.;
Rajan, C.;
Rajbhandari, B.;
Rakhmanov, M.;
Ramirez, K. E.;
Ramos-Buades, A.;
Rana, Javed;
Rapagnani, P.;
Raymond, V.;
Razzano, M.;
Read, J.;
Regimbau, T.;
Rei, L.;
Reid, S.;
Reitze, D. H.;
Ren, W.;
Ricci, F.;
Ricker, P. M.;
Riemenschneider, G.;
Riles, K.;
Rizzo, M.;
Robertson, N. A.;
Robie, R.;
Robinet, F.;
Robson, T.;
Rocchi, A.;
Rolland, L.;
Rollins, J. G.;
Roma, V. J.;
Romano, R.;
Romel, C. L.;
Romie, J. H.;
Rosi'nska, D.;
Ross, M. P.;
Rowan, S.;
R"udiger, A.;
Ruggi, P.;
Rutins, G.;
Ryan, K.;
Sachdev, S.;
Sadecki, T.;
Sakellariadou, M.;
Salconi, L.;
Saleem, M.;
Salemi, F.;
Samajdar, A.;
Sammut, L.;
Sampson, L. M.;
Sanchez, E. J.;
Sanchez, L. E.;
Sanchis-Gual, N.;
Sandberg, V.;
Sanders, J. R.;
Sarin, N.;
Sassolas, B.;
Sathyaprakash, B. S.;
Saulson, P. R.;
Sauter, O.;
Savage, R. L.;
Sawadsky, A.;
Schale, P.;
Scheel, M.;
Scheuer, J.;
Schmidt, P.;
Schnabel, R.;
Schofield, R. M. S.;
Sch"onbeck, A.;
Schreiber, E.;
Schuette, D.;
Schulte, B. W.;
Schutz, B. F.;
Schwalbe, S. G.;
Scott, J.;
Scott, S. M.;
Seidel, E.;
Sellers, D.;
Sengupta, A. S.;
Sentenac, D.;
Sequino, V.;
Sergeev, A.;
Setyawati, Y.;
Shaddock, D. A.;
Shaffer, T. J.;
Shah, A. A.;
Shahriar, M. S.;
Shaner, M. B.;
Shao, L.;
Shapiro, B.;
Shawhan, P.;
Shen, H.;
Shoemaker, D. H.;
Shoemaker, D. M.;
Siellez, K.;
Siemens, X.;
Sieniawska, M.;
Sigg, D.;
Silva, A. D.;
Singer, L. P.;
Singh, A.;
Singhal, A.;
Sintes, A. M.;
Slagmolen, B. J. J.;
Slaven-Blair, T. J.;
Smith, B.;
Smith, J. R.;
Smith, R. J. E.;
Somala, S.;
Son, E. J.;
Sorazu, B.;
Sorrentino, F.;
Souradeep, T.;
Spencer, A. P.;
Srivastava, A. K.;
Staats, K.;
Steinke, M.;
Steinlechner, J.;
Steinlechner, S.;
Steinmeyer, D.;
Steltner, B.;
Stevenson, S. P.;
Stocks, D.;
Stone, R.;
Stops, D. J.;
Strain, K. A.;
Stratta, G.;
Strigin, S. E.;
Strunk, A.;
Sturani, R.;
Stuver, A. L.;
Summerscales, T. Z.;
Sun, L.;
Sunil, S.;
Suresh, J.;
Sutton, P. J.;
Swinkels, B. L.;
Szczepa'nczyk, M. J.;
Tacca, M.;
Tait, S. C.;
Talbot, C.;
Talukder, D.;
Tanner, D. B.;
T'apai, M.;
Taracchini, A.;
Tasson, J. D.;
Taylor, J. A.;
Taylor, R.;
Tewari, S. V.;
Theeg, T.;
Thies, F.;
Thomas, E. G.;
Thomas, M.;
Thomas, P.;
Thorne, K. A.;
Thrane, E.;
Tiwari, S.;
Tiwari, V.;
Tokmakov, K. V.;
Toland, K.;
Tonelli, M.;
Tornasi, Z.;
Torres-Forn'e, A.;
Torrie, C. I.;
T"oyr"a, D.;
Travasso, F.;
Traylor, G.;
Trinastic, J.;
Tringali, M. C.;
Trozzo, L.;
Tsang, K. W.;
Tse, M.;
Tso, R.;
Tsuna, D.;
Tsukada, L.;
Tuyenbayev, D.;
Ueno, K.;
Ugolini, D.;
Urban, A. L.;
Usman, S. A.;
Vahlbruch, H.;
Vajente, G.;
Valdes, G.;
van Bakel, N.;
van Beuzekom, M.;
Brand, J. F. J. van den;
Broeck, C. Van Den;
Vander-Hyde, D. C.;
van der Schaaf, L.;
van Heijningen, J. V.;
van Veggel, A. A.;
Vardaro, M.;
Varma, V.;
Vass, S.;
Vas'uth, M.;
Vecchio, A.;
Vedovato, G.;
Veitch, J.;
Veitch, P. J.;
Venkateswara, K.;
Venugopalan, G.;
Verkindt, D.;
Vetrano, F.;
Vicer'e, A.;
Viets, A. D.;
Vinciguerra, S.;
Vine, D. J.;
Vinet, J. -Y.;
Vitale, S.;
Vo, T.;
Vocca, H.;
Vorvick, C.;
Vyatchanin, S. P.;
Wade, A. R.;
Wade, L. E.;
Wade, M.;
Walet, R.;
Walker, M.;
Wallace, L.;
Walsh, S.;
Wang, G.;
Wang, H.;
Wang, J. Z.;
Wang, W. H.;
Wang, Y. F.;
Ward, R. L.;
Warner, J.;
Was, M.;
Watchi, J.;
Weaver, B.;
Wei, L. -W.;
Weinert, M.;
Weinstein, A. J.;
Weiss, R.;
Wellmann, F.;
Wen, L.;
Wessel, E. K.;
Wessels, P.;
Westerweck, J.;
Wette, K.;
Whelan, J. T.;
Whiting, B. F.;
Whittle, C.;
Wilken, D.;
Williams, D.;
Williams, R. D.;
Williamson, A. R.;
Willis, J. L.;
Willke, B.;
Wimmer, M. H.;
Winkler, W.;
Wipf, C. C.;
Wittel, H.;
Woan, G.;
Woehler, J.;
Wofford, J. K.;
Wong, W. K.;
Worden, J.;
Wright, J. L.;
Wu, D. S.;
Wysocki, D. M.;
Xiao, S.;
Yam, W.;
Yamamoto, H.;
Yancey, C. C.;
Yang, L.;
Yap, M. J.;
Yazback, M.;
Yu, Hang;
Yu, Haocun;
Yvert, M.;
zny, A. Zadro.;
Zanolin, M.;
Zelenova, T.;
Zendri, J. -P.;
Zevin, M.;
Zhang, J.;
Zhang, L.;
Zhang, M.;
Zhang, T.;
Zhang, Y. -H.;
Zhao, C.;
Zhou, M.;
Zhou, Z.;
Zhu, S. J.;
Zhu, X. J.;
Zimmerman, A. B.;
Zlochower, Y.;
Zucker, M. E.;
Zweizig, J.
Submitted: 2018-05-29, last modified: 2019-01-22
On August 17, 2017, the Advanced LIGO and Advanced Virgo gravitational-wave
detectors observed a low-mass compact binary inspiral. The initial sky
localization of the source of the gravitational-wave signal, GW170817, allowed
electromagnetic observatories to identify NGC 4993 as the host galaxy. In this
work, we improve initial estimates of the binary's properties, including
component masses, spins, and tidal parameters, using the known source location,
improved modeling, and recalibrated Virgo data. We extend the range of
gravitational-wave frequencies considered down to 23 Hz, compared to 30 Hz in
the initial analysis. We also compare results inferred using several signal
models, which are more accurate and incorporate additional physical effects as
compared to the initial analysis. We improve the localization of the
gravitational-wave source to a 90% credible region of $16~\mathrm{deg}^2$. We
find tighter constraints on the masses, spins, and tidal parameters, and
continue to find no evidence for nonzero component spins. The component masses
are inferred to lie between 1.00 and 1.89 $M_\odot$ when allowing for large
component spins, and to lie between 1.16 and 1.60 $M_\odot$ (with a total mass
$2.73^{+0.04}_{-0.01} \, M_\odot$) when the spins are restricted to be within
the range observed in Galactic binary neutron stars. Under minimal assumptions
about the nature of the compact objects, our constraints for the tidal
deformability parameter $\tilde \Lambda$ are $(0,630)$ when we allow for large
component spins, and $300^{+420}_{-230}$ (using a 90% highest posterior density
interval) when restricting the magnitude of the component spins, ruling out
several equation-of-state models at the 90% credible level. Finally, with LIGO
and GEO600 data, we use a Bayesian analysis to place upper limits on the
amplitude and spectral energy density of a possible post-merger signal.
(Abridged)
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1808.08676 [pdf] - 1834034
Constraining the p-mode--g-mode tidal instability with GW170817
The LIGO Scientific Collaboration;
The Virgo Collaboration;
Abbott, B. P.;
Abbott, R.;
Abbott, T. D.;
Acernese, F.;
Ackley, K.;
Adams, C.;
Adams, T.;
Addesso, P.;
Adhikari, R. X.;
Adya, V. B.;
Affeldt, C.;
Agarwal, B.;
Agathos, M.;
Agatsuma, K.;
Aggarwal, N.;
Aguiar, O. D.;
Aiello, L.;
Ain, A.;
Ajith, P.;
Allen, B.;
Allen, G.;
Allocca, A.;
Aloy, M. A.;
Altin, P. A.;
Amato, A.;
Ananyeva, A.;
Anderson, S. B.;
Anderson, W. G.;
Angelova, S. V.;
Antier, S.;
Appert, S.;
Arai, K.;
Araya, M. C.;
Areeda, J. S.;
Arène, M.;
Arnaud, N.;
Arun, K. G.;
Ascenzi, S.;
Ashton, G.;
Ast, M.;
Aston, S. M.;
Astone, P.;
Atallah, D. V.;
Aubin, F.;
Aufmuth, P.;
Aulbert, C.;
AultONeal, K.;
Austin, C.;
Avila-Alvarez, A.;
Babak, S.;
Bacon, P.;
Badaracco, F.;
Bader, M. K. M.;
Bae, S.;
Baker, P. T.;
Baldaccini, F.;
Ballardin, G.;
Ballmer, S. W.;
Banagiri, S.;
Barayoga, J. C.;
Barclay, S. E.;
Barish, B. C.;
Barker, D.;
Barkett, K.;
Barnum, S.;
Barone, F.;
Barr, B.;
Barsotti, L.;
Barsuglia, M.;
Barta, D.;
Bartlett, J.;
Bartos, I.;
Bassiri, R.;
Basti, A.;
Batch, J. C.;
Bawaj, M.;
Bayley, J. C.;
Bazzan, M.;
Bécsy, B.;
Beer, C.;
Bejger, M.;
Belahcene, I.;
Bell, A. S.;
Beniwal, D.;
Bensch, M.;
Berger, B. K.;
Bergmann, G.;
Bernuzzi, S.;
Bero, J. J.;
Berry, C. P. L.;
Bersanetti, D.;
Bertolini, A.;
Betzwieser, J.;
Bhandare, R.;
Bilenko, I. A.;
Bilgili, S. A.;
Billingsley, G.;
Billman, C. R.;
Birch, J.;
Birney, R.;
Birnholtz, O.;
Biscans, S.;
Biscoveanu, S.;
Bisht, A.;
Bitossi, M.;
Bizouard, M. A.;
Blackburn, J. K.;
Blackman, J.;
Blair, C. D.;
Blair, D. G.;
Blair, R. M.;
Bloemen, S.;
Bock, O.;
Bode, N.;
Boer, M.;
Boetzel, Y.;
Bogaert, G.;
Bohe, A.;
Bondu, F.;
Bonilla, E.;
Bonnand, R.;
Booker, P.;
Boom, B. A.;
Booth, C. D.;
Bork, R.;
Boschi, V.;
Bose, S.;
Bossie, K.;
Bossilkov, V.;
Bosveld, J.;
Bouffanais, Y.;
Bozzi, A.;
Bradaschia, C.;
Brady, P. R.;
Bramley, A.;
Branchesi, M.;
Brau, J. E.;
Briant, T.;
Brighenti, F.;
Brillet, A.;
Brinkmann, M.;
Brockill, P.;
Brooks, A. F.;
Brown, D. D.;
Brunett, S.;
Buchanan, C. C.;
Buikema, A.;
Bulik, T.;
Bulten, H. J.;
Buonanno, A.;
Buskulic, D.;
Buy, C.;
Byer, R. L.;
Cabero, M.;
Cadonati, L.;
Cagnoli, G.;
Cahillane, C.;
Bustillo, J. Calderón;
Callister, T. A.;
Calloni, E.;
Camp, J. B.;
Canepa, M.;
Canizares, P.;
Cannon, K. C.;
Cao, H.;
Cao, J.;
Capano, C. D.;
Capocasa, E.;
Carbognani, F.;
Caride, S.;
Carney, M. F.;
Diaz, J. Casanueva;
Casentini, C.;
Caudill, S.;
Cavaglià, M.;
Cavalier, F.;
Cavalieri, R.;
Cella, G.;
Cepeda, C. B.;
Cerdá-Durán, P.;
Cerretani, G.;
Cesarini, E.;
Chaibi, O.;
Chamberlin, S. J.;
Chan, M.;
Chao, S.;
Charlton, P.;
Chase, E.;
Chassande-Mottin, E.;
Chatterjee, D.;
Chatziioannou, Katerina;
Cheeseboro, B. D.;
Chen, H. Y.;
Chen, X.;
Chen, Y.;
Cheng, H. -P.;
Chia, H. Y.;
Chincarini, A.;
Chiummo, A.;
Chmiel, T.;
Cho, H. S.;
Cho, M.;
Chow, J. H.;
Christensen, N.;
Chu, Q.;
Chua, A. J. K.;
Chua, S.;
Chung, K. W.;
Chung, S.;
Ciani, G.;
Ciobanu, A. A.;
Ciolfi, R.;
Cipriano, F.;
Cirelli, C. E.;
Cirone, A.;
Clara, F.;
Clark, J. A.;
Clearwater, P.;
Cleva, F.;
Cocchieri, C.;
Coccia, E.;
Cohadon, P. -F.;
Cohen, D.;
Colla, A.;
Collette, C. G.;
Collins, C.;
Cominsky, L. R.;
Constancio, M.;
Conti, L.;
Cooper, S. J.;
Corban, P.;
Corbitt, T. R.;
Cordero-Carrión, I.;
Corley, K. R.;
Cornish, N.;
Corsi, A.;
Cortese, S.;
Costa, C. A.;
Cotesta, R.;
Coughlin, M. W.;
Coughlin, S. B.;
Coulon, J. -P.;
Countryman, S. T.;
Couvares, P.;
Covas, P. B.;
Cowan, E. E.;
Coward, D. M.;
Cowart, M. J.;
Coyne, D. C.;
Coyne, R.;
Creighton, J. D. E.;
Creighton, T. D.;
Cripe, J.;
Crowder, S. G.;
Cullen, T. J.;
Cumming, A.;
Cunningham, L.;
Cuoco, E.;
Canton, T. Dal;
Dálya, G.;
Danilishin, S. L.;
DÁntonio, S.;
Danzmann, K.;
Dasgupta, A.;
Costa, C. F. Da Silva;
Dattilo, V.;
Dave, I.;
Davier, M.;
Davis, D.;
Daw, E. J.;
Day, B.;
DeBra, D.;
Deenadayalan, M.;
Degallaix, J.;
De Laurentis, M.;
Deléglise, S.;
Del Pozzo, W.;
Demos, N.;
Denker, T.;
Dent, T.;
De Pietri, R.;
Derby, J.;
Dergachev, V.;
De Rosa, R.;
De Rossi, C.;
DeSalvo, R.;
de Varona, O.;
Dhurandhar, S.;
D\'{\ı, M. C.;
Di Fiore, az} L.;
Di Giovanni, M.;
Di Girolamo, T.;
Di Lieto, A.;
Ding, B.;
Di Pace, S.;
Di Palma, I.;
Di Renzo, F.;
Dmitriev, A.;
Doctor, Z.;
Dolique, V.;
Donovan, F.;
Dooley, K. L.;
Doravari, S.;
Dorrington, I.;
Álvarez, M. Dovale;
Downes, T. P.;
Drago, M.;
Dreissigacker, C.;
Driggers, J. C.;
Du, Z.;
Dupej, P.;
Dwyer, S. E.;
Easter, P. J.;
Edo, T. B.;
Edwards, M. C.;
Effler, A.;
Eggenstein, H. -B.;
Ehrens, P.;
Eichholz, J.;
Eikenberry, S. S.;
Eisenmann, M.;
Eisenstein, R. A.;
Essick, R. C.;
Estelles, H.;
Estevez, D.;
Etienne, Z. B.;
Etzel, T.;
Evans, M.;
Evans, T. M.;
Fafone, V.;
Fair, H.;
Fairhurst, S.;
Fan, X.;
Farinon, S.;
Farr, B.;
Farr, W. M.;
Fauchon-Jones, E. J.;
Favata, M.;
Fays, M.;
Fee, C.;
Fehrmann, H.;
Feicht, J.;
Fejer, M. M.;
Feng, F.;
Fernandez-Galiana, A.;
Ferrante, I.;
Ferreira, E. C.;
Ferrini, F.;
Fidecaro, F.;
Fiori, I.;
Fiorucci, D.;
Fishbach, M.;
Fisher, R. P.;
Fishner, J. M.;
Fitz-Axen, M.;
Flaminio, R.;
Fletcher, M.;
Fong, H.;
Font, J. A.;
Forsyth, P. W. F.;
Forsyth, S. S.;
Fournier, J. -D.;
Frasca, S.;
Frasconi, F.;
Frei, Z.;
Freise, A.;
Frey, R.;
Frey, V.;
Fritschel, P.;
Frolov, V. V.;
Fulda, P.;
Fyffe, M.;
Gabbard, H. A.;
Gadre, B. U.;
Gaebel, S. M.;
Gair, J. R.;
Gammaitoni, L.;
Ganija, M. R.;
Gaonkar, S. G.;
Garcia, A.;
Garc\'{\ı, C.;
Garufi, a-Quirós} F.;
Gateley, B.;
Gaudio, S.;
Gaur, G.;
Gayathri, V.;
Gemme, G.;
Genin, E.;
Gennai, A.;
George, D.;
George, J.;
Gergely, L.;
Germain, V.;
Ghonge, S.;
Ghosh, Abhirup;
Ghosh, Archisman;
Ghosh, S.;
Giacomazzo, B.;
Giaime, J. A.;
Giardina, K. D.;
Gill, K.;
Giordano, G.;
Glover, L.;
Goetz, E.;
Goetz, R.;
Goncharov, B.;
González, G.;
Castro, J. M. Gonzalez;
Gopakumar, A.;
Gorodetsky, M. L.;
Gossan, S. E.;
Gosselin, M.;
Gouaty, R.;
Grado, A.;
Graef, C.;
Granata, M.;
Grant, A.;
Gras, S.;
Gray, C.;
Greco, G.;
Green, A. C.;
Green, R.;
Gretarsson, E. M.;
Groot, P.;
Grote, H.;
Grunewald, S.;
Gruning, P.;
Guidi, G. M.;
Gulati, H. K.;
Guo, X.;
Gupta, A.;
Gupta, M. K.;
Gushwa, K. E.;
Gustafson, E. K.;
Gustafson, R.;
Halim, O.;
Hall, B. R.;
Hall, E. D.;
Hamilton, E. Z.;
Hamilton, H. F.;
Hammond, G.;
Haney, M.;
Hanke, M. M.;
Hanks, J.;
Hanna, C.;
Hannam, M. D.;
Hannuksela, O. A.;
Hanson, J.;
Hardwick, T.;
Harms, J.;
Harry, G. M.;
Harry, I. W.;
Hart, M. J.;
Haster, C. -J.;
Haughian, K.;
Healy, J.;
Heidmann, A.;
Heintze, M. C.;
Heitmann, H.;
Hello, P.;
Hemming, G.;
Hendry, M.;
Heng, I. S.;
Hennig, J.;
Heptonstall, A. W.;
Hernandez, F. J.;
Heurs, M.;
Hild, S.;
Hinderer, T.;
Hoak, D.;
Hochheim, S.;
Hofman, D.;
Holland, N. A.;
Holt, K.;
Holz, D. E.;
Hopkins, P.;
Horst, C.;
Hough, J.;
Houston, E. A.;
Howell, E. J.;
Hreibi, A.;
Huerta, E. A.;
Huet, D.;
Hughey, B.;
Hulko, M.;
Husa, S.;
Huttner, S. H.;
Huynh-Dinh, T.;
Iess, A.;
Indik, N.;
Ingram, C.;
Inta, R.;
Intini, G.;
Isa, H. N.;
Isac, J. -M.;
Isi, M.;
Iyer, B. R.;
Izumi, K.;
Jacqmin, T.;
Jani, K.;
Jaranowski, P.;
Johnson, D. S.;
Johnson, W. W.;
Jones, D. I.;
Jones, R.;
Jonker, R. J. G.;
Ju, L.;
Junker, J.;
Kalaghatgi, C. V.;
Kalogera, V.;
Kamai, B.;
Kandhasamy, S.;
Kang, G.;
Kanner, J. B.;
Kapadia, S. J.;
Karki, S.;
Karvinen, K. S.;
Kasprzack, M.;
Katolik, M.;
Katsanevas, S.;
Katsavounidis, E.;
Katzman, W.;
Kaufer, S.;
Kawabe, K.;
Keerthana, N. V.;
Kéfélian, F.;
Keitel, D.;
Kemball, A. J.;
Kennedy, R.;
Key, J. S.;
Khalili, F. Y.;
Khamesra, B.;
Khan, H.;
Khan, I.;
Khan, S.;
Khan, Z.;
Khazanov, E. A.;
Kijbunchoo, N.;
Kim, Chunglee;
Kim, J. C.;
Kim, K.;
Kim, W.;
Kim, W. S.;
Kim, Y. -M.;
King, E. J.;
King, P. J.;
Kinley-Hanlon, M.;
Kirchhoff, R.;
Kissel, J. S.;
Kleybolte, L.;
Klimenko, S.;
Knowles, T. D.;
Koch, P.;
Koehlenbeck, S. M.;
Koley, S.;
Kondrashov, V.;
Kontos, A.;
Korobko, M.;
Korth, W. Z.;
Kowalska, I.;
Kozak, D. B.;
Krämer, C.;
Kringel, V.;
Krishnan, B.;
Królak, A.;
Kuehn, G.;
Kumar, P.;
Kumar, R.;
Kumar, S.;
Kuo, L.;
Kutynia, A.;
Kwang, S.;
Lackey, B. D.;
Lai, K. H.;
Landry, M.;
Lang, R. N.;
Lange, J.;
Lantz, B.;
Lanza, R. K.;
Lartaux-Vollard, A.;
Lasky, P. D.;
Laxen, M.;
Lazzarini, A.;
Lazzaro, C.;
Leaci, P.;
Leavey, S.;
Lee, C. H.;
Lee, H. K.;
Lee, H. M.;
Lee, H. W.;
Lee, K.;
Lehmann, J.;
Lenon, A.;
Leonardi, M.;
Leroy, N.;
Letendre, N.;
Levin, Y.;
Li, J.;
Li, T. G. F.;
Li, X.;
Linker, S. D.;
Littenberg, T. B.;
Liu, J.;
Liu, X.;
Lo, R. K. L.;
Lockerbie, N. A.;
London, L. T.;
Longo, A.;
Lorenzini, M.;
Loriette, V.;
Lormand, M.;
Losurdo, G.;
Lough, J. D.;
Lovelace, G.;
Lück, H.;
Lumaca, D.;
Lundgren, A. P.;
Lynch, R.;
Ma, Y.;
Macas, R.;
Macfoy, S.;
Machenschalk, B.;
MacInnis, M.;
Macleod, D. M.;
Hernandez, I. Maga\ na;
na-Sandoval, F. Maga\;
Zertuche, L. Maga\ na;
Magee, R. M.;
Majorana, E.;
Maksimovic, I.;
Man, N.;
Mandic, V.;
Mangano, V.;
Mansell, G. L.;
Manske, M.;
Mantovani, M.;
Marchesoni, F.;
Marion, F.;
Márka, S.;
Márka, Z.;
Markakis, C.;
Markosyan, A. S.;
Markowitz, A.;
Maros, E.;
Marquina, A.;
Martelli, F.;
Martellini, L.;
Martin, I. W.;
Martin, R. M.;
Martynov, D. V.;
Mason, K.;
Massera, E.;
Masserot, A.;
Massinger, T. J.;
Masso-Reid, M.;
Mastrogiovanni, S.;
Matas, A.;
Matichard, F.;
Matone, L.;
Mavalvala, N.;
Mazumder, N.;
McCann, J. J.;
McCarthy, R.;
McClelland, D. E.;
McCormick, S.;
McCuller, L.;
McGuire, S. C.;
McIver, J.;
McManus, D. J.;
McRae, T.;
McWilliams, S. T.;
Meacher, D.;
Meadors, G. D.;
Mehmet, M.;
Meidam, J.;
Mejuto-Villa, E.;
Melatos, A.;
Mendell, G.;
Mendoza-Gandara, D.;
Mercer, R. A.;
Mereni, L.;
Merilh, E. L.;
Merzougui, M.;
Meshkov, S.;
Messenger, C.;
Messick, C.;
Metzdorff, R.;
Meyers, P. M.;
Miao, H.;
Michel, C.;
Middleton, H.;
Mikhailov, E. E.;
Milano, L.;
Miller, A. L.;
Miller, A.;
Miller, B. B.;
Miller, J.;
Millhouse, M.;
Mills, J.;
Milovich-Goff, M. C.;
Minazzoli, O.;
Minenkov, Y.;
Ming, J.;
Mishra, C.;
Mitra, S.;
Mitrofanov, V. P.;
Mitselmakher, G.;
Mittleman, R.;
Moffa, D.;
Mogushi, K.;
Mohan, M.;
Mohapatra, S. R. P.;
Montani, M.;
Moore, C. J.;
Moraru, D.;
Moreno, G.;
Morisaki, S.;
Mours, B.;
Mow-Lowry, C. M.;
Mueller, G.;
Muir, A. W.;
Mukherjee, Arunava;
Mukherjee, D.;
Mukherjee, S.;
Mukund, N.;
Mullavey, A.;
Munch, J.;
niz, E. A. Mu\;
Muratore, M.;
Murray, P. G.;
Nagar, A.;
Napier, K.;
Nardecchia, I.;
Naticchioni, L.;
Nayak, R. K.;
Neilson, J.;
Nelemans, G.;
Nelson, T. J. N.;
Nery, M.;
Neunzert, A.;
Nevin, L.;
Newport, J. M.;
Ng, K. Y.;
Ng, S.;
Nguyen, P.;
Nguyen, T. T.;
Nichols, D.;
Nielsen, A. B.;
Nissanke, S.;
Nitz, A.;
Nocera, F.;
Nolting, D.;
North, C.;
Nuttall, L. K.;
Obergaulinger, M.;
Oberling, J.;
OBrien, B. D.;
ODea, G. D.;
Ogin, G. H.;
Oh, J. J.;
Oh, S. H.;
Ohme, F.;
Ohta, H.;
Okada, M. A.;
Oliver, M.;
Oppermann, P.;
Oram, Richard J.;
OŔeilly, B.;
Ormiston, R.;
Ortega, L. F.;
OŚhaughnessy, R.;
Ossokine, S.;
Ottaway, D. J.;
Overmier, H.;
Owen, B. J.;
Pace, A. E.;
Pagano, G.;
Page, J.;
Page, M. A.;
Pai, A.;
Pai, S. A.;
Palamos, J. R.;
Palashov, O.;
Palomba, C.;
Pal-Singh, A.;
Pan, Howard;
Pan, Huang-Wei;
Pang, B.;
Pang, P. T. H.;
Pankow, C.;
Pannarale, F.;
Pant, B. C.;
Paoletti, F.;
Paoli, A.;
Papa, M. A.;
Parida, A.;
Parker, W.;
Pascucci, D.;
Pasqualetti, A.;
Passaquieti, R.;
Passuello, D.;
Patil, M.;
Patricelli, B.;
Pearlstone, B. L.;
Pedersen, C.;
Pedraza, M.;
Pedurand, R.;
Pekowsky, L.;
Pele, A.;
Penn, S.;
Perez, C. J.;
Perreca, A.;
Perri, L. M.;
Pfeiffer, H. P.;
Phelps, M.;
Phukon, K. S.;
Piccinni, O. J.;
Pichot, M.;
Piergiovanni, F.;
Pierro, V.;
Pillant, G.;
Pinard, L.;
Pinto, I. M.;
Pirello, M.;
Pitkin, M.;
Poggiani, R.;
Popolizio, P.;
Porter, E. K.;
Possenti, L.;
Post, A.;
Powell, J.;
Prasad, J.;
Pratt, J. W. W.;
Pratten, G.;
Predoi, V.;
Prestegard, T.;
Principe, M.;
Privitera, S.;
Prodi, G. A.;
Prokhorov, L. G.;
Puncken, O.;
Punturo, M.;
Puppo, P.;
Pürrer, M.;
Qi, H.;
Quetschke, V.;
Quintero, E. A.;
Quitzow-James, R.;
Rabeling, D. S.;
Radkins, H.;
Raffai, P.;
Raja, S.;
Rajan, C.;
Rajbhandari, B.;
Rakhmanov, M.;
Ramirez, K. E.;
Ramos-Buades, A.;
Rana, Javed;
Rapagnani, P.;
Raymond, V.;
Razzano, M.;
Read, J.;
Regimbau, T.;
Rei, L.;
Reid, S.;
Reitze, D. H.;
Ren, W.;
Ricci, F.;
Ricker, P. M.;
Riles, K.;
Rizzo, M.;
Robertson, N. A.;
Robie, R.;
Robinet, F.;
Robson, T.;
Rocchi, A.;
Rolland, L.;
Rollins, J. G.;
Roma, V. J.;
Romano, R.;
Romel, C. L.;
Romie, J. H.;
Rosińska, D.;
Ross, M. P.;
Rowan, S.;
Rüdiger, A.;
Ruggi, P.;
Rutins, G.;
Ryan, K.;
Sachdev, S.;
Sadecki, T.;
Sakellariadou, M.;
Salconi, L.;
Saleem, M.;
Salemi, F.;
Samajdar, A.;
Sammut, L.;
Sampson, L. M.;
Sanchez, E. J.;
Sanchez, L. E.;
Sanchis-Gual, N.;
Sandberg, V.;
Sanders, J. R.;
Sarin, N.;
Sassolas, B.;
Saulson, P. R.;
Sauter, O.;
Savage, R. L.;
Sawadsky, A.;
Schale, P.;
Scheel, M.;
Scheuer, J.;
Schmidt, P.;
Schnabel, R.;
Schofield, R. M. S.;
Schönbeck, A.;
Schreiber, E.;
Schuette, D.;
Schulte, B. W.;
Schutz, B. F.;
Schwalbe, S. G.;
Scott, J.;
Scott, S. M.;
Seidel, E.;
Sellers, D.;
Sengupta, A. S.;
Sentenac, D.;
Sequino, V.;
Sergeev, A.;
Setyawati, Y.;
Shaddock, D. A.;
Shaffer, T. J.;
Shah, A. A.;
Shahriar, M. S.;
Shaner, M. B.;
Shao, L.;
Shapiro, B.;
Shawhan, P.;
Shen, H.;
Shoemaker, D. H.;
Shoemaker, D. M.;
Siellez, K.;
Siemens, X.;
Sieniawska, M.;
Sigg, D.;
Silva, A. D.;
Singer, L. P.;
Singh, A.;
Singhal, A.;
Sintes, A. M.;
Slagmolen, B. J. J.;
Slaven-Blair, T. J.;
Smith, B.;
Smith, J. R.;
Smith, R. J. E.;
Somala, S.;
Son, E. J.;
Sorazu, B.;
Sorrentino, F.;
Souradeep, T.;
Spencer, A. P.;
Srivastava, A. K.;
Staats, K.;
Steinke, M.;
Steinlechner, J.;
Steinlechner, S.;
Steinmeyer, D.;
Steltner, B.;
Stevenson, S. P.;
Stocks, D.;
Stone, R.;
Stops, D. J.;
Strain, K. A.;
Stratta, G.;
Strigin, S. E.;
Strunk, A.;
Sturani, R.;
Stuver, A. L.;
Summerscales, T. Z.;
Sun, L.;
Sunil, S.;
Suresh, J.;
Sutton, P. J.;
Swinkels, B. L.;
Szczepańczyk, M. J.;
Tacca, M.;
Tait, S. C.;
Talbot, C.;
Talukder, D.;
Tanner, D. B.;
Tápai, M.;
Taracchini, A.;
Tasson, J. D.;
Taylor, J. A.;
Taylor, R.;
Tewari, S. V.;
Theeg, T.;
Thies, F.;
Thomas, E. G.;
Thomas, M.;
Thomas, P.;
Thorne, K. A.;
Thrane, E.;
Tiwari, S.;
Tiwari, V.;
Tokmakov, K. V.;
Toland, K.;
Tonelli, M.;
Tornasi, Z.;
Torres-Forné, A.;
Torrie, C. I.;
Töyrä, D.;
Travasso, F.;
Traylor, G.;
Trinastic, J.;
Tringali, M. C.;
Trozzo, L.;
Tsang, K. W.;
Tse, M.;
Tso, R.;
Tsuna, D.;
Tsukada, L.;
Tuyenbayev, D.;
Ueno, K.;
Ugolini, D.;
Urban, A. L.;
Usman, S. A.;
Vahlbruch, H.;
Vajente, G.;
Valdes, G.;
van Bakel, N.;
van Beuzekom, M.;
Brand, J. F. J. van den;
Broeck, C. Van Den;
Vander-Hyde, D. C.;
van der Schaaf, L.;
van Heijningen, J. V.;
van Veggel, A. A.;
Vardaro, M.;
Varma, V.;
Vass, S.;
Vasúth, M.;
Vecchio, A.;
Vedovato, G.;
Veitch, J.;
Veitch, P. J.;
Venkateswara, K.;
Venugopalan, G.;
Verkindt, D.;
Vetrano, F.;
Viceré, A.;
Viets, A. D.;
Vinciguerra, S.;
Vine, D. J.;
Vinet, J. -Y.;
Vitale, S.;
Vo, T.;
Vocca, H.;
Vorvick, C.;
Vyatchanin, S. P.;
Wade, A. R.;
Wade, L. E.;
Wade, M.;
Walet, R.;
Walker, M.;
Wallace, L.;
Walsh, S.;
Wang, G.;
Wang, H.;
Wang, J. Z.;
Wang, W. H.;
Wang, Y. F.;
Ward, R. L.;
Warner, J.;
Was, M.;
Watchi, J.;
Weaver, B.;
Wei, L. -W.;
Weinert, M.;
Weinstein, A. J.;
Weiss, R.;
Wellmann, F.;
Wen, L.;
Wessel, E. K.;
We{ß, P.;
Westerweck, els} J.;
Wette, K.;
Whelan, J. T.;
Whiting, B. F.;
Whittle, C.;
Wilken, D.;
Williams, D.;
Williams, R. D.;
Williamson, A. R.;
Willis, J. L.;
Willke, B.;
Wimmer, M. H.;
Winkler, W.;
Wipf, C. C.;
Wittel, H.;
Woan, G.;
Woehler, J.;
Wofford, J. K.;
Wong, W. K.;
Worden, J.;
Wright, J. L.;
Wu, D. S.;
Wysocki, D. M.;
Xiao, S.;
Yam, W.;
Yamamoto, H.;
Yancey, C. C.;
Yang, L.;
Yap, M. J.;
Yazback, M.;
Yu, Hang;
Yu, Haocun;
Yvert, M.;
Zadrożny, A.;
Zanolin, M.;
Zelenova, T.;
Zendri, J. -P.;
Zevin, M.;
Zhang, J.;
Zhang, L.;
Zhang, M.;
Zhang, T.;
Zhang, Y. -H.;
Zhao, C.;
Zhou, M.;
Zhou, Z.;
Zhu, S. J.;
Zhu, X. J.;
Zimmerman, A. B.;
Zucker, M. E.;
Zweizig, J.;
Weinberg, Nevin N.
Submitted: 2018-08-26, last modified: 2018-09-19
We analyze the impact of a proposed tidal instability coupling $p$-modes and
$g$-modes within neutron stars on GW170817. This non-resonant instability
transfers energy from the orbit of the binary to internal modes of the stars,
accelerating the gravitational-wave driven inspiral. We model the impact of
this instability on the phasing of the gravitational wave signal using three
parameters per star: an overall amplitude, a saturation frequency, and a
spectral index. Incorporating these additional parameters, we compute the Bayes
Factor ($\ln B^{pg}_{!pg}$) comparing our $p$-$g$ model to a standard one. We
find that the observed signal is consistent with waveform models that neglect
$p$-$g$ effects, with $\ln B^{pg}_{!pg} = 0.03^{+0.70}_{-0.58}$ (maximum a
posteriori and 90% credible region). By injecting simulated signals that do not
include $p$-$g$ effects and recovering them with the $p$-$g$ model, we show
that there is a $\simeq 50\%$ probability of obtaining similar $\ln
B^{pg}_{!pg}$ even when $p$-$g$ effects are absent. We find that the $p$-$g$
amplitude for 1.4 $M_\odot$ neutron stars is constrained to $\lesssim
\text{few}\times10^{-7}$, with maxima a posteriori near $\sim 10^{-7}$ and
$p$-$g$ saturation frequency $\sim 70\, \mathrm{Hz}$. This suggests that there
are less than a few hundred excited modes, assuming they all saturate by wave
breaking. For comparison, theoretical upper bounds suggest a $p$-$g$ amplitude
$\lesssim 10^{-6}$ and $\lesssim 10^{3}$ modes saturating by wave breaking.
Thus, the measured constraints only rule out extreme values of the $p$-$g$
parameters. They also imply that the instability dissipates $\lesssim 10^{51}\,
\mathrm{ergs}$ over the entire inspiral, i.e., less than a few percent of the
energy radiated as gravitational waves.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1312.0598 [pdf] - 1292104
The impact of angular momentum on black hole accretion rates in
simulations of galaxy formation
Rosas-Guevara, Y. M.;
Bower, R. G.;
Schaye, J.;
Furlong, M.;
Frenk, C. S.;
Booth, C. M.;
Crain, R.;
Vecchia, C. Dalla;
Schaller, M.;
Theuns, T.
Submitted: 2013-12-02, last modified: 2015-09-11
Feedback from energy liberated by gas accretion onto black holes (BHs) is an
attractive mechanism to explain the exponential cut-off at the massive end of
the galaxy stellar mass function (SMF). Semi-analytic models of galaxy
formation in which this form of feedback is assumed to suppress cooling in
haloes where the gas cooling time is large compared to the dynamical time do
indeed achieve a good match to the observed SMF. Furthermore, hydrodynamic
simulations of individual halos in which gas is assumed to accrete onto the
central BH at the Bondi rate have shown that a self-regulating regime is
established in which the BH grows just enough to liberate an amount of energy
comparable to the thermal energy of the halo. However, this process is
efficient at suppressing the growth not only of massive galaxies but also of
galaxies like the Milky Way, leading to disagreement with the observed SMF. The
Bondi accretion rate, however, is inappropriate when the accreting material has
angular momentum. We present an improved accretion model that takes into
account the circularisation and subsequent viscous transport of infalling
material and include it as a "subgrid" model in hydrodynamic simulations of the
evolution of halos with a wide range of masses. The resulting accretion rates
are generally low in low mass ($\lsim 10^{11.5} \msun$) halos, but show
outbursts of Eddington-limited accretion during galaxy mergers. During
outbursts these objects strongly resemble quasars. In higher mass haloes, gas
accretion occurs continuously, typically at $~10$ % of the Eddington rate,
which is conducive to the formation of radio jets. The resulting dependence of
the accretion behaviour on halo mass induces a break in the relation between
galaxy stellar mass and halo mass in these simulations that matches
observations.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1407.7040 [pdf] - 1215926
The EAGLE project: Simulating the evolution and assembly of galaxies and
their environments
Schaye, Joop;
Crain, Robert A.;
Bower, Richard G.;
Furlong, Michelle;
Schaller, Matthieu;
Theuns, Tom;
Vecchia, Claudio Dalla;
Frenk, Carlos S.;
McCarthy, I. G.;
Helly, John C.;
Jenkins, Adrian;
Rosas-Guevara, Y. M.;
White, Simon D. M.;
Baes, Maarten;
Booth, C. M.;
Camps, Peter;
Navarro, Julio F.;
Qu, Yan;
Rahmati, Alireza;
Sawala, Till;
Thomas, Peter A.;
Trayford, James
Submitted: 2014-07-25, last modified: 2014-10-02
We introduce the Virgo Consortium's EAGLE project, a suite of hydrodynamical
simulations that follow the formation of galaxies and black holes in
representative volumes. We discuss the limitations of such simulations in light
of their finite resolution and poorly constrained subgrid physics, and how
these affect their predictive power. One major improvement is our treatment of
feedback from massive stars and AGN in which thermal energy is injected into
the gas without the need to turn off cooling or hydrodynamical forces, allowing
winds to develop without predetermined speed or mass loading factors. Because
the feedback efficiencies cannot be predicted from first principles, we
calibrate them to the z~0 galaxy stellar mass function and the amplitude of the
galaxy-central black hole mass relation, also taking galaxy sizes into account.
The observed galaxy mass function is reproduced to $\lesssim 0.2$ dex over the
full mass range, $10^8 < M_*/M_\odot \lesssim 10^{11}$, a level of agreement
close to that attained by semi-analytic models, and unprecedented for
hydrodynamical simulations. We compare our results to a representative set of
low-redshift observables not considered in the calibration, and find good
agreement with the observed galaxy specific star formation rates, passive
fractions, Tully-Fisher relation, total stellar luminosities of galaxy
clusters, and column density distributions of intergalactic CIV and OVI. While
the mass-metallicity relations for gas and stars are consistent with
observations for $M_* \gtrsim 10^9 M_\odot$, they are insufficiently steep at
lower masses. The gas fractions and temperatures are too high for clusters of
galaxies, but for groups these discrepancies can be resolved by adopting a
higher heating temperature in the subgrid prescription for AGN feedback. EAGLE
constitutes a valuable new resource for studies of galaxy formation.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:1310.7571 [pdf] - 1180294
The impact of baryonic processes on the two-point correlation functions
of galaxies, subhaloes and matter
Submitted: 2013-10-28, last modified: 2014-03-16
The observed clustering of galaxies and the cross-correlation of galaxies and
mass provide important constraints on both cosmology and models of galaxy
formation. Even though the dissipation and feedback processes associated with
galaxy formation are thought to affect the distribution of matter, essentially
all models used to predict clustering data are based on collisionless
simulations. Here, we use large hydrodynamical simulations to investigate how
galaxy formation affects the autocorrelation functions of galaxies and
subhaloes, as well as their cross-correlation with matter. We show that the
changes due to the inclusion of baryons are not limited to small scales and are
even present in samples selected by subhalo mass. Samples selected by subhalo
mass cluster ~10% more strongly in a baryonic run on scales r > 1Mpc/h, and
this difference increases for smaller separations. While the inclusion of
baryons boosts the clustering at fixed subhalo mass on all scales, the sign of
the effect on the cross-correlation of subhaloes with matter can vary with
radius. We show that the large-scale effects are due to the change in subhalo
mass caused by the strong feedback associated with galaxy formation and may
therefore not affect samples selected by number density. However, on scales r <
r_vir significant differences remain after accounting for the change in subhalo
mass. We conclude that predictions for galaxy-galaxy and galaxy-mass clustering
from models based on collisionless simulations will have errors greater than
10% on sub-Mpc scales, unless the simulation results are modified to correctly
account for the effects of baryons on the distributions of mass and satellites.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:1308.4974 [pdf] - 1178723
Simulations of disk galaxies with cosmic ray driven galactic winds
Submitted: 2013-08-22, last modified: 2013-10-01
We present results from high-resolution hydrodynamic simulations of isolated
SMC- and Milky Way-sized galaxies that include a model for feedback from
galactic cosmic rays (CRs). We find that CRs are naturally able to drive winds
with mass loading factors of up to ~10 in dwarf systems. The scaling of the
mass loading factor with circular velocity between the two simulated systems is
consistent with \propto v_c^{1-2} required to reproduce the faint end of the
galaxy luminosity function. In addition, simulations with CR feedback reproduce
both the normalization and the slope of the observed trend of wind velocity
with galaxy circular velocity. We find that winds in simulations with CR
feedback exhibit qualitatively different properties compared to SN driven
winds, where most of the acceleration happens violently in situ near star
forming sites. In contrast, the CR-driven winds are accelerated gently by the
large-scale pressure gradient established by CRs diffusing from the
star-forming galaxy disk out into the halo. The CR-driven winds also exhibit
much cooler temperatures and, in the SMC-sized system, warm (T~10^4 K) gas
dominates the outflow. The prevalence of warm gas in such outflows may provide
a clue as to the origin of ubiquitous warm gas in the gaseous halos of galaxies
detected via absorption lines in quasar spectra.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:1307.6879 [pdf] - 1172988
The Impact of Different Physical Processes on the Statistics of
Lyman-limit and Damped Lyman-alpha Absorbers
Submitted: 2013-07-25, last modified: 2013-09-26
We compute the z = 3 neutral hydrogen column density distribution function
f(NHI) for 19 simulations drawn from the OWLS project using a post-processing
correction for self-shielding calculated with full radiative transfer of the
ionising background radiation. We investigate how different physical processes
and parameters affect the abundance of Lyman-limit systems (LLSs) and damped
Lyman-alpha absorbers (DLAs) including: i) metal-line cooling; ii) the
efficiency of feedback from SNe and AGN; iii) the effective equation of state
for the ISM; iv) cosmological parameters; v) the assumed star formation law
and; vi) the timing of hydrogen reionization . We find that the normalisation
and slope, D = d log10 f /d log10 NHI, of f(NHI) in the LLS regime are robust
to changes in these physical processes. Among physically plausible models,
f(NHI) varies by less than 0.2 dex and D varies by less than 0.18 for LLSs.
This is primarily due to the fact that these uncertain physical processes
mostly affect star-forming gas which contributes less than 10% to f(NHI) in the
the LLS column density range. At higher column densities, variations in f(NHI)
become larger (approximately 0.5 dex at NHI = 10^22 cm^-2 and 1.0 dex at NHI =
10^23 cm^-2) and molecular hydrogen formation also becomes important. Many of
these changes can be explained in the context of self-regulated star formation
in which the amount of star forming gas in a galaxy will adjust such that
outflows driven by feedback balance inflows due to accretion. Data and code to
reproduce all figures can be found at the following url:
https://bitbucket.org/galtay/hi-cddf-owls-1
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:1211.3120 [pdf] - 1157757
Physical properties of simulated galaxy populations at z=2 - II. Effects
of cosmology, reionization and ISM physics
Submitted: 2012-11-13, last modified: 2013-08-06
We use hydrodynamical simulations from the OWLS project to investigate the
dependence of the physical properties of galaxy populations at redshift 2 on
the assumed star formation law, the equation of state imposed on the unresolved
interstellar medium, the stellar initial mass function, the reionization
history, and the assumed cosmology. This work complements that of Paper I,
where we studied the effects of varying models for galactic winds driven by
star formation and AGN. The normalisation of the matter power spectrum strongly
affects the galaxy mass function, but has a relatively small effect on the
physical properties of galaxies residing in haloes of a fixed mass.
Reionization suppresses the stellar masses and gas fractions of low-mass
galaxies, but by z = 2 the results are insensitive to the timing of
reionization. The stellar initial mass function mainly determines the physical
properties of galaxies through its effect on the efficiency of the feedback,
while changes in the recycled mass and metal fractions play a smaller role. If
we use a recipe for star formation that reproduces the observed star formation
law independently of the assumed equation of state of the unresolved ISM, then
the latter is unimportant. The star formation law, i.e. the gas consumption
time scale as a function of surface density, determines the mass of dense,
star-forming gas in galaxies, but affects neither the star formation rate nor
the stellar mass. This can be understood in terms of self-regulation: the gas
fraction adjusts until the outflow rate balances the inflow rate.
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:1211.1021 [pdf] - 1157527
Physical properties of simulated galaxy populations at z=2 - I. Effect
of metal-line cooling and feedback from star formation and AGN
Submitted: 2012-11-05, last modified: 2013-08-06
We use hydrodynamical simulations from the OWLS project to investigate the
dependence of the physical properties of galaxy populations at redshift 2 on
metal-line cooling and feedback from star formation and active galactic nuclei
(AGN). We find that if the sub-grid feedback from star formation is implemented
kinetically, the feedback is only efficient if the initial wind velocity
exceeds a critical value. This critical velocity increases with galaxy mass and
also if metal-line cooling is included. This suggests that radiative losses
quench the winds if their initial velocity is too low. If the feedback is
efficient, then the star formation rate is inversely proportional to the amount
of energy injected per unit stellar mass formed (which is proportional to the
initial mass loading for a fixed wind velocity). This can be understood if the
star formation is self-regulating, i.e. if the star formation rate (and thus
the gas fraction) increase until the outflow rate balances the inflow rate.
Feedback from AGN is efficient at high masses, while increasing the initial
wind velocity with gas pressure or halo mass allows one to generate galaxy-wide
outflows at all masses. Matching the observed galaxy mass function requires
efficient feedback. In particular, the predicted faint-end slope is too steep
unless we resort to highly mass loaded winds for low-mass objects. Such
efficient feedback from low-mass galaxies (M_* << 10^10 Msun) also reduces the
discrepancy with the observed specific star formation rates, which are higher
than predicted unless the feedback transitions from highly efficient to
inefficient just below the observed stellar mass range.
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:1306.1563 [pdf] - 1171866
A measurement of galaxy halo mass from the surrounding HI Ly{\alpha}
absorption
Submitted: 2013-06-06
We measure the dark matter halo masses of z~2.36 UV color-selected
star-forming galaxies by matching the observed median HI Ly{\alpha} absorption
around them, as observed in the spectra of background QSOs, to the absorption
around haloes above a given mass in cosmological simulations. Focusing on
transverse separations 0-2 pMpc and line of sight separations 154-616 km/s, we
find a minimum halo mass of log10(Mmin/Msun)=11.6(+0.2)(-0.2), which is in good
agreement with published halo mass estimates from clustering analyses. We
verified that the measured halo mass is insensitive to a change in the
cosmological parameters (WMAP1 vs. WMAP3) and to the inclusion of strong AGN
feedback. One unique strength of this method is that it can be used in narrow
field galaxy-QSO surveys, i.e. ~30 x 30 arcseconds. In addition, we find that
the observed anisotropy in the 2-D HI Ly{\alpha} absorption distribution on
scales of 1.5-2 pMpc is consistent with being a consequence of large-scale gas
infall into the potential wells occupied by galaxies.
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:1203.3802 [pdf] - 653770
The interaction between feedback from active galactic nuclei and
supernovae
Submitted: 2012-03-16, last modified: 2013-04-18
Energetic feedback from supernovae (SNe) and from active galactic nuclei
(AGN) are both important processes that are thought to control how much gas is
able to condense into galaxies and form stars. We show that although both AGN
and SNe suppress star formation, they mutually weaken one another's effect by
up to an order of magnitude in haloes in the mass range for which both feedback
processes are efficient (10^11.25 M_sun < m_200 < 10^12.5 M_sun). These results
demonstrate the importance of the simultaneous, non-independent inclusion of
these two processes in models of galaxy formation to estimate the total
feedback strength. These results are of particular relevance to semi-analytic
models, which implicitly assume the effects of the two feedback processes to be
independent, and also to hydrodynamical simulations that model only one of the
feedback processes.
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:1207.4555 [pdf] - 1124947
The impact of baryons on the spins and shapes of dark matter haloes
Submitted: 2012-07-19, last modified: 2013-01-21
We use numerical simulations to investigate how the statistical properties of
dark matter (DM) haloes are affected by the baryonic processes associated with
galaxy formation. We focus on how these processes influence the spin and shape
of a large number of DM haloes covering a wide range of mass scales, from
galaxies to clusters at redshifts zero and one, extending to dwarf galaxies at
redshift two. The haloes are extracted from the OverWhelmingly Large
Simulations, a suite of state-of-the-art high-resolution cosmological
simulations run with a range of feedback prescriptions. We find that the median
spin parameter in DM-only simulations is independent of mass, redshift and
cosmology. At z=0 baryons increase the spin of the DM in the central region
(<=0.25 r_200) by up to 30 per cent when feedback is weak or absent. This
increase can be attributed to the transfer of angular momentum from baryons to
the DM, but is no longer present at z=2. We also present fits to the mass
dependence of the DM halo shape at both low and high redshift. At z=0 the
sphericity (triaxiality) is negatively (positively) correlated with halo mass
and both results are independent of cosmology. Interestingly, these
mass-dependent trends are markedly weaker at z=2. While the cooling of baryons
acts to make the overall DM halo more spherical, stronger feedback
prescriptions tend to reduce the impact of baryons by reducing the central halo
mass concentration. More generally, we demonstrate a strongly positive
(negative) correlation between halo sphericity (triaxiality) and galaxy
formation efficiency, with the latter measured using the central halo baryon
fraction. In conclusion, our results suggest that the effects of baryons on the
DM halo spin and shape are minor when the effects of cooling are mitigated, as
required by realistic models of galaxy formation, although they remain
significant for the inner halo.
[29]
oai:arXiv.org:1207.6567 [pdf] - 1125144
The impact of feedback from galaxy formation on the Lyman-alpha
transmitted flux
Submitted: 2012-07-27, last modified: 2012-11-27
The forest of Lyman-alpha absorption lines seen in the spectra of distant
quasars has become an important probe of the distribution of matter in the
Universe. We use large, hydrodynamical simulations from the OWLS project to
investigate the effect of feedback from galaxy formation on the probability
distribution function and the power spectrum of the Lyman-alpha transmitted
flux. While metal-line cooling is unimportant, both galactic outflows from
massive galaxies driven by active galactic nuclei and winds from low-mass
galaxies driven by supernovae have a substantial impact on the flux statistics.
At redshift z=2.25, the effects on the flux statistics are of a similar
magnitude as the statistical uncertainties of published data sets. The changes
in the flux statistics are not due to differences in the temperature-density
relation of the photo-ionised gas. Instead, they are caused by changes in the
density distribution and in the fraction of hot, collisionally ionised gas. It
may be possible to disentangle astrophysical and cosmological effects by taking
advantage of the fact that they induce different redshift dependencies. In
particular, the magnitude of the feedback effects appears to decrease rapidly
with increasing redshift. Analyses of Lyman-alpha forest data from surveys that
are currently in process, such as BOSS/SDSS-III and X-Shooter/VLT, must take
galactic winds into account.
[30]
oai:arXiv.org:1201.5641 [pdf] - 1093284
Absorption signatures of warm-hot gas at low redshift: Broad HI
Lyman-Alpha Absorbers
Submitted: 2012-01-26, last modified: 2012-07-02
We investigate the physical state of HI absorbing gas at low redshift (z =
0.25) using a subset of cosmological, hydrodynamic simulations from the OWLS
project, focusing in particular on broad (b_HI > 40 km/s) HI Lyman-Alpha
absorbers (BLAs), which are believed to originate in shock-heated gas in the
warm-hot intergalactic medium (WHIM). Our fiducial model, which includes
radiative cooling by heavy elements and feedback by supernovae and active
galactic nuclei, predicts that by z = 0.25 nearly 60 per cent of the gas mass
ends up at densities and temperatures characteristic of the WHIM and we find
that half of this fraction is due to outflows. The standard HI observables
(distribution of HI column densities N_HI, distribution of Doppler parameters
b_HI, b_HI - N_HI correlation) and the BLA line number density predicted by our
simulations are in remarkably good agreement with observations.
BLAs arise in gas that is hotter, more highly ionised and more enriched than
the gas giving rise to typical Lyman-Alpha forest absorbers. The majority of
the BLAs arise in warm-hot (log (T/K) ~ 5) gas at low (log Delta < 1.5)
overdensities. On average, thermal broadening accounts for at least 60 per cent
of the BLA line width, which in turn can be used as a rough indicator of the
thermal state of the gas. Detectable BLAs account for only a small fraction of
the true baryon content of the WHIM at low redshift. In order to detect the
bulk of the mass in this gas phase, a sensitivity at least one order of
magnitude better than achieved by current ultraviolet spectrographs is
required. We argue that BLAs mostly trace gas that has been shock-heated and
enriched by outflows and that they therefore provide an important window on a
poorly understood feedback process.
[31]
oai:arXiv.org:1109.4612 [pdf] - 1084289
Influence of baryons on the orbital structure of dark matter haloes
Submitted: 2011-09-21, last modified: 2012-04-23
We explore the dynamical signatures imprinted by baryons on dark matter
haloes during the formation process using the OverWhelmingly Large Simulations
(OWLS), a set of state-of-the-art high-resolution cosmological hydrodynamical
simulations. We present a detailed study of the effects of the implemented
feedback prescriptions on the orbits of dark matter particles, stellar
particles and subhaloes, analysing runs with no feedback, with stellar feedback
and with feedback from supermassive black holes. We focus on the central
regions (0.25 r_{200}) of haloes with virial masses ~ 6 x 10^{13} (~ 7 x
10^{11}) Msun/h at z = 0(2). We also investigate how the orbital content
(relative fractions of the different orbital types) of these haloes depends on
several key parameters such as their mass, redshift and dynamical state. The
results of spectral analyses of the orbital content of these simulations are
compared, and the change in fraction of box, tube and irregular orbits is
quantified. Box orbits are found to dominate the orbital structure of dark
matter haloes in cosmological simulations. There is a strong anticorrelation
between the fraction of box orbits and the central baryon fraction. While
radiative cooling acts to reduce the fraction of box orbits, strong feedback
implementations result in a similar orbital distribution to that of the dark
matter only case. The orbital content described by the stellar particles is
found to be remarkably similar to that drawn from the orbits of dark matter
particles, suggesting that either they have forgotten their dynamical history,
or that subhaloes bringing in stars are not biased significantly with respect
to the main distribution. The orbital content of the subhaloes is in broad
agreement with that seen in the outer regions of the particle distributions.
[32]
oai:arXiv.org:1202.3787 [pdf] - 713239
The XMM Cluster Survey: The interplay between the brightest cluster
galaxy and the intra-cluster medium via AGN feedback
Stott, John P.;
Hickox, Ryan C.;
Edge, Alastair C.;
Collins, Chris A.;
Hilton, Matt;
Harrison, Craig D.;
Romer, A. Kathy;
Rooney, Philip J.;
Kay, Scott T.;
Miller, Christopher J.;
Sahlen, Martin;
Lloyd-Davies, Ed J.;
Mehrtens, Nicola;
Hoyle, Ben;
Liddle, Andrew R.;
Viana, Pedro T. P.;
McCarthy, Ian G.;
Schaye, Joop;
Booth, C. M.
Submitted: 2012-02-16, last modified: 2012-03-08
Using a sample of 123 X-ray clusters and groups drawn from the XMM-Cluster
Survey first data release, we investigate the interplay between the brightest
cluster galaxy (BCG), its black hole, and the intra-cluster/group medium (ICM).
It appears that for groups and clusters with a BCG likely to host significant
AGN feedback, gas cooling dominates in those with Tx > 2 keV while AGN feedback
dominates below. This may be understood through the sub-unity exponent found in
the scaling relation we derive between the BCG mass and cluster mass over the
halo mass range 10^13 < M500 < 10^15Msol and the lack of correlation between
radio luminosity and cluster mass, such that BCG AGN in groups can have
relatively more energetic influence on the ICM. The Lx - Tx relation for
systems with the most massive BCGs, or those with BCGs co-located with the peak
of the ICM emission, is steeper than that for those with the least massive and
most offset, which instead follows self-similarity. This is evidence that a
combination of central gas cooling and powerful, well fuelled AGN causes the
departure of the ICM from pure gravitational heating, with the steepened
relation crossing self-similarity at Tx = 2 keV. Importantly, regardless of
their black hole mass, BCGs are more likely to host radio-loud AGN if they are
in a massive cluster (Tx > 2 keV) and again co-located with an effective fuel
supply of dense, cooling gas. This demonstrates that the most massive black
holes appear to know more about their host cluster than they do about their
host galaxy. The results lead us to propose a physically motivated, empirical
definition of 'cluster' and 'group', delineated at 2 keV.
[33]
oai:arXiv.org:1011.5502 [pdf] - 1042177
The filling factor of intergalactic metals at redshift z=3
Submitted: 2010-11-24, last modified: 2011-10-20
Observations of quasar absorption line systems reveal that the z=3
intergalactic medium (IGM) is polluted by heavy elements down to HI optical
depths tau_HI<<10. What is not yet clear, however, is what fraction of the
volume needs to be enriched by metals and whether it suffices to enrich only
regions close to galaxies in order to reproduce the observations. We use gas
density fields derived from large cosmological simulations, together with
synthetic quasar spectra and imposed, model metal distributions to investigate
what enrichment patterns can reproduce the observed median optical depth of CIV
as a function of tau_HI. Our models can only satisfy the observational
constraints if the z=3 IGM was primarily enriched by galaxies that reside in
low-mass (m_tot<10^10 M_sun) haloes that can eject metals out to distances
>10^2 kpc. Galaxies in more massive haloes cannot possibly account for the
observations as they are too rare for their outflows to cover a sufficiently
large fraction of the volume. Galaxies need to enrich gas out to distances that
are much greater than the virial radii of their host haloes. Assuming the
metals to be well mixed on small scales, our modeling requires that the
fractions of the simulated volume and baryonic mass that are polluted with
metals are, respectively, >10% and >50% in order to match observations.
[34]
oai:arXiv.org:1107.3720 [pdf] - 499270
Modelling neutral hydrogen in galaxies using cosmological hydrodynamical
simulations
Submitted: 2011-07-19, last modified: 2011-09-28
The characterisation of the atomic and molecular hydrogen content of
high-redshift galaxies is a major observational challenge that will be
addressed over the coming years with a new generation of radio telescopes. We
investigate this important issue by considering the states of hydrogen across a
range of structures within high-resolution cosmological hydrodynamical
simulations. Additionally, our simulations allow us to investigate the
sensitivity of our results to numerical resolution and to sub-grid baryonic
physics (especially feedback from supernovae and active galactic nuclei). We
find that the most significant uncertainty in modelling the neutral hydrogen
distribution arises from our need to model a self-shielding correction in
moderate density regions. Future simulations incorporating radiative transfer
schemes will be vital to improve on our empirical self-shielding threshold.
Irrespective of the exact nature of the threshold we find that while the atomic
hydrogen mass function evolves only mildly from redshift two to zero, the
molecular hydrogen mass function increases with increasing redshift, especially
at the high-mass end. Interestingly, the weak evolution of the neutral hydrogen
mass function is insensitive to the feedback scheme utilised, but the opposite
is true for the molecular gas, which is more closely associated with the star
formation in the simulations.
[35]
oai:arXiv.org:1104.1174 [pdf] - 416231
The effects of galaxy formation on the matter power spectrum: A
challenge for precision cosmology
Submitted: 2011-04-06, last modified: 2011-05-03
Upcoming weak lensing surveys, such as LSST, EUCLID, and WFIRST, aim to
measure the matter power spectrum with unprecedented accuracy. In order to
fully exploit these observations, models are needed that, given a set of
cosmological parameters, can predict the non-linear matter power spectrum at
the level of 1% or better for scales corresponding to comoving wave numbers
0.1<k<10 h/Mpc. We have employed the large suite of simulations from the OWLS
project to investigate the effects of various baryonic processes on the matter
power spectrum. In addition, we have examined the distribution of power over
different mass components, the back-reaction of the baryons on the CDM, and the
evolution of the dominant effects on the matter power spectrum. We find that
single baryonic processes are capable of changing the power spectrum by up to
several tens of per cent. Our simulation that includes AGN feedback, which we
consider to be our most realistic simulation as, unlike those used in previous
studies, it has been shown to solve the overcooling problem and to reproduce
optical and X-ray observations of groups of galaxies, predicts a decrease in
power relative to a dark matter only simulation ranging, at z=0, from 1% at
k~0.3 h/Mpc to 10% at k~1 h/Mpc and to 30% at k~10 h/Mpc. This contradicts the
naive view that baryons raise the power through cooling, which is the dominant
effect only for k>70 h/Mpc. Therefore, baryons, and particularly AGN feedback,
cannot be ignored in theoretical power spectra for k>0.3 h/Mpc. It will thus be
necessary to improve our understanding of feedback processes in galaxy
formation, or at least to constrain them through auxiliary observations, before
we can fulfil the goals of upcoming weak lensing surveys.
[36]
oai:arXiv.org:1102.3912 [pdf] - 1052204
The drop in the cosmic star formation rate below redshift 2 is caused by
a change in the mode of gas accretion and by AGN feedback
Submitted: 2011-02-18, last modified: 2011-04-12
The cosmic star formation rate is observed to drop sharply after redshift
z=2. We use a large, cosmological, smoothed particle hydrodynamics simulation
to investigate how this decline is related to the evolution of gas accretion
and to outflows driven by active galactic nuclei (AGN). We find that the drop
in the star formation rate follows a corresponding decline in the global
cold-mode accretion rate density onto haloes, but with a delay of order the gas
consumption time scale in the interstellar medium. Here we define cold-mode
(hot-mode) accretion as gas that is accreted and whose temperature has never
exceeded (did exceed) 10^5.5 K. In contrast to cold-mode accretion, which peaks
at z~3, the hot mode continues to increase to z~1 and remains roughly constant
thereafter. By the present time, the hot mode strongly dominates the global
accretion rate onto haloes. Star formation does not track hot-mode halo
accretion because most of the hot halo gas never accretes onto galaxies. AGN
feedback plays a crucial role by preferentially preventing gas that entered
haloes in the hot mode from accreting onto their central galaxies.
Consequently, in the absence of AGN feedback, gas accreted in the hot mode
would become the dominant source of fuel for star formation and the drop off in
the cosmic star formation rate would be much less steep.
[37]
oai:arXiv.org:1011.2491 [pdf] - 1041881
The rates and modes of gas accretion on to galaxies and their gaseous
haloes
Submitted: 2010-11-10, last modified: 2011-02-18
(Abridged) We study the rate at which gas accretes onto galaxies and haloes
and investigate whether the accreted gas was shocked to high temperatures
before reaching a galaxy. For this purpose we use a suite of large
cosmological, hydrodynamical simulations from the OWLS project. We improve on
previous work by considering a wider range of halo masses and redshifts, by
distinguishing accretion onto haloes and galaxies, by including important
feedback processes, and by comparing simulations with different physics. The
specific rate of gas accretion onto haloes is, like that for dark matter, only
weakly dependent on halo mass. For halo masses Mhalo>>10^11 Msun it is
relatively insensitive to feedback processes. In contrast, accretion rates onto
galaxies are determined by radiative cooling and by outflows driven by
supernovae and active galactic nuclei. Galactic winds increase the halo mass at
which the central galaxies grow the fastest by about two orders of magnitude to
Mhalo~10^12 Msun. Gas accretion is bimodal, with maximum past temperatures
either of order the virial temperature or <~10^5 K. The fraction of gas
accreted on to haloes in the hot mode is insensitive to feedback and metal-line
cooling. It increases with decreasing redshift, but is mostly determined by
halo mass, increasing gradually from less than 10% for ~10^11 Msun to greater
than 90% at 10^13 Msun. In contrast, for accretion onto galaxies the cold mode
is always significant and the relative contributions of the two accretion modes
are more sensitive to feedback and metal-line cooling. The majority of stars
present in any mass halo at any redshift were formed from gas accreted in the
cold mode, although the hot mode contributes typically over 10% for
Mhalo>~10^11 Msun. Galaxies, but not necessarily their gaseous haloes, are
predominantly fed by gas that did not experience an accretion shock when it
entered the host halo.
[38]
oai:arXiv.org:1005.0844 [pdf] - 1026679
Towards an understanding of the evolution of the scaling relations for
supermassive black holes
Submitted: 2010-05-05, last modified: 2011-01-03
The growth of the supermassive black holes (BHs) that reside at the centres
of most galaxies is intertwined with the physical processes that drive the
formation of the galaxies themselves. The evolution of the relations between
the mass of the BH, m_BH, and the properties of its host therefore represent
crucial aspects of the galaxy formation process. We use a cosmological
simulation, as well as an analytical model, to investigate how and why the
scaling relations for BHs evolve with cosmic time. We find that a simulation
that reproduces the observed redshift zero relations between m_BH and the
properties of its host galaxy, as well as the thermodynamic profiles of the
intragroup medium, also reproduces the observed evolution in the ratio m_BH/m_s
for massive galaxies, although the evolution of the m_BH/sigma relation is in
apparent conflict with observations. The simulation predicts that the relations
between m_BH and the binding energies of both the galaxy and its dark matter
halo do not evolve, while the ratio m_BH/m_halo increases with redshift. The
simple, analytic model of Booth & Schaye (2010), in which the mass of the BH is
controlled by the gravitational binding energy of its host halo, quantitatively
reproduces the latter two results. Finally, we can explain the evolution in the
relations between m_BH and the mass and binding energy of the stellar component
of its host galaxy for massive galaxies (m_s~10^11 M_sun) at low redshift (z<1)
if these galaxies grow primarily through dry mergers.
[39]
oai:arXiv.org:1007.2840 [pdf] - 378176
Absorption signatures of warm-hot gas at low redshift: OVI
Submitted: 2010-07-16, last modified: 2010-12-02
We investigate the origin and physical properties of OVI absorbers at low
redshift (z = 0.25) using a subset of cosmological, hydrodynamical simulations
from the OverWhelmingly Large Simulations (OWLS) project. Intervening OVI
absorbers are believed to trace shock-heated gas in the Warm-Hot Intergalactic
Medium (WHIM) and may thus play a key role in the search for the missing
baryons in the present-day Universe. When compared to observations, the
predicted distributions of the different OVI line parameters (column density,
Doppler parameter, rest equivalent width) from our simulations exhibit a lack
of strong OVI absorbers. This suggests that physical processes on sub-grid
scales (e.g. turbulence) may strongly influence the observed properties of OVI
systems. We find that the intervening OVI absorption arises mainly in highly
metal-enriched (0.1 << Z/Z_sun < 1) gas at typical overdensities of 1 <<
rho/<rho> < 100. One third of the OVI absorbers in our simulation are found to
trace gas at temperatures T < 10^5 K, while the rest arises in gas at higher
temperatures around T =10^5.3 K. The OVI resides in a similar region of
(rho,T)-space as much of the shock-heated baryonic matter, but the vast
majority of this gas has a lower metal content and does not give rise to
detectable OVI absorption As a consequence of the patchy metal distribution,
OVI absorbers in our simulations trace only a very small fraction of the cosmic
baryons (<2 percent) and the cosmic metals. Instead, these systems presumably
trace previously shock-heated, metal-rich material from galactic winds that is
now cooling. The common approach of comparing OVI and HI column densities to
estimate the physical conditions in intervening absorbers from QSO observations
may be misleading, as most of the HI (and most of the gas mass) is not
physically connected with the high-metallicity patches that give rise to the
OVI absorption.
[40]
oai:arXiv.org:1008.4799 [pdf] - 590745
Gas expulsion by quasar-driven winds as a solution to the over-cooling
problem in galaxy groups and clusters
Submitted: 2010-08-27, last modified: 2010-11-23
Galaxy groups are not scaled down versions of massive galaxy clusters - the
hot gas in groups (known as the intragroup medium, IGrM for short) is, on
average, less dense than the intracluster medium, implying that one or more
non-gravitational processes (e.g., radiative cooling, star formation, and/or
feedback) has had a relatively larger effect on groups. In the present study,
we compare a number of cosmological hydrodynamic simulations that form part of
the OverWhelmingly Large Simulations project to isolate and quantify the
effects of cooling and feedback from supernovae (SNe) and active galactic
nuclei (AGN) on the gas. This is achieved by comparing Lagrangian thermal
histories of the gas in the different runs, which were all started from
identical initial conditions. While radiative cooling, star formation, and SN
feedback are all necessary ingredients, only runs that also include AGN
feedback are able to successfully reproduce the optical and X-ray properties of
groups and low-mass clusters. We isolate how, when, and exactly what gas is
heated by AGN. Interestingly, we find that the gas that constitutes the
present-day IGrM is that which was not strongly heated by AGN. Instead, the low
median density/high median entropy of the gas in present-day groups is achieved
by the ejection of lower entropy gas from low-mass progenitor galaxies at high
redshift (primarily 2 < z < 4). This corresponds to the epoch when supermassive
black holes accreted most of their mass, typically at a rate that is close to
the Eddington limit (i.e., when the black holes are in a `quasar mode').
[41]
oai:arXiv.org:1004.5386 [pdf] - 378167
Feedback and the Structure of Simulated Galaxies at redshift z=2
Submitted: 2010-04-29, last modified: 2010-09-25
We study the properties of simulated high-redshift galaxies using
cosmological N-body/gasdynamical runs from the OverWhelmingly Large Simulations
(OWLS) project. The runs contrast several feedback implementations of varying
effectiveness: from no-feedback, to supernova-driven winds to powerful
AGN-driven outflows. These different feedback models result in large variations
in the abundance and structural properties of bright galaxies at z=2. We find
that feedback affects the baryonic mass of a galaxy much more severely than its
spin, which is on average roughly half that of its surrounding dark matter halo
in our runs. Feedback induces strong correlations between angular momentum
content and galaxy mass that leave their imprint on galaxy scaling relations
and morphologies. Encouragingly, we find that galaxy disks are common in
moderate-feedback runs, making up typically ~50% of all galaxies at the centers
of haloes with virial mass exceeding 1e11 M_sun. The size, stellar masses, and
circular speeds of simulated galaxies formed in such runs have properties that
straddle those of large star-forming disks and of compact early-type galaxies
at z=2. Once the detailed abundance and structural properties of these rare
objects are well established it may be possible to use them to gauge the
overall efficacy of feedback in the formation of high redshift galaxies.
[42]
oai:arXiv.org:1005.3921 [pdf] - 378170
The enrichment history of cosmic metals
Submitted: 2010-05-21, last modified: 2010-07-06
We use a suite of cosmological, hydrodynamical simulations to investigate the
chemical enrichment history of the Universe. Specifically, we trace the origin
of the metals back in time to investigate when various gas phases were enriched
and by what halo masses. We find that the age of the metals decreases strongly
with the density of the gas in which they end up. At least half of the metals
that reside in the diffuse intergalactic medium (IGM) at redshift zero (two)
were ejected from galaxies above redshift two (three). The mass of the haloes
that last contained the metals increases rapidly with the gas density. More
than half of the mass in intergalactic metals was ejected by haloes with total
masses less than 1e11 solar masses and stellar masses less than 1e9 solar
masses. The range of halo masses that contributes to the enrichment is wider
for the hotter part of the IGM. By combining the `when' and `by what' aspects
of the enrichment history, we show that metals residing in lower density gas
were typically ejected earlier and by lower mass haloes.
[43]
oai:arXiv.org:1002.3393 [pdf] - 1025246
Metal-line emission from the warm-hot intergalactic medium: II.
Ultraviolet
Submitted: 2010-02-18, last modified: 2010-06-14
Approximately half the baryons in the local Universe are thought to reside in
the warm-hot intergalactic medium (WHIM). Emission lines from metals in the UV
band are excellent tracers of the cooler fraction of this gas. We present
predictions for the surface brightness of a sample of UV lines that could
potentially be observed by the next generation of UV telescopes at z<1. We use
a subset of simulations from the OWLS project to create emission maps and to
investigate the effect of varying the physical prescriptions for star
formation, supernova and AGN feedback, chemodynamics and radiative cooling.
Most models produce results in agreement within a factor of a few, indicating
that the predictions are robust. Of the lines we consider, C III is the
strongest line, but it typically traces gas colder than 10^5 K. The same is
true for Si IV. The second strongest line, C IV, traces circum-galactic gas
with T~10^5 K. O VI and Ne VIII probe the warmer (T~10^5.5 K and T~10^6 K,
respectively) and more diffuse gas that may be a better tracer of the large
scale structure. N V emission is intermediate between C IV and O VI. The
intensity of all emission lines increases strongly with gas density and
metallicity, and for the bright emission it is tightly correlated with the
temperature for which the line emissivity is highest. In particular, the C III,
C IV, Si IV and O VI emission that is sufficiently bright to be potentially
detectable in the near future (>10^3 photon/s/cm^2/sr), comes from relatively
dense (rho>10^2 rho_mean) and metal rich (Z>0.1 Z_sun) gas. As such, emission
lines are highly biased tracers of the missing baryons and are not an optimal
tool to close the baryon budget. However, they do provide a powerful means to
detect the gas cooling onto or flowing out of galaxies and groups. (Abridged)
[44]
oai:arXiv.org:0910.5723 [pdf] - 1018146
Metal-line emission from the warm-hot intergalactic medium: I. Soft
X-rays
Submitted: 2009-10-29, last modified: 2010-04-28
Emission lines from metals offer one of the most promising ways to detect the
elusive warm-hot intergalactic medium (WHIM; 10^5 K<T<10^7 K), which is thought
to contain a substantial fraction of the baryons in the low-redshift Universe.
We present predictions for the soft X-ray line emission from the WHIM using a
subset of cosmological simulations from the OverWhelmingly Large Simulations
(OWLS) project. We use the OWLS models to test the dependence of the predicted
emission on a range of physical prescriptions, such as cosmology, gas cooling
and feedback from star formation and accreting black holes. Provided that
metal-line cooling is taken into account, the models give surprisingly similar
results, indicating that the predictions are robust. Soft X-ray lines trace the
hotter part of the WHIM (T>10^6 K). We find that the OVIII 18.97A is the
strongest emission line, with a predicted maximum surface brightness of ~10^2
photon/s/cm^2/sr, but a number of other lines are only slightly weaker. All
lines show a strong correlation between the intensity of the observed flux and
the density and metallicity of the gas responsible for the emission. On the
other hand, the potentially detectable emission consistently corresponds to the
temperature at which the emissivity of the electronic transition peaks. The
emission traces neither the baryonic nor the metal mass. In particular, the
emission that is potentially detectable with proposed missions, traces
overdense (rho>10^2rho_mean) and metal-rich (Z>0.1Z_sun) gas in and around
galaxies and groups. While soft X-ray line emission is therefore not a
promising route to close the baryon budget, it does offer the exciting
possibility to image the gas accreting onto and flowing out of galaxies.
[45]
oai:arXiv.org:0911.2641 [pdf] - 590744
The case for AGN feedback in galaxy groups
McCarthy, Ian G.;
Schaye, Joop;
Ponman, Trevor J.;
Bower, Richard G.;
Booth, Craig M.;
Vecchia, Claudio Dalla;
Crain, Robert A.;
Springel, Volker;
Theuns, Tom;
Wiersma, Robert P. C.
Submitted: 2009-11-13, last modified: 2010-04-06
[Abridged] The relatively recent insight that energy input from supermassive
black holes (BHs) can have a substantial effect on the star formation rates
(SFRs) of galaxies motivates us to examine its effects on the scale of galaxy
groups. At present, groups contain most of the galaxies and a significant
fraction of the overall baryon content of the universe. To explore the effects
of BH feedback on groups, we analyse two high resolution cosmological hydro
simulations from the OverWhelmingly Large Simulations project. While both
include galactic winds driven by supernovae, only one includes feedback from
BHs. We compare the properties of the simulated groups to a wide range of
observational data, including hot gas radial profiles and gas mass fractions
(fgas), luminosity-mass-temperature (L-M-T) scaling relations, K-band
luminosity of the group and its central brightest galaxy (CBG), SFRs and ages
of the CBG, and gas/stellar metallicities. Both runs yield entropy profiles
similar to the data, while the run without AGN feedback yields highly peaked
temperature profiles, in discord with the observations. Energy input from BHs
significantly reduces fgas for groups with masses less than ~10^14 Msun,
yielding fgas-T and L-T relations that are in agreement with the data. The run
without AGN feedback suffers from the well known overcooling problem; the
resulting K-band luminosities are much larger than observed. By contrast, the
run that includes BH feedback yields K-band luminosities and CBG SFRs and ages
in agreement with current estimates. Both runs yield very similar gas-phase
metallicities that match X-ray data, but they predict very different stellar
metallicities. Based on the above, galaxy groups provide a compelling case that
BH feedback is a crucial ingredient in the formation of massive galaxies.
[46]
oai:arXiv.org:1001.3447 [pdf] - 220737
Impact of baryon physics on dark matter structures: a detailed
simulation study of halo density profiles
Submitted: 2010-01-19, last modified: 2010-03-08
The back-reaction of baryons on the dark matter halo density profile is of
great interest, not least because it is an important systematic uncertainty
when attempting to detect the dark matter. Here, we draw on a large suite of
high resolution cosmological hydrodynamical simulations, to systematically
investigate this process and its dependence on the baryonic physics associated
with galaxy formation. The inclusion of baryons results in significantly more
concentrated density profiles if radiative cooling is efficient and feedback is
weak. The dark matter halo concentration can in that case increase by as much
as 30 (10) per cent on galaxy (cluster) scales. The most significant effects
occur in galaxies at high redshift, where there is a strong anti-correlation
between the baryon fraction in the halo centre and the inner slope of both the
total and the dark matter density profiles. If feedback is weak, isothermal
inner profiles form, in agreement with observations of massive, early-type
galaxies. However, we find that AGN feedback, or extremely efficient feedback
from massive stars, is necessary to match observed stellar fractions in groups
and clusters, as well as to keep the maximum circular velocity similar to the
virial velocity as observed for disk galaxies. These strong feedback models
reduce the baryon fraction in galaxies by a factor of 3 relative to the case
with no feedback. The AGN is even capable of reducing the baryon fraction by a
factor of 2 in the inner region of group and cluster haloes. This in turn
results in inner density profiles which are typically shallower than isothermal
and the halo concentrations tend to be lower than in the absence of baryons.
[47]
oai:arXiv.org:0911.0935 [pdf] - 1018233
Dark matter haloes determine the masses of supermassive black holes
Submitted: 2009-11-05, last modified: 2010-02-16
The energy and momentum deposited by the radiation from accretion onto the
supermassive black holes (BHs) that reside at the centres of virtually all
galaxies can halt or even reverse gas inflow, providing a natural mechanism for
supermassive BHs to regulate their growth and to couple their properties to
those of their host galaxies. However, it remains unclear whether this
self-regulation occurs on the scale at which the BH is gravitationally
dominant, on that of the stellar bulge, the galaxy, or that of the entire dark
matter halo. To answer this question, we use self-consistent simulations of the
co-evolution of the BH and galaxy populations that reproduce the observed
correlations between the masses of the BHs and the properties of their host
galaxies. We first confirm unambiguously that the BHs regulate their growth:
the amount of energy that the BHs inject into their surroundings remains
unchanged when the fraction of the accreted rest mass energy that is injected,
is varied by four orders of magnitude. The BHs simply adjust their masses so as
to inject the same amount of energy. We then use simulations with artificially
reduced star formation rates to demonstrate explicitly that BH mass is not set
by the stellar mass. Instead, we find that it is determined by the mass of the
dark matter halo with a secondary dependence on the halo concentration, of the
form that would be expected if the halo binding energy were the fundamental
property that controls the mass of the BH. We predict that the logarithmic
slope of the relation between dark matter halo mass and black hole mass is
1.55+/-0.05 and that the scatter around the mean relation in part reflects the
scatter in the halo concentration-mass relation.
[48]
oai:arXiv.org:1001.0077 [pdf] - 32338
The LAGUNA design study- towards giant liquid based underground
detectors for neutrino physics and astrophysics and proton decay searches
LAGUNA Collaboration;
Angus, D.;
Ariga, A.;
Autiero, D.;
Apostu, A.;
Badertscher, A.;
Bennet, T.;
Bertola, G.;
Bertola, P. F.;
Besida, O.;
Bettini, A.;
Booth, C.;
Borne, J. L.;
Brancus, I.;
Bujakowsky, W.;
Campagne, J. E.;
Danil, G. Cata;
Chipesiu, F.;
Chorowski, M.;
Cripps, J.;
Curioni, A.;
Davidson, S.;
Declais, Y.;
Drost, U.;
Duliu, O.;
Dumarchez, J.;
Enqvist, T.;
Ereditato, A.;
von Feilitzsch, F.;
Fynbo, H.;
Gamble, T.;
Galvanin, G.;
Gendotti, A.;
Gizicki, W.;
Goger-Neff, M.;
Grasslin, U.;
Gurney, D.;
Hakala, M.;
Hannestad, S.;
Haworth, M.;
Horikawa, S.;
Jipa, A.;
Juget, F.;
Kalliokoski, T.;
Katsanevas, S.;
Keen, M.;
Kisiel, J.;
Kreslo, I.;
Kudryastev, V.;
Kuusiniemi, P.;
Labarga, L.;
Lachenmaier, T.;
Lanfranchi, J. C.;
Lazanu, I.;
Lewke, T.;
Loo, K.;
Lightfoot, P.;
Lindner, M.;
Longhin, A.;
Maalampi, J.;
Marafini, M.;
Marchionni, A.;
Margineanu, R. M.;
Markiewicz, A.;
Marrodan-Undagoita, T.;
Marteau, J. E.;
Matikainen, R.;
Meindl, Q.;
Messina, M.;
Mietelski, J. W.;
Mitrica, B.;
Mordasini, A.;
Mosca, L.;
Moser, U.;
Nuijten, G.;
Oberauer, L.;
Oprina, A.;
Paling, S.;
Pascoli, S.;
Patzak, T.;
Pectu, M.;
Pilecki, Z.;
Piquemal, F.;
Potzel, W.;
Pytel, W.;
Raczynski, M.;
Rafflet, G.;
Ristaino, G.;
Robinson, M.;
Rogers, R.;
Roinisto, J.;
Romana, M.;
Rondio, E.;
Rossi, B.;
Rubbia, A.;
Sadecki, Z.;
Saenz, C.;
Saftoiu, A.;
Salmelainen, J.;
Sima, O.;
Slizowski, J.;
Slizowski, K.;
Sobczyk, J.;
Spooner, N.;
Stoica, S.;
Suhonen, J.;
Sulej, R.;
Szarska, M.;
Szeglowski, T.;
Temussi, M.;
Thompson, J.;
Thompson, L.;
Trzaska, W. H.;
Tippmann, M.;
Tonazzo, A.;
Urbanczyk, K.;
Vasseur, G.;
Williams, A.;
Winter, J.;
Wojutszewska, K.;
Wurm, M.;
Zalewska, A.;
Zampaolo, M.;
Zito, M.
Submitted: 2009-12-30
The feasibility of a next generation neutrino observatory in Europe is being
considered within the LAGUNA design study. To accommodate giant neutrino
detectors and shield them from cosmic rays, a new very large underground
infrastructure is required. Seven potential candidate sites in different parts
of Europe and at several distances from CERN are being studied: Boulby (UK),
Canfranc (Spain), Fr\'ejus (France/Italy), Pyh\"asalmi (Finland),
Polkowice-Sieroszowice (Poland), Slanic (Romania) and Umbria (Italy). The
design study aims at the comprehensive and coordinated technical assessment of
each site, at a coherent cost estimation, and at a prioritization of the sites
within the summer 2010.
[49]
oai:arXiv.org:0909.5196 [pdf] - 341102
The physics driving the cosmic star formation history
Schaye, Joop;
Vecchia, Claudio Dalla;
Booth, C. M.;
Wiersma, Robert P. C.;
Theuns, Tom;
Haas, Marcel R.;
Bertone, Serena;
Duffy, Alan R.;
McCarthy, I. G.;
van de Voort, Freeke
Submitted: 2009-09-28, last modified: 2009-11-24
We investigate the physics driving the cosmic star formation (SF) history
using the more than fifty large, cosmological, hydrodynamical simulations that
together comprise the OverWhelmingly Large Simulations (OWLS) project. We
systematically vary the parameters of the model to determine which physical
processes are dominant and which aspects of the model are robust. Generically,
we find that SF is limited by the build-up of dark matter haloes at high
redshift, reaches a broad maximum at intermediate redshift, then decreases as
it is quenched by lower cooling rates in hotter and lower density gas, gas
exhaustion, and self-regulated feedback from stars and black holes. The higher
redshift SF is therefore mostly determined by the cosmological parameters and
to a lesser extent by photo-heating from reionization. The location and height
of the peak in the SF history, and the steepness of the decline towards the
present, depend on the physics and implementation of stellar and black hole
feedback. Mass loss from intermediate-mass stars and metal-line cooling both
boost the SF rate at late times. Galaxies form stars in a self-regulated
fashion at a rate controlled by the balance between, on the one hand, feedback
from massive stars and black holes and, on the other hand, gas cooling and
accretion. Paradoxically, the SF rate is highly insensitive to the assumed SF
law. This can be understood in terms of self-regulation: if the SF efficiency
is changed, then galaxies adjust their gas fractions so as to achieve the same
rate of production of massive stars. Self-regulated feedback from accreting
black holes is required to match the steep decline in the observed SF rate
below redshift two, although more extreme feedback from SF, for example in the
form of a top-heavy IMF at high gas pressures, can help.
[50]
oai:arXiv.org:0904.2572 [pdf] - 1001943
Cosmological simulations of the growth of supermassive black holes and
feedback from active galactic nuclei: method and tests
Submitted: 2009-04-17, last modified: 2009-05-15
(Abridged) We present a method that tracks the growth of supermassive black
holes (BHs) and the feedback from AGN in cosmological simulations. Our model is
a substantially modified version of the one by Springel et al. (2005). Because
cosmological simulations lack both the resolution and the physics to model the
multiphase interstellar medium, they tend to strongly underestimate the
Bondi-Hoyle accretion rate. To allow low-mass BHs to grow, it is therefore
necessary to increase the predicted Bondi-Hoyle rates in dense gas by large,
ad-hoc factors. We explore the physical regimes where the use of such factors
is reasonable, and through this introduce a new prescription for gas accretion.
Feedback from AGN is modeled by coupling a fraction of the rest-mass energy of
the accreted gas thermally into the surrounding medium. We describe the
implementation as well as the limitations of the model and motivate all the
changes relative to previous work.
We investigate the robustness of the predictions for the cosmic star
formation history, the redshift zero cosmic BH density, BH scaling relations,
and galaxy specific star formation rates. We find that the freedom introduced
by the need to increase the predicted accretion rates, the standard procedure
in the literature, is the most significant source of uncertainty. Our
simulations demonstrate that supermassive BHs are able to regulate their growth
by releasing a fixed amount of energy for a given halo mass, independent of the
assumed efficiency of AGN feedback, which sets the normalization of the BH
scaling relations. Regardless of whether BH seeds are initially placed above or
below the BH scaling relations they grow onto the same relations. AGN feedback
efficiently suppresses star formation in high-mass galaxies.
[51]
oai:arXiv.org:0804.4474 [pdf] - 12148
Damped Lyman Alpha Systems in Galaxy Formation Simulations
Submitted: 2008-04-29, last modified: 2008-10-17
We investigate the population of z=3 damped Lyman alpha absorbers (DLAs) in a
recent series of high resolution galaxy formation simulations. The simulations
are of interest because they form at z=0 some of the most realistic disk
galaxies to date. No free parameters are available in our study: these have
been fixed by physical and z=0 observational constraints, and thus our study
provides a genuine consistency test. The precise role of DLAs in galaxy
formation remains in debate, but they provide a number of strong constraints on
the nature of our simulated bound systems at z=3 because of their coupled
information on neutral H I densities, kinematics, metallicity and estimates of
star formation activity.
Our results, without any parameter-tuning, closely match the observed
incidence rate and column density distributions of DLAs. Our simulations are
the first to reproduce the distribution of metallicities (with a median of
Z_{DLA} = Z_{solar}/20) without invoking observationally unsupported mechanisms
such as dust biasing. This is especially encouraging given that these
simulations have previously been shown to have a realistic 0<z<2 stellar
mass-metallicity relation. Additionally, we see a strong positive correlation
between sightline metallicity and low-ion velocity width, the normalization and
slope of which comes close to matching recent observational results. However,
we somewhat underestimate the number of observed high velocity width systems;
the severity of this disagreement is comparable to other recent DLA focused
studies. By z=0 the majority of the z=3 neutral gas forming the DLAs has been
converted into stars, in agreement with rough physical expectations.
[Abridged]
[52]
oai:arXiv.org:0708.0221 [pdf] - 488915
Neutral hydrogen in galactic fountains
Submitted: 2007-08-02
Simulations of an isolated Milky Way-like galaxy, in which supernovae power a
galactic fountain, reproduce the observed velocity and 21cm brightness
statistics of galactic neutral hydrogen (HI). The simulated galaxy consists of
a thin HI disk, similar in extent and brightness to that observed in the Milky
Way, and extra-planar neutral gas at a range of velocities due to the galactic
fountain. Mock observations of the neutral gas resemble the HI flux
measurements from the Leiden-Argentine-Bonn (LAB) HI, survey, including a
high-velocity tail which matches well with observations of high-velocity
clouds. The simulated high-velocity clouds are typically found close to the
galactic disk, with a typical line-of-sight distance of 13kpc from observers on
the solar circle. The fountain efficiently cycles matter from the centre of the
galaxy to its outskirts at a rate of around 0.5 M_sun/yr
[53]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0701877 [pdf] - 89006
Molecular cloud regulated star formation in galaxies
Submitted: 2007-01-30
We describe a numerical implementation of star formation in disk galaxies, in
which the conversion of cooling gas to stars in the multiphase interstellar
medium is governed by the rate at which molecular clouds are formed and
destroyed. In the model, clouds form from thermally unstable ambient gas and
get destroyed by feedback from massive stars and thermal conduction. Feedback
in the ambient phase cycles gas into a hot galactic fountain or wind. We model
the ambient gas hydrodynamically using smoothed particle hydrodynamics (SPH).
However, we cannot resolve the Jeans mass in the cold and dense molecular gas
and, therefore, represent the cloud phase with ballistic particles that
coagulate when colliding. We show that this naturally produces a multiphase
medium with cold clouds, a warm disk, hot supernova bubbles and a hot, tenuous
halo. Our implementation of this model is based on the Gadget N-Body code. We
illustrate the model by evolving an isolated Milky Way-like galaxy and study
the properties of a disk formed in a rotating spherical collapse. Many observed
properties of disk galaxies are reproduced well, including the molecular cloud
mass spectrum, the molecular fraction as a function of radius, the Schmidt law,
the stellar density profile and the appearance of a galactic fountain.
[54]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0609620 [pdf] - 85212
The Origin and Evolution of the Mass-Metallicity Relationship for
Galaxies: Results from Cosmological N-Body Simulations
Submitted: 2006-09-21, last modified: 2006-12-21
We examine the origin and evolution of the mass-metallicity relationship
(MZR, M-Z) for galaxies using high resolution cosmological SPH + N-Body
simulations that include a physically motivated description of supernovae
feedback and subsequent metal enrichment. We discriminate between two sources
that may contribute to the origin of the MZR: 1) metal and baryon loss due to
gas outflow, or 2) inefficient star formation at the lowest galaxy masses. Our
simulated galaxies reproduce the observed MZR in shape and normalization both
at z=0 and z=2. We find that baryon loss occurs due to UV heating before star
formation turns on in galaxies with M_baryon < 10^8 M_sun, but that some gas
loss due to supernovae induced winds is required to subsequently reproduce the
low effective chemical yield observed in low mass galaxies. Despite this, we
show that low star formation efficiencies, regulated by supernovae feedback,
are primarily responsible for the lower metallicities of low mass galaxies and
the overall M-Z trend. We find that the shape of the MZR is relatively constant
with redshift, but that its normalization increases with time. Simulations with
no energy feedback from supernovae overproduce metals at low galaxy masses by
rapidly transforming a large fraction of their gas into stars. Despite the fact
that our low mass galaxies have lost a majority of their baryons, they are
still the most gas rich objects in our simulations due to their low star
formation efficiencies.
