Normalized to: Blondin, J.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1809.05608 [pdf] - 2087953
Chimera: A massively parallel code for core-collapse supernova
simulation
Bruenn, Stephen W.;
Blondin, John M.;
Hix, W. Raphael;
Lentz, Eric J.;
Messer, O. E. Bronson;
Mezzacappa, Anthony;
Endeve, Eirik;
Harris, J. Austin;
Marronetti, Pedro;
Budiardja, Reuben D.;
Chertkow, Merek A.;
Lee, Ching-Tsai
Submitted: 2018-09-14, last modified: 2020-02-25
We provide a detailed description of the Chimera code, a code developed to
model core collapse supernovae in multiple spatial dimensions. The core
collapse supernova explosion mechanism remains the subject of intense research.
Progress to date demonstrates that it involves a complex interplay of neutrino
production, transport, and interaction in the stellar core, three-dimensional
stellar core fluid dynamics and its associated instabilities, nuclear burning,
and the foundational physics of the neutrino-stellar core weak interactions and
the equations of state of all stellar core constituents -particularly, the
nuclear equation of state associated with nucleons, both free and bound in
nuclei. Chimera, by incorporating detailed neutrino transport, realistic
neutrino-matter interactions, three-dimensional hydrodynamics, realistic
nuclear, leptonic, and photonic equations of state, and a nuclear reaction
network, along with other refinements, can be used to study the role of
neutrino radiation, hydrodynamic instabilities, and a variety of input physics
in the explosion mechanism itself. It can also be used to compute observables
such as neutrino signatures, gravitational radiation, and the products of
nucleosynthesis associated with core collapse supernovae. The code contains
modules for neutrino transport, multidimensional compressible hydrodynamics,
nuclear reactions, a variety of neutrino interactions, equations of state, and
modules to provide data for post-processing observables such as the products of
nucleosynthesis, and gravitational radiation. Chimera is an evolving code,
being updated periodically with improved input physics and numerical
refinements. We detail here the current version of the code, from which future
improvements will stem, which can in turn be described as needed in future
publications.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1808.03878 [pdf] - 1763054
Investigating the Structure of Vela X
Slane, P.;
Lovchinsky, I.;
Kolb, C.;
Snowden, S. L.;
Temim, T.;
Blondin, J.;
Bocchino, F.;
Miceli, M.;
Chevalier, R. A.;
Hughes, J. P.;
Patnaude, D. J.;
Gaetz, T.
Submitted: 2018-08-11
Vela X is the prototypical example of a pulsar wind nebula whose morphology
and detailed structure have been affected by the interaction with the reverse
shock of its host supernova remnant. The resulting complex of filamentary
structure and mixed-in ejecta embedded in a nebula that is offset from the
pulsar provides the best example we have of this middle-age state that
characterizes a significant fraction of composite SNRs, and perhaps all of the
large-diameter PWNe seen as TeV sources. Here we report on an XMM-Newton Large
Project study of Vela X, supplemented by additional Chandra observations.
Through broad spectral modeling as well as detailed spectral investigations of
discrete emission regions, we confirm previous studies that report evidence for
ejecta material within Vela X, and show that equivalent width variations of O
VII and O VIII are consistent with temperature maps within the PWN that show
low-temperature regions where the projected SNR emission appears to dominate
emission from the ejecta. We identify spectral variations in the nonthermal
emission, with hard emission being concentrated near the pulsar. We carry out
investigations of the Vela X "cocoon" structure and, with hydrodynamical
simulations, show that its overall properties are consistent with structures
formed in the late-phase evolution of a composite SNR expanding into a
surrounding medium with a density gradient, with ejecta material being swept
beyond the pulsar and compressed into an elongated structure in the direction
opposite the high external density.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1710.08372 [pdf] - 1590147
Gravitational wave signals from multi-dimensional core-collapse
supernova explosion simulations
Yakunin, K. N.;
Endeve, E.;
Mezzacappa, A.;
Szczpanczyk, M.;
Zanolin, M.;
Marronetti, P.;
Lentz, E. J.;
Bruenn, S. W.;
Hix, W. R.;
Messer, O. E. B.;
Blondin, J. M.;
Harris, J. A.
Submitted: 2017-10-23
In this work we report briefly on the gravitational wave (GW) signal computed
in the context of a self-consistent, 3D simulation of a core-collapse supernova
(CCSN) explosion of a 15M$_\odot$ progenitor star. We present a short overview
of the GW signal, including signal amplitude, frequency distribution, and the
energy emitted in the form of GWs for each phase of explosion, along with
neutrino luminosities, and discuss correlations between them.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1707.07021 [pdf] - 1586241
Pulsar Wind Bubble Blowout from a Supernova
Submitted: 2017-07-21, last modified: 2017-07-24
For pulsars born in supernovae, the expansion of the shocked pulsar wind
nebula is initially in the freely expanding ejecta of the supernova. While the
nebula is in the inner flat part of the ejecta density profile, the swept-up,
accelerating shell is subject to the Rayleigh-Taylor instability. We carried
out 2 and 3-dimensional simulations showing that the instability gives rise to
filamentary structure during this initial phase but does not greatly change the
dynamics of the expanding shell. The flow is effectively self-similar. If the
shell is powered into the outer steep part of the density profile, the shell is
subject to a robust Rayleigh-Taylor instability in which the shell is
fragmented and the shocked pulsar wind breaks out through the shell. The flow
is not self-similar in this phase. For a wind nebula to reach this phase
requires that the deposited pulsar energy be greater than the supernova energy,
or that the initial pulsar period be in the ms range for a typical $10^{51}$
erg supernova. These conditions are satisfied by some magnetar models for Type
I superluminous supernovae. We also consider the Crab Nebula, which may be
associated with a low energy supernova for which this scenario applies.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1707.06352 [pdf] - 1586157
Evolution of a Pulsar Wind Nebula within a Composite Supernova Remnant
Submitted: 2017-07-19
The interaction between a pulsar wind nebula (PWN) and its host supernova
remnant (SNR) can produce a vast array of observable structures. Asymmetry
present within these structures derives from the complexity of the composite
system, where many factors take turns playing a dominating hand throughout the
stages of composite SNR evolution. Of particular interest are systems
characterized by blastwave expansion within a nonuniform interstellar medium
(ISM), which contain an active pulsar having a substantial "kick" velocity
(upward of 300 km s$^{-1}$ ), because these systems tend to produce complex
morphologies. We present a numerical model that employs these and several other
factors in an effort to generate asymmetry similar to that seen in various
X-ray and radio observations. We find that the main parameters driving
structure are ISM uniformity and total pulsar spin- down energy, with secondary
contributions from factors such as pulsar trajectory and initial spin-down
luminosity. We also investigate the dynamics behind PWN "tails," which may form
to link active pulsars to a crushed, relic nebula as the reverse shock passes.
We find that the directions of such tails are not good indicators of pulsar
motion, but direction does reveal the flow of ejecta created by the passage of
a reverse shock.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1705.05405 [pdf] - 1583441
The Three-Dimensional Expansion of the Ejecta from Tycho's Supernova
Remnant
Williams, Brian J.;
Coyle, Nina M.;
Yamaguchi, Hiroya;
Depasquale, Joseph;
Seitenzahl, Ivo R.;
Hewitt, John W.;
Blondin, John M.;
Borkowski, Kazimierz J.;
Ghavamian, Parviz;
Petre, Robert;
Reynolds, Stephen P.
Submitted: 2017-05-15
We present the first three-dimensional measurements of the velocity of
various ejecta knots in Tycho's supernova remnant, known to result from a Type
Ia explosion. Chandra X-ray observations over a 12-year baseline from 2003 to
2015 allow us to measure the proper motion of nearly 60 "tufts" of Si-rich
ejecta, giving us the velocity in the plane of the sky. For the line of sight
velocity, we use two different methods: a non-equilibrium ionization model fit
to the strong Si and S lines in the 1.2-2.8 keV regime, and a fit consisting of
a series of Gaussian lines. These methods give consistent results, allowing us
to determine the red or blue shift of each of the knots. Assuming a distance of
3.5 kpc, we find total velocities that range from 2400 to 6600 km s$^{-1}$,
with a mean of 4430 km s$^{-1}$. We find several regions where the ejecta knots
have overtaken the forward shock. These regions have proper motions in excess
of 6000 km s$^{-1}$. Some Type Ia supernova explosion models predict a velocity
asymmetry in the ejecta. We find no such velocity asymmetries in Tycho, and
discuss our findings in light of various explosion models, favoring those
delayed detonation models with relatively vigorous and symmetrical
deflagrations. Finally, we compare measurements with models of the remnant's
evolution that include both smooth and clumpy ejecta profiles, finding that
both ejecta profiles can be accommodated by the observations.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1701.07325 [pdf] - 1535017
The Gravitational Wave Signal of a Core Collapse Supernova Explosion of
a 15M$_\odot$ Star
Yakunin, Konstantin N.;
Mezzacappa, Anthony;
Marronetti, Pedro;
Lentz, Eric J.;
Bruenn, Stephen W.;
Hix, W. Raphael;
Messer, O. E. Bronson;
Endeve, Eirik;
Blondin, John M.;
Harris, J. Austin
Submitted: 2017-01-25
In this Letter, we report on the gravitational wave signal computed in the
context of an $ab$ $initio$, three-dimensional simulation of a core collapse
supernova explosion, beginning with a 15M$_\odot$ star and using
state-of-the-art weak interactions. The simulation was performed with our
neutrino hydrodynamics code Chimera. We discuss the potential for detection of
our predicted gravitational signal by the current generation of gravitational
wave detectors.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1604.01779 [pdf] - 1415183
An X-ray and Radio Study of the Varying Expansion Velocities in Tycho's
Supernova Remnant
Submitted: 2016-04-06
We present newly obtained X-ray and radio observations of Tycho's supernova
remnant using {\it Chandra} and the Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array in 2015 and
2013/14, respectively. When combined with earlier epoch observations by these
instruments, we now have time baselines for expansion measurements of the
remnant of 12-15 year in the X-rays and 30 year in the radio. The remnant's
large angular size allows for proper motion measurements at many locations
around the periphery of the blast wave. We find, consistent with earlier
measurements, a clear gradient in the expansion velocity of the remnant,
despite its round shape. The proper motions on the western and southwestern
sides of the remnant are about a factor of two higher than those in the east
and northeast. We showed in an earlier work that this is related to an offset
of the explosion site from the geometric center of the remnant due to a density
gradient in the ISM, and using our refined measurements reported here, we find
that this offset is $\sim 23"$ towards the northeast. An explosion center
offset in such a circular remnant has implications for searches for progenitor
companions in other remnants.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1602.05553 [pdf] - 1382138
The Multi-Dimensional Character of Core-Collapse Supernovae
Hix, W. R.;
Lentz, E. J.;
Bruenn, S. W.;
Mezzacappa, A.;
Messer, O. E. B.;
Endeve, E.;
Blondin, J. M.;
Harris, J. A.;
Marronett, P.;
Yakunin, K. N.
Submitted: 2016-02-17
Core-collapse supernovae, the culmination of massive stellar evolution, are
spectacular astronomical events and the principle actors in the story of our
elemental origins. Our understanding of these events, while still incomplete,
centers around a neutrino-driven central engine that is highly hydrodynamically
unstable. Increasingly sophisticated simulations reveal a shock that stalls for
hundreds of milliseconds before reviving. Though brought back to life by
neutrino heating, the development of the supernova explosion is inextricably
linked to multi-dimensional fluid flows. In this paper, the outcomes of
three-dimensional simulations that include sophisticated nuclear physics and
spectral neutrino transport are juxtaposed to learn about the nature of the
three dimensional fluid flow that shapes the explosion. Comparison is also made
between the results of simulations in spherical symmetry from several groups,
to give ourselves confidence in the understanding derived from this
juxtaposition.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1510.06304 [pdf] - 1332084
X-ray Polarization from High Mass X-ray Binaries
Submitted: 2015-10-21, last modified: 2015-12-23
X-ray astronomy allows study of objects which may be associated with compact
objects, i.e. neutron stars or black holes, and also may contain strong
magnetic fields. Such objects are categorically non-spherical, and likely
non-circular when projected on the sky. Polarization allows study of such
geometric effects, and X-ray polarimetry is likely to become feasible for a
significant number of sources in the future. Potential targets for future X-ray
polarization observations are the high-mass X-ray binaries (HMXBs), which
consist of a compact object in orbit with an early type star. In this paper ws
show that X-ray polarization from HMXBs has a distinct signature which depends
on the source inclination and orbital phase. The presence of the X-ray source
displaced from the star creates linear polarization even if the primary wind is
spherically symmetric whenever the system is viewed away from conjunction.
Direct X-rays dilute this polarization whenever the X-ray source is not
eclipsed; at mid-eclipse the net polarization is expected to be small or zero
if the wind is circularly symmetric around the line of centers. Resonance line
scattering increases the scattering fraction, often by large factors, over the
energy band spanned by resonance lines. Real winds are not expected to be
spherically symmetric, or circularly symmetric around the line of centers,
owing to the combined effects of the compact object gravity and ionization on
the wind hydrodynamics. A sample calculation shows that this creates
polarization fractions ranging up to tens of percent at mid-eclipse.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1409.5779 [pdf] - 1361289
The Development of Explosions in Axisymmetric Ab Initio Core-Collapse
Supernova Simulations of 12-25 $M_\odot$ Stars
Bruenn, Stephen W.;
Lentz, Eric J.;
Hix, W. Raphael;
Mezzacappa, Anthony;
Harris, James Austin;
Messer, O. E. Bronson;
Endeve, Eirik;
Blondin, John M.;
Chertkow, Merek Austin;
Lingerfelt, Eric J.;
Marronetti, Pedro;
Yakunin, Konstantin N.
Submitted: 2014-09-19, last modified: 2015-11-03
We present four ab initio axisymmetric core-collapse supernova simulations
for 12, 15, 20, and 25 $M_\odot$ progenitors. All of the simulations yield
explosions and have been evolved for at least 1.2 seconds after core bounce and
1 second after material first becomes unbound. Simulations were computed with
our Chimera code employing spectral neutrino transport, special and general
relativistic transport effects, and state-of-the-art neutrino interactions.
Continuing the evolution beyond 1 second allows explosions to develop more
fully and the processes powering the explosions to become more clearly evident.
We compute explosion energy estimates, including the binding energy of the
stellar envelope outside the shock, of 0.34, 0.88, 0.38, and 0.70 B ($10^{51}$
ergs) and increasing at 0.03, 0.15, 0.19, and 0.52 B s$^{-1}$, respectively,
for the 12, 15, 20, and 25 $M_\odot$ models. Three models developed pronounced
prolate shock morphologies, while the 20 $M_\odot$ model, though exhibiting
lobes and accretion streams like the other models, develops an approximately
spherical, off-center shock as the explosion begins and then becomes moderately
prolate $\sim$600 ms after bounce. This reduces the explosion energy relative
to the other models by reducing mass accretion during the critical explosion
power-up phase. We examine the growth of the explosion energy in our models
through detailed analyses of the energy sources and flows. We find that the 12
and 20 $M_\odot$ models have explosion energies comparable to that of the lower
range of observed explosion energies while the 15 and 25 $M_\odot$ models are
within the range of observed explosion energies, particularly considering the
rate at which their explosion energies are increasing. The ejected $^{56}$Ni
masses given by our models are all within observational limits as are the
proto-neutron star masses and kick velocities. (Truncated)
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1507.05680 [pdf] - 1249195
A Neutrino-Driven Core Collapse Supernova Explosion of a 15 M Star
Mezzacappa, Anthony;
Lentz, Eric J.;
Bruenn, Stephen W.;
Hix, W. Raphael;
Messer, O. E. Bronson;
Endeve, Eirik;
Blondin, John M.;
Harris, J. Austin;
Marronetti, Pedro;
Yakunin, Konstantin N.;
Lingerfelt, Eric J.
Submitted: 2015-07-20
We present results from an ab initio three-dimensional, multi-physics core
collapse supernova simulation for the case of a 15 M progenitor. Our simulation
includes multi-frequency neutrino transport with state-of-the-art neutrino
interactions in the "ray-by-ray" approximation, and approximate general
relativity. Our model exhibits a neutrino-driven explosion. The shock radius
begins an outward trajectory at approximately 275 ms after bounce, giving the
first indication of a developing explosion in the model. The onset of this
shock expansion is delayed relative to our two-dimensional counterpart model,
which begins at approximately 200 ms after core bounce. At a time of 441 ms
after bounce, the angle-averaged shock radius in our three-dimensional model
has reached 751 km. Further quantitative analysis of the outcomes in this model
must await further development of the post-bounce dynamics and a simulation
that will extend well beyond 1 s after stellar core bounce, based on the
results for the same progenitor in the context of our two-dimensional,
counterpart model. This more complete analysis will determine whether or not
the explosion is robust and whether or not observables such as the explosion
energy, 56Ni mass, etc. are in agreement with observations. Nonetheless, the
onset of explosion in our ab initio three-dimensional multi-physics model with
multi-frequency neutrino transport and general relativity is encouraging.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1505.05110 [pdf] - 1248033
Three-dimensional core-collapse supernova simulated using a 15 $M_\odot$
progenitor
Lentz, Eric J.;
Bruenn, Stephen W.;
Hix, W. Raphael;
Mezzacappa, Anthony;
Messer, O. E. Bronson;
Endeve, Eirik;
Blondin, John M.;
Harris, J. Austin;
Marronetti, Pedro;
Yakunin, Konstantin N.
Submitted: 2015-05-19, last modified: 2015-06-16
We have performed ab initio neutrino radiation hydrodynamics simulations in
three and two spatial dimensions (3D and 2D) of core-collapse supernovae from
the same 15 $M_\odot$ progenitor through 440 ms after core bounce. Both 3D and
2D models achieve explosions, however, the onset of explosion (shock revival)
is delayed by $\sim$100 ms in 3D relative to the 2D counterpart and the growth
of the diagnostic explosion energy is slower. This is consistent with
previously reported 3D simulations utilizing iron-core progenitors with dense
mantles. In the $\sim$100 ms before the onset of explosion, diagnostics of
neutrino heating and turbulent kinetic energy favor earlier explosion in 2D.
During the delay, the angular scale of convective plumes reaching the shock
surface grows and explosion in 3D is ultimately lead by a single, large-angle
plume, giving the expanding shock a directional orientation not dissimilar from
those imposed by axial symmetry in 2D simulations. We posit that shock revival
and explosion in the 3D simulation may be delayed until sufficiently large
plumes form, whereas such plumes form more rapidly in 2D, permitting earlier
explosions.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1506.03069 [pdf] - 1258982
Late-time Evolution of Composite Supernova Remnants: Deep Chandra
Observations and Hydrodynamical Modeling of a Crushed Pulsar Wind Nebula in
SNR G327.1-1.1
Submitted: 2015-06-09
In an effort to better understand the evolution of composite supernova
remnants (SNRs) and the eventual fate of relativistic particles injected by
their pulsars, we present a multifaceted investigation of the interaction
between a pulsar wind nebula (PWN) and its host SNR G327.1-1.1. Our 350 ks
Chandra X-ray observations of SNR G327.1-1.1 reveal a highly complex
morphology; a cometary structure resembling a bow shock, prong-like features
extending into large arcs in the SNR interior, and thermal emission from the
SNR shell. Spectral analysis of the non-thermal emission offers clues about the
origin of the PWN structures, while enhanced abundances in the PWN region
provide evidence for mixing of supernova ejecta with PWN material. The overall
morphology and spectral properties of the SNR suggest that the PWN has
undergone an asymmetric interaction with the SNR reverse shock (RS) that can
occur as a result of a density gradient in the ambient medium and/or a moving
pulsar that displaces the PWN from the center of the remnant. We present
hydrodynamical simulations of G327.1-1.1 that show that its morphology and
evolution can be described by a ~ 17,000 yr old composite SNR that expanded
into a density gradient with an orientation perpendicular to the pulsar's
motion. We also show that the RS/PWN interaction scenario can reproduce the
broadband spectrum of the PWN from radio to gamma-ray wavelengths. The analysis
and modeling presented in this work have important implications for our general
understanding of the structure and evolution of composite SNRs.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1505.05824 [pdf] - 1045115
Gravitational Wave Signatures of Ab Initio Two-Dimensional Core Collapse
Supernova Explosion Models for 12-25 Solar Masses Stars
Yakunin, Konstantin N.;
Mezzacappa, Anthony;
Marronetti, Pedro;
Yoshida, Shin'ichirou;
Bruenn, Stephen W.;
Hix, W. Raphael;
Lentz, Eric J.;
Messer, O. E. Bronson;
Harris, J. Austin;
Endeve, Eirik;
Blondin, John M.;
Lingerfelt, Eric J.
Submitted: 2015-05-21
We present the gravitational waveforms computed in ab initio two-dimensional
core collapse supernova models evolved with the Chimera code for progenitor
masses between 12 and 25 solar masses. All models employ multi-frequency
neutrino transport in the ray-by-ray approximation, state-of-the-art weak
interaction physics, relativistic transport corrections such as the
gravitational redshift of neutrinos, two-dimensional hydrodynamics with the
commensurate relativistic corrections, Newtonian self-gravity with a general
relativistic monopole correction, and the Lattimer-Swesty equation of state
with 220 MeV compressibility, and begin with the most recent Woosley-Heger
nonrotating progenitors in this mass range. All of our models exhibit robust
explosions. Therefore, our waveforms capture all stages of supernova
development: 1) a relatively short and weak prompt signal, 2) a quiescent
stage, 3) a strong signal due to convection and SASI activity, 4) termination
of active accretion onto the proto-neutron star, and 5) a slowly increasing
tail that reaches a saturation value. Fourier decomposition shows that the
gravitational wave signals we predict should be observable by AdvLIGO for
Galactic events across the range of progenitors considered here. The
fundamental limitation of these models is in their imposition of axisymmetry.
Further progress will require counterpart three-dimensional models, which are
underway.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1501.01688 [pdf] - 918909
Recent Progress on Ascertaining the Core Collapse Supernova Explosion
Mechanism
Mezzacappa, Anthony;
Bruenn, Stephen W.;
Lentz, Eric J.;
Hix, W. Raphael;
Harris, J. Austin;
Messer, O. E. Bronson;
Endeve, Eirik;
Chertkow, Merek A.;
Blondin, John M.;
Marronetti, Pedro;
Yakunin, Konstantin N.
Submitted: 2015-01-07
We have been working within the fundamental paradigm that core collapse
supernovae (CCSNe) may be neutrino driven, since the first suggestion of this
by Colgate and White nearly five decades ago. Computational models have become
increasingly sophisticated, first in one spatial dimension assuming spherical
symmetry, then in two spatial dimensions assuming axisymmetry, and now in three
spatial dimensions with no imposed symmetries. The increase in the number of
spatial dimensions has been accompanied by an increase in the physics included
in the models, and an increase in the sophistication with which this physics
has been modeled. Computation has played an essential role in the development
of CCSN theory, not simply for the obvious reason that such multidimensional,
multi-physics, nonlinear events cannot possibly be fully captured analytically,
but for its role in discovery. In particular, the discovery of the standing
accretion shock instability (SASI) through computation about a decade ago has
impacted all simulations performed since then. Today, we appear to be at a
threshold, where neutrinos, neutrino-driven convection, and the SASI, working
together over time scales significantly longer than had been anticipated in the
past, are able to generate explosions, and in some cases, robust explosions, in
a number of axisymmetric models. But how will this play out in three
dimensions? Early results from the first three-dimensional (3D), multi-physics
simulation of the "Oak Ridge" group are promising. I will discuss the essential
components of today's models and the requirements of realistic CCSN modeling,
present results from our one-, two-, and three-dimensional models, place our
models in context with respect to other efforts around the world, and discuss
short- and long-term next steps.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1411.0037 [pdf] - 891490
Advancing Nucleosynthesis in Self-consistent, Multidimensional Models of
Core-Collapse Supernovae
Harris, J. Austin;
Hix, W. Raphael;
Chertkow, Merek A.;
Bruenn, Stephen W.;
Lentz, Eric J.;
Messer, O. E. Bronson;
Mezzacappa, Anthony;
Blondin, John M.;
Marronetti, Pedro;
Yakunin, Konstantin N.
Submitted: 2014-10-31
We investigate core-collapse supernova (CCSN) nucleosynthesis in polar
axisymmetric simulations using the multidimensional radiation hydrodynamics
code CHIMERA. Computational costs have traditionally constrained the evolution
of the nuclear composition in CCSN models to, at best, a 14-species
$\alpha$-network. Such a simplified network limits the ability to accurately
evolve detailed composition, neutronization and the nuclear energy generation
rate. Lagrangian tracer particles are commonly used to extend the nuclear
network evolution by incorporating more realistic networks in post-processing
nucleosynthesis calculations. Limitations such as poor spatial resolution of
the tracer particles, estimation of the expansion timescales, and determination
of the "mass-cut" at the end of the simulation impose uncertainties inherent to
this approach. We present a detailed analysis of the impact of these
uncertainties on post-processing nucleosynthesis calculations and implications
for future models.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1405.7075 [pdf] - 828527
Two- and Three-Dimensional Multi-Physics Simulations of Core Collapse
Supernovae: A Brief Status Report and Summary of Results from the "Oak Ridge"
Group
Mezzacappa, Anthony;
Bruenn, Stephen W.;
Lentz, Eric J.;
Hix, W. Raphael;
Messer, O. E. Bronson;
Harris, J. Austin;
Lingerfelt, Eric J.;
Endeve, Eirik;
Yakunin, Konstantin N.;
Blondin, John M.;
Marronetti, Pedro
Submitted: 2014-05-27
We summarize the results of core collapse supernova theory from one-, two-,
and three-dimensional models and provide a snapshot of the field at this time.
We also present results from the "Oak Ridge" group in this context. Studies in
both one and two spatial dimensions define the necessary} physics that must be
included in core collapse supernova models: a general relativistic treatment of
gravity (at least an approximate one), spectral neutrino transport, including
relativistic effects such as gravitational redshift, and a complete set of
neutrino weak interactions that includes state-of-the-art electron capture on
nuclei and energy-exchanging scattering on electrons and nucleons. Whether or
not the necessarily approximate treatment of this physics in current models
that include it is sufficient remains to be determined in the context of future
models that remove the approximations. We summarize the results of the Oak
Ridge group's two-dimensional supernova models. In particular, we demonstrate
that robust neutrino-driven explosions can be obtained. We also demonstrate
that our predictions of the explosion energies and remnant neutron star masses
are in agreement with observations, although a much larger number of models
must be developed before more confident conclusions can be made. We provide
preliminary results from our ongoing three dimensional model with the same
physics. Finally, we speculate on future outcomes and directions.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1310.8205 [pdf] - 1180364
Accretion in supergiant High Mass X-ray Binaries
Submitted: 2013-10-30
Supergiant High Mass X-ray Binary systems (sgHMXBs) consist of a massive,
late type, star and a neutron star. The massive stars exhibits strong,
radiatively driven, stellar winds. Wind accretion onto compact object triggers
X-ray emission, which alters the stellar wind significantly. Hydrodynamic
simulation has been used to study the neutron star - stellar wind interaction
it two sgHMXBs: i) A heavily obscured sgHMXB (IGR J17252-3616) discovered by
INTEGRAL. To account for observable quantities (i.e., absorbing column density)
we have to assume a very slow wind terminal velocity of about 500 km/s and a
rather massive neutron star. If confirmed in other obscured systems, this could
provide a completely new stellar wind diagnostics. ii) A classical sgHMXB (Vela
X-1) has been studied in depth to understand the origin of the off-states
observed in this system. Among many models used to account for this observed
behavior (clumpy wind, gating mechanism) we propose that self-organized
criticality of the accretion stream is the likely reason for the observed
behavior. In conclusion, the neutron star, in these two examples, acts very
efficiently as a probe to study stellar winds.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1305.0567 [pdf] - 1166379
Azimuthal Density Variations Around the Rim of Tycho's Supernova Remnant
Submitted: 2013-05-02
{\it Spitzer} images of Tycho's supernova remnant in the mid-infrared reveal
limb-brightened emission from the entire periphery of the shell and faint
filamentary structures in the interior. As with other young remnants, this
emission is produced by dust grains, warmed to $\sim 100$ K in the post-shock
environment by collisions with energetic electrons and ions. The ratio of the
70 to 24 $\mu$m fluxes is a diagnostic of the dust temperature, which in turn
is a sensitive function of the plasma density. We find significant variations
in the 70/24 flux ratio around the periphery of Tycho's forward shock, implying
order-of-magnitude variations in density. While some of these are likely
localized interactions with dense clumps of the interstellar medium, we find an
overall gradient in the ambient density surrounding Tycho, with densities 3-10
times higher in the NE than in the SW. This large density gradient is
qualitatively consistent with the variations in the proper motion of the shock
observed in radio and X-ray studies. Overall, the mean ISM density around Tycho
is quite low ($\sim 0.1-0.2$ cm$^{-3}$), consistent with the lack of thermal
X-ray emission observed at the forward shock. We perform two-dimensional
hydrodynamic simulations of a Type Ia SN expanding into a density gradient in
the ISM, and find that the overall round shape of the remnant is still easily
acheivable, even for explosions into significant gradients. However, this leads
to an offset of the center of the explosion from the geometric center of the
remnant of up to 20%, although lower values of 10% are preferred. The best
match with hydrodynamical simulations is achieved if Tycho is located at a
large (3-4 kpc) distance in a medium with a mean preshock density of $\sim 0.2$
cm$^{-3}$. Such preshock densities are obtained for highly ($\ga 50$%) porous
ISM grains.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:1212.1747 [pdf] - 1158377
Axisymmetric Ab Initio Core-Collapse Supernova Simulations of 12-25
M_sol Stars
Bruenn, Stephen W.;
Mezzacappa, Anthony;
Hix, W. Raphael;
Lentz, Eric J.;
Messer, O. E. Bronson;
Lingerfelt, Eric J.;
Blondin, John M.;
Endeve, Eirik;
Marronetti, Pedro;
Yakunin, Konstantin N.
Submitted: 2012-12-07, last modified: 2013-03-12
We present an overview of four ab initio axisymmetric core-collapse supernova
simulations employing detailed spectral neutrino transport computed with our
CHIMERA code and initiated from Woosley & Heger (2007) progenitors of mass 12,
15, 20, and 25 M_sol. All four models exhibit shock revival over \sim 200 ms
(leading to the possibility of explosion), driven by neutrino energy
deposition. Hydrodynamic instabilities that impart substantial asymmetries to
the shock aid these revivals, with convection appearing first in the 12 M_sol
model and the standing accretion shock instability (SASI) appearing first in
the 25 M_sol model. Three of the models have developed pronounced prolate
morphologies (the 20 M_sol model has remained approximately spherical). By 500
ms after bounce the mean shock radii in all four models exceed 3,000 km and the
diagnostic explosion energies are 0.33, 0.66, 0.65, and 0.70 Bethe (B =
$10^{51}$ ergs) for the 12, 15, 20, and 25 M_sol models, respectively, and are
increasing. The three least massive of our models are already sufficiently
energetic to completely unbind the envelopes of their progenitors (i.e., to
explode), as evidenced by our best estimate of their explosion energies, which
first become positive at 320, 380, and 440 ms after bounce. By 850 ms the 12
M_sol diagnostic explosion energy has saturated at 0.38 B, and our estimate for
the final kinetic energy of the ejecta is \sim 0.3 B, which is comparable to
observations for lower-mass progenitors.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:1212.4534 [pdf] - 1158601
X-ray Emission from Strongly Asymmetric Circumstellar Material in the
Remnant of Kepler's Supernova
Submitted: 2012-12-18
Kepler's supernova remnant resulted from a thermonuclear explosion, but is
interacting with circumstellar material (CSM) lost from the progenitor system.
We describe a statistical technique for isolating X-ray emission due to CSM
from that due to shocked ejecta. Shocked CSM coincides well in position with 24
$\mu$m emission seen by {\sl Spitzer}. We find most CSM to be distributed along
the bright north rim, but substantial concentrations are also found projected
against the center of the remnant, roughly along a diameter with position angle
$\sim 100^\circ$. We interpret this as evidence for a disk distribution of CSM
before the SN, with the line of sight to the observer roughly in the disk
plane. We present 2-D hydrodynamic simulations of this scenario, in qualitative
agreement with the observed CSM morphology. Our observations require Kepler to
have originated in a close binary system with an AGB star companion.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:1210.7790 [pdf] - 1152556
Three-dimensional numerical investigations of the morphology of type Ia
SNRs
Submitted: 2012-10-29
We explore the morphology of Type Ia supernova remnants (SNRs) using
three-dimensional hydrodynamics modeling and an exponential density profile.
Our model distinguishes ejecta from the interstellar medium (ISM), and tracks
the ionization age of shocked ejecta, both of which allow for additional
analysis of the simulated remnants. We also include the adiabatic index as a
free parameter, which affects the compressibility of the fluid and emulates the
efficiency of cosmic ray acceleration by shock fronts. In addition to
generating 3-D images of the simulations, we compute line-of-sight projections
through the remnants for comparison against observations of Tycho's SNR and SN
1006. We find that several features observed in these two remnants, such as the
separation between the fluid discontinuities and the presence of ejecta knots
ahead of the forward shock, can be generated by smooth ejecta without any
initial clumpiness. Our results are consistent with SN 1006 being dynamically
younger than Tycho's SNR, and more efficiently accelerating cosmic rays at its
forward shock. We conclude that clumpiness is not a necessary condition to
reproduce many observed features of Type Ia supernova remnants, particularly
the radial profiles and the fleecy emission from ejecta at the central region
of both remnants.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:1210.2952 [pdf] - 574632
Neutron star masses from hydrodynamical effects in obscured sgHMXBs
Submitted: 2012-10-10
A population of obscured supergiant High Mass X-ray Binaries (sgHMXBs) has
been discovered by INTEGRAL. X-ray wind tomography of IGR J17252-3616 inferred
a slow wind velocity to account for the enhanced obscuration. The main goal of
this study is to understand under which conditions high obscuration could
occur. We have used an hydrodynamical code to simulate the flow of the stellar
wind around the neutron star. A grid of simulations was used to study the
dependency of the absorbing column density and of the X-ray light-curves on the
model parameters. A comparison between the simulation results and the
observations of IGR J17252-3616 provides an estimate on these parameters. We
have constrained the wind terminal velocity to 500-600 km/s and the neutron
star mass to 1.75-2.15 solar masses. We have confirmed that the initial
hypothesis of a slow wind velocity with a moderate mass loss rate is valid. The
mass of the neutron star can be constrained by studying its impact on the
accretion flow.
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:1204.0717 [pdf] - 1117737
Hoyle-Lyttleton Accretion in Three Dimensions
Submitted: 2012-04-03
We investigate the stability of gravitational accretion of an ideal gas onto
a compact object moving through a uniform medium at Mach 3. Previous
three-dimensional simulations have shown that such accretion is not stable, and
that strong rotational 'disk-like' flows are generated and accreted on short
time scales. We re-address this problem using overset spherical grids that
provide a factor of seven improvement in spatial resolution over previous
simulations. With our higher spatial resolution we found these 3D accretion
flows remained remarkably axisymmetric. We examined two cases of accretion with
different sized accretors. The larger accretor produced very steady flow, with
the mass accretion rate varying by less than 0.02% over 30 flow times. The
smaller accretor exhibited an axisymmetric breathing mode that modulated the
mass accretion rate by a constant 20%. Nonetheless, the flow remained highly
axisymmetric with only negligible accretion of angular momentum in both cases.
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:1203.3748 [pdf] - 1117359
Turbulence and magnetic field amplification from spiral SASI modes in
core-collapse supernovae
Submitted: 2012-03-16
The stationary accretion shock instability (SASI) plays a central role in
modern simulations of the explosion phase of core-collapse supernovae (CCSNe).
It may be key to realizing neutrino powered explosions, and possibly links
birth properties of pulsars (e.g., kick, spin, and magnetic field) to supernova
dynamics. Using high-resolution magnetohydrodynamic simulations, we study the
development of turbulence, and subsequent amplification of magnetic fields in a
simplified model of the post-bounce core-collapse supernova environment.
Turbulence develops from secondary instabilities induced by the SASI. Our
simulations suggest that the development of turbulence plays an important role
for the subsequent evolution of the SASI. The turbulence also acts to amplify
weak magnetic fields via a small-scale dynamo.
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:1203.3108 [pdf] - 1117303
Turbulent Magnetic Field Amplification from Spiral SASI Modes:
Implications for Core-Collapse Supernovae and Proto-Neutron Star
Magnetization
Submitted: 2012-03-14
We extend our investigation of magnetic field evolution in three-dimensional
flows driven by the stationary accretion shock instability (SASI) with a suite
of higher-resolution idealized models of the post-bounce core-collapse
supernova environment. Our magnetohydrodynamic simulations vary in initial
magnetic field strength, rotation rate, and grid resolution. Vigorous
SASI-driven turbulence inside the shock amplifies magnetic fields
exponentially; but while the amplified fields reduce the kinetic energy of
small-scale flows, they do not seem to affect the global shock dynamics. The
growth rate and final magnitude of the magnetic energy are very sensitive to
grid resolution, and both are underestimated by the simulations. Nevertheless
our simulations suggest that neutron star magnetic fields exceeding $10^{14}$ G
can result from dynamics driven by the SASI, \emph{even for non-rotating
progenitors}.
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:1108.1207 [pdf] - 1083229
RCW 86: A Type Ia Supernova in a Wind-Blown Bubble
Williams, Brian J.;
Blair, William P.;
Blondin, John M.;
Borkowski, Kazimierz J.;
Ghavamian, Parviz;
Long, Knox S.;
Raymond, John C.;
Reynolds, Stephen P.;
Rho, Jeonghee;
Winkler, P. Frank
Submitted: 2011-08-04
We report results from a multi-wavelength analysis of the Galactic SNR RCW
86, the proposed remnant of the supernova of 185 A.D. We report new infrared
observations from {\it Spitzer} and {\it WISE}, where the entire shell is
detected at 24 and 22 $\mu$m. We fit the infrared flux ratios with models of
collisionally heated ambient dust, finding post-shock gas densities in the
non-radiative shocks of 2.4 and 2.0 cm$^{-3}$ in the SW and NW portions of the
remnant, respectively. The Balmer-dominated shocks around the periphery of the
shell, large amount of iron in the X-ray emitting ejecta, and lack of a compact
remnant support a Type Ia origin for this remnant. From hydrodynamic
simulations, the observed characteristics of RCW 86 are successfully reproduced
by an off-center explosion in a low-density cavity carved by the progenitor
system. This would make RCW 86 the first known case of a Type Ia supernova in a
wind-blown bubble. The fast shocks ($> 3000$ km s$^{-1}$) observed in the NE
are propagating in the low-density bubble, where the shock is just beginning to
encounter the shell, while the slower shocks elsewhere have already encountered
the bubble wall. The diffuse nature of the synchrotron emission in the SW and
NW is due to electrons that were accelerated early in the lifetime of the
remnant, when the shock was still in the bubble. Electrons in a bubble could
produce gamma-rays by inverse-Compton scattering. The wind-blown bubble
scenario requires a single-degenerate progenitor, which should leave behind a
companion star.
[29]
oai:arXiv.org:1011.3752 [pdf] - 262883
Core Collapse Supernovae using CHIMERA: Gravitational Radiation from
Non-Rotating Progenitors
Yakunin, Konstantin;
Marronetti, Pedro;
Mezzacappa, Anthony;
Bruenn, Stephen W;
Lee, Ching-Tsai;
Chertkow, Merek A;
Hix, W Raphael;
Blondin, John M;
Lentz, Eric J;
Messer, O E Bronson;
Yoshida, Shin
Submitted: 2010-11-16
The CHIMERA code is a multi-dimensional multi-physics engine dedicated
primarily to the simulation of core collapse supernova explosions. One of the
most important aspects of these explosions is their capacity to produce
gravitational radiation that is detectable by Earth-based laser-interferometric
gravitational wave observatories such as LIGO and VIRGO. We present here
preliminary gravitational signatures of two-dimensional models with
non-rotating progenitors. These simulations exhibit explosions, which are
followed for more than half a second after stellar core bounce.
[30]
oai:arXiv.org:1005.0779 [pdf] - 251306
Gravitational Waves from Core Collapse Supernovae
Yakunin, Konstantin N;
Marronetti, Pedro;
Mezzacappa, Anthony;
Bruenn, Stephen W;
Lee, Ching-Tsai;
Chertkow, Merek A;
Hix, W Raphael;
Blondin, John M;
Lentz, Eric J;
Messer, O E Bronson;
Yoshida, Shin'ichirou
Submitted: 2010-05-05, last modified: 2010-07-14
We present the gravitational wave signatures for a suite of axisymmetric core
collapse supernova models with progenitors masses between 12 and 25 solar
masses. These models are distinguished by the fact they explode and contain
essential physics (in particular, multi-frequency neutrino transport and
general relativity) needed for a more realistic description. Thus, we are able
to compute complete waveforms (i.e., through explosion) based on
non-parameterized, first-principles models. This is essential if the waveform
amplitudes and time scales are to be computed more precisely. Fourier
decomposition shows that the gravitational wave signals we predict should be
observable by AdvLIGO across the range of progenitors considered here. The
fundamental limitation of these models is in their imposition of axisymmetry.
Further progress will require counterpart three-dimensional models.
[31]
oai:arXiv.org:1002.4914 [pdf] - 1025406
2D and 3D Core-Collapse Supernovae Simulation Results Obtained with the
CHIMERA Code
Submitted: 2010-02-25
Much progress in realistic modeling of core-collapse supernovae has occurred
recently through the availability of multi-teraflop machines and the increasing
sophistication of supernova codes. These improvements are enabling simulations
with enough realism that the explosion mechanism, long a mystery, may soon be
delineated. We briefly describe the CHIMERA code, a supernova code we have
developed to simulate core-collapse supernovae in 1, 2, and 3 spatial
dimensions. We then describe the results of an ongoing suite of 2D simulations
initiated from a 12, 15, 20, and 25 solar mass progenitor. These have all
exhibited explosions and are currently in the expanding phase with the shock at
between 5,000 and 20,000 km. We also briefly describe an ongoing simulation in
3 spatial dimensions initiated from the 15 solar mass progenitor.
[32]
oai:arXiv.org:1002.4909 [pdf] - 1025405
Mechanisms of Core-Collapse Supernovae & Simulation Results from the
CHIMERA Code
Submitted: 2010-02-25
Unraveling the mechanism for core-collapse supernova explosions is an
outstanding computational challenge and the problem remains essentially
unsolved despite more than four decades of effort. However, much progress in
realistic modeling has occurred recently through the availability of
multi-teraflop machines and the increasing sophistication of supernova codes.
These improvements have led to some key insights which may clarify the picture
in the not too distant future. Here we briefly review the current status of the
three explosion mechanisms (acoustic, MHD, and neutrino heating) that are
currently under active investigation, concentrating on the neutrino heating
mechanism as the one most likely responsible for producing explosions from
progenitors in the mass range ~10 to ~25 solar masses. We then briefly describe
the CHIMERA code, a supernova code we have developed to simulate core-collapse
supernovae in 1, 2, and 3 spatial dimensions. We finally describe the results
of an ongoing suite of 2D simulations initiated from a 12, 15, 20, and 25 solar
mass progenitor. These have all exhibited explosions and are currently in the
expanding phase with the shock at between 5,000 and 10,000 km. We finally very
briefly describe an ongoing simulation in 3 spatial dimensions initiated from
the 15 solar mass progenitor.
[33]
oai:arXiv.org:0905.3753 [pdf] - 315914
Circumstellar Shells in Absorption in Type Ia Supernovae
Submitted: 2009-05-22, last modified: 2009-06-17
Progenitors of Type Ia supernovae (SNe) have been predicted to modify their
ambient circumstellar (CSM) and interstellar environments through the action of
their powerful winds. While there is X-ray and optical evidence for
circumstellar interaction in several remnants of Type Ia SNe, widespread
evidence for such interaction in Type Ia SNe themselves has been lacking. We
consider prospects for detection of CSM shells that have been predicted to be
common around Type Ia SNe. Such shells are most easily detected in Na I
absorption lines. Variable (declining) absorption is expected to occur soon
after the explosion, primarily during the SN rise time, for shells located
within 1 - 10 pc of a SN. The distance of the shell from the SN can be
determined by measuring the time scale for line variability.
[34]
oai:arXiv.org:0905.2769 [pdf] - 24355
Revisiting the Flip-Flop Instability of Hoyle-Lyttleton Accretion
Submitted: 2009-05-17
We revisit the flip-flop instability of two-dimensional planar accretion
using high-fidelity numerical simulations. By starting from an initially
steady-state axisymmetric solution, we are able to follow the growth of this
overstability from small amplitudes. In the small-amplitude limit, before any
transient accretion disk is formed, the oscillation period of the accretion
shock is comparable to the Keplerian period at the Hoyle-Lyttleton accretion
radius (R_a), independent of the size of the accreting object. The growth rate
of the overstability increases dramatically with decreasing size of the
accretor, but is relatively insensitive to the upstream Mach number of the
flow. We confirm that the flip-flop does not require any gradient in the
upstream flow. Indeed, a small density gradient as used in the discovery
simulations has virtually no influence on the growth rate of the overstability.
The ratio of specific heats does influence the overstability, with smaller
gamma leading to faster growth of the instability. For a relatively large
accretor (a radius of 0.037R_a) planar accretion is unstable for gamma = 4/3,
but stable for gamma > 1.6. Planar accretion is unstable even for gamma = 5/3
provided the accretor has a radius of < 0.0025R_a. We also confirm that when
the accretor is sufficiently small, the secular evolution is described by
sudden jumps between states with counter-rotating quasi-Keplerian accretion
disks.
[35]
oai:arXiv.org:0709.1484 [pdf] - 4792
Ascertaining the Core Collapse Supernova Mechanism: An Emerging Picture?
Submitted: 2007-09-10
Here we present the results from two sets of simulations, in two and three
spatial dimensions. In two dimensions, the simulations include multifrequency
flux-limited diffusion neutrino transport in the "ray-by-ray-plus"
approximation, two-dimensional self gravity in the Newtonian limit, and nuclear
burning through a 14-isotope alpha network. The three-dimensional simulations
are model simulations constructed to reflect the post stellar core bounce
conditions during neutrino shock reheating at the onset of explosion. They are
hydrodynamics-only models that focus on critical aspects of the shock stability
and dynamics and their impact on the supernova mechanism and explosion. In two
dimensions, we obtain explosions (although in one case weak) for two
progenitors (11 and 15 Solar mass models). Moreover, in both cases the
explosion is initiated when the inner edge of the oxygen layer accretes through
the shock. Thus, the shock is not revived while in the iron core, as previously
discussed in the literature. The three-dimensional studies of the development
of the stationary accretion shock instability (SASI) demonstrate the
fundamentally new dynamics allowed when simulations are performed in three
spatial dimensions. The predominant l=1 SASI mode gives way to a stable m=1
mode, which in turn has significant ramifications for the distribution of
angular momentum in the region between the shock and proto-neutron star and,
ultimately, for the spin of the remnant neutron star. Moreover, the
three-dimensional simulations make clear, given the increased number of degrees
of freedom, that two-dimensional models are severely limited by artificially
imposed symmetries.
[36]
oai:arXiv.org:0709.0537 [pdf] - 4575
Modeling core collapse supernovae in 2 and 3 dimensions with spectral
neutrino transport
Submitted: 2007-09-04
The overwhelming evidence that the core collapse supernova mechanism is
inherently multidimensional, the complexity of the physical processes involved,
and the increasing evidence from simulations that the explosion is marginal
presents great computational challenges for the realistic modeling of this
event, particularly in 3 spatial dimensions. We have developed a code which is
scalable to computations in 3 dimensions which couples PPM Lagrangian with
remap hydrodynamics [1], multigroup, flux-limited diffusion neutrino transport
[2], with many improvements), and a nuclear network [3]. The neutrino transport
is performed in a ray-by-ray plus approximation wherein all the lateral effects
of neutrinos are included (e.g., pressure, velocity corrections, advection)
except the transport. A moving radial grid option permits the evolution to be
carried out from initial core collapse with only modest demands on the number
of radial zones. The inner part of the core is evolved after collapse along
with the rest of the core and mantle by subcycling the lateral evolution near
the center as demanded by the small Courant times. We present results of 2-D
simulations of a symmetric and an asymmetric collapse of both a 15 and an 11 M
progenitor. In each of these simulations we have discovered that once the
oxygen rich material reaches the shock there is a synergistic interplay between
the reduced ram pressure, the energy released by the burning of the shock
heated oxygen rich material, and the neutrino energy deposition which leads to
a revival of the shock and an explosion.
[37]
oai:arXiv.org:0708.3858 [pdf] - 4345
A Deep Chandra Observation of Kepler's Supernova Remnant: A Type Ia
Event with Circumstellar Interaction
Submitted: 2007-08-29
We present initial results of a 750 ks Chandra observation of the remnant of
Kepler's supernova of AD 1604. The strength and prominence of iron emission,
together with the absence of O-rich ejecta, demonstrate that Kepler resulted
from a thermonuclear supernova, even though evidence for circumstellar
interaction is also strong. We have analyzed spectra of over 100 small regions,
and find that they fall into three classes. (1) The vast majority show Fe L
emission between 0.7 and 1 keV and Si and S K alpha emission; we associate
these with shocked ejecta. A few of these are found at or beyond the mean blast
wave radius. (2) A very few regions show solar O/Fe abundance rations; these we
associate with shocked circumstellar medium (CSM). Otherwise O is scarce. (3) A
few regions are dominated by continuum, probably synchrotron radiation.
Finally, we find no central point source, with a limit about 100 times fainter
than the central object in Cas A. The evidence that the blast wave is
interacting with CSM may indicate a Ia explosion in a more massive progenitor.
[38]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0611680 [pdf] - 87066
Pulsar spins from an instability in the accretion shock of supernovae
Submitted: 2006-11-21
Rotation-powered radio pulsars are born with inferred initial rotation
periods of order 300 ms (some as short as 20 ms) in core-collapse supernovae.
In the traditional picture, this fast rotation is the result of conservation of
angular momentum during the collapse of a rotating stellar core. This leads to
the inevitable conclusion that pulsar spin is directly correlated with the
rotation of the progenitor star. So far, however, stellar theory has not been
able to explain the distribution of pulsar spins, suggesting that the birth
rotation is either too slow or too fast. Here we report a robust instability of
the stalled accretion shock in core-collapse supernovae that is able to
generate a strong rotational flow in the vicinity of the accreting
proto-neutron star. Sufficient angular momentum is deposited on the
proto-neutron star to generate a final spin period consistent with
observations, even beginning with spherically symmetrical initial conditions.
This provides a new mechanism for the generation of neutron star spin and
weakens, if not breaks, the assumed correlation between the rotational periods
of supernova progenitor cores and pulsar spin.
[39]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0611698 [pdf] - 87084
Linear growth of spiral SASI modes in core-collapse supernovae
Submitted: 2006-11-21
Two-dimensional axisymmetric simulations have shown that the post-bounce
accretion shock in core collapse supernovae is subject to the Spherical
Accretion Shock Instability, or SASI. Recent three-dimensional simulations have
revealed the existence of a non-axisymmetric mode of the SASI as well, where
the postshock flow displays a spiral pattern. Here we investigate the growth of
these spiral modes using two-dimensional simulations of the post-bounce
accretion flow in the equatorial plane of a core-collapse supernova. By
perturbing a steady-state model we are able to excite both one, two and
three-armed spiral modes that grow exponentially with time, demonstrating that
these are linearly unstable modes closely related to the original axisymmetric
sloshing modes. By tracking the distribution of angular momentum, we show that
these modes are able to efficiently separate the angular momentum of the
accretion flow (which maintains a net angular momentum of zero), leading to a
significant spin-up of the underlying accreting proto-neutron star.
[40]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0610508 [pdf] - 85932
X-Ray Emission from Planetary Nebulae Calculated by 1D Spherical
Numerical Simulations
Submitted: 2006-10-17, last modified: 2006-11-13
We calculate the X-ray emission from both constant and time evolving shocked
fast winds blown by the central stars of planetary nebulae (PNs) and compare
with observations. Using spherically symmetric numerical simulations with
radiative cooling, we calculate the flow structure, and the X-ray temperature
and luminosity of the hot bubble formed by the shocked fast wind. We find that
a constant fast wind gives results that are very close to those obtained from
the self-similar solution. We show that in order for a fast shocked wind to
explain the observed X-ray properties of PNs, rapid evolution of the wind is
essential. More specifically, the mass loss rate of the fast wind should be
high early on when the speed is ~300-700 km/s, and then it needs to drop
drastically by the time the PN age reaches ~1000 yr. This implies that the
central star has a very short pre-PN (post-AGB) phase.
[41]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0507181 [pdf] - 74350
The Spherical Accretion Shock Instability in the Linear Regime
Submitted: 2005-07-07
We use time-dependent, axisymmetric, hydrodynamic simulations to study the
linear stability of the stalled, spherical accretion shock that arises in the
post-bounce phase of core-collapse supernovae. We show that this accretion
shock is stable to radial modes, with decay rates and oscillation frequencies
in close agreement with the linear stability analysis of Houck and Chevalier.
For non-spherical perturbations we find that the l=1 mode is always unstable
for parameters appropriate to core-collapse supernovae. We also find that the
l=2 mode is unstable, but typically has a growth rate smaller than that for
l=1. Furthermore, the l=1 mode is the only mode found to transition into a
nonlinear stage in our simulations. This result provides a possible explanation
for the dominance of an l=1 'sloshing' mode seen in many two-dimensional
simulations of core-collapse supernovae.
[42]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0409760 [pdf] - 67841
A Million-Second Chandra View of Cassiopeia A
Hwang, Una;
Laming, J. Martin;
Badenes, Carles;
Berendse, Fred;
Blondin, John;
Cioffi, Denis;
DeLaney, Tracey;
Dewey, Daniel;
Fesen, Robert;
Flanagan, Kathryn A.;
Fryer, Christopher L.;
Ghavamian, Parviz;
Hughes, John P.;
Morse, Jon A.;
Plucinsky, Paul P.;
Petre, Robert;
Pohl, Martin;
Rudnick, Lawrence;
Sankrit, Ravi;
Slane, Patrick O.;
Smith, Randall K.;
Vink, Jacco;
Warren, Jessica S.
Submitted: 2004-09-30
We introduce a million-second observation of the supernova remnant Cassiopeia
A with the Chandra X-ray Observatory. The bipolar structure of the Si-rich
ejecta (NE jet and SW counterpart) is clearly evident in the new images, and
their chemical similarity is confirmed by their spectra. These are most likely
due to jets of ejecta as opposed to cavities in the circumstellar medium, since
we can reject simple models for the latter. The properties of these jets and
the Fe-rich ejecta will provide clues to the explosion of Cas A.
[43]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0405276 [pdf] - 64796
Magnetic Rayleigh-Taylor instability for Pulsar Wind Nebulae in
expanding Supernova Remnants
Submitted: 2004-05-14
We present a numerical investigation of the development of Rayleigh-Taylor
instability at the interface between an expanding Pulsar Wind Nebula and its
surrounding Supernova Remnant. These systems have long been thought to be
naturally subject to this kind of instability, given their expansion behavior
and the density jump at the contact discontinuity. High resolution images of
the Crab Nebula at optical frequencies show the presence of a complex network
of line-emitting filaments protruding inside the synchrotron nebula. These
structures are interpreted as the observational evidence that Rayleigh-Taylor
instability is in fact at work. The development of this instability in the
regime appropriate to describe Supernova Remnant-Pulsar Wind Nebula systems is
non-trivial. The conditions at the interface are likely close to the stability
threshold, and the inclusion of the nebular magnetic field, which might play an
important role in stabilizing the system, is essential to the modeling. If
Rayleigh-Taylor features can grow efficiently a mixing layer in the outer
portion of the nebula might form where most of the supernova material is
confined. When a magnetic field close to equipartition is included we find that
the interface is stable, and that even a weaker magnetic field affects
substantially the growth and shape of the fingers.
[44]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0404328 [pdf] - 64236
The effects of spin-down on the structure and evolution of pulsar wind
nebulae
Submitted: 2004-04-16
We present high resolution spherically symmetric relativistic
magnetohydrodynamical simulations of the evolution of a pulsar wind nebula
inside the free expanding ejecta of the supernova progenitor. The evolution is
followed starting from a few years after the supernova explosion and up to an
age of the remnant of 1500 years. We consider different values of the pulsar
wind magnetization parameter and also different braking indices for the
spin-down process. We compare the numerical results with those derived through
an approximate semi-analytical approach that allows us to trace the time
evolution of the positions of both the pulsar wind termination shock and the
contact discontinuity between the nebula and the supernova ejecta. We also
discuss, whenever a comparison is possible, to what extent our numerical
results agree with former self-similar models, and how these models could be
adapted to take into account the temporal evolution of the system. The inferred
magnetization of the pulsar wind could be an order of magnitude lower than that
derived from time independent analytic models.
[45]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0303491 [pdf] - 55730
Spherically symmetric relativistic MHD simulations of pulsar wind
nebulae in supernova remnants
Submitted: 2003-03-21
Pulsars, formed during supernova explosions, are known to be sources of
relativistic magnetized winds whose interaction with the expanding supernova
remnants (SNRs) gives rise to a pulsar wind nebula (PWN). We present
spherically symmetric relativistic magnetohydrodynamics (RMHD) simulations of
the interaction of a pulsar wind with the surrounding SNR, both in particle and
magnetically dominated regimes. As shown by previous simulations, the evolution
can be divided in three phases: free expansion, a transient phase characterized
by the compression and reverberation of the reverse shock, and a final Sedov
expansion. The evolution of the contact discontinuity between the PWN and the
SNR (and consequently of the SNR itself) is almost independent of the
magnetization of the nebula as long as the total (magnetic plus particle)
energy is the same. However, a different behaviour of the PWN internal
structure is observable during the compression-reverberation phase, depending
on the degree of magnetization=2E The simulations were performed using the
third order conservative scheme by Del Zanna et al. (2003).
[46]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0210634 [pdf] - 52672
Stability of Standing Accretion Shocks, With an Eye Toward Core Collapse
Supernovae
Submitted: 2002-10-29
We examine the stability of standing, spherical accretion shocks. Accretion
shocks arise in core collapse supernovae (the focus of this paper), star
formation, and accreting white dwarfs and neutron stars. We present a simple
analytic model and use time-dependent hydrodynamics simulations to show that
this solution is stable to radial perturbations. In two dimensions we show that
small perturbations to a spherical shock front can lead to rapid growth of
turbulence behind the shock, driven by the injection of vorticity from the now
non-spherical shock. We discuss the ramifications this instability may have for
the supernova mechanism.
[47]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0107076 [pdf] - 43447
Pulsar Wind Nebulae in Evolved Supernova Remnants
Submitted: 2001-07-04
For pulsars similar to the one in the Crab Nebula, most of the energy input
to the surrounding wind nebula occurs on a timescale of less than 1000 years;
during this time, the nebula expands into freely expanding supernova ejecta. On
a timescale 10,000 years, the interaction of the supernova with the surrounding
medium drives a reverse shock front toward the center of the remnant, where it
crushes the PWN (pulsar wind nebula). One- and two-dimensional, two-fluid
simulations of the crushing and re-expansion phases of a PWN show that (1)
these phases are subject to Rayleigh-Taylor instabilities that result in the
mixing of thermal and nonthermal fluids, and (2) asymmetries in the surrounding
interstellar medium give rise to asymmetries in the position of the PWN
relative to the pulsar and explosion site. These effects are expected to be
observable in the radio emission from evolved PWN because of the long lifetimes
of radio emitting electrons. The scenario can explain the chaotic and
asymmetric appearance of the Vela X PWN relative to the Vela pulsar without
recourse to a directed flow from the vicinity of the pulsar. The displacement
of the radio nebulae in G327.1--1.1, MSH15--56 (G326.3--1.8), G0.9+0.1, and W44
relative to the X-ray nebulae may be due to this mechanism. On timescales much
greater than the nebular crushing time, the initial PWN may be mixed with
thermal gas and become unobservable, so that even the radio emission is
dominated by recently injected particles.
[48]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0104024 [pdf] - 41763
Rayleigh-Taylor Instabilities in Young Supernova Remnants Undergoing
Efficient Particle Acceleration
Submitted: 2001-04-02, last modified: 2001-06-14
We employ hydrodynamic simulations to study the effects of high shock
compression ratios, as expected for fast shocks with efficient particle
acceleration, on the convective instability of driven waves in supernova
remnants. We find that the instability itself does not depend significantly on
the compression ratio, but because the width of the interaction region between
the forward and reverse shocks can shrink significantly with increasing shock
compression, we find that convective instabilities can reach all the way to the
forward shock front if compression ratios are high enough.
[49]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0012494 [pdf] - 40083
Testing Hydrodynamic Models of LMC X-4 with UV and X-ray Spectra
Submitted: 2000-12-25
We compare the predictions of hydrodynamic models of the LMC X-4 X-ray binary
system with observations of UV P Cygni lines with the GHRS and STIS
spectrographs on the Hubble Space Telescope. The hydrodynamic model determines
density and velocity fields of the stellar wind, wind-compressed disk,
accretion stream, Keplerian accretion disk, and accretion disk wind. We use a
Monte Carlo code to determine the UV P Cygni line profiles by simulating the
radiative transfer of UV photons that originate on the star and are scattered
in the wind. The qualitative orbital variation predicted is similar to that
observed, although the model fails to reproduce the strong orbital asymmetry
(the observed absorption is strongest for phi>0.5). The model predicts a
mid-eclipse X-ray spectrum, due almost entirely to Compton scattering, with a
factor 4 less flux than observed with ASCA. We discuss how the model may need
to be altered to explain the spectral variability of the system.
[50]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0011072 [pdf] - 39079
Hydrodynamic Models of Line-Driven Accretion Disk Winds II: Adiabatic
Winds from Nonisothermal Disks
Submitted: 2000-11-02
We present here numerical hydrodynamic simulations of line-driven accretion
disk winds in cataclysmic variable systems. We calculate wind mass-loss rate,
terminal velocities, and line profiles for CIV (1550 A) for various viewing
angles. The models are 2.5-dimensional, include an energy balance condition,
and calculate the radiation field as a function of position near an optically
thick accretion disk. The model results show that centrifugal forces produce
collisions of streamlines in the disk wind which in turn generate an enhanced
density region, underlining the necessity of two dimensional calculations where
these forces may be represented. For disk luminosity Ldisk = Lsun, white dwarf
mass Mwd = 0.6 Msun, and white dwarf radii Rwd = 0.01 Rsun, we obtain a wind
mass-loss rate of dMwind/dt = 8.0E-12 Msun/yr, and a terminal velocity of ~3000
km/s. The line profiles we obtain are consistent with observations in their
general form, in particular in the maximum absorption at roughly half the
terminal velocity for the blue-shifted component, in the magnitudes of the wind
velocities implied by the absorption components, in the FWHM of the emission
components, and in the strong dependence in inclination angle.
[51]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0010285 [pdf] - 38632
Dynamics of Fe-Ni Bubbles in Young Supernova Remnants
Submitted: 2000-10-14
Observations of core-collapse supernovae (SNe) have revealed the presence of
extensive mixing of radioactive material in SN ejecta. The mixing of
radioactive material, mostly freshly synthesized Ni, is not complete, which
leads to a two-phase SN ejecta structure. The low-density phase consists of Fe
bubbles, created by the energy input from radioactive Co and Ni, surrounded by
compressed high-density metal-rich ejecta. We report on the theoretical
investigation of supernova remnant (SNR) dynamics with the two-phase SN ejecta.
We first present 3-dimensional hydrodynamic simulations of a single Fe bubble
immersed in an outer ejecta envelope, and compare the results with previous
work on shock-cloud interactions. We then consider randomly distributed Fe
bubbles with an average volume filling fraction of 1/2. We find that the
presence of Fe bubbles leads to vigorous turbulence and mixing of Fe with other
heavy elements and with the ambient normal-abundance gas. The turbulent energy
can be an order of magnitude larger than in the case of smooth ejecta. A
significant fraction of the shocked ejecta is found in narrow filaments and
clumps moving with radial velocities larger than the velocity of the forward
shock. Observational consequences of the two-phase ejecta on SNR X-ray spectra
and images are briefly mentioned.
[52]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9909181 [pdf] - 108217
Tidally-Driven Transport in Accretion Disks in Close Binary Systems
Submitted: 1999-09-10
The effects of binary tidal forces on transport within an accretion disk are
studied with a time-dependent hydrodynamical model of a two-dimensional
isothermal accretion disk. Tidal forces quickly truncate the accretion disk to
radii of order half the average radius of the Roche lobe, and excite a
two-armed spiral wave that remains stationary in the rotating reference frame
of the binary system. We measure an effective alpha of order 0.1 near the outer
edge of the disk in all of our models, independent of the mass ratio, Mach
number, and radial density profile. However, in cold disks with high Mach
number, the effective alpha drops rapidly with decreasing radius such that it
falls below our threshold of measurement (roughly .001) at a radius of only one
third the tidal radius. In warmer disks where the Mach numbers remain below 20,
we can measure an effective alpha down to radii 10 times smaller than the
maximum size of the disk.
[53]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9709188 [pdf] - 98641
Investigation of Neutrino-Driven Convection and the Core Collapse
Supernova Mechanism Using Multigroup Neutrino Transport
Submitted: 1997-09-18
We investigate neutrino-driven convection in core collapse supernovae and its
ramifications for the explosion mechanism, for a 15 solar mass model. Our
two-dimensional simulation begins at 12 ms after bounce and proceeds for 500
ms. We couple two-dimensional PPM hydrodynamics to precalculated
one-dimensional MGFLD neutrino transport. (The accuracy of this approximation
is assessed.) For the moment we sacrifice dimensionality for realism in other
aspects of our neutrino transport. MGFLD is an implementation of neutrino
transport that simultaneously (a) is multigroup and (b) simulates with greater
realism the transport of neutrinos in opaque, semitransparent, and transparent
regions. Both are crucial to the accurate determination of postshock neutrino
heating, which sensitively depends on the luminosities, spectra, and flux
factors of the electron neutrinos and antineutrinos emerging from their
respective neutrinospheres. By 212 ms after bounce, we see large-scale,
neutrino-driven convection beneath the shock, characterized by higher-entropy,
expanding upflows and denser, lower-entropy, finger-like downflows. The radial
convection velocities at this time become supersonic just below the shock,
reaching magnitudes in excess of 10^{9} cm/sec. Eventually, however, the shock
recedes to smaller radii, and at 500 ms after bounce there is no evidence in
our simulation of an explosion. While vigorous, neutrino-driven convection in
our model does not have a significant impact on the overall shock dynamics. The
differences between our results and those of other groups are considered. These
most likely result from differences in (1) numerical hydrodynamics methods, (2)
initial postbounce models, and most important, (3) neutrino transport
approximations.
[54]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9709184 [pdf] - 98637
The Interplay Between Protoneutron Star Convection and Neutrino
Transport in Core Collapse Supernovae
Submitted: 1997-09-18
We couple two-dimensional hydrodynamics to realistic one-dimensional
multigroup flux-limited diffusion neutrino transport to investigate
protoneutron star convection in core collapse supernovae, and more
specifically, the interplay between its development and neutrino transport, for
both 15 and 25 solar mass models. In the presence of neutrino transport,
protoneutron star convection velocities are too small relative to bulk inflow
velocities to result in any significant convective transport of entropy and
leptons. A simple analytical model supports our numerical results, indicating
that the inclusion of neutrino transport reduces the entropy-driven
(lepton-driven) convection growth rates and asymptotic velocities by a factor
of 3 (50) at the neutrinosphere and a factor 250 (1000) at a density of 10^{12}
g/cm^{3}, for both our 15 and 25 solar mass models. Moreover, when transport is
included, the initial postbounce entropy gradient is smoothed out by neutrino
diffusion, whereas the initial lepton gradient is maintained by electron
capture and neutrino escape near the neutrinosphere. Despite the maintenance of
the lepton gradient, protoneutron star convection does not develop over the 100
ms duration typical of all our simulations, except in the instance where
``low-test'' initial conditions are used, which are generated by core collapse
and bounce simulations that neglect neutrino-electron scattering and ion-ion
screening corrections to neutrino- nucleus elastic scattering.
[55]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9612107 [pdf] - 96135
An Investigation of Neutrino-Driven Convection and the Core Collapse
Supernova Mechanism Using Multigroup Neutrino Transport
Submitted: 1996-12-10
We investigate neutrino-driven convection in core collapse supernovae and its
ramifications for the explosion mechanism. We begin with an ``optimistic'' 15
solar mass precollapse model, which is representative of the class of stars
with compact iron cores. This model is evolved through core collapse and bounce
in one dimension using multigroup (neutrino-energy--dependent) flux-limited
diffusion (MGFLD) neutrino transport and Lagrangian hydrodynamics, providing
realistic initial conditions for the postbounce convection and evolution. Our
two-dimensional simulation begins at 106 ms after bounce at a time when there
is a well-developed gain region, and proceeds for 400 ms. We couple
two-dimensional (PPM) hydrodynamics to one-dimensional MGFLD neutrino
transport. At 225 ms after bounce we see large-scale convection behind the
shock, characterized by high-entropy, mushroom-like, expanding upflows and
dense, low-entropy, finger-like downflows. The upflows reach the shock and
distort it from sphericity. The radial convection velocities become supersonic
just below the shock, reaching magnitudes in excess of 10^9 cm/sec. Eventually,
however, the shock recedes to smaller radii, and at about 500 ms after bounce
there is no evidence in our simulation of an explosion or of a developing
explosion. Failure in our ``optimistic'' 15 solar mass Newtonian model leads us
to conclude that it is unlikely, at least in our approximation, that
neutrino-driven convection will lead to explosions for more massive stars with
fatter iron cores or in cases in which general relativity is included.
[56]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9609006 [pdf] - 95326
Deciphering Core Collapse Supernovae: Is Convection the Key? I. Prompt
Convection
Submitted: 1996-08-31
We couple two-dimensional hydrodynamics to detailed one-dimensional
multigroup flux-limited diffusion neutrino transport to investigate prompt
convection in core collapse supernovae. Our initial conditions, time-dependent
boundary conditions, and neutrino distributions for computing neutrino heating,
cooling, and deleptonization rates are obtained from one-dimensional
simulations that implement multigroup flux-limited diffusion neutrino transport
and one-dimensional hydrodynamics. The development and evolution of prompt
convection and its ramifications for the shock dynamics are investigated for
both 15 and 25 solar mass models, representative of the two classes of stars
with compact and extended iron cores, respectively. In the absence of neutrino
transport, prompt convection develops and dissipates on a time scale $\sim$15
ms for both models. Prompt convection seeds convection behind the shock, which
causes distortions in the shock's sphericity, but on the average, the shock
radius is not boosted significantly. In the presence of neutrino transport,
prompt convection velocities are too small relative to bulk inflow velocities
to result in any significant convective transport of entropy and leptons. A
simple analytical model supports our numerical results, indicating that the
inclusion of transport reduces the convection growth rates and asymptotic
velocities by factors of 4--250.
[57]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9601137 [pdf] - 93992
Axisymmetric circumstellar interaction in supernovae
Submitted: 1996-01-24
Multiwavelength observations of Type II supernovae have shown evidence for
the interaction of supernovae with the dense slow winds from the red supergiant
progenitor stars. Observations of planetary nebulae and the nebula around SN
1987A show that the slow winds from extended stars frequently have an axisymme-
tric structure with a high density in the equatorial plane. We have carried out
numerical calculations of the interaction of a supernova with such an axisymme-
tric density distribution. For small values of the angular density gradient at
the pole, the asymmetry in the interaction shell is greater than, but close to,
that expected from purely radial motion. If the angular density gradient is
above a moderate value, the flow qualitatively changes and a protrusion emerges
along the axis. For a power-law supernova density profile, the flow approaches
a self-similar state in which the protrusion length is $2-4$ times the radius
of the main shell. The critical density gradient is larger for steeper density
profiles of the ejecta. Most of our calculations are axisymmetric, but we have
carried out a 3-dimensional calculation to show that the protrusion is not a
numerical artifact along the symmetry axis. For typical supernova parameters,
the protrusions take $\gtrsim$ several years to develop. The appearance of the
shell with protrusions is similar to that observed in VLBI radio images of the
remnant 41.9 +58 in M82 and, possibly, of SN 1986J. We also considered the
possibility of asymmetric ejecta and found that it had a relatively small
effect on the asymmetry of the interaction region.