Normalized to: Bissantz, N.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1607.07226 [pdf] - 1443065
Uncertainty Limits on Solutions of Inverse Problems over Multiple Orders
of Magnitude using Bootstrap Methods: An Astroparticle Physics Example
Submitted: 2016-07-25
Astroparticle experiments such as IceCube or MAGIC require a deconvolution of
their measured data with respect to the response function of the detector to
provide the distributions of interest, e.g. energy spectra. In this paper,
appropriate uncertainty limits that also allow to draw conclusions on the
geometric shape of the underlying distribution are determined using bootstrap
methods, which are frequently applied in statistical applications. Bootstrap is
a collective term for resampling methods that can be employed to approximate
unknown probability distributions or features thereof. A clear advantage of
bootstrap methods is their wide range of applicability. For instance, they
yield reliable results, even if the usual normality assumption is violated.
The use, meaning and construction of uncertainty limits to any user-specific
confidence level in the form of confidence intervals and levels are discussed.
The precise algorithms for the implementation of these methods, applicable for
any deconvolution algorithm, are given. The proposed methods are applied to
Monte Carlo simulations to show their feasibility and their precision in
comparison to the statistical uncertainties calculated with the deconvolution
software TRUEE.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:0902.4636 [pdf] - 469401
How well do STARLAB and NBODY4 compare? I: Simple models
Submitted: 2009-02-26, last modified: 2009-02-27
N-body simulations are widely used to simulate the dynamical evolution of a
variety of systems, among them star clusters. Much of our understanding of
their evolution rests on the results of such direct N-body simulations. They
provide insight in the structural evolution of star clusters, as well as into
the occurrence of stellar exotica. Although the major pure N-body codes
STARLAB/KIRA and NBODY4 are widely used for a range of applications, there is
no thorough comparison study yet. Here we thoroughly compare basic quantities
as derived from simulations performed either with STARLAB/KIRA or NBODY4.
We construct a large number of star cluster models for various stellar mass
function settings (but without stellar/binary evolution, primordial binaries,
external tidal fields etc), evolve them in parallel with STARLAB/KIRA and
NBODY4, analyse them in a consistent way and compare the averaged results
quantitatively. For this quantitative comparison we develop a bootstrap
algorithm for functional dependencies.
We find an overall excellent agreement between the codes, both for the
clusters' structural and energy parameters as well as for the properties of the
dynamically created binaries. However, we identify small differences, like in
the energy conservation before core collapse and the energies of escaping
stars, which deserve further studies. Our results reassure the comparability
and the possibility to combine results from these two major N-body codes, at
least for the purely dynamical models (i.e. without stellar/binary evolution)
we performed. (abridged)
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:0812.3491 [pdf] - 19650
The Milky Way Spiral Arm Pattern
Submitted: 2008-12-18
A complete map of the 3D distribution of molecular (CO) gas was constructed
using a realistic dynamical model of the gas flow in the barred potential of
the Milky Way. The map shows two prominent spiral arms starting at the bar ends
connecting smoothly to the 4-armed spiral pattern observed in the atomic
hydrogen gas in the outer Galaxy. Unlike previous attempts, our new map
uncovers the gas distribution in the bar region of the Galaxy and the far side
of the disk. For the first time, we can follow spiral arms in gas as they pass
behind the galactic centre.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:0712.4264 [pdf] - 8502
3D Distribution of Molecular Gas in the Barred Milky Way
Submitted: 2007-12-27
We present a new model of the three-dimensional distribution of molecular gas
in the Milky Way Galaxy, based on CO line data. Our analysis is based on a
gas-flow simulation of the inner Galaxy using smoothed-particle hydrodynamics
(SPH) using a realistic barred gravitional potential derived from the observed
COBE/DIRBE near-IR light distribution. The gas model prescribes the gas orbits
much better than a simple circular rotation model and is highly constrained by
observations, but it cannot predict local details. In this study, we provide a
3D map of the observed molecular gas distribution using the velocity field from
the SPH model. A comparison with studies of the Galactic Center region suggests
that the main structures are reproduced but somewhat stretched along the
line-of-sight, probably on account of limited resolution of the underlying SPH
simulation. The gas model will be publicly available and may prove useful in a
number of applications, among them the analysis of diffuse gamma-ray emission
as measured with GLAST.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0702413 [pdf] - 469637
The Young Star Cluster System in the Antennae: Evidence for a Turnover
in the luminosity function
Submitted: 2007-02-15
The luminosity functions (LFs) of star cluster systems (i.e. the number of
clusters per luminosity interval) are vital diagnostics to probe the conditions
of star cluster formation. Early studies have revealed a clear dichotomy
between old globular clusters and young clusters, with the former characterised
by Gaussian-shaped LFs, and the latter following a power law. Recently, this
view was challenged by studies of galaxy merger remnants and post-starburst
galaxies. In this paper we re-evaluate the young ($\lta$ few hundreds of Myrs,
with the majority $\lta$ few tens of Myrs) star cluster system in the ongoing
spiral-spiral major merger system NGC 4038/39, the "Antennae" galaxies. The
Antennae galaxies represent a very active and complex star-forming environment,
which hampers cluster selection and photometry as well as the determination of
observational completeness fractions. A main issue of concern is the large
number of bright young stars contained in most earlier studies, which we
carefully exclude from our cluster sample by accurately determining the source
sizes. The resulting LFs are fitted both with Gaussian and with power-law
distributions, taking into account both the observational completeness
fractions and photometric errors, and compared using a likelihood ratio test.
The likelihood ratio results are rigidly evaluated using Monte Carlo
simulations. We perform a number of additional tests, e.g. with subsets of the
total sample, all confirming our main result: that a Gaussian distribution fits
the observed LFs of clusters in this preferentially very young cluster system
significantly better than a power-law distribution, at a (statistical) error
probability of less than 0.5 per cent.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0312461 [pdf] - 61674
Large-Scale Model of the Milky Way: Stellar Kinematics and Microlensing
Event Timescale Distribution in the Galactic Bulge
Submitted: 2003-12-17
We build a stellar-dynamical model of the Milky Way barred bulge and disk,
using a newly implemented adaptive particle method. The underlying mass model
has been previously shown to match the Galactic near-infrared surface
brightness as well as gas-kinematic observations. Here we show that the new
stellar-dynamical model also matches the observed stellar kinematics in several
bulge fields, and that its distribution of microlensing event timescales
reproduces the observed timescale distribution of the {\it MACHO} experiment
with a reasonable stellar mass function. The model is therefore an excellent
basis for further studies of the Milky Way. We also predict the observational
consequences of this mass function for parallax shifted events.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0309356 [pdf] - 469633
Analysing observed star cluster SEDs with evolutionary synthesis models:
Systematic uncertainties
Submitted: 2003-09-12
We discuss the systematic uncertainties inherent to analyses of observed
(broad-band) Spectral Energy Distributions (SEDs) of star clusters with
evolutionary synthesis models. We investigate the effects caused by restricting
oneself to a limited number of available passbands, choices of various passband
combinations, finite observational errors, non-continuous model input parameter
values, and restrictions in parameter space allowed during analysis. Starting
from a complete set of UBVRIJH passbands (respectively their Hubble Space
Telescope/WFPC2 equivalents) we investigate to which extent clusters with
different combinations of age, metallicity, internal extinction and mass can or
cannot be disentangled in the various evolutionary stages throughout their
lifetimes and what are the most useful passbands required to resolve the
ambiguities. We find the U and B bands to be of the highest significance, while
the V band and near-infrared data provide additional constraints. A code is
presented that makes use of luminosities of a star cluster system in all of the
possibly available passbands, and tries to find ranges of allowed
age-metallicity-extinction-mass combinations for individual members of star
cluster systems. Numerous tests and examples are presented. We show the
importance of good photometric accuracies and of determining the cluster
parameters independently without any prior assumptions.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0309153 [pdf] - 58980
Star Cluster Formation and Evolution in the Dwarf Starburst Galaxy NGC
1569
Submitted: 2003-09-04
We analyse multi-wavelength Hubble Space Telescope (HST) observations of a
large number of star clusters in the nearby (post-) starburst dwarf galaxy NGC
1569. Their spectral energy distributions (SEDs) cover at least the wavelength
range from U to I in equivalent HST filters, in most cases supplemented by
near-infrared data. Using our most up-to-date evolutionary synthesis models of
the Goettingen GALEV code we determine ages, metallicities, extinction values
and masses for each individual cluster robustly and independently. We confirm
the youth of most of these objects. The majority were formed in a very intense
starburst starting around 25 Myr ago. While there are two prominent ``super
star clusters'' present in this galaxy, with masses of (5-16) * 10^5 Msun,
almost all remaining clusters are significantly less massive than an average
Milky Way globular cluster, and are generally consistent with open cluster-type
objects. We determine the cluster mass function from individual cluster masses
derived by scaling the model SEDs of known mass to the observed cluster SEDs
for each individual cluster. We find signs of a change in the cluster mass
function as the burst proceeds, which we attribute to the special conditions of
star cluster formation in this starburst dwarf galaxy environment.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0308250 [pdf] - 58529
Large-scale Gas Dynamics in the Milky Way
Submitted: 2003-08-14
We present new gas flow models for the Milky Way inside the solar circle.
Using a mass model derived from the COBE/DIRBE maps and clump giant star
counts, and using a parametric model for the spiral arm pattern in the disk, we
calculate the gas flow and compare with 12CO observations. We find that models
with 4 spiral arms fit the observations better then 2-armed models. We also
find that models with separate pattern speeds for the bar and spiral arms can
explain the gas flow in the bar corotation region better than single-pattern
speed models.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0301169 [pdf] - 54140
Parametric versus non-parametric modelling? Statistical evidence based
on P-value curves
Submitted: 2003-01-10
In astrophysical (inverse) regression problems it is an important task to
decide whether a given parametric model describes the observational data
sufficiently well or whether a non-parametric modelling becomes necessary.
However, in contrast to common practice this cannot be decided by solely
comparing the quality of fit due to possible over-fitting by the non-parametric
method. Therefore, in this paper we present a resampling algorithm which allows
to decide whether deviations between a parametric and a non-parametric model
are systematic or due to noise. The algorithm is based on a statistical
comparison of the corresponding residuals, under the assumption of the
parametric model as well as under violation of this assumption. This yields a
graphical tool for a robust decision making of parametric versus non-parametric
modelling.
Moreover, our approach can be used for the selection of the most proper model
among several competitors (model selection). The methods are illustrated by the
problem of recovering the luminosity density in the Milky Way [MW] from
near-infrared [NIR] surface brightness data of the DIRBE experiment on board of
the COBE satellite. Among the parametric models investigated one with 4-armed
spiral structure performs best. In this model the Sagittarius-Carina arm and
its counter-arm are significantly weaker than the other pair of arms.
Furthermore, we find statistical evidence for an improvement over a range of
parametric models with different spiral structure morphologies by a
non-parametric model of Bissantz & Gerhard (2002).
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0212516 [pdf] - 53906
Gas Dynamics in the Milky Way: Second Pattern Speed and Large-Scale
Morphology
Submitted: 2002-12-23
We present new gas flow models for the Milky Way inside the solar circle. To
this end we use SPH simulations in gravitational potentials determined from the
NIR luminosity distribution (including spiral arms) which are based on the
COBE/DIRBE maps. Gas flows in models which include massive spiral arms clearly
match the observed 12CO lvplot better than if the potential does not include
spiral structure. Besides single pattern speed models we investigate models
with separate pattern speeds for the bar and spiral arms. The most important
difference is that in the latter case the gas spiral arms go through the bar
corotation region, keeping the gas aligned with the arms there. In the (l,v)
plot this results in characteristic regions which appear to be nearly void of
gas.In single pattern speed models these regions are filled with gas because
the spiral arms dissolve in the bar corotation region. Comparing with the 12CO
data we find evidence for separate pattern speeds in the Milky Way.From a
series of models the preferred range for the bar pattern speed is Om_p=60\pm5
/Gyr, corresponding to corotation at 3.4\pm0.3kpc. The spiral pattern speed is
less well constrained, but our preferred value is Om_sp\approx 20 /Gyr. A
further series of gas models is computed for different bar angles, using
separately determined luminosity models and gravitational potentials in each
case. We find acceptable gas models for 20<=\phibar<=25. The model with
(\phibar=20, Om_p=60 /Gyr, Om_sp=20 /Gyr) gives an excellent fit to the spiral
arm ridges in the observed (l,v) plot.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0205536 [pdf] - 49610
A graphical selection method for parametric models in noisy
inhomogeneous regression
Submitted: 2002-05-30
A common problem in physics is to fit regression data by a parametric class
of functions, and to decide whether a certain functional form allows for a good
fit of the data. Common goodness of fit methods are based on the calculation of
the distribution of certain statistical quantities under the assumption that
the model under consideration {\it holds true}. This proceeding bears
methodological flaws, e.g. a good ``fit'' - albeit the model is wrong - might
be due to over-fitting, or to the fact that the chosen statistical criterion is
not powerful enough against the present particular deviation between model and
true regression function. This causes particular difficulties when models with
different numbers of parameters are to be compared. Therefore the number of
parameters is often penalised additionally. We provide a methodology which
circumvents these problems to some extent. It is based on the consideration of
the error distribution of the goodness of fit criterion under a broad range of
possible models - and not only under the assumption that a given model holds
true. We present a graphical method to decide for the most evident model from a
range of parametric models of the data. The method allows to quantify
statistical evidence {\it for} the model (up to some distance between model and
true regression function) and not only {\it absence of evidence} against, as
common goodness of fit methods do. Finally we apply our method to the problem
of recovering the luminosity density of the Milky Way from a de-reddened {\it
COBE/DIRBE} L-band map. We present statistical evidence for flaring of the
stellar disc inside the solar circle.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0110368 [pdf] - 45425
Spiral arms, bar shape and bulge microlensing in the Milky Way
Submitted: 2001-10-16
A new model for the luminosity distribution in the inner Milky Way is found,
using a non-parametric penalized maximum-likelihood algorithm to deproject a
dereddened COBE/DIRBE L-band map of the inner Galaxy. The model is also
constrained by the apparent magnitude (line-of-sight) distributions of clump
giant stars in certain bulge fields. An important new feature is the inclusion
of a spiral arm model in the disk. Spiral arms make the model appear broader on
the sky, thus our bar is more elongated than in previous eight-fold symmetric
models. They also lead to a smoother disk model interior to the Sun. The bar
length is approx. 3.5kpc and its axis ratios are 1:(0.3-0.4):0.3, independent
of whether the spiral arm model is 4-armed or 2-armed. The larger elongation in
the plane makes it possible to reproduce the observed clump giant distributions
as well. For the bar angle we estimate 15^o <= phi <= 30^o, with the best
models obtained for 20^o <= phi <= 25^o. We use our reference model to predict
a microlensing optical depth map towards the bulge, normalising its mass by the
observed terminal velocity curve. For clump giant sources at (l,b)=(3.9,-3.8)
we find tau_{-6}:=tau/10^{-6}=1.27, within 1.8*sigma of the new MACHO
measurement given by Popowski et al. The value for all sources at
(l,b)=(2.68,-3.35) is tau_{-6}=1.1, still >3*sigma away from the published
MACHO DIA value. The dispersion of these tau_{-6} values within our models is
10%. Because the distribution of sources is well-fit by the NIR model,
increasing the predicted optical depths by >20% will be difficult. Thus the
high value of the measured clump giant optical depth argues for a near-maximal
disk in the Milky Way. (abridged)
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0106351 [pdf] - 43147
New statistical goodness of fit techniques in noisy inhomogeneous
inverse problems - With application to the recovering of the luminosity
distribution of the Milky Way
Submitted: 2001-06-20
The assumption that a parametric class of functions fits the data structure
sufficiently well is common in fitting curves and surfaces to regression data.
One then derives a parameter estimate resulting from a least squares fit, say,
and in a second step various kinds of chi^2 goodness of fit measures, to assess
whether the deviation between data and estimated surface is due to random noise
and not to systematic departures from the model. In this paper we show that
commonly-used chi^2-measures are invalid in regression models, particularly
when inhomogeneous noise is present. Instead we present a bootstrap algorithm
which is applicable in problems described by noisy versions of Fredholm
integral equations. of the first kind. We apply the suggested method to the
problem of recovering the luminosity density in the Milky Way from data of the
DIRBE experiment on board the COBE satellite.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0003330 [pdf] - 35204
Is Galactic Structure Compatible with Microlensing Data?
Submitted: 2000-03-22, last modified: 2000-04-04
We generalize to elliptical models the argument of Kuijken (1997), which
connects the microlensing optical depth towards the Galactic bulge to the
Galactic rotation curve. When applied to the latest value from the MACHO
collaboration for the optical depth for microlensing of bulge sources, the
argument implies that the Galactic bar cannot plausibly reconcile the measured
values of the optical depth, the rotation curve and the local mass density.
Either there is a problem with the interpretation of the microlensing data, or
our line of sight to the Galactic centre is highly atypical in that it passes
through a massive structure that wraps only a small distance around the
Galactic centre.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9612026 [pdf] - 1234850
Microlensing Optical Depth of the COBE Bulge
Submitted: 1996-12-03
We examine the left-right asymmetry in the cleaned COBE/DIRBE near-infrared
data of the inner Galaxy and show (i) that the Galactic bar is probably not
seen very nearly end-on, and (ii) that even if it is, it is not highly
elongated. The assumption of constant mass-to-light ratio is used to derive
simulated terminal-velocity plots for the ISM from our model luminosity
distributions. By comparing these plots with observed terminal velocities we
determine the mass-to-light ratio of the near-IR bulge and disk.
Assuming that all this mass contributes to gravitational microlensing we
compute optical depths $\tau$ for microlensing in Galactic-centre fields. For
three models with bar major axis between $10\deg-25\deg$ from the Sun-Galactic
Center line, the resulting optical depths in Baade's window lie in the range
$0.83\times10^{-6} \lta \tau \lta 0.89\times10^{-6}$ for main-sequence stars
and $1.2\times10^{-6} \lta \tau \lta 1.3\times10^{-6}$ for red-clump giants. We
discuss a number of uncertainties including possible variations of the
near-infrared mass-to-light ratio. We conclude that, although the values
predicted from analyzing the COBE and gas velocity data are inconsistent at the
$2-2.5\sigma$ level with recent observational determinations of $\tau$, we
believe they should be taken seriously.