Normalized to: Birnstiel, T.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2007.05274 [pdf] - 2131979
Disk Evolution Study Through Imaging of Nearby Young Stars (DESTINYS): A
close low mass companion to ET Cha
Ginski, C.;
Ménard, F.;
Rab, Ch.;
Mamajek, E. E.;
van Holstein, R. G.;
Benisty, M.;
Manara, C. F.;
Torres, R. Asensio;
Bohn, A.;
Birnstiel, T.;
Delorme, P.;
Facchini, S.;
Garufi, A.;
Gratton, R.;
Hogerheijde, M.;
Huang, J.;
Kenworthy, M.;
Langlois, M.;
Pinilla, P.;
Pinte, C.;
Ribas, Á.;
Rosotti, G.;
Schmidt, T. O. B.;
Ancker, M. van den;
Wahhaj, Z.;
Waters, L. B. F. M.;
Williams, J.;
Zurlo, A.
Submitted: 2020-07-10
To understand the formation of planetary systems, one needs to understand the
initial conditions of planet formation, i.e. the young gas-rich planet forming
disks. Spatially resolved high-contrast observations are of particular
interest, since substructures in disks, linked to planet formation, can be
detected and close companions or even planets in formation embedded in the disk
can be revealed. In this study we present the first result of the DESTINYS
survey (Disk Evolution Study Through Imaging of Nearby Young Stars). DESTINYS
is an ESO/SPHERE large program that aims at studying disk evolution in
scattered light, mainly focusing on a sample of low-mass stars (<1$M_\odot$) in
nearby (~200 pc) star-forming regions. In this particular study we present the
observations of the ET Cha (RECX 15) system, a nearby 'old' classical T Tauri
star (5-8 Myr, ~100 pc), which is still strongly accreting. We use SPHERE/IRDIS
in H-band polarimetric imaging mode to obtain high contrast images of the ET
Cha system to search for scattered light from the circumstellar disk as well as
thermal emission from close companions. We additionally employ VLT/NACO total
intensity archival data taken in 2003. We report here the discovery of a
low-mass (sub)stellar companion with SPHERE/IRDIS to ET Cha. We are estimating
the mass of this new companion based on photometry. Depending on the system age
it is a 5 Myr, 50 $M_{Jup}$ brown dwarf or an 8 Myr, 0.10 $M_\odot$ M-type
pre-main-sequence star. We explore possible orbital solutions and discuss the
recent dynamic history of the system. Independent of the precise companion mass
we find that the presence of the companion likely explains the small size of
the disk around ET Cha. The small separation of the binary pair indicates that
the disk around the primary component is likely clearing from the outside in,
explaining the high accretion rate of the system.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:2006.08799 [pdf] - 2115462
Constraining the parameter space for the Solar Nebula
Submitted: 2020-06-15
If we want to understand planetesimal formation, the only data set we have is
our own Solar System. It is particularly interesting as it is so far the only
planetary system we know of that developed life. Understanding the conditions
under which the Solar Nebula evolved is crucial in order to understand the
different processes in the disk and the subsequent dynamical interaction
between (proto-)planets, once the gas disk is gone. Protoplanetary disks
provide a plethora of different parameters to explore. The question is whether
this parameter space can be constrained, allowing simulations to reproduce the
Solar System. Models and observations of planet formation provide constraints
on the initial planetesimal mass in certain regions of the Solar Nebula. By
making use of pebble flux-regulated planetesimal formation, we perform a
parameter study with nine different disk parameters like the initial disk mass,
initial disk size, initial dust-to-gas ratio, turbulence level, and more. We
find that the distribution of mass in planetesimals in the disk depends on the
planetesimal formation timescale and the pebbles' drift timescale. Multiple
disk parameters can influence pebble properties and thus planetesimal
formation. However, it is still possible to draw some conclusions on potential
parameter ranges. Pebble flux-regulated planetesimal formation seems to be very
robust, allowing simulations with a wide range of parameters to meet the
initial planetesimal constraints for the Solar Nebula. I.e., it does not
require a lot of fine tuning.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:2003.06522 [pdf] - 2077059
Planet-induced Vortices with Dust Coagulation in Protoplanetary Disks
Submitted: 2020-03-13
In this work, we study how the dust coagulation/fragmentation will influence
the evolution and observational appearances of vortices induced by a massive
planet embedded in a low viscosity disk by performing global 2D high-resolution
hydrodynamical simulations. Within the vortex, due to its higher gas surface
density and steeper pressure gradients, dust coagulation, fragmentation and
drift (to the vortex center) are all quite efficient, producing dust particles
ranging from micron to $\sim 1.0\ {\rm cm}$, as well as overall high
dust-to-gas ratio (above unity). In addition, the dust size distribution is
quite non-uniform inside the vortex, with the mass weighted average dust size
at the vortex center ($\sim 4.0$ mm) being a factor of $\sim10$ larger than
other vortex regions. Both large ($\sim$ mm) and small (tens of micron)
particles contribute strongly to affect the gas motion within the vortex. As
such, we find that the inclusion of dust coagulation has a significant impact
on the vortex lifetime and the typical vortex lifetime is about 1000 orbits.
After the initial gaseous vortex is destroyed, the dust spreads into a ring
with a few remaining smaller gaseous vortices with a high dust concentration
and a large maximum size ($\sim$ mm). At late time, the synthetic dust
continuum images for the coagulation case show as a ring inlaid with several
hot spots at 1.33 mm band, while only distinct hot spots remain at 7.0 mm.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1906.07708 [pdf] - 2072543
Gas accretion damped by dust back-reaction at the snow line
Submitted: 2019-06-18, last modified: 2020-02-27
Context. The water snowline divides dry and icy solid material in
protoplanetary disks, and has been thought to significantly affect planet
formation at all stages. If dry particles break up more easily than icy ones,
then the snowline causes a traffic jam, because small grains drift inward at
lower speeds than larger pebbles. Aims. We aim to evaluate the effect of high
dust concentrations around the snowline onto the gas dynamics. Methods. Using
numerical simulations, we model the global radial evolution of an axisymmetric
protoplanetary disk. Our model includes particle growth, evaporation and
recondensation of water, and the back-reaction of dust onto the gas, taking
into account the vertical distribution of dust particles. Results. We find that
the dust back-reaction can stop and even reverse the net flux of gas outside
the snowline, decreasing the gas accretion rate onto the star to under $50\%$
of its initial value. At the same time the dust accumulates at the snowline,
reaching dust-to-gas ratios of $\epsilon \gtrsim 0.8$, and delivers large
amounts of water vapor towards the inner disk, as the icy particles cross the
snowline. However, the accumulation of dust at the snowline and the decrease in
the gas accretion rate only take place if the global dust-to-gas ratio is high
($\varepsilon_0 \gtrsim 0.03$), if the viscous turbulence is low ($\alpha_\nu
\lesssim 10^{-3} $), if the disk is large enough ($r_c \gtrsim 100\,
\textrm{au}$), and only during the early phases of the disk evolution ($t
\lesssim 1\, \textrm{Myr}$). Otherwise the dust back-reaction fails to perturb
the gas motion.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:2001.11040 [pdf] - 2061705
A multi-frequency ALMA characterization of substructures in the GM Aur
protoplanetary disk
Huang, Jane;
Andrews, Sean M.;
Dullemond, Cornelis P.;
Oberg, Karin I.;
Qi, Chunhua;
Zhu, Zhaohuan;
Birnstiel, Tilman;
Carpenter, John M.;
Isella, Andrea;
Macias, Enrique;
McClure, Melissa K.;
Perez, Laura M.;
Teague, Richard;
Wilner, David J.;
Zhang, Shangjia
Submitted: 2020-01-29
The protoplanetary disk around the T Tauri star GM Aur was one of the first
hypothesized to be in the midst of being cleared out by a forming planet. As a
result, GM Aur has had an outsized influence on our understanding of disk
structure and evolution. We present 1.1 and 2.1 mm ALMA continuum observations
of the GM Aur disk at a resolution of ~50 mas (~8 au), as well as HCO$^+$
$J=3-2$ observations at a resolution of ~100 mas. The dust continuum shows at
least three rings atop faint, extended emission. Unresolved emission is
detected at the center of the disk cavity at both wavelengths, likely due to a
combination of dust and free-free emission. Compared to the 1.1 mm image, the
2.1 mm image shows a more pronounced "shoulder" near R~40 au, highlighting the
utility of longer-wavelength observations for characterizing disk
substructures. The spectral index $\alpha$ features strong radial variations,
with minima near the emission peaks and maxima near the gaps. While low
spectral indices have often been ascribed to grain growth and dust trapping,
the optical depth of GM Aur's inner two emission rings renders their dust
properties ambiguous. The gaps and outer disk ($R>100$ au) are optically thin
at both wavelengths. Meanwhile, the HCO$^+$ emission indicates that the gas
cavity is more compact than the dust cavity traced by the millimeter continuum,
similar to other disks traditionally classified as "transitional."
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:2001.10545 [pdf] - 2061699
Dust entrainment in photoevaporative winds: The impact of X-rays
Submitted: 2020-01-28
X-ray- and EUV- (XEUV-) driven photoevaporative winds acting on
protoplanetary disks around young T-Tauri stars may crucially impact disk
evolution, affecting both gas and dust distributions. We investigate the dust
entrainment in XEUV-driven photoevaporative winds and compare our results to
existing MHD and EUV-only models. For an X-ray luminosity of $L_X = 2 \cdot
10^{30}\,\mathrm{erg/s}$ emitted by a $M_* = 0.7\,\mathrm{M}_\odot$ star,
corresponding to a wind mass-loss rate of $\dot{M}_\mathrm{w} \simeq 2.6 \cdot
10^{-8} \,\mathrm{M_\odot/yr}$, we find dust entrainment for sizes $a_0
\lesssim 11\,\mu$m ($9\,\mu$m) from the inner $25\,$AU ($120\,$AU). This is an
enhancement over dust entrainment in less vigorous EUV-driven winds with
$\dot{M}_\mathrm{w} \simeq 10^{-10}\,\mathrm{M_\odot/yr}$. Our numerical model
also shows deviations of dust grain trajectories from the gas streamlines even
for $\mu$m-sized particles. In addition, we find a correlation between the size
of the entrained grains and the maximum height they reach in the outflow.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1912.11178 [pdf] - 2042344
Ring Morphology with Dust Coagulation in Protoplanetary Disks
Submitted: 2019-12-23
Tidal interactions between the embedded planets and their surrounding
protoplanetary disks are often postulated to produce the observed complex dust
substructures, including rings, gaps, and asymmetries. In this Letter, we
explore the consequences of dust coagulation on the dust dynamics and ring
morphology. Coagulation of dust grains leads to dust size growth which, under
typical disk conditions, produces faster radial drifts, potentially threatening
the dust ring formation. Utilizing 2D hydrodynamical simulations of
protoplanetary disks which include a full treatment of dust coagulation, we
find that if the planet does not open a gap quickly enough, the formation of an
inner ring is impeded due to dust coagulation and subsequent radial drift.
Furthermore, we find that a "buildup" of sub-mm sized grains often appears in
the dust emission at the outer edge of the dust disk.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1909.10526 [pdf] - 2025860
Including Dust Coagulation in Hydrodynamic Models of Protoplanetary
Disks: Dust Evolution in the Vicinity of a Jupiter-mass Planet
Submitted: 2019-09-23
Dust growth is often neglected when building models of protoplanetary disks
due to its complexity and computational expense. However, it does play a major
role in shaping the evolution of protoplanetary dust and planet formation. In
this paper, we present a numerical model coupling 2-D hydrodynamic evolution of
a protoplanetary disk, including a Jupiter-mass planet, and dust coagulation.
This is obtained by including multiple dust fluids in a single grid-based
hydrodynamic simulation and solving the Smoluchowski equation for dust
coagulation on top of solving for the hydrodynamic evolution. We find that
fragmentation of dust aggregates trapped in a pressure bump outside of the
planetary gap leads to an enhancement in density of small grains. We compare
the results obtained from the full coagulation treatment to the commonly used,
fixed dust size approach and to previously applied, less computationally
intensive methods for including dust coagulation. We find that the full
coagulation results cannot be reproduced using the fixed-size treatment, but
some can be mimicked using a relatively simple method for estimating the
characteristic dust size in every grid cell.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1909.04674 [pdf] - 1975444
The DSHARP Rings: Evidence of Ongoing Planetesimal Formation?
Submitted: 2019-09-10
Recent high-resolution interferometric observations of protoplanetary disks
at (sub-)millimeter wavelengths reveal omnipresent substructures, such as
rings, spirals, and asymmetries. A detailed investigation of eight rings
detected in five disks by the DSHARP survey came to the conclusion that all
rings are just marginally optically thick with optical depths between 0.2 and
0.5 at a wavelength of 1.25 mm. This surprising result could either be
coincidental or indicate that the optical depth in all of the rings is
regulated by the same process.
We investigated if ongoing planetesimal formation could explain the
"fine-tuned" optical depths in the DSHARP rings by removing dust and
transforming it into "invisible" planetesimals. We performed a one-dimensional
simulation of dust evolution in the second dust ring of the protoplanetary disk
around HD 163296, including radial transport of gas and dust, dust growth and
fragmentation, and planetesimal formation via gravitational collapse of
sufficiently dense pebble concentrations.
We show that planetesimal formation can naturally explain the observed
optical depths if streaming instability regulates the midplane dust-to-gas
ratio to unity. Furthermore, our simple monodisperse analytical model supports
the hypothesis that planetesimal formation in dust rings should universally
limit their optical depth to the observed range.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1904.02127 [pdf] - 1890422
One Solution to the Mass Budget Problem for Planet Formation: Optically
Thick Disks with Dust Scattering
Zhu, Zhaohuan;
Zhang, Shangjia;
Jiang, Yan-Fei;
Kataoka, Akimasa;
Birnstiel, Tilman;
Dullemond, Cornelis P.;
Andrews, Sean M.;
Huang, Jane;
Perez, Laura M.;
Carpenter, John M.;
Bai, Xue-Ning;
Wilner, David J.;
Ricci, Luca
Submitted: 2019-04-03, last modified: 2019-05-07
ALMA surveys have suggested that the dust in Class II disks may not be enough
to explain the averaged solid mass in exoplanets, under the assumption that the
mm disk continuum emission is optically thin. This optically thin assumption
seems to be supported by recent DSHARP observations where the measured optical
depths of spatially resolved disks are mostly less than one. However, we point
out that dust scattering can considerably reduce the emission from an optically
thick region. If that scattering is ignored, the optical depth will be
considerably underestimated. An optically thick disk with scattering can be
misidentified as an optically thin disk. Dust scattering in more inclined disks
can reduce the intensity even further, making the disk look even fainter. The
measured optical depth of $\sim$0.6 in several DSHARP disks can be naturally
explained by optically thick dust with an albedo of $\sim$0.9 at 1.25 mm. Using
the DSHARP opacity, this albedo corresponds to a dust population with the
maximum grain size ($s_{max}$) of 0.1-1 mm. For optically thick scattering
disks, the measured spectral index $\alpha$ can be either larger or smaller
than 2 depending on if the dust albedo increases or decreases with wavelength.
Using the DSHARP opacity, $\alpha<2$ corresponds to $s_{max}$ of 0.03-0.3 mm.
We describe how this optically thick scattering scenario could explain the
observed scaling between submm continuum sizes and luminosities, and might help
ease the tension between the dust size constraints from polarization and dust
continuum measurements. We suggest that a significant amount of disk mass can
be hidden from ALMA observations at short millimeter wavelengths. For compact
disks smaller than 30 au, we can easily underestimate the dust mass by more
than a factor of 10. Longer wavelength observations (e.g. VLA or SKA) are
desired to probe the dust mass in disks.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1905.01285 [pdf] - 1901923
Effects of Ringed Structures and Dust Size Growth on Millimeter
Observations of Protoplanetary Disks
Li, Ya-Ping;
Li, Hui;
Ricci, Luca;
Li, Shengtai;
Birnstiel, Tilman;
Isella, Andrea;
Ansdell, Megan;
Yuan, Feng;
Drazkowska, Joanna;
Stammler, Sebastian
Submitted: 2019-05-03
The growth of solids from sub-micron to millimeter and centimeter sizes is
the early step toward the formation of planets inside protoplanetary disks
(PPDs). However, such processes and their potential impact on the later stages
of solid growth are still poorly understood. In this work, we test the
hypothesis that most disks contain at least one ringed structure with a
relative small radius. We have carried out a large family of 1D two-fluid
(gas+dust) hydrodynamical simulations by evolving the gas and dust motion
self-consistently while allowing dust size to evolve via coagulation and
fragmentation. We investigate the joint effects of ringed structures and dust
size growth on the overall sub-millimeter and millimeter (mm) flux and spectral
index of PPDs. Ringed structures slow down the dust radial drift and speed up
the dust growth. In particular, we find that those unresolved disks with a high
fragmentation velocity ($\sim10\ {\rm m~s^{-1}}$) and a high dust surface
density ($\sim10\ {\rm g\ cm^{-2}}$ in the ring) can have mm spectral indices
as low as $\sim2.0$, consistent with mm observations of faint disks in nearby
star forming regions. Furthermore, disks with more than one ringed structure
can potentially reproduce brighter disks with spectral indices lower than
$\sim2.5$. Future multi-wavelength high-resolution observations of these low
spectral index sources can be used to test the existence of the ringed
structures in the unresolved disks and differentiate the effects of dust size
growth from optical depth.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1902.07089 [pdf] - 1863015
Planetesimal Population Synthesis: Pebble Flux Regulated Planetesimal
Formation
Submitted: 2019-02-19, last modified: 2019-04-06
We propose an expression for a local planetesimal formation rate proportional
to the instantaneous radial pebble flux. The result --- a radial planetesimal
distribution --- can be used as initial condition to study the formation of
planetary embryos. We follow the idea that one needs particle traps to locally
enhance the dust-to-gas ratio sufficiently such that particle gas interactions
can no longer prevent planetesimal formation on small scales. The location of
these traps can emerge everywhere in the disk. Their occurrence and lifetime is
subject of ongoing research, thus they are implemented via free parameters.
This enables us to study the influence of the disk properties on the formation
of planetesimals, predicting their time dependent formation rates and location
of primary pebble accretion. We show that large $\alpha$-values of $0.01$
(strong turbulence) prevent the formation of planetesimals in the inner part of
the disk, arguing for lower values of around $0.001$ (moderate turbulence), at
which planetesimals form quickly at all places where they are needed for
proto-planets. Planetesimals form as soon as dust has grown to pebbles
($\sim\mathrm{mm}$ to $\mathrm{dm}$) and the pebble flux reaches a critical
value, which is after a few thousand years at $2-3\,$AU and after a few hundred
thousand years at $20-30\,$AU. Planetesimal formation lasts until the pebble
supply has decreased below a critical value. The final spatial planetesimal
distribution is steeper compared to the initial dust and gas distribution which
helps to explain the discrepancy between the minimum mass solar nebula and
viscous accretion disks.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1903.05077 [pdf] - 1847123
Protoplanetary Disk Science Enabled by Extremely Large Telescopes
Jang-Condell, Hannah;
Brittain, Sean;
Weinberger, Alycia;
Liu, Michael;
Faherty, Jacqueline;
Bae, Jaehan;
Andrews, Sean;
Ansdell, Megan;
Birnstiel, Til;
Boss, Alan;
Close, Laird;
Currie, Thayne;
Desch, Steven J;
Dodson-Robinson, Sarah;
Dong, Chuanfei;
Duchene, Gaspard;
Espaillat, Catherine;
Follette, Kate;
Gaidos, Eric;
Gao, Peter;
Haghighipour, Nader;
Hartnett, Hilairy;
Hasegawa, Yasuhiro;
Kama, Mihkel;
Kim, Jinyoung Serena;
Kóspál, Ágnes;
Lisse, Carey;
Lyra, Wladimir;
Macintosh, Bruce;
Mawet, Dimitri;
McGehee, Peregrine;
Meyer, Michael;
Peretz, Eliad;
Perez, Laura;
Pontoppidan, Klaus;
Sallum, Steph;
Salyk, Colette;
Szentgyorgyi, Andrew;
Wagner, Kevin
Submitted: 2019-03-12
The processes that transform gas and dust in circumstellar disks into diverse
exoplanets remain poorly understood. One key pathway is to study exoplanets as
they form in their young ($\sim$few~Myr) natal disks. Extremely Large
Telescopes (ELTs) such as GMT, TMT, or ELT, can be used to establish the
initial chemical conditions, locations, and timescales of planet formation, via
(1)~measuring the physical and chemical conditions in protoplanetary disks
using infrared spectroscopy and (2)~studying planet-disk interactions using
imaging and spectro-astrometry. Our current knowledge is based on a limited
sample of targets, representing the brightest, most extreme cases, and thus
almost certainly represents an incomplete understanding. ELTs will play a
transformational role in this arena, thanks to the high spatial and spectral
resolution data they will deliver. We recommend a key science program to
conduct a volume-limited survey of high-resolution spectroscopy and
high-contrast imaging of the nearest protoplanetary disks that would result in
an unbiased, holistic picture of planet formation as it occurs.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1812.04193 [pdf] - 1815119
The Disk Substructures at High Angular Resolution Project (DSHARP): III.
Spiral Structures in the Millimeter Continuum of the Elias 27, IM Lup, and
WaOph 6 Disks
Huang, Jane;
Andrews, Sean M.;
Pérez, Laura M.;
Zhu, Zhaohuan;
Dullemond, Cornelis P.;
Isella, Andrea;
Benisty, Myriam;
Bai, Xue-Ning;
Birnstiel, Tilman;
Carpenter, John M.;
Guzmán, Viviana V.;
Hughes, A. Meredith;
Öberg, Karin I.;
Ricci, Luca;
Wilner, David J.;
Zhang, Shangjia
Submitted: 2018-12-10, last modified: 2019-01-14
We present an analysis of ALMA 1.25 millimeter continuum observations of
spiral structures in three protoplanetary disks from the Disk Substructures at
High Angular Resolution Project. The disks around Elias 27, IM Lup, and WaOph 6
were observed at a resolution of $\sim40-60$ mas ($\sim6-7$ au). All three
disks feature $m=2$ spiral patterns in conjunction with annular substructures.
Gas kinematics established by $^{12}$CO $J=2-1$ observations indicate that the
continuum spiral arms are trailing. The arm-interarm intensity contrasts are
modest, typically less than 3. The Elias 27 spiral pattern extends throughout
much of the disk, and the arms intersect the gap at $R\sim69$ au. The spiral
pattern in the IM Lup disk is particularly complex-it extends about halfway
radially through the disk, exhibiting pitch angle variations with radius and
interarm features that may be part of ring substructures or spiral arm
branches. Spiral arms also extend most of the way through the WaOph 6 disk, but
the source overall is much more compact than the other two disks. We discuss
possible origins for the spiral structures, including gravitational instability
and density waves induced by a stellar or planetary companion. Unlike the
millimeter continuum counterparts of many of the disks with spiral arms
detected in scattered light, these three sources do not feature high-contrast
crescent-like asymmetries or large ($R>20$ au) emission cavities. This
difference may point to multiple spiral formation mechanisms operating in
disks.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1812.04041 [pdf] - 1814209
The Disk Substructures at High Angular Resolution Project (DSHARP): II.
Characteristics of Annular Substructures
Huang, Jane;
Andrews, Sean M.;
Dullemond, Cornelis P.;
Isella, Andrea;
Pérez, Laura M.;
Guzmán, Viviana V.;
Öberg, Karin I.;
Zhu, Zhaohuan;
Zhang, Shangjia;
Bai, Xue-Ning;
Benisty, Myriam;
Birnstiel, Tilman;
Carpenter, John M.;
Hughes, A. Meredith;
Ricci, Luca;
Weaver, Erik;
Wilner, David J.
Submitted: 2018-12-10, last modified: 2019-01-14
The Disk Substructures at High Angular Resolution Project used ALMA to map
the 1.25 millimeter continuum of protoplanetary disks at a spatial resolution
of ~5 au. We present a systematic analysis of annular substructures in the 18
single-disk systems targeted in this survey. No dominant architecture emerges
from this sample; instead, remarkably diverse morphologies are observed.
Annular substructures can occur at virtually any radius where millimeter
continuum emission is detected and range in widths from a few au to tens of au.
Intensity ratios between gaps and adjacent rings range from near-unity to just
a few percent. In a minority of cases, annular substructures co-exist with
other types of substructures, including spiral arms (3/18) and crescent-like
azimuthal asymmetries (2/18). No clear trend is observed between the positions
of the substructures and stellar host properties. In particular, the absence of
an obvious association with stellar host luminosity (and hence the disk thermal
structure) suggests that substructures do not occur preferentially near major
molecular snowlines. Annular substructures like those observed in DSHARP have
long been hypothesized to be due to planet-disk interactions. A few disks
exhibit characteristics particularly suggestive of this scenario, including
substructures in possible mean-motion resonance and "double gap" features
reminiscent of hydrodynamical simulations of multiple gaps opened by a planet
in a low-viscosity disk.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1810.06194 [pdf] - 1822908
The dimming of RW Auriga. Is dust accretion preceding an outburst?
Submitted: 2018-10-15, last modified: 2019-01-08
RW Aur A has experienced various dimming events in the last years, decreasing
its brightness by $\sim 2\ \textrm{mag}$ for periods of months to years.
Multiple observations indicate that a high concentration of dust grains, from
the protoplanetary disk's inner regions, is blocking the starlight during these
events. We propose a new mechanism that can send large amounts of dust close to
the star on short timescales, through the reactivation of a dead zone in the
protoplanetary disk. Using numerical simulations we model the accretion of gas
and dust, along with the growth and fragmentation of particles in this
scenario. We find that after the reactivation of the dead zone, the accumulated
dust is rapidly accreted towards the star in around 15 years, at rates of
$\dot{M}_\textrm{d} = 6 \times 10^{-6}\, \textrm{M}_\odot/\textrm{yr}$ and
reaching dust-to-gas ratios of $\epsilon \approx 5$, preceding an increase in
the gas accretion by a few years. This sudden rise of dust accretion can
provide the material required for the dimmings, although the question of how to
put the dust into the line of sight remains open to speculation.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1812.04043 [pdf] - 1811243
The Disk Substructures at High Angular Resolution Project (DSHARP): V.
Interpreting ALMA maps of protoplanetary disks in terms of a dust model
Birnstiel, Tilman;
Dullemond, Cornelis P.;
Zhu, Zhaohuan;
Andrews, Sean M.;
Bai, Xue-Ning;
Wilner, David J.;
Carpenter, John M.;
Huang, Jane;
Isella, Andrea;
Benisty, Myriam;
Pérez, Laura M.;
Zhang, Shangjia
Submitted: 2018-12-10
The Disk Substructures at High Angular Resolution Project (DSHARP) is the
largest homogeneous high-resolution ($\sim 0.035$ arcsec, or $\sim$ 5 au) disk
continuum imaging survey with ALMA so far. In the coming years, many more disks
will be mapped with ALMA at similar resolution. Interpreting the results in
terms of the properties and quantities of the emitting dusty material is,
however, a very non-trivial task. This is in part due to the uncertainty in the
dust opacities, an uncertainty which is not likely to be resolved any time
soon. It is also partly due to the fact that, as the DSHARP survey has shown,
these disk often contain regions of intermediate to high optical depth, even at
millimeter wavelengths and at relatively large radius in the disk. This makes
the interpretation challenging, in particular if the grains are large and have
a large albedo. On the other hand, the highly structured features seen in the
DSHARP survey, of which strong indications were already seen in earlier
observations, provide a unique opportunity to study the dust growth and
dynamics. To provide continuity within the DSHARP project, its follow-up
projects, and projects by other teams interested in these data, we present here
the methods and opacity choices used within the DSHARP collaboration to link
the measured intensity $I_\nu$ to dust surface density $\Sigma_d$.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1812.04040 [pdf] - 1811241
The Disk Substructures at High Angular Resolution Project (DSHARP): I.
Motivation, Sample, Calibration, and Overview
Andrews, Sean M.;
Huang, Jane;
Pérez, Laura M.;
Isella, Andrea;
Dullemond, Cornelis P.;
Kurtovic, Nicolás T.;
Guzmán, Viviana V.;
Carpenter, John M.;
Wilner, David J.;
Zhang, Shangjia;
Zhu, Zhaohuan;
Birnstiel, Tilman;
Bai, Xue-Ning;
Benisty, Myriam;
Hughes, A. Meredith;
Öberg, Karin I.;
Ricci, Luca
Submitted: 2018-12-10
We introduce the Disk Substructures at High Angular Resolution Project
(DSHARP), one of the initial Large Programs conducted with the Atacama Large
Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA). The primary goal of DSHARP is to find
and characterize substructures in the spatial distributions of solid particles
for a sample of 20 nearby protoplanetary disks, using very high resolution
(0.035 arcsec, or 5 au FWHM) observations of their 240 GHz (1.25 mm) continuum
emission. These data provide a first homogeneous look at the small-scale
features in disks that are directly relevant to the planet formation process,
quantifying their prevalence, morphologies, spatial scales, spacings, symmetry,
and amplitudes, for targets with a variety of disk and stellar host properties.
We find that these substructures are ubiquitous in this sample of large, bright
disks. They are most frequently manifested as concentric, narrow emission rings
and depleted gaps, although large-scale spiral patterns and small arc-shaped
azimuthal asymmetries are also present in some cases. These substructures are
found at a wide range of disk radii (from a few au to more than 100 au), are
usually compact ($<$10 au), and show a wide range of amplitudes (brightness
contrasts). Here we discuss the motivation for the project, describe the survey
design and the sample properties, detail the observations and data calibration,
highlight some basic results, and provide a general overview of the key
conclusions that are presented in more detail in a series of accompanying
articles. The DSHARP data -- including visibilities, images, calibration
scripts, and more -- are released for community use at
https://almascience.org/alma-data/lp/DSHARP.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1812.04044 [pdf] - 1811244
The Disk Substructures at High Angular Resolution Project (DSHARP) VI:
Dust trapping in thin-ringed protoplanetary disks
Dullemond, Cornelis P.;
Birnstiel, Tilman;
Huang, Jane;
Kurtovic, Nicolás T.;
Andrews, Sean M.;
Guzmán, Viviana V.;
Pérez, Laura M.;
Isella, Andrea;
Zhu, Zhaohuan;
Benisty, Myriam;
Wilner, David J.;
Bai, Xue-Ning;
Carpenter, John M.;
Zhang, Shangjia;
Ricci, Luca
Submitted: 2018-12-10
A large fraction of the protoplanetary disks observed with ALMA display
multiple well-defined and nearly perfectly circular rings in the continuum, in
many cases with substantial peak-to-valley contrast. The DSHARP campaign shows
that several of these rings are very narrow in radial extent. In this paper we
test the hypothesis that these dust rings are caused by dust trapping in radial
pressure bumps, and if confirmed, put constraints on the physics of the dust
trapping mechanism. We model this process analytically in 1D, assuming
axisymmetry. By comparing this model to the data, we find that all rings are
consistent with dust trapping. Based on a plausible model of the dust
temperature we find that several rings are narrower than the pressure scale
height, providing strong evidence for dust trapping. The rings have peak
absorption optical depth in the range between 0.2 and 0.5. The dust masses
stored in each of these rings is of the order of tens of Earth masses, though
much ambiguity remains due to the uncertainty of the dust opacities. The dust
rings are dense enough to potentially trigger the streaming instability, but
our analysis cannot give proof of this mechanism actually operating. Our
results show, however, that the combination of very low alpha_turb << 5e-4 and
very large grains a_grain >> 0.1 cm can be excluded by the data for all the
rings studied in this paper.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1812.04045 [pdf] - 1811245
The Disk Substructures at High Angular Resolution Project (DSHARP): VII.
The Planet-Disk Interactions Interpretation
Zhang, Shangjia;
Zhu, Zhaohuan;
Huang, Jane;
Guzmán, Viviana V.;
Andrews, Sean M.;
Birnstiel, Tilman;
Dullemond, Cornelis P.;
Carpenter, John M.;
Isella, Andrea;
Pérez, Laura M.;
Benisty, Myriam;
Wilner, David J.;
Baruteau, Clément;
Bai, Xue-Ning;
Ricci, Luca
Submitted: 2018-12-10
The Disk Substructures at High Angular Resolution Project (DSHARP) provides a
large sample of protoplanetary disks having substructures which could be
induced by young forming planets. To explore the properties of planets that may
be responsible for these substructures, we systematically carry out a grid of
2-D hydrodynamical simulations including both gas and dust components. We
present the resulting gas structures, including the relationship between the
planet mass and 1) the gaseous gap depth/width, and 2) the sub/super-Keplerian
motion across the gap. We then compute dust continuum intensity maps at the
frequency of the DSHARP observations. We provide the relationship between the
planet mass and 1) the depth/width of the gaps at millimeter intensity maps, 2)
the gap edge ellipticity and asymmetry, and 3) the position of secondary gaps
induced by the planet. With these relationships, we lay out the procedure to
constrain the planet mass using gap properties, and study the potential planets
in the DSHARP disks. We highlight the excellent agreement between observations
and simulations for AS 209 and the detectability of the young Solar System
analog. Finally, under the assumption that the detected gaps are induced by
young planets, we characterize the young planet population in the planet
mass-semimajor axis diagram. We find that the occurrence rate for $>$ 5 $M_J$
planets beyond 5-10 au is consistent with direct imaging constraints. Disk
substructures allow us probe a wide-orbit planet population (Neptune to Jupiter
mass planets beyond 10 au) that is not accessible to other planet searching
techniques.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:1812.04046 [pdf] - 1811246
Disk Substructures at High Angular Resolution Program (DSHARP): VIII.
The Rich Ringed Substructures in the AS 209 Disk
Guzmán, Viviana V.;
Huang, Jane;
Andrews, Sean M.;
Isella, Andrea;
Pérez, Laura M.;
Carpenter, John M.;
Dullemond, Cornelis P.;
Ricci, Luca;
Birnstiel, Tilman;
Zhang, Shangjia;
Zhu, Zhaohuan;
Bai, Xue-Ning;
Benisty, Myriam;
Öberg, Karin I.;
Wilner, David J.
Submitted: 2018-12-10
We present a detailed analysis of the high-angular resolution (0.''037,
corresponding to 5 au) observations of the 1.25 mm continuum and $^{12}$CO
$2-1$ emission from the disk around the T Tauri star AS 209. AS 209 hosts one
of the most unusual disks from the DSHARP sample, the first high angular
resolution ALMA survey of disks (Andrews et al. 2018), as nearly all of the
emission can be explained with concentric Gaussian rings. In particular, the
dust emission consists of a series of narrow and closely spaced rings in the
inner $\sim$60 au, two well-separated bright rings in the outer disk, centered
at 74 and 120 au, and at least two fainter emission features at 90 and 130 au.
We model the visibilities with a parametric representation of the radial
surface brightness profile, consisting of a central core and 7 concentric
Gaussian rings. Recent hydro-dynamical simulations of low viscosity disks show
that super-Earth planets can produce the multiple gaps seen in AS 209
millimeter continuum emission. The $^{12}$CO line emission is centrally peaked
and extends out to $\sim$300 au, much farther than the millimeter dust
emission. We find axisymmetric, localized deficits of CO emission around four
distinct radii, near 45, 75, 120 and 210 au. The outermost gap is located well
beyond the edge of the millimeter dust emission, and therefore cannot be due to
dust opacity and must be caused by a genuine CO surface density reduction, due
either to chemical effects or depletion of the overall gas content.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:1812.04047 [pdf] - 1811247
The Disk Substructures at High Angular Resolution Project (DSHARP) - IX.
A high definition study of the HD 163296 planet forming disk
Isella, Andrea;
Huang, Jane;
Andrews, Sean M.;
Dullemond, Cornelis P.;
Birnstiel, Tilman;
Zhang, Shangjia;
Zhu, Zhaohuan;
Guzmán, Viviana V.;
Pérez, Laura M.;
Bai, Xue-Ning;
Benisty, Myriam;
Carpenter, John M.;
Ricci, Luca;
Wilner, David J.
Submitted: 2018-12-10
ALMA observations of protoplanetary disks acquired by the Disk Substructure
at High Angular Resolution Project (DSHARP) resolve the dust and gas emission
on angular scales as small as 3 astronomical units, offering an unprecedented
detailed view of the environment where planets form. In this article, we
present and discuss observations of the HD 163296 protoplanetary disk that
imaged the 1.25 mm dust continuum and $^{12}$CO J=2-1 rotational line emission
at a spatial resolution of 4 and 10 au, respectively. The continuum
observations resolve and allow us to characterize the previously discovered
dust rings at radii of 67 and 100 au. They also reveal new small scale
structures, such as a dark gap at 10 au, a bright ring at 15 au, a dust
crescent at a radius of 55 au, and several fainter azimuthal asymmetries. The
observations of the CO and dust emission inform about the vertical structure of
the disk and allow us to directly constrain the dust extinction optical depth
at the dust rings. Furthermore, the observed asymmetries in the dust continuum
emission corroborate to the hypothesis that the complex structure of the HD
163296 disk is the result of the gravitational interaction with yet unseen
planets.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:1812.04049 [pdf] - 1811248
The Disk Substructures at High Angular Resolution Project (DSHARP): X.
Multiple rings, a misaligned inner disk, and a bright arc in the disk around
the T Tauri star HD 143006
Pérez, Laura M.;
Benisty, Myriam;
Andrews, Sean M.;
Isella, Andrea;
Dullemond, Cornelis P.;
Huang, Jane;
Kurtovic, Nicolás T.;
Guzmán, Viviana V.;
Zhu, Zhaohuan;
Birnstiel, Tilman;
Zhang, Shangjia;
Carpenter, John M.;
Wilner, David J.;
Ricci, Luca;
Bai, Xue-Ning;
Weaver, Erik;
Öberg, Karin I.
Submitted: 2018-12-10
We present a detailed analysis of new ALMA observations of the disk around
the T-Tauri star HD 143006, which at 46 mas (7.6 au) resolution reveal new
substructures in the 1.25 mm continuum emission. The disk resolves into a
series of concentric rings and gaps together with a bright arc exterior to the
rings that resembles hydrodynamics simulations of a vortex, and a bridge-like
feature connecting the two innermost rings. Although our $^{12}$CO observations
at similar spatial resolution do not show obvious substructure, they reveal an
inner disk depleted of CO emission. From the continuum emission and the CO
velocity field we find that the innermost ring has a higher inclination than
the outermost rings and the arc. This is evidence for either a small
($\sim8^{\circ}$) or moderate ($\sim41^{\circ}$) misalignment between the inner
and outer disk, depending on the specific orientation of the near/far sides of
the inner/outer disk. We compare the observed substructures in the ALMA
observations with recent scattered light data from VLT/SPHERE of this object.
In particular, the location of narrow shadow lanes in the SPHERE image combined
with pressure scale height estimates, favor a large misalignment of about
$41^{\circ}$. We discuss our findings in the context of a dust-trapping vortex,
planet-carved gaps, and a misaligned inner disk due to the presence of an
inclined companion to HD 143006.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:1809.06403 [pdf] - 1769514
Science with an ngVLA: Dust growth and dust trapping in protoplanetary
disks
Submitted: 2018-09-17, last modified: 2018-10-18
ALMA has revolutionized our view of protoplanetary disks, revealing
structures such as gaps, rings and asymmetries that indicate dust trapping as
an important mechanism in the planet formation process. However, the high
resolution images have also shown that the optically thin assumption for
millimeter continuum emission may not be valid and the low values of the
spectral index may be related to optical depth rather than dust growth. Longer
wavelength observations are essential to properly disentangle these effects.
The high sensitivity and spatial resolution of the next-generation Very Large
Array (ngVLA) will open up the possibilities to spatially resolve disk
continuum emission at centimeter wavelengths and beyond, which allows the study
of dust growth in disks in the optically thin regime and further constrain
models of planet formation.
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:1810.04961 [pdf] - 1791152
Evidence For A Vertical Dependence on the Pressure Structure in AS 209
Submitted: 2018-10-11
We present an improved method to measure the rotation curves for disks with
non-axisymmetric brightness profiles initially published in Teague et al.
(2018a). Application of this method to the well studied AS$~$209 system shows
substantial deviations from Keplerian rotation of up to $\pm 5\%$. These
deviations are most likely due to perturbations in the gas pressure profile,
including a perturbation located at $\approx 250~$au and spanning up to
$\approx 50~$au which is only detected kinematically. Modelling the required
temperature and density profiles required to recover the observed rotation
curve we demonstrate that the rings observed in $\mu$m scattered light are
coincident with the pressure maxima, and are radially offset from the rings
observed in mm continuum emission. This suggests that if rings in the NIR are
due to sub-$\mu$m grains trapped in pressure maxima that there is a vertical
dependence on the radius of the pressure minima.
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:1808.09472 [pdf] - 1751990
Diverse protoplanetary disk morphology produced by a Jupiter-mass planet
Submitted: 2018-08-28, last modified: 2018-08-29
Combining hydrodynamic planet-disk interaction simulations with dust
evolution models, we show that protoplanetary disks having a giant planet can
reveal diverse morphology in (sub-)millimeter continuum, including a full disk
without significant radial structure, a transition disk with an inner cavity, a
disk with a single gap and a central continuum peak, and a disk with multiple
rings and gaps. Such a diversity originates from (1) the level of viscous
transport in the disk which determines the number of gaps a planet can open;
(2) the size and spatial distributions of grains determined by the coagulation,
fragmentation, and radial drift, which in turn affects the emmisivity of the
disk at (sub-)millimeter wavelengths; and (3) the angular resolution used to
observe the disk. In particular, our results show that disks having the same
underlying gas distribution can have very different grain size/spatial
distributions and thus appearance in continuum, depending on the interplay
among coagulation, fragmentation, and radial drift. This suggests that proper
treatments for the grain growth have to be included in models of protoplanetary
disks concerning continuum properties and that complementary molecular line
observations are highly desired in addition to continuum observations to reveal
the true nature of disks. The fact that a single planet can produce diverse
disk morphology emphasizes the need to search for more direct, localized
signatures of planets in order to confirm (or dispute) the planetary origin of
observed ringed substructures.
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:1808.01768 [pdf] - 1751948
Temperature, Mass and Turbulence: A Spatially Resolved Multi-Band
Non-LTE Analysis of CS in TW~Hya
Submitted: 2018-08-06
Observations of multiple rotational transitions from a single molecule allow
for unparalleled constraints on the physical conditions of the emitting region.
We present an analysis of CS in TW~Hya using the $J=7-6$, $5-4$ and $3-2$
transitions imaged at $\sim 0.5^{\prime\prime}$ spatial resolution, resulting
in a temperature and column density profile of the CS emission region extending
out to 230~au, far beyond previous measurements. In addition, the 15~kHz
resolution of the observations and the ability to directly estimate the
temperature of the CS emitting gas, allow for one of the most sensitive
searches for turbulent broadening in a disk to date. Limits of $v_{\rm turb}
\lesssim 0.1 c_s$ can be placed across the entire radius of the disk. We are
able to place strict limits of the local H$_2$ density due to the collisional
excitations of the observed transitions. From these we find that a minimum disk
mass of $3 \times 10^{-4}~M_{\rm sun}$ is required to be consistent with the CS
excitation conditions and can uniquely constrain the gas surface density
profile in the outer disk.
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:1807.06995 [pdf] - 1718655
Optical dimming of RW Aur associated with an iron rich corona and
exceptionally high absorbing column density
Günther, Hans Moritz;
Birnstiel, T.;
Huenemoerder, D. P.;
Principe, D. A.;
Schneider, P. C.;
Wolk, S. J.;
Dubois, Franky;
Logie, Ludwig;
Rau, Steve;
Vanaverbeke, Sigfried
Submitted: 2018-07-18
RW Aur is a binary system composed of two young, low-mass stars. The primary,
RW Aur A, has undergone visual dimming events ($\Delta V =2-3$~mag) in 2011,
2014-16, and 2017-2018. Visual and IR observations indicate a gray absorber
that moved into the line-of-sight. This dimming is also associated with changes
in the outflow. In 2017, when the optical brightness was almost 2~mag below the
long-term average we triggered a Chandra observation to measure the absorbing
column density $N_\mathrm{H}$ and to constrain dust properties and the
gas-to-dust ratio of the absorber. In 2017, the X-ray spectrum is more absorbed
than it was in the optically bright state ($N_\mathrm{H} = (4\pm 1) \times
10^{23}\;\mathrm{cm}^{-2}$) and shows significantly more hot plasma than in
X-ray observations taken before. Also, a new emission feature at $6.63\pm0.02$
keV (statistic) $\pm0.02$ keV (systematic) appeared indicating an Fe abundance
an order of magnitude above Solar, in contrast with previous sub-Solar Fe
abundance measurements. Comparing X-ray absorbing column density $N_\mathrm{H}$
and optical extinction $A_V$, we find that either the gas-to-dust ratio in the
absorber is orders of magnitude higher than in the ISM or the absorber has
undergone significant dust evolution. Given the high column density coupled
with changes in the X-ray spectral shape, this absorber is probably located in
the inner disk. We speculate that a break-up of planetesimals or a terrestrial
planet could supply large grains causing gray absorption; some of these grains
would be accreted and enrich the stellar corona with iron which could explain
the inferred high abundance.
[29]
oai:arXiv.org:1806.11568 [pdf] - 1747971
Discovery of a planetary-mass companion within the gap of the transition
disk around PDS 70
Keppler, M.;
Benisty, M.;
Müller, A.;
Henning, Th.;
van Boekel, R.;
Cantalloube, F.;
Ginski, C.;
van Holstein, R. G.;
Maire, A. -L.;
Pohl, A.;
Samland, M.;
Avenhaus, H.;
Baudino, J. -L.;
Boccaletti, A.;
de Boer, J.;
Bonnefoy, M.;
Chauvin, G.;
Desidera, S.;
Langlois, M.;
Lazzoni, C.;
Marleau, G.;
Mordasini, C.;
Pawellek, N.;
Stolker, T.;
Vigan, A.;
Zurlo, A.;
Birnstiel, T.;
Brandner, W.;
Feldt, M.;
Flock, M.;
Girard, J.;
Gratton, R.;
Hagelberg, J.;
Isella, A.;
Janson, M.;
Juhasz, A.;
Kemmer, J.;
Kral, Q.;
Lagrange, A. -M.;
Launhardt, R.;
Matter, A.;
Ménard, F.;
Milli, J.;
Mollière, P.;
Olofsson, J.;
Perez, L.;
Pinilla, P.;
Pinte, C.;
Quanz, S. P.;
Schmidt, T.;
Udry, S.;
Wahhaj, Z.;
Williams, J. P.;
Buenzli, E.;
Cudel, M.;
Dominik, C.;
Galicher, R.;
Kasper, M.;
Lannier, J.;
Mesa, D.;
Mouillet, D.;
Peretti, S.;
Perrot, C.;
Salter, G.;
Sissa, E.;
Wildi, F.;
Abe, L.;
Antichi, J.;
Augereau, J. -C.;
Baruffolo, A.;
Baudoz, P.;
Bazzon, A.;
Beuzit, J. -L.;
Blanchard, P.;
Brems, S. S.;
Buey, T.;
De Caprio, V.;
Carbillet, M.;
Carle, M.;
Cascone, E.;
Cheetham, A.;
Claudi, R.;
Costille, A.;
Delboulbé, A.;
Dohlen, K.;
Fantinel, D.;
Feautrier, P.;
Fusco, T.;
Giro, E.;
Gisler, D.;
Gluck, L.;
Gry, C.;
Hubin, N.;
Hugot, E.;
Jaquet, M.;
Mignant, D. Le;
Llored, M.;
Madec, F.;
Magnard, Y.;
Martinez, P.;
Maurel, D.;
Meyer, M.;
Moeller-Nilsson, O.;
Moulin, T.;
Mugnier, L.;
Origne, A.;
Pavlov, A.;
Perret, D.;
Petit, C.;
Pragt, J.;
Puget, P.;
Rabou, P.;
Ramos, J.;
Rigal, F.;
Rochat, S.;
Roelfsema, R.;
Rousset, G.;
Roux, A.;
Salasnich, B.;
Sauvage, J. -F.;
Sevin, A.;
Soenke, C.;
Stadler, E.;
Suarez, M.;
Turatto, M.;
Weber, L.
Submitted: 2018-06-29, last modified: 2018-07-12
Young circumstellar disks are of prime interest to understand the physical
and chemical conditions under which planet formation takes place. Only very few
detections of planet candidates within these disks exist, and most of them are
currently suspected to be disk features. In this context, the transition disk
around the young star PDS 70 is of particular interest, due to its large gap
identified in previous observations, indicative of ongoing planet formation. We
aim to search for the presence of planets and search for disk structures
indicative for disk-planet interactions and other evolutionary processes. We
analyse new and archival near-infrared (NIR) images of the transition disk PDS
70 obtained with the VLT/SPHERE, VLT/NaCo and Gemini/NICI instruments in
polarimetric differential imaging (PDI) and angular differential imaging (ADI)
modes. We detect a point source within the gap of the disk at about 195 mas
(about 22 au) projected separation. The detection is confirmed at five
different epochs, in three filter bands and using different instruments. The
astrometry results in an object of bound nature, with high significance. The
comparison of the measured magnitudes and colours to evolutionary tracks
suggests that the detection is a companion of planetary mass. We confirm the
detection of a large gap of about 54 au in size within the disk in our
scattered light images, and detect a signal from an inner disk component. We
find that its spatial extent is very likely smaller than about 17 au in radius.
The images of the outer disk show evidence of a complex azimuthal brightness
distribution which may in part be explained by Rayleigh scattering from very
small grains. Future observations of this system at different wavelengths and
continuing astrometry will allow us to test theoretical predictions regarding
planet-disk interactions, planetary atmospheres and evolutionary models.
[30]
oai:arXiv.org:1805.10290 [pdf] - 1705335
A Kinematical Detection of Two Embedded Jupiter Mass Planets in HD
163296
Submitted: 2018-05-25, last modified: 2018-05-30
We present the first kinematical detection of embedded protoplanets within a
protoplanetary disk. Using archival ALMA observations of HD 163296, we
demonstrate a new technique to measure the rotation curves of CO isotopologue
emission to sub-percent precision relative to the Keplerian rotation. These
rotation curves betray substantial deviations caused by local perturbations in
the radial pressure gradient, likely driven by gaps carved in the gas surface
density by Jupiter-mass planets. Comparison with hydrodynamic simulations shows
excellent agreement with the gas rotation profile when the disk surface density
is perturbed by two Jupiter mass planets at 83 au and 137 au. As the rotation
of the gas is dependent on the pressure of the total gas component, this method
provides a unique probe of the gas surface density profile without incurring
significant uncertainties due to gas-to-dust ratios or local chemical
abundances which plague other methods. Future analyses combining both methods
promise to provide the most accurate and robust measures of embedded planetary
mass. Furthermore, this method provides a unique opportunity to explore
wide-separation planets beyond the mm continuum edge and to trace the gas
pressure profile essential in modelling grain evolution in disks.
[31]
oai:arXiv.org:1805.06457 [pdf] - 1717138
The Millimeter Continuum Size-Frequency Relationship in the UZ Tau E
Disk
Tripathi, Anjali;
Andrews, Sean M.;
Birnstiel, Tilman;
Chandler, Claire J.;
Isella, Andrea;
Perez, Laura M.;
Harris, Robert J.;
Ricci, Luca;
Wilner, David J.;
Carpenter, John M.;
Calvet, Nuria;
Corder, Stuartt. A.;
Deller, Adam T.;
Dullemond, Cornelis P.;
Greaves, Jane S.;
Henning, Thomas;
Kwon, Woojin;
Lazio, T. Joseph W.;
Linz, Hendrik;
Testi, Leonardo
Submitted: 2018-05-16
We present high spatial resolution observations of the continuum emission
from the young multiple star system UZ Tau at frequencies from 6 to 340 GHz. To
quantify the spatial variation of dust emission in the UZ Tau E circumbinary
disk, the observed interferometric visibilities are modeled with a simple
parametric prescription for the radial surface brightnesses at each frequency.
We find evidence that the spectrum steepens with radius in the disk, manifested
as a positive correlation between the observing frequency and the radius that
encircles a fixed fraction of the emission ($R_{eff} \propto \nu^{0.34 \pm
0.08}$). The origins of this size--frequency relation are explored in the
context of a theoretical framework for the growth and migration of disk solids.
While that framework can reproduce a similar size--frequency relation, it
predicts a steeper spectrum than is observed. Moreover, it comes closest to
matching the data only on timescales much shorter ($\le 1$ Myr) than the
putative UZ Tau age (~2-3 Myr). These discrepancies are the direct consequences
of the rapid radial drift rates predicted by models of dust evolution in a
smooth gas disk. One way to mitigate that efficiency problem is to invoke
small-scale gas pressure modulations that locally concentrate drifting solids.
If such particle traps reach high continuum optical depths at 30-340 GHz with a
~30-60% filling fraction in the inner disk ($r \lesssim20$ au), they can also
explain the observed spatial gradient in the UZ Tau E disk spectrum.
[32]
oai:arXiv.org:1805.02261 [pdf] - 1736374
First direct detection of a polarized companion outside of a resolved
circumbinary disk around CS Cha
Ginski, C.;
Benisty, M.;
van Holstein, R. G.;
Juhász, A.;
Schmidt, T. O. B.;
Chauvin, G.;
de Boer, J.;
Wilby, M.;
Manara, C. F.;
Delorme, P.;
Ménard, F.;
Pinilla, P.;
Birnstiel, T.;
Flock, M.;
Keller, C.;
Kenworthy, M.;
Milli, J.;
Olofsson, J.;
Pérez, L.;
Snik, F.;
Vogt, N.
Submitted: 2018-05-06
In the present study we aim to investigate the circumstellar environment of
the spectroscopic binary T Tauri star CS Cha. From unresolved mid- to
far-infrared photometry it is predicted that CS Cha hosts a disk with a large
cavity. In addition, SED modeling suggests significant dust settling, pointing
towards an evolved disk that may show signs of ongoing or completed planet
formation. We observed CS Cha with the high contrast imager VLT/SPHERE in
polarimetric differential imaging mode to resolve the circumbinary disk in near
infrared scattered light. These observations were followed-up by VLT/NACO
L-band observations and complemented by archival VLT/NACO K-band and HST/WFPC2
I-band data. We resolve the compact circumbinary disk around CS Cha for the
first time in scattered light. We find a smooth, low inclination disk with an
outer radius of $\sim$55 au (at 165 pc). We do not detect the inner cavity but
find an upper limit for the cavity size of $\sim$15 au. Furthermore, we find a
faint co-moving companion with a projected separation of 210 au from the
central binary outside of the circumbinary disk. The companion is detected in
polarized light and shows an extreme degree of polarization (13.7$\pm$0.4 \% in
J-band). The companion's J- and H-band magnitudes are compatible with masses of
a few M$_\mathrm{Jup}$. However, K-, L- and I-band data draw this conclusion
into question. We explore with radiative transfer modeling whether an
unresolved circum-companion disk can be responsible for the high polarization
and complex photometry. We find that the set of observations is best explained
by a heavily extincted low mass ($\sim 20 \mathrm{M}_\mathrm{Jup}$) brown dwarf
or high mass planet with an unresolved disk and dust envelope.
[33]
oai:arXiv.org:1803.04467 [pdf] - 1648981
Witnessing Planetary Systems in the Making with the Next Generation Very
Large Array
Ricci, Luca;
Isella, Andrea;
Andrews, Sean M.;
Birnstiel, Tilman;
Cuzzi, Jeffrey N.;
D'Angelo, Gennaro;
Dong, Ruobing;
Dutrey, Anne;
Ercolano, Barbara;
Estrada, Paul R.;
Flock, Mario;
Li, Hui;
Liu, Shang-Fei;
Lyra, Wladimir;
Oberg, Karin;
Okuzumi, Satoshi;
Perez, Laura;
Turner, Neal;
van der Marel, Nienke;
Wilner, David;
Youdin, Andrew N.;
Zhu, Zhaohuan
Submitted: 2018-03-12
The discovery of thousands of exoplanets over the last couple of decades has
shown that the birth of planets is a very efficient process in nature. Theories
invoke a multitude of mechanisms to describe the assembly of planets in the
disks around pre-main-sequence stars, but observational constraints have been
sparse on account of insufficient sensitivity and resolution. Understanding how
planets form and interact with their parental disk is crucial also to
illuminate the main characteristics of a large portion of the full population
of planets that is inaccessible to current and near-future observations. This
White Paper describes some of the main issues for our current understanding of
the formation and evolution of planets, and the critical contribution expected
in this field by the Next Generation Very Large Array.
[34]
oai:arXiv.org:1709.10130 [pdf] - 1670477
Inside-Out Planet Formation. IV. Pebble Evolution and Planet Formation
Timescales
Submitted: 2017-09-28, last modified: 2018-02-18
Systems with tightly-packed inner planets (STIPs) are very common. Chatterjee
& Tan proposed Inside-Out Planet Formation (IOPF), an in situ formation theory,
to explain these planets. IOPF involves sequential planet formation from
pebble-rich rings that are fed from the outer disk and trapped at the pressure
maximum associated with the dead zone inner boundary (DZIB). Planet masses are
set by their ability to open a gap and cause the DZIB to retreat outwards. We
present models for the disk density and temperature structures that are
relevant to the conditions of IOPF. For a wide range of DZIB conditions, we
evaluate the gap opening masses of planets in these disks that are expected to
lead to truncation of pebble accretion onto the forming planet. We then
consider the evolution of dust and pebbles in the disk, estimating that pebbles
typically grow to sizes of a few cm during their radial drift from several tens
of AU to the inner, $\lesssim1\:$AU-scale disk. A large fraction of the
accretion flux of solids is expected to be in such pebbles. This allows us to
estimate the timescales for individual planet formation and entire planetary
system formation in the IOPF scenario. We find that to produce realistic STIPs
within reasonable timescales similar to disk lifetimes requires disk accretion
rates of $\sim10^{-9}\:M_\odot\:{\rm yr}^{-1}$ and relatively low viscosity
conditions in the DZIB region, i.e., Shakura-Sunyaev parameter of
$\alpha\sim10^{-4}$.
[35]
oai:arXiv.org:1801.03948 [pdf] - 1626504
CO and dust properties in the TW Hya disk from high-resolution ALMA
observations
Huang, Jane;
Andrews, Sean M.;
Cleeves, L. Ilsedore;
Oberg, Karin I.;
Wilner, David J.;
Bai, Xuening;
Birnstiel, Til;
Carpenter, John;
Hughes, A. Meredith;
Isella, Andrea;
Perez, Laura M.;
Ricci, Luca;
Zhu, Zhaohuan
Submitted: 2018-01-11
We analyze high angular resolution ALMA observations of the TW Hya disk to
place constraints on the CO and dust properties. We present new, sensitive
observations of the $^{12}$CO $J = 3-2$ line at a spatial resolution of 8 AU
(0\farcs14). The CO emission exhibits a bright inner core, a shoulder at
$r\approx70$ AU, and a prominent break in slope at $r\approx90$ AU. Radiative
transfer modeling is used to demonstrate that the emission morphology can be
reasonably reproduced with a $^{12}$CO column density profile featuring a steep
decrease at $r\approx15$ AU and a secondary bump peaking at $r\approx70$ AU.
Similar features have been identified in observations of rarer CO
isotopologues, which trace heights closer to the midplane. Substructure in the
underlying gas distribution or radially varying CO depletion that affects much
of the disk's vertical extent may explain the shared emission features of the
main CO isotopologues. We also combine archival 1.3 mm and 870 $\mu$m continuum
observations to produce a spectral index map at a spatial resolution of 2 AU.
The spectral index rises sharply at the continuum emission gaps at radii of 25,
41, and 47 AU. This behavior suggests that the grains within the gaps are no
larger than a few millimeters. Outside the continuum gaps, the low spectral
index values of $\alpha\approx 2$ indicate either that grains up to centimeter
size are present, or that the bright continuum rings are marginally optically
thick at millimeter wavelengths.
[36]
oai:arXiv.org:1710.06485 [pdf] - 1593719
The circumstellar disk HD$\,$169142: gas, dust and planets acting in
concert?
Pohl, A.;
Benisty, M.;
Pinilla, P.;
Ginski, C.;
de Boer, J.;
Avenhaus, H.;
Henning, Th.;
Zurlo, A.;
Bocaletti, A.;
Augereau, J. -C.;
Birnstiel, T.;
Dominik, C.;
Facchini, S.;
Fedele, D.;
Janson, M.;
Keppler, M.;
Kral, Q.;
Langlois, M.;
Ligi, R.;
Maire, A. -L.;
Ménard, F.;
Meyer, M.;
Pinte, C.;
Quanz, S. P.;
Sauvage, J. -F.;
Sezestre, É.;
Stolker, T.;
Szulágyi, J.;
van Boekel, R.;
van der Plas, G.;
Baruffolo, A.;
Baudoz, P.;
Mignant, D. Le;
Maurel, D.;
Ramos, J.;
Weber, L.
Submitted: 2017-10-17
HD$\,$169142 is an excellent target to investigate signs of planet-disk
interaction due to the previous evidence of gap structures. We performed J-band
(~1.2{\mu}m) polarized intensity imaging of HD169142 with VLT/SPHERE. We
observe polarized scattered light down to 0.16" (~19 au) and find an inner gap
with a significantly reduced scattered light flux. We confirm the previously
detected double ring structure peaking at 0.18" (~21 au) and 0.56" (~66 au),
and marginally detect a faint third gap at 0.70"-0.73" (~82-85 au). We explore
dust evolution models in a disk perturbed by two giant planets, as well as
models with a parameterized dust size distribution. The dust evolution model is
able to reproduce the ring locations and gap widths in polarized intensity, but
fails to reproduce their depths. It, however, gives a good match with the ALMA
dust continuum image at 1.3 mm. Models with a parameterized dust size
distribution better reproduce the gap depth in scattered light, suggesting that
dust filtration at the outer edges of the gaps is less effective. The pile-up
of millimeter grains in a dust trap and the continuous distribution of small
grains throughout the gap likely require a more efficient dust fragmentation
and dust diffusion in the dust trap. Alternatively, turbulence or charging
effects might lead to a reservoir of small grains at the surface layer that is
not affected by the dust growth and fragmentation cycle dominating the dense
disk midplane. The exploration of models shows that extracting planet
properties such as mass from observed gap profiles is highly degenerate.
[37]
oai:arXiv.org:1709.00428 [pdf] - 1587829
Millimeter Spectral Indices and Dust Trapping By Planets in Brown Dwarf
Disks
Pinilla, P.;
Quiroga-Nuñez, L. H.;
Benisty, M.;
Natta, A.;
Ricci, L.;
Henning, Th.;
van der Plas, G.;
Birnstiel, T.;
Testi, L.;
Ward-Duong, K.
Submitted: 2017-09-01
Disks around brown dwarfs (BDs) are excellent laboratories to study the first
steps of planet formation in cold and low-mass disk conditions. The
radial-drift velocities of dust particles in BD disks are higher than in disks
around more massive stars. Therefore, BD disks are expected to be more depleted
in millimeter-sized grains compared to disks around T Tauri or Herbig Ae/Be
stars. However, recent millimeter observations of BD disks revealed low
millimeter spectral indices, indicating the presence of large grains in these
disks and challenging models of dust evolution. We present 3\,mm photometric
observations carried out with the IRAM/Plateau de Bure Interferometer (PdBI) of
three BD disks in the Taurus star forming region, which have been observed with
ALMA at 0.89\,mm. The disks were not resolved and only one was detected with
enough confidence ($\sim3.5\sigma$) with PdBI. Based on these observations, we
obtain the values and lower limits of the spectral index and find low values
($\alpha_{\rm{mm}}\lesssim 3.0$). We compare these observations in the context
of particle trapping by an embedded planet, a promising mechanism to explain
the observational signatures in more massive and warmer disks. We find,
however, that this model cannot reproduce the current millimeter observations
for BD disks, and multiple-strong pressure bumps globally distributed in the
disk remain as a favorable scenario to explain observations. Alternative
possibilities are that the gas masses in BD disk are very low
($\sim2\times10^{-3}\,M_{\rm{Jup}}$) such that the millimeter grains are
decoupled and do not drift, or fast growth of fluffy aggregates.
[38]
oai:arXiv.org:1709.00361 [pdf] - 1587811
X-ray photoevaporation's limited success in the formation of
planetesimals by the streaming instability
Submitted: 2017-09-01
The streaming instability is often invoked as solution to the fragmentation
and drift barriers in planetesimal formation, catalyzing the aggregation of
dust on kyr timescales to grow km-sized cores. However there remains a lack of
consensus on the physical mechanism(s) responsible for initiating it. One
potential avenue is disc photoevaporation, wherein the preferential removal of
relatively dust-free gas increases the disc metallicity. Late in the disc
lifetime, photoevaporation dominates viscous accretion, creating a gradient in
the depleted gas surface density near the location of the gap. This induces a
local pressure maximum that collects drifting dust particles, which may then
become susceptible to the streaming instability. Using a one-dimensional
viscous evolution model of a disc subject to internal X-ray photoevaporation,
we explore the efficacy of this process to build planetestimals. Over a range
of parameters we find that the amount of dust mass converted into planetesimals
is often < 1 M_Earth and at most a few M_Earth spread across tens of AU. We
conclude that photoevaporation may at best be relevant for the formation of
debris discs, rather than a common mechanism for the formation of planetary
cores. Our results are in contrast to a recent, similar investigation that
considered an FUV-driven photoevaporation model and reported the formation of
tens of M_Earth at large (> 100 AU) disc radii. The discrepancies are primarily
a consequence of the different photoevaporation profiles assumed. Until
observations more tightly constrain photoevaporation models, the relevance of
this process to the formation of planets remains uncertain.
[39]
oai:arXiv.org:1708.03238 [pdf] - 1586968
The properties of the inner disk around HL Tau: Multi-wavelength
modeling of the dust emission
Liu, Yao;
Henning, Thomas;
Carrasco-Gonzalez, Carlos;
Chandler, Claire J.;
Linz, Hendrik;
Birnstiel, Til;
van Boekel, Roy;
Perez, Laura M.;
Flock, Mario;
Testi, Leonardo;
Rodriguez, Luis F.;
Galvan-Madrid, Roberto
Submitted: 2017-08-10
We conducted a detailed radiative transfer modeling of the dust emission from
the circumstellar disk around HL Tau. The goal of our study is to derive the
surface density profile of the inner disk and its structure. In addition to the
Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array images at Band 3 (2.9mm), Band 6
(1.3mm), and Band 7 (0.87mm), the most recent Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array
(VLA) observations at 7mm were included in the analysis. A simulated annealing
algorithm was invoked to search for the optimum model. The radiative transfer
analysis demonstrates that most radial components (i.e., >6AU) of the disk
become optically thin at a wavelength of 7mm, which allows us to constrain, for
the first time, the dust density distribution in the inner region of the disk.
We found that a homogeneous grain size distribution is not sufficient to
explain the observed images at different wavelengths simultaneously, while
models with a shallower grain size distribution in the inner disk work well. We
found clear evidence that larger grains are trapped in the first bright ring.
Our results imply that dust evolution has already taken place in the disk at a
relatively young (i.e., ~1Myr) age. We compared the midplane temperature
distribution, optical depth, and properties of various dust rings with those
reported previously. Using the Toomre parameter, we briefly discussed the
gravitational instability as a potential mechanism for the origin of the dust
clump detected in the first bright ring via the VLA observations.
[40]
oai:arXiv.org:1707.02321 [pdf] - 1585682
Dust Density Distribution and Imaging Analysis of Different Ice Lines in
Protoplanetary Disks
Submitted: 2017-07-07, last modified: 2017-08-02
Recent high angular resolution observations of protoplanetary disks at
different wavelengths have revealed several kinds of structures, including
multiple bright and dark rings. Embedded planets are the most used explanation
for such structures, but there are alternative models capable of shaping the
dust in rings as it has been observed. We assume a disk around a Herbig star
and investigate the effect that ice lines have on the dust evolution, following
the growth, fragmentation, and dynamics of multiple dust size particles,
covering from 1 $\mu$m to 2 m sized objects. We use simplified prescriptions of
the fragmentation velocity threshold, which is assumed to change radially at
the location of one, two, or three ice lines. We assume changes at the radial
location of main volatiles, specifically H$_2$O, CO$_2$, and NH$_3$. Radiative
transfer calculations are done using the resulting dust density distributions
in order to compare with current multiwavelength observations. We find that the
structures in the dust density profiles and radial intensities at different
wavelengths strongly depend on the disk viscosity. A clear gap of emission can
be formed between ice lines and be surrounded by ring-like structures, in
particular between the H$_2$O and CO$_2$ (or CO). The gaps are expected to be
shallower and narrower at millimeter emission than at near-infrared, opposite
to model predictions of particle trapping. In our models, the total gas surface
density is not expected to show strong variations, in contrast to other
gap-forming scenarios such as embedded giant planets or radial variations of
the disk viscosity.
[41]
oai:arXiv.org:1707.07197 [pdf] - 1586260
VLA observations of the disk around the young brown dwarf 2MASS
J044427+2512
Submitted: 2017-07-22
We present multi-wavelength radio observations obtained with the VLA of the
protoplanetary disk surrounding the young brown dwarf 2MASS J04442713+2512164
(2M0444) in the Taurus star forming region. 2M0444 is the brightest known brown
dwarf disk at millimeter wavelengths, making this an ideal target to probe
radio emission from a young brown dwarf. Thermal emission from dust in the disk
is detected at 6.8 and 9.1 mm, whereas the 1.36 cm measured flux is dominated
by ionized gas emission. We combine these data with previous observations at
shorter sub-mm and mm wavelengths to test the predictions of dust evolution
models in gas-rich disks after adapting their parameters to the case of 2M0444.
These models show that the radial drift mechanism affecting solids in a gaseous
environment has to be either completely made inefficient, or significantly
slowed down by very strong gas pressure bumps in order to explain the presence
of mm/cm-sized grains in the outer regions of the 2M0444 disk. We also discuss
the possible mechanisms for the origin of the ionized gas emission detected at
1.36 cm. The inferred radio luminosity for this emission is in line with the
relation between radio and bolometric luminosity valid for for more massive and
luminous young stellar objects, and extrapolated down to the very low
luminosity of the 2M0444 brown dwarf.
[42]
oai:arXiv.org:1706.08977 [pdf] - 1585220
A Millimeter Continuum Size-Luminosity Relationship for Protoplanetary
Disks
Submitted: 2017-06-27
We present a sub-arcsecond resolution survey of the 340 GHz dust continuum
emission from 50 nearby protoplanetary disks, based on new and archival
observations with the Submillimeter Array. The observed visibility data were
modeled with a simple prescription for the radial surface brightness profile.
The results were used to extract intuitive, empirical estimates of the emission
"size" for each disk, $R_{\rm eff}$, defined as the radius that encircles a
fixed fraction of the total continuum luminosity, $L_{\rm mm}$. We find a
significant correlation between the sizes and luminosities, such that $R_{\rm
eff} \propto L_{\rm mm}^{0.5}$, providing a confirmation and quantitative
characterization of a putative trend that was noted previously. This
correlation suggests that these disks have roughly the same average surface
brightness interior to their given effective radius, ~0.2 Jy arcsec$^{-2}$ (or
8 K in brightness temperature). The same trend remains, but the 0.2dex of
dispersion perpendicular to this relation essentially disappears, when we
account for the irradiation environment of each disk with a crude approximation
of the dust temperatures based on the stellar host luminosities. We consider
two (not mutually exclusive) explanations for the origin of this
size-luminosity relationship. Simple models of the growth and migration of disk
solids can account for the observed trend for a reasonable range of initial
conditions, but only on timescales that are much shorter than the nominal ages
present in the sample. An alternative scenario invokes optically thick emission
concentrated on unresolved scales, with filling factors of a few tens of
percent, that are perhaps manifestations of localized particle traps.
[43]
oai:arXiv.org:1705.06235 [pdf] - 1583539
Different dust and gas radial extents in protoplanetary disks:
consistent models of grain growth and CO emission
Submitted: 2017-05-17, last modified: 2017-06-01
ALMA observations of protoplanetary disks confirm earlier indications that
there is a clear difference between the dust and gas radial extents. The origin
of this difference is still debated, with both radial drift of the dust and
optical depth effects suggested in the literature. In this work, the feedback
of realistic dust particle distributions onto the gas chemistry and molecular
emissivity is investigated, with a particular focus on CO isotopologues. The
radial dust grain size distribution is determined using dust evolution models
that include growth, fragmentation and radial drift. A new version of the code
DALI is used to take into account how dust surface area and density influence
the disk thermal structure, molecular abundances and excitation. The difference
of dust and gas radial sizes is largely due to differences in the optical depth
of CO lines and millimeter continuum, without the need to invoke radial drift.
The effect of radial drift is primarily visible in the sharp outer edge of the
continuum intensity profile. The gas outer radius probed by $^{12}$CO emission
can easily differ by a factor of $\sim 2$ between the models for a turbulent
$\alpha$ ranging between typical values. Grain growth and settling concur in
thermally decoupling the gas and dust components, due to the low collision rate
with large grains. As a result, the gas can be much colder than the dust at
intermediate heights, reducing the CO excitation and emission, especially for
low turbulence values. Also, due to disk mid-plane shadowing, a second CO
thermal desorption (rather than photodesorption) front can occur in the warmer
outer mid-plane disk. The models are compared to ALMA observations of HD 163296
as a test case. In order to reproduce the observed CO snowline of the system, a
binding energy for CO typical of ice mixtures needs to be used rather than the
lower pure CO value.
[44]
oai:arXiv.org:1705.02381 [pdf] - 1573966
Composition of Early Planetary Atmospheres II: Coupled Dust and Chemical
Evolution in Protoplanetary Disks
Submitted: 2017-05-05
We present the next step in a series of papers devoted to connecting the
composition of the atmospheres of forming planets with the chemistry of their
natal evolving protoplanetary disks. The model presented here computes the
coupled chemical and dust evolution of the disk and the formation of three
planets per disk model. Our three canonical planet traps produce a Jupiter near
1 AU, a Hot Jupiter and a Super-Earth. We study the dependency of the final
orbital radius, mass, and atmospheric chemistry of planets forming in disk
models with initial disk masses that vary by 0.02 $M_\odot$ above and below our
fiducial model ($M_{disk,0} = 0.1 ~M_\odot$). We compute C/O and C/N for the
atmospheres formed in our 3 models and find that C/O$_{\rm planet}\sim$
C/O$_{\rm disk}$, which does not vary strongly between different planets formed
in our model. The nitrogen content of atmospheres can vary in planets that grow
in different disk models. These differences are related to the formation
history of the planet, the time and location that the planet accretes its
atmosphere, and are encoded in the bulk abundance of NH$_3$. These results
suggest that future observations of atmospheric NH$_3$ and an estimation of the
planetary C/O and C/N can inform the formation history of particular planetary
systems.
[45]
oai:arXiv.org:1703.09227 [pdf] - 1567743
A Multi-Wavelength Analysis of Dust and Gas in the SR 24S Transition
Disk
Pinilla, P.;
Pérez, L. M.;
Andrews, S.;
van der Marel, N.;
van Dishoeck, E. F.;
Ataiee, S.;
Benisty, M.;
Birnstiel, T.;
Juhász, A.;
Natta, A.;
Ricci, L.;
Testi, L.
Submitted: 2017-03-27
We present new Atacama Large Millimeter/sub-millimeter Array (ALMA) 1.3 mm
continuum observations of the SR 24S transition disk with an angular resolution
$\lesssim0.18"$ (12 au radius). We perform a multi-wavelength investigation by
combining new data with previous ALMA data at 0.45 mm. The visibilities and
images of the continuum emission at the two wavelengths are well characterized
by a ring-like emission. Visibility modeling finds that the ring-like emission
is narrower at longer wavelengths, in good agreement with models of dust
trapping in pressure bumps, although there are complex residuals that suggest
potentially asymmetric structures. The 0.45 mm emission has a shallower profile
inside the central cavity than the 1.3 mm emission. In addition, we find that
the $^{13}$CO and C$^{18}$O (J=2-1) emission peaks at the center of the
continuum cavity. We do not detect either continuum or gas emission from the
northern companion to this system (SR 24N), which is itself a binary system.
The upper limit for the dust disk mass of SR 24N is $\lesssim
0.12\,M_{\bigoplus}$, which gives a disk mass ratio in dust between the two
components of $M_{\mathrm{dust, SR\,24S}}/M_{\mathrm{dust,
SR\,24N}}\gtrsim840$. The current ALMA observations may imply that either
planets have already formed in the SR 24N disk or that dust growth to mm-sizes
is inhibited there and that only warm gas, as seen by ro-vibrational CO
emission inside the truncation radii of the binary, is present.
[46]
oai:arXiv.org:1702.02147 [pdf] - 1535526
A Surface Density Perturbation in the TW Hydrae Disk at 95 au Traced by
Molecular Emission
Submitted: 2017-02-07
We present ALMA Cycle~2 observations at $0.5^{\prime\prime}$ resolution of TW
Hya of CS $J=5-4$ emission. The radial profile of the integrated line emission
displays oscillatory features outwards of $1.5^{\prime\prime}$ ($\approx 90$
au). A dip-like feature at $1.6^{\prime\prime}$ is coincident in location,
depth and width with features observed in dust scattered light at near-infrared
wavelengths. Using a thermochemical model indicative of TW Hya, gas-grain
chemical modelling and non-LTE radiative transfer, we demonstrate that such a
feature can be reproduced with a surface density depression, consistent with
the modelling performed for scattered light observations of TW Hya. We further
demonstrate that a gap in the dust distribution and dust opacity only cannot
reproduce the observed CS feature. The outer enhancement at
$3.1^{\prime\prime}$ is identified as a region of intensified desorption due to
enhanced penetration of the interstellar FUV radiation at the exponential edge
of the disk surface density, which intensifies the photochemical processing of
gas and ices.
[47]
oai:arXiv.org:1701.02385 [pdf] - 1564009
Redistribution of CO at the Location of the CO Ice Line in evolving Gas
and Dust Disks
Submitted: 2017-01-09, last modified: 2017-01-31
Context. Ice lines are suggested to play a significant role in grain growth
and planetesimal formation in protoplanetary disks. Evaporation fronts directly
influence the gas and ice abundances of volatile species in the disk and
therefore the coagulation physics and efficiency and the chemical composition
of the resulting planetesimals.
Aims. In this work we investigate the influence of the existence of the CO
ice line on the particle growth and on the distribution of CO in the disk.
Methods. We include the possibility of tracking the CO content and/or other
volatiles in particles and in the gas in our existing dust coagulation and disk
evolution model and developed a method for evaporation and condensation of CO
using the Hertz-Knudsen equation. Our model does not include fragmentation,
yet, which will be part of further investigations.
Results. We find no enhanced grain growth just outside the ice line where the
particle size is limited by radial drift. Instead we find a depletion of solid
material inside the ice line which is solely due to evaporation of the CO. Such
a depression inside the ice line may be observable and may help to quantify the
processes described in this work. Furthermore, we find that the viscosity and
diffusivity of the gas heavily influence the re-distribution of vaporized CO at
the ice line and can lead to an increase in the CO abundance by up to a factors
of a few in the region just inside the ice line. Depending on the strength of
the gaseous transport mechanisms the position of the ice line in our model can
change by up to 10 AU and consequently, the temperature at that location can
range from 21 K to 23 K.
[48]
oai:arXiv.org:1611.02718 [pdf] - 1511474
Radial Drift of Dust in Protoplanetary Disks: The Evolution of Ice lines
and Dead zones
Submitted: 2016-11-08
We have developed a new model for the astrochemical structure of a viscously
evolving protoplanetary disk that couples an analytic description of the disk's
temperature and density profile, chemical evolution, and an evolving dust
distribution. We compute evolving radial distributions for a range of dust
grain sizes, which depend on coagulation, fragmentation and radial drift
processes. In particular we find that the water ice line plays an important
role in shaping the radial distribution of the maximum grain size because ice
coated grains are significantly less susceptible to fragmentation than their
dry counterparts. This in turn has important effects on disk ionization and
therefore on the location of dead zones. In comparison to a simple constant
gas-to-dust ratio model for the dust as an example, we find that the new model
predicts an outer dead zone edge that moves in by a factor of about 3 at 1 Myr
(to 5 AU) and by a factor of about 14 by 3 Myr (to 0.5 AU). We show that the
changing position of the dead zone and heat transition traps have important
implications for the formation and trapping of planets in protoplanetary disks.
Finally, we consider our results in light of recent ALMA observations of HL Tau
and TW Hya.
[49]
oai:arXiv.org:1610.08381 [pdf] - 1546279
Testing dust trapping in the circumbinary disk around GG Tau A
Submitted: 2016-10-26, last modified: 2016-10-27
The protoplanetary disk around the GGTau A binary system is so far one of the
most studied young circumbinary disk. Observations of the dust continuum
emission at sub-mm/mm wavelengths detected a dust ring located between 200AU
and 300AU from the center of mass of the system. If the disk and the binary
orbit are coplanar, given the observed projected separation of the stars in the
binary system, the classical theory of tidal interaction between a binary
system and its circumbinary disk predicts a truncation radius which is
significantly smaller than the measured inner radius of the mm-sized dust ring.
We investigate the origin of this dust ring structure in the GG Tau A disk,
test whether the interaction between the binary and the disk can produce a dust
trap at the location of the observed ring, and discuss an alternative scenario
which invokes a misalignment between the disk and the stellar orbital planes.
We run a set of hydrodynamical simulations for an orbit consistent with the
astrometric solutions for the GG Tau A stellar proper motions, and for
different disk temperature and viscosities. We then apply a dust evolution
model in post-processing in order to to retrieve the distribution of mm-sized
grains. Comparing models and observations, we show that, if the binary orbit
and the disk were coplanar,the tidal truncation of the circumbinary disk would
occur at a radius that is too small compared to the inner edge inferred by the
dust observations, and that the pressure bump and the dust ring in the models
would be located at <150AU from the center of mass of the stellar system. This
shows that the GG Tau A disk cannot be coplanar with the binary orbital plane.
We also discuss the viability of the misaligned disk scenario, suggesting that
in order for dust trapping to occur at the observed radius, the disk and
orbital plane must be misaligned by an angle of about 25 degrees.
[50]
oai:arXiv.org:1610.02044 [pdf] - 1528279
Can dead zones create structures like a transition disk?
Submitted: 2016-10-06, last modified: 2016-10-22
[Abridged] Regions of low ionisation where the activity of the
magneto-rotational instability is suppressed, the so-called dead zones, have
been suggested to explain gaps and asymmetries of transition disks. We
investigate the gas and dust evolution simultaneously assuming simplified
prescriptions for a dead zone and a magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) wind acting on
the disk. We explore whether the resulting gas and dust distribution can create
signatures similar to those observed in transition disks. For the dust
evolution, we included the transport, growth, and fragmentation of dust
particles. To compare with observations, we produced synthetic images in
scattered optical light and in thermal emission at mm wavelengths. In all
models with a dead zone, a bump in the gas surface density is produced that is
able to efficiently trap large particles ($\gtrsim 1$ mm) at the outer edge of
the dead zone. The gas bump reaches an amplitude of a factor of $\sim5$, which
can be enhanced by the presence of an MHD wind that removes mass from the inner
disk. While our 1D simulations suggest that such a structure can be present
only for $\sim$1 Myr, the structure may be maintained for a longer time when
more realistic 2D/3D simulations are performed. In the synthetic images,
gap-like low-emission regions are seen at scattered light and in thermal
emission at mm wavelengths, as previously predicted in the case of planet-disk
interaction. As a conclusion, main signatures of transition disks can be
reproduced by assuming a dead zone in the disk, such as gap-like structure in
scattered light and millimetre continuum emission, and a lower gas surface
density within the dead zone. Previous studies showed that the Rossby wave
instability can also develop at the edge of such dead zones, forming vortices
and also creating asymmetries.
[51]
oai:arXiv.org:1607.00387 [pdf] - 1470733
Investigating dust trapping in transition disks with millimeter-wave
polarization
Submitted: 2016-07-01
Spatially resolved polarized (sub-)mm emission has been observed for example
in the protoplanetary disk around HL Tau. Magnetically aligned grains are
commonly interpreted as the source of polarization. However, self-scattering by
large dust grains with a high enough albedo is another polarization mechanism,
becoming a compelling method independent of the spectral index to constrain the
dust grain size in protoplanetary disks. We study the dust polarization at mm
wavelength in the dust trapping scenario proposed for transition disks, when a
giant planet opens a gap in the disk. We investigate the characteristic
polarization patterns and their dependence on disk inclination, dust size
evolution, planet position, and observing wavelength. We combine
two-dimensional hydrodynamical simulations of planet-disk interactions with
self-consistent dust growth models. These size-dependent dust density
distributions are used for follow-up three-dimensional radiative transfer
calculations to predict the polarization degree at ALMA bands due to scattered
thermal emission. We find that the polarization pattern of a disk with a
planetary gap after 1 Myr of dust evolution shows a distinctive three ring
structure. Two narrow inner rings are located at the planet gap edges. For
increasing observing wavelengths all three rings slightly change their
position, where the innermost and outermost rings move inward. This distance is
detectable comparing the results at ALMA bands 3, 6 and 7. Within the highest
polarized intensity regions the polarization vectors are oriented in the
azimuthal direction. For an inclined disk there is an interplay between
polarization originating from a flux gradient and inclination-induced
quadrupole polarization. For intermediate inclined transition disks the
polarization degree is as high as ~ 2% at band 3, which is well above the
detection limit of future ALMA observations.
[52]
oai:arXiv.org:1606.00005 [pdf] - 1444032
Measuring Turbulence in TW Hya with ALMA: Methods and Limitations
Teague, Richard;
Guilloteau, Stephane;
Semenov, Dmitry;
Henning, Thomas;
Dutrey, Anne;
Pietu, Vincent;
Birnstiel, Tilman;
Chapillon, Edwige;
Hollenbach, David;
Gorti, Uma
Submitted: 2016-05-31
We obtain high spatial and spectral resolution images of the CO J=2-1, CN
N=2-1 and CS J=5-4 emission with ALMA in Cycle~2. The radial distribution of
the turbulent broadening is derived with three approaches: two `direct' and one
modelling. The first requires a single transition and derives \Tex{} directly
from the line profile, yielding a \vturb{}. The second assumes two different
molecules are co-spatial thus their relative linewidths allow for a calculation
of \Tkin{} and \vturb{}. Finally we fit a parametric disk model where physical
properties of the disk are described by power laws, to compare our `direct'
methods with previous values. The two direct methods were limited to the outer
$r > 40$~au disk due to beam smear. The direct method found \vturb{} ranging
from $\approx$~\vel{130} at 40~au, dropping to $\approx$~\vel{50} in the outer
disk, qualitatively recovered with the parametric model fitting. This
corresponds to roughly $0.2 - 0.4~c_s$. CN was found to exhibit strong non-LTE
effects outside $r \approx 140$~au, so \vturb{} was limited to within this
radius. The assumption that CN and CS are co-spatial is consistent with
observed linewidths only within $r \lesssim 100$~au, within which \vturb{} was
found to drop from \vel{100} ($\approx~0.4~c_s$) to nothing at 100~au. The
parametric model yielded a near constant \vel{50} for CS ($0.2 - 0.4~c_s$). We
demonstrate that absolute flux calibration is and will be the limiting factor
in all studies of turbulence using a single molecule. The magnitude of the
dispersion is comparable with or below that predicted by the magneto-rotational
instability theory. A more precise comparison would require to reach an
absolute calibration precision of order 3\%, or to find a suitable combination
of light and heavy molecules which are co-located in the disk.
[53]
oai:arXiv.org:1604.02952 [pdf] - 1408395
Dust Evolution and the Formation of Planetesimals
Submitted: 2016-04-11, last modified: 2016-05-18
The solid content of circumstellar disks is inherited from the interstellar
medium: dust particles of at most a micrometer in size. Protoplanetary disks
are the environment where these dust grains need to grow at least 13 orders of
magnitude in size. Our understanding of this growth process is far from
complete, with different physics seemingly posing obstacles to this growth at
various stages. Yet, the ubiquity of planets in our galaxy suggests that planet
formation is a robust mechanism. This chapter focuses on the earliest stages of
planet formation, the growth of small dust grains towards the gravitationally
bound "planetesimals", the building blocks of planets. We will introduce some
of the key physics involved in the growth processes and discuss how they are
expected to shape the global behavior of the solid content of disks. We will
consider possible pathways towards the formation of larger bodies and conclude
by reviewing some of the recent observational advances in the field.
[54]
oai:arXiv.org:1603.09352 [pdf] - 1389005
Ringed Substructure and a Gap at 1 AU in the Nearest Protoplanetary Disk
Andrews, Sean M.;
Wilner, David J.;
Zhu, Zhaohuan;
Birnstiel, Tilman;
Carpenter, John M.;
Perez, Laura M.;
Bai, Xue-Ning;
Oberg, Karin I.;
Hughes, A. Meredith;
Isella, Andrea;
Ricci, Luca
Submitted: 2016-03-30
We present long-baseline Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA)
observations of the 870 micron continuum emission from the nearest gas-rich
protoplanetary disk, around TW Hya, that trace millimeter-sized particles down
to spatial scales as small as 1 AU (20 mas). These data reveal a series of
concentric ring-shaped substructures in the form of bright zones and narrow
dark annuli (1-6 AU) with modest contrasts (5-30%). We associate these features
with concentrations of solids that have had their inward radial drift slowed or
stopped, presumably at local gas pressure maxima. No significant
non-axisymmetric structures are detected. Some of the observed features occur
near temperatures that may be associated with the condensation fronts of major
volatile species, but the relatively small brightness contrasts may also be a
consequence of magnetized disk evolution (the so-called zonal flows). Other
features, particularly a narrow dark annulus located only 1 AU from the star,
could indicate interactions between the disk and young planets. These data
signal that ordered substructures on ~AU scales can be common, fundamental
factors in disk evolution, and that high resolution microwave imaging can help
characterize them during the epoch of planet formation.
[55]
oai:arXiv.org:1603.09357 [pdf] - 1383742
Constraining turbulence mixing strength in transitional discs with
planets using SPHERE and ALMA
Submitted: 2016-03-30
We investigate the effect that the turbulent mixing strength parameter
$\alpha_{\rm{turb}}$ plays on near-infrared polarimetric and sub-millimetre
interferometric imaging observations of transitional discs (TDs) with a gap
carved by a planet. We generate synthetic observations of these objects with
ALMA and VLT/SPHERE-ZIMPOL by combining hydrodynamical, dust evolution,
radiative transfer and instrument models for values of
$\alpha_{\rm{turb}}=[10^{-4}, 10^{-3}, 10^{-2}]$. We find that, through a
combination of effects on the viscosity of the gas, the turbulent mixing and
dust evolution processes, $\alpha_{\rm{turb}}$ strongly affects the morphology
of the dust distribution that can be traced with these observations. We
constrain the value of $\alpha_{\rm{turb}}$ to be within an order of magnitude
of $10^{-3}$ in TD sources that show cavities in sub-mm continuum images while
featuring continuous distribution of dust or smaller cavities in
NIR-polarimetric images.
[56]
oai:arXiv.org:1603.03731 [pdf] - 1396941
The VLA view of the HL Tau Disk - Disk Mass, Grain Evolution, and Early
Planet Formation
Carrasco-Gonzalez, Carlos;
Henning, Thomas;
Chandler, Claire J.;
Linz, Hendrik;
Perez, Laura;
Rodriguez, Luis F.;
Galvan-Madrid, Roberto;
Anglada, Guillem;
Birnstiel, Til;
van Boekel, Roy;
Flock, Mario;
Klahr, Hubert;
Macias, Enrique;
Menten, Karl;
Osorio, Mayra;
Testi, Leonardo;
Torrelles, Jose M.;
Zhu, Zhaohuan
Submitted: 2016-03-11, last modified: 2016-03-18
The first long-baseline ALMA campaign resolved the disk around the young star
HL Tau into a number of axisymmetric bright and dark rings. Despite the very
young age of HL Tau these structures have been interpreted as signatures for
the presence of (proto)planets. The ALMA images triggered numerous theoretical
studies based on disk-planet interactions, magnetically driven disk structures,
and grain evolution. Of special interest are the inner parts of disks, where
terrestrial planets are expected to form. However, the emission from these
regions in HL Tau turned out to be optically thick at all ALMA wavelengths,
preventing the derivation of surface density profiles and grain size
distributions. Here, we present the most sensitive images of HL Tau obtained to
date with the Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array at 7.0 mm wavelength with a
spatial resolution comparable to the ALMA images. At this long wavelength the
dust emission from HL Tau is optically thin, allowing a comprehensive study of
the inner disk. We obtain a total disk dust mass of 0.001 - 0.003 Msun,
depending on the assumed opacity and disk temperature. Our optically thin data
also indicate fast grain growth, fragmentation, and formation of dense clumps
in the inner densest parts of the disk. Our results suggest that the HL Tau
disk may be actually in a very early stage of planetary formation, with planets
not already formed in the gaps but in the process of future formation in the
bright rings.
[57]
oai:arXiv.org:1601.01548 [pdf] - 1347839
The shadow of the Flying Saucer: A very low temperature for large dust
grains
Submitted: 2016-01-07
Dust determines the temperature structure of protoplanetary disks. However,
dust temperature determinations almost invariably rely on a complex modeling of
the Spectral Energy Distribution. We attempt a direct determination of the
temperature of large grains emitting at mm wavelengths.} We observe the edge-on
dust disk of the Flying Saucer, which appears in silhouette against the CO
J=2-1 emission from a background molecular cloud in $\rho$ Oph. The combination
of velocity gradients due to the Keplerian rotation of the disk and intensity
variations in the CO background as a function of velocity allows us to directly
measure the %absorbing dust temperature. The dust opacity can then be derived
from the emitted continuum radiation. The dust disk absorbs the radiation from
the CO clouds at several velocities. We derive very low dust temperatures, 5 to
7 K at radii around 100 au, which is much lower than most model predictions.
The dust optical depth is $> 0.2$ at 230 GHz, and the scale height at 100 au is
at least 8 au (best fit 13 au). However, the dust disk is very flat (flaring
index -0.35), which is indicative of dust settling in the outer parts.
[58]
oai:arXiv.org:1511.04105 [pdf] - 1327577
A tunnel and a traffic jam: How transition disks maintain a detectable
warm dust component despite the presence of a large planet-carved gap
Submitted: 2015-11-12, last modified: 2015-11-24
We combined hydrodynamical simulations of planet-disk interactions with dust
evolution models that include coagulation and fragmentation of dust grains over
a large range of radii and derived observational properties using radiative
transfer calculations. We studied the role of the snow line in the survival of
the inner disk of transition disks. Inside the snow line, the lack of ice
mantles in dust particles decreases the sticking efficiency between grains. As
a consequence, particles fragment at lower collision velocities than in regions
beyond the snow line. This effect allows small particles to be maintained for
up to a few Myrs within the first astronomical unit. These particles are
closely coupled to the gas and do not drift significantly with respect to the
gas. For lower mass planets (1$M_{\rm{Jup}}$), the pre-transition appearance
can be maintained even longer because dust still trickles through the gap
created by the planet, moves invisibly and quickly in the form of relatively
large grains through the gap, and becomes visible again as it fragments and
gets slowed down inside of the snow line. The global study of dust evolution of
a disk with an embedded planet, including the changes of the dust aerodynamics
near the snow line, can explain the concentration of millimetre-sized particles
in the outer disk and the survival of the dust in the inner disk if a large
dust trap is present in the outer disk. This behaviour solves the conundrum of
the combination of both near-infrared excess and ring-like millimetre emission
observed in several transition disks.
[59]
oai:arXiv.org:1511.06762 [pdf] - 1327587
Direct imaging of the water snow line at the time of planet formation
using two ALMA continuum bands
Submitted: 2015-11-20
Molecular snow lines in protoplanetary disks have been studied theoretically
for decades because of their importance in shaping planetary architectures and
compositions. The water snow line lies in the planet formation region at < 10
AU, and so far its location has been estimated only indirectly from
spatially-unresolved spectroscopy. This work presents a proof-of-concept method
to directly image the water snow line in protoplanetary disks through its
physical and chemical imprint in the local dust properties. We adopt a physical
disk model that includes dust coagulation, fragmentation, drift, and a change
in fragmentation velocities of a factor 10 between dry silicates and icy grains
as found by laboratory work. We find that the presence of a water snow line
leads to a sharp discontinuity in the radial profile of the dust emission
spectral index {\alpha}_mm, due to replenishment of small grains through
fragmentation. We use the ALMA simulator to demonstrate that this effect can be
observed in protoplanetary disks using spatially-resolved ALMA images in two
continuum bands. We explore the model dependence on the disk viscosity and find
that the spectral index reveals the water snow line for a wide range of
conditions, with opposite trends when the emission is optically thin rather
than thick. If the disk viscosity is low ({\alpha}_visc < 10^-3) the snow line
produces a ring-like structure with a minimum at {\alpha}_mm ~ 2 in the
optically thick regime, possibly similar to what has been measured with ALMA in
the innermost region of the HL Tau disk.
[60]
oai:arXiv.org:1511.05563 [pdf] - 1331145
C/O and Snowline Locations in Protoplanetary Disks: The Effect of Radial
Drift and Viscous Gas Accretion
Submitted: 2015-11-17
The C/O ratio is a defining feature of both gas giant atmospheric and
protoplanetary disk chemistry. In disks, the C/O ratio is regulated by the
presence of snowlines of major volatiles at different distances from the
central star. We explore the effect of radial drift of solids and viscous gas
accretion onto the central star on the snowline locations of the main C and O
carriers in a protoplanetary disk, H2O, CO2 and CO, and their consequences for
the C/O ratio in gas and dust throughout the disk. We determine the snowline
locations for a range of fixed initial particle sizes and disk types. For our
fiducial disk model, we find that grains with sizes ~0.5 cm < s < 7 m for an
irradiated disk, and ~0.001 cm < s < 7 m for an evolving and viscous disk,
desorb at a size-dependent location in the disk, which is independent of the
particle's initial position. The snowline radius decreases for larger
particles, up to sizes of ~7 m. Compared to a static disk, we find that radial
drift and gas accretion in a viscous disk move the H2O snowline inwards by up
to 40%, the CO2 snowline by up to 60%, and the CO snowline by up to 50%. We
thus determine an inner limit on the snowline locations when radial drift and
gas accretion are accounted for.
[61]
oai:arXiv.org:1510.00412 [pdf] - 1312052
Variability and dust filtration in the transition disk J160421.7-213028
observed in optical scattered light
Pinilla, P.;
de Boer, J.;
Benisty, M.;
Juhász, A.;
Ovelar, M. de Juan;
Dominik, C.;
Avenhaus, H.;
Birnstiel, T.;
Girard, J. H.;
Huelamo, N.;
Isella, A.;
Milli, J.
Submitted: 2015-10-01, last modified: 2015-10-23
Context. Some of transition disks show asymmetric structures in thermal
sub-millimetre emission and optical scattered light. These structures can be
the result of planet(s) or companions embedded in the disk.
Aims. We aim to detect and analyse the scattered light of the transition disk
J160421.7-213028, identify disk structures, and compare the results with
previous observations of this disk at other wavelengths.
Methods. We obtained and analysed new polarised intensity observations of the
transition disk J160421.7-213028 with VLT/SPHERE using the visible light
instrument ZIMPOL at $R'$ band (0.626$\mu$m). We probe the disk gap down to a
radius of confidence of 0.1'' (${\sim}15$ AU at 145 pc). We interpret the
results in the context of dust evolution when planets interact with the
parental disk.
Results. We observe a gap from 0.1 to 0.3'' (${\sim}15$ to 40AU) and a bright
annulus as previously detected by HiCIAO $H$ band observations at $1.65\mu$m.
The radial width of the annulus is around $40$AU, and its centre is at
${\sim}61$AU from the central star. The peak of the reflected light at
0.626$\mu$m is located 20 AU inward of the cavity detected in the
submillimetre. In addition, we detect a dip at a position angle of ${\sim}46.2
\pm 5.4^\circ$. A dip was also detected with HiCIAO, but located at
${\sim}85^\circ$. If the dip observed with HiCIAO is the same, this suggests an
average dip rotation of ${\sim}12^\circ/$year, which is inconsistent with the
local Keplerian angular velocity of $\sim$0.8$^\circ$/yr at $\sim$61AU.
Conclusions. The spatial discrepancy in the radial emission in
J160421.7-213028 at different wavelengths is consistent with dust filtration at
the outer edge of a gap carved by a massive planet. The dip rotation can be
interpreted by fast variability of the inner disk and/or the presence of a warp
or circumplanetary material of a planet at ${\sim}9.6$ AU.
[62]
oai:arXiv.org:1510.05660 [pdf] - 1304218
Dust Evolution Can Produce Scattered Light Gaps in Protoplanetary Disks
Submitted: 2015-10-19, last modified: 2015-10-21
Recent imaging of protoplanetary disks with high resolution and contrast have
revealed a striking variety of substructure. Of particular interest are cases
where near-infrared scattered light images show evidence for low-intensity
annular "gaps." The origins of such structures are still uncertain, but the
interaction of the gas disk with planets is a common interpretation. We study
the impact that the evolution of the solid material can have on the observable
properties of disks in a simple scenario without any gravitational or
hydrodynamical disturbances to the gas disk structure. Even with a smooth and
continuous gas density profile, we find that the scattered light emission
produced by small dust grains can exhibit ring-like depressions similar to
those presented in recent observations. The physical mechanisms responsible for
these features rely on the inefficient fragmentation of dust particles. The
occurrence and position of the proposed "gap" features depend most strongly on
the dust-to-gas ratio, the fragmentation threshold velocity, the strength of
the turbulence, and the age of the disk, and should be generic (at some radius)
for typically adopted disk parameters. The same physical processes can affect
the thermal emission at optically thin wavelengths ($\sim$1 mm), although the
behavior can be more complex; unlike for disk-planet interactions, a "gap"
should not be present at these longer wavelengths.
[63]
oai:arXiv.org:1509.03040 [pdf] - 1312007
Testing particle trapping in transition disks with ALMA
Submitted: 2015-09-10, last modified: 2015-10-13
We present new Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) continuum
observations at 336GHz of two transition disks, SR21 and HD135344B. In
combination with previous ALMA observations from Cycle 0 at 689GHz, we compare
the visibility profiles at the two frequencies and calculate the spectral index
($\alpha_{\rm{mm}}$). The observations of SR21 show a clear shift in the
visibility nulls, indicating radial variations of the inner edge of the cavity
at the two wavelengths. Notable radial variations of the spectral index are
also detected for SR21 with values of $\alpha_{\rm{mm}}{\sim}3.8-4.2$ in the
inner region ($r<35$ AU) and $\alpha_{\rm{mm}}{\sim}2.6-3.0$ outside. An
axisymmetric ring (which we call the ring model) or a ring with the addition of
an azimuthal Gaussian profile, for mimicking a vortex structure (which we call
the vortex model), is assumed for fitting the disk morphology. For SR21, the
ring model better fits the emission at 336GHz, conversely the vortex model
better fits the 689GHz emission. For HD135344B, neither a significant shift in
the null of the visibilities nor radial variations of $\alpha_{\rm{mm}}$ are
detected. Furthermore, for HD135344B, the vortex model fits both frequencies
better than the ring model. However, the azimuthal extent of the vortex
increases with wavelength, contrary to model predictions for particle trapping
by anticyclonic vortices. For both disks, the azimuthal variations of
$\alpha_{\rm{mm}}$ remain uncertain to confirm azimuthal trapping. The
comparison of the current data with a generic model of dust evolution that
includes planet-disk interaction suggests that particles in the outer disk of
SR21 have grown to millimetre sizes and have accumulated in a radial pressure
bump, whereas with the current resolution there is not clear evidence of radial
trapping in HD135344B, although it cannot be excluded either.
[64]
oai:arXiv.org:1508.01003 [pdf] - 1275506
A concentration of centimeter-sized grains in the Oph IRS 48 dust trap
Submitted: 2015-08-05, last modified: 2015-09-11
Azimuthally asymmetric dust distributions observed with ALMA in transition
disks have been interpreted as dust traps. We present VLA Ka band (34 GHz or
0.9 cm) and ALMA Cycle 2 Band 9 (680 GHz or 0.45 mm) observations at 0.2"
resolution of the Oph IRS 48 disk, which suggest that larger particles could be
more azimuthally concentrated than smaller dust grains, assuming an
axisymmetric temperature field or optically thin 680 GHz emission. Fitting an
intensity model to both data demonstrates that the azimuthal extent of the
millimeter emission is 2.3 $\pm0.9$ times as wide as the centimeter emission,
marginally consistent with the particle trapping mechanism under the above
assumptions. The 34 GHz continuum image also reveals evidence for ionized gas
emission from the star. Both the morphology and the spectral index variations
are consistent with an increase of large particles in the center of the trap,
but uncertainties remain due to the continuum optical depth at 680 GHz.
Particle trapping has been proposed in planet formation models to allow dust
particles to grow beyond millimeter sizes in the outer regions of
protoplanetary disks. The new observations in the Oph IRS 48 disk provide
support for the dust trapping mechanism for centimeter-sized grains, although
additional data is required for definitive confirmation.
[65]
oai:arXiv.org:1506.02383 [pdf] - 1260814
Sequential planet formation in the HD 100546 protoplanetary disk?
Submitted: 2015-06-08
Context. The disk around the Herbig Ae star, HD 100546, shows structures that
suggest the presence of two companions in the disk at $\sim10$ and $\sim70$ AU.
The outer companion seems to be in the act of formation.
Aims. Our aims are to provide constraints on the age of the planets in HD
100546 and to explore the potential evidence for sequential planet formation in
transition disks such as HD 100546.
Methods. We compare the recent resolved continuum observations of the disk
around HD 100546 with the results of dust evolution simulations using an
analytical prescription for the shapes of gaps carved by massive planets.
Results. An inner pressure bump must have been present since early in the
disk lifetime to have good agreement between the dust evolution models and the
continuum observations of HD 100546. This pressure bump may have resulted from
the presence of a very massive planet ($\sim20 M_{\rm{Jup}}$), which formed
early in the inner disk ($r\sim$10 AU). If only this single planet exists, the
disk is likely to be old, comparable to the stellar age ($\sim$5-10 Myr).
Another possible explanation is an additional massive planet in the outer disk
($r\sim70$ AU): either a low-mass outer planet ($\lesssim5 M_{\rm{Jup}}$)
injected at early times, or a higher mass outer planet ($\gtrsim15
M_{\rm{Jup}}$) formed very recently, traps the right amount of dust in pressure
bumps to reproduce the observations. In the latter case, the disk could be much
younger ($\sim3.0$ Myr).
Conclusions. In the case in which two massive companions are embedded in the
disk around HD 100546, as suggested in the literature, the outer companion
could be at least $\gtrsim$2.5 Myr younger than the inner companion.
[66]
oai:arXiv.org:1505.05325 [pdf] - 1129155
Asymmetric features in the protoplanetary disk MWC758
Benisty, M.;
Juhasz, A.;
Boccaletti, A.;
Avenhaus, H.;
Milli, J.;
Thalmann, C.;
Dominik, C.;
Pinilla, P.;
Buenzli, E.;
Pohl, A.;
Beuzit, J. -L.;
Birnstiel, T.;
de Boer, J.;
Bonnefoy, M.;
Chauvin, G.;
Christiaens, V.;
Garufi, A.;
Grady, C.;
Henning, T.;
Huelamo, N.;
Isella, A.;
Langlois, M.;
Menard, F.;
Mouillet, D.;
Olofsson, J.;
Pantin, E.;
Pinte, C.;
Pueyo, L.
Submitted: 2015-05-20
The study of dynamical processes in protoplanetary disks is essential to
understand planet formation. In this context, transition disks are prime
targets because they are at an advanced stage of disk clearing and may harbor
direct signatures of disk evolution. In this paper, we aim to derive new
constraints on the structure of the transition disk MWC 758, to detect
non-axisymmetric features and understand their origin. We obtained infrared
polarized intensity observations of the protoplanetary disk MWC 758 with
SPHERE/VLT at 1.04 microns to resolve scattered light at a smaller inner
working angle (0.093") and a higher angular resolution (0.027") than previously
achieved. We observe polarized scattered light within 0.53" (148 au) down to
the inner working angle (26 au) and detect distinct non-axisymmetric features
but no fully depleted cavity. The two small-scale spiral features that were
previously detected with HiCIAO are resolved more clearly, and new features are
identified, including two that are located at previously inaccessible radii
close to the star. We present a model based on the spiral density wave theory
with two planetary companions in circular orbits. The best model requires a
high disk aspect ratio (H/r~0.20 at the planet locations) to account for the
large pitch angles which implies a very warm disk. Our observations reveal the
complex morphology of the disk MWC758. To understand the origin of the detected
features, the combination of high-resolution observations in the submillimeter
with ALMA and detailed modeling is needed.
[67]
oai:arXiv.org:1410.5963 [pdf] - 903886
Gas and dust structures in protoplanetary disks hosting multiple planets
Submitted: 2014-10-22, last modified: 2014-11-18
Transition disks have dust-depleted inner regions and may represent an
intermediate step of an on-going disk dispersal process, where planet formation
is probably in progress. Recent millimetre observations of transition disks
reveal radially and azimuthally asymmetric structures, where micron- and
millimetre-sized dust particles may not spatially coexist. These properties can
be the result of particle trapping and grain growth in pressure bumps
originating from the disk interaction with a planetary companion. The multiple
features observed in some transition disks, such as SR 21, suggest the presence
of more than one planet. We study the gas and dust distributions of a disk
hosting two massive planets as function of different disk and dust parameters.
Observational signatures, such as the spectral energy distribution,
sub-millimetre, and polarised images are simulated for the various parameters.
We confirm that planets can lead to particle trapping, although for a disk with
high viscosity ($\alpha_{\rm{turb}}=10^{-2}$), the planet should be more
massive than $5 M_{\rm{Jup}}$ and dust fragmentation should occur with low
efficiency ($v_{f}\sim30\rm{m s}^{-1}$). This will lead to a ring-like feature
as observed in transition disks in the millimetre. When trapping occurs, we
find that a smooth distribution of micron sized grains throughout the disk,
sometimes observed in scattered light, can only happen if the combination of
planet mass and turbulence is such that small grains are not fully filtered
out. A high disk viscosity ($\alpha_{\rm{turb}}=10^{-2}$) ensures a
replenishment of the cavity in micron-sized dust, while for lower viscosity
($\alpha_{\rm{turb}}=10^{-3}$), the planet mass is constrained to be less than
$5 M_{\rm{Jup}}$. In these cases, the gas distribution is likely to show
low-amplitude azimuthal asymmetries caused by disk eccentricity rather than by
long-lived vortices.
[68]
oai:arXiv.org:1410.2713 [pdf] - 905292
The Herschel/PACS view of the Cep OB2 region: Global protoplanetary disk
evolution and clumpy star formation
Sicilia-Aguilar, Aurora;
Roccatagliata, Veronica;
Getman, Konstantin;
Rivière-Marichalar, Pablo;
Birnstiel, Tilman;
Merín, Bruno;
Fang, Min;
Henning, Thomas;
Eiroa, Carlos;
Currie, Thayne
Submitted: 2014-10-10
(Abridged) We use Herschel PACS observations at 70 and 160$\mu$m to probe the
protoplanetary disks around young stars in the CepOB2 clusters Tr37 and NGC7160
and to trace the small-scale cloud structure. We detect 95 protoplanetary disks
at 70$\mu$m, 41 at 160$\mu$m, and obtain upper limits for over 130 objects. The
detection fraction at 70$\mu$m depends on the spectral type (88% for K4 or
earlier, 17% for M3 or later stars) and on the disk type ($\sim$50% for full
and pre-transitional disks, $\sim$35% for transitional disks, no
low-excess/depleted disks detected). Non-accreting disks are consistent with
significantly lower masses. Accreting transition and pre-transition disks have
higher 70$\mu$m excesses than full disks, suggestive of more massive, flared
and/or thicker disks. Herschel data also reveal several mini-clusters in Tr37,
small, compact structures containing a few young stars surrounded by
nebulosity. Far-IR data are an excellent probe of the evolution of disks that
are too faint for submillimetre observations. We find a strong link between
far-IR emission and accretion, and between the inner and outer disk structure.
Herschel confirms the dichotomy between accreting and non-accreting transition
disks. Substantial mass depletion and global evolution need to occur to shut
down accretion in a protoplanetary disk, even if the disk has inner holes.
Disks likely follow different evolutionary paths: Low disk masses do not imply
opening inner holes, and having inner holes does not require low disk masses.
The mini-clusters reveal multi-episodic star formation in Tr37. The long
survival of mini-clusters suggest that they formed from the fragmentation of
the same core. Their various morphologies favour different formation/triggering
mechanisms acting within the same cluster. Herschel also unveils what could be
the first heavy mass loss episode of the O6.5 star HD206267.
[69]
oai:arXiv.org:1405.6542 [pdf] - 1209728
ALMA hints at the presence of two companions in the disk around HD
100546
Walsh, Catherine;
Juhasz, Attila;
Pinilla, Paola;
Harsono, Daniel;
Mathews, Geoffrey S.;
Dent, William R. F.;
Hogerheijde, Michiel R.;
Birnstiel, T.;
Meeus, Gwendolyn;
Nomura, Hideko;
Aikawa, Yuri;
Millar, T. J.;
Sandell, Goran
Submitted: 2014-05-26, last modified: 2014-07-10
HD 100546 is a well-studied Herbig Be star-disk system that likely hosts a
close-in companion with compelling observational evidence for an embedded
protoplanet at 68 AU. We present ALMA observations of the HD 100546 disk which
resolve the gas and dust structure at (sub)mm wavelengths. The CO emission (at
345.795 GHz) originates from an extensive molecular disk (390+/-20 AU in
radius) whereas the continuum emission is more compact (230+/-20 AU in radius)
suggesting radial drift of the mm-sized grains. The CO emission is similar in
extent to scattered light images indicating well-mixed gas and um-sized grains
in the disk atmosphere. Assuming azimuthal symmetry, a single-component
power-law model cannot reproduce the continuum visibilities. The visibilities
and images are better reproduced by a double-component model: a compact ring
with a width of 21 AU centered at 26 AU and an outer ring with a width of
75+/-3 AU centered at 190+/-3 AU. The influence of a companion and protoplanet
on the dust evolution is investigated. The companion at 10 AU facilitates the
accumulation of mm-sized grains within a compact ring, ~ 20 - 30 AU, by ~ 10
Myr. The injection of a protoplanet at 1 Myr hastens the ring formation (~ 1.2
Myr) and also triggers the development of an outer ring (~ 100 - 200 AU). These
observations provide additional evidence for the presence of a close-in
companion and hint at dynamical clearing by a protoplanet in the outer disk.
[70]
oai:arXiv.org:1404.5652 [pdf] - 1209105
Resolved Multifrequency Radio Observations of GG Tau
Andrews, Sean M.;
Chandler, Claire J.;
Isella, Andrea;
Birnstiel, Tilman;
Rosenfeld, Katherine A.;
Wilner, David J.;
Perez, Laura M.;
Ricci, Luca;
Carpenter, John M.;
Calvet, Nuria;
Corder, Stuartt A.;
Deller, Adam T.;
Dullemond, Cornelis P.;
Greaves, Jane S.;
Harris, Robert J.;
Henning, Thomas;
Kwon, Woojin;
Lazio, Joseph;
Linz, Hendrik;
Mundy, Lee G.;
Sargent, Anneila I.;
Storm, Shaye;
Testi, Leonardo
Submitted: 2014-04-22
We present sub-arcsecond resolution observations of continuum emission
associated with the GG Tau quadruple star system at wavelengths of 1.3, 2.8,
7.3, and 50 mm. These data confirm that the GG Tau A binary is encircled by a
circumbinary ring at a radius of 235 AU with a FWHM width of ~60 AU. We find no
clear evidence for a radial gradient in the spectral shape of the ring,
suggesting that the particle size distribution is spatially homogeneous on
angular scales of ~0.1". A central point source, likely associated with the
primary component (GG Tau Aa), exhibits a composite spectrum from dust and
free-free emission. Faint emission at 7.3 mm is observed toward the low-mass
star GG Tau Ba, although its origin remains uncertain. Using these measurements
of the resolved, multifrequency emission structure of the GG Tau A system,
models of the far-infrared to radio spectrum are developed to place constraints
on the grain size distribution and dust mass in the circumbinary ring. The
non-negligible curvature present in the ring spectrum implies a maximum
particle size of 1-10 mm, although we are unable to place strong constraints on
the distribution shape. The corresponding dust mass is 30-300 M_earth, at a
temperature of 20-30 K. We discuss how this significant concentration of
relatively large particles in a narrow ring at a large radius might be produced
in a local region of higher gas pressures (i.e., a particle "trap") located
near the inner edge of the circumbinary disk.
[71]
oai:arXiv.org:1402.5778 [pdf] - 820793
Millimetre spectral indices of transition disks and their relation to
the cavity radius
Pinilla, P.;
Benisty, M.;
Birnstiel, T.;
Ricci, L.;
Isella, A.;
Natta, A.;
Dullemond, C. P.;
Quiroga-Nuñez, L. H.;
Henning, T.;
Testi, L.
Submitted: 2014-02-24, last modified: 2014-03-14
Transition disks are protoplanetary disks with inner depleted dust cavities
and excellent candidates to investigate the dust evolution under the existence
of a pressure bump. A pressure bump at the outer edge of the cavity allows dust
grains from the outer regions to stop their rapid inward migration towards the
star and efficiently grow to millimetre sizes. Dynamical interactions with
planet(s) have been one of the most exciting theories to explain the clearing
of the inner disk. We look for evidence of the presence of millimetre dust
particles in transition disks by measuring their spectral index with new and
available photometric data. We investigate the influence of the size of the
dust depleted cavity on the disk integrated millimetre spectral index. We
present the 3mm photometric observations carried out with PdBI of four
transition disks: LkHa330, UXTauA, LRLL31, and LRLL67. We use available values
of their fluxes at 345GHz to calculate their spectral index, as well as the
spectral index for a sample of twenty transition disks. We compare the
observations with two kind of models. In the first set of models, we consider
coagulation and fragmentation of dust in a disk in which a cavity is formed by
a massive planet located at different positions. The second set of models
assumes disks with truncated inner parts at different radius and with power-law
dust size distributions, where the maximum size of grains is calculated
considering turbulence as the source of destructive collisions. We show that
the integrated spectral index is higher for transition disks than for regular
protoplanetary disks. For transition disks, the probability that the measured
spectral index is positively correlated with the cavity radius is 95%. High
angular resolution imaging of transition disks is needed to distinguish between
the dust trapping scenario and the truncated disk case.
[72]
oai:arXiv.org:1402.1354 [pdf] - 1203212
Dust Evolution in Protoplanetary Disks
Testi, Leonardo;
Birnstiel, Tilman;
Ricci, Luca;
Andrews, Sean;
Blum, Juergen;
Carpenter, John;
Dominik, Carsten;
Isella, Andrea;
Natta, Antonella;
Williams, Jonathan;
Wilner, David
Submitted: 2014-02-06
(abridged) In the core accretion scenario for the formation of planetary
rocky cores, the first step toward planet formation is the growth of dust
grains into larger and larger aggregates and eventually planetesimals. Although
dust grains are thought to grow from the submicron sizes typical of
interstellar dust to micron size particles in the dense regions of molecular
clouds and cores, the growth from micron size particles to pebbles and
kilometre size bodies must occur in protoplanetary disks. This step in the
formation of planetary systems is the last stage of solids evolution that can
be observed directly in young extrasolar systems.
In this chapter we review the constraints on the physics of grain-grain
collisions as they have emerged from laboratory experiments and numerical
computations. We then review the current theoretical understanding of the
global processes governing the evolution of solids in protoplanetary disks,
including dust settling, growth, and radial transport. The predicted
observational signatures are summarized.
We discuss recent developments in the study of grain growth in molecular
cloud cores and in collapsing envelopes of protostars as these provide the
initial conditions for the dust in disks. We discuss the observational evidence
for the growth of grains in young disks from mm surveys, as well as the recent
evidence of radial variations of the dust properties in disks. We include a
brief discussion of the constraints on the small end of the grain size
distribution and on dust settling as derived from optical and IR observations.
The observations are discussed in the context of global dust evolution models,
in particular we focus on the emerging evidence for a very efficient early
growth of grains and the radial distribution of grain sizes in disks. We also
highlight the limits of current models, including the need to slow the radial
drift of grains.
[73]
oai:arXiv.org:1311.5222 [pdf] - 1201767
On the Outer Edges of Protoplanetary Dust Disks
Submitted: 2013-11-20
The expectation that aerodynamic drag will force the solids in a gas-rich
protoplanetary disk to spiral in toward the host star on short timescales is
one of the fundamental problems in planet formation theory. The nominal
efficiency of this radial drift process is in conflict with observations,
suggesting that an empirical calibration of solid transport mechanisms in a
disk is highly desirable. However, the fact that both radial drift and grain
growth produce a similar particle size segregation in a disk (such that larger
particles are preferentially concentrated closer to the star) makes it
difficult to disentangle a clear signature of drift alone. We highlight a new
approach, by showing that radial drift leaves a distinctive "fingerprint" in
the dust surface density profile that is directly accessible to current
observational facilities. Using an analytical framework for dust evolution, we
demonstrate that the combined effects of drift and (viscous) gas drag naturally
produce a sharp outer edge in the dust distribution (or, equivalently, a sharp
decrease in the dust-to-gas mass ratio). This edge feature forms during the
earliest phase in the evolution of disk solids, before grain growth in the
outer disk has made much progress, and is preserved over longer timescales when
both growth and transport effects are more substantial. The key features of
these analytical models are reproduced in detailed numerical simulations, and
are qualitatively consistent with recent millimeter-wave observations that find
gas/dust size discrepancies and steep declines in dust continuum emission in
the outer regions of protoplanetary disks.
[74]
oai:arXiv.org:1309.1039 [pdf] - 1178997
Imaging diagnostics for transitional discs
Submitted: 2013-09-03
Transitional discs are a special type of protoplanetary discs where planet
formation is thought to be taking place. These objects feature characteristic
inner cavities and/or gaps of a few tens of AUs in the sub-millimitre images of
the disc. This signature suggests a localised depletion of matter in the disc
that could be caused by planet formation processes. However, recent
observations have revealed differences in the structures imaged at different
wavelengths in some of these discs. In this paper, we aim to explain these
observational differences using self-consistent physical 2-D hydrodynamical and
dust evolution models of such objects, assuming their morphology is indeed
generated by the presence of a planet. We use these models to derive the
distribution of gas and dust in a theoretical planet-hosting disc, for various
planet masses and orbital separations. We then simulate observations of the
emitted and scattered light from these models with VLT/SPHERE ZIMPOL,
Subaru/HiCIAO, VLT/VISIR and ALMA. We do this by first computing the full
resolution images of the models at different wavelengths, and then simulating
the observations accounting for the characteristics of each particular
instrument. The presence of the planet generates pressure bumps in the gas
distribution of the disc whose characteristics strongly depend on the planet
mass and position. These bumps cause large grains to accumulate while small
grains are allowed into inner regions. This spatial differentiation of the
grain sizes explains the differences in the observations since different
wavelengths and observing techniques trace different parts of the dust size
distribution. Based on this effect, we conclude that the combination of
visible/near-infrared polarimetric and sub-mm images is the best strategy to
constrain the properties of the unseen planet responsible for the disc
structure.
[75]
oai:arXiv.org:1306.1768 [pdf] - 677280
A Major Asymmetric Dust Trap in a Transition Disk
van der Marel, Nienke;
van Dishoeck, Ewine F.;
Bruderer, Simon;
Birnstiel, Til;
Pinilla, Paola;
Dullemond, Cornelis P.;
van Kempen, Tim A.;
Schmalzl, Markus;
Brown, Joanna M.;
Herczeg, Gregory J.;
Mathews, Geoffrey S.;
Geers, Vincent
Submitted: 2013-06-07
The statistics of discovered exoplanets suggest that planets form
efficiently. However, there are fundamental unsolved problems, such as
excessive inward drift of particles in protoplanetary disks during planet
formation. Recent theories invoke dust traps to overcome this problem. We
report the detection of a dust trap in the disk around the star Oph IRS 48
using observations from the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array
(ALMA). The 0.44-millimeter-wavelength continuum map shows high-contrast
crescent-shaped emission on one side of the star originating from
millimeter-sized grains, whereas both the mid-infrared image (micrometer-sized
dust) and the gas traced by the carbon monoxide 6-5 rotational line suggest
rings centered on the star. The difference in distribution of big grains versus
small grains/gas can be modeled with a vortex-shaped dust trap triggered by a
companion.
[76]
oai:arXiv.org:1304.6638 [pdf] - 664879
Explaining millimeter-sized particles in brown dwarf disks
Submitted: 2013-04-24
Planets have been detected around a variety of stars, including low-mass
objects, such as brown dwarfs. However, such extreme cases are challenging for
planet formation models. Recent sub-millimeter observations of disks around
brown dwarf measured low spectral indices of the continuum emission that
suggest that dust grains grow to mm-sizes even in these very low mass
environments. To understand the first steps of planet formation in scaled-down
versions of T-Tauri disks, we investigate the physical conditions that can
theoretically explain the growth from interstellar dust to millimeter-sized
grains in disks around brown dwarf. We modeled the evolution of dust particles
under conditions of low-mass disks around brown dwarfs. We used coagulation,
fragmentation and disk-structure models to simulate the evolution of dust, with
zero and non-zero radial drift. For the non-zero radial drift, we considered
strong inhomogeneities in the gas surface density profile that mimic long-lived
pressure bumps in the disk. We studied different scenarios that could lead to
an agreement between theoretical models and the spectral slope found by
millimeter observations. We find that fragmentation is less likely and rapid
inward drift is more significant for particles in brown dwarf disks than in
T-Tauri disks. We present different scenarios that can nevertheless explain
millimeter-sized grains. As an example, a model that combines the following
parameters can fit the millimeter fluxes measured for brown dwarf disks: strong
pressure inhomogeneities of $\sim$ 40% of amplitude, a small radial extent
$\sim$ 15 AU, a moderate turbulence strength $\alpha_{\mathrm{turb}}= 10^{-3}$,
and average fragmentation velocities for ices $v_f = 10 m s^{-1}$.
[77]
oai:arXiv.org:1302.1403 [pdf] - 1159547
Protoplanetary Disk Structure With Grain Evolution: the ANDES Model
Submitted: 2013-02-06
We present a self-consistent model of a protoplanetary disk: 'ANDES'
('AccretioN disk with Dust Evolution and Sedimentation'). ANDES is based on a
flexible and extendable modular structure that includes 1) a 1+1D
frequency-dependent continuum radiative transfer module, 2) a module to
calculate the chemical evolution using an extended gas-grain network with
UV/X-ray-driven processes surface reactions, 3) a module to calculate the gas
thermal energy balance, and 4) a 1+1D module that simulates dust grain
evolution. For the first time, grain evolution and time-dependent molecular
chemistry are included in a protoplanetary disk model. We find that grain
growth and sedimentation of large grains to the disk midplane lead to a
dust-depleted atmosphere. Consequently, dust and gas temperatures become higher
in the inner disk (R < 50 AU) and lower in the outer disk (R > 50 AU), in
comparison with the disk model with pristine dust. The response of disk
chemical structure to the dust growth and sedimentation is twofold. First, due
to higher transparency a partly UV-shielded molecular layer is shifted closer
to the dense midplane. Second, the presence of big grains in the disk midplane
delays the freeze-out of volatile gas-phase species such as CO there, while in
adjacent upper layers the depletion is still effective. Molecular
concentrations and thus column densities of many species are enhanced in the
disk model with dust evolution, e.g., CO2, NH2CN, HNO, H2O, HCOOH, HCN, CO. We
also show that time-dependent chemistry is important for a proper description
of gas thermal balance.
[78]
oai:arXiv.org:1301.1976 [pdf] - 1158930
Lopsided dust rings in transition disks
Submitted: 2013-01-09
Context. Particle trapping in local or global pressure maxima in
protoplanetary disks is one of the new paradigms in the theory of the first
stages of planet formation. However, finding observational evidence for this
effect is not easy. Recent work suggests that the large ring-shaped outer disks
observed in transition disk sources may in fact be lopsided and constitute
large banana-shaped vortices.
Aims. We wish to investigate how effective dust can accumulate along the
azimuthal direction. We also want to find out if the size- sorting resulting
from this can produce a detectable signatures at millimeter wavelengths.
Methods. To keep the numerical cost under control we develop a 1+1D method in
which the azimuthal variations are treated sepa- rately from the radial ones.
The azimuthal structure is calculated analytically for a steady-state between
mixing and azimuthal drift. We derive equilibration time scales and compare the
analytical solutions to time-dependent numerical simulations.
Results. We find that weak, but long-lived azimuthal density gradients in the
gas can induce very strong azimuthal accumulations of dust. The strength of the
accumulations depends on the P\'eclet number, which is the relative importance
of advection and diffusion. We apply our model to transition disks and our
simulated observations show that this effect would be easily observable with
ALMA and in principle allows to put constraints on the strength of turbulence
and the local gas density.
[79]
oai:arXiv.org:1208.0304 [pdf] - 1150444
Breaking through: The effects of a velocity distribution on barriers to
dust growth
Submitted: 2012-08-01
It is unknown how far dust growth can proceed by coagulation. Obstacles to
collisional growth are the fragmentation and bouncing barriers. However, in all
previous simulations of the dust-size evolution in protoplanetary disks, only
the mean collision velocity has been considered, neglecting that a small but
possibly important fraction of the collisions will occur at both much lower and
higher velocities. We study the effect of the probability distribution of
impact velocities on the collisional dust growth barriers. Assuming a
Maxwellian velocity distribution for colliding particles to determine the
fraction of sticking, bouncing, and fragmentation, we implement this in a
dust-size evolution code. We also calculate the probability of growing through
the barriers and the growth timescale in these regimes. We find that the
collisional growth barriers are not as sharp as previously thought. With the
existence of low-velocity collisions, a small fraction of the particles manage
to grow to masses orders of magnitude above the main population. A particle
velocity distribution softens the fragmentation barrier and removes the
bouncing barrier. It broadens the size distribution in a natural way, allowing
the largest particles to become the first seeds that initiate sweep-up growth
towards planetesimal sizes.
[80]
oai:arXiv.org:1207.6485 [pdf] - 563377
Ring shaped dust accumulation in transition disks
Submitted: 2012-07-27
Context.Transition disks are believed to be the final stages of
protoplanetary disks, during which a forming planetary system or
photoevaporation processes open a gap in the inner disk, drastically changing
the disk structure. From theoretical arguments it is expected that dust growth,
fragmentation and radial drift are strongly influenced by gas disk structure,
and pressure bumps in disks have been suggested as key features that may allow
grains to converge and grow efficiently.
Aims. We want to study how the presence of a large planet in a disk
influences the growth and radial distribution of dust grains, and how
observable properties are linked to the mass of the planet.
Methods. We combine two-dimensional hydrodynamical disk simulations of
disk-planet interactions with state-of-the-art coagulation/fragmentation models
to simulate the evolution of dust in a disk which has a gap created by a
massive planet. We compute images at different wavelengths and illustrate our
results using the example of the transition disk LkCa15.
Results. The gap opened by a planet and the long-range interaction between
the planet and the outer disk create a single large pressure bump outside the
planetary orbit. Millimeter-sized particles form and accumulate at the pressure
maximum and naturally produce ring-shaped sub-millimeter emission that is
long-lived because radial drift no longer depletes the large grain population
of the disk. For large planet masses around 9 $M_{\mathrm{Jup}}$, the pressure
maximum and, therefore, the ring of millimeter particles is located at
distances that can be more than twice the star-planet separation, creating a
large spatial separation between the gas inner edge of the outer disk and the
peak millimeter emission. Smaller grains do get closer to the gap and we
predict how the surface brightness varies at different wavelengths.
[81]
oai:arXiv.org:1206.5802 [pdf] - 530623
Can grain growth explain transition disks?
Submitted: 2012-06-25
Aims: Grain growth has been suggested as one possible explanation for the
diminished dust optical depths in the inner regions of protoplanetary
"transition" disks. In this work, we directly test this hypothesis in the
context of current models of grain growth and transport.
Methods: A set of dust evolution models with different disk shapes, masses,
turbulence parameters, and drift efficiencies is combined with radiative
transfer calculations in order to derive theoretical spectral energy
distributions (SEDs) and images.
Results: We find that grain growth and transport effects can indeed produce
dips in the infrared SED, as typically found in observations of transition
disks. Our models achieve the necessary reduction of mass in small dust by
producing larger grains, yet not large enough to be fragmenting efficiently.
However, this population of large grains is still detectable at millimeter
wavelengths. Even if perfect sticking is assumed and radial drift is neglected,
a large population of dust grains is left behind because the time scales on
which they are swept up by the larger grains are too long. This mechanism thus
fails to reproduce the large emission cavities observed in recent
millimeter-wave interferometric images of accreting transition disks.
[82]
oai:arXiv.org:1201.5781 [pdf] - 486276
A simple model for the evolution of the dust population in
protoplanetary disks
Submitted: 2012-01-27
Context: The global size and spatial distribution of dust is an important
ingredient in the structure and evolution of protoplanetary disks and in the
formation of larger bodies, such as planetesimals. Aims: We aim to derive
simple equations that explain the global evolution of the dust surface density
profile and the upper limit of the grain size distribution and which can
readily be used for further modeling or for interpreting of observational data.
Methods: We have developed a simple model that follows the upper end of the
dust size distribution and the evolution of the dust surface density profile.
This model is calibrated with state-of-the-art simulations of dust evolution,
which treat dust growth, fragmentation, and transport in viscously evolving gas
disks. Results: We find very good agreement between the full dust-evolution
code and the toy model presented in this paper. We derive analytical profiles
that describe the dust-to-gas ratios and the dust surface density profiles well
in protoplanetary disks, as well as the radial flux by solid material "rain
out", which is crucial for triggering any gravity assisted formation of
planetesimals. We show that fragmentation is the dominating effect in the inner
regions of the disk leading to a dust surface density exponent of -1.5, while
the outer regions at later times can become drift-dominated, yielding a dust
surface density exponent of -0.75. Our results show that radial drift is not
efficient in fragmenting dust grains. This supports the theory that small dust
grains are resupplied by fragmentation due to the turbulent state of the disk.
[83]
oai:arXiv.org:1201.4282 [pdf] - 1093135
Planetesimal formation by sweep-up: How the bouncing barrier can be
beneficial to growth
Submitted: 2012-01-20
The formation of planetesimals is often accredited to collisional sticking of
dust grains. The exact process is unknown, as collisions between larger
aggregates tend to lead to fragmentation or bouncing rather than sticking.
Recent laboratory experiments have however made great progress in the
understanding and mapping of the complex physics involved in dust collisions.
We want to study the possibility of planetesimal formation using the results
from the latest laboratory experiments, particularly by including the
fragmentation with mass transfer effect, which might lead to growth even at
high impact velocities. We present a new experimentally and physically
motivated dust collision model capable of predicting the outcome of a collision
between two particles of arbitrary masses and velocities. It is used together
with a continuum dust-size evolution code that is both fast in terms of
execution time and able to resolve the dust well at all sizes, allowing for all
types of interactions to be studied without biases. We find that for the
general dust population, bouncing collisions prevent the growth above
millimeter-sizes. However, if a small number of cm-sized particles are
introduced, for example due to vertical mixing or radial drift, they can act as
a catalyst and start to sweep up the smaller particles. At a distance of 3 AU,
100-meter-sized bodies are formed on a timescale of 1 Myr. We conclude that
direct growth of planetesimals might be a possibility thanks to a combination
of the existence of a bouncing barrier and the fragmentation with mass transfer
effect. The bouncing barrier is here even beneficial, as it prevents the growth
of too many large particles that would otherwise only fragment among each
other, and creates a reservoir of small particles that can be swept up by
larger bodies. However, for this process to work, a few seeds of cm in size or
larger have to be introduced.
[84]
oai:arXiv.org:1111.5037 [pdf] - 1091822
The TW Hya Disk at 870 microns: Comparison of CO and Dust Radial
Structures
Andrews, Sean M.;
Wilner, David J.;
Hughes, A. M.;
Qi, Chunhua;
Rosenfeld, Katherine A.;
Oberg, Karin I.;
Birnstiel, T.;
Espaillat, Catherine;
Cieza, Lucas A.;
Williams, Jonathan P.;
Lin, Shin-Yi;
Ho, Paul T. P.
Submitted: 2011-11-21, last modified: 2011-12-16
We present high resolution (0.3" = 16 AU), high signal-to-noise ratio
Submillimeter Array observations of the 870 microns (345 GHz) continuum and CO
J=3--2 line emission from the protoplanetary disk around TW Hya. Using
continuum and line radiative transfer calculations, those data and the
multiwavelength spectral energy distribution are analyzed together in the
context of simple two-dimensional parametric disk structure models. Under the
assumptions of a radially invariant dust population and (vertically integrated)
gas-to-dust mass ratio, we are unable to simultaneously reproduce the CO and
dust observations with model structures that employ either a single, distinct
outer boundary or a smooth (exponential) taper at large radii. Instead, we find
that the distribution of millimeter-sized dust grains in the TW Hya disk has a
relatively sharp edge near 60 AU, contrary to the CO emission (and
optical/infrared scattered light) that extends to a much larger radius of at
least 215 AU. We discuss some possible explanations for the observed radial
distribution of millimeter-sized dust grains and the apparent CO-dust size
discrepancy, and suggest that they may be hallmarks of substructure in the dust
disk or natural signatures of the growth and radial drift of solids that might
be expected for disks around older pre-main sequence stars like TW Hya.
[85]
oai:arXiv.org:1112.2349 [pdf] - 475765
Trapping dust particles in the outer regions of protoplanetary disks
Submitted: 2011-12-11
In order to explain grain growth to mm sized particles and their retention in
outer regions of protoplanetary disks, as it is observed at sub-mm and mm
wavelengths, we investigate if strong inhomogeneities in the gas density
profiles can slow down excessive radial drift and can help dust particles to
grow. We use coagulation/fragmentation and disk-structure models, to simulate
the evolution of dust in a bumpy surface density profile which we mimic with a
sinusoidal disturbance. For different values of the amplitude and length scale
of the bumps, we investigate the ability of this model to produce and retain
large particles on million years time scales. In addition, we introduced a
comparison between the pressure inhomogeneities considered in this work and the
pressure profiles that come from magnetorotational instability. Using the
Common Astronomy Software Applications ALMA simulator, we study if there are
observational signatures of these pressure inhomogeneities that can be seen
with ALMA. We present the favorable conditions to trap dust particles and the
corresponding calculations predicting the spectral slope in the mm-wavelength
range, to compare with current observations. Finally we present simulated
images using different antenna configurations of ALMA at different frequencies,
to show that the ring structures will be detectable at the distances of the
Taurus Auriga or Ophiucus star forming regions.
[86]
oai:arXiv.org:1107.3466 [pdf] - 386900
The Evolution of Gas and Dust in Protoplanetary Accretion Disks
Submitted: 2011-07-18
Dust constitutes only about one percent of the mass of circumstellar disks,
yet it is of crucial importance for the modeling of planet formation, disk
chemistry, radiative transfer and observations. The initial growth of dust from
sub-micron sized grains to planetesimals and also the radial transport of dust
in disks around young stars is the topic of this thesis. Circumstellar dust is
subject to radial drift, vertical settling, turbulent mixing, collisional
growth, fragmentation and erosion.
We approach this subject from three directions: analytical calculations,
numerical simulations, and comparison to observations. We describe the physical
and numerical concepts that go into a model which is able to simulate the
radial and size evolution of dust in a gas disk which is viscously evolving
over several million years. The resulting dust size distributions are compared
to our analytical predictions and a simple recipe for obtaining steady-state
dust size distributions is derived. With the numerical model at hand, we show
that grain fragmentation can explain the fact that circumstellar disks are
observed to be dust-rich for several million years. Finally, we investigate the
challenges that observations present to the theory of grain evolution, namely
that grains of millimeter sizes are observed at large distances from the star.
We have found that under the assumption that radial drift is ineffective, we
can reproduce some of the observed spectral indices and fluxes. Fainter objects
point towards a reduced dust-to-gas ratio or lower dust opacities.
[87]
oai:arXiv.org:1106.2150 [pdf] - 1077211
The mm-colors of a young binary disk system in the Orion Nebula Cluster
Submitted: 2011-06-10
We present new EVLA continuum observations at 7 mm of the 253-1536 binary
disk system in the Orion Nebula Cluster. The measured fluxes were combined with
data in the sub-mm to derive the millimeter spectral index of each individual
disk component. We show how these observations can be used to test the models
of dust evolution and early growth of solids in protoplanetary disks. Our
analysis indicates that the disk with lower density and higher temperature
hosts larger grains than the companion disk. This result is the opposite of
what predicted by the dust evolution models. The models and observational
results can be reconciled if the viscosity $\alpha$-parameter differs by more
than a factor of ten in the two disks, or if the distribution of solids in the
disks is strongly affected by radial motions. This analysis can be applied to
future high-angular resolution observations of young disks with EVLA and ALMA
to provide even stronger observational constraints to the models of dust
evolution in protoplanetary disks.
[88]
oai:arXiv.org:1011.4420 [pdf] - 1042081
Impact of grain evolution on the chemical structure of protoplanetary
disks
Submitted: 2010-11-19
We study the impact of dust evolution in a protoplanetary disk around a T
Tauri star on the disk chemical composition. For the first time we utilize a
comprehensive model of dust evolution which includes growth, fragmentation and
sedimentation. Specific attention is paid to the influence of grain evolution
on the penetration of the UV field in the disk. A chemical model that includes
a comprehensive set of gas phase and grain surface chemical reactions is used
to simulate the chemical structure of the disk. The main effect of the grain
evolution on the disk chemical composition comes from sedimentation, and, to a
lesser degree, from the reduction of the total grain surface area. The net
effect of grain growth is suppressed by the fragmentation process which
maintains a population of small grains, dominating the total grain surface
area. We consider three models of dust properties. In model GS both growth and
sedimentation are taken into account. In models A5 and A4 all grains are
assumed to have the same size (10(-5) cm and 10(-4) cm, respectively) with
constant gas-to-dust mass ratio of 100. Like in previous studies, the
"three-layer" pattern (midplane, molecular layer, hot atmosphere) in the disk
chemical structure is preserved in all models, but shifted closer to the
midplane in models with increased grain size (GS and A4). Unlike other similar
studies, we find that in models GS and A4 column densities of most gas-phase
species are enhanced by 1-3 orders of magnitude relative to those in a model
with pristine dust (A5), while column densities of their surface counterparts
are decreased. We show that column densities of certain species, like C2H,
HC(2n+1)N (n=0-3), H2O and some other molecules, as well as the C2H2/HCN
abundance ratio which are accessible with Herschel and ALMA can be used as
observational tracers of early stages of the grain evolution process in
protoplanetary disks.
[89]
oai:arXiv.org:1009.3011 [pdf] - 228508
Dust size distributions in coagulation/fragmentation equilibrium:
Numerical solutions and analytical fits
Submitted: 2010-09-15
Context. Grains in circumstellar disks are believed to grow by mutual
collisions and subsequent sticking due to surface forces. Results of many
fields of research involving circumstellar disks, such as radiative transfer
calculations, disk chemistry, magneto-hydrodynamic simulations largely depend
on the unknown grain size distribution.
Aims. As detailed calculations of grain growth and fragmentation are both
numerically challenging and computationally expensive, we aim to find simple
recipes and analytical solutions for the grain size distribution in
circumstellar disks for a scenario in which grain growth is limited by
fragmentation and radial drift can be neglected.
Methods. We generalize previous analytical work on self-similar steady-state
grain distributions. Numerical simulations are carried out to identify under
which conditions the grain size distributions can be understood in terms of a
combination of power-law distributions. A physically motivated fitting formula
for grain size distributions is derived using our analytical predictions and
numerical simulations.
Results. We find good agreement between analytical results and numerical
solutions of the Smoluchowski equation for simple shapes of the kernel
function. The results for more complicated and realistic cases can be fitted
with a physically motivated "black box" recipe presented in this paper. Our
results show that the shape of the dust distribution is mostly dominated by the
gas surface density (not the dust-to-gas ratio), the turbulence strength and
the temperature and does not obey an MRN type distribution.
[90]
oai:arXiv.org:1006.0940 [pdf] - 203707
Testing the theory of grain growth and fragmentation by millimeter
observations of protoplanetary disks
Birnstiel, T.;
Ricci, L.;
Trotta, F.;
Dullemond, C. P.;
Natta, A.;
Testi, L.;
Dominik, C.;
Henning, T.;
Ormel, C. W.;
Zsom, A.
Submitted: 2010-06-04
Context. Observations at sub-millimeter and mm wavelengths will in the near
future be able to resolve the radial dependence of the mm spectral slope in
circumstellar disks with a resolution of around a few AU at the distance of the
closest star-forming regions.
Aims. We aim to constrain physical models of grain growth and fragmentation
by a large sample of (sub-)mm observations of disks around pre-main sequence
stars in the Taurus-Auriga and Ophiuchus star-forming regions.
Methods. State-of-the-art coagulation/fragmentation and disk-structure codes
are coupled to produce steady-state grain size distributions and to predict the
spectral slopes at (sub-)mm wavelengths.
Results. This work presents the first calculations predicting the mm spectral
slope based on a physical model of grain growth. Our models can quite naturally
reproduce the observed mm-slopes, but a simultaneous match to the observed
range of flux levels can only be reached by a reduction of the dust mass by a
factor of a few up to about 30 while keeping the gas mass of the disk the same.
This dust reduction can either be due to radial drift at a reduced rate or
during an earlier evolutionary time (otherwise the predicted fluxes would
become too low) or due to efficient conversion of dust into larger, unseen
bodies.
[91]
oai:arXiv.org:1002.0335 [pdf] - 158338
Gas- and dust evolution in protoplanetary disks
Submitted: 2010-02-01
Context. Current models of the size- and radial evolution of dust in
protoplanetary disks generally oversimplify either the radial evolution of the
disk (by focussing at one single radius or by using steady state disk models)
or they assume particle growth to proceed monodispersely or without
fragmentation. Further studies of protoplanetary disks - such as observations,
disk chemistry and structure calculations or planet population synthesis models
- depend on the distribution of dust as a function of grain size and radial
position in the disk.
Aims. We attempt to improve upon current models to be able to investigate how
the initial conditions, the build-up phase, and the evolution of the
protoplanetary disk influence growth and transport of dust.
Methods. We introduce a new version of the model of Brauer et al. (2008) in
which we now include the time-dependent viscous evolution of the gas disk, and
in which more advanced input physics and numerical integration methods are
implemented.
Results. We show that grain properties, the gas pressure gradient, and the
amount of turbulence are much more influencing the evolution of dust than the
initial conditions or the build-up phase of the protoplanetary disk. We
quantify which conditions or environments are favorable for growth beyond the
meter size barrier. High gas surface densities or zonal flows may help to
overcome the problem of radial drift, however already a small amount of
turbulence poses a much stronger obstacle for grain growth.
[92]
oai:arXiv.org:0907.0985 [pdf] - 26039
Dust retention in protoplanetary disks
Submitted: 2009-07-06, last modified: 2009-08-07
Context: Protoplanetary disks are observed to remain dust-rich for up to
several million years. Theoretical modeling, on the other hand, raises several
questions. Firstly, dust coagulation occurs so rapidly, that if the small dust
grains are not replenished by collisional fragmentation of dust aggregates,
most disks should be observed to be dust poor, which is not the case. Secondly,
if dust aggregates grow to sizes of the order of centimeters to meters, they
drift so fast inwards, that they are quickly lost.
Aims: We attempt to verify if collisional fragmentation of dust aggregates is
effective enough to keep disks 'dusty' by replenishing the population of small
grains and by preventing excessive radial drift.
Methods: With a new and sophisticated implicitly integrated coagulation and
fragmentation modeling code, we solve the combined problem of coagulation,
fragmentation, turbulent mixing and radial drift and at the same time solve for
the 1-D viscous gas disk evolution.
Results: We find that for a critical collision velocity of 1 m/s, as
suggested by laboratory experiments, the fragmentation is so effective, that at
all times the dust is in the form of relatively small particles. This means
that radial drift is small and that large amounts of small dust particles
remain present for a few million years, as observed. For a critical velocity of
10 m/s, we find that particles grow about two orders of magnitude larger, which
leads again to significant dust loss since larger particles are more strongly
affected by radial drift.