Normalized to: Bingert, S.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1811.01572 [pdf] - 2005387
Non-Fourier description of heat flux evolution in 3D MHD simulations of
the solar corona
Submitted: 2018-11-05, last modified: 2019-11-27
The hot loop structures in the solar corona can be well modeled by three
dimensional magnetohydrodynamic simulations, where the corona is heated by
field line braiding driven at the photosphere. To be able to reproduce the
emission comparable to observations, one has to use realistic values for the
Spitzer heat conductivity, which puts a large constraint on the time step of
these simulations and make them therefore computationally expensive. Here, we
present a non-Fourier description of the heat flux evolution, which allow us to
speed up the simulations significantly. Together with the semi-relativistic
Boris correction, we are able to limit the time step constraint of the Alfv\'en
speed and speed up the simulations even further. We discuss the implementation
of these two methods to the Pencil Code and present their implications on the
time step, and the temperature structures, the ohmic heating rate and the
emission in simulations of the solar corona. Using a non-Fourier description of
the heat flux evolution together with the Boris correction, we can increase the
time step of the simulation significantly without moving far away from the
reference solution. However, for values of the Alfv\'en speed limit of 3 000
km/s and below, the simulation moves away from the reference solution und
produces much higher temperatures and much structures with stronger emission.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1611.06170 [pdf] - 1596975
Current systems of coronal loops in 3D MHD simulations
Submitted: 2016-11-18, last modified: 2017-12-04
We study the magnetic field and current structure associated with a coronal
loop. Through this we investigate to what extent the assumptions of a
force-free magnetic field break down and where they might be justified. We
analyse a 3D MHD model of the solar corona in an emerging active region with
the focus on the structure of the forming coronal loops. The lower boundary of
this simulation is taken from a model of an emerging active region. As a
consequence of the emerging magnetic flux and the horizontal motions at the
surface a coronal loop forms self-consistently. We investigate the current
density along magnetic field inside (and outside) this loop and study the
magnetic and plasma properties in and around it. We find that the total current
along the loop changes its sign from being antiparallel to parallel to the
magnetic field. This is caused by the inclination of the loop together with the
footpoint motion. Around the loop the currents form a complex non-force-free
helical structure. This is directly related to a bipolar current structure at
the loop footpoints at the base of the corona and a local reduction of the
background magnetic field (i.e. outside the loop) caused by the plasma flow
into and along the loop. The locally reduced magnetic pressure in the loop
allows the loop to sustain a higher density, which is crucial for the emission
in extreme UV. The acting of the flow on the magnetic field hosting the loop
turns out to be also responsible for the observed squashing of the loop. The
complex magnetic field and current system surrounding it can be modeled only in
3D MHD models where the magnetic field has to balance the plasma pressure. A 1D
coronal loop model or a force-free extrapolation can not capture the current
system and the complex interaction of the plasma and the magnetic field in the
coronal loop, despite the fact that the loop is under low-$\beta$ conditions.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1305.5693 [pdf] - 1579458
Observationally driven 3D MHD model of the solar corona above an active
region
Submitted: 2013-05-24, last modified: 2017-09-16
Aims. The goal is to employ a 3D magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) model including
spectral synthesis to model the corona in an observed solar active region. This
will allow us to judge the merits of the coronal heating mechanism built into
the 3D model. Methods. Photospheric observations of the magnetic field and
horizontal velocities in an active region are used to drive our coronal
simulation from the bottom. The currents induced by this heat the corona
through Ohmic dissipation. Heat conduction redistributes the energy that is
lost in the end through optically thin radiation. Based on the MHD model, we
synthesized profiles of coronal emission lines which can be directly compared
to actual coronal observations of the very same active region. Results. In the
synthesized model data we find hot coronal loops which host siphon flows or
which expand and lose mass through draining. These synthesized loops are at the
same location as and show similar dynamics in terms of Doppler shifts to the
observed structures. This match is shown through a comparison with Hinode data
as well as with 3D stereoscopic reconstructions of data from STEREO.
Conclusions. The considerable match to the actual observations shows that the
field-line braiding mechanism leading to the energy input in our corona
provides the proper distribution of heat input in space and time. From this we
conclude that in an active region the field-line braiding is the dominant
heating process, at least at the spatial scales available to current
observations.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1603.05276 [pdf] - 1579858
Scaling laws of coronal loops compared to a 3D MHD model of an Active
Region
Submitted: 2016-03-16, last modified: 2017-09-16
Context. The structure and heating of coronal loops are investigated since
decades. Established scaling laws relate fundamental quantities like the loop
apex temperature, pressure, length, and the coronal heating. Aims. We test such
scaling laws against a large-scale 3D MHD model of the Solar corona, which
became feasible with nowadays high-performance computing. Methods. We drive an
active region simulation a with photospheric observations and found strong
similarities to the observed coronal loops in X-rays and EUV wavelength. A 3D
reconstruction of stereoscopic observations showed that our model loops have a
realistic spatial structure. We compare scaling laws to our model data
extracted along an ensemble of field lines. Finally, we fit a new scaling law
that represents well hot loops and also cooler structures, which was not
possible before only based on observations. Results. Our model data gives some
support for scaling laws that were established for hot and EUV-emissive coronal
loops. For the RTV scaling law we find an offset to our model data, which can
be explained by 1D considerations of a static loop with a constant heat input
and conduction. With a fit to our model data we set up a new scaling law for
the coronal heat input along magnetic field lines. Conclusions. RTV-like
scaling laws were fitted to hot loops and therefore do not predict well the
coronal heat input for cooler structures that are hardly observable. The basic
differences between 1D and self-consistent 3D modeling account for deviations
between our and earlier scaling laws. We also conclude that a heating mechanism
by MHD-turbulent dissipation within a braided flux tube would heat the corona
stronger than consistent with our model corona.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1507.03573 [pdf] - 1579668
Coronal energy input and dissipation in a solar active region 3D MHD
model
Submitted: 2015-07-13, last modified: 2017-09-16
Context. We have conducted a 3D MHD simulation of the solar corona above an
active region (AR) in full scale and high resolution, which shows coronal
loops, and plasma flows within them, similar to observations. Aims. We want to
find the connection between the photospheric energy input by field-line
braiding with the coronal energy conversion by Ohmic dissipation of induced
currents. Methods. To this end we compare the coronal energy input and
dissipation within our simulation domain above different fields of view, e.g.
for a small loops system in the AR core. We also choose an ensemble of field
lines to compare, e.g., the magnetic energy input to the heating per particle
along these field lines. Results. We find an enhanced Ohmic dissipation of
currents in the corona above areas that also have enhanced upwards-directed
Poynting flux. These regions coincide with the regions where hot coronal loops
within the AR core are observed. The coronal density plays a role in estimating
the coronal temperature due to the generated heat input. A minimum flux density
of about 200 Gauss is needed in the photosphere to heat a field line to coronal
temperatures of about 1 MK. Conclusions. This suggests that the field-line
braiding mechanism provides the coronal energy input and that the Ohmic
dissipation of induced currents dominates the coronal heating mechanism.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1505.01174 [pdf] - 989560
Magnetic Jam in the Corona of the Sun
Submitted: 2015-05-05
The outer solar atmosphere, the corona, contains plasma at temperatures of
more than a million K, more than 100 times hotter that solar surface. How this
gas is heated is a fundamental question tightly interwoven with the structure
of the magnetic field in the upper atmosphere. Conducting numerical experiments
based on magnetohydrodynamics we account for both the evolving
three-dimensional structure of the atmosphere and the complex interaction of
magnetic field and plasma. Together this defines the formation and evolution of
coronal loops, the basic building block prominently seen in X-rays and extreme
ultraviolet (EUV) images. The structures seen as coronal loops in the EUV can
evolve quite differently from the magnetic field. While the magnetic field
continuously expands as new magnetic flux emerges through the solar surface,
the plasma gets heated on successively emerging fieldlines creating an EUV loop
that remains roughly at the same place. For each snapshot the EUV images
outline the magnetic field, but in contrast to the traditional view, the
temporal evolution of the magnetic field and the EUV loops can be different.
Through this we show that the thermal and the magnetic evolution in the outer
atmosphere of a cool star has to be treated together, and cannot be simply
separated as done mostly so far.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1410.1216 [pdf] - 1684042
Coronal loops above an Active Region - observation versus model
Submitted: 2014-10-05
We conducted a high-resolution numerical simulation of the solar corona above
a stable active region. The aim is to test the field-line braiding mechanism
for a sufficient coronal energy input. We also check the applicability of
scaling laws for coronal loop properties like the temperature and density. Our
3D-MHD model is driven from below by Hinode observations of the photosphere, in
particular a high-cadence time series of line-of-sight magnetograms and
horizontal velocities derived from the magnetograms. This driving applies
stress to the magnetic field and thereby delivers magnetic energy into the
corona, where currents are induced that heat the coronal plasma by Ohmic
dissipation. We compute synthetic coronal emission that we directly compare to
coronal observations of the same active region taken by Hinode. In the model,
coronal loops form at the same places as they are found in coronal
observations. Even the shapes of the synthetic loops in 3D space match those
found from a stereoscopic reconstruction based on STEREO spacecraft data. Some
loops turn out to be slightly over-dense in the model, as expected from
observations. This shows that the spatial and temporal distribution of the
Ohmic heating produces the structure and dynamics of a coronal loops system
close to what is found in observations.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1402.5343 [pdf] - 820791
A model for the formation of the active region corona driven by magnetic
flux emergence
Submitted: 2014-02-21
We present the first model that couples the formation of the corona of a
solar active region to a model of the emergence of a sunspot pair. This allows
us to study when, where, and why active region loops form, and how they evolve.
We use a 3D radiation MHD simulation of the emergence of an active region
through the upper convection zone and the photosphere as a lower boundary for a
3D MHD coronal model. The latter accounts for the braiding of the magnetic
fieldlines, which induces currents in the corona heating up the plasma. We
synthesize the coronal emission for a direct comparison to observations.
Starting with a basically field-free atmosphere we follow the filling of the
corona with magnetic field and plasma. Numerous individually identifiable hot
coronal loops form, and reach temperatures well above 1 MK with densities
comparable to observations. The footpoints of these loops are found where small
patches of magnetic flux concentrations move into the sunspots. The loop
formation is triggered by an increase of upwards-directed Poynting flux at
their footpoints in the photosphere. In the synthesized EUV emission these
loops develop within a few minutes. The first EUV loop appears as a thin tube,
then rises and expands significantly in the horizontal direction. Later, the
spatially inhomogeneous heat input leads to a fragmented system of multiple
loops or strands in a growing envelope.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1306.4685 [pdf] - 1172167
Structure of solar coronal loops: from miniature to large-scale
Submitted: 2013-06-19
We will use new data from the High-resolution Coronal Imager (Hi-C) with
unprecedented spatial resolution of the solar corona to investigate the
structure of coronal loops down to 0.2 arcsec. During a rocket flight Hi-C
provided images of the solar corona in a wavelength band around 193 A that is
dominated by emission from Fe XII showing plasma at temperatures around 1.5 MK.
We analyze part of the Hi-C field-of-view to study the smallest coronal loops
observed so far and search for the a possible sub-structuring of larger loops.
We find tiny 1.5 MK loop-like structures that we interpret as miniature coronal
loops. These have length of the coronal segment above the chromosphere of only
about 1 Mm and a thickness of less than 200 km. They could be interpreted as
the coronal signature of small flux tubes breaking through the photosphere with
a footpoint distance corresponding to the diameter of a cell of granulation. We
find loops that are longer than 50 Mm to have a diameter of about 2 arcsec or
1.5 Mm, consistent with previous observations. However, Hi-C really resolves
these loops with some 20 pixels across the loop. Even at this greatly improved
spatial resolution the large loops seem to have no visible sub-structure.
Instead they show a smooth variation in cross-section. The fact that the large
coronal loops do not show a sub-structure at the spatial scale of 0.1 arcsec
per pixel implies that either the densities and temperatures are smoothly
varying across these loops or poses an upper limit on the diameter of strands
the loops might be composed of. We estimate that strands that compose the 2
arcsec thick loop would have to be thinner than 15 km. The miniature loops we
find for the first time pose a challenge to be properly understood in terms of
modeling.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1303.1371 [pdf] - 1165054
Parametrization of coronal heating: spatial distribution and observable
consequences
Submitted: 2013-03-06
We investigate the difference in the spatial distribution of the energy input
for parametrizations of different mechanisms to heat the corona of the Sun and
possible impacts on the coronal emission. We use a 3D MHD model of a solar
active region as a reference and compare the Ohmic-type heating in this model
to parametrizations for alternating current (AC) and direct current (DC)
heating models, in particular, we use Alfven wave and MHD turbulence heating.
We extract the quantities needed for these two parametrizations from the
reference model and investigate the spatial distribution of the heat input in
all three cases, globally and along individual field lines. To study
differences in the resulting coronal emission we employ 1D loop models with a
prescribed heat input based on the heating rate we extracted along a bundle of
field lines. On average, all heating implementations show a roughly drop of the
heating rate with height. This also holds for individual field lines. While all
mechanism show a concentration of the energy input towards the low parts of the
atmosphere, for individual field lines the concentration towards the footpoints
is much stronger for the DC mechanisms than for the Alfven wave AC case. In
contrast, the AC model gives a stronger concentration of the emission towards
the footpoints. This is because the more homogeneous distribution of the energy
input leads to higher coronal temperatures and a more extended transition
region. The significant difference in the concentration of the heat input
towards the foot points for the AC and DC mechanisms, and the pointed
difference in the spatial distribution of the coronal emission for these cases
shows that the two mechanisms should be discriminable by observations. Before
drawing final conclusions, these parametrizations should be implemented in new
3D models in a more self-consistent way.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1211.6417 [pdf] - 1158091
Nanoflare statistics in an active region 3D MHD coronal model
Submitted: 2012-11-27, last modified: 2013-01-21
Context. We investigate the statistics of the spatial and temporal
distribution of the coronal heating in a three-dimensional magneto-
hydrodynamical (3D MHD) model. The model describes the temporal evolution of
the corona above an observed active region. The model is driven by photospheric
granular motions which braid the magnetic field lines. This induces currents
and their dissipation heats the plasma. We evaluate the transient heating as
subsequent heating events and analyze their statistics. The results are then
interpreted in the context of observed flare statistics and coronal heating
mechanisms. Methods. To conduct the numerical experiment we use a high order
finite difference code which solves the partial differential equations for the
conservation of mass, the momentum and energy balance, and the induction
equation. The energy balance includes the Spitzer heat conduction and the
optical thin radiative loss in the corona. Results. The temporal and spatial
distribution of the Ohmic heating in the 3D MHD model follow a power law and
can therefore be explained by system in a self-organized critical state. The
slopes of the power law are similar to the results based on flare observations.
We find that the corona is heated foot point dominated and the coronal heating
is dominated by events called nanoflares with energies on the order of 1017 J.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1209.0789 [pdf] - 1151124
Constant cross section of loops in the solar corona
Submitted: 2012-09-04
The corona of the Sun is dominated by emission from loop-like structures.
When observed in X-ray or extreme ultraviolet emission, these million K hot
coronal loops show a more or less constant cross section. In this study we show
how the interplay of heating, radiative cooling, and heat conduction in an
expanding magnetic structure can explain the observed constant cross section.
We employ a three-dimensional magnetohydrodynamics (3D MHD) model of the
corona. The heating of the coronal plasma is the result of braiding of the
magnetic field lines through footpoint motions and subsequent dissipation of
the induced currents. From the model we synthesize the coronal emission, which
is directly comparable to observations from, e.g., the Atmospheric Imaging
Assembly on the Solar Dynamics Observatory (AIA/SDO). We find that the
synthesized observation of a coronal loop seen in the 3D data cube does match
actually observed loops in count rate and that the cross section is roughly
constant, as observed. The magnetic field in the loop is expanding and the
plasma density is concentrated in this expanding loop; however, the temperature
is not constant perpendicular to the plasma loop. The higher temperature in the
upper outer parts of the loop is so high that this part of the loop is outside
the contribution function of the respective emission line(s). In effect, the
upper part of the plasma loop is not bright and thus the loop actually seen in
coronal emission appears to have a constant width. From this we can conclude
that the underlying field-line-braiding heating mechanism provides the proper
spatial and temporal distribution of the energy input into the corona --- at
least on the observable scales.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1112.3667 [pdf] - 559280
Catastrophic cooling and cessation of heating in the solar corona
Submitted: 2011-12-15
Condensations in the more than 10^6 K hot corona of the Sun are commonly
observed in the extreme ultraviolet (EUV). While their contribution to the
total solar EUV radiation is still a matter of debate, these condensations
certainly provide a valuable tool for studying the dynamic response of the
corona to the heating processes. We investigate different distributions of
energy input in time and space to investigate which process is most relevant
for understanding these coronal condensations. For a comparison to observations
we synthesize EUV emission from a time-dependent, one-dimensional model for
coronal loops, where we employ two heating scenarios: simply shutting down the
heating and a model where the heating is very concentrated at the loop
footpoints, while keeping the total heat input constant. The heating off/on
model does not lead to significant EUV count rates that one observes with
SDO/AIA. In contrast, the concentration of the heating near the footpoints
leads to thermal non-equilibrium near the loop top resulting in the well-known
catastrophic cooling. This process gives a good match to observations of
coronal condensations. This shows that the corona needs a steady supply of
energy to support the coronal plasma, even during coronal condensations.
Otherwise the corona would drain very fast, too fast to even form a
condensation.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1106.5972 [pdf] - 1077642
Ejection of cool plasma into the hot corona
Submitted: 2011-06-29
We investigate the processes that lead to the formation, ejection and fall of
a confined plasma ejection that was observed in a numerical experiment of the
solar corona. By quantifying physical parameters such as mass, velocity, and
orientation of the plasma ejection relative to the magnetic field, we provide a
description of the nature of this particular phenomenon. The time-dependent
three-dimensional magnetohydrodynamic (3D MHD) equations are solved in a box
extending from the chromosphere to the lower corona. The plasma is heated by
currents that are induced through field line braiding as a consequence of
photospheric motions. Spectra of optically thin emission lines in the extreme
ultraviolet range are synthesized, and magnetic field lines are traced over
time. Following strong heating just above the chromosphere, the pressure
rapidly increases, leading to a hydrodynamic explosion above the upper
chromosphere in the low transition region. The explosion drives the plasma,
which needs to follow the magnetic field lines. The ejection is then moving
more or less ballistically along the loop-like field lines and eventually drops
down onto the surface of the Sun. The speed of the ejection is in the range of
the sound speed, well below the Alfven velocity. The plasma ejection is
basically a hydrodynamic phenomenon, whereas the rise of the heating rate is of
magnetic nature. The granular motions in the photosphere lead (by chance) to a
strong braiding of the magnetic field lines at the location of the explosion
that in turn is causing strong currents which are dissipated. Future studies
need to determine if this process is a ubiquitous phenomenon on the Sun on
small scales. Data from the Atmospheric Imaging Assembly on the Solar Dynamics
Observatory (AIA/SDO) might provide the relevant information.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1105.5491 [pdf] - 1076914
Investigation of mass flows in the transition region and corona in a
three-dimensional numerical model approach
Submitted: 2011-05-27
The origin of solar transition region redshifts is not completely understood.
Current research is addressing this issue by investigating three-dimensional
magneto-hydrodynamic models that extend from the photosphere to the corona. By
studying the average properties of emission line profiles synthesized from the
simulation runs and comparing them to observations with present-day
instrumentation, we investigate the origin of mass flows in the solar
transition region and corona. Doppler shifts were determined from the emission
line profiles of various extreme-ultraviolet emission lines formed in the range
of $T=10^4-10^6$ K. Plasma velocities and mass flows were investigated for
their contribution to the observed Doppler shifts in the model. In particular,
the temporal evolution of plasma flows along the magnetic field lines was
analyzed. Comparing observed vs. modeled Doppler shifts shows a good
correlation in the temperature range $\log(T$/[K])=4.5-5.7, which is the basis
of our search for the origin of the line shifts. The vertical velocity obtained
when weighting the velocity by the density squared is shown to be almost
identical to the corresponding Doppler shift. Therefore, a direct comparison
between Doppler shifts and the model parameters is allowed. A simple
interpretation of Doppler shifts in terms of mass flux leads to overestimating
the mass flux. Upflows in the model appear in the form of cool pockets of gas
that heat up slowly as they rise. Their low temperature means that these
pockets are not observed as blueshifts in the transition region and coronal
lines. For a set of magnetic field lines, two different flow phases could be
identified. The coronal part of the field line is intermittently connected to
subjacent layers of either strong or weak heating, leading either to mass flows
into the loop or to the draining of the loop.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1103.6042 [pdf] - 1053063
Intermittent heating in the solar corona employing a 3D MHD model
Submitted: 2011-03-30, last modified: 2011-05-02
We investigate the spatial and temporal evolution of the heating of the
corona of a cool star such as our Sun in a three-dimensional
magneto-hydrodynamic (3D MHD) model. We solve the 3D MHD problem numerically in
a box representing part of the (solar) corona. The energy balance includes
Spitzer heat conduction along the magnetic field and optically thin radiative
losses. The self-consistent heating mechanism is based on the braiding of
magnetic field lines rooted in the convective photosphere. Magnetic stress
induced by photospheric motions leads to currents in the atmosphere which heat
the corona through Ohmic dissipation. While the horizontally averaged
quantities, such as heating rate, temperature or density, are relatively
constant in time, the simulated corona is highly variable and dynamic, on
average reaching temperatures and densities as found in observations. The
strongest heating per particle is found in the transition region from the
chromosphere to the corona. The heating is concentrated in current sheets
roughly aligned with the magnetic field and is transient in time and space.
This supports the idea that numerous small heating events heat the corona,
often referred to a nanoflares.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:0904.2312 [pdf] - 23350
Spectral analysis of 3D MHD models of coronal structures
Submitted: 2009-04-15
We study extreme-ultraviolet emission line spectra derived from
three-dimensional magnetohydrodynamic models of structures in the corona. In
order to investigate the effects of increased magnetic activity at photospheric
levels in a numerical experiment, a much higher magnetic flux density is
applied at photospheric levels as compared to the Sun. Thus, we can expect our
results to highlight the differences between the Sun and more active, but still
solar-like stars. We discuss signatures seen in extreme-ultraviolet emission
lines synthesized from these models and compare them to signatures found in the
spatial distribution and temporal evolution of Doppler shifts in lines formed
in the transition region and corona. This is of major interest to test the
quality of the underlying magnetohydrodynamic model to heat the corona, i.e.
currents in the corona driven by photospheric motions (flux braiding).