Normalized to: Bernhard, E.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2001.11573 [pdf] - 2101368
A binning-free method reveals a continuous relationship between
galaxies' AGN power and offset from main sequence
Submitted: 2020-01-30, last modified: 2020-05-04
Studies investigating the relationship between AGN power and the star
formation rates (SFRs) of their host galaxies often rely on averaging
techniques -- such as stacking -- to incorporate information from
non-detections. However, averages, and especially means, can be strongly
affected by outliers and can therefore give a misleading indication of the
"typical" case. Recently, a number of studies have taken a step further by
binning their sample in terms of AGN power (approximated by the 2-10keV
luminosity of the AGN), and investigating how the SFR distribution differs
between these bins. These bin thresholds are often weakly motivated, and
binning implicitly assumes that sources within the same bin have similar (or
even identical) properties. In this paper, we investigate whether the
distribution of host SFRs -- relative to the locus of the star-forming main
sequence (i.e., $R_{\rm MS}$) -- changes continuously as a function of AGN
power. We achieve this by using a hierarchical Bayesian model that completely
removes the need to bin in AGN power. In doing so, we find strong evidence that
the $R_{\rm MS}$ distribution changes with 2-10keV X-ray luminosity. The
results suggest that higher X_ray luminosity AGNs have a tighter physical
connection to the star-forming process than lower X-ray luminosity AGNs, at
least within the $0.8 < z < 1.2$ redshift range considered here.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:2002.08965 [pdf] - 2072708
The evolving AGN duty cycle in galaxies since z$\sim$3 as encoded in the
X-ray luminosity function
Delvecchio, I.;
Daddi, E.;
Aird, J.;
Mullaney, J. R.;
Bernhard, E.;
Grimmett, L. P.;
Carraro, R.;
Cimatti, A.;
Zamorani, G.;
Caplar, N.;
Vito, F.;
Elbaz, D.;
Rodighiero, G.
Submitted: 2020-02-20
We present a new modeling of the X-ray luminosity function (XLF) of Active
Galactic Nuclei (AGN) out to z$\sim$3, dissecting the contribution of
main-sequence (MS) and starburst (SB) galaxies. For each galaxy population, we
convolved the observed galaxy stellar mass (M$_{\star}$) function with a grid
of M$_{\star}$-independent Eddington ratio ($\lambda_{\rm EDD}$) distributions,
normalised via empirical black hole accretion rate (BHAR) to star formation
rate (SFR) relations. Our simple approach yields an excellent agreement with
the observed XLF since z$\sim$3. We find that the redshift evolution of the
observed XLF can only be reproduced through an intrinsic flattening of the
$\lambda_{\rm EDD}$ distribution, and with a positive shift of the break
$\lambda^{*}$, consistent with an anti-hierarchical behavior. The AGN accretion
history is predominantly made by massive (10$^{10}<$M$_{\star}<$10$^{11}$
M$_{\odot}$) MS galaxies, while SB-driven BH accretion, possibly associated
with galaxy mergers, becomes dominant only in bright quasars, at $\log$(L$_{\rm
X}$/erg s$^{-1}$)$>$44.36 + 1.28$\cdot$(1+z). We infer that the probability of
finding highly-accreting ($\lambda_{\rm EDD}>$ 10%) AGN significantly increases
with redshift, from 0.4% (3.0%) at z=0.5 to 6.5% (15.3%) at z=3 for MS (SB)
galaxies, implying a longer AGN duty cycle in the early Universe. Our results
strongly favor a M$_{\star}$-dependent ratio between BHAR and SFR, as BHAR/SFR
$\propto$ M$_{\star}^{0.73[+0.22,-0.29]}$, supporting a non-linear BH buildup
relative to the host. Finally, this framework opens potential questions on
super-Eddington BH accretion and different $\lambda_{\rm EDD}$ prescriptions
for understanding the cosmic BH mass assembly.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1910.08114 [pdf] - 2026048
The galaxy's gas content regulated by the dark matter halo mass results
in a super-linear M$_{\rm BH}$-M$_{\star}$ relation
Delvecchio, I.;
Daddi, E.;
Shankar, F.;
Mullaney, J. R.;
Zamorani, G.;
Aird, J.;
Bernhard, E.;
Cimatti, A.;
Elbaz, D.;
Giavalisco, M.;
Grimmett, L. P.
Submitted: 2019-10-17
Supermassive black holes (SMBHs) are tightly correlated with their hosts but
the origin of such connection remains elusive. To explore the cosmic build-up
of this scaling relation, we present an empirically-motivated model that tracks
galaxy and SMBH growth down to z=0. Starting from a random mass seed
distribution at z=10, we assume that each galaxy evolves on the star-forming
"main sequence" (MS) and each BH follows the recently-derived stellar mass
(M$_{\star}$) dependent ratio between BH accretion rate and star formation
rate, going as BHAR/SFR$\propto$M$_{\star}^{0.73[+0.22,-0.29]}$. Our simple
recipe naturally describes the BH-galaxy build-up in two stages. At first, the
SMBH lags behind the host that evolves along the MS. Later, as the galaxy grows
in M$_{\star}$, our M$_{\star}$-dependent BHAR/SFR induces a super-linear BH
growth, as M$_{\rm BH}$$\propto$M$_{\star}^{1.7}$. According to this formalism,
smaller BH seeds increase their relative mass faster and earlier than bigger BH
seeds, at fixed M$_{\star}$, thus setting along a gradually tighter M$_{\rm
BH}$-M$_{\star}$ locus towards higher M$_{\star}$. Assuming reasonable values
of the radiative efficiency $\epsilon \sim$0.1, our empirical trend agrees with
both high-redshift model predictions and intrinsic M$_{\rm BH}$-M$_{\star}$
relations of local BHs. We speculate that the observed non-linear BH-galaxy
build-up is reflected in a twofold behavior with dark matter halo mass (M$_{\rm
DM}$), displaying a clear turnover at M$_{\rm
DM}\sim$2$\times$10$^{12}$M$_{\odot}$. While Supernovae-driven feedback
suppresses BH growth in smaller halos (BHAR/SFR$\propto$M$_{\rm DM}^{1.6}$),
above the M$_{\rm DM}$ threshold cold gas inflows possibly fuel both BH
accretion and star formation in a similar fashion (BHAR/SFR$\propto$M$_{\rm
DM}^{0.3}$).
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1907.12136 [pdf] - 1938573
A contribution of star-forming clumps and accreting satellites to the
mass assembly of z ~ 2 galaxies
Zanella, A.;
Floc'h, E. Le;
Harrison, C. M.;
Daddi, E.;
Bernhard, E.;
Gobat, R.;
Strazzullo, V.;
Valentino, F.;
Cibinel, A.;
Almeida, J. Sánchez;
Kohandel, M.;
Fensch, J.;
Behrendt, M.;
Burkert, A.;
Onodera, M.;
Bournaud, F.;
Scholtz, J.
Submitted: 2019-07-28
We investigate the contribution of clumps and satellites to the galaxy mass
assembly. We analyzed spatially-resolved Hubble Space Telescope observations
(imaging and slitless spectroscopy) of 53 star-forming galaxies at z ~ 1 - 3.
We created continuum and emission line maps and pinpointed residual "blobs"
detected after subtracting the galaxy disk. Those were separated into compact
(unresolved) and extended (resolved) components. Extended components have sizes
~ 2 kpc and comparable stellar mass and age as the galaxy disks, whereas the
compact components are 1.5 dex less massive and 0.4 dex younger than the disks.
Furthermore the extended blobs are typically found at larger distances from the
galaxy barycenter than the compact ones. Prompted by these observations and by
the comparison with simulations, we suggest that compact blobs are in-situ
formed clumps, whereas the extended ones are accreting satellites. Clumps and
satellites enclose respectively ~ 20% and ~< 80% of the galaxy stellar mass, ~
30% and ~ 20% of its star formation rate. Considering the compact blobs, we
statistically estimated that massive clumps (Mstar >~ 10^9 Msun) have lifetimes
of ~ 650 Myr, and the less massive ones (10^8 < Mstar < 10^9 Msun) of ~ 145
Myr. This supports simulations predicting long-lived clumps (lifetime > 100
Myr). Finally, ~< 30% (13%) of our sample galaxies are undergoing single
(multiple) merger(s), they have a projected separation ~< 10 kpc, and the
typical mass ratio of our satellites is 1:5 (but ranges between 1:10 and 1:1),
in agreement with literature results for close pair galaxies.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1904.08406 [pdf] - 1912809
Revealing the differences in the SMBH accretion rate distributions of
starburst and non-starburst galaxies
Submitted: 2019-04-16
We infer and compare the specific X-ray luminosity distributions for a sample
of massive (i.e. $\log_{10} (M*/M\odot) > 10.5$) galaxies split according to
their far-infrared-derived star-forming properties (i.e., starburst and
non-starburst) and redshift. We model each distribution as a power-law with an
upper and lower turnover, and adopt a maximum likelihood method to include
information from non-detections in the form of upper limits. When we use our
inferred distributions to calculate the ratios of high to low sLx AGN
(corresponding to above and below $0.1\lambda_{\text{Edd}}$, respectively) we
find that starbursts have significantly higher proportions of high sLx AGN
compared to their non-starburst counterparts. These findings help explain the
increase in average X-ray luminosity in bins of increasing SFR reported by
previous studies.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1811.05980 [pdf] - 1791380
Inferring a difference in the star-forming properties of lower versus
higher X-ray luminosity AGNs
Submitted: 2018-11-14
We explore the distribution of RMS=SFR/SFR_MS (where SFR_MS is the star
formation rate of "Main Sequence" star-forming galaxies) for AGN hosts at z=1.
We split our sample into two bins of X-ray luminosity divided at Lx=2x10^43erg
s-1 to investigate whether the RMS distribution changes as a function of AGN
power. Our main results suggest that, when the RMS distribution of AGN hosts is
modelled as a log-normal distribution (i.e. the same shape as that of MS
galaxies), galaxies hosting more powerful X-ray AGNs (i.e. Lx>2x10^43erg s-1)
display a narrower RMS distribution that is shifted to higher values compared
to their lower Lx counterparts. In addition, we find that more powerful X-ray
AGNs have SFRs that are more consistent with that of MS galaxies compared to
lower Lx AGNs. Despite this, the mean SFRs (as opposed to RMS) measured from
these distributions are consistent with the previously observed flat
relationship between SFR and Lx. Our results suggest that the typical
star-forming properties of AGN hosts change with Lx , and that more powerful
AGNs typically reside in more MS-like star-forming galaxies compared to lower
Lx AGNs.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1801.07717 [pdf] - 1636833
Evidence for a mass-dependent AGN Eddington ratio distribution via the
flat relationship between SFR and AGN luminosity
Submitted: 2018-01-23, last modified: 2018-02-19
The lack of a strong correlation between AGN X-ray luminosity ($L_X$; a proxy
for AGN power) and the star formation rate (SFR) of their host galaxies has
recently been attributed to stochastic AGN variability. Studies using
population synthesis models have incorporated this by assuming a broad,
universal (i.e. does not depend on the host galaxy properties) probability
distribution for AGN specific X-ray luminosities (i.e. the ratio of $L_X$ to
host stellar mass; a common proxy for Eddington ratio). However, recent studies
have demonstrated that this universal Eddington ratio distribution fails to
reproduce the observed X-ray luminosity functions beyond z$\sim$1.2.
Furthermore, empirical studies have recently shown that the Eddington ratio
distribution may instead depend upon host galaxy properties, such as SFR and/or
stellar mass. To investigate this further we develop a population synthesis
model in which the Eddington ratio distribution is different for star-forming
and quiescent host galaxies. We show that, although this model is able to
reproduce the observed X-ray luminosity functions out to z$\sim$2, it fails to
simultaneously reproduce the observed flat relationship between SFR and X-ray
luminosity. We can solve this, however, by incorporating a mass dependency in
the AGN Eddington ratio distribution for star-forming host galaxies. Overall,
our models indicate that a relative suppression of low Eddington ratios
($\lambda_{\rm Edd}\lesssim$0.1) in lower mass galaxies (M<$10^{10-11}$Msun) is
required to reproduce both the observed X-ray luminosity functions and the
observed flat SFR/X-ray relationship.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1604.06455 [pdf] - 1400567
An enhanced fraction of starbursting galaxies among high Eddington ratio
AGNs
Submitted: 2016-04-21
We investigate the star-forming properties of 1620 X-ray selected AGN host
galaxies as a function of their specific X-ray luminosity (i.e., X-ray
luminosity per unit host stellar mass) -- a proxy of the Eddington ratio. Our
motivation is to determine whether there is any evidence of a suppression of
star-formation at high Eddington ratios, which may hint toward "AGN feedback"
effects. Star-formation rates (SFRs) are derived from fits to Herschel-measured
far-infrared spectral energy distributions, taking into account any
contamination from the AGN. Herschel-undetected AGNs are included via stacking
analyses to provide average SFRs in bins of redshift and specific X-ray
luminosity (spanning $0.01 \lesssim L_{\rm X}/M_{\ast} \lesssim 100~L_{\odot}
~M_{\odot}^{-1}$). After normalising for the effects of mass and redshift
arising from the evolving galaxy main sequence, we find that the SFRs of high
specific luminosity AGNs are slightly enhanced compared to their lower specific
luminosity counterparts. This suggests that the SFR distribution of AGN hosts
changes with specific X-ray luminosity, a result reinforced by our finding of a
significantly higher fraction of starbursting hosts among high specific
luminosity AGNs compared to that of the general star-forming galaxy population
(i.e., 8-10 per cent vs. 3 per cent). Contrary to our original motivation, our
findings suggest that high specific luminosity AGNs are more likely to reside
in galaxies with enhanced levels of star-formation.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1506.05459 [pdf] - 1273162
ALMA and Herschel reveal that X-ray selected AGN and main-sequence
galaxies have different star formation rate distributions
Mullaney, J. R.;
Alexander, D. M.;
Aird, J.;
Bernhard, E.;
Daddi, E.;
Del Moro, A.;
Dickinson, M.;
Elbaz, D.;
Harrison, C. M.;
Juneau, S.;
Liu, D.;
Pannella, M.;
Rosario, D.;
Santini, P.;
Sargent, M.;
Schreiber, C.;
Simpson, J.;
Stanley, F.
Submitted: 2015-06-17, last modified: 2015-07-29
Using deep Herschel and ALMA observations, we investigate the star formation
rate (SFR) distributions of X-ray selected AGN host galaxies at 0.5<z<1.5 and
1.5<z<4, comparing them to that of normal, star-forming (i.e., "main-sequence",
or MS) galaxies. We find 34--55 per cent of AGNs in our sample have SFRs at
least a factor of two below that of the average MS galaxy, compared to ~15 per
cent of all MS galaxies, suggesting significantly different SFR distributions.
Indeed, when both are modelled as log-normal distributions, the mass and
redshift-normalised SFR distributions of X-ray AGNs are roughly twice as broad,
and peak ~0.4 dex lower, than that of MS galaxies. However, like MS galaxies,
the normalised SFR distribution of AGNs in our sample appears not to evolve
with redshift. Despite X-ray AGNs and MS galaxies having different SFR
distributions, the linear-mean SFR of AGNs derived from our distributions is
remarkably consistent with that of MS galaxies, and thus with previous results
derived from stacked Herschel data. This apparent contradiction is due to the
linear-mean SFR being biased by bright outliers, and thus does not necessarily
represent a true characterisation of the typical SFR of X-ray AGNs.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1501.03672 [pdf] - 959557
Constraining the properties of AGN host galaxies with Spectral Energy
Distribution modeling
Ciesla, L.;
Charmandaris, V.;
Georgakakis, A.;
Bernhard, E.;
Mitchell, P. D.;
Buat, V.;
Elbaz, D.;
Floc'h, E. Le;
Lacey, C. G.;
Magdis, G. E.;
Xilouris, M.
Submitted: 2015-01-15, last modified: 2015-01-16
[abridged] We use the latest release of CIGALE, a galaxy SED fitting model
relying on energy balance, to study the influence of an AGN in estimating both
the SFR and stellar mass in galaxies, as well as the contribution of the AGN to
the power output of the host. Using the galaxy formation SAM GALFORM, we create
mock galaxy SEDs using realistic star formation histories (SFH) and add an AGN
of Type 1, Type 2, or intermediate type whose contribution to the bolometric
luminosity can be variable. We perform an SED fitting of these catalogues with
CIGALE assuming three different SFHs: a single- and
double-exponentially-decreasing, and a delayed SFH. Constraining
thecontribution of an AGN to the LIR (fracAGN) is very challenging for
fracAGN<20%, with uncertainties of ~5-30% for higher fractions depending on the
AGN type, while FIR and sub-mm are essential. The AGN power has an impact on
the estimation of $M_*$ in Type 1 and intermediate type AGNs but has no effect
for galaxies hosting Type 2 AGNs. We find that in the absence of AGN emission,
the best estimates of $M_*$ are obtained using the
double-exponentially-decreasing model but at the expense of realistic ages of
the stellar population. The delayed SFH model provides good estimates of $M_*$
and SFR, with a maximum offset of 10% as well as better estimates of the age.
Our analysis shows that the underestimation of the SFR increases with fracAGN
for Type 1 systems, as well as for low contributions of an intermediate AGN
type, but it is quite insensitive to the emission of Type 2 AGNs up to
fracAGN~45%. Similarly the UV emission is critical in accurately retrieving the
$M_*$ for Type 1 and intermediate type AGN, and the SFR of all of the three AGN
types. We show that the presence of AGN emission introduces a scatter to the
SFR-$M_*$ main sequence relation derived from SED fitting, which is driven by
the uncertainties on $M_*$.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1405.1425 [pdf] - 1209389
Modeling the connection between ultraviolet and infrared galaxy
populations across cosmic times
Submitted: 2014-05-06
Using a phenomenological approach, we self-consistently model the redshift
evolution of the ultraviolet (UV) and infrared (IR) luminosity functions across
cosmic time, as well as a range of observed IR properties of UV-selected galaxy
population. This model is an extension of the 2SFM (2 star-formation modes)
formalism, which is based on the observed "main-sequence" of star-forming
galaxies, i.e. a strong correlation between their stellar mass and their star
formation rate (SFR), and a secondary population of starbursts with an excess
of star formation. The balance between the UV light from young, massive stars
and the dust-reprocessed IR emission is modeled following the empirical
relation between the attenuation (IRX for IR excess hereafter) and the stellar
mass, assuming a scatter of 0.4\,dex around this relation. We obtain a good
overall agreement with the measurements of the IR luminosity function up to z~3
and the UV luminosity functions up to z~6, and show that a scatter on the IRX-M
relation is mandatory to reproduce these observables. We also naturally
reproduce the observed, flat relation between the mean IRX and the UV
luminosity at L$_{\rm UV}>$10$^{9.5}$ L$_\odot$. Finally, we perform
predictions of the UV properties and detectability of IR-selected samples and
the vice versa, and discuss the results in the context of the UV-rest-frame and
sub-millimeter surveys of the next decade.