Comment on Scafetta, Nicola. 'Discussion on Common Errors in Analyzing Sea Level Accelerations, Solar Trends and Global Warming.' arXiv:1305.2812 (May 13, 2013a). doi:10.5194/prp-1-37-2013.

An old conceptual physics-based back-of-the-envelope model for greenhouse effect is revisited and validated against state-of-the-art reanalyses. Untraditional diagnostics show a physically consistent picture, for which the state of earth's climate is constrained by well-known physical principles, such as energy balance, flow and, conservation. Greenhouse gas concentrations affect the atmospheric optical depth for infrared radiation, and increased opacity implies higher altitude from which earth's equivalent bulk heat loss takes place without being re-absorbed. Such increase is seen in the reanalyses. There has also been a reduction in the correlation between the spatial structure of outgoing long-wave radiation and surface temperature, consistent with increasingly more processes interfering with the upwelling infrared light before it reaches the top of the atmosphere. State-of-the-art reanalyses further imply increases in the overturning in the troposphere, consistent with a constant and continuous vertical energy flow. The associateion between these aspects can be interpreted as an entanglement between greenhouse effect and the hydrological cycle, where reduced energy transfer associated with increased opacity is compensated by tropospheric overturning activity.

The state of earth's climate is constrained by well-known physical principles such as energy balance and the conservation of energy. Increased greenhouse gas concentrations affect the atmospheric optical depth, and physical consistency implies that changes in the energy transfer in terms of infra-red light must be compensated by other means of energy flow. Here, a simple heuristic and comprehensive model is used to interpret new aspects of real-world data. It is shown that trends in tropospheric overturning activity and the estimated altitude where earth's bulk heat loss should place are two independent indicators of climate change. There has been increased vertical overturning in the middle and upper parts of the troposphere since 1995 on a global scale. Greater overturning compensates for reduced radiative energy transfer associated with increased optical depth. An increased optical depth is also expected to raise the altitude from where planetary bulk heat loss takes place according to the heuristic model, and an estimated trend of 40m/decade is consistent with a surface warming rate of 0.2K/decade. The simple comprehensive model of the greenhouse effect can also account for feedback processes, changes in the hydrological cycle, and may assist the wider scientific community in understanding of the main principles involved.