Normalized to: Baturin, V.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1905.08303 [pdf] - 1905850
Interpolation of equation-of-state data
Submitted: 2019-05-20, last modified: 2019-06-13
Aims. We use Hermite splines to interpolate pressure and its derivatives
simultaneously, thereby preserving mathematical relations between the
derivatives. The method therefore guarantees that thermodynamic identities are
obeyed even between mesh points. In addition, our method enables an estimation
of the precision of the interpolation by comparing the Hermite-spline results
with those of frequent cubic (B-) spline interpolation.
Methods. We have interpolated pressure as a function of temperature and
density with quintic Hermite 2D-splines. The Hermite interpolation requires
knowledge of pressure and its first and second derivatives at every mesh point.
To obtain the partial derivatives at the mesh points, we used tabulated values
if given or else thermodynamic equalities, or, if not available, values
obtained by differentiating B-splines.
Results. The results were obtained with the grid of the SAHA-S
equation-of-state (EOS) tables. The maximum $lg P$ difference lies in the range
from $10^{-9}$ to $10^{-4}$, and $\Gamma_1$ difference varies from $10^{-9}$ to
$10^{-3}$. Specifically, for the points of a solar model, the maximum
differences are one order of magnitude smaller than the aforementioned values.
The poorest precision is found in the dissociation and ionization regions,
occurring at $T \sim 1.5\cdot 10^3 - 10^5$ K. The best precision is achieved at
higher temperatures, $T>10^5$ K. To discuss the significance of the
interpolation errors we compare them with the corresponding difference between
two different equation-of-state formalisms, SAHA-S and OPAL 2005. We find that
the interpolation errors of the pressure are a few orders of magnitude less
than the differences from between the physical formalisms, which is
particularly true for the solar-model points.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1902.10390 [pdf] - 1839728
Combining multiple structural inversions to constrain the Solar
modelling problem
Submitted: 2019-02-27
The Sun is the most studied of stars and a laboratory of fundamental physics.
However, the understanding of our star is stained by the solar modelling
problem which can stem from various causes. We combine inversions of sound
speed, an entropy proxy and the Ledoux discriminant with the position of the
base of the convective zone and the photospheric helium abundance to test
combinations of ingredients such as equation of state, abundance and opacity
tables. We study the potential of the inversions to constrain ad-hoc opacity
modifications and additional mixing in the Sun. We show that they provide
constraints on these modifications to the ingredients and that the solar
problem likely occurs from various sources and using phase shifts with our
approach is the next step to take.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1809.08958 [pdf] - 1811122
Combining multiple structural inversions to constrain the Solar
modelling problem
Buldgen, G.;
Salmon, S. J. A. J.;
Noels, A.;
Scuflaire, R.;
Montalban, J.;
Baturin, V. A.;
Eggenberger, P.;
Gryaznov, V. K.;
Iosilevskiy, I. L.;
Meynet, G.;
Chaplin, W. J.;
Miglio, A.;
Oreshina, A. V.;
Richard, O.;
Starostin, A. N.
Submitted: 2018-09-24
The Sun is the most studied of all stars. It is a reference for all other
observed stars and a laboratory of fundamental physics helping us understand
processes occuring in conditions irreproducible on Earth. However, our
understanding of the Sun is currently stained by the solar modelling problem
which can stem from various causes, such as the opacities, the equation of
state and the mixing of chemical elements. We combine inversions of sound
speed, an entropy proxy and the Ledoux discriminant with constraints such as
the position of the base of the convective zone and the photospheric helium
abundance. We test various combinations of standard ingredients for solar
modelling such as abundance tables, equation of state, formalism for convection
and diffusion and opacity tables and study the diagnostic potential of the
inversions to constrain ad-hoc modifications of the opacity profile and
additional mixing below the convective envelope. Combining inversions provides
stringent constraints on the modifications on the models, far beyond what is
achievable only from sound speed inversions. We constrain the form and
amplitude of the opacity increase required and show that a 15% increase at log
T=6.35 provides a significant improvement but that a more global increase of
the opacity, within the uncertainties of current tables, coupled with an
additional mixing at the bottom of the convective zone gives the best agreement
for low metallicity models. We show that high metallicity models do not satisfy
all the inversion results. We conclude that the solar problem likely occurs
from various small sources, as ingredients such as the equation of state or the
formalism of convection can induce small but significant changes and that using
phase shift analyses combined with our approach is the next step for a better
understanding of the inaccuracies of solar models just below the convective
envelope.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1708.04937 [pdf] - 1587170
Equation of state SAHA-S meets stellar evolution code CESAM2k
Submitted: 2017-08-16
We present an example of an interpolation code of the SAHA-S equation of
state that has been adapted for use in the stellar evolution code CESAM2k. The
aim is to provide the necessary data and numerical procedures for its
implementation in a stellar code. A technical problem is the discrepancy
between the sets of thermodynamic quantities provided by the SAHA-S equation of
state and those necessary in the CESAM2k computations. Moreover, the
independent variables in a practical equation of state (like SAHA-S) are
temperature and density, whereas for modelling calculations the variables
temperature and pressure are preferable. Specifically for the CESAM2k code,
some additional quantities and their derivatives must be provided. To provide
the bridge between the equation of state and stellar modelling, we prepare
auxiliary tables of the quantities that are demanded in CESAM2k. Then we use
cubic spline interpolation to provide both smoothness and a good approximation
of the necessary derivatives. Using the B-form of spline representation
provides us with an efficient algorithm for three-dimensional interpolation.
The table of B-spline coefficients provided can be directly used during stellar
model calculations together with the module of cubic spline interpolation. This
implementation of the SAHA-S equation of state in the CESAM2k stellar structure
and evolution code has been tested on a solar model evolved to the present. A
comparison with other equations of state is briefly discussed. The choice of a
regular net of mesh points for specific primary quantities in the SAHA-S
equation of state, together with accurate and consistently smooth tabulated
values, provides an effective algorithm of interpolation in modelling
calculations. The proposed module of interpolation procedures can be easily
adopted in other evolution codes.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1612.01331 [pdf] - 1533005
Evolution of lithium abundance in the Sun and solar twins
Submitted: 2016-12-05
Evolution of the 7Li abundance in the convection zone of the Sun during
different stages of its life time is considered to explain its low photospheric
value in comparison with that of the solar system meteorites. Lithium is
intensively and transiently burned in the early stages of evolution (pre-main
sequence, pMS) when the radiative core arises, and then the Li abundance only
slowly decreases during the main sequence (MS). We study the rates of lithium
burning during these two stages. In a model of the Sun, computed ignoring pMS
and without extra-convective mixing (overshooting) at the base of the
convection zone, the lithium abundance does not decrease significantly during
the MS life time of 4.6 Gyr. Analysis of helioseismic inversions together with
post-model computations of chemical composition indicates the presence of the
overshooting region and restricts its thickness. It is estimated to be
approximately half of the local pressure scale height 0.5Hp) which corresponds
to 3.8 % of the solar radius. Introducing this extra region does not noticeably
deplete lithium during the MS stage. In contrast, at the pMS stage, an
overshooting region with a value of approximately 0.18Hp is enough to produce
the observed lithium depletion. If we conclude that the dominant lithium
burning takes place during the pMS stage, the dispersion of the lithium
abundance in solar twins is explained by different physical conditions,
primarily during the early stage of evolution before the MS.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1402.0204 [pdf] - 1203131
Helioseismic Measurements in the Solar Envelope Using Group Velocities
of Surface Waves
Submitted: 2014-02-02
At intermediate and high degree $l$, solar p- and f modes can be considered
as surface waves. Using variational principle, we derive an integral expression
for the group velocities of the surface waves in terms of adiabatic
eigenfunctions of normal modes, and address the benefits of using
group-velocity measurements as a supplementary diagnostic tool in solar
seismology. The principal advantage of using group velocities, when compared
with direct analysis of the oscillation frequencies, comes from their smaller
sensitivity to the uncertainties in the near-photospheric layers. We address
some numerical examples where group velocities are used to reveal
inconsistencies between the solar models and the seismic data. Further, we
implement the group-velocity measurements to the calibration of the specific
entropy, helium abundance Y and heavy-element abundance Z in the
adiabatically-stratified part of the solar convective envelope, using different
recent versions of the equation of state. The results are in close agreement
with our earlier measurements based on more sophisticated analysis of the solar
oscillation frequencies (Vorontsov et al. 2013, MNRAS 430, 1636). These results
bring further support to the downward revision of the solar heavy-element
abundances in recent spectroscopic measurements.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0604352 [pdf] - 81421
A synoptic comparison of the MHD and the OPAL equations of state
Submitted: 2006-04-17, last modified: 2006-04-28
A detailed comparison is carried out between two popular equations of state
(EOS), the Mihalas-Hummer-Dappen (MHD) and the OPAL equations of state, which
have found widespread use in solar and stellar modeling during the past two
decades. They are parts of two independent efforts to recalculate stellar
opacities; the international Opacity Project (OP) and the Livermore-based OPAL
project. We examine the difference between the two equations of state in a
broad sense, over the whole applicable rho-T range, and for three different
chemical mixtures. Such a global comparison highlights both their differences
and their similarities.
We find that omitting a questionable hard-sphere correction, tau, to the
Coulomb interaction in the MHD formulation, greatly improves the agreement
between the MHD and OPAL EOS. We also find signs of differences that could stem
from quantum effects not yet included in the MHD EOS, and differences in the
ionization zones that are probably caused by differences in the mechanisms for
pressure ionization. Our analysis do not only give a clearer perception of the
limitations of each equation of state for astrophysical applications, but also
serve as guidance for future work on the physical issues behind the
differences. The outcome should be an improvement of both equations of state.