Normalized to: Barker, A.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2005.04941 [pdf] - 2097472
Angular momentum transport, layering, and zonal jet formation by the GSF
instability: nonlinear simulations at a general latitude
Submitted: 2020-05-11
We continue our investigation into the nonlinear evolution of the
Goldreich-Schubert-Fricke (GSF) instability in differentially rotating
radiation zones. This instability may be a key player in transporting angular
momentum in stars and giant planets, but its nonlinear evolution remains mostly
unexplored. In a previous paper we considered the equatorial instability,
whereas here we simulate the instability at a general latitude for the first
time. We adopt a local Cartesian Boussinesq model in a modified shearing box
for most of our simulations, but we also perform some simulations with
stress-free, impenetrable, radial boundaries. We first revisit the linear
instability and derive some new results, before studying its nonlinear
evolution. The instability is found to behave very differently compared with
its behaviour at the equator. In particular, here we observe the development of
strong zonal jets ("layering" in the angular momentum), which can considerably
enhance angular momentum transport, particularly in axisymmetric simulations.
The jets are, in general, tilted with respect to the local gravity by an angle
that corresponds initially with that of the linear modes, but which evolves
with time and depends on the strength of the flow. The instability transports
angular momentum much more efficiently (by several orders of magnitude) than it
does at the equator, and we estimate that the GSF instability could contribute
to the missing angular momentum transport required in both red giant and
subgiant stars. It could also play a role in the long-term evolution of the
solar tachocline and the atmospheric dynamics of hot Jupiters.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:2003.02595 [pdf] - 2065467
Wave propagation in semi-convective regions of giant planets
Submitted: 2020-03-05
Recent observations of Jupiter and Saturn suggest that heavy elements may be
diluted in the gaseous envelope, providing a compositional gradient that could
stabilise ordinary convection and produce a stably-stratified layer near the
core of these planets. This region could consist of semi-convective layers with
a staircase-like density profile, which have multiple convective zones
separated by thin stably-stratified interfaces, as a result of double-diffusive
convection. These layers could have important effects on wave propagation and
tidal dissipation that have not been fully explored. We analyse the effects of
these layers on the propagation and transmission of internal waves within giant
planets, extending prior work in a local Cartesian model. We adopt a simplified
global Boussinesq planetary model in which we explore the internal waves in a
non-rotating spherical body. We begin by studying the free modes of a region
containing semi-convective layers. We then analyse the transmission of internal
waves through such a region. The free modes depend strongly on the staircase
properties, and consist of modes with both internal and interfacial gravity
wave-like behaviour. We determine the frequency shifts of these waves as a
function of the number of steps to explore their potential to probe planetary
internal structures. We also find that wave transmission is strongly affected
by the presence of a staircase. Very large-wavelength waves are transmitted
efficiently, but small-scale waves are only transmitted if they are resonant
with one of the free modes. The effective size of the core is therefore larger
for non-resonant modes.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:2002.02461 [pdf] - 2050423
Convection with Misaligned Gravity and Rotation: Simulations and
Rotating Mixing Length Theory
Submitted: 2020-02-06
We present numerical simulations, using two complementary setups, of rotating
Boussinesq thermal convection in a three-dimensional Cartesian geometry with
misaligned gravity and rotation vectors. This model represents a small region
at a non-polar latitude in the convection zone of a star or planet. We
investigate the effects of rotation on the bulk properties of convection at
different latitudes, focusing on determining the relation between the heat flux
and temperature gradient. We show that our results may be interpreted using
rotating mixing length theory (RMLT). The simplest version of RMLT (due to
Stevenson) considers the single mode that transports the most heat. This works
reasonably well in explaining our results, but there is a systematic departure
from these predictions (up to approximately $30\%$ in the temperature gradient)
at mid-latitudes. We develop a more detailed treatment of RMLT that includes
the transport afforded by multiple modes, and we show that this accounts for
most of the systematic differences. We also show that convectively-generated
zonal flows and meridional circulations are produced in our simulations, and
that their properties depend strongly on the dimensions of the box. These flows
also affect the heat transport, contributing to departures from RMLT at some
latitudes. However, we find the theoretical predictions of the multi-mode
theory for the mid-layer temperature gradient, the root-mean-square (RMS)
vertical velocity, the RMS temperature fluctuation, and the spatial spectrum of
the heat transport at different latitudes, are all in reasonably good agreement
with our numerical results when zonal flows are small.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1912.07910 [pdf] - 2039771
Turbulent viscosity acting on the equilibrium tidal flow in convective
stars
Submitted: 2019-12-17
Convection is thought to act as a turbulent viscosity in damping tidal flows
and in driving spin and orbital evolution in close convective binary systems.
This turbulent viscosity should be reduced, compared to mixing-length
predictions, when the forcing (tidal) frequency $|{\omega}_t|$ exceeds the
turnover frequency ${\omega}_{cv}$ of the dominant convective eddies. However,
two contradictory scaling laws have been proposed and this issue remains highly
disputed. To revisit this controversy, we conduct the first direct numerical
simulations (DNS) of convection interacting with the equilibrium tidal flow in
an idealized global model of a low-mass star. We present direct computations of
the turbulent effective viscosity, ${\nu}_E$, acting on the equilibrium tidal
flow. We unexpectedly report the coexistence of the two disputed scaling laws,
which reconciles previous theoretical (and numerical) findings. We recover the
universal quadratic scaling ${\nu}_E \propto (|{\omega}_t|/{\omega}_{cv})^{-2}$
in the high-frequency regime $|{\omega}_t|/{\omega}_{cv} \gg 1$. Our results
also support the linear scaling ${\nu}_E \propto
(|{\omega}_t|/{\omega}_{cv})^{-1}$ in an intermediate regime with $1 \leq
|{\omega}_t|/{\omega}_{cv} = \mathcal{O}(10)$. Both regimes may be relevant to
explain the observed properties of close binaries, including spin
synchronization of solar-type stars and the circularization of low-mass stars.
The robustness of these two regimes of tidal dissipation, and the transition
between them, should be explored further in more realistic models. A better
understanding of the interaction between convection and tidal flows is indeed
essential to correctly interpret observations of close binary stars and
short-period planetary orbits.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1910.06034 [pdf] - 2011269
Tidal flows with convection: frequency-dependence of the effective
viscosity and evidence for anti-dissipation
Submitted: 2019-10-14, last modified: 2019-12-09
Tidal interactions are important in driving spin and orbital evolution in
planetary and stellar binary systems, but the fluid dynamical mechanisms
responsible remain incompletely understood. One key mechanism is the
interaction between tidal flows and convection. Turbulent convection is thought
to act as an effective viscosity in damping large-scale tidal flows, but there
is a long-standing controversy over the efficiency of this mechanism when the
tidal frequency exceeds the turnover frequency of the dominant convective
eddies. This high frequency regime is relevant for many applications, such as
for tides in stars hosting hot Jupiters. We explore the interaction between
tidal flows and convection using hydrodynamical simulations within a local
Cartesian model of a small patch of a convection zone of a star or planet. We
adopt the Boussinesq approximation and simulate Rayleigh-B\'enard convection,
modelling the tidal flow as a background oscillatory shear flow. We demonstrate
that the effective viscosity of both laminar and turbulent convection is
approximately frequency-independent for low frequencies. When the forcing
frequency exceeds the dominant convective frequency, the effective viscosity
scales inversely with the square of the tidal frequency. We also show that
negative effective viscosities are possible, particularly for high frequency
tidal forcing, suggesting the surprising possibility of tidal anti-dissipation.
These results are supported by a complementary high frequency asymptotic
analysis that extends prior work by Ogilvie & Lesur. We discuss the
implications of these results for interpreting the orbital decay of hot
Jupiters, and for several other astrophysical problems.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1905.06962 [pdf] - 1890533
Angular momentum transport by the GSF instability: nonlinear simulations
at the equator
Submitted: 2019-05-16
We present an investigation into the nonlinear evolution of the
Goldreich-Schubert-Fricke (GSF) instability using axisymmetric and
three-dimensional simulations near the equator of a differentially rotating
radiation zone. This instability may provide an important contribution to
angular momentum transport in stars and planets. We adopt a local Boussinesq
Cartesian shearing box model, which represents a small patch of a
differentially rotating stellar radiation zone. Complementary simulations are
also performed with stress-free, impenetrable boundaries in the local radial
direction. The linear and nonlinear evolution of the equatorial axisymmetric
instability is formally equivalent to the salt fingering instability. This is
no longer the case in 3D, but we find that the instability behaves nonlinearly
in a similar way to salt fingering. Axisymmetric simulations -- and those in 3D
with short dimensions along the local azimuthal direction -- quickly develop
strong jets along the rotation axis, which inhibit the instability and lead to
predator-prey-like temporal dynamics. In 3D, the instability initially produces
homogeneous turbulence and enhanced momentum transport, though in some cases
jets form on a much longer timescale. We propose and validate numerically a
simple theory for nonlinear saturation of the GSF instability and its resulting
angular momentum transport. This theory is straightforward to implement in
stellar evolution codes incorporating rotation. We estimate that the GSF
instability could contribute towards explaining the missing angular momentum
transport required in red giant stars, and play a role in the long-term
evolution of the solar tachocline.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1902.04848 [pdf] - 1905681
Layered semi-convection and tides in giant planet interiors - II. Tidal
dissipation
Submitted: 2019-02-13
Recent Juno observations have suggested that the heavy elements in Jupiter
could be diluted throughout a large fraction of its gaseous envelope, providing
a stabilising compositional gradient over an extended region of the planet.
This could trigger layered semi-convection, which, in the context of giant
planets more generally, may explain Saturn's luminosity excess and play a role
in causing the abnormally large radii of some hot Jupiters. In giant planet
interiors, it could take the form of density staircases, which are convective
layers separated by thin stably stratified interfaces. In addition, the
efficiency of tidal dissipation is known to depend strongly on the planetary
internal structure. We aim to study the resulting tidal dissipation when
internal waves are excited in a region of layered semi-convection by tidal
gravitational forcing due to other bodies (such as moons in giant planet
systems, or stars in hot Jupiter systems). We adopt a local Cartesian model
with a background layered density profile subjected to an imposed tidal
forcing, and we compute the viscous and thermal dissipation rates numerically.
We find that the rates of tidal dissipation can be enhanced in a region of
layered semi-convection compared to a uniformly convective medium, where the
latter corresponds with the usual assumption adopted in giant planet interior
models. In particular, a region of layered semi-convection possesses a richer
set of resonances, allowing enhanced dissipation for a wider range of tidal
frequencies. The details of these results significantly depend on the
structural properties of the layered semi-convective regions. Layered
semi-convection could contribute towards explaining the high tidal dissipation
rates observed in Jupiter and Saturn, which have not yet been fully explained
by theory. Further work is required to explore the efficiency of this mechanism
in global models.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1810.02773 [pdf] - 1767743
On Kelvin-Helmholtz and parametric instabilities driven by coronal waves
Submitted: 2018-10-05
The Kelvin-Helmholtz instability has been proposed as a mechanism to extract
energy from magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) kink waves in flux tubes, and to drive
dissipation of this wave energy through turbulence. It is therefore a
potentially important process in heating the solar corona. However, it is
unclear how the instability is influenced by the oscillatory shear flow
associated with an MHD wave. We investigate the linear stability of a
discontinuous oscillatory shear flow in the presence of a horizontal magnetic
field within a Cartesian framework that captures the essential features of MHD
oscillations in flux tubes. We derive a Mathieu equation for the Lagrangian
displacement of the interface and analyse its properties, identifying two
different instabilities: a Kelvin-Helmholtz instability and a parametric
instability involving resonance between the oscillatory shear flow and two
surface Alfv\'{e}n waves. The latter occurs when the system is Kelvin-Helmholtz
stable, thus favouring modes that vary along the flux tube, and as a
consequence provides an important and additional mechanism to extract energy.
When applied to flows with the characteristic properties of kink waves in the
solar corona, both instabilities can grow, with the parametric instability
capable of generating smaller scale disturbances along the magnetic field than
possible via the Kelvin-Helmholtz instability. The characteristic time-scale
for these instabilities is $\sim 100$ s, for wavelengths of $200$ km. The
parametric instability is more likely to occur for smaller density contrasts
and larger velocity shears, making its development more likely on coronal loops
than on prominence threads.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1710.10058 [pdf] - 1590361
Layered semi-convection and tides in giant planet interiors
Submitted: 2017-10-27
Layered semi-convection could operate in giant planets, potentially
explaining the constraints on the heavy elements distribution in Jupiter
deduced recently from Juno observations, and contributing to Saturn's
luminosity excess or the abnormally large radius of some hot Jupiters. This is
a state consisting of density staircases, in which convective layers are
separated by thin stably stratified interfaces. The efficiency of tidal
dissipation in a planet depends strongly on its internal structure. It is
crucial to improve our understanding of the mechanisms driving this
dissipation, since it has important consequences to predict the long-term
evolution of any planetary system. In this work, our goal is to study the
resulting tidal dissipation when internal waves are excited by other bodies
(such as the moons of giant planets) in a region of layered semi-convection. We
find that the rates of tidal dissipation can be significantly enhanced in a
layered semi-convective medium compared to a uniformly convective medium,
especially in the astrophysically relevant sub-inertial frequency range. Thus,
layered semi-convection is a possible candidate to explain high tidal
dissipation rates recently observed in Jupiter and Saturn.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1704.08974 [pdf] - 1582956
Layered semi-convection and tides in giant planet interiors - I.
Propagation of internal waves
Submitted: 2017-04-28
Layered semi-convection is a possible candidate to explain Saturn's
luminosity excess and the abnormally large radius of some hot Jupiters. In
giant planet interiors, it could lead to the creation of density staircases,
which are convective layers separated by thin stably stratified interfaces. We
study the propagation of internal waves in a region of layered semi-convection,
with the aim to predict energy transport by internal waves incident upon a
density staircase. The goal is then to understand the resulting tidal
dissipation when these waves are excited by other bodies such as moons in giant
planets systems. We use a local Cartesian analytical model, taking into account
the complete Coriolis acceleration at any latitude, thus generalizing previous
works. We find transmission of incident internal waves to be strongly affected
by the presence of a density staircase, even if these waves are initially pure
inertial waves (which are restored by the Coriolis acceleration). In
particular, low-frequency waves of all wavelengths are perfectly transmitted
near the critical latitude. Otherwise, short-wavelength waves are only
efficiently transmitted if they are resonant with a free mode (interfacial
gravity wave or short-wavelength inertial mode) of the staircase. In all other
cases, waves are primarily reflected unless their wavelengths are longer than
the vertical extent of the entire staircase (not just a single step). We expect
incident internal waves to be strongly affected by the presence of a density
staircase in a frequency-, latitude- and wavelength-dependent manner. First,
this could lead to new criteria to probe the interior of giant planets by
seismology; and second, this may have important consequences for tidal
dissipation and our understanding of the evolution of giant planet systems.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1703.08003 [pdf] - 1552052
Nonlinear tidal flows in short-period planets
Submitted: 2017-03-23
I discuss two related nonlinear mechanisms of tidal dissipation that require
finite tidal deformations for their operation: the elliptical instability and
the precessional instability. Both are likely to be important for the tidal
evolution of short-period extrasolar planets. The elliptical instability is a
fluid instability of elliptical streamlines, such as in tidally deformed
non-synchronously rotating or non-circularly orbiting planets. I summarise the
results of local and global simulations that indicate this mechanism to be
important for tidal spin synchronisation, planetary spin-orbit alignment and
orbital circularisation for the shortest period hot Jupiters. The precessional
instability is a fluid instability that occurs in planets undergoing axial
precession, such as those with spin-orbit misalignments (non-zero obliquities).
I summarise the outcome of local MHD simulations designed to study the
turbulent damping of axial precession, which suggest this mechanism to be
important in driving tidal evolution of the spin-orbit angle for hot Jupiters.
Avenues for future work are also discussed.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1702.01123 [pdf] - 1535398
Searching For Rapid Orbital Decay of WASP-18b
Submitted: 2017-02-03
The WASP-18 system, with its massive and extremely close-in planet, WASP-18b
(M$_{p}$ = 10.3M$_{J}$, a = 0.02 AU, P = 22.6 hours), is one of the best known
exoplanet laboratories to directly measure Q', the modified tidal quality
factor and proxy for efficiency of tidal dissipation, of the host star.
Previous analysis predicted a rapid orbital decay of the planet toward its host
star that should be measurable on the time scale of a few years, if the star is
as dissipative as is inferred from the circularization of close-in solar-type
binary stars. We have compiled published transit and secondary eclipse timing
(as observed by WASP, TRAPPIST, and Spitzer) with more recent unpublished light
curves (as observed by TRAPPIST and HST) with coverage spanning nine years. We
find no signature of a rapid decay. We conclude that the absence of rapid
orbital decay most likely derives from Q' being larger than was inferred from
solar-type stars, and find that Q' $\geq $1$\times10^{6}$, at 95\,\%
confidence; this supports previous work suggesting that F-stars, with their
convective cores and thin convective envelopes, are significantly less tidally
dissipative than solar-type stars, with radiative cores and large convective
envelopes.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1605.03867 [pdf] - 1443960
On turbulence driven by axial precession and tidal evolution of the
spin-orbit angle of close-in giant planets
Submitted: 2016-05-12
The spin axis of a rotationally deformed planet is forced to precess about
its orbital angular momentum vector, due to the tidal gravity of its host star,
if these directions are misaligned. This induces internal fluid motions inside
the planet that are subject to a hydrodynamic instability. We study the
turbulent damping of precessional fluid motions, as a result of this
instability, in the simplest local computational model of a giant planet (or
star), with and without a weak internal magnetic field. Our aim is to determine
the outcome of this instability, and its importance in driving tidal evolution
of the spin-orbit angle in precessing planets (and stars). We find that this
instability produces turbulent dissipation that is sufficiently strong that it
could drive significant tidal evolution of the spin-orbit angle for hot
Jupiters with orbital periods shorter than about 10-18 days. If this mechanism
acts in isolation, this evolution would be towards alignment or anti-alignment,
depending on the initial angle, but the ultimate evolution (if other tidal
mechanisms also contribute) is expected to be towards alignment. The turbulent
dissipation is proportional to the cube of the precession frequency, so it
leads to much slower damping of stellar spin-orbit angles, implying that this
instability is unlikely to drive evolution of the spin-orbit angle in stars
(either in planetary or close binary systems). We also find that the
instability-driven flow can act as a system-scale dynamo, which may play a role
in producing magnetic fields in short-period planets.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1603.06840 [pdf] - 1392945
Nonlinear tides in a homogeneous rotating planet or star: global
simulations of the elliptical instability
Submitted: 2016-03-22
I present results from the first global hydrodynamical simulations of the
elliptical instability in a tidally deformed gaseous planet (or star) with a
free surface. The elliptical instability is potentially important for tidal
evolution of the shortest-period hot Jupiters. I model the planet as a
spin-orbit aligned or anti-aligned, and non-synchronously rotating, tidally
deformed, homogeneous fluid body. A companion paper presented an analysis of
the global modes and instabilities of such a planet. Here I focus on the
nonlinear evolution of the elliptical instability. This is observed to produce
bursts of turbulence that drive the planet towards synchronism with its orbit
in an erratic manner. If the planetary spin is initially anti-aligned, the
elliptical instability also drives spin-orbit alignment on a similar timescale
as the spin synchronisation. The instability generates differential rotation
inside the planet in the form of zonal flows, which play an important role in
the saturation of the instability, and in producing the observed burstiness.
These results are broadly consistent with the picture obtained using a local
Cartesian model (where columnar vortices played the role of zonal flows). I
also simulate the instability in a container that is rigid (but stress-free)
rather than free, finding broad quantitative agreement. The dissipation
resulting from the elliptical instability could explain why the shortest-period
hot Jupiters tend to have circular orbits inside about 2-3 days, and predicts
spin-synchronisation (and spin-orbit alignment) out to about 10-15 days.
However, other mechanisms must be invoked to explain tidal circularisation for
longer orbital periods.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1603.06839 [pdf] - 1392944
Nonlinear tides in a homogeneous rotating planet or star: global modes
and elliptical instability
Submitted: 2016-03-22
We revisit the global modes and instabilities of homogeneous rotating
ellipsoidal fluid masses, which are the simplest global models of rotationally
and tidally deformed gaseous planets or stars. The tidal flow in a short-period
planet may be unstable to the elliptical instability, a hydrodynamic
instability that can drive tidal evolution. We perform a global (and local WKB)
analysis to study this instability using the elegant formalism of Lebovitz &
Lifschitz. We survey the parameter space of global instabilities with harmonic
orders $\ell\leq 5$, for planets with spins that are purely aligned (prograde)
or anti-aligned (retrograde) with their orbits. In general, the instability has
a much larger growth rate if the planetary spin and orbit are anti-aligned
rather than aligned. We have identified a violent instability for anti-aligned
spins outside of the usual frequency range for the elliptical instability (when
$\frac{n}{\Omega}\lesssim -1$, where $n$ and $\Omega$ are the orbital and spin
angular frequencies, respectively) if the tidal amplitude is sufficiently
large. We also explore the instability in a rigid ellipsoidal container, which
is found to be quantitatively similar to that with a realistic free surface.
Finally, we study the effect of rotation and tidal deformation on mode
frequencies. We find that larger rotation rates and larger tidal deformations
both decrease the frequencies of the prograde sectoral surface gravity modes.
This increases the prospect of their tidal excitation, potentially enhancing
the tidal response over expectations from linear theory. In a companion paper,
we use our results to interpret global simulations of the elliptical
instability.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1603.02544 [pdf] - 1379054
Nonlinear hydrodynamical evolution of eccentric Keplerian discs in two
dimensions: validation of secular theory
Submitted: 2016-03-08
We perform global two-dimensional hydrodynamical simulations of Keplerian
discs with free eccentricity over thousands of orbital periods. Our aim is to
determine the validity of secular theory in describing the evolution of
eccentric discs, and to explore their nonlinear evolution for moderate
eccentricities. Linear secular theory is found to correctly predict the
structure and precession rates of discs with small eccentricities. However,
discs with larger eccentricities (and eccentricity gradients) are observed to
precess faster (retrograde relative to the orbital motion), at a rate that
depends on their eccentricities (and eccentricity gradients). We derive
analytically a nonlinear secular theory for eccentric gas discs, which explains
this result as a modification of the pressure forces whenever eccentric orbits
in a disc nearly intersect. This effect could be particularly important for
highly eccentric discs produced in tidal disruption events, or for narrow
gaseous rings; it might also play a role in causing some of the variability in
superhump binary systems. In two dimensions, the eccentricity of a moderately
eccentric disc is long-lived and persists throughout the duration of our
simulations. Eccentric modes are however weakly damped by their interaction
with non-axisymmetric spiral density waves (driven by the Papaloizou-Pringle
instability, which occurs in our idealised setup with solid walls), as well as
numerical diffusion.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1503.06953 [pdf] - 1232099
On the vertical-shear instability in astrophysical discs
Submitted: 2015-03-24
We explore the linear stability of astrophysical discs exhibiting vertical
shear, which arises when there is a radial variation in the temperature or
entropy. Such discs are subject to a "vertical-shear instability", which recent
nonlinear simulations have shown to drive hydrodynamic activity in the
MRI-stable regions of protoplanetary discs. We first revisit locally isothermal
discs using the quasi-global reduced model derived by Nelson et al. (2013).
This analysis is then extended to global axisymmetric perturbations in a
cylindrical domain. We also derive and study a reduced model describing discs
with power law radial entropy profiles ("locally polytropic discs"), which are
somewhat more realistic in that they possess physical (as opposed to numerical)
surfaces. In all cases the fastest growing modes have very short wavelengths
and are localised at the disc surfaces (if present), where the vertical shear
is maximal. An additional class of modestly growing vertically global body
modes is excited, corresponding to destabilised classical inertial waves
("r-modes"). We discuss the properties of both types of modes, and stress that
those that grow fastest occur on the shortest available length scales
(determined either by the numerical grid or the physical viscous length). This
ill-posedness makes simulations of the instability difficult to interpret. We
end with some brief speculation on the nonlinear saturation and resulting
angular momentum transport.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1409.6488 [pdf] - 1222188
Hydrodynamic instability in eccentric astrophysical discs
Submitted: 2014-09-23
Eccentric Keplerian discs are believed to be unstable to three-dimensional
hydrodynamical instabilities driven by the time-dependence of fluid properties
around an orbit. These instabilities could lead to small-scale turbulence, and
ultimately modify the global disc properties. We use a local model of an
eccentric disc, derived in a companion paper, to compute the nonlinear vertical
("breathing mode") oscillations of the disc. We then analyse their linear
stability to locally axisymmetric disturbances for any disc eccentricity and
eccentricity gradient using a numerical Floquet method. In the limit of small
departures from a circular reference orbit, the instability of an isothermal
disc is explained analytically. We also study analytically the small-scale
instability of an eccentric neutrally stratified polytropic disc with any
polytropic index using a WKB approximation. We find that eccentric discs are
generically unstable to the parametric excitation of small-scale inertial
waves. The nonlinear evolution of these instabilities should be studied in
numerical simulations, where we expect them to lead to a decay of the disc
eccentricity and eccentricity gradient as well as to induce additional
transport and mixing. Our results highlight that it is essential to consider
the three-dimensional structure of eccentric discs, and their resulting
vertical oscillatory flows, in order to correctly capture their evolution.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1409.6487 [pdf] - 1222187
Local and global dynamics of eccentric astrophysical discs
Submitted: 2014-09-23
We formulate a local dynamical model of an eccentric disc in which the
dominant motion consists of elliptical Keplerian orbits. The model is a
generalization of the well known shearing sheet, and is suitable for both
analytical and computational studies of the local dynamics of eccentric discs.
It is spatially homogeneous in the horizontal dimensions but has a
time-dependent geometry that oscillates at the orbital frequency. We show how
certain averages of the stress tensor in the local model determine the
large-scale evolution of the shape and mass distribution of the disc. The
simplest solutions of the local model are laminar flows consisting of a
(generally nonlinear) vertical oscillation of the disc. Eccentric discs lack
vertical hydrostatic equilibrium because of the variation of the vertical
gravitational acceleration around the eccentric orbit, and in some cases
because of the divergence of the orbital velocity field associated with an
eccentricity gradient. We discuss the properties of the laminar solutions,
showing that they can exhibit extreme compressional behaviour for
eccentricities greater than about $0.5$, especially in discs that behave
isothermally. We also derive the linear evolutionary equations for an eccentric
disc that follow from the laminar flows in the absence of a shear viscosity. In
a companion paper we show that these solutions are linearly unstable and we
determine the associated growth rates and unstable modes.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1403.7207 [pdf] - 1208661
Theory and simulations of rotating convection
Submitted: 2014-03-27, last modified: 2014-06-26
We study thermal convection in a rotating fluid in order to better understand
the properties of convection zones in rotating stars and planets. We first
derive mixing-length theory for rapidly-rotating convection, arriving at the
results of Stevenson (1979) via simple physical arguments. The theory predicts
the properties of convection as a function of the imposed heat flux and
rotation rate, independent of microscopic diffusivities. In particular, it
predicts the mean temperature gradient; the rms velocity and temperature
fluctuations; and the size of the eddies that dominate heat transport. We test
all of these predictions with high resolution three-dimensional hydrodynamical
simulations of Boussinesq convection in a Cartesian box. The results agree
remarkably well with the theory across more than two orders of magnitude in
rotation rate. For example, the temperature gradient is predicted to scale as
the rotation rate to the 4/5th power at fixed flux, and the simulations yield
$0.75\pm 0.06$. We conclude that the mixing length theory is a solid foundation
for understanding the properties of convection zones in rotating stars and
planets.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:1401.0643 [pdf] - 791844
Nonlinear evolution of tidally forced inertial waves in rotating fluid
bodies
Submitted: 2014-01-03
We perform one of the first studies into the nonlinear evolution of tidally
excited inertial waves in a uniformly rotating fluid body, exploring a
simplified model of the fluid envelope of a planet (or the convective envelope
of a solar-type star) subject to the gravitational tidal perturbations of an
orbiting companion. Our model contains a perfectly rigid spherical core, which
is surrounded by an envelope of incompressible uniform density fluid. The
corresponding linear problem was studied in previous papers which this work
extends into the nonlinear regime, at moderate Ekman numbers (the ratio of
viscous to Coriolis accelerations). By performing high-resolution numerical
simulations, using a combination of pseudo-spectral and spectral element
methods, we investigate the effects of nonlinearities, which lead to
time-dependence of the flow and the corresponding dissipation rate. Angular
momentum is deposited non-uniformly, leading to the generation of significant
differential rotation in the initially uniformly rotating fluid, i.e. the body
does not evolve towards synchronism as a simple solid body rotator. This
differential rotation modifies the properties of tidally excited inertial
waves, changes the dissipative properties of the flow, and eventually becomes
unstable to a secondary shear instability provided that the Ekman number is
sufficiently small. Our main result is that the inclusion of nonlinearities
eventually modifies the flow and the resulting dissipation from what linear
calculations would predict, which has important implications for tidal
dissipation in fluid bodies. We finally discuss some limitations of our
simplified model, and propose avenues for future research to better understand
the tidal evolution of rotating planets and stars.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:1309.0108 [pdf] - 1178921
Nonlinear evolution of the elliptical instability in the presence of
weak magnetic fields
Submitted: 2013-08-31
We investigate whether the elliptical instability is important for tidal
dissipation in gaseous planets and stars. In a companion paper, we found that
the conventional elliptical instability results in insufficient dissipation
because it produces long-lived vortices that then quench further instability.
Here, we study whether the addition of a magnetic field prevents those vortices
from forming, and hence leads to enhanced dissipation. We present results from
magnetohydrodynamical simulations that evolve the elliptical instability in a
local patch of a rotating planet or star, in the presence of a weak magnetic
field. We find that magnetic fields do indeed prevent vortices from forming,
and hence greatly enhance the steady state dissipation rate. In addition, the
resulting turbulence acts as a small-scale dynamo, amplifying the initially
weak field. The inferred tidal dissipation is potentially important at short
orbital periods. For example, it can circularise hot Jupiters with orbital
periods shorter than 2.5 days, and synchronise their spins with their orbits
out to 6 days. However, it appears unable to account for the hot Jupiters that
appear to have been circularised out to six to ten day orbital periods. It also
cannot account for the inferred circularisation of many close binary stars.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:1309.0107 [pdf] - 1178920
Nonlinear evolution of the tidal elliptical instability in gaseous
planets and stars
Submitted: 2013-08-31
Tidally distorted rotating stars and gaseous planets are subject to a
well-known linear fluid instability -- the elliptical instability. It has been
proposed that this instability might drive enough energy dissipation to solve
the long-standing problem of the origin of tidal dissipation in stars and
planets. But the nonlinear outcome of the elliptical instability has yet to be
investigated in the parameter regime of interest, and the resulting turbulent
energy dissipation has not yet been quantified. We do so by performing three
dimensional hydrodynamical simulations of a small patch of a tidally deformed
fluid planet or star subject to the elliptical instability. We show that when
the tidal deformation is weak, the nonlinear outcome of the instability leads
to the formation of long-lived columnar vortices aligned with the axis of
rotation. These vortices shut off the elliptical instability, and the net
result is insufficient energy dissipation to account for tidal dissipation.
However, further work is required to account for effects neglected here,
including magnetic fields, turbulent convection, and realistic boundary
conditions.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:1204.5432 [pdf] - 1118240
Magnetic buoyancy instabilities in the presence of magnetic flux pumping
at the base of the solar convection zone
Submitted: 2012-04-24
We perform idealised numerical simulations of magnetic buoyancy instabilities
in a model of the solar tachocline. We introduce a simplified model of magnetic
flux pumping in an upper layer (the convection zone), and study the effects of
its inclusion on the evolution of buoyancy instabilities in a lower layer (the
radiative interior). We study its effects on the instability of both a
preconceived magnetic slab and of a shear-generated magnetic layer. In the
former, we find that in the regime in which the downward pumping velocity is
comparable with the Alfven speed of the magnetic layer, flux pumping is able to
hold back the bulk of the magnetic field, with only small pockets of strong
field able to rise into the upper layer. In simulations in which the magnetic
layer is generated by shear, we find that the shear velocity is not necessarily
required to exceed that of the pumping (therefore the kinetic energy of the
shear is not required to exceed that of the overlying convection), for strong
localised pockets of magnetic field to be produced which can rise into the
upper layer. This is because magnetic flux pumping acts to store the field
below the interface, allowing it to be amplified both by the shear, and by
vortical fluid motions, until pockets of field can achieve sufficient strength
to rise into the upper layer. In addition, we find that the interface between
the two layers is a natural location for the production of strong vertical
gradients in the magnetic field. If these gradients are sufficiently strong to
allow the development of magnetic buoyancy instabilities, strong shear is not
necessarily required to drive them (c.f. previous work by Vasil & Brummell). We
find that the addition of magnetic flux pumping appears to be able to assist
shear-driven magnetic buoyancy in producing strong flux concentrations that can
rise into the convection zone from the radiative interior.
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:1106.5001 [pdf] - 1077531
Stability analysis of a tidally excited internal gravity wave near the
centre of a solar-type star
Submitted: 2011-06-24
We perform a stability analysis of a tidally excited nonlinear internal
gravity wave near the centre of a solar-type star in two-dimensions. The
motivation is to understand the tidal interaction between short-period planets
and their solar-type host stars, which involves the launching of gravity waves
at the top of the radiation zone that propagate towards the stellar centre.
Studying the instabilities of these waves near the centre, where nonlinearities
are most important, is essential, since it may have implications for the
survival of these planets. When the waves have sufficient amplitude to overturn
the stratification, they break and form a critical layer, which efficiently
absorbs subsequent ingoing wave angular momentum, and can result in the planet
spiralling into the star. However, previous simulations do not find the waves
to undergo instability for smaller amplitudes. This work has two aims: to
determine any instabilities that set in for small-amplitude waves, and to
further understand the breaking of large-amplitude waves. Our main result is
that the waves undergo parametric instabilities for any amplitude. However,
because the nonlinearity is spatially localised in the innermost wavelengths,
their growth rates are sufficiently small that they do not result in
astrophysically important tidal dissipation. The resulting modified tidal
quality factors are estimated to be Q'_star>10^7, and possibly much greater, so
the dissipation is much weaker than that which results from critical-layer
absorption. These results support our explanation for the survival of all
currently observed short-period planets around solar-type main-sequence stars:
that planets unable to cause wave breaking at the centre of their host stars
are likely to survive against tidal decay. This hypothesis will be tested by
ongoing and future observations of transiting planets, such as WASP and Kepler.
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:1102.0861 [pdf] - 1051890
Internal wave breaking and the fate of planets around solar-type stars
Submitted: 2011-02-04
Internal gravity waves are excited at the interface of convection and
radiation zones of a solar-type star by the tidal forcing of a short-period
planet. The fate of these waves as they approach the centre of the star depends
on their amplitude. We discuss the results of numerical simulations of these
waves approaching the centre of a star, and the resulting evolution of the spin
of the central regions of the star, and the orbit of the planet. If the waves
break, we find efficient tidal dissipation, which is not present if the waves
perfectly reflect from the centre. This highlights an important amplitude
dependence of the (stellar) tidal quality factor Q', which has implications for
the survival of planets on short-period orbits around solar-type stars, with
radiative cores.
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:1102.0857 [pdf] - 1051889
Three-dimensional simulations of internal wave breaking and the fate of
planets around solar-type stars
Submitted: 2011-02-04
We study the fate of internal gravity waves approaching the centre of a
non-rotating solar-type star, by performing 3D numerical simulations using a
Boussinesq-type model. These waves are excited at the top of the radiation zone
by the tidal forcing of a short-period planet on a circular, coplanar orbit.
This extends previous work done in 2D by Barker & Ogilvie. We first derive a
linear wave solution, which is not exact in 3D; however, the reflection of
ingoing waves from the centre is close to perfect for moderate amplitude waves.
Waves with sufficient amplitude to cause isentropic overturning break, and
deposit their angular momentum near the centre. This forms a critical layer, at
which the angular velocity of the flow matches the orbital angular frequency of
the planet. This efficiently absorbs ingoing waves, and spins up the star from
the inside out, while the planet spirals into the star. We also perform
numerical integrations to determine the linearised adiabatic tidal response
throughout the star, for solar-type stellar models with masses in the range 0.5
< m_star/M_sun < 1.1, throughout their main sequence lifetimes. The aim is to
study the launching region for these waves at the top of the radiation zone in
more detail, and to determine the accuracy of a semi-analytic approximation for
the tidal torque on the star, that was derived under the assumption that all
ingoing wave angular momentum is absorbed in a critical layer. The main
conclusions are that this nonlinear mechanism of tidal dissipation could
provide an explanation for the survival of all short-period extrasolar planets
observed around FGK stars, while it predicts the destruction of more massive
planets. This work provides further support for the model outlined in a
previous paper by Barker & Ogilvie, and makes predictions that will be tested
by ongoing observational studies, such as WASP and Kepler.
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:1001.4009 [pdf] - 1024764
On internal wave breaking and tidal dissipation near the centre of a
solar-type star
Submitted: 2010-01-22
We study the fate of internal gravity waves, which are excited by tidal
forcing by a short-period planet at the interface of convection and radiation
zones, approaching the centre of a solar-type star. We study at what amplitude
these wave are subject to instabilities. These instabilities lead to wave
breaking whenever the amplitude exceeds a critical value. Below this value, the
wave reflects perfectly from the centre of the star. Wave breaking results in
spinning up the central regions of the star, and the formation of a critical
layer, which acts as an absorbing barrier for ingoing waves. As these waves are
absorbed, the star is spun up from the inside out. This results in an important
amplitude dependence of the tidal quality factor Q'. If the tidal forcing
amplitude exceeds the value required for wave breaking, efficient dissipation
results over a continuous range of tidal frequencies, leading to Q' \approx
10^5 (P/1day)^(8/3), for the current Sun. This varies by less than a factor of
5 throughout the range of G and K type main sequence stars, for a given orbit.
We predict fewer giant planets with orbital periods of less than about 2 days
around such stars, if they cause breaking at the centre, due to the efficiency
of this process. This mechanism would, however, be ineffective in stars with a
convective core, such as WASP-18, WASP-12 and OGLE-TR-56, perhaps partly
explaining the survival of their close planetary companions.
[29]
oai:arXiv.org:0902.4563 [pdf] - 21808
On the tidal evolution of Hot Jupiters on inclined orbits
Submitted: 2009-02-26
Tidal friction is thought to be important in determining the long-term
spin-orbit evolution of short-period extrasolar planetary systems. Using a
simple model of the orbit-averaged effects of tidal friction, we study the
evolution of close-in planets on inclined orbits, due to tides. We analyse the
effects of the inclusion of stellar magnetic braking by performing a
phase-plane analysis of a simplified system of equations, including the braking
torque. The inclusion of magnetic braking is found to be important, and its
neglect can result in a very different system history. We then present the
results of numerical integrations of the tidal evolution equations, where we
find that it is essential to consider coupled evolution of the orbital and
rotational elements, including dissipation in both the star and planet, to
accurately model the evolution. The main result of our integrations is that for
typical Hot Jupiters, tidal friction aligns the stellar spin with the orbit on
a similar time as it causes the orbit to decay. This means that if a planet is
observed to be aligned, then it probably formed coplanar. This reinforces the
importance of Rossiter-McLaughlin effect observations in determining the degree
of spin-orbit alignment in transiting systems. We apply these results to the
XO-3 system, and constrain the tidal quality factors Q' in both the star and
planet in this system. Using a model in which inertial waves are excited by
tidal forcing in the outer convective envelope and dissipated by turbulent
viscosity, we calculate Q' for a range of F-star models, and find it to vary
considerably within this class of stars. This means that assuming a single Q'
applies to all stars is probably incorrect. We propose an explanation for the
survival of WASP-12 b & OGLE-TR-56 b, in terms of weak dissipation in the star.
[30]
oai:arXiv.org:0902.4554 [pdf] - 21807
Effects of Magnetic Braking and Tidal Friction on Hot Jupiters
Submitted: 2009-02-26
Tidal friction is thought to be important in determining the long-term
spin-orbit evolution of short-period extrasolar planetary systems. Using a
simple model of the orbit-averaged effects of tidal friction Eggleton, Kiseleva
& Hut (1998), we analyse the effects of the inclusion of stellar magnetic
braking on the evolution of such systems. A phase-plane analysis of a
simplified system of equations, including only the stellar tide together with a
model of the braking torque proposed by Verbunt & Zwaan (1981), is presented.
The inclusion of stellar magnetic braking is found to be extremely important in
determining the secular evolution of such systems, and its neglect results in a
very different orbital history. We then show the results of numerical
integrations of the full tidal evolution equations, using the misaligned spin
and orbit of the XO-3 system as an example, to study the accuracy of simple
timescale estimates of tidal evolution. We find that it is essential to
consider coupled evolution of the orbit and the stellar spin in order to model
the behaviour accurately. In addition, we find that for typical Hot Jupiters
the stellar spin-orbit alignment timescale is of the same order as the inspiral
time, which tells us that if a planet is observed to be aligned, then it
probably formed coplanar. This reinforces the importance of Rossiter-McLaughlin
effect observations in determining the degree of spin-orbit alignment in
transiting systems.
[31]
oai:arXiv.org:0803.4422 [pdf] - 11342
The effect of ambipolar resistivity on the formation of dense cores
Submitted: 2008-03-31
We aim to understand the formation of dense cores by magnetosonic waves in
regions where the thermal to magnetic pressure ratio is small. Because of the
low-ionisation fraction in molecular clouds, neutral and charged particles are
weakly coupled. Ambipolar diffusion then plays an important role in the
formation process. A quiescent, uniform plasma is perturbed by a fast-mode
wave. Using 2D numerical simulations, we follow the evolution of the fast-mode
wave. The simulations are done with a multifluid, adaptive mesh refinement MHD
code. Initial perturbations with wavelengths that are 2 orders of magnitude
larger than the dissipation length are strongly affected by the ion-neutral
drift. Only in situations where there are large variations in the magnetic
field corresponding to a highly turbulent gas can fast-mode waves generate
dense cores. This means that, in most cores, no substructure can be produced.
However, Core D of TMC-1 is an exception to this case. Due to its atypically
high ionisation fraction, waves with wavelengths up to 3 orders of magnitude
greater than the dissipation length can be present. Such waves are only weakly
affected by ambipolar diffusion and can produce dense substructure without
large wave-amplitudes. Our results also explain the observed transition from
Alfvenic turbulent motion at large scales to subsonic motions at the level of
dense cores.