Normalized to: Bains, I.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:1509.03308 [pdf] - 1275538
Infall, outflow, and turbulence in massive star-forming cores in the
G333 giant molecular cloud
Submitted: 2015-09-10
We present molecular line imaging observations of three massive molecular
outflow sources, G333.6-0.2, G333.1-0.4, and G332.8-0.5, all of which also show
evidence for infall, within the G333 giant molecular cloud (GMC). All three are
within a beam size (36 arcseconds) of IRAS sources, 1.2-mm dust clumps, various
masing species and radio continuum-detected HII regions and hence are
associated with high-mass star formation. We present the molecular line data
and derive the physical properties of the outflows including the mass,
kinematics, and energetics and discuss the inferred characteristics of their
driving sources. Outflow masses are of 10 to 40 solar masses in each lobe, with
core masses of order 10^3 solar masses. outflow size scales are a few tenth of
a parsec, timescales are of several x10^4 years, mass loss rates a few x10^-4
solar masses/year. We also find the cores are turbulent and highly supersonic.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1310.1131 [pdf] - 1179711
MALT90: The Millimetre Astronomy Legacy Team 90 GHz Survey
Jackson, J. M.;
Rathborne, J. M.;
Foster, J. B.;
Whitaker, J. S.;
Sanhueza, P.;
Claysmith, C.;
Mascoop, J. L.;
Wienen, M.;
Breen, S. L.;
Herpin, F.;
Duarte-Cabral, A.;
Csengeri, T.;
Longmore, S.;
Contreras, Y.;
Indermuehle, B.;
Barnes, P. J.;
Walsh, A. J.;
Cunningham, M. R.;
Brooks, K. J.;
Britton, T. R.;
Voronkov, M. A.;
Urquhart, J. S.;
Alves, J.;
Jordan, C. H.;
Hill, T.;
Hoq, S.;
Finn, S.;
C., S.;
Bains, I.;
Bontemps, S.;
Bronfman, L.;
Caswell, J. L.;
Deharveng, L.;
Ellingsen, S. P.;
Fuller, G. A.;
Garay, G.;
Green, J. A.;
Hindson, L.;
Jones, P. A.;
Lenfestey, C.;
Lo, N.;
Lowe, V.;
Mardones, D.;
Menten, K. M.;
Minier, V.;
Morgan, L. K.;
Motte, F.;
Muller, E.;
Peretto, N.;
Purcell, C. R.;
Schilke, P.;
Schneider-Bontemps, N.;
Schuller, F.;
Titmarsh, A.;
Wyrowski, F.;
Zavagno, A.
Submitted: 2013-10-03
The Millimetre Astronomy Legacy Team 90 GHz (MALT90) survey aims to
characterise the physical and chemical evolution of high-mass star-forming
clumps. Exploiting the unique broad frequency range and on-the-fly mapping
capabilities of the Australia Telescope National Facility Mopra 22 m
single-dish telescope, MALT90 has obtained 3' x 3' maps toward ~2000 dense
molecular clumps identified in the ATLASGAL 870 um Galactic plane survey. The
clumps were selected to host the early stages of high-mass star formation and
to span the complete range in their evolutionary states (from prestellar, to
protostellar, and on to HII regions and photodissociation regions). Because
MALT90 mapped 16 lines simultaneously with excellent spatial (38") and spectral
(0.11 km/s) resolution, the data reveal a wealth of information about the
clump's morphologies, chemistry, and kinematics. In this paper we outline the
survey strategy, observing mode, data reduction procedure, and highlight some
early science results. All MALT90 raw and processed data products are available
to the community. With its unprecedented large sample of clumps, MALT90 is the
largest survey of its type ever conducted and an excellent resource for
identifying interesting candidates for high resolution studies with ALMA.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1108.5776 [pdf] - 1083684
A Spitzer Space Telescope survey of massive young stellar objects in the
G333.2-0.4 giant molecular cloud
Submitted: 2011-08-29, last modified: 2011-10-05
The G333 giant molecular cloud contains a few star clusters and H II regions,
plus a number of condensations currently forming stars. We have mapped 13 of
these sources with the appearance of young stellar objects (YSOs) with the
Spitzer Infrared Spectrograph in the SL, SH, and LH modules (5-36 micron). We
use these spectra plus available photometry and images to characterize the
YSOs. The spectral energy distributions (SEDs) of all sources peak between 35
and 110 micron, thereby showing their young age. The objects are divided into
two groups: YSOs associated with extended emission in IRAC band 2 at 4.5 micron
(`outflow sources') and YSOs that have extended emission in all IRAC bands
peaking at the longest wavelengths (`red sources'). The two groups of objects
have distinctly different spectra: All the YSOs associated with outflows show
evidence of massive envelopes surrounding the protostar because the spectra
show deep silicate absorption features and absorption by ices at 6.0, 6.8, and
15.2 micron. We identify these YSOs with massive envelopes cool enough to
contain ice-coated grains as the `bloated' protostars in the models of Hosokawa
et al. All spectral maps show ionized forbidden lines and PAH emission
features. For four of the red sources, these lines are concentrated to the
centres of the maps, from which we infer that these YSOs are the source of
ionizing photons. Both types of objects show evidence of shocks, with most of
the outflow sources showing a line of [S I] in the outflows and two of the red
sources showing the more highly excited [Ne III] and [S IV] lines in outflow
regions at some distance from the YSOs. The 4.5 micron emission seen in the
IRAC band 2 images of the outflow sources is not due to H2 lines, which are too
faint in the 5-10 micron wavelength region to be as strong as is needed to
account for the IRAC band 2 emission.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1103.3910 [pdf] - 1052849
Observations and radiative transfer modelling of a massive dense cold
core in G333
Submitted: 2011-03-20
Cold massive cores are one of the earliest manifestations of high mass star
formation. Following the detection of SiO emission from G333.125-0.562, a cold
massive core, further investigations of the physics, chemistry and dynamics of
this object has been carried out. Mopra and NANTEN2 molecular line profile
observations, Australia Telescope Compact Array (ATCA) line and continuum
emission maps, and Spitzer 24 and 70 \mum images were obtained. These new data
further constrain the properties of this prime example of the very early stages
of high mass star formation. A model for the source was constructed and
compared directly with the molecular line data using a 3D molecular line
transfer code - MOLLIE. The ATCA data reveal that G333.125-0.562 is composed of
two sources. One of the sources is responsible for the previously detected
molecular outflow and is detected in the Spitzer 24 and 70 \mum band data.
Turbulent velocity widths are lower than other more active regions of G333
which reflects the younger evolutionary stage and/or lower mass of this core.
The molecular line modelling requires abundances of the CO isotopes that
strongly imply heavy depletion due to freeze-out of this species onto dust
grains. The principal cloud is cold, moderately turbulent and possesses an
outflow which indicates the presence of a central driving source. The secondary
source could be an even less evolved object as no apparent associations with
continuum emissions at (far-)infrared wavelengths.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1010.0612 [pdf] - 1041041
Discrete Source Survey of 6 GHz OH emission from PNe & pPNe and first 6
GHz images of K 3-35
Submitted: 2010-10-04
The aim of this study is to investigate the physical properties of molecular
envelopes of planetary nebulae in their earliest stages of evolution. Using the
100m telescope at Effelsberg, we have undertaken a high sensitivity discrete
source survey for the first excited state of OH maser emission (J=5/2, 2PI3/2
at 6GHz) in the direction of planetary and proto-planetary nebulae exhibiting
18cm OH emission (main and/or satellite lines), and we further validate our
detections using the Nan\c{c}ay radio telescope at 1.6-1.7GHz and MERLIN
interferometer at 1.6-1.7 and 6GHz. Two sources have been detected at 6035MHz
(5cm), both of them are young (or very young) planetary nebulae. The first one
is a confirmation of the detection of a weak 6035MHz line in Vy 2-2. The second
one is a new detection, in K 3-35, which was already known to be an exceptional
late type star because it exhibits 1720MHz OH emission. The detection of
6035MHz OH maser emission is confirmed by subsequent observations made with the
MERLIN interferometer. These lines are very rarely found in evolved stars. The
1612MHz masers surround but are offset from the 1720 and 6035MHz masers which
in turn lie close to a compact 22GHz continuum source embedded in the optical
nebula.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1008.0111 [pdf] - 1034034
The 2008 Outburst in the Young Stellar System Z CMa: The First Detection
of Twin Jets
Whelan, Emma;
Dougados, Catherine;
Perrin, Marshall;
Bonnefoy, Mickael;
Bains, Indra;
Redman, Matt;
Ray, Tom;
Bouy, Herve;
Benisty, Myriam;
Bouvier, Jerome;
Chauvin, Gael;
Garcia, Paulo;
Grankin, Konstantin;
Malbet, Fabien
Submitted: 2010-07-31
The Z CMa binary is understood to undergo both FU Orionis (FUOR) and EX
Orionis (EXOR) type outbursts. While the SE component has been spectro-
scopically identified as an FUOR, the NW component, a Herbig Be star, is the
source of the EXOR outbursts. The system has been identified as the source of a
large outflow, however, previous studies have failed to identify the driver.
Here we present adaptive optics (AO) assisted [FeII] spectro-images which
reveal for the first time the presence of two jets. Observations made using
OSIRIS at the Keck Observatory show the Herbig Be star to be the source of the
parsec-scale outflow, which within 2'' of the source shows signs of wiggling
and the FUOR to '' be driving a ~ 0.4 jet. The wiggling of the Herbig Be star's
jet is evidence for an additional companion which could in fact be generating
the EXOR outbursts, the last of which began in 2008 (Grankin & Artemenko 2009).
Indeed the dy- namical scale of the wiggling corresponds to a time-scale of 4-8
years which is in agreement with the time-scale of these outbursts. The
spectro-images also show a bow-shock shaped feature and possible associated
knots. The origin of this structure is as of yet unclear. Finally interesting
low velocity structure is also observed. One possibility is that it originates
in a wide-angle outflow launched from a circumbinary disk.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:0907.4089 [pdf] - 1003067
Supersonic turbulence in the cold massive core JCMT 18354-0649S
Submitted: 2009-07-23
An example of a cold massive core, JCMT 18354-0649S, a possible high mass
analogue to a low mass star forming core is studied. Line and continuum
observations from JCMT, Mopra Telescope and Spitzer are presented and modelled
in detail using a 3D molecular line radiative transfer code. In almost every
way JCMT 18354-0649S is a scaled-up version of a typical low mass core with
similar temperatures, chemical abundances and densities. The difference is that
both the infall velocity and the turbulent width of the line profiles are an
order of magnitude larger. While the higher infall velocity is expected due to
the large mass of JCMT 18354-0649S, we suggest that the dissipation of this
highly supersonic turbulence may lead to the creation of dense clumps of gas
that surround the high mass core.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:0902.2452 [pdf] - 21363
Molecular line mapping of the giant molecular cloud associated with RCW
106 - III. Multi-molecular line mapping
Lo, N.;
Cunningham, M. R.;
Jones, P. A.;
Bains, I.;
Burton, M. G.;
Wong, T.;
Muller, E.;
Kramer, C.;
Ossenkopf, V.;
Henkel, C.;
Deragopian, G.;
Donnelly, S.;
Ladd, E. F.
Submitted: 2009-02-14
We present multi-molecular line maps obtained with the Mopra Telescope
towards the southern giant molecular cloud (GMC) complex G333, associated with
the HII region RCW 106. We have characterised the GMC by decomposing the 3D
data cubes with GAUSSCLUMPS, and investigated spatial correlations among
different molecules with principal component analysis (PCA). We find no
correlation between clump size and line width, but a strong correlation between
emission luminosity and line width. PCA classifies molecules into high and low
density tracers, and reveals that HCO+ and N2H+ are anti-correlated.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:0812.1832 [pdf] - 19329
High velocity water maser emission from the Post-AGB star OH 009.1-0.4
Submitted: 2008-12-09
Observations of H$_2$O masers towards the post-AGB star and water fountain
source OH 009.1--0.4 were made as part of HOPS (The H$_2$O southern galactic
Plane Survey), with the Mopra radiotelescope. Together with followup
observations using the Australia Telescope Compact Array (ATCA), we have
identified H$_2$O maser emission over a velocity spread of nearly 400km/s
(--109 to +289km/s). This velocity spread appears to be the largest of any
known maser source in our Galaxy. High resolution observations with the ATCA
indicate the maser emission is confined to a region $0\farcs3 \times 0\farcs3$
and shows weak evidence for a separation of the red- and blueshifted maser
spots. We are unable to determine if the water fountain is projected along the
line of sight, or is inclined, but either way OH 009.1--0.4 is an interesting
source, worthy of followup observations.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:0807.4766 [pdf] - 14978
The Large-Scale Atomic and Molecular Gas in the Circinus Galaxy
Submitted: 2008-07-29
We have used the ATCA and the SEST to map the large-scale atomic and
molecular gas in the nearby Circinus galaxy. The HI mosaic of Circinus exhibits
the warps in position angle and inclination revealed in the single-pointing
image, both of which appear to settle beyond the inner 30 kpc which was
previously imaged. The molecular gas has been mapped in both the CO
transitions, where we derive a total molecular gas mass of ~2e9 Mo. Within a
radius of 3 kpc, i.e. where CO was clearly detected, the molecular fraction
climbs steeply from ~0.7 to unity with proximity to the nucleus. Our HI mosaic
gives an atomic gas mass of ~6e9 Mo which is 70% of the fully mapped single
dish value. The total neutral gas mass to dynamical mass ratio is therefore 3%,
consistent with the SAS3 classification of Circinus. The high (molecular) gas
mass fraction found previously, only occurs close to the central ~0.5 kpc and
falls to < 10% within and outwith this region, allaying previous concerns
regarding the validity of applying the Galactic conversion ratio to Circinus.
The rotation curve, as traced by both the HI and CO, exhibits a steep dip at ~1
kpc, the edge of the atomic/molecular ring, within which the star-burst is
occurring. We find the atomic and molecular gases to trace different
kinematical features and believe that the fastest part of the sub-kpc ring
consists overwhelmingly of molecular gas. Beyond the inner kpc, the velocity
climbs to settle into a solid body rotation at >10 kpc. Most of the starlight
emanates from within this radius and so much of the dynamical mass, which
remains climbing to the limit of our data (>50 kpc), must be due to the dark
matter halo.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:0802.2298 [pdf] - 10153
Molecular line mapping of the giant molecular cloud associated with RCW
106 - II. Column density and dynamical state of the clumps
Wong, T.;
Ladd, E. F.;
Brisbin, D.;
Burton, M. G.;
Bains, I.;
Cunningham, M. R.;
Lo, N.;
Jones, P. A.;
Thomas, K. L.;
Longmore, S. N.;
Vigan, A.;
Mookerjea, B.;
Kramer, C.;
Fukui, Y.;
Kawamura, A.
Submitted: 2008-02-15
We present a fully sampled C^{18}O (1-0) map towards the southern giant
molecular cloud (GMC) associated with the HII region RCW 106, and use it in
combination with previous ^{13}CO (1-0) mapping to estimate the gas column
density as a function of position and velocity. We find localized regions of
significant ^{13}CO optical depth in the northern part of the cloud, with
several of the high-opacity clouds in this region likely associated with a
limb-brightened shell around the HII region G333.6-0.2. Optical depth
corrections broaden the distribution of column densities in the cloud, yielding
a log-normal distribution as predicted by simulations of turbulence.
Decomposing the ^{13}CO and C^{18}O data cubes into clumps, we find relatively
weak correlations between size and linewidth, and a more sensitive dependence
of luminosity on size than would be predicted by a constant average column
density. The clump mass spectrum has a slope near -1.7, consistent with
previous studies. The most massive clumps appear to have gravitational binding
energies well in excess of virial equilibrium; we discuss possible
explanations, which include magnetic support and neglect of time-varying
surface terms in the virial theorem. Unlike molecular clouds as a whole, the
clumps within the RCW 106 GMC, while elongated, appear to show random
orientations with respect to the Galactic plane.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:0707.1399 [pdf] - 2950
Detection of SiO emission from a massive dense cold core
Submitted: 2007-07-10
We report the detection of the SiO (J = 2 - 1) transition from the massive
cold dense core G333.125-0.562. The core remains undetected at wavelengths
shorter than 70 micron and has compact 1.2 mm dust continuum. The SiO emission
is localised to the core. The observations are part of a continuing
multi-molecular line survey of the giant molecular cloud G333. Other detected
molecules in the core include 13CO, C18O, CS, HCO+, HCN, HNC, CH3OH, N2H+, SO,
HC3N, NH3, and some of their isotopes. In addition, from NH3 (1,1) and (2,2)
inversion lines, we obtain a temperature of 13 K. From fitting to the spectral
energy distribution we obtain a colour temperature of 18 K and a gas mass of 2
x 10^3 solar mass. We have also detected a 22 GHz water maser in the core,
together with methanol maser emission, suggesting the core will host massive
star formation. We hypothesise that the SiO emission arises from shocks
associated with an outflow in the cold core.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0702673 [pdf] - 89727
A search for 22-GHz water masers within the giant molecular cloud
associated with RCW106
Breen, S. L.;
Ellingsen, S. P.;
Johnston-Hollitt, M.;
Wotherspoon, S.;
Bains, I.;
Burton, M. G.;
Cunningham, M.;
Lo, N.;
Senkbeil, C. E.;
Wong, T.
Submitted: 2007-02-26
We report the results of a blind search for 22-GHz water masers in two
regions, covering approximately half a square degree, within the giant
molecular cloud associated with RCW 106. The complete search of the two regions
was carried out with the 26-m Mount Pleasant radio telescope and resulted in
the detection of nine water masers, five of which are new detections. Australia
Telescope Compact Array (ATCA) observations of these detections have allowed us
to obtain positions with arcsecond accuracy, allowing meaningful comparison
with infrared and molecular data for the region. We find that for the regions
surveyed there are more water masers than either 6.7-GHz methanol, or main-line
OH masers. The water masers are concentrated towards the central axis of the
star formation region, in contrast to the 6.7-GHz methanol masers which tend to
be located near the periphery. The colours of the GLIMPSE point sources
associated with the water masers are similar to those of 6.7-GHz methanol
masers, but slightly less red. We have made a statistical investigation of the
properties of the 13CO and 1.2-mm dust clumps with and without associated water
masers. We find that the water masers are associated with the more massive,
denser and brighter 13CO and 1.2-mm dust clumps. We present statistical models
that are able to predict those 13CO and 1.2-mm dust clumps that are likely to
have associated water masers, with a low misclassification rate.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0701866 [pdf] - 88995
A Search for Propylene Oxide and Glycine in Sagittarius B2 (LMH) and
Orion
Cunningham, M. R.;
Jones, P. A.;
Godfrey, P. D.;
Cragg, D. M.;
Bains, I.;
Burton, M. G.;
Calisse, P.;
Crighton, N. H. M.;
Curran, S. J.;
Davis, T. M.;
Dempsey, J. T.;
Fulton, B.;
Hidas, M. G.;
Hill, T.;
Kedziora-Chudczer, L.;
Minier, V.;
Pracy, M. B.;
Purcell, C.;
Shobbrook, J.;
Travouillon, T.
Submitted: 2007-01-30
We have used the Mopra Telescope to search for glycine and the simple chiral
molecule propylene oxide in the Sgr B2 (LMH) and Orion KL, in the 3-mm band. We
have not detected either species, but have been able to put sensitive upper
limits on the abundances of both molecules. The 3-sigma upper limits derived
for glycine conformer I are 3.7 x 10^{14} cm^{-2} in both Orion-KL and Sgr B2
(LMH), comparable to the reported detections of conformer I by Kuan et al.
However, as our values are 3-sigma upper limits rather than detections we
conclude that this weighs against confirming the detection of Kuan et al. We
find upper limits for the glycine II column density of 7.7 x 10^{12} cm^{-2} in
both Orion-KL and Sgr B2 (LMH), in agreement with the results of Combes et al.
The results presented here show that glycine conformer II is not present in the
extended gas at the levels detected by Kuan et al. for conformer I. Our ATCA
results (Jones et al.) have ruled out the detection of glycine (both conformers
I and II) in the compact hot core of the LMH at the levels reported, so we
conclude that it is unlikely that Kuan et al. have detected glycine in either
Sgr B2 or Orion-KL. We find upper limits for propylene oxide abundance of 3.0 x
10^{14} cm^{-2} in Orion-KL and 6.7 x 10^{14} cm^{-2} in Sgr B2 (LMH). We have
detected fourteen features in Sgr B2 and four features in Orion-KL which have
not previously been reported in the ISM, but have not be able to plausibly
assign these transitions to any carrier.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0512589 [pdf] - 78789
A CH3CN and HCO+ survey towards southern methanol masers associated with
star formation
Purcell, C. R.;
Balasubramanyam, R.;
Burton, M. G.;
Walsh, A. J.;
Minier, V.;
Hunt-Cunningham, M. R.;
Kedziora-Chudczer, L. L.;
Longmore, S. N.;
Hill, T.;
Bains, I.;
Barnes, P. J.;
Busfield, A. L.;
Calisse, P.;
Crighton, N. H. M.;
Curran, S. J.;
Davis, T. M.;
Dempsey, J. T.;
Derragopian, G.;
Fulton, B.;
Hidas, M. G.;
Hoare, M. G.;
Lee, J. -K.;
Ladd, E. F.;
Lumsden, S. L.;
Moore, T. J. T.;
Murphy, M. T.;
Oudmaijer, R. D.;
Pracy, M. B.;
Rathborne, J.;
Robertson, S.;
Schultz, A. S. B.;
Shobbrook, J.;
Sparks, P. A.;
Storey, J.;
Travouillion, T.
Submitted: 2005-12-23
We present the initial results of a 3-mm spectral line survey towards 83
methanol maser selected massive star-forming regions. Here we report
observations of the J=5-4 and 6-5 rotational transitions of methyl cyanide
(CH3CN) and the J=1-0 transition of HCO+and H13CO+.
CH3CN emission is detected in 58 sources (70 %) of our sample). We estimate
the temperature and column density for 37 of these using the rotational diagram
method. The temperatures we derive range from 28-166 K, and are lower than
previously reported temperatures, derived from higher J transitions. We find
that CH3CN is brighter and more commonly detected towards ultra-compact HII
(UCHII) regions than towards isolated maser sources. Detection of CH3CN towards
isolated maser sources strongly suggests that these objects are internally
heated and that CH3CN is excited prior to the UCHII phase of massive
star-formation.
HCO+ is detected towards 82 sources (99 % of our sample), many of which
exhibit asymmetric line profiles compared to H13CO+. Skewed profiles are
indicative of inward or outward motions, however, we find approximately equal
numbers of red and blue-skewed profiles among all classes. Column densities are
derived from an analysis of the HCO+ and H13CO+ line profiles.
80 sources have mid-infrared counterparts: 68 seen in emission and 12 seen in
absorption as `dark clouds'. Seven of the twelve dark clouds exhibit asymmetric
HCO+ profiles, six of which are skewed to the blue, indicating infalling
motions. CH3CN is also common in dark clouds, where it has a 90 % detection
rate.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0211473 [pdf] - 53208
Sub-au imaging of water vapour clouds around four Asymptotic Giant
Branch stars
Submitted: 2002-11-21
We present MERLIN maps of the 22-GHz H2O masers around four low-mass
late-type stars (IK Tau U Ori, RT Vir and U Her), made with an angular
resolution of ~ 15 milliarcsec and a velocity resolution of 0.1 km s-1. The H2O
masers are found in thick expanding shells with inner radii ~ 6 to 16 au and
outer radii four times larger. The expansion velocity increases radially
through the H2O maser regions, with logarithmic velocity gradients of 0.5--0.9.
IK Tau and RT Vir have well-filled H2O maser shells with a spatial offset
between the near and far sides of the shell, which suggests that the masers are
distributed in oblate spheroids inclined to the line of sight. U Ori and U Her
have elongated poorly-filled shells with indications that the masers at the
inner edge have been compressed by shocks; these stars also show OH maser
flares. MERLIN resolves individual maser clouds, which have diameters of 2 -- 4
au and filling factors of only ~ 0.01 with respect to the whole H2O maser
shells. The CSE velocity structure gives additional evidence the maser clouds
are density bounded. Masing clouds can be identified over a similar timescale
to their sound crossing time (~2 yr) but not longer. The sizes and observed
lifetimes of these clouds are an order of magnitude smaller than those around
red supergiants, similar to the ratio of low-mass:high-mass stellar masses and
sizes. This suggests that cloud size is determined by stellar properties, not
local physical phenomena in the wind.