Normalized to: Ataiee, S.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2002.08077 [pdf] - 2076924
The role of disc torques in forming resonant planetary systems
Submitted: 2020-02-19
The most accurate method for modelling planetary migration and hence the
formation of resonant systems is using hydrodynamical simulations. Usually, the
force (torque) acting on a planet is calculated using the forces from the gas
disc and the star, while the gas accelerations are computed using the pressure
gradient, the star, and the planet's gravity, ignoring its own gravity. For the
non-migrating the neglect of the disc gravity results in a consistent torque
calculation while for the migrating case it is inconsistent. We aim to study
how much this inconsistent torque calculation can affect the final
configuration of a two-planet system. Our focus will be on low-mass planets
because most of the multi-planetary systems, discovered by the Kepler survey,
have masses around 10 Earth masses. Performing hydrodynamical simulations of
planet-disc interaction, we measure the torques on non-migrating and migrating
planets for various disc masses as well as density and temperature slopes with
and without considering the disc self-gravity. Using this data, we find a
relation that quantifies the inconsistency, use it in an N-body code, and
perform an extended parameter study modelling the migration of a planetary
system with different planet mass ratios and disc surface densities, in order
to investigate the impact of the torque inconsistency on the architecture of
the planetary system. Not considering disc self-gravity produces an
artificially larger torque on the migrating planet that can result in tighter
planetary systems. The deviation of this torque from the correct value is
larger in discs with steeper surface density profiles. In hydrodynamical
modelling of multi-planetary systems, it is crucial to account for the torque
correction, otherwise the results favour more packed systems.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1901.07640 [pdf] - 2000175
Stability of the co-orbital resonance under dissipation: Application to
its evolution in protoplanetary discs
Submitted: 2019-01-22, last modified: 2019-11-19
Despite the existence of co-orbital bodies in the solar system, and the
prediction of the formation of co-orbital planets by planetary system formation
models, no co-orbital exoplanets (also called trojans) have been detected thus
far. In this paper we investigate how a pair of co-orbital exoplanets would
fare during their migration in a protoplanetary disc. To this end, we computed
a stability criterion of the Lagrangian equilibria L4 and L5 under generic
dissipation and slow mass evolution. Depending on the strength and shape of
these perturbations, the system can either evolve towards the Lagrangian
equilibrium, or tend to increase its amplitude of libration, possibly all the
way to horseshoe orbits or even exiting the resonance. We estimated the various
terms of our criterion using a set of hydrodynamical simulations, and show that
the dynamical coupling between the disc perturbations and both planets have a
significant impact on the stability: the structures induced by each planet in
the disc perturb the dissipative forces applied on the other planets over each
libration cycle. Amongst our results on the stability of co-orbitals, several
are of interest to constrain the observability of such configurations:
long-distance inward migration and smaller leading planets tend to increase the
libration amplitude around the Lagrangian equilibria, while leading massive
planets and belonging to a resonant chain tend to stabilise it. We also show
that, depending on the strength of the dissipative forces, both the inclination
and the eccentricity of the smaller of the two co-orbitals can be significantly
increased during the inward migration of the co-orbital pair, which can have a
significant impact on the detectability by transit of such configurations.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1910.08560 [pdf] - 2026057
The impact of planet wakes on the location and shape of the water
iceline in a protoplanetary disk
Submitted: 2019-10-18
Context: Planets in accretion disks can excite spiral shocks, and---if
massive enough---open gaps in their vicinity. Both of these effects can
influence the overall disk thermal structure.
Aims: We model planets of different masses and semimajor axes in disks of
various viscosities and accretion rates to examine their impact on disk
thermodynamics and highlight the mutable, non-axisymmetric nature of icelines
in systems with massive planets.
Methods: We conduct a parameter study using numerical hydrodynamics
simulations where we treat viscous heating, thermal cooling and stellar
irradiation as additional source terms in the energy equation, with some runs
including radiative diffusion. Our parameter space consists of a grid
containing different combinations of planet and disk parameters.
Results: Both gap opening and shock heating can displace the iceline, with
the effects being amplified for massive planets in optically thick disks. The
gap region can split an initially hot (T>170 K) disk into a hot inner disk and
a hot ring just outside of the planet's location, while shock heating can
reshape the originally axisymmetric iceline into water-poor islands along
spirals. We also find that radiative diffusion does not alter the picture
significantly in this context.
Conclusions: Shock heating and gap opening by a planet can effectively heat
up optically thick disks and in general move and/or reshape the water iceline.
This can affect the gap structure and migration torques. It can also produce
azimuthal features that follow the trajectory of spiral arms, creating hot
zones, "islands" of vapor and ice around spirals which could affect the
accretion or growth of icy aggregates.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1908.10395 [pdf] - 1967016
1:1 orbital resonance of circumbinary planets
Submitted: 2019-08-27
The recent detection of the third planet in Kepler-47 has shown that binary
stars can host several planets in circumbinary orbits. To understand the
evolution of such systems we have performed two-dimensional hydrodynamic
simulations of the circumbinary disc with two embedded planets for several
Kepler systems. In two cases, Kepler-47 and -413, the planets are captured in a
1:1 mean-motion resonance at the planet parking position near the inner edge of
the disc. The orbits are fully aligned, have mean eccentricities of about 0.25
to 0.30, and the planets are entangled in a horseshoe type of motion.
Subsequent n-body simulations without the disc show that the configurations are
stable. Our results point to the existence of a new class of stable resonant
orbits around binary stars. It remains to be seen if such orbits exist in
reality.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1809.05383 [pdf] - 1750331
The formation of Jupiter by hybrid pebble-planetesimal accretion
Alibert, Yann;
Venturini, Julia;
Helled, Ravit;
Ataiee, Sareh;
Burn, Remo;
Senecal, Luc;
Benz, Willy;
Mayer, Lucio;
Mordasini, Christoph;
Quanz, Sascha P.;
Schönbächler, Maria
Submitted: 2018-09-14
The standard model for giant planet formation is based on the accretion of
solids by a growing planetary embryo, followed by rapid gas accretion once the
planet exceeds a so-called critical mass. The dominant size of the accreted
solids (cm-size particles named pebbles or km to hundred km-size bodies named
planetesimals) is, however, unknown. Recently, high-precision measurements of
isotopes in meteorites provided evidence for the existence of two reservoirs in
the early Solar System. These reservoirs remained separated from ~1 until ~ 3
Myr after the beginning of the Solar System's formation. This separation is
interpreted as resulting from Jupiter growing and becoming a barrier for
material transport. In this framework, Jupiter reached ~20 Earth masses within
~1 Myr and slowly grew to ~50 Earth masses in the subsequent 2 Myr before
reaching its present-day mass. The evidence that Jupiter slowed down its growth
after reaching 20 Earth masses for at least 2 Myr is puzzling because a planet
of this mass is expected to trigger fast runaway gas accretion. Here, we use
theoretical models to describe the conditions allowing for such a slow
accretion and show that Jupiter grew in three distinct phases. First, rapid
pebble accretion brought the major part of Jupiter's core mass. Second, slow
planetesimal accretion provided the energy required to hinder runaway gas
accretion during 2 Myr. Third, runaway gas accretion proceeded. Both pebbles
and planetesimals therefore have an important role in Jupiter's formation.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1808.10707 [pdf] - 1789487
Metallicity effect and planet mass function in pebble-based planet
formation models
Submitted: 2018-08-31
One of the main scenarios of planet formation is the core accretion model
where a massive core forms first and then accretes a gaseous envelope. This
core forms by accreting solids, either planetesimals, or pebbles. A key
constraint in this model is that the accretion of gas must proceed before the
dissipation of the gas disc. Classical planetesimal accretion scenario predicts
that the time needed to form a giant planets core is much longer than the time
needed to dissipate the disc. This difficulty led to the development of another
accretion scenario, in which cores grow by accretion of pebbles, which are much
smaller and thus more easily accreted, leading to a more rapid formation. The
aim of this paper is to compare our updated pebble-based planet formation model
with observations, in particular the well studied metallicity effect. We adopt
the Bitsch et al. 2015a disc model and the Bitsch et al. 2015b pebble model and
use a population synthesis approach to compare the formed planets with
observations. We find that keeping the same parameters as in Bitsch et al.
2015b leads to no planet growth due to a computation mistake in the pebble flux
(Bitsch et al. 2017). Indeed a large fraction of the heavy elements should be
put into pebbles (Zpeb/Ztot = 0.9) in order to form massive planets using this
approach. The resulting mass functions show a huge amount of giants and a lack
of Neptune mass planets, which are abundant according to observations. To
overcome this issue we include the computation of the internal structure for
the planetary atmosphere to our model. This leads to the formation of Neptune
mass planets but no observable giants. Reducing the opacity of the planetary
envelope finally matches observations better. We conclude that modeling the
internal structure for the planetary atmosphere is necessary to reproduce
observations.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1804.00924 [pdf] - 1721062
How much does turbulence change the pebble isolation mass for planet
formation?
Submitted: 2018-04-03, last modified: 2018-04-05
When a planet becomes massive enough, it gradually carves a partial gap
around its orbit in the protoplanetary disk. A pressure maximum can be formed
outside the gap where solids that are loosely coupled to the gas, typically in
the pebble size range, can be trapped. The minimum planet mass for building
such a trap, which is called the pebble isolation mass (PIM), is important for
two reasons: it marks the end of planetary growth by pebble accretion, and the
trapped dust forms a ring that may be observed with millimetre observations. We
study the effect of disk turbulence on the pebble isolation mass and find its
dependence on the gas turbulent viscosity, aspect ratio, and particles Stokes
number. By means of 2D gas hydrodynamical simulations, we found the minimum
planet mass to form a radial pressure maximum beyond the orbit of the planet,
which is the necessary condition to trap pebbles. We then carried out 2D gas
plus dust hydrodynamical simulations to examine how dust turbulent diffusion
impacts particles trapping at the pressure maximum. We finally provide a
semi-analytical calculation of the PIM based on comparing the radial drift
velocity of solids and the root mean square turbulent velocity fluctuations
around the pressure maximum. From our results of gas simulations, we provide an
expression for the PIM versus disk aspect ratio and turbulent viscosity. Our
gas plus dust simulations show that the effective PIM can be nearly an order of
magnitude larger in high-viscosity disks because turbulence diffuse particles
out of the pressure maximum. This is quantified by our semi-analytical
calculation, which gives an explicit dependence of the PIM with Stokes number
of particles. We conclude than disk turbulence can significantly alter the PIM,
depending on the level of turbulence in regions of planet formation.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1703.09227 [pdf] - 1567743
A Multi-Wavelength Analysis of Dust and Gas in the SR 24S Transition
Disk
Pinilla, P.;
Pérez, L. M.;
Andrews, S.;
van der Marel, N.;
van Dishoeck, E. F.;
Ataiee, S.;
Benisty, M.;
Birnstiel, T.;
Juhász, A.;
Natta, A.;
Ricci, L.;
Testi, L.
Submitted: 2017-03-27
We present new Atacama Large Millimeter/sub-millimeter Array (ALMA) 1.3 mm
continuum observations of the SR 24S transition disk with an angular resolution
$\lesssim0.18"$ (12 au radius). We perform a multi-wavelength investigation by
combining new data with previous ALMA data at 0.45 mm. The visibilities and
images of the continuum emission at the two wavelengths are well characterized
by a ring-like emission. Visibility modeling finds that the ring-like emission
is narrower at longer wavelengths, in good agreement with models of dust
trapping in pressure bumps, although there are complex residuals that suggest
potentially asymmetric structures. The 0.45 mm emission has a shallower profile
inside the central cavity than the 1.3 mm emission. In addition, we find that
the $^{13}$CO and C$^{18}$O (J=2-1) emission peaks at the center of the
continuum cavity. We do not detect either continuum or gas emission from the
northern companion to this system (SR 24N), which is itself a binary system.
The upper limit for the dust disk mass of SR 24N is $\lesssim
0.12\,M_{\bigoplus}$, which gives a disk mass ratio in dust between the two
components of $M_{\mathrm{dust, SR\,24S}}/M_{\mathrm{dust,
SR\,24N}}\gtrsim840$. The current ALMA observations may imply that either
planets have already formed in the SR 24N disk or that dust growth to mm-sizes
is inhibited there and that only warm gas, as seen by ro-vibrational CO
emission inside the truncation radii of the binary, is present.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1508.04443 [pdf] - 1273298
Scattered light images of spiral arms in marginally gravitationally
unstable discs with an embedded planet
Submitted: 2015-08-18
Scattered light images of transition discs in the near-infrared often show
non-axisymmetric structures in the form of wide-open spiral arms in addition to
their characteristic low-opacity inner gap region. We study self-gravitating
discs and investigate the influence of gravitational instability on the shape
and contrast of spiral arms induced by planet-disc interactions.
Two-dimensional non-isothermal hydrodynamical simulations including viscous
heating and a cooling prescription are combined with three-dimensional dust
continuum radiative transfer models for direct comparison to observations. We
find that the resulting contrast between the spirals and the surrounding disc
in scattered light is by far higher for pressure scale height variations, i.e.
thermal perturbations, than for pure surface density variations. Self-gravity
effects suppress any vortex modes and tend to reduce the opening angle of
planet-induced spirals, making them more tightly wound. If the disc is only
marginally gravitationally stable with a Toomre parameter around unity, an
embedded massive planet (planet-to-star mass ratio of $10^{-2}$) can trigger
gravitational instability in the outer disc. The spirals created by this
instability and the density waves launched by the planet can overlap resulting
in large-scale, more open spiral arms in the outer disc. The contrast of these
spirals is well above the detection limit of current telescopes.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1410.5963 [pdf] - 903886
Gas and dust structures in protoplanetary disks hosting multiple planets
Submitted: 2014-10-22, last modified: 2014-11-18
Transition disks have dust-depleted inner regions and may represent an
intermediate step of an on-going disk dispersal process, where planet formation
is probably in progress. Recent millimetre observations of transition disks
reveal radially and azimuthally asymmetric structures, where micron- and
millimetre-sized dust particles may not spatially coexist. These properties can
be the result of particle trapping and grain growth in pressure bumps
originating from the disk interaction with a planetary companion. The multiple
features observed in some transition disks, such as SR 21, suggest the presence
of more than one planet. We study the gas and dust distributions of a disk
hosting two massive planets as function of different disk and dust parameters.
Observational signatures, such as the spectral energy distribution,
sub-millimetre, and polarised images are simulated for the various parameters.
We confirm that planets can lead to particle trapping, although for a disk with
high viscosity ($\alpha_{\rm{turb}}=10^{-2}$), the planet should be more
massive than $5 M_{\rm{Jup}}$ and dust fragmentation should occur with low
efficiency ($v_{f}\sim30\rm{m s}^{-1}$). This will lead to a ring-like feature
as observed in transition disks in the millimetre. When trapping occurs, we
find that a smooth distribution of micron sized grains throughout the disk,
sometimes observed in scattered light, can only happen if the combination of
planet mass and turbulence is such that small grains are not fully filtered
out. A high disk viscosity ($\alpha_{\rm{turb}}=10^{-2}$) ensures a
replenishment of the cavity in micron-sized dust, while for lower viscosity
($\alpha_{\rm{turb}}=10^{-3}$), the planet mass is constrained to be less than
$5 M_{\rm{Jup}}$. In these cases, the gas distribution is likely to show
low-amplitude azimuthal asymmetries caused by disk eccentricity rather than by
long-lived vortices.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1410.0132 [pdf] - 903814
Planet-vortex interaction:How a vortex can shepherd a planetary embryo
Submitted: 2014-10-01
Context: Anticyclonic vortices are considered as a favourable places for
trapping dust and forming planetary embryos. On the other hand, they are
massive blobs that can interact gravitationally with the planets in the disc.
Aims: We aim to study how a vortex interacts gravitationally with a planet
which migrates toward it or a planet which is created inside the vortex.
Methods: We performed hydrodynamical simulations of a viscous locally
isothermal disc using GFARGO and FARGO-ADSG. We set a stationary Gaussian
pressure bump in the disc in a way that RWI is triggered. After a large vortex
is established, we implanted a low mass planet in the outer disc or inside the
vortex and allowed it to migrate. We also examined the effect of vortex
strength on the planet migration and checked the validity of the final result
in the presence of self-gravity. Results: We noticed regardless of the planet's
initial position, the planet is finally locked to the vortex or its migration
is stopped in a farther orbital distance in case of a stronger vortex. For the
model with the weaker vortex, we studied the effect of different parameters
such as background viscosity, background surface density, mass of the planet
and different planet positions. In these models, while the trapping time and
locking angle of the planet vary for different parameters, the main result,
which is the planet-vortex locking, remains valid. We discovered that even a
planet with a mass less than 5 * 10^{-7} M_{\star} comes out from the vortex
and is locked to it at the same orbital distance. For a stronger vortex, both
in non-self-gravitated and self-gravitating models, the planet migration is
stopped far away from the radial position of the vortex. This effect can make
the vortices a suitable place for continual planet formation under the
condition that they save their shape during the planetary growth.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1305.5676 [pdf] - 1171570
Trapping of giant-planet cores - I. Vortex aided trapping at the outer
dead zone edge
Submitted: 2013-05-24, last modified: 2013-06-28
In this paper the migration of a 10 Earth-mass planetary core is investigated
at the outer boundary of the dead zone of a protoplanetary disc by means of 2D
hydrodynamic simulations done with the graphics processor unit version of the
FARGO code. In the dead zone, the effective viscosity is greatly reduced due to
the disc self-shielding against stellar UV radiation, X-rays from the stellar
magnetosphere and interstellar cosmic rays. As a consequence, mass accumulation
occurs near the outer dead zone edge, which is assumed to trap planetary cores
enhancing the efficiency of the core-accretion scenario to form giant planets.
Contrary to the perfect trapping of planetary cores in 1D models, our 2D
numerical simulations show that the trapping effect is greatly dependent on the
width of the region where viscosity reduction is taking place. Planet trapping
happens exclusively if the viscosity reduction is sharp enough to allow the
development of large-scale vortices due to the Rossby wave instability. The
trapping is only temporarily, and its duration is inversely proportional to the
width of the viscosity transition. However, if the Rossby wave instability is
not excited, a ring-like axisymmetric density jump forms, which cannot trap the
10 Earth-mass planetary cores. We revealed that the stellar torque exerted on
the planet plays an important role in the migration history as the barycentre
of the system significantly shifts away from the star due to highly
non-axisymmetric density distribution of the disc. Our results still support
the idea of planet formation at density/pressure maximum, since the migration
of cores is considerably slowed down enabling them further growth and runaway
gas accretion in the vicinity of an overdense region.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1304.1736 [pdf] - 1165773
Asymmetric transition disks: Vorticity or eccentricity?
Submitted: 2013-04-05
Context. Transition disks typically appear in resolved millimeter
observations as giant dust rings surrounding their young host stars. More
accurate observations with ALMA have shown several of these rings to be in fact
asymmetric: they have lopsided shapes. It has been speculated that these rings
act as dust traps, which would make them important laboratories for studying
planet formation. It has been shown that an elongated giant vortex produced in
a disk with a strong viscosity jump strikingly resembles the observed
asymmetric rings.
Aims. We aim to study a similar behavior for a disk in which a giant planet
is embedded. However, a giant planet can induce two kinds of asymmetries: (1) a
giant vortex, and (2) an eccentric disk. We studied under which conditions each
of these can appear, and how one can observationally distinguish between them.
This is important because only a vortex can trap particles both radially and
azimuthally, while the eccentric ring can only trap particles in radial
direction.
Methods. We used the FARGO code to conduct the hydro-simulations. We set up a
disk with an embedded giant planet and took a radial grid spanning from 0.1 to
7 times the planet semi-major axis. We ran the simulations with various
viscosity values and planet masses for 1000 planet orbits to allow a fully
developed vortex or disk eccentricity. Afterwards, we compared the dust
distribution in a vortex-holding disk with an eccentric disk using dust
simulations.
Results. We find that vorticity and eccentricity are distinguishable by
looking at the azimuthal contrast of the dust density. While vortices, as
particle traps, produce very pronounced azimuthal asymmetries, eccentric
features are not able to accumulate millimeter dust particles in azimuthal
direction, and therefore the asymmetries are expected to be modest.