Normalized to: Ashman, K.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0510311 [pdf] - 76807
The Ages of Globular Clusters in NGC 4365 Revisited with Deep HST
Observations
Submitted: 2005-10-11
We present new Hubble Space Telescope (HST)-NIC3, near-infrared H-band
photometry of globular clusters (GC) around NGC 4365 and NGC 1399 in
combination with archival HST-WCPC2 and ACS optical data. We find that NGC 4365
has a number of globular clusters with bluer optical colors than expected for
their red optical to near-infrared colors and an old age. The only known way to
explain these colors is with a significant population of intermediate-age (2-8
Gyr) clusters in this elliptical galaxy. In contrast, NGC 1399 reveals no such
population. Our result for NGC 1399 is in agreement with previous spectroscopic
work that suggests that its clusters have a large metallicity spread and are
nearly all old. In the literature, there are various results from spectroscopic
studies of modest samples of NGC 4365 globular clusters. The spectroscopic data
allow for either the presence or absence of a significant population of
intermediate-age clusters, given the index uncertainties indicated by comparing
objects in common between these studies and the few spectroscopic candidates
with optical to near-IR colors indicative of intermediate ages. Our new near-IR
data of the NGC 4365 GC system with much higher signal-to-noise agrees well
with earlier published photometry and both give strong evidence of a
significant intermediate-age component. The agreement between the photometric
and spectroscopic results for NGC 1399 and other systems lends further
confidence to this conclusion, and to the effectiveness of the near-IR
technique.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0305064 [pdf] - 56537
Modeling the dynamical evolution of the M87 globular cluster system
Submitted: 2003-05-05
We study the dynamical evolution of the M87 globular cluster system (GCS)
with a number of numerical simulations. We explore a range of different initial
conditions for the GCS mass function (GCMF), for the GCS spatial distribution
and for the GCS velocity distribution. We confirm that an initial power-law
GCMF like that observed in young cluster systems can be readily transformed
through dynamical processes into a bell-shaped GCMF. However,only models with
initial velocity distributions characterized by a strong radial anisotropy
increasing with the galactocentric distance are able to reproduce the observed
constancy of the GCMF at all radii.We show that such strongly radial orbital
distributions are inconsistent with the observed kinematics of the M87 GCS. The
evolution of models with a bell-shaped GCMF with a turnover similar to that
currently observed in old GCS is also investigated. We show that models with
this initial GCMF can satisfy all the observational constraints currently
available on the GCS spatial distribution,the GCS velocity distribution and on
the GCMF properties.In particular these models successfully reproduce both the
lack of a radial gradient of the GCS mean mass recently found in an analysis of
HST images of M87 at multiple locations, and the observed kinematics of the M87
GCS.Our simulations also show that evolutionary processes significantly affect
the initial GCS properties by leading to the disruption of many clusters and
changing the masses of those which survive.The preferential disruption of inner
clusters flattens the initial GCS number density profile and it can explain the
rising specific frequency with radius; we show that the inner flattening
observed in the M87 GCS spatial distribution can be the result of the effects
of dynamical evolution on an initially steep density profile. (abridged)
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0210587 [pdf] - 52625
Globular Cluster Formation
Submitted: 2002-10-27
The discovery of young globular clusters in merging galaxies and other
environments provides an opportunity to study directly the process of globular
cluster formation. Empirically it appears that globular cluster formation
occurs preferentially in regions in which star formation occurs at a high rate
and efficiency. Further, the interstellar medium in such regions is likely to
be at a higher pressure than less active star-forming environments. An
additional observational clue to the globular cluster formation process is that
young globular clusters have little or no mass-radius relationship. In this
paper I argue that high pressure and high star-formation efficiency are
responsible for current globular cluster formation. I suggest that the
precursors to globular clusters are molecular clouds and that the mass-radius
relationship exhibited by such clouds is wiped out by a variable star formation
efficiency.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0109248 [pdf] - 44747
A Comparative Study of Globular Cluster Systems in UGC 9799 and NGC 1129
Submitted: 2001-09-17
We present a preliminary analysis of HST-WFPC2 observations of globular
cluster systems in the two brightest galaxies, UGC 9799 (cD) and NGC 1129
(non-cD), located in the center of rich clusters.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0107146 [pdf] - 43517
Some Constraints on The Formation of Globular Clusters
Submitted: 2001-07-08
We explore the constraints on globular cluster formation provided by the
observed conditions in starbursts where globulars are currently forming, and by
the observed properties of young and old globular clusters. We note that the
pressure in the ISM of starbursts and mergers implies that molecular clouds in
these environments have radii similar to those of globular clusters. Such
molecular clouds are therefore viable precursors to globular clusters if the
star formation efficiency in the clouds is high. A high star formation
efficiency may be a consequence of the high density and associated high binding
energy and short dynamical timescale of molecular clouds in such environments.
We also note that the apparent lack of a mass-radius relationship in young and
old globular cluster systems places important constraints on globular cluster
formation models. This is because molecular clouds are observed to follow a
virial scaling relation between mass and radius. We suggest that a variable
star formation efficiency may weaken or eliminate the mass-radius relation of
molecular clouds as they fragment to form globular clusters. We attribute the
absence of young globular clusters in the disks of ordinary galaxies such as
the Milky Way to the relatively low ambient pressures in such systems.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0011423 [pdf] - 39430
Globular Clusters as Probes of the Virgo gE NGC 4472
Submitted: 2000-11-22
We present radial velocities for 144 globular clusters around the Virgo gE
NGC 4472 (M49), and ages and metallicities from co-added spectra of 131
clusters. We confirm our earlier finding that the metal-poor clusters have a
significantly higher velocity dispersion than the metal-rich clusters, and we
find little or no rotation in the metal-rich clusters. The velocity dispersion
profile is consistent with isotropic orbits for the clusters and the NGC 4472
mass distribution inferred from X-ray data. Our sample of clusters spans a
metallicity range of -1.6 < [Fe/H] < 0 dex. The metal-poor and metal-rich
cluster populations are coeval within the errors, and all clusters are older
than 6 Gyr at 95% confidence. Our findings are consistent with a merger origin
for NGC 4472, but other elliptical formation models cannot be ruled out.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0009130 [pdf] - 37972
Dynamical Constraints on the Formation of NGC 4472 and Its Globular
Clusters
Submitted: 2000-09-08
We present new radial velocities for 87 globular clusters around the
elliptical galaxy NGC 4472, and combine these with our previously published
data to create a data set of velocities for 144 globular clusters around NGC
4472. We utilize this data set to analyze the kinematics of the NGC 4472
globular cluster system. The new data confirms our previous discovery that the
metal-poor clusters have significantly higher velocity dispersion than the
metal-rich clusters in NGC 4472. We also find very little or no rotation in the
more spatially concentrated metal-rich population, with a resulting upper limit
for this population of (v/sigma)_{proj} < 0.34 at a 99% confidence level. The
very small angular momentum in the metal-rich population requires efficient
angular momentum transport during the formation of this population which is
spatially concentrated and chemically enriched. Such angular momentum transfer
can be provided by galaxy mergers, but has not been achieved in other extant
models of elliptical galaxy formation that include dark matter halos. We also
calculate the velocity dispersion as a function of radius, and show that it is
consistent with roughly isotropic orbits for the clusters and the mass
distribution of NGC 4472 inferred from X-ray observations of the hot gas around
the galaxy.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0007063 [pdf] - 36901
Ages and Metallicities of Globular Clusters in NGC 4472
Submitted: 2000-07-05
We have derived ages and metallicities from co-added spectra of 131 globular
clusters associated with the giant elliptical galaxy NGC 4472. Based upon a
calibration with Galactic globular clusters, we find that our sample of
globular clusters in NGC 4472 span a metallicity range of approximately -1.6 <=
[Fe/H] <= 0 dex. There is evidence of a radial metallicity gradient in the
globular cluster system, which is steeper than that seen in the underlying
starlight. Determination of the absolute ages of the globular clusters is
uncertain, but formally, the metal-poor population of globular clusters has an
age of 14.5 +/- 4 Gyr and the metal-rich population is 13.8 +/- 6 Gyr old.
Monte Carlo simulations indicate that the globular cluster populations present
in these data are older than 6 Gyr at the 95% confidence level. We find that
within the uncertainties, the globular clusters are old and coeval, implying
that the bimodality seen in the broadband colours primarily reflects
metallicity and not age differences.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9904247 [pdf] - 106144
The Formation and Evolution of Young Globular Clusters in NGC 3256
Submitted: 1999-04-19
We present images of the recent galaxy merger NGC 3256 obtained with the
WFPC2 of the Hubble Space Telescope in B and I filters. We show that there is a
large population of more than 1,000 compact, bright blue objects in this galaxy
within the 7 kpc x 7 kpc region studied. These objects have sizes, colors and
luminosities like those expected for young Galactic globular clusters with ages
ranging from a few to several hundred Myr. On this basis, we identify at least
some fraction of the compact, bright blue objects in NGC 3256 as young globular
clusters. The young cluster system comprises 15-20% of the luminosity of the
galaxy in B and half that in I within the region studied, indicating a high
efficiency of cluster formation on a galaxy-wide scale. We find that the
intrinsic color distribution is broad, and there is no significant trend of
color with magnitude. The combination of the broad range of observed colors and
the lack of a trend of redder colors at fainter magnitudes can not be fit
solely by a broad age distribution and/or differential reddening, although the
latter is clearly present. The observations can be accounted for by either the
preferential depletion/destruction of lower mass clusters as they age, or a
very young age (<= 20 Myr) for the cluster population, comparable to or less
than the dynamical time of the region in which the clusters are observed. We
also find that the luminosity function of the young cluster system can be
roughly fit by a power-law with an exponent of -1.8, with tentative evidence
that it flattens at faint magnitudes. The clusters are compact in size, with
typical estimated half-light radii of 5-10 parsecs, but there is no obvious
cut-off for larger radii, and only a shallow trend of size with luminosity.
(slightly abridged).
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9903324 [pdf] - 105728
HST Imaging of Globular Clusters in the Edge--on Spiral Galaxies NGC
4565 and NGC 5907
Submitted: 1999-03-22
We present a study of the globular cluster systems of two edge-on spiral
galaxies, NGC4565 and NGC5907, from WFPC2 images in the F450W and F814W
filters. The globular cluster systems of both galaxies appear to be similar to
the Galactic globular cluster system. In particular, we derive total numbers of
globular clusters of N_{GC}(4565)= 204+/-38 {+87}{-53} and
N_{GC}(5907)=170+/-41 {+47}{-72} (where the first are statistical, the second
potential systematic errors) for NGC4565 and NGC5907, respectively. This
determination is based on a comparison to the Milky Way system, for which we
adopt a total number of globular clusters of 180+/-20. The specific frequency
of both galaxies is S_N~0.6: indistinguishable from the value for the Milky
Way. The similarity in the globular cluster systems of the two galaxies is
noteworthy since they have significantly different thick disks and
bulge-to-disk ratios. This would suggest that these two components do not play
a major role in the building up of a globular cluster system around late-type
galaxies.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9812199 [pdf] - 104306
The Globular Cluster System in the Inner Region of M87
Submitted: 1998-12-09
1057 globular cluster candidates have been identified in a WFPC2 image of the
inner region of M87. The Globular Cluster Luminosity Function (GCLF) can be
well fit by a Gaussian profile with a mean value of m_V^0=23.67 +/- 0.07 mag
and sigma=1.39 +/- 0.06 mag (compared to m_V^0=23.74 mag and sigma=1.44 mag
from an earlier study using the same data by Whitmore it et al. 1995). The GCLF
in five radial bins is found to be statistically the same at all points,
showing no clear evidence of dynamical destruction processes based on the
luminosity function (LF), in contradiction to the claim by Gnedin (1997).
Similarly, there is no obvious correlation between the half light radius of the
clusters and the galactocentric distance. The core radius of the globular
cluster density distribution is R_c=56'', considerably larger than the core of
the stellar component (R_c=6.8''). The mean color of the cluster candidates is
V-I=1.09 mag which corresponds to an average metallicity of Fe/H = -0.74 dex.
The color distribution is bimodal everywhere, with a blue peak at V-I=0.95 mag
and a red peak at V-I=1.20 mag. The red population is only 0.1 magnitude bluer
than the underlying galaxy, indicating that these clusters formed late in the
metal enrichment history of the galaxy and were possibly created in a burst of
star/cluster formation 3-6 Gyr after the blue population. We also find that
both the red and the blue cluster distributions have a more elliptical shape
(Hubble type E3.5) than the nearly spherical galaxy. The average half light
radius of the clusters is ~2.5 pc which is comparable to the 3 pc average
effective radius of the Milky Way clusters, though the red candidates are ~20%
smaller than the blue ones.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9803293 [pdf] - 100828
Spectroscopy of Globular Clusters in NGC 4472
Submitted: 1998-03-25
Optical multi-slit spectra have been obtained for 47 globular clusters
surrounding the brightest Virgo elliptical NGC 4472 (M49). Including data from
the literature, we analyze velocities for a total sample of 57 clusters and
present the first tentative evidence for kinematic differences between the red
and blue cluster populations which make up the bimodal colour distribution of
this galaxy. The redder clusters are more centrally concentrated and have a
velocity dispersion of 240 km/sec compared with 320 km/sec for the blue
clusters. The origin of this difference appears to be a larger component of
systematic rotation in the blue cluster system. The larger rotation in the more
extended blue cluster system is indicative of efficient angular momentum
transport, as provided by galaxy mergers. Masses estimated from the globular
cluster velocities are consistent with the mass distribution estimated from
X-ray data, and indicate that the M/L rises to 50 times solar at 2.5 R_e.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9712206 [pdf] - 99695
Globular Cluster Systems of Elliptical Galaxies
Submitted: 1997-12-16
We review the observed properties of globular cluster systems and their
implications for models of galaxy formation. Observations show that globular
clusters form in gas-rich mergers, and that bimodal metallicity distributions
are common in the globular cluster systems of ellipticals, with the metal-poor
population more extended than the metal-rich one. These are three of the four
predictions of the simple merger model of Ashman & Zepf (1992). The fourth
prediction concerns the properties of the globular cluster systems of spirals,
and is still to be tested by observation. Adopting Occam's razor, the
confirmation of the fundamental predictions of the merger model from both young
and old globular cluster systems is strong evidence that typical elliptical
galaxies formed from the mergers of spiral galaxies. However, the simplifying
assumptions of the Ashman-Zepf merger model limit its applicability to certain
complex situations such as the formation of cD galaxies. We conclude this
review by introducing new observational and theoretical programs that will
further the understanding of the physical mechanisms of globular cluster and
galaxy formation.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9709122 [pdf] - 98575
Some Revised Observational Constraints on the Formation and Evolution of
the Galactic Disk
Submitted: 1997-09-12
A set of 76 open clusters with abundances based upon DDO photometry and/or
moderate dispersion spectroscopy has been transformed to a common [Fe/H] scale
and used to study the local structure and evolution of the galactic disk. The
metallicity distribution of clusters with R_GC is best described by two
distinct zones. Between R_GC = 6.5 and 10 kpc, the distribution has a mean
[Fe/H] = 0.0 and a dispersion of 0.1 dex; there is only weak evidence for a
shallow abundance gradient over this distance range. Beyond R_GC = 10 kpc, the
metallicity distribution has a dispersion between 0.10 and 0.15 dex, but with a
mean [Fe/H] = -0.3, implying a sharp discontinuity at R_GC = 10 kpc. After
correcting for the discontinuity, no evidence is found for a gradient
perpendicular to the plane. Adopting the clusters interior to 10 kpc as a
representative sample of the galactic disk over the last 7 Gyr, the cluster
metallicity range is found to be about half that of the field stars. When
coupled with the discontinuity in the galactocentric gradient, the discrepancy
in the metallicity distribution is interpreted as an indication of significant
diffusion of field stars into the solar neighborhood from beyond 10 kpc. These
results imply that the sun is NOT atypical of the stars formed in the solar
circle 4.6 Gyr ago. It is suggested that the discontinuity reflects the edge of
the initial galactic disk as defined by the disk globular cluster system and
the so-called thick disk; the initial offset in [Fe/H] created by the
differences in the chemical history on either side of the discontinuity has
carried through to the current stage of galactic evolution. If correct,
diffusion coupled with the absence of an abundance gradient could make the
separation of field stars on the basis of galactocentric origin difficult.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9609176 [pdf] - 1469390
Kinematics and Metallicities of Globular Clusters in M104
Submitted: 1996-09-25
We have obtained spectra for globular cluster candidates in M104 with LDSS-2
on the William Herschel Telescope, confirming 34 objects as M104 globular
clusters. We find a cluster velocity dispersion of $\sim$ 260 km/sec, and the
Projected Mass Estimator gives a mass of 5.0 (3.5,6.7) $\times 10^{11}$
M$_\odot$ for M104 within a projected radius of $\sim 330^{''}$ (14 kpc for
D=8.55 Mpc). Our best estimate for the mass-to-light ratio is M/L$_{V_T}$=
16$^{+5.5}_{-5.0}$ within the same radius. Considering all of the possible
sources of uncertainty, we find a lower limit of M/L_V= 5.3, which is larger
than the M/L$_V$ found from rotation curve analyses inside 180$^{''}$. We thus
conclude that the mass-to-light ratio increases with radius, or in other words
that M104 possesses a dark matter halo. There is a marginal detection of
rotation in the M104 cluster system at the 92.5% confidence level; larger
samples will be needed to investigate this possibility. Interestingly, the M104
globular cluster and planetary nebulae (PNe) kinematics are roughly consistent
inside $\sim 100^{''}$. Finally, we find a mean cluster metallicity of [Fe/H] =
$-$0.70 $\pm$ 0.3, which is more typical of clusters in gE/cD galaxies than it
is of clusters in other spirals.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9506069 [pdf] - 92859
Globular Cluster Systems As Distance Indicators: Metallicity Effects On
The Luminosity Function
Submitted: 1995-06-09
We investigate the universality of the globular cluster luminosity function
(GCLF) and the use of this function as an extragalactic distance indicator.
Previous studies have found an offset between GCLF distances and those obtained
with other techniques. We show that this offset can be understood in terms of a
metallicity effect. Specifically, the globular cluster systems used in distance
scale studies have traditionally been those around elliptical galaxies. These
systems have higher mean metallicities than the Milky Way globular cluster
system. Consequently, the peak of the GCLF in the systems around ellipticals is
significantly fainter in $B$ and $V$ than the GCLF peak in the Milky Way. We
calculate the shift in the peak of the GCLF relative to the Milky Way globulars
in $B$, $V$, $R$, $I$ and $J$ for a range of globular cluster metallicities.
Applying these corrections, we find good agreement between GCLF distances and
those obtained using the surface brightness fluctuations method. The similarity
between metallicity-corrected GCLFs suggests that the underlying mass function
of globular cluster systems is remarkably constant from one galaxy to another.
Our results allow the GCLF to be employed as an improved distance indicator.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9503050 [pdf] - 92467
Spectroscopy of Candidate Young Globular Clusters in NGC 1275
Submitted: 1995-03-13
We present spectra of the brightest member of the population of compact blue
objects discovered in the peculiar galaxy NGC 1275 by Holtzman et al. using
Hubble Space Telescope images. These spectra show strong Balmer absorption
lines like those observed in A-type stars, as expected if the object is a young
globular cluster. The age estimated from the strength of the Balmer lines is
about 0.5 Gyr, although ages ranging from 0.1 Gyr to 0.9 Gyr can not be
confidently excluded given current models of stellar populations. If these
estimated ages are adopted for the young cluster population of NGC 1275 as a
whole, the fading predicted by stellar populations models gives a luminosity
function which is consistent with that of the Galactic globular cluster system
convolved with the observational selection function for the NGC 1275 system. We
also use the equivalent widths of the Mg $b$ and Fe 5270 features to constrain
the metallicity of the young cluster. Combining these absorption-line widths
with the age estimates from the Balmer lines and stellar population models, we
find a metallicity of roughly solar based on the Mg $b$ index and somewhat
higher for the Fe 5270 index. The radial velocity of the absorption lines of
the cluster spectrum is offset from the emission lines of the galaxy spectrum
at the same position by $-130$ \kms, providing further evidence for the
identification of the object as a globular cluster, and opening up the future
possibility of studying the kinematics of young cluster systems. The discovery
of objects with the characteristics of young globular clusters in NGC 1275,
which shows evidence of a recent interaction or merger, supports the hypothesis
that galaxy interactions and mergers are favorable sites for the formation of
globular clusters.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9411030 [pdf] - 92012
Constraints on the Formation History of the Elliptical Galaxy NGC 3923
from the Colors of Its Globular Clusters
Submitted: 1994-11-06
We present a study of the colors of globular clusters associated with the
elliptical galaxy NGC 3923. Our final sample consists of Washington system C
and T_1 photometry for 143 globular cluster candidates with an expected
contamination of no more than 10%. We find that the color distribution of the
NGC 3923 globular cluster system (GCS) is broad and appears to have at least
two peaks. A mixture modeling analysis of the color distribution indicates that
a two component model is favored over a single component one at a high level of
confidence (>99%). This evidence for more than one population in the GCS of NGC
3923 is similar to that previously noted for the four other elliptical galaxies
for which similar data have been published. Furthermore, we find that the NGC
3923 GCS is redder than the GCSs of previously studied elliptical galaxies of
similar luminosity. The median metallicity inferred from our (C-T_1)_0 colors
is [Fe/H]_{med} = -0.56, with an uncertainty of 0.14 dex arising from all
sources of uncertainty in the mean color. This is more metal rich than the
median metallicity found for the GCS of M87 using the same method, [Fe/H]_{med}
= -0.94. Since M87 is more luminous than NGC 3923, this result points to
significant scatter about any trend of higher GCS metallicity with increasing
galaxy luminosity. We also show that there is a color gradient in the NGC 3923
GCS corresponding to about -0.5 dex in Delta[Fe/H]\Delta(log r). We conclude
that the shape of the color distribution of individual GCSs and the variation
in mean color among the GCSs of ellipticals are difficult to understand if
elliptical galaxies are formed in a single protogalactic
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9408098 [pdf] - 91783
The Richness of the Globular Cluster System of NGC 3923: Clues to
Elliptical Galaxy Formation
Submitted: 1994-08-30
We present new data on the globular cluster system of the elliptical galaxy
NGC 3923 which show that it has the most globular clusters per unit luminosity
of any non-cluster elliptical yet observed, with $S_N=6.4 \pm1.4$. NGC 3923 is
also among the brightest ellipticals outside of a galaxy cluster for which the
number of globular clusters has been determined. Our observation of a large
number of clusters per unit luminosity (high $S_N$ value) for a bright
elliptical in a sparse environment is consistent with the suggestion of
Djorgovski \& Santiago that the number of globular clusters is a power law
function of the luminosity with an exponent greater than one. We relate this
higher specific frequency of globular clusters in more luminous galaxies to
other observations which indicate that the physical conditions within
elliptical galaxies at the time of their formation were dependent on galaxy
mass.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9408030 [pdf] - 91715
Detecting Bimodality in Astronomical Datasets
Submitted: 1994-08-10
We discuss statistical techniques for detecting and quantifying bimodality in
astronomical datasets. We concentrate on the KMM algorithm, which estimates the
statistical significance of bimodality in such datasets and objectively
partitions data into sub-populations. By simulating bimodal distributions with
a range of properties we investigate the sensitivity of KMM to datasets with
varying characteristics. Our results facilitate the planning of optimal
observing strategies for systems where bimodality is suspected.
Mixture-modeling algorithms similar to the KMM algorithm have been used in
previous studies to partition the stellar population of the Milky Way into
subsystems. We illustrate the broad applicability of KMM by analysing published
data on globular cluster metallicity distributions, velocity distributions of
galaxies in clusters, and burst durations of gamma-ray sources. PostScript
versions of the tables and figures, as well as FORTRAN code for KMM and
instructions for its use, are available by anonymous ftp from
kula.phsx.ukans.edu.