Normalized to: Araujo-Betancor, S.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:0704.1129 [pdf] - 236
SW Sextantis stars: the dominant population of CVs with orbital periods
between 3-4 hours
Rodriguez-Gil, P.;
Gaensicke, B. T.;
Hagen, H. -J.;
Araujo-Betancor, S.;
Aungwerojwit, A.;
Prieto, C. Allende;
Boyd, D.;
Casares, J.;
Engels, D.;
Giannakis, O.;
Harlaftis, E. T.;
Kube, J.;
Lehto, H.;
Martinez-Pais, I. G.;
Schwarz, R.;
Skidmore, W.;
Staude, A.;
Torres, M. A. P.
Submitted: 2007-04-09, last modified: 2007-04-11
[Abridged] We present time-series optical photometry of five new CVs
identified by the Hamburg Quasar Survey. The eclipses observed in HS 0129+2933,
HS 0220+0603, and HS 0455+8315 provided very accurate orbital periods of
3.35129827(65), 3.58098501(34), and 3.56937674(26) h, respectively. HS
0805+3822 shows grazing eclipses and has a likely orbital period of 3.2169(2)
h. Time-resolved optical spectroscopy of the new CVs (with the exception of HS
0805+3822) is also presented. Radial velocity studies provided an orbital
period of 3.55 h for HS 1813+6122, which allowed us to identify the observed
photometric signal at 3.39 h as a negative superhump wave. The spectroscopic
behaviour clearly identifies these new CVs as new SW Sextantis stars. These new
additions increase the number of known SW Sex stars to 35. Almost 40 per cent
of the total SW Sex population do not show eclipses, invalidating the
requirement of eclipses as a defining characteristic of the class and the
models based on a high orbital inclination geometry alone. On the other hand,
the predominance of orbital periods in the narrow 3-4.5 h range is becoming
more pronounced. In fact, almost half the CVs which populate the 3-4.5 h period
interval are definite members of the class. These statistics are confirmed by
our results from the Hamburg Quasar Survey CVs. Remarkably, 54 per cent of the
Hamburg nova-like variables have been identified as SW Sex stars with orbital
periods in the 3-4.5 h range. The observation of this pile-up of systems close
to the upper boundary of the period gap is difficult to reconcile with the
standard theory of CV evolution, as the SW Sex stars are believed to have the
highest mass transfer rates among CVs. Finally, we review the full range of
common properties that the SW Sex stars exhibit.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0605588 [pdf] - 82275
Dwarf novae in the Hamburg Quasar Survey: Rarer than expected
Aungwerojwit, A.;
Gaensicke, B. T.;
Rodriguez-Gil, P.;
Hagen, H. -J.;
Araujo-Betancor, S.;
Baernbantner, O.;
Engels, D.;
Fried, R. E.;
Harlaftis, E. T.;
Mislis, D.;
Nogami, D.;
Schmeer, P.;
Schwarz, R.;
Staude, A.;
Torres, M. A. P.
Submitted: 2006-05-23
We report the discovery of five new dwarf novae from the Hamburg Quasar
Survey (HQS), and discuss the properties of the sample of dwarf novae in the
HQS. The orbital periods of the new dwarf novae are ~105.1 min or ~109.9 min,
114.3+-2.7 min, 92.66+-0.17 min, 272.317+-0.001 min, 258.02+-0.56 min for
HS0417+7445, HS1016+3412, HS1340+1524, HS1857+7127, and HS2214+2845,
respectively. HS1857+7127 is found to be partially eclipsing. In HS2214+2845
the secondary star of spectral type M3+-1 is clearly detected, and we estimate
the distance to the system to be d=390+-40 pc. We recorded one superoutburst of
the SU UMa system HS0417+7445. HS1016+3412 and HS1340+1524 have rare outbursts,
and their subtype is yet undetermined. HS1857+7127 frequently varies in
brightness and may be a Z Cam-type dwarf nova. HS2214+2845 is a U Gem-type
dwarf nova with a most likely cycle length of 71 d. To date, 14 new dwarf novae
have been identified in the HQS. The ratio of short-period (<3 h) to
long-period (>3 h) systems of this sample is 1.3, much smaller compared to the
ratio of 2.7 found for all known dwarf novae. The HQS dwarf novae display
typically infrequent or low-amplitude outburst activity, underlining the
strength of spectroscopic selection in identifying new CVs independently of
their variability. The spectroscopic properties of short-period CVs in the HQS
suggest that most of them are still evolving towards the minimum period. Their
total number agrees with the predictions of population models within an order
of magnitude. However, the bulk of all CVs is predicted to have evolved past
the minimum period, and those systems remain unidentified. Those post-bounce
systems may have markedly weaker Hbeta emission lines compared to the average
known short-period CVs, and probably undergo no or extremely rare outbursts.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0510712 [pdf] - 77208
A ZZ Ceti white dwarf in SDSS J133941.11+484727.5
Gaensicke, B. T.;
Rodriguez-Gil, P.;
Marsh, T. R.;
de Martino, D.;
Nestoras, J.;
Szkody, P.;
Aungwerojwit, A.;
Barros, S. C. C.;
Dillon, M.;
Araujo-Betancor, S.;
Arevalo, M. J.;
Casares, J.;
Groot, P. J.;
Kolb, U.;
Lazaro, C.;
Hakala, P.;
Martinez-Pais, I. G.;
Nelemans, G.;
Roelofs, G.;
Schreiber, M. R.;
Besselaar, E. van den;
Zurita, C.
Submitted: 2005-10-25
We present time-resolved spectroscopy and photometry of the cataclysmic
variable (CV) SDSSJ133941.11+484727.5 (SDSS1339) which has been discovered in
the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Data Release 4. The orbital period determined from
radial velocity studies is 82.524(24)min, close to the observed period minimum.
The optical spectrum of SDSS1339 is dominated to 90% by emission from the white
dwarf. The spectrum can be successfully reproduced by a three-component model
(white dwarf, disc, secondary) with Twd=12500K for a fixed log g=8.0, d=170pc,
and a spectral type of the secondary later than M8. The mass transfer rate
corresponding to the optical luminosity of the accretion disc is very
low,~1.7x10^-13Msun/yr. Optical photometry reveals a coherent variability at
641s with an amplitude of 0.025mag, which we interpret as non-radial pulsations
of the white dwarf. In addition, a long-period photometric variation with a
period of either 320min or 344min and an amplitude of 0.025mag is detected,
which bears no apparent relation with the orbital period of the system. Similar
long-period photometric signals have been found in the CVs
SDSSJ123813.73-033933.0, SDSSJ204817.85-061044.8, GW Lib and FS Aur, but so far
no working model for this behaviour is available.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0507342 [pdf] - 74511
HS0139+0559, HS0229+8016, HS0506+7725 and HS0642+5049: Four new
long-period cataclysmic variables
Aungwerojwit, A.;
Gaensicke, B. T.;
Rodriguez-Gil, P.;
Hagen, H. -J.;
Harlaftis, E. T.;
Papadimitriou, C.;
Lehto, H.;
Araujo-Betancor, S.;
Heber, U.;
Fried, R. E.;
Engels, D.;
Katajainen, S.
Submitted: 2005-07-14
We present time-resolved optical spectroscopy and photometry of four
relatively bright (V~14.0-15.5) long-period cataclysmic variables (CVs)
discovered in the Hamburg Quasar Survey: HS0139+0559, HS0229+8016, HS0506+7725
and HS0642+5049. Their respective orbital periods, 243.69+-0.49min,
232.550+-0.049min, 212.7+-0.2min and 225.90+-0.23min are determined from radial
velocity and photometric variability studies. HS0506+7725 is characterised by
strong Balmer and He emission lines, short-period (~10-20min) flickering and
weak X-ray emission in the ROSAT All Sky Survey. The detection of a deep low
state (~18.5) identifies HS0506+7725 as a member of the VY Scl stars.
HS0139+0559, HS0229+8016 and HS0642+5049 display thick-disc like spectra and no
or only weak flickering activity. HS0139+0559 and HS0229+8016 exhibit clean
quasi-sinusoidal radial velocity varations of their emission lines but no or
very little orbital photometric variability. In contrast, we detect no radial
velocity variation in HS0642+5049 but a noticeable orbital brightness
variation. We identify all three systems either as UX UMa-type novalike
variables or as Z Cam-type dwarf novae. Our identification of these four new
systems underlines that the currently known sample of CVs is rather incomplete
even for bright objects. The four new systems add to the clustering of orbital
periods in the 3-4h range found in the sample of HQS selected CVs, and we
discuss the large incidence of magnetic CVs and VY Scl/SW Sex stars found in
this period range among the known population of CVs.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0506055 [pdf] - 73455
HS 0943+1404, a true intermediate polar
Rodriguez-Gil, P.;
Gaensicke, B. T.;
Hagen, H. -J.;
Nogami, D.;
Torres, M. A. P.;
Lehto, H.;
Aungwerojwit, A.;
Littlefair, S.;
Araujo-Betancor, S.;
Engels, D.
Submitted: 2005-06-02
We have identified a new intermediate polar, HS 0943+1404, as part of our
ongoing search for cataclysmic variables in the Hamburg Quasar Survey. The
orbital and white dwarf spin periods determined from time-resolved photometry
and spectroscopy are Porb ~= 250 min and Pspin = 69.171 +- 0.001 min,
respectively. The combination of a large ratio Pspin/Porb ~= 0.3 and a long
orbital period is very unusual compared to the other known intermediate polars.
The magnetic moment of the white dwarf is estimated to be mu1 ~ 10^{34} G cm^3,
which is in the typical range of polars. Our extensive photometry shows that HS
0943+1404 enters into deep (~ 3 mag) low states, which are also a
characteristic feature of polars. We therefore suggest that the system is a
true ``intermediate'' polar that will eventually synchronise, that is, a
transitional object between intermediate polars and polars. The optical
spectrum of HS 0943+1404 also exhibits a number of unusual emission lines, most
noticeably NII 5680, which is likely to reflect enhanced nitrogen abundances in
the envelope of the secondary.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0504460 [pdf] - 72557
Cataclysmic variables from a ROSAT/2MASS selection I: Four new
intermediate polars
Gaensicke, B. T.;
Marsh, T. R.;
Edge, A.;
Rodriguez-Gil, P.;
Steeghs, D.;
Araujo-Betancor, S.;
Harlaftis, E.;
Giannakis, O.;
Pyrzas, S.;
Morales-Rueda, L.;
Aungwerojwit, A.
Submitted: 2005-04-21
We report the first results from a new search for cataclysmic variables (CVs)
using a combined X-ray (ROSAT) / infrared (2MASS) target selection that
discriminates against background AGN. Identification spectra were obtained at
the Isaac Newton Telescope for a total of 174 targets, leading to the discovery
of 12 new CVs. Initially devised to find short-period low-mass-transfer CVs,
this selection scheme has been very successful in identifying new intermediate
polars. Photometric and spectroscopic follow-up observations identify four of
the new CVs as intermediate polars: 1RXSJ063631.9+353537 (Porb~201min,
Pspin=1008.3408s or 930.5829), 1RXSJ070407.9+262501 (Porb~250min,
Pspin=480.708s), 1RXSJ173021.5-055933 (Porb=925.27min, Pspin=128.0s), and
1RXSJ180340.0+401214 (Porb=160.21min, Pspin=1520.51s). RXJ1730, also a
moderately bright hard X-ray source in the INTEGRAL/IBIS Galactic plane survey,
resembles the enigmatic AE Aqr. It is likely that its white dwarf is not
rotating at the spin equilibrium period, and the system may represent a
short-lived phase in CV evolution.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0412180 [pdf] - 69584
Far-ultraviolet Spectroscopy of Magnetic Cataclysmic Variables
Submitted: 2004-12-08
We have obtained HST/STIS data for a total of eleven polars as part of a
program aimed to compile a homogeneous database of high-quality far-ultraviolet
(FUV) spectra for a large number of cataclysmic variables (CVs). Of the eleven
polars, eight were found in a state of low accretion activity (V347Pav, VVPup,
V834Cen, BLHyi, MRSer, STLMi, RXJ1554.2+2721 and V895Cen) and three in a state
of high activity (CDInd, ANUMa and UWPic). The STIS spectra of the low-state
polars unambiguously reveal the photospheric emission of their white dwarf (WD)
primaries. We have used pure hydrogen WD models to fit the FUV spectra of the
low-state systems (except RX J1554.2+2721, which is a high-field polar) in
order to measure the WD effective temperatures. In all cases, the fits could be
improved by adding a second component, which is presumably due to residual
accretion onto the magnetic pole of the WD. The WD temperatures obtained range
from 10800K to 14200K for log g = 8.0. Comparing the WD temperatures of polars
to those of non-magnetic CVs, we find that at any given orbital period the WDs
in polars are colder than those in non-magnetic CVs. The temperatures of polars
below the period gap are consistent with gravitational radiation as the only
active angular momentum loss mechanism. The differences in WD effective
temperatures between polars and non-magnetic CVs are significantly larger above
the period gap, suggesting that magnetic braking in polars might be reduced by
the strong field of the primary.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0410292 [pdf] - 68141
Time-Resolved Ultraviolet Spectroscopy of the SW Sex Star DW UMa:
Confirmation of a Hidden White Dwarf and the UV Counterpart to Phase 0.5
Absorption Events
Submitted: 2004-10-12
We present time-resolved, ultraviolet (UV) spectroscopy of the SW Sex star DW
UMa in the high state. We confirm that, shortward of 1500 \AA, the high-state,
UV continuum level is lower than the white dwarf (WD)-dominated low-state
level. We also do not see the WD contact phases in the high state eclipse light
curves. These results confirm our earlier finding that the WD in this system is
hidden from view in the high state. Based on this, we caution that eclipse
mapping of high-inclination SW Sex stars in the high state may yield incorrect
or misleading results. In the context of DW UMa, we demonstrate explicitly that
distance estimates obtained by recent eclipse mapping studies cannot be
reconciled with the WD-dominated low-state spectrum. We also show that the
fluxes of the UV emission lines in the high state drop near orbital phase 0.5.
This is the first detection of a UV counterpart to the class-defining phase 0.5
absorption seen in the optical emission lines of SW Sex stars.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0410223 [pdf] - 68073
HS2331+3905: The cataclysmic variable that has it all
Submitted: 2004-10-08
We report detailed follow-up observations of the cataclysmic variable
HS2331+3905, identified as an emission-line object in the Hamburg Quasar
Survey. An orbital period of 81.08min is unambiguously determined from the
detection of eclipses in the light curves of HS2331+3905. A second photometric
period is consistently detected at P~83.38min, ~2.8% longer than the orbital
period, which we tentatively relate to the presence of permanent superhumps.
High time resolution photometry exhibits short-timescale variability on time
scales of 5-6min which we interpret as non-radial white dwarf pulsations, as
well as a coherent signal at 1.12min, which is likely to be the white dwarf
spin period. A large-amplitude quasi-sinusoidal radial velocity modulation of
the Balmer and Helium lines with a period ~3.5h is persistently detected
throughout three seasons of time-resolved spectroscopy. However, this
spectroscopic period, which is in no way related to the orbital period, is not
strictly coherent but drifts in period and/or phase on time scales of a few
days. Modeling the far-ultraviolet to infrared spectral energy distribution of
HS2331+3905, we determine a white dwarf temperature of Teff=10500K (assuming
Mwd=0.6Msun), close to the ZZ Ceti instability strip of single white dwarfs.
The spectral model implies a distance of d=90+-15pc, and a low value for the
distance is supported by the large proper motion of the system, mu=0.14"/yr.
The non-detection of molecular bands and the low J, H, and K fluxes of
HS2331+3905 make this object a very likely candidate for a brown-dwarf donor.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0408057 [pdf] - 66548
Optical spectroscopy of flares from the black hole X-ray transient
A0620-00 in quiescence
Submitted: 2004-08-03
We present a time-resolved spectrophotometric study of the optical
variability in the quiescent soft X-ray transient A0620-00. Superimposed on the
double-humped continuum lightcurve are the well known flare events which last
tens of minutes. Some of the flare events that appear in the continuum
lightcurve are also present in the emission line lightcurves. From the Balmer
line flux and variations, we find that the persistent emission is optically
thin. During the flare event at phase 1.15 the Balmer decrement dropped
suggesting either a significant increase in temperature or that the flares are
more optically thick than the continuum. The data suggests that there are two
HI emitting regions, the accretion disc and the accretion stream/disc region,
with different Balmer decrements. The orbital modulation of H$\alpha$ with the
continuum suggests that the steeper decrement is most likely associated with
the stream/disc impact region. We construct Doppler images of the H$\alpha$ and
H$\beta$ emission lines. Apart from showing enhanced blurred emission at the
region where the stream impacts the accretion disc, the maps also show
significant extended structure from the opposite side of the disc. The trailed
spectra show characteristic S-wave features that can be interpreted in the
context of an eccentric accretion disc (abridged).
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0402270 [pdf] - 62784
The mysterious nature of HS2331+3905
Submitted: 2004-02-11
We report the discovery of one unique cataclysmic variable drawn from the
Hamburg Quasar Survey, HS2331+3905. Follow-up observations obtained over three
years unveiled a very unusual picture. The large amplitude 3.5 h radial
velocity variations obtained from our optical spectroscopy is not the orbital
period of the system, as one would normally expect. Instead, extensive CCD
photometry strongly suggests that HS2331+3905 is a short orbital period
cataclysmic variable with Porb = 81.09 min, containing a cold white dwarf which
appears to exhibit ZZ Ceti pulsations.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0402189 [pdf] - 62703
HS2237+8154: On the onset of mass transfer or entering the period gap?
Submitted: 2004-02-09
We report follow-up observations of a new white dwarf/red dwarf binary
HS2237+8154, identified as a blue variable star from the Hamburg Quasar Survey.
Ellipsoidal modulation observed in the R band as well as the Halpha radial
velocity variations measured from time-resolved spectroscopy determine the
orbital period to be Porb=178.10+-0.08min. The optical spectrum of HS2237+8154
is well described by a combination of a Teff=11500+-1500K white dwarf (assuming
log g=8) and a dM3.5+-0.5 secondary star. The distance implied from the flux
scaling factors of both stellar components is d=105+-25pc. Combining the
constraints obtained from the radial velocity of the secondary and from the
ellipsoidal modulation, we derive a binary inclination of i~50deg-70deg and
stellar masses of Mwd=0.47-0.67Msun and Msec=0.2-0.4Msun. All observations
imply that the secondary star must be nearly Roche-lobe filling. Consequently,
HS2237+8154 may be either a pre-cataclysmic variable close to the start of mass
transfer, or (considering its orbital period) a cataclysmic variable that
terminated mass transfer and entered the period gap, or a hibernating nova.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0312149 [pdf] - 61362
DW Cancri: a magnetic VY Scl star with an orbital period of 86 minutes
Submitted: 2003-12-05
We present the first time-resolved spectroscopic study of the cataclysmic
variable DW Cancri. We have determined an orbital period of 86.10 +- 0.05 min,
which places the system very close to the observed minimum period of
hydrogen-rich cataclysmic variables. This invalidates previous speculations of
DW Cnc being either a permanent superhumper below the period minimum or a
nova-like variable with an orbital period longer than 3 hours showing
quasi-periodic oscillations. The Balmer and HeI lines have double-peaked
profiles and exhibit an intense S-wave component moving with the orbital
period. Remarkably, the Balmer and HeI radial velocity curves are modulated at
two periods: 86.10 +- 0.05 min (orbital) and 38.58 +- 0.02 min. The same short
period is found in the equivalent width variations of the single-peaked HeII
4686 line. We also present time-resolved photometry of the system which shows a
highly-coherent variation at 38.51 min, consistent with the short spectroscopic
period. The large number of similarities with the short-period intermediate
polar V1025 Cen lead us to suggest that DW Cnc is another intermediate polar
below the period gap, and we tentatively identify the photometric and
spectroscopic 38-min signals with the white dwarf spin period. DW Cnc has never
been observed to undergo an outburst, but it occasionally exhibits low states
\~2 mag fainter than its typical brightness level of V~14.5, resembling the
behaviour of the high mass-transfer VY Scl stars.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0305270 [pdf] - 56743
1RXSJ062518.2+733433: A new intermediate polar
Submitted: 2003-05-15
We report the identification of the cataclysmic variable 1RXSJ062518.2+733433
as an intermediate polar. The orbital period of the system is determined to be
283.0+-2 min from the radial velocity variation of Halpha, measured in an
extensive set of time-resolved spectroscopy. Differential optical photometry
obtained over a base line of three weeks reveals the presence of coherent
variability with a period of 19.788+-0.002 min, which we suggest to be the
white dwarf spin period. The power spectrum of our photometry also contains a
strong signal near the spectroscopically determined orbital period. The
emission lines in 1RXSJ062518.2+733433 display a complex multicomponent
structure. In the trailed spectrogram of HeI 6678 we detect a narrow component
with a radial velocity semi-amplitude of ~140kms, consistent with a possible
origin on the irradiated face of the secondary. The absence of eclipses gives
an upper limit on the binary inclination of i<=60deg.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0210384 [pdf] - 52422
Discovery of 15-second oscillations in Hubble Space Telescope
observations of WZ Sagittae following the 2001 outburst
Submitted: 2002-10-17, last modified: 2002-10-28
We report the discovery of 15-s oscillations in ultraviolet observations of
WZ Sge obtained with the Hubble Space Telescope approximately one month after
the peak of the 2001 outburst. This is the earliest detection of oscillations
in WZ Sge following an outburst and the first time that a signal near 15 s has
been seen to be dominant. The oscillations are quite strong (amplitude about
5%), but not particularly coherent. In one instance, the oscillation period
changed by 0.7 s between successive observations separated by less than 1 hour.
We have also found evidence for weaker signals with periods near 6.5 s in some
of our data. We discuss the implications of our results for the models that
have been proposed to account for the 28-s oscillations seen in quiescence. If
the periods of the 15-s oscillations can be identified with the periods of
revolution of material rotating about the white dwarf, the mass of the white
dwarf must satisfy M_WD > 0.71 M_sun. The corresponding limit for the 6.5-s
signals is M_WD > 1.03 M_sun.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0209542 [pdf] - 51948
The system parameters of DW Ursae Majoris
Araujo-Betancor, S.;
Knigge, C.;
Long, K. S.;
Hoard, D. W.;
Szkody, P.;
Rodgers, B.;
Krisciunas, K.;
Dhillon, V. S.;
Hynes, R. I.;
Patterson, J.;
Kemp, J.
Submitted: 2002-09-25
We present new constraints on the system parameters of the SW Sextantis star
DW Ursae Majoris, based on ultraviolet (UV) eclipse observations with the
Hubble Space Telescope. Our data were obtained during a low state of the
system, in which the UV light was dominated by the hot white dwarf (WD)
primary. Eclipse analysis, using the full Roche lobe geometry, allows us to set
firm limits on the masses and radii of the system components and the distance
between them: 0.67 \leq M_1/M_sun \leq 1.06, 0.008 \leq R_1/R_sun \leq 0.014,
M_2/M_sun > 0.16, R_2/R_sun > 0.28 and a/R_sun > 1.05. For q = M_2/M_1 < 1.5
the inclination must satisfy i > 71 degrees. Using Smith & Dhillon's
mass-period relation for CV secondaries, our estimates for the system
parameters become M_1/M_sun = 0.77 \pm 0.07, R_1/R_sun = 0.012 \pm 0.001,
M_2/M_sun = 0.30 \pm 0.10, R_2/R_sun = 0.34 \pm 0.04, q =0.39 \pm 0.12, i = 82
\pm 4 degrees and a/R_sun = 1.14 \pm 0.06. We have also estimated the spectral
type of the secondary, M3.5 \pm 1.0, and distance to the system, d =930 \pm 160
pc, from time-resolved I- and K-band photometry. Finally, we have repeated
Knigge et al.'s WD model atmosphere fit to the low-state UV spectrum of DW UMa
in order to account for the higher surface gravity indicated by our eclipse
analysis. In this way we obtained a second estimate for the distance, d = 590
\pm 100 pc, which allows us to obtain a second estimate for the spectral type
of the secondary, M7 \pm 2.0. We conclude that the true value for the distance
and spectral type will probably be in between the values obtained by the two
methods.