Normalized to: Antiochos, S.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2004.00079 [pdf] - 2074060
Major Scientific Challenges and Opportunities in Understanding Magnetic
Reconnection and Related Explosive Phenomena throughout the Universe
Ji, H.;
Alt, A.;
Antiochos, S.;
Baalrud, S.;
Bale, S.;
Bellan, P. M.;
Begelman, M.;
Beresnyak, A.;
Blackman, E. G.;
Brennan, D.;
Brown, M.;
Buechner, J.;
Burch, J.;
Cassak, P.;
Chen, L. -J.;
Chen, Y.;
Chien, A.;
Craig, D.;
Dahlin, J.;
Daughton, W.;
DeLuca, E.;
Dong, C. F.;
Dorfman, S.;
Drake, J.;
Ebrahimi, F.;
Egedal, J.;
Ergun, R.;
Eyink, G.;
Fan, Y.;
Fiksel, G.;
Forest, C.;
Fox, W.;
Froula, D.;
Fujimoto, K.;
Gao, L.;
Genestreti, K.;
Gibson, S.;
Goldstein, M.;
Guo, F.;
Hesse, M.;
Hoshino, M.;
Hu, Q.;
Huang, Y. -M.;
Jara-Almonte, J.;
Karimabadi, H.;
Klimchuk, J.;
Kunz, M.;
Kusano, K.;
Lazarian, A.;
Le, A.;
Li, H.;
Li, X.;
Lin, Y.;
Linton, M.;
Liu, Y. -H.;
Liu, W.;
Longcope, D.;
Loureiro, N.;
Lu, Q. -M.;
Ma, Z-W.;
Matthaeus, W. H.;
Meyerhofer, D.;
Mozer, F.;
Munsat, T.;
Murphy, N. A.;
Nilson, P.;
Ono, Y.;
Opher, M.;
Park, H.;
Parker, S.;
Petropoulou, M.;
Phan, T.;
Prager, S.;
Rempel, M.;
Ren, C.;
Ren, Y.;
Rosner, R.;
Roytershteyn, V.;
Sarff, J.;
Savcheva, A.;
Schaffner, D.;
Schoeffier, K.;
Scime, E.;
Shay, M.;
Sitnov, M.;
Stanier, A.;
TenBarge, J.;
Tharp, T.;
Uzdensky, D.;
Vaivads, A.;
Velli, M.;
Vishniac, E.;
Wang, H.;
Werner, G.;
Xiao, C.;
Yamada, M.;
Yokoyama, T.;
Yoo, J.;
Zenitani, S.;
Zweibel, E.
Submitted: 2020-03-31
This white paper summarizes major scientific challenges and opportunities in
understanding magnetic reconnection and related explosive phenomena as a
fundamental plasma process.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:1905.13218 [pdf] - 1972686
A Model for Energy Buildup and Eruption Onset in Coronal Mass Ejections
Submitted: 2019-05-30, last modified: 2019-10-01
Coronal mass ejections (CMEs) and eruptive flares (EFs) are the most
energetic explosions in the solar system. Their underlying origin is the free
energy that builds up slowly in the sheared magnetic field of a filament
channel. We report the first end-to-end numerical simulation of a CME/EF, from
zero-free-energy initial state through filament-channel formation to violent
eruption, driven solely by the magnetic-helicity condensation process. Helicity
is the topological measure of linkages between magnetic flux systems, and is
conserved in the corona, building up inexorably until it is ejected into
interplanetary space. Numerous investigations have demonstrated that helicity
injected by small-scale vortical motions, such as those observed in the
photosphere, undergoes an inverse cascade from small scales to large,
`condensing' at magnetic-polarity boundaries. Our new results verify that this
process forms a filament channel within a compact bipolar region embedded in a
background dipole field, and show for the first time that a fast CME eventually
occurs via the magnetic-breakout mechanism. We further show that the trigger
for explosive eruption is reconnection onset in the flare current sheet that
develops above the polarity inversion line: this reconnection forms flare loops
below the sheet and a CME flux rope above, and initiates high-speed outward
flow of the CME. Our findings have important implications for magnetic
self-organization and explosive behavior in solar and other astrophysical
plasmas, and for understanding and predicting explosive solar activity.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1909.13578 [pdf] - 1994271
Escape of Flare-accelerated Particles in Solar Eruptive Events
Submitted: 2019-09-30
Impulsive solar energetic particle events are widely believed to be due to
the prompt escape into the interplanetary medium of flare-accelerated particles
produced by solar eruptive events. According to the standard model for such
events, however, particles accelerated by the flare reconnection should remain
trapped in the flux rope comprising the coronal mass ejection. The particles
should reach the Earth only much later, along with the bulk ejecta. To resolve
this paradox, we have extended our previous axisymmetric model for the escape
of flare-accelerated particles to fully three-dimensional (3D) geometries. We
report the results of magnetohydrodynamic simulations of a coronal system that
consists of a bipolar active region embedded in a background global dipole
field structured by solar wind. Our simulations show that multiple magnetic
reconnection episodes occur prior to and during the CME eruption and its
interplanetary propagation. In addition to the episodes that build up the flux
rope, reconnection between the open field and the CME couples the closed corona
to the open interplanetary field. Flare-accelerated particles initially trapped
in the CME thereby gain access to the open interplanetary field along a trail
blazed by magnetic reconnection. A key difference between these 3D results and
our previous calculations is that the interchange reconnection allows
accelerated particles to escape from deep within the CME flux-rope. We estimate
the spatial extent of the particle-escape channels. The relative timings
between flare acceleration and release of the energetic particles through
CME/open-field coupling are also determined. All our results compare favourably
with observations.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:1909.09423 [pdf] - 1975466
Numerical Simulation of Helical Jets at Active Region Peripheries
Submitted: 2019-09-20
Coronal jets are observed above minority polarity intrusions throughout the
solar corona. Some of the most energetic occur on the periphery of active
regions where the magnetic field is strongly inclined. These jets exhibit a
non-radial propagation in the low corona as they follow the inclined field, and
often have a broad, helical shape. We present a three-dimensional
magnetohydrodynamic simulation of such an active-region-periphery helical jet.
We consider an initially potential field with a bipolar flux distribution
embedded in a highly inclined magnetic field, representative of the field
nearby an active region. The flux of the minority polarity sits below a
bald-patch separatrix initially. Surface motions are used to inject free energy
into the closed field beneath the separatrix, forming a sigmoidal flux rope
which eventually erupts producing a helical jet. We find that a null point
replaces the bald patch early in the evolution and that the eruption results
from a combination of magnetic breakout and an ideal kinking of the erupting
flux rope. We discuss how the two mechanisms are coupled, and compare our
results with previous simulations of coronal-hole jets. This comparison
supports the hypothesis that the generic mechanism for all coronal jets is a
coupling between breakout reconnection and an ideal instability. We further
show that our results are in good qualitative and quantitative agreement with
observations of active-region periphery jets.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1909.06637 [pdf] - 1996747
First Detection of Plasmoids from Breakout Reconnection on the Sun
Submitted: 2019-09-14
Transient collimated plasma ejections (jets) occur frequently throughout the
solar corona, in active regions, quiet Sun, and coronal holes. Although
magnetic reconnection is generally agreed to be the mechanism of energy release
in jets, the factors that dictate the location and rate of reconnection remain
unclear. Our previous studies demonstrated that the magnetic breakout model
explains the triggering and evolution of most jets over a wide range of scales,
through detailed comparisons between our numerical simulations and
high-resolution observations. An alternative explanation, the resistive-kink
model, invokes breakout reconnection without forming and explosively expelling
a flux rope. Here we report direct observations of breakout reconnection and
plasmoid formation during two jets in the fan-spine topology of an embedded
bipole. For the first time, we observed the formation and evolution of multiple
small plasmoids with bidirectional flows associated with fast reconnection in
3D breakout current sheets in the solar corona. The first narrow jet was
launched by reconnection at the breakout current sheet originating at the
deformed 3D null, without significant flare reconnection or a filament
eruption. In contrast, the second jet and release of cool filament plasma were
triggered by explosive breakout reconnection when the leading edge of the
rising flux rope formed by flare reconnection beneath the filament encountered
the preexisting breakout current sheet. These observations solidly support both
reconnection-driven jet models: the resistive kink for the first jet, and the
breakout model for the second explosive jet with a filament eruption.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1909.03768 [pdf] - 1967071
The Role of Magnetic Helicity in Coronal Heating
Submitted: 2019-09-09
One of the greatest challenges in solar physics is understanding the heating
of the Sun's corona. Most theories for coronal heating postulate that free
energy in the form of magnetic twist/stress is injected by the photosphere into
the corona where the free energy is converted into heat either through
reconnection or wave dissipation. The magnetic helicity associated with the
twist/stress, however, is expected to be conserved and appear in the corona. In
previous work we showed that helicity associated with the small-scale twists
undergoes an inverse cascade via stochastic reconnection in the corona, and
ends up as the observed large-scale shear of filament channels. Our ``helicity
condensation'' model accounts for both the formation of filament channels and
the observed smooth, laminar structure of coronal loops. In this paper, we
demonstrate, using helicity- and energy-conserving numerical simulations of a
coronal system driven by photospheric motions, that the model also provides a
natural mechanism for heating the corona. We show that the heat generated by
the reconnection responsible for the helicity condensation process is
sufficient to account for the observed coronal heating. We study the role that
helicity injection plays in determining coronal heating and find that,
crucially, the heating rate is only weakly dependent on the net helicity
preference of the photospheric driving. Our calculations demonstrate that
motions with 100\% helicity preference are least efficient at heating the
corona; those with 0\% preference are most efficient. We discuss the physical
origins of this result and its implications for the observed corona.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1907.10598 [pdf] - 1966894
Determining the Transport of Magnetic Helicity and Free Energy in the
Sun's Atmosphere
Submitted: 2019-07-24
The most important factors determining solar coronal activity are believed to
be the availability of magnetic free energy and the constraint of magnetic
helicity conservation. Direct measurements of the helicity and magnetic free
energy in the coronal volume are difficult, but their values may be estimated
from measurements of the helicity and free energy transport rates through the
photosphere. We examine these transport rates for a topologically open system
such as the corona, in which the magnetic fields have a nonzero normal
component at the boundaries, and derive a new formula for the helicity
transport rate at the boundaries. In addition, we derive new expressions for
helicity transport due to flux emergence/submergence versus photospheric
horizontal motions. The key feature of our formulas is that they are manifestly
gauge invariant. Our results are somewhat counterintuitive in that only the
lamellar electric field produced by the surface potential transports helicity
across boundaries, and the solenoidal electric field produced by a surface
stream function does not contribute to the helicity transport. We discuss the
physical interpretation of this result. Furthermore, we derive an expression
for the free energy transport rate and show that a necessary condition for free
energy transport across a boundary is the presence of a closed magnetic field
at the surface, indicating that there are current systems within the volume. We
discuss the implications of these results for using photospheric vector
magnetic and velocity field measurements to derive the solar coronal helicity
and magnetic free energy, which can then be used to constrain and drive models
for coronal activity.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1904.08982 [pdf] - 1870258
Observations of Solar Coronal Rain in Null Point Topologies
Submitted: 2019-04-18
Coronal rain is the well-known phenomenon in which hot plasma high in the
Sun's corona undergoes rapid cooling (from > 10^6 K to < 10^4 K), condenses,
and falls to the surface. Coronal rain appears frequently in active region
coronal loops and is very common in post-flare loops. This Letter presents
discovery observations, which show that coronal rain is ubiquitous in the
embedded bipole very near a coronal hole boundary. Our observed structures
formed when the photospheric decay of active region leading sunspots resulted
in a large parasitic polarity embedded in a background unipolar region. We
observe coronal rain to appear within the legs of closed loops well under the
fan surface, as well as preferentially near separatrices of the resulting
coronal topology: the spine lines, null point, and fan surface. We analyze 3
events using SDO Atmospheric Imaging Assembly (AIA) observations in the 304,
171, and 211 {/AA} channels, as well as SDO Helioseismic and Magnetic Imager
(HMI) magnetograms. The frequency of rain formation and the ease with which it
is observed strongly suggests that this phenomenon is generally present in
null-point topologies of this size scale. We argue that these rain events could
be explained by the classic process of thermal nonequilibrium or via
interchange reconnection at the null; it is also possible that both mechanisms
are present. Further studies with higher spatial resolution data and MHD
simulations will be required to determine the exact mechanism(s).
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1902.00922 [pdf] - 1851679
Multiwavelength Study of Equatorial Coronal-Hole Jets
Submitted: 2019-02-03
Jets (transient/collimated plasma ejections) occur frequently throughout the
solar corona and contribute mass/energy to the corona and solar wind. By
combining numerical simulations and high-resolution observations, we have made
substantial progress recently on determining the energy buildup and release
processes in these jets. Here we describe a study of 27 equatorial coronal-hole
jets using Solar Dynamics Observatory/AIA and HMI observations on 2013 June
27-28 and 2014 January 8-10. Out of 27 jets, 18 (67%) are associated with
mini-filament ejections; the other 9 (33%) do not show mini-filament eruptions
but do exhibit mini-flare arcades and other eruptive signatures. This indicates
that every jet in our sample involved a filament-channel eruption. From the
complete set of events, 6 jets (22%) are apparently associated with tiny
flux-cancellation events at the polarity inversion line, and 2 jets (7%) are
associated with sympathetic eruptions of filaments from neighboring bright
points. Potential-field extrapolations of the source-region photospheric
magnetic fields reveal that all jets originated in the fan-spine topology of an
embedded bipole associated with an extreme ultraviolet coronal bright point.
Hence, all our jets are in agreement with the breakout model of solar
eruptions. We present selected examples and discuss the implications for the
jet energy build-up and initiation mechanisms.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1808.03688 [pdf] - 1751962
A Model for Coronal Hole Bright Points and Jets due to Moving Magnetic
Elements
Submitted: 2018-08-10
Coronal jets and bright points occur prolifically in predominantly unipolar
magnetic regions, such as coronal holes, where they appear above
minority-polarity intrusions. Intermittent low-level reconnection and
explosive, high-energy-release reconnection above these intrusions are thought
to generate bright points and jets, respectively. The magnetic field above the
intrusions possesses a spine-fan topology with a coronal null point. The
movement of magnetic flux by surface convection adds free energy to this field,
forming current sheets and inducing reconnection. We conducted
three-dimensional magnetohydrodynamic simulations of moving magnetic elements
as a model for coronal jets and bright points. A single minority-polarity
concentration was subjected to three different experiments: a large-scale
surface flow that sheared part of the separatrix surface only, a large-scale
surface flow that also sheared part of the polarity inversion line surrounding
the minority flux, and the latter flow setup plus a "fly-by" of a
majority-polarity concentration past the moving minority-polarity element. We
found that different bright-point morphologies, from simple loops to sigmoids,
were created. When only the field near the separatrix was sheared, steady
interchange reconnection modulated by quasi-periodic, low-intensity bursts of
reconnection occurred, suggestive of a bright point with periodically varying
intensity. When the field near the PIL was strongly sheared, on the other hand,
filament channels repeatedly formed and erupted via the breakout mechanism,
explosively increasing the interchange reconnection and generating non-helical
jets. The fly-by produced even more energetic and explosive jets. Our results
explain several key aspects of coronal-hole bright points and jets, and the
relationships between them.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1801.08582 [pdf] - 1641466
Evidence For The Magnetic Breakout Model in an Equatorial Coronal-Hole
Jet
Submitted: 2018-01-25
Small, impulsive jets commonly occur throughout the solar corona, but are
especially visible in coronal holes. Evidence is mounting that jets are part of
a continuum of eruptions that extends to much larger coronal mass ejections and
eruptive flares. Because coronal-hole jets originate in relatively simple
magnetic structures, they offer an ideal testbed for theories of energy buildup
and release in the full range of solar eruptions. We analyzed an equatorial
coronal-hole jet observed by SDO/AIA on 09 January 2014, in which the
magnetic-field structure was consistent with the embedded-bipole topology that
we identified and modeled previously as an origin of coronal jets. In addition,
this event contained a mini-filament, which led to important insights into the
energy storage and release mechanisms. SDO/HMI magnetograms revealed footpoint
motions in the primary minority-polarity region at the eruption site, but show
negligible flux emergence or cancellation for at least 16 hours before the
eruption. Therefore, the free energy powering this jet probably came from
magnetic shear concentrated at the polarity inversion line within the embedded
bipole. We find that the observed activity sequence and its interpretation
closely match the predictions of the breakout jet model, strongly supporting
the hypothesis that the breakout model can explain solar eruptions on a wide
range of scales.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1712.00134 [pdf] - 1622363
A Breakout Model for Solar Coronal Jets with Filaments
Submitted: 2017-11-30, last modified: 2017-12-08
Recent observations have revealed that many solar coronal jets involve the
eruption of miniature versions of large-scale filaments. Such "mini-filaments"
are observed to form along the polarity inversion lines of strong, magnetically
bipolar regions embedded in open (or distantly closing) unipolar field. During
the generation of the jet, the filament becomes unstable and erupts. Recently
we described a model for these mini-filament jets, in which the well-known
magnetic-breakout mechanism for large-scale coronal mass ejections is extended
to these smaller events. In this work we use three-dimensional
magnetohydrodynamic simulations to study in detail three realisations of the
model. We show that the breakout-jet generation mechanism is robust and that
different realisations of the model can explain different observational
features. The results are discussed in relation to recent observations and
previous jet models.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1711.00166 [pdf] - 1605056
The Mechanism for the Energy Buildup Driving Solar Eruptive Events
Submitted: 2017-10-31
The underlying origin of solar eruptive events (SEEs), ranging from giant
coronal mass ejections to small coronal-hole jets, is that the lowest-lying
magnetic flux in the Sun's corona undergoes the continual buildup of stress and
free energy. This magnetic stress has long been observed as the phenomenon of
"filament channels:" strongly sheared magnetic field localized around
photospheric polarity inversion lines. However, the mechanism for the stress
buildup - the formation of filament channels - is still debated. We present
magnetohydrodynamic simulations of a coronal volume that is driven by
transient, cellular boundary flows designed to model the processes by which the
photosphere drives the corona. The key feature of our simulations is that they
accurately preserve magnetic helicity, the topological quantity that is
conserved even in the presence of ubiquitous magnetic reconnection. Although
small-scale random stress is injected everywhere at the photosphere, driving
stochastic reconnection throughout the corona, the net result of the magnetic
evolution is a coherent shearing of the lowest-lying field lines. This highly
counter-intuitive result - magnetic stress builds up locally rather than
spreading out to attain a minimum energy state - explains the formation of
filament channels and is the fundamental mechanism underlying SEEs.
Furthermore, this mechanism may be relevant to other astrophysical or
laboratory plasmas.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1611.04968 [pdf] - 1580608
Dynamics of Coronal-Hole Boundaries
Submitted: 2016-11-15, last modified: 2017-05-24
Remote and in-situ observations strongly imply that the slow solar wind
consists of plasma from the hot, closed-field corona that is released onto open
magnetic field lines. The Separatrix Web (S-Web) theory for the slow wind
proposes that photospheric motions, at the scale of supergranules, are
responsible for generating dynamics at coronal-hole boundaries, which result in
the closed plasma release. We use three-dimensional magnetohydrodynamic (3D
MHD) simulations to determine the effect of photospheric flows on the open and
closed magnetic flux of a model corona with a dipole magnetic field and an
isothermal solar wind. A rotational surface motion is used to approximate
photospheric supergranular driving and is applied at the boundary between the
coronal hole and helmet streamer. The resulting dynamics consist primarily of
prolific and efficient interchange reconnection between open and closed flux.
Magnetic flux near the coronal-hole boundary experiences multiple interchange
events, with some flux interchanging over fifty times in one day. Additionally,
we find that the interchange reconnection occurs all along the coronal-hole
boundary, even producing a lasting change in magnetic-field connectivity in
regions that were not driven by the applied motions. Our results show that
these dynamics should be ubiquitous in the Sun and heliosphere. We discuss the
implications of our simulations for understanding the observed properties of
the slow solar wind, with particular focus on the global-scale consequences of
interchange reconnection.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1701.08797 [pdf] - 1574629
The Formation of Heliospheric Arcs of Slow Solar Wind
Submitted: 2017-01-30, last modified: 2017-04-26
A major challenge in solar and heliospheric physics is understanding how
highly localized regions, far smaller than 1 degree at the Sun, are the source
of solar-wind structures spanning more than 20 degrees near Earth. The Sun's
atmosphere is divided into magnetically open regions, coronal holes, where
solar-wind plasma streams out freely and fills the solar system, and closed
regions, where the plasma is confined to coronal loops. The boundary between
these regions extends outward as the heliospheric current sheet (HCS).
Measurements of plasma composition imply that the solar wind near the HCS, the
so-called slow solar wind, originates in closed regions, presumably by the
processes of field-line opening or interchange reconnection. Mysteriously,
however, slow wind is also often seen far from the HCS. We use high-resolution,
three-dimensional magnetohydrodynamic simulations to calculate the dynamics of
a coronal hole whose geometry includes a narrow corridor flanked by closed
field and which is driven by supergranule-like flows at the coronal-hole
boundary. We find that these dynamics result in the formation of giant arcs of
closed-field plasma that extend far from the HCS and span tens of degrees in
latitude and longitude at Earth, accounting for the slow solar wind
observations.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1612.08323 [pdf] - 1533852
A model for stealth coronal mass ejections
Submitted: 2016-12-25
Stealth coronal mass ejections (CMEs) are events in which there are almost no
observable signatures of the CME eruption in the low corona but often a
well-resolved slow flux rope CME observed in the coronagraph data. We present
results from a three-dimensional numerical magnetohydrodynamics (MHD)
simulation of the 1--2 June 2008 slow streamer blowout CME that Robbrecht et
al. (2009) called "the CME from nowhere." We model the global coronal structure
using a 1.4 MK isothermal solar wind and a low-order potential field source
surface representation of the Carrington Rotation 2070 magnetogram synoptic
map. The bipolar streamer belt arcade is energized by simple shearing flows
applied in the vicinity of the helmet streamer's polarity inversion line. The
flows are large scale and impart a shear typical of that expected from the
differential rotation. The slow expansion of the energized helmet streamer
arcade results in the formation of a radial current sheet. The subsequent onset
of expansion-induced flare reconnection initiates the stealth CME while
gradually releasing the stored magnetic energy. We present favorable
comparisons between our simulation results and the multiviewpoint SOHO-LASCO
(Large Angle and Spectrometric Coronagraph) and STEREO-SECCHI (Sun Earth
Connection Coronal and Heliospheric Investigation) coronagraph observations of
the preeruption streamer structure and the initiation and evolution of the
stealth streamer blowout CME.
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1609.08825 [pdf] - 1523859
A model for straight and helical solar jets: II. Parametric study of the
plasma beta
Submitted: 2016-09-28
Jets are dynamic, impulsive, well-collimated plasma events that develop at
many different scales and in different layers of the solar atmosphere.
Jets are believed to be induced by magnetic reconnection, a process central
to many astrophysical phenomena. Within the solar atmosphere, jet-like events
develop in many different environments, e.g., in the vicinity of active regions
as well as in coronal holes, and at various scales, from small photospheric
spicules to large coronal jets. In all these events, signatures of helical
structure and/or twisting/rotating motions are regularly observed. The present
study aims to establish that a single model can generally reproduce the
observed properties of these jet-like events.
In this study, using our state-of-the-art numerical solver ARMS, we present a
parametric study of a numerical tridimensional magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) model
of solar jet-like events. Within the MHD paradigm, we study the impact of
varying the atmospheric plasma $\beta$ on the generation and properties of
solar-like jets.
The parametric study validates our model of jets for plasma $\beta$ ranging
from $10^{-3}$ to $1$, typical of the different layers and magnetic
environments of the solar atmosphere. Our model of jets can robustly explain
the generation of helical solar jet-like events at various $\beta \le 1$. This
study introduces the new result that the plasma $\beta$ modifies the morphology
of the helical jet, explaining the different observed shapes of jets at
different scales and in different layers of the solar atmosphere.
Our results allow us to understand the energisation, triggering, and driving
processes of jet-like events. Our model allows us to make predictions of the
impulsiveness and energetics of jets as determined by the surrounding
environment, as well as the morphological properties of the resulting jets.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1607.06756 [pdf] - 1531090
The Role of Magnetic Helicity in Structuring the Solar Corona
Submitted: 2016-07-22, last modified: 2016-07-27
Two of the most widely observed and yet most puzzling features of the Sun's
magnetic field are coronal loops that are smooth and laminar and
prominences/filaments that are strongly sheared. These two features would seem
to be quite unrelated in that the loops are near their minimum-energy
current-free state, whereas filaments are regions of high magnetic stress and
intense electric currents. We argue that, in fact, these two features are
inextricably linked in that both are due to a single process: the injection of
magnetic helicity into the corona by photospheric motions and the subsequent
evolution of this helicity by coronal reconnection. In this paper, we present
numerical simulations of the response of a \citet{Parker72} corona to
photospheric driving motions that have varying degrees of helicity preference.
We obtain four main conclusions: 1) in agreement with the helicity condensation
model of \citet{Antiochos13}, the inverse cascade of helicity by magnetic
reconnection results in the formation of prominences/filaments localized about
polarity inversion lines (PILs); 2) this same process removes most structure
from the rest of the corona, resulting in smooth and laminar coronal loops; 3)
the amount of remnant tangling in coronal loops is inversely dependent on the
net helicity injected by the driving motions; and 4) the structure of the solar
corona depends only on the helicity preference of the driving motions and not
on their detailed time dependence. We discuss the implications of our results
for high-resolution observations of the corona.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1606.09201 [pdf] - 1530914
Reconnection-Driven Coronal-Hole Jets with Gravity and Solar Wind
Submitted: 2016-06-29
Coronal-hole jets occur ubiquitously in solar coronal holes, at EUV and X-ray
bright points associated with intrusions of minority magnetic polarity. The
embedded-bipole model for these jets posits that they are driven by explosive,
fast reconnection between the stressed closed field of the embedded bipole and
the open field of the surrounding coronal hole. Previous numerical studies in
Cartesian geometry, assuming uniform ambient magnetic field and plasma while
neglecting gravity and solar wind, demonstrated that the model is robust and
can produce jet-like events in simple configurations. We have extended these
investigations by including spherical geometry, gravity, and solar wind in a
nonuniform, coronal hole-like ambient atmosphere. Our simulations confirm that
the jet is initiated by the onset of a kink-like instability of the internal
closed field, which induces a burst of reconnection between the closed and
external open field, launching a helical jet. Our new results demonstrate that
the jet propagation is sustained through the outer corona, in the form of a
traveling nonlinear Alfven wave front trailed by slower-moving plasma density
enhancements that are compressed and accelerated by the wave. This finding
agrees well with observations of white-light coronal-hole jets, and can explain
microstreams and torsional Alfven waves detected in situ in the solar wind. We
also use our numerical results to deduce scaling relationships between
properties of the coronal source region and the characteristics of the
resulting jet, which can be tested against observations.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1511.06500 [pdf] - 1415010
Achieving Consistent Doppler Measurements from SDO/HMI Vector Field
Inversions
Submitted: 2015-11-20
NASA's Solar Dynamics Observatory is delivering vector field observations of
the full solar disk with unprecedented temporal and spatial resolution;
however, the satellite is in a highly inclined geostationary orbit. The
relative spacecraft-Sun velocity varies by $\pm3$~km/s over a day which
introduces major orbital artifacts in the Helioseismic Magnetic Imager data. We
demonstrate that the orbital artifacts contaminate all spatial and temporal
scales in the data. We describe a newly-developed three stage procedure for
mitigating these artifacts in the Doppler data derived from the Milne-Eddington
inversions in the HMI Pipeline. This procedure was applied to full disk images
of AR11084 to produce consistent Dopplergrams. The data adjustments reduce the
power in the orbital artifacts by 31dB. Furthermore, we analyze in detail the
corrected images and show that our procedure greatly improve the temporal and
spectral properties of the data without adding any new artifacts. We conclude
that this new and easily implemented procedure makes a dramatic improvement in
the consistency of the HMI data and in its usefulness for precision scientific
studies.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:1412.7378 [pdf] - 913197
Structures in the outer solar atmosphere
Submitted: 2014-12-23
The structure and dynamics of the outer solar atmosphere are reviewed with
emphasis on the role played by the magnetic field. Contemporary observations
that focus on high resolution imaging over a range of temperatures, as well as
UV, EUV and hard X-ray spectroscopy, demonstrate the presence of a vast range
of temporal and spatial scales, mass motions, and particle energies present. By
focussing on recent developments in the chromosphere, corona and solar wind, it
is shown that small scale processes, in particular magnetic reconnection, play
a central role in determining the large-scale structure and properties of all
regions. This coupling of scales is central to understanding the atmosphere,
yet poses formidable challenges for theoretical models.
[22]
oai:arXiv.org:1411.5396 [pdf] - 1265612
Filament Channel Formation Via Magnetic Helicity Condensation
Submitted: 2014-11-19
A major unexplained feature of the solar atmosphere is the accumulation of
magnetic shear, in the form of filament channels, at photospheric polarity
inversion lines (PILs). In addition to free energy, this shear also represents
magnetic helicity, which is conserved under reconnection. In this paper, we
address the problem of filament channel formation and show how they acquire
their shear and magnetic helicity. The results of 3D simulations using the
Adaptively Refined Magnetohydrodynamics Solver (ARMS) are presented that
support the model of filament channel formation by magnetic helicity
condensation developed by \citet{Antiochos13}. We consider the supergranular
twisting of a quasi-potential flux system that is bounded by a PIL and contains
a coronal hole (CH). The magnetic helicity injected by the small-scale
photospheric motions is shown to inverse-cascade up to the largest allowable
scales that define the closed flux system: the PIL and the CH. This process
produces field lines that are both sheared and smooth, and are sheared in
opposite senses at the PIL and the CH. The accumulated helicity and shear flux
are shown to be in excellent quantitative agreement with the
helicity-condensation model. We present a detailed analysis of the simulations,
including comparisons of our analytical and numerical results, and discuss
their implications for observations.
[23]
oai:arXiv.org:1402.2645 [pdf] - 1203302
Simulations of Emerging Magnetic Flux. II: The formation of Unstable
Coronal Flux Ropes and the Initiation of CMEs
Submitted: 2014-02-07, last modified: 2014-03-26
We present results from 3D magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) simulations of the
emergence of a twisted convection zone flux tube into a pre-existing coronal
dipole field. As in previous simulations, following the partial emergence of
the sub-surface flux into the corona, a combination of vortical motions and
internal magnetic reconnection forms a coronal flux rope. Then, in the
simulations presented here, external reconnection between the emerging field
and the pre-existing dipole coronal field allows further expansion of the
coronal flux rope into the corona. After sufficient expansion, internal
reconnection occurs beneath the coronal flux rope axis, and the flux rope
erupts up to the top boundary of the simulation domain ($\sim$ 36 Mm above the
surface). We find that the presence of a pre-existing field, orientated in a
direction to facilitate reconnection with the emerging field, is vital to the
fast rise of the coronal flux rope. The simulations shown in this paper are
able to self-consistently create many of the surface and coronal signatures
used by coronal mass ejection (CME) models. These signatures include: surface
shearing and rotational motions; quadrupolar geometry above the surface;
central sheared arcades reconnecting with oppositely orientated overlying
dipole fields; the formation of coronal flux ropes underlying potential coronal
field; and internal reconnection which resembles the classical flare
reconnection scenario. This suggests that proposed mechanisms for the
initiation of a CME, such as "magnetic breakout", are operating during the
emergence of new active regions.
[24]
oai:arXiv.org:1301.0654 [pdf] - 1158818
A Model for the Escape of Solar-Flare Accelerated Particles
Submitted: 2013-01-03, last modified: 2013-06-12
We address the problem of how particles that are accelerated by solar flares
can escape promptly into the heliosphere, on time scales of an hour or less.
Impulsive solar energetic particles (SEP) bursts are generally observed in
association with so-called eruptive flares consisting of a coronal mass
ejection (CME) and a flare. These highly prompt SEPs are believed to be
accelerated directly by the flare, rather than by the CME shock, although the
precise mechanism by which the particles are accelerated remains controversial.
Whatever their origin, within the magnetic geometry of the standard
eruptive-flare model, the accelerated particles should remain trapped in the
closed magnetic fields of the coronal flare loops and the ejected flux rope. In
this case the particles would reach the Earth only after a delay of many hours
to a few days, when the bulk ejecta arrive at Earth. We propose that the
external magnetic reconnection intrinsic to the breakout model for CME
initiation can naturally account for the prompt escape of flare-accelerated
energetic particles onto open interplanetary magnetic flux tubes. We present
detailed 2.5D MHD simulations of a breakout CME/flare event with a background
isothermal solar wind. Our calculations demonstrate that if the event occurs
sufficiently near a coronal-hole boundary, interchange reconnection between
open and closed field can occur, which allows particles from deep inside the
ejected flux rope to access solar wind field lines soon after eruption. We
compare these results with the standard observations of impulsive SEPs and
discuss the implications of the model for further observations and
calculations.
[25]
oai:arXiv.org:1211.4132 [pdf] - 1157876
Helicity Condensation as the Origin of Coronal and Solar Wind Structure
Submitted: 2012-11-17
Three of the most important and most puzzling features of the Sun's
atmosphere are the smoothness of the closed field corona, the accumulation of
magnetic shear at photospheric polarity inversion lines (PIL), and the
complexity of the slow wind. We propose that a single process, helicity
condensation, is the physical mechanism giving rise to all three features. A
simplified model is presented for how helicity is injected and transported in
the closed corona by magnetic reconnection. With this model we demonstrate that
helicity must condense onto PILs and coronal hole boundaries, and estimate the
rate of helicity accumulation at PILs and the loss to the wind. Our results can
account for many of the observed properties of the closed corona and wind.
[26]
oai:arXiv.org:1102.3704 [pdf] - 1052183
A Model for the Sources of the Slow Solar Wind
Submitted: 2011-02-17
Models for the origin of the slow solar wind must account for two seemingly
contradictory observations: The slow wind has the composition of the closed
field corona, implying that it originates from the continuous opening and
closing of flux at the boundary between open and closed field. On the other
hand, the slow wind also has large angular width, up to ~ 60{\circ}, suggesting
that its source extends far from the open-closed boundary. We propose a model
that can explain both observations. The key idea is that the source of the slow
wind at the Sun is a network of narrow (possibly singular) open-field corridors
that map to a web of separatrices and quasi-separatrix layers in the
heliosphere. We compute analytically the topology of an open-field corridor and
show that it produces a quasi-separatrix layer in the heliosphere that extends
to angles far from the heliospheric current sheet. We then use an MHD code and
MDI/SOHO observations of the photospheric magnetic field to calculate
numerically, with high spatial resolution, the quasi-steady solar wind and
magnetic field for a time period preceding the August 1, 2008 total solar
eclipse. Our numerical results imply that, at least for this time period, a web
of separatrices (which we term an S-web) forms with sufficient density and
extent in the heliosphere to account for the observed properties of the slow
wind. We discuss the implications of our S-web model for the structure and
dynamics of the corona and heliosphere, and propose further tests of the model.
[27]
oai:arXiv.org:1011.0009 [pdf] - 1041635
Magnetic Topology of Coronal Hole Linkages
Submitted: 2010-10-29
In recent work, Antiochos and coworkers argued that the boundary between the
open and closed field regions on the Sun can be extremely complex with narrow
corridors of open flux connecting seemingly disconnected coronal holes from the
main polar holes, and that these corridors may be the sources of the slow solar
wind. We examine, in detail, the topology of such magnetic configurations using
an analytical source surface model that allows for analysis of the field with
arbitrary resolution. Our analysis reveals three important new results: First,
a coronal hole boundary can join stably to the separatrix boundary of a
parasitic polarity region. Second, a single parasitic polarity region can
produce multiple null points in the corona and, more important, separator lines
connecting these points. It is known that such topologies are extremely
favorable for magnetic reconnection, because they allow this process to occur
over the entire length of the separators rather than being confined to a small
region around the nulls. Finally, the coronal holes are not connected by an
open-field corridor of finite width, but instead are linked by a singular line
that coincides with the separatrix footprint of the parasitic polarity. We
investigate how the topological features described above evolve in response to
the motion of the parasitic polarity region. The implications of our results
for the sources of the slow solar wind and for coronal and heliospheric
observations are discussed.
[28]
oai:arXiv.org:1007.5484 [pdf] - 1034022
Tests of Dynamical Flux Emergence as a Mechanism for CME Initiation
Submitted: 2010-07-30, last modified: 2010-08-03
Current coronal mass ejection (CME) models set their lower boundary to be in
the lower corona. They do not calculate accurately the transfer of free
magnetic energy from the convection zone to the magnetically dominated corona
because they model the effects of flux emergence using kinematic boundary
conditions or simply assume the appearance of flux at these heights. We test
the importance of including dynamical flux emergence in CME modeling by
simulating, in 2.5D, the emergence of sub-surface flux tubes into different
coronal magnetic field configurations. We investigate how much free magnetic
energy, in the form of shear magnetic field, is transported from the convection
zone to the corona, and whether dynamical flux emergence can drive CMEs. We
find that multiple coronal flux ropes can be formed during flux emergence, and
although they carry some shear field into the corona, the majority of shear
field is confined to the lower atmosphere. Less than 10% of the magnetic energy
in the corona is in the shear field, and this, combined with the fact that the
coronal flux ropes bring up significant dense material, means that they do not
erupt. Our results have significant implications for all CME models which rely
on the transfer of free magnetic energy from the lower atmosphere into the
corona but which do not explicitly model this transfer. Such studies of flux
emergence and CMEs are timely, as we have new capabilities to observe this with
Hinode and SDO, and therefore to test the models against observations.
[29]
oai:arXiv.org:0912.0953 [pdf] - 902639
Can Thermal Nonequilibrium Explain Coronal Loops?
Submitted: 2009-12-04, last modified: 2010-04-26
Any successful model of coronal loops must explain a number of observed
properties. For warm (~ 1 MK) loops, these include: 1. excess density, 2. flat
temperature profile, 3. super-hydrostatic scale height, 4. unstructured
intensity profile, and 5. 1000--5000 s lifetime. We examine whether thermal
nonequilibrium can reproduce the observations by performing hydrodynamic
simulations based on steady coronal heating that decreases exponentially with
height. We consider both monolithic and multi-stranded loops. The simulations
successfully reproduce certain aspects of the observations, including the
excess density, but each of them fails in at least one critical way. Monolithic
models have far too much intensity structure, while multi-strand models are
either too structured or too long-lived. Our results appear to rule out the
widespread existence of heating that is both highly concentrated low in the
corona and steady or quasi-steady (slowly varying or impulsive with a rapid
cadence). Active regions would have a very different appearance if the dominant
heating mechanism had these properties. Thermal nonequilibrium may nonetheless
play an important role in prominences and catastrophic cooling events (e.g.,
coronal rain) that occupy a small fraction of the coronal volume. However,
apparent inconsistencies between the models and observations of cooling events
have yet to be understood.
[30]
oai:arXiv.org:0804.4862 [pdf] - 12216
STEREO/SECCHI Stereoscopic Observations Constraining the Initiation of
Polar Coronal Jets
Submitted: 2008-04-30
We report on the first stereoscopic observations of polar coronal jets made
by the EUVI/SECCHI imagers on board the twin STEREO spacecraft. The
significantly separated viewpoints ($\sim$ 11$^\circ$) allowed us to infer the
3D dynamics and morphology of a well-defined EUV coronal jet for the first
time. Triangulations of the jet's location in simultaneous image pairs led to
the true 3D position and thereby its kinematics. Initially the jet ascends
slowly at $\approx$10-20 $\mathrm{{km} {s}^{-1}}$ and then, after an apparent
'jump' takes place, it accelerates impulsively to velocities exceeding 300
$\mathrm{{km} {s}^{-1}}$ with accelerations exceeding the solar gravity.
Helical structure is the most important geometrical feature of the jet which
shows evidence of untwisting. The jet structure appears strikingly different
from each of the two STEREO viewpoints: face-on in the one viewpoint and
edge-on in the other. This provides conclusive evidence that the observed
helical structure is real and is not resulting from possible projection effects
of single viewpoint observations. The clear demonstration of twisted structure
in polar jets compares favorably with synthetic images from a recent MHD
simulation of jets invoking magnetic untwisting as their driving mechanism.
Therefore, the latter can be considered as a viable mechanism for the
initiation of polar jets.
[31]
oai:arXiv.org:0804.3995 [pdf] - 12061
A Mechanism for Coronal Hole Jets
Submitted: 2008-04-24
Bald patches are magnetic topologies in which the magnetic field is concave
up over part of a photospheric polarity inversion line. A bald patch topology
is believed to be the essential ingredient for filament channels and is often
found in extrapolations of the observed photospheric field. Using an analytic
source-surface model to calculate the magnetic topology of a small bipolar
region embedded in a global magnetic dipole field, we demonstrate that although
common in closed-field regions close to the solar equator, bald patches are
unlikely to occur in the open-field topology of a coronal hole. Our results
give rise to the following question: What happens to a bald patch topology when
the surrounding field lines open up? This would be the case when a bald patch
moves into a coronal hole, or when a coronal hole forms in an area that
encompasses a bald patch. Our magnetostatic models show that, in this case, the
bald patch topology almost invariably transforms into a null point topology
with a spine and a fan. We argue that the time-dependent evolution of this
scenario will be very dynamic since the change from a bald patch to null point
topology cannot occur via a simple ideal evolution in the corona. We discuss
the implications of these findings for recent Hinode XRT observations of
coronal hole jets and give an outline of planned time-dependent 3D MHD
simulations to fully assess this scenario.
[32]
oai:arXiv.org:0705.4430 [pdf] - 1736
Structure and Dynamics of the Sun's Open Magnetic Field
Submitted: 2007-05-30
The solar magnetic field is the primary agent that drives solar activity and
couples the Sun to the Heliosphere. Although the details of this coupling
depend on the quantitative properties of the field, many important aspects of
the corona - solar wind connection can be understood by considering only the
general topological properties of those regions on the Sun where the field
extends from the photosphere out to interplanetary space, the so-called open
field regions that are usually observed as coronal holes. From the simple
assumptions that underlie the standard quasi-steady corona-wind theoretical
models, and that are likely to hold for the Sun, as well, we derive two
conjectures on the possible structure and dynamics of coronal holes: (1)
Coronal holes are unique in that every unipolar region on the photosphere can
contain at most one coronal hole. (2) Coronal holes of nested polarity regions
must themselves be nested. Magnetic reconnection plays the central role in
enforcing these constraints on the field topology. From these conjectures we
derive additional properties for the topology of open field regions, and
propose several observational predictions for both the slowly varying and
transient corona/solar wind.
[33]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/0501473 [pdf] - 70585
Magnetic Flux Tube Reconnection: Tunneling Versus Slingshot
Submitted: 2005-01-21
The discrete nature of the solar magnetic field as it emerges into the corona
through the photosphere indicates that it exists as isolated flux tubes in the
convection zone, and will remain as discrete flux tubes in the corona until it
collides and reconnects with other coronal fields. Collisions of these flux
tubes will in general be three dimensional, and will often lead to
reconnection, both rearranging the magnetic field topology in fundamental ways,
and releasing magnetic energy. With the goal of better understanding these
dynamics, we carry out a set of numerical experiments exploring fundamental
characteristics of three dimensional magnetic flux tube reconnection. We first
show that reconnecting flux tubes at opposite extremes of twist behave very
differently: in some configurations, low twist tubes slingshot while high twist
tubes tunnel. We then discuss a theory explaining these differences: by
assuming helicity conservation during the reconnection one can show that at
high twist, tunneled tubes reach a lower magnetic energy state than slingshot
tubes, whereas at low twist the opposite holds. We test three predictions made
by this theory. 1) We find that the level of twist at which the transition from
slingshot to tunnel occurs is about two to three times higher than predicted on
the basis of energetics and helicity conservation alone, probably because the
dynamics of the reconnection play a large role as well. 2) We find that the
tunnel occurs at all flux tube collision angles predicted by the theory. 3) We
find that the amount of magnetic energy a slingshot or a tunnel reconnection
releases agrees reasonably well with the theory, though at the high
resistivities we have to use for numerical stability, a significant amount of
magnetic energy is lost to diffusion, independent of reconnection.
[34]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9901039 [pdf] - 1235296
The Role of Helicity in Magnetic Reconnection: 3D Numerical Simulations
Submitted: 1999-01-05
We demonstrate that conservation of global helicity plays only a minor role
in determining the nature and consequences of magnetic reconnection in the
solar atmosphere. First, we show that observations of the solar coronal
magnetic field are in direct conflict with Taylor's theory. Next, we present
results from three-dimensional MHD simulations of the shearing of bipolar and
multi-polar coronal magnetic fields by photospheric footpoint motions, and
discuss the implications of these results for Taylor's theory and for models of
solar activity. The key conclusion of this work is that significant magnetic
reconnection occurs only at very specific locations and, hence, the Sun's
magnetic field cannot relax completely down to the minimum energy state
predicted by conservation of global helicity.
[35]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9809161 [pdf] - 102865
The Role of Magnetic Reconnection in Solar Activity
Submitted: 1998-09-12
We argue that magnetic reconnection plays the determining role in many of the
various manifestations of solar activity. In particular, it is the trigger
mechanism for the most energetic of solar events, coronal mass ejections and
eruptive flares. We propose that in order to obtain explosive eruptions,
magnetic reconnection in the corona must have an ``on-off'' nature, and show
that reconnection in a sheared multi-polar field configuration does have this
property. Numerical simulation results which support this model are presented,
and implications for coronal mass ejections/eruptive flare prediction are
discussed.
[36]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9808199 [pdf] - 102543
The Dynamic Formation of Prominence Condensations
Submitted: 1998-08-19
We present simulations of a model for the formation of a prominence
condensation in a coronal loop. The key idea behind the model is that the
spatial localization of loop heating near the chromosphere leads to a
catastrophic cooling in the corona (Antiochos & Klimchuk 1991). Using a new
adaptive grid code, we simulate the complete growth of a condensation, and find
that after approx. 5,000 s it reaches a quasi-steady state. We show that the
size and the growth time of the condensation are in good agreement with data,
and discuss the implications of the model for coronal heating and SOHO/TRACE
observations.
[37]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9807220 [pdf] - 102214
A Model for Solar Coronal Mass Ejections
Submitted: 1998-07-21
We propose a new model for the initiation of a solar coronal mass ejection
(CME). The model agrees with two properties of CMEs and eruptive flares that
have proved to be very difficult to explain with previous models. a) Very
low-lying magnetic field lines, down to the photospheric neutral line, can open
toward infinity during an eruption. b) The eruption is driven solely by
magnetic free energy stored in a closed, sheared arcade; consequently, the
magnetic energy of the closed state is well above that of the post-eruption
open state. The key new feature of our model is that CMEs occur in multi-polar
topologies, in which reconnection between a sheared arcade and neighboring flux
systems triggers the eruption. In this ``magnetic breakout'' model,
reconnection removes the unsheared field above the low-lying, sheared core flux
near the neutral line, thereby allowing this core flux to burst open. We
present numerical simulations which demonstrate that our model can account for
the energy requirements for CMEs. We discuss the implication of the model for
CME/flare prediction.
[38]
oai:arXiv.org:astro-ph/9806030 [pdf] - 101623
The Magnetic Topology of Solar Eruptions
Submitted: 1998-06-02
We present an explanation for the well-known observation that complexity of
the solar magnetic field is a necessary ingredient for strong activity such as
large eruptive flares. Our model starts with the standard picture for the
energy build up -- highly-sheared, newly-emerged magnetic field near the
photospheric neutral line held down by overlying unsheared field. Previously,
we proposed the key new idea that magnetic reconnection between the unsheared
field and neighboring flux systems decreases the amount of overlying field and,
thereby, allows the low-lying sheared flux to ``break out'' (Antiochos, DeVore
and Klimchuk 1998, ApJ, submitted). In this paper we show that a bipolar active
region does not have the necessary complexity for this process to occur, but a
delta sunspot has the right topology for magnetic breakout. We discuss the
implications of these results for observations from SOHO and TRACE.