The interpretation of the DAMA seasonal variation pattern as a Dark Matter (DM) effect rests on the assumption that all sources of variable background have been excluded from the measurement. We have identified an overlooked background that mimics the DM signature -- a large, patently existing effect that has nothing to do with detection within the scintillators. This process takes place exclusively within the individual photomultiplier tubes (PMTs), with two familiar actors (thermionic electrons and helium atoms), two familiar processes (helium penetration of glass and ion afterpulsing), and a simple storyline: (a) After defeating the insulation of the DAMA detector, helium atoms from the variable local environment penetrate the PMT vacua; (b) Thermionic electrons from the PMT photocathode ionize helium atoms; (c) Secondary electrons from each helium ion impact in the photocathode form an afterpulse, and thus effectively boost and extend the waveform. We demonstrate that the accidental coincidences of such inflated dark noise waveforms, originating from any pair of PMTs, mimic scintillation events at a rate of $\approx$ 1 cpd/kg/keV, which is consistent with DAMA result. The reported seasonal variation of $\sim$ 1% thus implicates an equivalent variation of helium concentration in the local environment. We predict that the DAMA detector with a modified readout logic -- blinded for the DM scintillation events \textendash will measure the same, helium -- driven seasonal variation pattern as the original detector.