Normalized to: Übler, H.
[1]
oai:arXiv.org:2006.03046 [pdf] - 2107968
Rotation Curves in z~1-2 Star-Forming Disks: Evidence for Cored Dark
Matter Distributions
Genzel, R.;
Price, S. H.;
Übler, H.;
Schreiber, N. M. Förster;
Shimizu, T. T.;
Tacconi, L. J.;
Bender, R.;
Burkert, A.;
Contursi, A.;
Coogan, R.;
Davies, R. L.;
Davies, R. I.;
Dekel, A.;
Herrera-Camus, R.;
Lee, M.;
Lutz, D.;
Naab, T.;
Neri, R.;
Nestor, A.;
Renzini, A.;
Saglia, R.;
Schuster, K.;
Sternberg, A.;
Wisnioski, E.;
Wuyts, S.
Submitted: 2020-06-04
We report high quality, H{\alpha} or CO rotation curves (RCs) to several Re
for 41 large, massive, star-forming disk galaxies (SFGs), across the peak of
cosmic galaxy evolution (z~0.67-2.45), taken with the ESO-VLT, the LBT and
IRAM-NOEMA. Most RC41 SFGs have reflection symmetric RCs plausibly described by
equilibrium dynamics. We fit the major axis position-velocity cuts with
beam-convolved, forward modeling with a bulge, a turbulent rotating disk, and a
dark matter (DM) halo. We include priors for stellar and molecular gas masses,
optical light effective radii and inclinations, and DM masses from abundance
matching scaling relations. Two-thirds or more of the z>1.2 SFGs are baryon
dominated within a few Re of typically 5.5 kpc, and have DM fractions less than
maximal disks (<fDM (Re)>=0.12). At lower redshift (z<1.2) that fraction is
less than one-third. DM fractions correlate inversely with the baryonic angular
momentum parameter, baryonic surface density and bulge mass. Inferred low DM
fractions cannot apply to the entire disk & halo but more plausibly reflect a
flattened, or cored, inner DM density distribution. The typical central 'DM
deficit' in these cores relative to NFW distributions is ~30% of the bulge
mass. The observations are consistent with rapid radial transport of baryons in
the first generation massive gas rich halos forming globally gravitationally
unstable disks, and leading to efficient build-up of massive bulges and central
black holes. A combination of heating due to dynamical friction and AGN
feedback may drive DM out of the initial cusps.
[2]
oai:arXiv.org:2004.02891 [pdf] - 2093279
From Nuclear to Circumgalactic: Zooming in on AGN-Driven Outflows at
z~2.2 with SINFONI
Davies, Rebecca L.;
Schreiber, N. M. Förster;
Lutz, D.;
Genzel, R.;
Belli, S.;
Shimizu, T. T.;
Contursi, A.;
Davies, R. I.;
Herrera-Camus, R.;
Lee, M. M.;
Naab, T.;
Price, S. H.;
Renzini, A.;
Schruba, A.;
Sternberg, A.;
Tacconi, L. J.;
Übler, H.;
Wisnioski, E.;
Wuyts, S.
Submitted: 2020-04-06
We use deep adaptive optics assisted integral field spectroscopy from SINFONI
on the VLT to study the spatially resolved properties of ionized gas outflows
driven by active galactic nuclei (AGN) in three galaxies at z~2.2 -- K20-ID5,
COS4-11337 and J0901+1814. These systems probe AGN feedback from nuclear to
circumgalactic scales, and provide unique insights into the different
mechanisms by which AGN-driven outflows interact with their host galaxies.
K20-ID5 and COS4-11337 are compact star forming galaxies with powerful
$\sim$1500 km s$^{-1}$ AGN-driven outflows that dominate their nuclear
H$\alpha$ emission. The outflows do not appear to have any impact on the
instantaneous star formation activity of the host galaxies, but they carry a
significant amount of kinetic energy which could heat the halo gas and
potentially lead to a reduction in the rate of cold gas accretion onto the
galaxies. The outflow from COS4-11337 is propagating directly towards its
companion galaxy COS4-11363, at a projected separation of 5.4 kpc. COS4-11363
shows signs of shock excitation and recent truncation of star formation
activity, which could plausibly have been induced by the outflow from
COS4-11337. J0901+1814 is gravitationally lensed, giving us a unique view of a
compact (R = 470 $\pm$ 70 pc), relatively low velocity ($\sim$650 km s$^{-1}$)
AGN-driven outflow. J0901+1814 has a similar AGN luminosity to COS4-11337,
suggesting that the difference in outflow properties is not related to the
current AGN luminosity, and may instead reflect a difference in the
evolutionary stage of the outflow and/or the coupling efficiency between the
AGN ionizing radiation field and the gas in the nuclear regions.
[3]
oai:arXiv.org:1902.09554 [pdf] - 2097151
The MOSDEF Survey: Kinematic and Structural Evolution of Star-Forming
Galaxies at $1.4\leq z\leq 3.8$
Price, Sedona H.;
Kriek, Mariska;
Barro, Guillermo;
Shapley, Alice E.;
Reddy, Naveen A.;
Freeman, William R.;
Coil, Alison L.;
Shivaei, Irene;
Azadi, Mojegan;
de Groot, Laura;
Siana, Brian;
Mobasher, Bahram;
Sanders, Ryan L.;
Leung, Gene C. K.;
Fetherolf, Tara;
Zick, Tom O.;
Übler, Hannah;
Schreiber, Natascha M. Förster
Submitted: 2019-02-25, last modified: 2020-03-16
We present ionized gas kinematics for 681 galaxies at $z\sim 1.4-3.8$ from
the MOSFIRE Deep Evolution Field survey, measured using models which account
for random galaxy-slit misalignments together with structural parameters
derived from CANDELS Hubble Space Telescope (HST) imaging. Kinematics and sizes
are used to derive dynamical masses. Baryonic masses are estimated from stellar
masses and inferred gas masses from dust-corrected star formation rates (SFRs)
and the Kennicutt-Schmidt relation. We measure resolved rotation for 105
galaxies. For the remaining 576 galaxies we use models based on HST imaging
structural parameters together with integrated velocity dispersions and
baryonic masses to statistically constrain the median ratio of intrinsic
ordered to disordered motion, $V/\sigma_{V,0}$. We find that $V/\sigma_{V,0}$
increases with increasing stellar mass and decreasing specific SFR (sSFR).
These trends may reflect marginal disk stability, where systems with higher gas
fractions have thicker disks. For galaxies with detected rotation we assess
trends between their kinematics and mass, sSFR, and baryon surface density
($\Sigma_{\mathrm{bar},e}$). Intrinsic dispersion correlates most with
$\Sigma_{\mathrm{bar},e}$ and velocity correlates most with mass. By comparing
dynamical and baryonic masses, we find that galaxies at $z\sim 1.4-3.8$ are
baryon dominated within their effective radii ($R_E$), with Mdyn/Mbaryon
increasing over time. The inferred baryon fractions within $R_E$,
$f_{\mathrm{bar}}$, decrease over time, even at fixed mass, size, or surface
density. At fixed redshift, $f_{\mathrm{bar}}$ does not appear to vary with
stellar mass but increases with decreasing $R_E$ and increasing
$\Sigma_{\mathrm{bar},e}$. For galaxies at $z\geq2$, the median inferred baryon
fractions generally exceed 100%. We discuss possible explanations and future
avenues to resolve this tension.
[4]
oai:arXiv.org:2002.09499 [pdf] - 2069078
The regulation of galaxy growth along the size-mass relation by
star-formation, as traced by H${\alpha}$ in KMOS$^{3D}$ galaxies at 0.7 < z <
2.7
Wilman, D. J.;
Fossati, M.;
Mendel, J. T.;
Saglia, R.;
Wisnioski, E.;
Wuyts, S.;
Schreiber, N. Förster;
Beifiori, A.;
Bender, R.;
Belli, S.;
Übler, H.;
Lang, P.;
Chan, J. C. C.;
Davies, R. L.;
Nelson, E. J.;
Genzel, R.;
Tacconi, L. J.;
Galametz, A.;
Davies, R. I.;
Lutz, D.;
Price, S.;
Burkert, A.;
Tadaki, K.;
Herrera-Camus, R.;
Brammer, G.;
Momcheva, I.;
van Dokkum, P.
Submitted: 2020-02-21
We present half-light sizes measured from H${\alpha}$ emission tracing
star-formation in 281 star-forming galaxies from the KMOS3D survey at 0.7 < z <
2.7. Sizes are derived by fitting 2D exponential disk models, with bootstrap
errors averaging 20%. H${\alpha}$ sizes are a median (mean) of 1.19 (1.26)
times larger than those of the stellar continuum, which due to radial dust
gradients places an upper limit on the growth in stellar size via star
formation, with just 43% intrinsic scatter. At fixed continuum size the
H${\alpha}$ size shows no residual trend with stellar mass, star formation
rate, redshift or morphology. The only significant residual trend is with the
excess obscuration of H${\alpha}$ by dust, at fixed continuum obscuration. The
scatter in continuum size at fixed stellar mass is likely driven by the scatter
in halo spin parameters. The stability of the ratio of H${\alpha}$ size to
continuum size demonstrates a high degree of stability in halo spin and in the
transfer of angular momentum to the disk over a wide range of physical
conditions and cosmic time. This may require local regulation by feedback
processes. The implication of our results, as we demonstrate using a toy model,
is that our upper limit on star-formation driven growth is sufficient only to
evolve star-forming galaxies approximately along the observed size-mass
relation, consistent with the size growth of galaxies at constant cumulative
co-moving number density. To explain the observed evolution of the size-mass
relation of star-forming disk galaxies other processes, such as the
preferential quenching of compact galaxies or galaxy mergers, may be required.
[5]
oai:arXiv.org:1909.11096 [pdf] - 2006634
The KMOS^3D Survey: data release and final survey paper
Wisnioski, E.;
Schreiber, N. M. Förster;
Fossati, M.;
Mendel, J. T.;
Wilman, D.;
Genzel, R.;
Bender, R.;
Wuyts, S.;
Davies, R. L.;
Übler, H.;
Bandara, K.;
Beifiori, A.;
Belli, S.;
Brammer, G.;
Chan, J.;
Davies, R. I.;
Fabricius, M.;
Galametz, A.;
Lang, P.;
Lutz, D.;
Nelson, E. J.;
Momcheva, I.;
Price, S.;
Rosario, D.;
Saglia, R.;
Seitz, S.;
Shimizu, T.;
Tacconi, L. J.;
Tadaki, K.;
van Dokkum, P. G.;
Wuyts, E.
Submitted: 2019-09-24
We present the completed KMOS$^\mathrm{3D}$ survey $-$ an integral field
spectroscopic survey of 739, $\log(M_{\star}/M_{\odot})>9$, galaxies at
$0.6<z<2.7$ using the K-band Multi Object Spectrograph (KMOS) at the Very Large
Telescope (VLT). KMOS$^\mathrm{3D}$ provides a population-wide census of
kinematics, star formation, outflows, and nebular gas conditions both on and
off the star-forming galaxy main sequence through the spatially resolved and
integrated properties of H$\alpha$, [N II], and [S II] emission lines. We
detect H$\alpha$ emission for 91% of galaxies on the main sequence of
star-formation and 79% overall. The depth of the survey has allowed us to
detect galaxies with star-formation rates below 1 M$_{\odot}$/ yr$^{-1}$, as
well as to resolve 81% of detected galaxies with $\geq3$ resolution elements
along the kinematic major axis. The detection fraction of H$\alpha$ is a strong
function of both color and offset from the main sequence, with the detected and
non-detected samples exhibiting different SED shapes. Comparison of H$\alpha$
and UV+IR star formation rates (SFRs) reveal that dust attenuation corrections
may be underestimated by 0.5 dex at the highest masses
($\log(M_{\star}/M_{\odot})>10.5$). We confirm our first year results of a high
rotation dominated fraction (monotonic velocity gradient and
$v_\mathrm{rot}$/$\sigma_0 > \sqrt{3.36}$) of 77% for the full
KMOS$^\mathrm{3D}$ H$\alpha$sample. The rotation-dominated fraction is a
function of both stellar mass and redshift with the strongest evolution
measured over the redshift range of the survey for galaxies with
$\log(M_{\star}/M_{\odot})<10.5$. With this paper we include a final data
release of all 739 observed objects.
[6]
oai:arXiv.org:1906.02737 [pdf] - 1925082
The Evolution and Origin of Ionized Gas Velocity Dispersion from
$z\sim2.6$ to $z\sim0.6$ with KMOS$^{\rm 3D}$
Übler, Hannah D. N.;
Genzel, Reinhard;
Wisnioski, Emily;
Schreiber, Natascha M. Förster;
Shimizu, T. Taro;
Price, Sedona H.;
Tacconi, Linda J.;
Belli, Sirio;
Wilman, David J.;
Fossati, Matteo;
Mendel, J. Trevor;
Davies, Rebecca L.;
Beifiori, Alessandra;
Bender, Ralf;
Brammer, Gabriel B.;
Burkert, Andreas;
Chan, Jeffrey;
Davies, Richard I.;
Fabricius, Maximilian;
Galametz, Audrey;
Herrera-Camus, Rodrigo;
Lang, Philipp;
Lutz, Dieter;
Momcheva, Ivelina G.;
Naab, Thorsten;
Nelson, Erica J.;
Saglia, Roberto P.;
Tadaki, Ken-ichi;
van Dokkum, Pieter G.;
Wuyts, Stijn
Submitted: 2019-06-06
We present the $0.6<z<2.6$ evolution of the ionized gas velocity dispersion
in 175 star-forming disk galaxies based on data from the full KMOS$^{\rm 3D}$
integral field spectroscopic survey. In a forward-modelling Bayesian framework
including instrumental effects and beam-smearing, we fit simultaneously the
observed galaxy velocity and velocity dispersion along the kinematic major axis
to derive the intrinsic velocity dispersion $\sigma_0$. We find a reduction of
the average intrinsic velocity dispersion of disk galaxies as a function of
cosmic time, from $\sigma_0\sim45$ km s$^{-1}$ at $z\sim2.3$ to
$\sigma_0\sim30$ km s$^{-1}$ at $z\sim0.9$. There is substantial intrinsic
scatter ($\sigma_{\sigma_0, {\rm int}}\approx10$ km s$^{-1}$) around the
best-fit $\sigma_0-z$-relation beyond what can be accounted for from the
typical measurement uncertainties ($\delta\sigma_0\approx12$ km s$^{-1}$),
independent of other identifiable galaxy parameters. This potentially suggests
a dynamic mechanism such as minor mergers or variation in accretion being
responsible for the scatter. Putting our data into the broader literature
context, we find that ionized and atomic+molecular velocity dispersions evolve
similarly with redshift, with the ionized gas dispersion being $\sim10-15$ km
s$^{-1}$ higher on average. We investigate the physical driver of the on
average elevated velocity dispersions at higher redshift, and find that our
galaxies are at most marginally Toomre-stable, suggesting that their turbulent
velocities are powered by gravitational instabilities, while stellar feedback
as a driver alone is insufficient. This picture is supported through comparison
with a state-of-the-art analytical model of galaxy evolution.
[7]
oai:arXiv.org:1807.04738 [pdf] - 1867963
The KMOS^3D Survey: Demographics and Properties of Galactic Outflows at
z = 0.6 - 2.7
Schreiber, N. M. Förster;
Übler, H.;
Davies, R. L.;
Genzel, R.;
Wisnioski, E.;
Belli, S.;
Shimizu, T.;
Lutz, D.;
Fossati, M.;
Herrera-Camus, R.;
Mendel, J. T.;
Tacconi, L. J.;
Wilman, D.;
Beifiori, A.;
Brammer, G.;
Burkert, A.;
Carollo, C. M.;
Davies, R. I.;
Eisenhauer, F.;
Fabricius, M.;
Lilly, S. J.;
Momcheva, I.;
Naab, T.;
Nelson, E. J.;
Price, S.;
Renzini, A.;
Saglia, R.;
Sternberg, A.;
van Dokkum, P.;
Wuyts, S.
Submitted: 2018-07-12, last modified: 2019-02-26
We present a census of ionized gas outflows in 599 normal galaxies at
redshift 0.6<z<2.7, mostly based on integral field spectroscopy of Ha, [NII],
and [SII] line emission. The sample fairly homogeneously covers the main
sequence of star-forming galaxies with masses 9.0<log(M*/Msun)<11.7, and probes
into the regimes of quiescent galaxies and starburst outliers. About 1/3
exhibits the high-velocity component indicative of outflows, roughly equally
split into winds driven by star formation (SF) and active galactic nuclei
(AGN). The incidence of SF-driven winds correlates mainly with star formation
properties. These outflows have typical velocities of ~450 km/s, local electron
densities of n_e~380 cm^-3, modest mass loading factors of ~0.1-0.2 at all
galaxy masses, and energetics compatible with momentum driving by young stellar
populations. The SF-driven winds may escape from log(M*/Msun)<10.3 galaxies but
substantial mass, momentum, and energy in hotter and colder outflow phases seem
required to account for low galaxy formation efficiencies in the low-mass
regime. Faster AGN-driven outflows (~1000-2000 km/s) are commonly detected
above log(M*/Msun)~10.7, in up to ~75% of log(M*/Msun)>11.2 galaxies. The
incidence, strength, and velocity of AGN-driven winds strongly correlates with
stellar mass and central concentration. Their outflowing ionized gas appears
denser (n_e~1000 cm^-3), and possibly compressed and shock-excited. These winds
have comparable mass loading factors as the SF-driven winds but carry ~10 (~50)
times more momentum (energy). The results confirm our previous findings of high
duty cycle, energy-driven outflows powered by AGN above the Schechter mass,
which may contribute to star formation quenching.
[8]
oai:arXiv.org:1808.10700 [pdf] - 1851542
Kiloparsec Scale Properties of Star-Formation Driven Outflows at z~2.3
in the SINS/zC-SINF AO Survey
Davies, Rebecca L.;
Schreiber, Natascha M. Förster;
Übler, Hannah;
Genzel, Reinhard;
Lutz, Dieter;
Renzini, Alvio;
Tacchella, Sandro;
Tacconi, Linda J.;
Belli, Sirio;
Burkert, Andreas;
Carollo, C. Marcella;
Davies, Richard I.;
Herrera-Camus, Rodrigo;
Lilly, Simon J.;
Mancini, Chiara;
Naab, Thorsten;
Nelson, Erica J.;
Price, Sedona H.;
Shimizu, Thomas Taro;
Sternberg, Amiel;
Wisnioski, Emily;
Wuyts, Stijn
Submitted: 2018-08-31, last modified: 2019-02-14
We investigate the relationship between star formation activity and outflow
properties on kiloparsec scales in a sample of 28 star forming galaxies at
$z\sim$ 2-2.6, using adaptive optics assisted integral field observations from
SINFONI on the VLT. The narrow and broad components of the H$\alpha$ emission
are used to simultaneously determine the local star formation rate surface
density ($\Sigma_{\rm SFR}$), and the outflow velocity $v_{\rm out}$ and mass
outflow rate $\dot{M}_{\rm out}$, respectively. We find clear evidence for
faster outflows with larger mass loading factors at higher $\Sigma_{\rm SFR}$.
The outflow velocities scale as $v_{\rm out}$ $\propto$ $\Sigma_{\rm SFR}^{0.34
\pm 0.10}$, which suggests that the outflows may be driven by a combination of
mechanical energy released by supernova explosions and stellar winds, as well
as radiation pressure acting on dust grains. The majority of the outflowing
material does not have sufficient velocity to escape from the galaxy halos, but
will likely be re-accreted and contribute to the chemical enrichment of the
galaxies. In the highest $\Sigma_{\rm SFR}$ regions the outflow component
contains an average of $\sim$45% of the H$\alpha$ flux, while in the lower
$\Sigma_{\rm SFR}$ regions only $\sim$10% of the H$\alpha$ flux is associated
with outflows. The mass loading factor, $\eta$ = $\dot{M}_{\rm out}$/SFR, is
positively correlated with $\Sigma_{\rm SFR}$ but is relatively low even at the
highest $\Sigma_{\rm SFR}$: $\eta \lesssim$ 0.5 $\times$ (380 cm$^{-3}$/n$_e$).
This may be in tension with the $\eta$ $\gtrsim$ 1 required by cosmological
simulations, unless a significant fraction of the outflowing mass is in other
gas phases and has sufficient velocity to escape the galaxy halos.
[9]
oai:arXiv.org:1711.02111 [pdf] - 1656171
The KMOS$^\mathrm{3D}$ Survey: rotating compact star forming galaxies
and the decomposition of integrated line widths
Wisnioski, E.;
Mendel, J. T.;
Schreiber, N. M. Förster;
Genzel, R.;
Wilman, D.;
Wuyts, S.;
Belli, S.;
Beifiori, A.;
Bender, R.;
Brammer, G.;
Chan, J.;
Davies, R. I.;
Davies, R. L.;
Fabricius, M.;
Fossati, M.;
Galametz, A.;
Lang, P.;
Lutz, D.;
Nelson, E. J.;
Momcheva, I.;
Rosario, D.;
Saglia, R.;
Tacconi, L. J.;
Tadaki, K.;
Übler, H.;
van Dokkum, P. G.
Submitted: 2017-11-06, last modified: 2018-03-14
Using integral field spectroscopy we investigate the kinematic properties of
35 massive centrally-dense and compact star-forming galaxies
(${\log{\overline{M}_*}}=11.1$, $\log{(\Sigma_\mathrm{1kpc})}>9.5$,
$\log{(M_\ast/r_e^{1.5})}>10.3$) at $z\sim0.7-3.7$ within the
KMOS$^\mathrm{3D}$survey. We spatially resolve 23 compact star-forming galaxies
(SFGs) and find that the majority are dominated by rotational motions with
velocities ranging from {$95-500$ km s$^{-1}$}. The range of rotation
velocities is reflected in a similar range of integrated H$\alpha$ linewidths,
$75-400$ km s$^{-1}$, consistent with the kinematic properties of mass-matched
extended galaxies from the full KMOS$^\mathrm{3D}$ sample. The fraction of
compact SFGs that are classified as `rotation-dominated' or `disk-like' also
mirrors the fractions of the full KMOS$^\mathrm{3D}$ sample. We show that
integrated line-of-sight gas velocity dispersions from KMOS$^\mathrm{3D}$ are
best approximated by a linear combination of their rotation and turbulent
velocities with a lesser but still significant contribution from galactic scale
winds. The H$\alpha$ exponential disk sizes of compact SFGs are on average
$2.5\pm0.2$ kpc, $1-2\times$ the continuum sizes, in agreement with previous
work. The compact SFGs have a $1.4\times$ higher AGN incidence than the full
KMOS$^\mathrm{3D}$ sample at fixed stellar mass with average AGN fraction of
76\%. Given their high and centrally concentrated stellar masses as well as
stellar to dynamical mass ratios close to unity, the compact SFGs are likely to
have low molecular gas fractions and to quench on a short time scale unless
replenished with inflowing gas. The rotation in these compact systems suggests
that their direct descendants are rotating passive galaxies.
[10]
oai:arXiv.org:1802.02135 [pdf] - 1641502
Ionized and molecular gas kinematics in a z=1.4 star-forming galaxy
Übler, Hannah D. N.;
Genzel, Reinhard;
Tacconi, Linda J.;
Schreiber, Natascha M. Förster;
Neri, Roberto;
Contursi, Alessandra;
Belli, Sirio;
Nelson, Erica J.;
Lang, Philipp;
Shimizu, T. Taro;
Davies, Ric;
Herrera-Camus, Rodrigo;
Lutz, Dieter;
Plewa, Philipp M.;
Price, Sedona H.;
Schuster, Karl;
Sternberg, Amiel;
Tadaki, Ken-ichi;
Wisnioski, Emily;
Wuyts, Stijn
Submitted: 2018-02-06
We present deep observations of a $z=1.4$ massive, star-forming galaxy in
molecular and ionized gas at comparable spatial resolution (CO 3-2, NOEMA;
H$\alpha$, LBT). The kinematic tracers agree well, indicating that both gas
phases are subject to the same gravitational potential and physical processes
affecting the gas dynamics. We combine the one-dimensional velocity and
velocity dispersion profiles in CO and H$\alpha$ to forward-model the galaxy in
a Bayesian framework, combining a thick exponential disk, a bulge, and a dark
matter halo. We determine the dynamical support due to baryons and dark matter,
and find a dark matter fraction within one effective radius of $f_{\rm
DM}(\leq$$R_{e})=0.18^{+0.06}_{-0.04}$. Our result strengthens the evidence for
strong baryon-dominance on galactic scales of massive $z\sim1-3$ star-forming
galaxies recently found based on ionized gas kinematics alone.
[11]
oai:arXiv.org:1702.01140 [pdf] - 1637458
PHIBSS: Unified Scaling Relations of Gas Depletion Time and Molecular
Gas Fractions
Tacconi, L. J.;
Genzel, R.;
Saintonge, A.;
Combes, F.;
García-Burillo, S.;
Neri, R.;
Bolatto, A.;
Contini, T.;
Schreiber, N. M. Förster;
Lilly, S.;
Lutz, D.;
Wuyts, S.;
Accurso, G.;
Boissier, J.;
Boone, F.;
Bouché, N.;
Bournaud, F.;
Burkert, A.;
Carollo, M.;
Cooper, M.;
Cox, P.;
Feruglio, C.;
Freundlich, J.;
Herrera-Camus, R.;
Juneau, S.;
Lippa, M.;
Naab, T.;
Renzini, A.;
Salome, P.;
Sternberg, A.;
Tadaki, K.;
Übler, H.;
Walter, F.;
Weiner, B.;
Weiss, A.
Submitted: 2017-02-03, last modified: 2018-01-11
This paper provides an update of our previous scaling relations (Genzel et
al.2015) between galaxy integrated molecular gas masses, stellar masses and
star formation rates, in the framework of the star formation main-sequence
(MS), with the main goal to test for possible systematic effects. For this
purpose our new study combines three independent methods of determining
molecular gas masses from CO line fluxes, far-infrared dust spectral energy
distributions, and ~1mm dust photometry, in a large sample of 1444 star forming
galaxies (SFGs) between z=0 and 4. The sample covers the stellar mass range
log(M*/M_solar)=9.0-11.8, and star formation rates relative to that on the MS,
delta_MS=SFR/SFR(MS), from 10^{-1.3} to 10^{2.2}. Our most important finding is
that all data sets, despite the different techniques and analysis methods used,
follow the same scaling trends, once method-to-method zero point offsets are
minimized and uncertainties are properly taken into account. The molecular gas
depletion time t_depl, defined as the ratio of molecular gas mass to star
formation rate, scales as (1+z)^{-0.6}x(delta_MS)^{-0.44}, and is only weakly
dependent on stellar mass. The ratio of molecular-to-stellar mass mu_gas
depends on (1+z)^{2.5}x (delta_MS)^{0.52}x(M*)^{-0.36}, which tracks the
evolution of the specific star formation rate. The redshift dependence of
mu_gas requires a curvature term, as may the mass-dependences of t_depl and
mu_gas. We find no or only weak correlations of t_depl and mu_gas with optical
size R or surface density once one removes the above scalings, but we caution
that optical sizes may not be appropriate for the high gas and dust columns at
high-z.
[12]
oai:arXiv.org:1703.04321 [pdf] - 1581906
The evolution of the Tully-Fisher relation between z~2.3 and z~0.9 with
KMOS^3D
Übler, H.;
Schreiber, N. M. Förster;
Genzel, R.;
Wisnioski, E.;
Wuyts, S.;
Lang, P.;
Naab, T.;
Burkert, A.;
Tacconi, L. J.;
Wilman, D. J.;
Fossati, M.;
Mendel, J. T.;
Beifiori, A.;
Belli, S.;
Bender, R.;
Brammer, G.;
Chan, J.;
Davies, R.;
Fabricius, M.;
Galametz, A.;
Lutz, D.;
Momcheva, I.;
Nelson, E. J.;
Saglia, R. P.;
Seitz, S.;
Tadaki, K.;
van Dokkum, P. G.
Submitted: 2017-03-13, last modified: 2017-06-07
We investigate the stellar mass and baryonic mass Tully-Fisher relations
(TFRs) of massive star-forming disk galaxies at redshift z~2.3 and z~0.9 as
part of the KMOS^3D integral field spectroscopy survey. Our spatially resolved
data allow reliable modelling of individual galaxies, including the effect of
pressure support on the inferred gravitational potential. At fixed circular
velocity, we find higher baryonic masses and similar stellar masses at z~2.3 as
compared to z~0.9. Together with the decreasing gas-to-stellar mass ratios with
decreasing redshift, this implies that the contribution of dark matter to the
dynamical mass at the galaxy scale increases towards lower redshift. A
comparison to local relations reveals a negative evolution of the stellar and
baryonic TFR zero-points from z=0 to z~0.9, no evolution of the stellar TFR
zero-point from z~0.9 to z~2.3, and a positive evolution of the baryonic TFR
zero-point from z~0.9 to z~2.3. We discuss a toy model of disk galaxy evolution
to explain the observed, non-monotonic TFR evolution, taking into account the
empirically motivated redshift dependencies of galactic gas fractions, and of
the relative amount of baryons to dark matter on galaxy and halo scales.
[13]
oai:arXiv.org:1703.07778 [pdf] - 1582077
KMOS-3D Reveals Low-Level Star Formation Activity in Massive Quiescent
Galaxies at 0.7 < z < 2.7
Belli, Sirio;
Genzel, Reinhard;
Schreiber, Natascha M. Förster;
Wisnioski, Emily;
Wilman, David J.;
Wuyts, Stijn;
Mendel, J. Trevor;
Beifiori, Alessandra;
Bender, Ralf;
Brammer, Gabriel B.;
Burkert, Andreas;
Chan, Jeffrey;
Davies, Rebecca L.;
Davies, Ric;
Fabricius, Maximilian;
Fossati, Matteo;
Galametz, Audrey;
Lang, Philipp;
Lutz, Dieter;
Momcheva, Ivelina G.;
Nelson, Erica J.;
Saglia, Roberto P.;
Tacconi, Linda J.;
Tadaki, Ken-ichi;
Übler, Hannah;
van Dokkum, Pieter
Submitted: 2017-03-22, last modified: 2017-05-23
We explore the H-alpha emission in the massive quiescent galaxies observed by
the KMOS-3D survey at 0.7 < z < 2.7. The H-alpha line is robustly detected in
20 out of 120 UVJ-selected quiescent galaxies, and we classify the emission
mechanism using the H-alpha line width and the [NII]/H-alpha line ratio. We
find that AGN are likely to be responsible for the line emission in more than
half of the cases. We also find robust evidence for star formation activity in
nine quiescent galaxies, which we explore in detail. The H-alpha kinematics
reveal rotating disks in five of the nine galaxies. The dust-corrected H-alpha
star formation rates are low (0.2 - 7 Msun/yr), and place these systems
significantly below the main sequence. The 24micron-based infrared
luminosities, instead, overestimate the star formation rates. These galaxies
present a lower gas-phase metallicity compared to star-forming objects with
similar stellar mass, and many of them have close companions. We therefore
conclude that the low-level star formation activity in these nine quiescent
galaxies is likely to be fueled by inflowing gas or minor mergers, and could be
a sign of rejuvenation events.
[14]
oai:arXiv.org:1703.10197 [pdf] - 1582230
Rotating starburst cores in massive galaxies at z=2.5
Tadaki, Ken-ichi;
Kodama, Tadayuki;
Nelson, Erica J.;
Belli, Sirio;
Schreiber, Natascha M. Förster;
Genzel, Reinhard;
Hayashi, Masao;
Herrera-Camus, Rodrigo;
Koyama, Yusei;
Lang, Philipp;
Lutz, Dieter;
Shimakawa, Rhythm;
Tacconi, Linda J.;
Übler, Hannah;
Wisnioski, Emily;
Wuyts, Stijn;
Hatsukade, Bunyo;
Lippa, Magdalena;
Nakanishi, Kouichiro;
Ikarashi, Soh;
Kohno, Kotaro;
Suzuki, Tomoko L.;
Tamura, Yoichi;
Tanaka, Ichi
Submitted: 2017-03-29, last modified: 2017-05-14
We present spatially resolved ALMA observations of the CO J=3-2 emission line
in two massive galaxies at z=2.5 on the star-forming main sequence. Both
galaxies have compact dusty star-forming cores with effective radii of Re=1.3
kpc and Re=1.2 kpc in the 870 um continuum emission. The spatial extent of
star-forming molecular gas is also compact with Re=1.9 kpc and Re=2.3 kpc, but
more extended than the dust emission. Interpreting the observed
position-velocity diagrams with dynamical models, we find the starburst cores
to be rotation-dominated with the ratio of the maximum rotation velocity to the
local velocity dispersion of v/sigma=7.0 (v=386 km/s) and v/sigma_0=4.1 (v=391
km/s). Given that the descendants of these massive galaxies in the local
universe are likely ellipticals with v/sigma nearly an order of magnitude
lower, the rapidly rotating galaxies would lose significant net angular
momentum in the intervening time. The comparisons among dynamical, stellar,
gas, and dust mass suggest that the starburst CO-to-H2 conversion factor of
alpha_CO=0.8 Msun/(K km/s/pc2) is appropriate in the spatially resolved cores.
The dense cores are likely to be formed in extreme environments similar to the
central regions of local ultraluminous infrared galaxies. Our work also
demonstrates that a combination of medium-resolution CO and high-resolution
dust continuum observations is a powerful tool for characterizing the dynamical
state of molecular gas in distant galaxies.
[15]
oai:arXiv.org:1703.05491 [pdf] - 1581962
Falling outer rotation curves of star-forming galaxies at 0.6 < z < 2.6
probed with KMOS^3D and SINS/ZC-SINF
Lang, P.;
Schreiber, N. M. Förster;
Genzel, R.;
Wuyts, S.;
Wisnioski, E.;
Beifiori, A.;
Belli, S.;
Bender, R.;
Brammer, G.;
Burkert, A.;
Chan, J.;
Davies, R.;
Fossati, M.;
Galametz, A.;
Kulkarni, S. K.;
Lutz, D.;
Mendel, J. T.;
Momcheva, I. G.;
Naab, T.;
Nelson, E. J.;
Saglia, R. P.;
Seitz, S.;
Tacchella, S.;
Tacconi, L. J.;
Tadaki, K.;
Übler, H.;
van Dokkum, P. G.;
Wilman, D. J.
Submitted: 2017-03-16
We exploit the deep resolved Halpha kinematic data from the KMOS^3D and
SINS/zC-SINF surveys to examine the largely unexplored outer disk kinematics of
star-forming galaxies (SFGs) out to the peak of cosmic star formation. Our
sample contains 101 SFGs representative of the more massive (9.3 < log(M*/Msun)
< 11.5) main sequence population at 0.6<z<2.6. Through a novel stacking
approach we are able to constrain a representative rotation curve extending out
to ~4 effective radii. This average rotation curve exhibits a significant drop
in rotation velocity beyond the turnover, with a slope of Delta(V)/Delta(R) =
$-0.26^{+0.10}_{-0.09}$ in units of normalized coordinates V/V_max and
R/R_turn. This result confirms that the fall-off seen previously in some
individual galaxies is a common feature of our sample of high-z disks. We show
that this outer fall-off strikingly deviates from the flat or mildly rising
rotation curves of local spiral galaxies of similar masses. We furthermore
compare our data with models including baryons and dark matter demonstrating
that the falling stacked rotation curve can be explained by a high mass
fraction of baryons relative to the total dark matter halo (m_d>~0.05) in
combination with a sizeable level of pressure support in the outer disk. These
findings are in agreement with recent studies demonstrating that star-forming
disks at high redshift are strongly baryon dominated within the disk scale, and
furthermore suggest that pressure gradients caused by large turbulent gas
motions are present even in their outer disks. We demonstrate that these
results are largely independent of our model assumptions such as the presence
of a central stellar bulge, the effect of adiabatic contraction at fixed m_d,
and variations in the concentration parameter.
[16]
oai:arXiv.org:1703.04310 [pdf] - 1545687
Strongly baryon-dominated disk galaxies at the peak of galaxy formation
ten billion years ago
Genzel, R.;
Schreiber, N. M. Förster;
Übler, H.;
Lang, P.;
Naab, T.;
Bender, R.;
Tacconi, L. J.;
Wisnioski, E.;
Wuyts, S.;
Alexander, T.;
Beifiori, A.;
Belli, S.;
Brammer, G.;
Burkert, A.;
Carollo, C. M.;
Chan, J.;
Davies, R.;
Fossati, M.;
Galametz, A.;
Genel, S.;
Gerhard, O.;
Lutz, D.;
Mendel, J. T.;
Momcheva, I.;
Nelson, E. J.;
Renzini, A.;
Saglia, R.;
Sternberg, A.;
Tacchella, S.;
Tadaki, K.;
Wilman, D.
Submitted: 2017-03-13
In cold dark matter cosmology, the baryonic components of galaxies are
thought to be mixed with and embedded in non-baryonic and non-relativistic dark
matter, which dominates the total mass of the galaxy and its dark matter halo.
In the local Universe, the mass of dark matter within a galactic disk increases
with disk radius, becoming appreciable and then dominant in the outer, baryonic
regions of the disks of star-forming galaxies. This results in rotation
velocities of the visible matter within the disk that are constant or
increasing with disk radius. Comparison between the dynamical mass and the sum
of stellar and cold gas mass at the peak epoch of galaxy formation, inferred
from ancillary data, suggest high baryon factions in the inner, star-forming
regions of the disks. Although this implied baryon fraction may be larger than
in the local Universe, the systematic uncertainties (stellar initial mass
function, calibration of gas masses) render such comparisons inconclusive in
terms of the mass of dark matter. Here we report rotation curves for the outer
disks of six massive star-forming galaxies, and find that the rotation
velocities are not constant, but decrease with radius. We propose that this
trend arises because of two main factors: first, a large fraction of the
massive, high-redshift galaxy population was strongly baryon dominated, with
dark matter playing a smaller part than in the local Universe; and second, the
large velocity dispersion in high-redshift disks introduces a substantial
pressure term that leads to a decrease in rotation velocity with increasing
radius. The effect of both factors appears to increase with redshift.
Qualitatively, the observations suggest that baryons in the early Universe
efficiently condensed at the centres of dark matter halos when gas fractions
were high, and dark matter was less concentrated. [Abridged]
[17]
oai:arXiv.org:1611.07524 [pdf] - 1532774
Galaxy environment in the 3D-HST fields. Witnessing the onset of
satellite quenching at z ~ 1-2
Fossati, M.;
Wilman, D. J.;
Mendel, J. T.;
Saglia, R. P.;
Galametz, A.;
Beifiori, A.;
Bender, R.;
Chan, J. C. C.;
Fabricius, M.;
Bandara, K.;
Brammer, G. B.;
Davies, R.;
Schreiber, N. M. Förster;
Genzel, R.;
Hartley, W.;
Kulkarni, S. K.;
Lang, P.;
Momcheva, I. G.;
Nelson, E. J.;
Skelton, R.;
Tacconi, L. J.;
Tadaki, K.;
Übler, H.;
van Dokkum, P. G.;
Wisnioski, E.;
Whitaker, K. E.;
Wuyts, E.;
Wuyts, S.
Submitted: 2016-11-22
We make publicly available a catalog of calibrated environmental measures for
galaxies in the five 3D-HST/CANDELS deep fields. Leveraging the spectroscopic
and grism redshifts from the 3D-HST survey, multi wavelength photometry from
CANDELS, and wider field public data for edge corrections, we derive densities
in fixed apertures to characterize the environment of galaxies brighter than
$JH_{140} < 24$ mag in the redshift range $0.5<z<3.0$. By linking observed
galaxies to a mock sample, selected to reproduce the 3D-HST sample selection
and redshift accuracy, each 3D-HST galaxy is assigned a probability density
function of the host halo mass, and a probability that is a central or a
satellite galaxy. The same procedure is applied to a $z=0$ sample selected from
SDSS. We compute the fraction of passive central and satellite galaxies as a
function of stellar and halo mass, and redshift, and then derive the fraction
of galaxies that were quenched by environment specific processes. Using the
mock sample, we estimate that the timescale for satellite quenching is $t_{\rm
quench} \sim 2-5$ Gyr; longer at lower stellar mass or lower redshift, but
remarkably independent of halo mass. This indicates that, in the range of
environments commonly found within the 3D-HST sample, satellites are quenched
by exhaustion of their gas reservoir in absence of cosmological accretion. We
find that the quenching times can be separated into a delay phase during which
satellite galaxies behave similarly to centrals at fixed stellar mass, and a
phase where the star formation rate drops rapidly ($\sim 0.4-0.6$ Gyr), as
shown previously at $z=0$. We conclude that this scenario requires satellite
galaxies to retain a large reservoir of multi-phase gas upon accretion, even at
high redshift, and that this gas sustains star formation for the long quenching
times observed.
[18]
oai:arXiv.org:1608.05412 [pdf] - 1531307
Bulge-forming galaxies with an extended rotating disk at z~2
Tadaki, Ken-ichi;
Genzel, Reinhard;
Kodama, Tadayuki;
Wuyts, Stijn;
Wisnioski, Emily;
Schreiber, Natascha M. Förster;
Burkert, Andreas;
Lang, Philipp;
Tacconi, Linda J.;
Lutz, Dieter;
Belli, Sirio;
Davies, Richard I.;
Hatsukade, Bunyo;
Hayashi, Masao;
Herrera-Camus, Rodrigo;
Ikarashi, Soh;
Inoue, Shigeki;
Kohno, Kotaro;
Koyama, Yusei;
Mendel, J. Trevor;
Nakanishi, Kouichiro;
Shimakawa, Rhythm;
Suzuki, Tomoko L.;
Tamura, Yoichi;
Tanaka, Ichi;
Übler, Hannah;
Wilman, Dave J.
Submitted: 2016-08-18, last modified: 2016-10-25
We present 0".2-resolution Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array
observations at 870 um for 25 Halpha-seleced star-forming galaxies (SFGs)
around the main-sequence at z=2.2-2.5. We detect significant 870 um continuum
emission in 16 (64%) of these SFGs. The high-resolution maps reveal that the
dust emission is mostly radiated from a single region close to the galaxy
center. Exploiting the visibility data taken over a wide $uv$ distance range,
we measure the half-light radii of the rest-frame far-infrared emission for the
best sample of 12 massive galaxies with logM*>11. We find nine galaxies to be
associated with extremely compact dust emission with R_{1/2,870um}<1.5 kpc,
which is more than a factor of 2 smaller than their rest-optical sizes,
R_{1/2,1.6um}=3.2 kpc, and is comparable with optical sizes of massive
quiescent galaxies at similar redshifts. As they have an exponential disk with
Sersic index of n=1.2 in the rest-optical, they are likely to be in the
transition phase from extended disks to compact spheroids. Given their high
star formation rate surface densities within the central 1 kpc of Sigma
SFR1kpc=40 Msol/yr/kpc^2, the intense circumnuclear starbursts can rapidly
build up a central bulge with Sigma M*1kpc>1e10 Msol/kpc^2 in several hundred
Myr, i.e. by z~2. Moreover, ionized gas kinematics reveal that they are
rotation-supported with an angular momentum as large as that of typical SFGs at
z=1-3. Our results suggest bulges are commonly formed in extended rotating
disks by internal processes, not involving major mergers.
[19]
oai:arXiv.org:1603.03432 [pdf] - 1510225
KMOS^3D: Dynamical constraints on the mass budget in early star-forming
disks
Wuyts, S.;
Schreiber, N. M. Förster;
Wisnioski, E.;
Genzel, R.;
Burkert, A.;
Bandara, K.;
Beifiori, A.;
Belli, S.;
Bender, R.;
Brammer, G. B.;
Chan, J.;
Davies, R.;
Fossati, M.;
Galametz, A.;
Kulkarni, S. K.;
Lang, P.;
Lutz, D.;
Mendel, J. T.;
Momcheva, I. G.;
Naab, T.;
Nelson, E. J.;
Saglia, R. P.;
Seitz, S.;
Tacconi, L. J.;
Tadaki, K.;
Übler, H.;
van Dokkum, P. G.;
Wilman, D. J.;
Wuyts, E.
Submitted: 2016-03-10, last modified: 2016-08-11
We exploit deep integral-field spectroscopic observations with KMOS/VLT of
240 star-forming disks at 0.6 < z < 2.6 to dynamically constrain their mass
budget. Our sample consists of massive ($\gtrsim 10^{9.8} M_\odot$) galaxies
with sizes $R_e \gtrsim 2$ kpc. By contrasting the observed velocity and
dispersion profiles to dynamical models, we find that on average the stellar
content contributes $32^{+8}_{-7}\%$ of the total dynamical mass, with a
significant spread among galaxies (68th percentile range f_star ~ 18 - 62%).
Including molecular gas as inferred from CO- and dust-based scaling relations,
the estimated baryonic mass adds up to $56^{+17}_{-12}\%$ of total for the
typical galaxy in our sample, reaching ~ 90% at z > 2. We conclude that baryons
make up most of the mass within the disk regions of high-redshift star-forming
disk galaxies, with typical disks at z > 2 being strongly baryon-dominated
within $R_e$. Substantial object-to-object variations in both stellar and
baryonic mass fractions are observed among the galaxies in our sample, larger
than what can be accounted for by the formal uncertainties in their respective
measurements. In both cases, the mass fractions correlate most strongly with
measures of surface density. High $\Sigma_{star}$ galaxies feature stellar mass
fractions closer to unity, and systems with high inferred gas or baryonic
surface densities leave less room for additional mass components other than
stars and molecular gas. Our findings can be interpreted as more extended disks
probing further (and more compact disks probing less far) into the dark matter
halos that host them.
[20]
oai:arXiv.org:1603.01139 [pdf] - 1457186
The evolution of metallicity and metallicity gradients from z=2.7-0.6
with KMOS3D
Wuyts, Eva;
Wisnioski, Emily;
Fossati, Matteo;
Schreiber, Natascha M. Förster;
Genzel, Reinhard;
Davies, Ric;
Mendel, J. Trevor;
Naab, Thorsten;
Röttgers, Bernhard;
Wilman, David J.;
Wuyts, Stijn;
Bandara, Kaushala;
Beifiori, Alessandra;
Belli, Sirio;
Bender, Ralf;
Brammer, Gabriel B.;
Burkert, Andreas;
Chan, Jeffrey;
Galametz, Audrey;
Kulkarni, Sandesh K.;
Lang, Philipp;
Lutz, Dieter;
Momcheva, Ivelina G.;
Nelson, Erica J.;
Rosario, David;
Saglia, Roberto P.;
Seitz, Stella;
Tacconi, Linda J.;
Tadaki, Ken-ichi;
Übler, Hannah;
van Dokkum, Pieter
Submitted: 2016-03-03
We present measurements of the [NII]/Ha ratio as a probe of gas-phase oxygen
abundance for a sample of 419 star-forming galaxies at z=0.6-2.7 from the
KMOS3D near-IR multi-IFU survey. The mass-metallicity relation (MZR) is
determined consistently with the same sample selection, metallicity tracer, and
methodology over the wide redshift range probed by the survey. We find good
agreement with long-slit surveys in the literature, except for the low-mass
slope of the relation at z~2.3, where this sample is less biased than previous
samples based on optical spectroscopic redshifts. In this regime we measure a
steeper slope than some literature results. Excluding the AGN contribution from
the MZR reduces sensitivity at the high mass end, but produces otherwise
consistent results. There is no significant dependence of the [NII]/Ha ratio on
SFR or environment at fixed redshift and stellar mass. The IFU data allow
spatially resolved measurements of [NII]/Ha, from which we can infer abundance
gradients for 180 galaxies, thus tripling the current sample in the literature.
The observed gradients are on average flat, with only 15 gradients
statistically offset from zero at >3sigma. We have modelled the effect of
beam-smearing, assuming a smooth intrinsic radial gradient and known seeing,
inclination and effective radius for each galaxy. Our seeing-limited
observations can recover up to 70% of the intrinsic gradient for the largest,
face-on disks, but only 30% for the smaller, more inclined galaxies. We do not
find significant trends between observed or corrected gradients and any stellar
population, dynamical or structural galaxy parameters, mostly in agreement with
existing studies with much smaller sample sizes. In cosmological simulations,
strong feedback is generally required to produce flat gradients at high
redshift.
[21]
oai:arXiv.org:1403.6124 [pdf] - 1208564
Why stellar feedback promotes disc formation in simulated galaxies
Submitted: 2014-03-24, last modified: 2014-07-04
We study how feedback influences baryon infall onto galaxies using
cosmological, zoom-in simulations of haloes with present mass
$M_{vir}=6.9\times10^{11} M_{\odot}$ to $1.7\times10^{12} M_{\odot}$. Starting
at z=4 from identical initial conditions, implementations of weak and strong
stellar feedback produce bulge- and disc-dominated galaxies, respectively.
Strong feedback favours disc formation: (1) because conversion of gas into
stars is suppressed at early times, as required by abundance matching
arguments, resulting in flat star formation histories and higher gas fractions;
(2) because 50% of the stars form in situ from recycled disc gas with angular
momentum only weakly related to that of the z=0 dark halo; (3) because
late-time gas accretion is typically an order of magnitude stronger and has
higher specific angular momentum, with recycled gas dominating over primordial
infall; (4) because 25-30% of the total accreted gas is ejected entirely before
z~1, removing primarily low angular momentum material which enriches the nearby
inter-galactic medium. Most recycled gas roughly conserves its angular
momentum, but material ejected for long times and to large radii can gain
significant angular momentum before re-accretion. These processes lower galaxy
formation efficiency in addition to promoting disc formation.